Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

I have strawpoll at the bottom. Again your feedback will help shape how I structure my patreon stuff moving forward.

Not sure how many people realize but I work a full time job in addition to my patreon job.

I have not yet reached a amount where I can quit my job. I have been

hovering under the next goal for a few months. I was hoping the free

release of ARIA would give me a bit of a boost but it really hasn't

much. I haven't posted it on NG yet, but it has been posted in several

other places. It being a multi part file might have complicated things a

bit.


solo I would need about 6k. with ttrop I would need about 7-7.5k. 9k or 10k I would have been working on this full time a long time ago would be much further along than I am right now.


Lately I have been thinking about switching the contents of the $10 and $5 patreon tiers.  wondering what peoples thoughts on this was.


without much thought one might assume the cheaper the beta is the better. But I'm not sure it is the case.


My original idea was to make it half price as the common $10 amount most people have and go for having more patrons. Not sure if that is not working, or just going slowly.

Well I do have more patrons then most. out of about 29.8k people with creator patreon pages running. I am around rank 54 for top number of npatreons lol. not bad imo. almost in top 50.


https://graphtreon.com/creator/vortex00

all the -% is from the time patreon started showing the actual amounts.


but I have seen people with far less patrons yet way more donation amounts.

At the same time there are people with more patrons than me and have

less amounts XD


https://graphtreon.com/

really interesting website, I love looking at numbers. Probably from my engineering background. the difference between me and #53 is staggering lol. I'm only comparing myself to other NSFW people


I just wonder if I am selling myself short?

Is everyone paying $10 to everyone else and I am the only dumbass here charging $5, which could be causing me to not be able to working this full time?


It seems like even with my job a I do a lot more than people working on their stuff full time.

a look at another patreon user Fenoxo who also has essentially a beta access at $5, but triple the patrons.

https://graphtreon.com/creator/user?u=121401

So I'm trying to decide what to do here. stay the course and try to get more patrons, or risk losing patron but have beta at $10? do I even have the potential to have 3k+ patrons? do I just need to market more ? what is the problem here ? lol.

I feel like if I was able to work on my stuff full time I'd would have been done with literally everything I am working on right now probably Q3 last year.


wanted to know if you are paying $10 to other people how my stuff matches up in terms of content and value. when people release their $10 beta access for the month how much is really new vs what is new in my stuff across both UMCH and ARIA stuff.


I'm fairly confident my $20 package is reasonable.


I haven't made up my mind but definitely leave your input on this. Lurking means I have no idea what your opinion on this is.


made a straw poll also but typically consider written comments very heavily.

http://strawpoll.me/6903992


Having said all this. I will have beta for UMCH, ARIA, and the new ARIA game early next month. If you are unfamiliar with the new ARIA game or UMCH please check these links:
http://spiralvortexplay.com/svp/2016/02/22/new-aria-game-updates/

http://spiralvortexplay.com/svp/2016/02/23/umch-updates/

Files

Previews only

Comments

Thanny

I would not recommend trying to artificially boost donations in that way. Being able to do this full time rather than as a well-paid hobby (let that sink in for a bit) is something that should happen on its own or not at all.

Gremloblin

I'm sorry to hear that your not doing well with money. I really like ARIA and UMCH is very interesting so I planned to pay the equivalent to two new game for each of them. If you go up to $10 I'll still support but only half as long. I hope you don't feel slighted.

Thanny

And you'd do well to note how those clearly doing things full time are put under a lot more pressure to produce more and more content in less and less time, with ample dissatisfaction when that content doesn't meet expectations, however unreasonable.

vortex00

As with anything involving money. I produce content from 2-3 different games even with a job. produce stuff for the job also. I'm no stranger to delivering results. I feel like you might be assuming I have enough time and energy to do both. I am barely able to and it is taking it's toll on me. Both are not possible forever. So if there is something I can change, I need to figure out what it is as early as possible. Much thanks for the feedback good to have various perspectives so I can figure out what could possibly be a solution. The solution might not lie in swapping tiers. But if I can figure something else out, that would be well worth the discussion.

Wilsonthegreen

Comparatively your 10 is about as good as the other 10 pledge goals I'm aware of. As for things like declined pledges, I'm not sure what you could do. I know that patreon already emails people when there pledges are canceled, so an extra from you would probably be redundant. And for swapping goals, I feel a lot of long term mooks would feel cheated by having their rewards swapped. It could prove profitable but only if the amount that upgrade to 10 is larger than the amount that would bail. But you're already trying to find that number with the survey. I left my two cents in their already but I'm already at 10 so not sure how much it'll help.

vortex00

Just trying to see if any has some ideas on what I might be able to do here before I do anything rash because I'm kinda starting to get kinda burnt out again. Have any suggestions do to make my $10 more appealing?

vortex00

Well nice to know to 10 is comparable. Now that I think about it. I've seen a few people have on their patreons "Early access" and opposed to a "beta". What I'm calling a beta is what others call early access, having it available a month before public. But that is not really what beta is. I'm now wondering people actually want a true beta, which can be potentially buggy or not even working at all in parts of the game. Or early access to something that is supposed to stable yet unfinished. I remember going through several iterations of ARIA with Brigma and JD on the path to 2.3. Not sure much of that was useful to the majority of people at the time. Essentially it would leave the $5 as it is and add more to the $10 amount by potentially having different "betas" at times during the month.

Calibus

I'm also of the opinion that raising it to $10 will make you lose money. I think there's a big chance that it'll be perceived as greedy, and I bet a lot of people at the $5 tier can't afford / don't want to pay more. Focusing more on increasing the value of the $10 tier instead of taking stuff away from the $5 tier might work better. The $10 tier is pretty weak, I think. It seems, from following your updates, that there are some animations that never get previews posted for patrons. Maybe you could make the $10 tier have -some- animations, and the $20 tier just gets more animations. That might work better than a pure binary animations/no animations. Just one idea. I'm honestly not too informed on this topic. I am curious about the declined pledges though. Is it that common an issue? That's really shitty if it is. Have you considered doing a system where you only send out content at the end of each month to people whose payments clear, instead of just always having it available for all patrons? I personally really don't like this kind of system as it feels kinda shitty when you start supporting someone late and end up missing out on content, but maybe you could have a way for people to get past content by going through you. Or maybe even have past content unlock automatically after they've been a patron for X number of months with no declined charges. I think a system like that would keep late arrivals from feeling left out. I don't know if you've thought of / toyed around with these kinds of ideas before or not, but if you're getting a lot of declined pledges it seems like a good place to focus on fixing.

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback. I most of the time have a at least one animation for UMCH and ARIA Not sure I can produce more than that in my current status. Or are you suggesting I add perhaps older animations to the 10 amount ? Not sure many apply aside from just having it separate from the game. A lot of the older animations are probably in the game already. I was think about having multiple betas throughout the month thoguh. because what I am calling beta right right should really be called early access. On the topic of declined payments, A while back I opted in to testing the patreon system where the payment takes place when becoming a patron. I opt into all of the beta stuff actually. It is not currently in effect yet but it should not effect current patrons at all. Only the new ones. I'm no sure when that will begin to take effect but hopefully I will know in advance. But yeah declined payment has been a issue for all patrons since day 1. It is why they started trying to show the more accurate amount you make and applied it to everyone. So most people do the inbox thing. what I was thinking about doing was having the inbox after the payments clear. then a bit later in the month have that magic link I coded up. But it is still missing the incentive to actually have the payment clear. I think it checks for it thoguh idk. but assuming my account is set to have the payment process when new people sign up. I won't run into the problem of people being left out on sign up. but I would still have the declined payments issue. Patreon has nice stuff coming down the road. Just needs to get here sooner than later.

Shirayuki

I have all of the creators I'm supporting at $10 except 2 of them (one being $5 and $25)

Jay Dakat

Wish I could give you some sort of helpful advice but I really don't know. :/ Raising the price could backfire. Not that I think it would be unfair but it's all about what people perceive as good value. At the moment, I think you offer very good value and that's more likely to get patrons. If I were you and I had to choose, I would leave the rewards as they are.

Galgano

This is going by what I do, so take my advice with a grain of salt. When I find someone on Patreon I want to support, I usually just do the lowest tier and forget about it. Then, months down the line, I'll feel like playing their game and what not. I don't really expect huge leaps forward in terms of content each month, so having access to the newest thing each month tends to be...underwhelming. Obviously there are times when everything lines up and a whole mess (i.e. a whole new area to explore with lots of content for that area. Not just a single thing that you can do in that area) of new content comes out, but unless you can absolutely do that on a regular basis, I wouldn't raise the game access cost to 10. To me, the tiers represent devotion to the cause. 5$ may be a lot to some people, but we are humans: if we want something bad enough, we will find ways to save money elsewhere to get what we want at the higher price. You were talking about the difference between early access and closed beta with some other people too. Anyway, here's my proposal: At the Free Tier: You get access to the current build every six months. People are going to find some way to make your games free to play by putting it up somewhere for download, so might as well give the cheapskates what they want. Who knows, they may like your stance on "sharing the wealth" so to speak and decide to chip in some more money for the higher tiers. At the 5$ Tier: You get access to current build every other month or if a huge update comes out (because everyone loves huge updates). This way, it's the best of both worlds. People can get access to your game, but not too much access. Plus, it gives you an extra month to push a larger amount of content into the build. At the 10$ Tier: You get access to the current build every month. If you are willing to put more money towards the cause, then you deserve something a little extra. There may not be a bunch of new-new content each month, but you get to show your support and you get to see the step by step process. Plus, since you can see all the latest stuff, you can get the 5$ and Free Tier people hyped for the next release by word of mouth. Anyway, that's my idea. You obviously don't have to use it, and you can change it how you see fit, but that might help by letting people give more, but they don't have to break the bank since they can still play the game at the 5$ tier. Edit: Also, I hate that enter submits the post and doesn't return down a line.

Fealow

You won't find much of a suggestion in this post, but I just wanted to say that I am paying the $20 tier each month because I simply want to support you and have some decent H games to play. I don't really expect any beta/early access stuff in return for my money, if I'm honest I often find it more of a hassle to faff about with version updates and demos etc... Sure it can be nice some times, but it's not a deal breaker for me. I'd like to think there are other people out there that share the same viewon this.

Marty Schmarty

This is just my opinion, but maybe do a bit of both? Isn't there an option for limiting the number of people within a certain tier? So what you could do is lock the $5 tier to a number near what it is now, then make the $10 tier the new entry tier. This way everyone that is not willing to move up to $10 won't leave, and everyone willing to go up to $10 will and you can lock the $5 tier to a lower number. Give $10 something $5 doesn't get to incentivise.

six2make4

Sorry mate, but I can hardly imagine that raising the price for the beta will do much good. This comment may sound a bit mean and I appologise but my way with words is... Yeah... Anyhow, you have essentially given people cake and now they are accustomed to eating cake, now you want to give them bread instead for the price of what they used to get cake. I don't imagine it's gonna swing well for most people and it's probably more because they are accustomed to something else than out of ill-will or they simply can't afford it, but the result would probably be the same.

six2make4

Sorry mate, but I can hardly imagine that raising the price for the beta will do much good. This comment may sound a bit mean and I appologise but my way with words is... Yeah... Anyhow, you have essentially given people cake and now they are accustomed to eating cake, now you want to give them bread instead for the price of what they used to get cake. I don't imagine it's gonna swing well for most people and it's probably more because they are accustomed to something else than out of ill-will or they simply can't afford it, but the result would probably be the same. So what can be done? Well first off when you completely finished and given ARIA a good polish it's likely to pick up, some more exposure could also help, it's not much but it's what I got ontop of my head and remember Fen had created one of the best games in a niche market when he started his patreon, that is like guaranteed moneyz.

Sing Love

I personally don't mind upping my pledge due to an increase. Sadly, I doubt my thoughts are the same as others. There's a higher chance of backfire than profit with increased cost, but it mostly comes from the people not understanding that we're not just supporting a single game but a dev to make games. More exposure is probably your best bet. Even on international forums might generate a bigger profit than increase cost. Well regardless of what you do my pledge isn't going anywhere.

Munkyboy

Ok, this reply made me think, and so I looked at why I was pledging at the level I'm at, and the difference between the $5 level, and the $10 level isn't all that much, content-wise; Some images and animations, and access to secret links. Sorry, but secret links doesn't spark my imagination, and artwork doesn't really interest me as much as it might some people. What gets my attention is game content, and if you could be a little more descriptive as to what secret links might actually get me, then I would think less about bumping my pledge and actually do it. You are actually one of the few creators that I'm actually interested in supporting :) Your work 'caught my eye', but I gotta keep that same eye on my money, cuz I ain't got a whole lot of it :( You know, that bang for the buck thing? So just a little more bang on the $10 level would convince me to give you the extra bucks :) Sorry, I don't know if I make any sense, or if I sound like some cheap-ass dumb-shit, but maybe my two cents will help... Thanx :D

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback~ yeah I want to make the $10 more interesting at least.

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback and sorry for the late reply, I took this into consideration. Especially at the lowest tier because I didn't think people do that lol. Plus adding in other confusion I normally get. I'm not sure what you mean by free tier. it that $1? or just following me on patreon ? Most updates are public after month of so anyways.

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback and sorry for the late reply~ Yes getting things ready for DL for the new month is usually reasonably time consuming.

vortex00

Thanks for the feedback and sorry for the later reply. I actually like this idea, kind of like a early bird special. I would like to try the $10 holding it's own for a while longer. I made it with things I think people might be interested in.

vortex00

np thanks for the honest feedback and sorry for the late reply. Sometimes it just feel like I am selling myself short. But I will try some different stuff.