Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

  

Hello all, since the small story poll will be done tomorrow and like in most months these days, I’ve got a few questions I thought I’d put past you all. 

First of all, two broad questions.

Tattoos and piercings: 

Where does everyone stand on the use of these as plot devices/points of interest? I have ideas of magic imbued tattoos/runes I can use in practically every story I am writing that has magic in them. Stallion too though not magic ones LOL. But I once saw a LuNa fanfic or picture that showed Nami having gotten a tattoo of Luffy’s straw hat on one of her breasts, and I remember thinking, ‘now that’s a properly piratical way of showing devotion’. But I’ve never used tattoos on any of my main characters before, and other than earrings haven’t used piercings before either. So I’m wondering what people think about body additions like that.

The Patron-only story poll format: 

In my announcement of Making Wave’s victory in this month’s poll, I mentioned adopting a rotation of the three currently ongoing Patron-only stories. That is Bhaalson Remodel, Making Waves, and Sword Bow and Horse. I would take two of them, the story that was not mentioned the month before and the fic which took second place and put them through a poll against one another. Bhaalson won in November, MW this month. That means in January, Bhaalson will reenter the rotation against Sword Bow and Horse. Does everyone like this idea, or not?  

And before anyone asks, no.  Heroes of the High Seas won’t be on here unless it receives truly massive support. 

And I know another question on this point will be which story is closer to completion the answer is MW. But that's only because it is much further along, and don’t expect it to end in less than a year. And frankly, my Fairy Tail muse could use some juice (*hint, hint*) to get that far.

Now for the story-specific questions: 

Stallion: 

1. The time is coming up soon (as in the next chapter) where a final decision has to be made on whether or not Nami will join the Raffy/Robin relationship. I am just wondering if  Nami is the type to be satisfied when told she’ll only be able to have a bit of the pie, or if she’ll make a play to push Robin out of the relationship.  I’m really torn on this point, so I’d like everyone’s opinion on it. 

2. I went into this fic with the specific desire to keep it small and centered on the Strawhat Crew, just like the original is, sans the flashbacks, of course, LOL (Oda has embraced the flashback far too much in my opinion).  But that means I only want to show one adventure/fight occurring elsewhere. So after the next chapter, which will obviously be all Strawhats all the time, which would everyone prefer to see: Usopp and co.’s continuing adventures or Blackbeard being found by Ace?

FILFy:

1. Only two real questions for FILFy, but the first does actually have something to do with the next chapter, specifically how it ends. Besides Rias, who from the extended family should go with Her, Lily, and Harry to England? Yubelluna is in given her bandrui powers. Kala is out, but she’ll get more than a bit of time with Harry in the next chapter. Yasaka can’t, and Kunou will stay with her. 

So the question is, should Tonks and Teddy come along, or not? Rias leaving Akeno behind to lead the rest of her peerage makes sense, but I want at least one member of her peerage to come, and I don’t want to automatically take Koneko. I’d like to take one of either Loup or Kiba, but I don’t know if I can justify it. 

You see how undecided I am on this point.

2. Judging from canon, is Azazel the type to ignore Sirzechs’ warnings and try to get close to the wards around Kuoh in order to observe them? Because if so… he is in for a very nasty surprise. I want to know though since it could serve as part of the adventures that the people left behind will have while Harry, Rias and the others are in the UK/elsewhere.

ATP: 

1. Only one question here, but it’s a bit of a doozy in terms of story flow. I haven’t heard back from Mordreek (or any of my other ATP editors) about the last chapter. And I am kind of leery about going into a real Asgardian heavy chapter without his input. I can probably find someone else – either among all of you or among my story reviewers on fanfic – but I have to wonder, could I instead safely put off the confrontation with the Shadows and instead insert my version of the Avengers movie without any buildup to it?

Bhaalson: 

1. This is just a question for those who played the original game. How much time exactly passed in BG? I am thinking about half a year or so, but that is based on how many ‘days’ passed while I was galivanting around doing all the quests I could. 

GDWHOM:

1. I’ve decided once and for all that I will continue the Rias/Ranma romance line, but it will be slow and she and Saeko will bang heads several times, despite mutual respect. I have also decided to remove Gabriel from the romance.  There’s just no way to have her get involved with a human and not Fall. And Gabriel is one of the most loyal Archangels, she would never contemplate that. 

So, who should replace her in the pairing? Serafall for shits and giggles? Rika, because she loves a strong man? Or Koneko coming to love Ranma during their ongoing acclimatization exercises? Or her sister, a dark cat swooping in to ride the dark horse?  Or should it be Akeno seeing the sadist/masochist within the two martial artists and wanting to experience it for herself?

Comments

Kasey Rasmussen

Tattoos are cool if done correctly. Let nami join but she get with Robin first luffy(ranma) won't make a move without Robin say so.

Aaron Hardin

Filfy: given the treatment werewolves get in England Loup should not go. Kiba may be interesting if they run across the Pendragon family. Azazel is a semi unethical scientist currently focused on sacred gears, so if the wards tickle his interest (which they will if he learns then are a amalgamation if multiple magic schools), he would totally have someone else poke it to see what happens, and if he can’t convince someone else to do it he will do it himself.

JustDK

I love tattoos with some sort of power in other fics, always interesting. For Stallion. 1). Definitely no for Nami. It's not fun to try and force her in when it's not needed, there are so many other great female characters in one piece. Hopefully Boa, she's awesome and devoted. 2) Usopp. For fluffy. 1) Bring tonks and teddy, seems weird to go back to England without them. Bring Loup, maybe involve him with a werewolf, definitely more interesting then kiba.

Gune

As someone with tattoos I have found that in fics they can actually be written wrong. Like some HP fics where he all of a sudden gets his body covered in tattoos and piercings to make him cool. But I do like the idea of tattoos in fics that have actual meaning or a feeling behind it. Stallion - 1. I like the idea of Nami joining Robin n Co cause Nami is one of my favourites when it comes to being written in fics and I can imagine some great scenes with the 3 of them playing off each other. 2. I like sticking with the strawhats. Filfy - 1. I think Kiba and Tonks should go. I like the idea of Kiba going with Harry so they can get some bonding going on between Harry and Rias peerage. Tonks is my all time favourite HP fic character so getting a scene where she lays some smack into whoever is trying to upset Harry/Lily would be gold. Especially if its Ginny and Rias refuses to say or do anything as its Lily's mother. 2. Yes as it could be done as a rather funny scene. ATP - How much would dealing with the shadows after the avengers affect the timeline? As in isn't Jean due to pop soon so would that happen during the shadow arc or the avengers arc and would that affect what you have planned? You've also put a lot of effort into the lore of the Asgardians and I would love to see that detail go forward and if that means waiting until you hear back from the expert then so be it .

AC DC 1C 2C

Tattoos are good if done right, as long as they're not taken to extreme. I think I read a One Piece story that had Gin as a tattoo artist and each of the crew ended up getting their personal jolly rogers tattooed somewhere. I thought that was cool and an immense way of showing the crew's devotion to each other. Stallion - 1) Yes to Nami, I think her greedy nature is sometimes taken a bit too far in some fiction. She's a practical person, better to have a piece of the pie than to crave it from afar. 2) I'm interested in both, maybe split them both between both chapters. If not...Usopp because Teach can be handled via Flashback. FILFY: Tonks would probably be the most logical choice, since Rias would likely want an extra set of eyes that knew the whose who regarding Harry's past. Kiba might also want to come, since England is one of the most 'Knighthood' enshrouded places and Kiba has shown to have a bit of fixation on his code of chivalry. I'd suggest against Loup, anti-werewolf discrimination in Europe is a bad thing. 2) Azazel is a slightly amoral scientist, his Lust for Knowledge is just as strong as his libido. That and he's one of the strongest existances in the Biblical Faction and he knows it, his ego and his belief that Sizrech's is likely acting like the overly proud/protective Siscon that he is would likely have him dismiss or at least underestimate his warning.

Tomon

Broad category: 1) Tattoos and piercings: I dislike them and definitely don't find all the getting ear (or something) pierced to look cool as its so often used in HP stories where Harry is empancipated (last part no always necessary). This applies to all other stories as well. It's a little better with tattoos of magical origin or purpose. While familiar that can sink into your skin is also kinda overused I'm more okay with it than the other options. As a magical protection/device it's an interesting concept. Still in that case I would actually like the ability for it to be invisible since we are throwing magic around. And could be only visible when being used as another level of protection :) Nami getting such tattoo to show her devotion is interesting but for me a tattoo on a breast would just make sexy girl if not ugly outright, then at least less pretty. But I freely admit it's a subjective feeling along with the fact that I feel it's way too overused. If you want some magical protection which isn't jewelry I would actually recommend Soul. Harry is demigod/god and he is shown being able to influence if not outright manipulate the soul. That's something that cannot be taken away (or not by almost anyone) and also shown the level of trust :) 2) The Patron-only story poll format: Making wave is cool. Still I vote for "Heroes of the High Seas" as a way of starting the massive support :P How the system is implemented is up to you :) Stallion: 1) It can still work but if Nami tries to push Robin out at this point, then unless it's exceptionally well timed (meeting CP9, Robin thinking of or actually running away) then it should brutally backfire. And that would be very awkward afterwards. To be honest I feel like the ship kinda sailed for Nami and she missed her opportunity. Especially if we were to add some other strawhats female to the relationship which I on the other hand can see happening quite easily. Well, of course only if some female join the strawhats crew down the line ;) 2) I think we need at least one more chapter dealing with Usopp, Alvida and Buggy with crew. A chapter which clearly show their destination be it what it's gonna be. But Ace vs Blackbeards needs to be shown unless you intent to let it play exactly like canon. So probably both even if you prefer to have a small main character focused storytelling pov :) But it should be in this order and if you truly want just one then Ace is more important. What was Buggy up to can be handled by conversation as well. FILFy: 1) Well I don't think that either Tonks or Teddy wants to show up in England just yet to be honest. And the only one that popped to me mind right from the start and remained here is Koneko, who may not want to left her little sister or Tousan out of her sight :) From the others it's probably best to take Kiba who is more level headed (other than one topic) and can actually be here to protect his King as a peerage member. After all taking 'another werewolf' may be seen badly by the idiots of Wizarding England and while Harry may not care, his current family isn't allergic to actually trying to be diplomatic. At least at first :) 2) I feel that he wouldn't go there after being warned by Sirchezs. But if he was near the wards he also may not be able to hold himself back. So going there just to study wards? No. Trying to study the wards when being nearby? Yes. Still he could be possible just bored enough I guess :) ATP: 1) It could be actually fun. The crew preping for their Asgard mission and instead having to once again deal with another event and Hela smacking everyone around being cranky about what she seems like more important being delayed :-D GDWHOM: 1) How does the fall happens after the God passing anyway? I still find weird that pure love would cause to fall anyway. But I admit I just don't know the specific or angels becoming fallen in canon to be any judge if it's indeed impossible or not. In my subjective opinion it's doable ;) Other girls: Rika I think would want him for herself, not being a third girl 'added'. Akeno probably not here. She tried to check the waters but left dissapointed. No point of pushing here to it again. Koneko is MAYBE possible, especially if you let her experience heat and Ranma overcome his problems fully. Serafall would go for it :-D Just for the sheer fun. But would Ranma? With two girls that already cause him headache sometimes? :-D

Alamar Xandal

Stallion 1. I think that Nami is smart enough to realize that she wouldn't be able to usurp Robin in the relationship and that part of the pie is better than having none of it, though it would probably take her some time to fully accept and adjust to it 2. I would honestly prefer to see both, but if I had to choose I would rather see Usopp than Ace.

Delphinous

on tattoos and piercings: i don't like piercings in general, they are unsanitary at best and harmful at worst. tattoo's however, can be very nice if well done. to me, a good tattoo is very meaningful, because it's a declaration that you want to keep for the rest of your life, in my mind. i don't want someone getting a tattoo because it's cool, i want someone to be so moved by a deep emotion or event that shapes their life that they want to declare it to the world. this is like a marine who has dedicated his life to the corp getting semper fi across his shoulders, and not a teenager getting 'thug' on his knuckles to look tougher. so if anyone gets a tattoo, even if it's magical, i'd want it to be taken nearly as seriously as a decision to get married, or what degree you want to pursue at college, as opposed to being the level of 'do i get a bike or take the bus to work every day' i hope that makes sense ps. i also think that a magical tattoo should be minimally movable. a dragons can blink and it's scales can shimmer, but i don't want it wandering around the body, for FILFY, i think that Loup should get some more character development. if i remember right, he wanted to get some training from harry on being a werewolf way back when they were early in their meetings, and i feel like he's supposed to sort of fill ron's old role of 'near age male friend' as part of his balance against the heavy amount of nearby females, and they need more development between them for that to be there. i do feel like azazel would take the warnings seriously, but he wouldn't be able to contain his curiosity and he would just have to poke the wards with a metaphorical stick at least once, just to see. he would be moderately cautious because of the warning, but still somewhat overconfident for ATP, you've changed the asgardians so much i'm not sure how the avengers movie would work for you. on the other hand, loki's entire plan is basically out of the blue as far as asgard was concerned, and fury would absolutely be pushing shield to develop tessaract weapons, so i don't think you'd honestly need much buildup anyways, and you can probably go straight into it fairly quickly. it's actually probably better to do it before the war with the shadows, because the war witht he shadows would change everything, and i also feel like harry would keep putting of starting his war with the shadows unless they started it first, just because he doesn't now for sure how to fight and win, and if they pushed loki to go try to screw with earth as their way to start off the war, it would push harry into acting for baldurs gate 1, from what i can find, the minimum playtime to finish is 28 hours, the average is 70, and the maximum amount for people who actually finish everything in it is about 98, which translates to a minimum of 11 days 16 hours days minimum, 29 days 4 hours average, and 40 days 20 hours max 'in game time' i don't know how well that matches up with in game lore and that isn't accounting for in game travel time, but i hope it helps

Justin Sully

BG2 starts in the same year as BG1 (1368), so I'd say a few months give or take.

Tellemicus Sundance

Honestly, as long as they subscribe the general lore of the series, I really don't have a problem with magic tattoos. But if you do something like the cliche of Naruto-style storage seals in Harry Potter or Ranma or whatever, then I hope you have a very good explanation for how they work in-universe. Stallion 1) I suppose it all depends on strong her friendship is with Robin. If she views her as a good friend, then I could see her being willing to share. But, in my own humble opinion, I would VERY MUCH like to see her join the relationship. Stallion 2) I say just have it focus on the Strawhats. That way, when whatever happens with Ace and Blackbeard reaches Luffy, it'll be just as much a surprise to us as it will be for him.

UrpsychoEX

Tattoos- Tattoo's have a place depending on why you're including them. The idea of a pirate getting a tattoo to show devotion or crew loyalty is a goood one. The idea of using tattoos to give yourself runic defenses/offenses is a good one as well. I'll trust you to know where to draw the line. Patron-only- I don't mind if you wish to go this way. Stallion- 1. I would say the Nami from the beginning of the story would try to take Raffy from Robin. However after all the time she's spent with the crew and all the things they've done together I believe it is perfectly acceptable to have her be 'less greedy' when it comes to a relationship. I personally don't mind multi-pairing stories and can easily see that being where Nami ends up. 2. I'd prefer Blackbeard I guess? I don't care for Usopp as a character, nor Alvida or Buggy, but I don't mind seeing what is going on with them occasionally. I think the Blackbeard/Ace bit might be more important future plot wise however. FILFy- 1. I would like you to take Koneko because she is a favorite of mine and I could see her not wanting to leave Lily and Asia alone, since Kunou won't be able to go with them. If you are completely against her going I would suggest Loup and not Kiba though that is a personal choice. Kiba would be the best to go story wise as one of Rias' peerage members. I don't really care about Tonks or Teddy in this story. I don't know why but I just don't find myself invested in them, which is odd as I like Tonks and Teddy in other stories. I might just have to do with Nym's quick jump from Witch to Devil with zero thought... 2. Yes he is. Azazel isn't one to believe someone just because he respects them. He'll poke and prod and push as far as he can and try to fast talk his way out of trouble once he pushes to far. Especially if he knows two of the main ward holders aren't present. Even if Rias was there I think he would still do so as long as Harry was away for a bit. He's curious not suicidal. ATP- 1. If you always planned for that then sure have at it. If it's just something you're adding to put off the Shadow's the please don't. To be honest the only reason Marvel needed to build up to Avengers was brand recognition. Bhaalson- 1. Half a year seems short to me. I think I racked up about a year, maybe 10-11 months, on my best play through that didn't include console commands. I'd say go with somewhere between 6-9 months. GDWHOM- 1. I will agree with Gabriel not being involved. It is impossible without her Falling and therefore something she wouldn't do. I guess you could get around it but the Biblical God would need to be involved in changing the rules and that's not happening. I would go with Koneko or Akeno in that order. I don't think Ranma would be to happy with Koneko's sister (forgot her name) after what she caused, but she could be an option for a very slow burn relationship. I don't think Serafall would be interested to be honest. If Ranma was with Sona maybe she would just to mess with her but he isn't really interesting beyond being a very powerful martial artist.

Kariston Draconis

Tattoo's/Piercings: In general, I'm not against them, but if included in the story for a character who doesn't canonically have them, it really depends on the context. Robyn and/or Nami getting a straw hat tattoo like in your example? That works given the setting and characters, but I can't see Ranma, in either form, getting nipple piercings for example. Patron-only poll format: It works, though I think you need to put something in place for if a story keeps losing with only a small margin of difference between it and the winners. Stallion: 1. Never really got into One Piece, so can't comment on Nami's character, but I will say that either a couple or a trio works for me. 2. Ussop and co. had the last non-strawhat focus, so I think it's Blackbeard/Ace's turn. GDWHOM: First, let me just say YAY! Like I said before, every other Ranma/DxD fic that's still alive (all 2 of them, what's up with that low number anyway?) is avoiding the Ranma/Rias line, so someone needs to do it. And I agree with your reasons for excluding Gabriel from the group, it really doesn't work given the setting. As for her replacement, well, of the girls/women you've listed: 1. Serafall- I can't see this one working, to be honest, given everything that's gone on so far, as well as how little they've interacted. Plus, Nanya did it already. 2. Rika- Don't see it working with her either, she fits more the "Cool Big Sis" role here. 3. Koneko- Yeah, I can see this one working out, she's already obviously crushing on him, I can see that developing into more concrete feelings, and I can see Ranma reciprocating as he gets to know her better, maybe even helping her through her own issues with her sister earlier than canon. Plus it'd be interesting to see him actually hook up with a little sister type character for once. 4. Kuroka- Nanya did this one also, but I can still see it working, especially if you do the "help sisters reconcile earlier than canon" thing I just mentioned, Ranma being an older sibling himself would be able to understand exactly why she did what she did. 5. Akeno- Honestly, I'm kinda surprised she hasn't already tried to make at least a slightly-more-than-semi-serious play at getting in on that, plus she's just a fun character. Other possibilities and how they might work: Sona, in an opposites-attract kind of way, due to something forcing them to work closely together for an extended period of time perhaps; Ravel Phenex, depending on how you handle the part about Ranma nearly killing her older brother, if his actions afterwards come off as suitably heroic I can see her falling for him at the very least; Le Fay Pendragon, she's just a magical cinnamon roll, though could also qualify as another little sister, despite already having a big brother; Xenovia, depending on how you handle her breakdown at the "God Is Dead" revelations, she could join Ranma's new team rather than becoming a devil, one thing leading to another.

doubledamn

So is Heroes of the High Seas available for reading anywhere at the moment?

FitzThrawn

FILFy 1. I think Koneko would insist on going to make sure Lilly and Asia are ok, especially if she picked up on any fear Lilly might not recognize she has about seeing Ginny again. I would be interested in seeing Kiba go as well. In an earlier chapter you had Harry describe Kiba as his best friend among the peerage, but that hasn't come across to me so some development of that friendship would be nice. 2. Azazel would definitely investigate the wards but knowing what they already did he might be cautious enough to check them beforehand, even if he thinks SirZechs is exaggerating.

Seraphim38

I would go with Akeno

vimesenthusiast

not yet, should be out by next week. Have it back from its first editor, going to send it on to the next sometime today.

zagan

Tatoos : I could be nice, as long they limit themselves to one tatoo. Stallion 1 : I think the three way relationship could work if Nami and Robin can manage to have a real relationship too, not necessarily romantic or sexual but at least close friend or confidant. Stallion 2 : Ace no question, Usopp can wait a little (even if I'm curious to see dino-Usopp) FILFY 1 : Tonks and Teddy can stay behind, and Loup could come. FILFY 2 : I don't know enough about D&D to judge, but I like to see him try. ATP : I'll prefer to see the confrontation with the Shadow before the Avengers movie. Bhaalson : I don't know about any official timeline but I know that in my game probably at least a year because I slept every time I run out of spellslot. But yeah half a year seem like a good estimate.

GreedOnGreed

could you use compressed runes patterns that look like tribal tattoos or print them on bones? I don't like piercings much, do you use ear and navel at the limit? Yes, it's okay even if I'm not a Bhaalson fan. stalion: Nami is greedy but bisexual, so initially she would try to get Ruffy's attention but after talking to Robin and being seduced by her the situation would settle down. Ace that with the Ranma effect he should be much stronger than the canon. Filfy:  No, she should be engaged with the Japanese police. Could you bring Mittelt because he would like to see the Barcelona game? Yes, because Azazel always jerk off. GDWHOM: none of them, Serafall has too big a difference in status and in addition there is already Rias as hell, he is too anti-authoritarian to stay with Rica, Koneko will be a little sister together with Asia and maybe Ravel, Kuroka would just like his seed, Akeno is already out with his S but would look good with duck M. What about Valery Tepes or a female angel by accident from the springs mixing the magic of chaos and one of the Office snakes?

GreedOnGreed

Serafall has too big a difference in status and in addition there is already Rias for a devil, he is too anti-authoritarian to stay with Rica, Koneko will be a little sister together with Asia and maybe Ravel, Kuroka would just like his seed, Akeno is already out with his S but would look good with duck M. What about Valery Tepes or a female angel by accident from the springs mixing the magic of chaos and one of the Office snakes?

Alejandro Kalansky

Stallion: 1 Will not like it but after having seen them that night will accept it 2 Usopp FILFy: 1 Do not take Tonks and Teddy along. 2 He will take a closer look but will try not to enter what he thinks is the detection area unless he believe he can get away with it GDWHOM: Koneko

link01742

I would love for the Nami thing to work out, I would Image that Nami, in order to get an in with Raffy, would go further than she would have before into the martial arts in through this learn more about her self basically Ranma and Nami would fight-fuck and in a way, she would "mellow out" this training also leads into Heni getting into the situation

Adam Ouellette

Tasteful tattoos is fine, but I really like piercings personally. My favorite patreon only stories are MW and Sword bow and horse so can't really comment on how you do the rotation without being incredibly biased. For Nami I'd say having her join cause she is greedy and wants him all to himself she is, in my opinion, greedy enough to want at least some of him than nothing. For the side story, mmmm I'm voting for Ace. I vote for Koneko to come and not Teddy and Tonks. Yes Azazel is the type to ignore the warning, he did ignore God and fell so I don't think being warned by a stronger being will really deter him. I think for ATP if you want to do the Avengers you don't need to have build up as the actual movie didn't have any real build up in the first place. Skipping question from Bhaalson. Ooh for the other person I vote Koneko!!!!

Heinan

The Patron-only story poll format: I like the idea.

Heinan

Stallion 2: Usopp and co is more interesting for me.

Hiryo

A) Tattoos and piercings: These tattoos and piercings have to fit to the setting/character. As with barbarian tribes has trophies, or like Drows having piercing in the ear as representations for their goddess. On the other side it could be a tribal thing or being possessed and having some marks of what possesses them (Naruto whisker marks). On the other hand, with the magical ones, usually tattoos have to be spoken as they are done and if one destroys these with a flesh wound cancel these rings. Or having sigils dispelled etc. Also, if someone is magical sensitive can locate where on the body, he senses the magical origin. In most cases piercings and tattoos can be a representation of status, ‘beauty’, ‘sexual instrument/symbol’ or something else. B) The Patron-only story poll format: This idea is awesome! I love this rotation! C) Stallion: 1) Hmm, as how you wrote it, I think Nami want to have the pie alone and fights for it but looses and maybe concentrates on her purpose more? I believe, with how you wrote the story that this would be the outcome. 2) I like to see how you will do the Blackbeard meeting Ace, to get some guessing what will be there in the future with them. As well Usopp & Co where already mentioned a few times. D) GDWHOM: 1) Yay RiasXRanma!!! Aww, real sad that there won’t be a RanmaXGabriel setting there but I think we all saw that coming, what with how the story developed. 2) I would be for Serafall and as for Akeno, she could ‘play them like a fiddle’! >:) Don’t forget to change the description of GDWHOM pairing on ff.net.

Rumil's Apprentice

Tattoos and piercings: I guess I can see where you're coming from. Riddle's Dark Mark a magical tattoo with limited capabilities. I dislike the idea of something like magically-imbued tattoos being extremely powerful, but perhaps if they have limited, but specific utility. Or maybe they are a one-shot defensive thing. In general though, I like the idea of magical body art. Basically, if in canon Potterverse the portraits and photos move, so can magical body art. In canon Potterverse, Sirius Black has tattoos, and there is an tattoo shop in Diagon Alley https://harrypotter.fandom.com/wiki/Tatoo_Artist The fic "Three Black Birds" by Excited-Insomniac on FFN has some good ideas on magical body art in the early chapters. If the characters are the kind of people who would get tattoos, then let them get tattoos. In terms of piercings, I always assumed that if you can create magical items, then you can create magical jewelry. Basically, what you've already done in ATP. The Patron-only story poll format: That rotation sounds fine to me. I don't have a strong opinion. FILFy: 1. Well, Harry, Lily, and Asia have practically adopted Koneko into the family. So unless there is a pressing reason otherwise, I think she would want to go on the trip as well. Kiba is originally from Europe, so maybe there is a reason he would want to visit? I can't think of a reason off the top of my head though. Loup doesn't seem like the kind of guy would would care about such a trip, unless he had a job like babysitting Lily or maybe a mission to meet other werewolves. 2. Azazel seems to be a very cautious person when it comes to politics, military, and strategy. However, his personality is bit obsessive with a slight mad scientist vibe. Maybe he'll try to get some sort of probe through the wards, but not risk himself bodily. ATP: 1. Actually, I always assumed that the Custodes would deal with Loki and the Chitauri before the final battle with the Shadows. I haven't yet envisioned how Harry and Hela would be able to maneuver a situation to decisively confront the Shadows without the Trickster. And honestly, it would be more poetic for the god most hamstrung by the Shadows to be the one to orchestrate their final defeat. Besides, I've been imagining all these great scenes when Hela and Harry meet her father on the battlefield, and the jokes they can have at Loki's expense. It would also be poetic for Loki and Sigyn to reunite before the assault on the Shadows. That could maybe be the final push needed to get Loki back on the right track. Bhaalson: 1. The canon timeline is that the BG1 story starts in the early spring and ends before winter of that same calendar year. But, well, it's a single player RPG. If the characters do every single side-quest and bonus dungeon available before finishing the main quest, then I'm not sure the story would actually be able fit into a 6-9 month timeframe. However, nothing in the BG1 story claims that the characters are immediately kidnapped by Irenicus after defeating Sarevok. So, I guess it's open to interpretation.

Razgriz0x

Stallion- Nami gets used to sharing and Ace meeting Blackbeard. FILFy- Tonks, Teddy and Koneko. Tonks can show youngsters around while Harry deals with 'boring' grown up stuff... and Koneko because she's the 'onee-san'. Azazel is a naughty boy and should finally reap the consequences of his ill thought actions and hubris. GDWHOM- Rika... cause she should still be friends with a certain big-tiddy blonde nurse... fun times ahead on that path, no? ATP- Avengers first, no lead up means it'll be a real surprise attack, just like in the movie... sorta. But yeah, movie then shadows. As for Tatoos and Piercings, not too interested, but if done right it could work.

MinotaurKing

Broad Questions: 1. If used sparingly and creatively, go for them otherwise I don't think they would add enough overall to use. 2. I actually really like this idea as it feels like a solid way to give them all a chance to get updated.

MinotaurKing

Stallion: 1. I just feel like Nami is too greedy to share Raffy's attentions, although I do see her making a very serious play for Raffy. 2. Unless the Blackbeard and Ace confrontation is going to go seriously off the rails I would rather see more of Buggy and Co's adventures.

MinotaurKing

FILFY: 1. Honestly it feels like it needs/has to be Koneko none of the others really feel like they fit the situation the way she does. 2. Yeah Azazael is totally the type to let his curiosity get the best of him, only to end up biting off more then he can chew.

MinotaurKing

GDWHOM: 1. I don't think there needs to be a replacement for her spot at all, just take her out of the pairing and leave it at that nothing says you need to slot in another girl in her stead.

Gilicze Laszlo Balazs

Tatoos: Yay Piercings: Nay... So... Magical tatoos are good if they are useful in a select few situations, can be easily hidden and aren't stupidly overpowered "get out of sh...t free cards". Piercings... just no. Poll format: This basicly means 1 month Ranma and 1 month not... most likely. I can live with that. Maybe we'll see a nice MW SBH streak next year :) Stallion: 1.: Nami: Yay. She deserves One Piece of the Raffypie (... ok... I know that was bad... sorry) I like the idea of Raffy getting a harem (whether he want's it or not :P) IF it make's sense. And he is a pirate so why shouldn't he. I can actually see Robin quite enjoying beeing the main mistress of said harem (those hands of hers will wander). 2. As for Ace vs Buggy and Co. I think I will go with Buggy and Co. Their adventures are actually kind of fun and I think Ace's fight with Teach is better as a sudden shock to Raffy. GDWHOM: 1. Rias: Yay, Removing Gabriel also Yay. I like the slow buildup of the double redhead relationship and that the girls have to learn to share. Also... If they do end up living together... Rias likes to sleep naked and crawl into other peoples beds so fun times are ahead for all :D 2. Replacing Gabriel... that's a tough o... oh who am I kidding... KONEKO FTW... I am very much a cat person and she is adorable. It could develop even slower than with Rias. If they live together (Which I seriusly hope now) they can have a lot of cute moments and/or she could sneak into Ranma's bed to sleep on his lap and sneak a few kisses before she gets caught. It could be such a sweet scene with Ranma accepting her feelings and the two cuddling up together to be found the next morning by the girls :P

Matthew Tanzy

GDWHOM: Serafall because it would be amusing.

Slider

Now that I’m nearly finished with the current chapter I feel like I can adequately reply. -Tattoos: I always rather like the idea of magic tattoos though an overload of them (either as a whole or more specifically on one person) does get a bit annoying. It’s a balancing act in my view. A little is really cool, a lot gets annoying. The piercings could be fun though I would advocate for it to be more of a funny thing rather than a true combat magic use thing. Need to get away in a hurry? Take out your nipple ring as a last ditch defense portkey or something. This sort of this would only really work for specific characters on like one or two stories but it would a hilarious moment for the others around them at the time. -Patron: I’m fine with that though I feel like if you can honestly finish MW within a year maybe it’s better to try and focus on that? -FILFy: 1. I feel like Tonks is almost a given and I’m a bit surprised you weren’t planning to have her go automatically. Not even just for the fact that she’s from England as well and might want some closer or to say hello to Andi, but also because of the Bash Brothers vibe you gave the two of them towards the beginning/middle of the story. Tonks would want to back Harry up on any international trip I’d think, especially to their old stomping ground. Teddy…might be best left at home. He’s probably old enough to go, but they are planning it as more of a ‘Harry searches for his god magic answers and finish up with Ginny being a bitch’ and less of a family vacation which would be more appropriate for Teddy to tag along with. As to others, I would say Asia. Largely because she is a sheltered girl and Harry would want to take her to see some more sights! If you want to take someone from the peerage that isn’t Koneko probably Kiba since he could use a bit more development with Harry. Loup would be entertaining for the werewolf in Wizarding Britain issues, though I feel like heads would get knocked fast if he tags along. Nothing wrong with bringing Koneko though, the girl going as one of the only peerage members would give her a decent bit of father/surrogate daughter time to bond more! -FILFY: 2. I think Azazel as you’ve written him would be interested in observing the wards though would back off if they started acting up. He’s not antagonist, though he can be subtle, he’s more of a mentor figure and a bit lazy than anything else from what I know of canon. While he’d very likely want to see the cool new comboplatter wards that combined various things, he wouldn’t be arrogant enough or stupid enough to let them smash him, nor would he be antagonist enough to truly ramp them up. -GDWHOM: I’m all for either Koneko or Serafall in this one!