Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

I'm sure most have heard by now about the cancellation of breeding seasons, the top earning hentai game on patreon.

http://kotaku.com/sex-game-cancelled-after-taking-in-five-figures-a-month-1783682938


http://breedingseasongame.blogspot.ca/2016/07/breeding-season-is-over-s-purple-has.html?zx=41a99d537f0c1e97


A few people linked me the blog post the day it happened but I wanted to wait a bit to make post on it. I actually wanted to read both sides of the story.

I'm not going to go into detail on it, but as someone who has been making hentai for over 8 years now, there's quite a large amount of decision making on both sides that I would have never done and certainly question. However this post is not about that stuff in particular, but I think it has made some patreon teams reflect on those events that happened, even if only a little bit and compare that situation within their own teams/groups so something like this won't happen to them.


ttrop was actually the first to link me the story and I discussed some on this stuff just to make sure we were on the same page. And we definitely are. So no extreme stuff like that will happen between myself and ttrop even in a hypothetical worst case scenario and certainly not with ongoing stuff pinoytoons.


Also as many people here might know, because I bounce back and fourth between multiple H games projects, I do like to keep them manageable in size so I can finish them, despite some wanting me to have them hanging around in a constant state of updates. I have seen time and time again, but on a much smaller scale where people working on a project never managed to actually finish because it is so easy to get off track and have all these ideas you want to add to a game. Plus going back and changing stuff to make it better, plus adding in all the amazing ideas from fans, you just get to point where it becomes overwhelming where the game will never be done.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Brigma

Breeding Season was a fun game and I did pledge to it for several months, but it was a mess before this whole debacle even happened. It was very poorly managed and as you stated new features were added so frequently that the game likely would have never been finished.

vortex00

when I read the story I thought about what you had said a while ago heh. Basically the same thing you are saying now. So I wasn't really surprised. and yeah all that is definitely a project killer. Hell even managed size projects seems like a struggle at times.

Anonymous

When I followed that game a year ago, I could tell they were setting the scope too big because they consistently added new monsters to the workload, and the project started feeling impossible to manage. This is why I've always liked you as a developer more than others. You consistently set reasonable expectations and are able to fulfill them regularly.

Brigma

The scope of the game was just too massive, I'm actually surprised it didn't collapse under it's own weight some time ago. Still it was a fun game and some of my suggestions for your trainer game were based on it's mechanics. For those that don't know, Breeding Season was a game that let you breed monsters together to create offspring that possessed desirable traits from their parents while losing undesirable ones. The game didn't let you change a monster's base stats once it was born so you had to keep breeding successive generations until you got a perfect one all the while avoiding incest as much as possible or the whole gene pool would collapse. It was a fun premise that I greatly enjoyed and to the creators credit they did get the mechanics working, until they decided to revamp the whole thing every few months. The main problem was with the animations. Every race of monster had a sprite for each gender, a loli version of each gender, and a futa female. That alone was 15 animations and then they decided to add feral versions of both genders and a female futa feral which brought the new total to 36. Then each of those versions could mate with the player and the player could be either male or female so the total animations for just 1 race of monster and the player was 52. Then the player could milk the monsters for items that could be sold or used in breeding which required a new animation for each variant of a creature and for both genders of the player so the final total of animations for just 1 race was 68. The team claimed they could produce 6 animations a month so that's a year right there assuming they didn't ditch every thing and start from scratch, which they did several times. Now you have to realize the game had about a dozen races so that's well over a decade to create the animations for just the individual races. When you take into account that the monsters could breed with other monsters which would each require a unique animation... you get the idea. It wasn't going to be finished in our lifetime.

JJATH

Well how about I just don't trust any of them again? It's simple, they all Fucked up badly. It's best to just avoid them unless they can bring something good to the table, But I won't trust S-Purples or Hbomb Again. Simples *Squeak*

Nathan O'Connor

I was disappointed when it ended. It had good ideas, some real potential, a gem waiting to be realised but they didn't seem able to bring it all together and when i found it a few months ago, between the apparent age of the game, the progress it had made and the comments section, the cracks were obvious. Ambition can be a double-edged sword. Sigh. 😧😕

Brigma

Trusting creators is something that some people are only now questioning, and really they should have thought about it from the start. When you pledge to a project there's no guarantee that it will ever be finished. While I trust Vortex not to do this, there's nothing stopping him from pulling up stakes right now and leaving his projects unfinished while keeping the money he's earned. The simple truth is that when you support a project you aren't actually supporting the project, you're supporting the artist or team while he/she/they work on the project. If you're satisfied with what you get every month for your money then there's no issue. If you think you're paying a little now for something in the future then you should just wait until the project is complete and buy it then

Anonymous

The game was "good enough" even before it reached patreon. I played, loved and completed it before this all happened. I never liked the new art BOTH TIMES... I was waiting for this to happen but now it has... im still disapointed and annoyed.

Thanny

I think it's worth noting that the project didn't collapse due to its scope (which was definitely too ambitious in places), but due to a bad contract made early on, and a douche-bag who exploited that contract for personal gain.

Nathan O'Connor

Hmm, this is actually the first time I've heard about this, do you know or have you heard, anything more about this, if you don't mind me asking.

vortex00

The contract was really short sighted yes on HBombs part to even being with yes. but you have to show both sides of the story thoguh to be fair. <a href="http://s-purple.tumblr.com/post/147484294391/breeding-seasons-cancelation-my-side-of-the" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">http://s-purple.tumblr.com/post/147484294391/breeding-seasons-cancelation-my-side-of-the</a> "I could have sold those assets to HBomb, but if I had left the art assets in, all my experience with HBomb up to this point leads me to believe that he would have simply sat on the art assets, continued to collect money from the Patreon, and not made any actual updates to the game. People would have been throwing money down a hole, and I refused to allow my work to enable that." "My current savings are not even half of that his quoted sum of $190,000, and was even less so at the time HBomb wrote the above, as a result of HBomb paying his personal taxes with my portion of the patreon funds from the shared bank account, as I mentioned previously." it is worth reading that whole tumblr post then make a decision after considering both sides. imo the contract was only like a killer having a assault rifle instead of rubber knife. It doesn't give motivation to use it thoguh. There were clearly other problems at play here when you read both sides and put them together. Because if you remove money, greed and contracts completely from the picture I also defiantly would have still left anyway. Also have to look at the other members on the team. I think if the environment was a nice to work in, the goal was attainable, and they were having fun and really liked working on the project, they would still stay to rebuild and keep the game going. Restarting is no problem when you have a nice and effective group to work with. I can say this both for independent work and white collar corporate work. One person does not ruin synergy, especially after finally leaving.

vortex00

I wasn't a huge fan of the art either heh. thought it was just me. Nothing wrong with it, just not my cup of tea I guess.

vortex00

I wouldn't say nothing heh, I took a huge risk and left my high paying job to work on this. So you best believe I'll be here to made sure stuff gets finished, goals met etc.

vortex00

yeah that multiplying is crazy. no way to finish, unless you hire on a lot of low budget animators I guess heh.

Nathan O'Connor

+Thanny +Vortex00 Thanks to both of you and i apologise, i did not notice the links in the description in the post you made Vortex00. It would seem Breeding Season is well and truly dead, i don't see it getting out of that quagmire alive. 😧 Oh well, unfortunately there's nothing to do now but to raise a glass to what was while it lasted. 🍸

vortex00

it is definitely a lot of finger pointing and evidence missing on both sides of the story. a total mess.