Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Thanks to all current patrons and new patrons. I will post what UMCH alpha stuff I managed to update today, and the preview images and preview animations for UMCH will be at their respective levels

for now I wanted to request feedback for ARIA art redesigns. At some point in the future I was going to make a smaller and separate version of aria but I can't use the cell shaded art in that marketplace unfortunately. let me know what you think about these art redesigns. Please check  the link for description info.

http://spiralvortexplay.com/svp/2015/09/30/aria-phia-art-revisited-feedback-requested/

Files

Previews only

(No title)

Comments

Miha Antauer

I'll take a number 3. Hold the outfit, thanks.

vortex00

hold the outfit meaning nude ? it will definitely have at least a breasts hanging out version if I use it.

R S

I still like 1 the best...

Praetor

1 or 2 are fine to me. 4 doesnt even really feel like Phia anymore.

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback. The market I am trying to get into might not understand the appeal of vector cell shading art. And how goes hand in hand with flash games and animations. and in certain cases required for the animations to be smooth and high quality.

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback. I'm not overly in favor of changing the art either but just seeing what works if I need to change it.

Mikael

I'll take a number 2,3. The outfit is still good

Dain

Still prefer the original but number 3 is a nice change in design, number 4 is a bit too much of a change imo

Redmage

personally i like the body and hair of number 4 but her pupil and iris are sooo small compared to the sclera of her eyes. Love the shade of red for her hair too

vortex00

I see, thanks for the feedback~ I will make adjustments and post these again.

Belly97

I like the original, but I prefer number 3. It would be good if her lines were a bit more muted/shaded down (like number 2's abs), and if her gear was a bit smaller/slimmer. Her hips could also be just a bit wider but not as wide as number 4, and just her hips, not her legs. Number 3's eyes are also great. Good job overall.

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback. I will make various edits and stuff based on feedback and post this again later today.

cdawson

when will the umch be uploaded

Anonymous

Seriously I prefer the 1 and 2.

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback. #1 you continue to see in the current ARIA game and future updates. #2 I might make the hair darker and balance out the skin a bit.

Zeralys

I am satisfied and 1 option, but if you need to update ... Best of all looks version 5. I would add to it the light of lanterns like as suit 2 version. And it would be nice if she not bites her lip. Also to say about the version 4. It is also very good. It would be nice if her nipples were a little smaller and not so much protruding. It would also be nice if the hips are not so wide. As a result, I would choose option 4 if it was the quality of both 5. And finally. Not a few important is how the author himself "sees" his creation :)

McSpazz

Out of all of them, I think my favorite is somewhere between four and five (five being the larger image visible on the website but not here on Patreon). While three and five are basically the same thing, the very subtle difference in her facial expression kind of sells it to me in addition to the slight difference in hair color. Three is very pretty, but Phia's personality doesn't really like a match to that smile...number five, however, has that little lip bite that gives off that subtle mischievous look. The reason I really love four lies purely in her body's stance. I really like that it's not just her standing static, you know? That extra little flare to her body to put emphasis on her personality (and...her breasts too, but that's beside the point) really makes her stand out. If we were to focus purely on 1 and 2 since they are the closest thing to what we already have in game, I easily have to say two. Not just because it has added detail, but also because it has far better defined muscle that you would expect out of a field agent. TL;DR: I really like four and five and would love some sort of merge between them, but I'd choose 2 if narrowed down to editing the model already in game.

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback I will take this into consideration when doing some edits..

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback. 3 and 5 have the exact same lines heh. the difference is only lipstick color. I will make edits and post these again.

JG7787

The original art style is great, but if you are thinking about changing it up, I say go all out with the change. I vote 4

scorch1402

I really like 3 and 5. The outfit on them is the best out of all of them I think. I like the brighter lights on the costume of 3 and the darker hair color on 5. the lip color on 3 I think is better than 5. I really like the hips and belly on 3 and 5 and the muscles on her arms

Maxed

The original is awesome but that last one, if that were animated I believe that would be a winner. I think I like the last one the best because she seems more "anime" styled, not sure if that's the right words for it but yeah; nevertheless the first one is still a winner if not the last one :P.

Trevor Muller

Vortex00; I think 2 and 3 are the best to pick from.

Lyrin

Four looks a bit...off. I'm not sure how to explain it. Three is my favorite, two comes--ironically--second, and first is still appreciable. I could probably get used to number four, if that's easier to draw somehow, but I prefer three.

Fredrik

I like 3, 4 and 5.

Nomad

Personally I like 2 most

alias#452

I prefer good old number one, with maybe number 2 as a close second.

Anonymous

I think overall 3 is the best one on the list. 5 has some good elements like how the lights on the "suit" are more muted. Bring more attention to the character instead of taking it away from the character. But I'd say 3 is a marked improvement over 1.

vortex00

Thanks for everyone's feedback on this!

Haseox5

For me its 3 or 4.