Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

A look back not only to this piece, but also to my entire two and a half years of Rock Music journey.

Files

Previews only

The Beatles, She’s Leaving Home - Reflections On My Journey

Comments

George Brady

I haven't watched, but this is just the title I was hoping for, Amy. Grab another cup of coffee, and I'm in!

Lynn Poole

John and Paul: vocals. Additional instruments: four violins, two violas, two cellos, double bass and harp. Paul admits he was impatient to record this and George Martin was busy. So he had someone else, Mike Leander, arrange it. George Martin has talked about how much that hurt him. After Paul apologized many times, they made peace. I have the box set and the initial takes of this are so lovely. The bare instrumentation is beautiful. Add a simple melody line, not provided by the vocals, and this is a beautiful classical piece.

Lynn Poole

Amy I had not heard the prominence of the harp until I listened to the isolated instrumentation. I thought there was a piano too. Of course now it's obvious it's the harp. What a versatile instrument! George Martin said this was one of their most well constructed songs. He likened it to an operetta. He did not arrange it but he produced it. This is one of my favorites but you provided new insights that may be similar to what GM heard.

Lee Kennison

I was just thinking how this song perfectly reflects the start of Amy's journey. Being the second song in her journey, it reflects Amy leaving her comfortable classical music home, entering into the crazy, yet exciting, would of rock and other contemporary music, along with its associated culture and people. Of course in Amy's case, she is not truly leaving her classical music home. It is more a case that she occasionally leaves the home she loves, in order to explore the rest of the world outside, only to return to her true home with a new perspective on life and music. Similar to going on vacation/holiday to a new land and culture. Great reaction and perspective on your journey and this song Amy.

George Brady

What a beautifully detailed personal reflection on this song, Amy. I realized while listening that I had experienced nothing like you just had, when first hearing it. I didn't, and couldn't have, at 16. Now, what I appreciate most is the lack of open criticism of either party in the narrative, in spite of their defensive statements. And the empathy from the band as opposed to the image of rebellious youth (that I just witnessed yesterday while watching Beatles 64 - I had forgotten, a little, the antipathy this group encountered). Thanks, Amy for the special appeal to us, to experience music!

Rodney Griffin

This such a heartbreakingly beautiful song. Tears me up ever time.

Julian Ortiz

I loved your reflections on your original first listen, your journey into Rock Music, and hearing how that experience has deepened your appreciation of this lovely song, Amy. I suppose I’ve had a similar experience with it as you described. I love it and sometimes I don’t like it so much because of the emotional impact it brings when listening to it. At the end of the day, the love far outweighs any negative emotions I might feel. I sometimes rather enjoy those dramatic tugging at my heart strings moments wrapped in that love and it brings me to a sense and place of peaceful serenity. I just can’t adequately express how much I adore this song. I’m a Metalhead… I enjoy and listen to fast, aggressive and sometimes very dark music. It’s my number one preference when turning on my iPod or the radio, but I was raised on The Beatles and Elvis Presley and Motown and Country and Traditional Spanish Folk music. This song is the opposite of everything I usually enjoy, and instead of being repelled by it, I embrace it. It is life for me and I enjoy the contrasts and duality because it brings me balance and those vivid colors. Without it, my life would be that dull grey newspaper you described. Your initial first listen to this song is what brought me first to your YouTube channel and then eventually here to this Patreon. I’ve been with you on that journey for two years now and it’s been so much fun. There’s still so much to look forward to, not only with The Beatles, but with other amazing groups and artists and that really excites me. This is hands down my favorite Patreon and I am grateful to you and Vlad for sharing this journey with all of us. 🫶🏼

Rea Lavi

Amy's illuminating comments about Paul's vocal delivery as "the newspaper" reporting on the story of the song, which is filled with emotional content, and about the instruments expressing the emotions of the song, made me think about Eleanor Rigby.

David Taylor

Well done Amy, Vlad. And Amy, I still go back and watch the SLH video analysis. Same with SFF. They hold up quite well if you ask me. You sure can set a scene. When you said the music was gray, a rainy, gloomy English sky immediately came to mind. I could even see the wet pavement. LOL

George Brady

I was surprised to recently discover several instances of critics pitting those two songs comparatively against each other. In my small sample, Eleanor Rigby fared better, while this song had more detractors.

Lynn Poole

My journey was the same. And here we are. A modern day Beatles family with a shared purpose.

Lynn Poole

Both are deserving of praise but the inclusion of the harp and Paul and John's perfect voices should be enough to dismiss the detractors. What do they know? We are the listening audience and we are the experts.

David Taylor

Amy, you called the vocals non-dramatic. I think of them as sympathetically poignant. Do you know the tale of the song's origins? It is quite bizarre and coincidental. Maybe someone with decent typing skills, and a better writing style will post it .

Lynn Poole

I think she's clutching her handkerchief because she's wiping away tears. This is not an easy decision for her.

Lynn Poole

I hope Vlad and Amy won't mind this posting. Rick Beato posted a video earlier today where he breaks down the chord structure to the melody and has similar commentary as Amy about the orchestra, especially the cello. I think it's a nice companion piece to Amy's review.

George Brady

"The note that she wished would say more" yes, Amy, this is only revelation in the narrative. This family didn't communicate, "she" fails even in a final message to express her confused feelings. The only non-newspaper messaging from the narrator is "Daddy, our Baby's gone" and then on to that "bye, bye" that you drew my attention to and helped me pay attention to, for the first time.

George Brady

I was surprised by the coincidence until I realized I wasn't watching Amy on YouTube. Still, one wonders.

Lynn Poole

A few minutes ago, I said to myself. I sure would like to know what was in that note. But then thought they kind of told us in what John is singing.

Paul D. Hoffmaster III

Dressing gown. When I was a kid, in the states, Philly area, it is funny how many women had their cleaning clothes, shopping clothes etc. even if they were not of money. I remember my mother changing and putting and on a head scarf when cleaning the house. When this song first came out, it didn't hit me for a few years until I was a few years older and really listen to the heart of what was being said. Being in the service I was being hit with a lot of new things to live with. Also coming from a broken home, in my early teens, these were a little the things that I heard from my parents about the other one when I was alone with one of them. Now I could heard the disconnect that was being said to me. Another good review again Amy, with a different outlook on the words that took me some time to understand as I said above. :)

George Brady

This is the most attention I've paid to this song, ever. It has had a journey with me, from pretending it didn't exist, to never playing it. I still never play it alone, but this album is diminished without it, it's irreplaceable now.

Lynn Poole

George I play this song more than any other except for my favorite (which you know) and the B side of the album that song is on.

Gustavo Faveron-Patriau

I hope at some point Amy will comment on one of the key elements of the Sgt. Pepper album: the fact that this is the first McCartney-lead Beatles project. Just look at the songs we have listened so far: Sgt. Pepper, With a Little Help, Getting Better, Fixing a Hole, and She´s Leaving Home are either mostly or entirely written by Paul (who also came up with the concept of the album), which makes Lucy the only non-McCartney-lead song so far. I love Amy´s comments but I confess I´m a little bummed by the fact that Paul was not even mentioned in this reaction.

George Brady

Really, Lynn, that's intriguing. It doesn't hit me as having appeal as a "singer's song". Do you vocalize along with it? The background harmony ("sheeee.. as Amy pointed out) or how?

Guillermo Ramirez

My dumb brain went to Bob Dylan's 4th time around instead

Lee Kennison

Highly recommended! I just watched this and just came here to see if anyone else recommended this, so I'm glad you did. You covered the points I was wanting to make on the melodic breakdown and how it works with the harmonic progression. Rick has an effective way of communicating this through his isolated tracks and on screen illustrations, in addition to his musical and verbal descriptions. Rick typically avoids playing large sections of Beatles songs due to copyright issues, even though they are probably his favorite band. So I was surprised he had so much of the songs content. Perhaps playing isolated tracks helps with this, but I doubt it. Rick used it as an illustration on how to write a perfect melody, along with mentioning he thought it was the most beautiful song on Sgt. Pepper's. I am always struck by the coincidence on some of the things Beato and Elizabeth post that relates to what Amy is reacting to. I have drawn Amy and Vlad's attention to these coincidences before, typically in direct messages. It would have been great if Rick was aware of Amy and her Beatles project, and asked her to come in to illustrate the harp part.

Lynn Poole

George Today I left to go do some errands after my first listen and sang it at the top of my voice. I replayed it several times. I sing the verses with Paul and the choruses with John.

Pedro Macedo

Great reaction, Amy, thanks. The song appears to have a connection to the Melanie Cole story Paul would have read in the newspaper. The song's sadness primarily stems from the mother's response. There are plenty of female reactors on YT crying for this hearing this song.

Rea Lavi

Kitchen, clutching, hankerchief.. brilliant

idreamofdouche

When I hear this song I always think of Go Ask Alice. It is a book where the girl descends into drug addiction and runs away from home. It was written 1971 and was a commentary about drug use in the 60's and the harm it caused. When Alice runs away from home and deeply regrets it, she hears this song on the radio and feels a deep connection because it reflects her longing for home and her family. Basically this song but from the girl's perspective.

Lynn Poole

From the Sgt Pepper book with the box set. George Martin considered it to be one of the best songs they ever constructed. He said: "The lyrics are particularly telling. I'm amazed, actually, that they did this at their age, because they could see the conflict between the young and the old. Such empathy is evoked in the stirring phrase 'clutching her handkerchief' and also the emotional line in which the girl's mother still calls her husband 'Daddy' as if her daughter were there listening."

Jazz C.

I do hope for some more dissecting of paul as an artist for sure! It’s Paul’s first time completely taking over an album which obviously will eventually lead to other issues and that trajectory is important. Certainly John is talked about as an artist but Paul singularly isn’t which I feel is a very lopsided considering how much he propels the band.

Jazz C.

This song always reminds me of I’ll follow the sun which you can interpret as being about leaving home as well. But I’m this instance paul isn’t singing from his experiences but rather outside looking in. Looking at the sadness and loneliness of the parents but also highlighting I think the dangerous and necessary feeling the child has. That removed tone kinda removes the judgement from each side but I do think he’s subtlety commenting on the kinda obliviousness of British parents during this era. “What did we do that was wrong?” You let your child feel so oppressed by your traditionalism (I think the music itself is portraying the parent as ultra traditional especially the way the “parents” talk) that she felt she HAD to run away. But there’s no acknowledgment from the parents in the song that they’re the ones that made living there intolerable to the child who just wanted to have fun (something that was always denied). John said his bits were basically just things his aunt used to tell him to guilt him when he was a rough kid “never thought of ourselves”. I think they’re trying to convey this feeling of the whole situation being tragic because neither side can understand the other which I think both John and Paul severely experienced with their parental figures (paul was particularly sensitive to parents oppressing their children)

Aurelio Asiain

Sorry to say it, but since Monday a message saying "Sorry/ We’re having a little trouble" is the only thing appearing on the screen. Please check it up.

Carl Payne

Fascinating perceptions from Amy. SLHome is a song that “plagued me” for years, simply because I first heard it in my mid teens & I think I was psychologically & culturally unable to fully appreciate the human emotions being expressed. At the time I was into boisterous guitar rock and blues and high energy jazz rock. It was all 100mph stuff. Years - and 2 kids later, I found myself listening to it through what seemed like new ears. I recall describing it to a mate as a masterpiece - & I recall his mocking laughter. So it was also comforting (?) or maybe instructive to hear Amy’s views tonight on how subjective musical appreciation certainly is. What a journey this music thing is……🤗

Misty Bastian

Amy, thank you for this reflection on the song and your experience of it through 2.5 years. When I was a girl and first heard it, I think I could only “hear” Her side—that She was oppressed and repressed, that She needed to have fun and to be free and gone. (Back then, being “gone” was about more than physical absence, as in “real gone,” meaning something like ecstasy.) So, I heard “Bye bye” in Her voice. Goodbye to all that noise. Here at the other end of life, I hear it more strictly in the narrator’s voice. One small act, but a whole lifetime of change. Between Wednesday at 5 and Friday at 9, it’s all swept away. Bye bye.

TangoEliott

I always loved this song but had 2 issues with this (I write before you finish). I never understood the man from the motor trade. Is she buying a car? Is she going to work for him? Does motor trade mean something else? Also, what do they mean that "fun is the one thing money can't buy". It is something money can always buy. It can't buy me love, but it can buy fun. So please, I have suffered for 57 years. Can't money buy fun?

Beatles4Sale

Paul is reporting the news. John is conveying the heart wrenching emotion of the parents. I love the way they go back and forth with each other.

celt67

She's going to start a new job, a new life. She is planning to work in the motor trade. She wants to be self sufficient. Her parents bought her things, but suppressed her. You can be wealthy and still miserable.

TangoEliott

Of course, you can be miserable but money can buy fun. I will accept the fact that she got a job in the auto industry but I still think money can buy fun. It can't fulfill you or make you happy but it can buy fun

RAD1

My father (a very loving man but non-musician) sharply criticized The Beatles as a bad influence. I think he would have changed his mind if he could listen to your (and Leonard Bernstein's) strong praise, and this song.

marielblues

I have always been amazed at how Amy hears (or interprets) things in the music in relation to the lyrics that perhaps not even the composer or arranger intended.

Lynn Poole

I have long wondered about that line so a couple of weeks ago I looked it up. Fun is an emotion, positive feeling, a state of enjoyment. It may result from an experience of enjoying something. I had thought it was an emotion so that was my query. "Is fun an emotion"? In an interview with the woman in the article, she said she had dated a man in the motor trade but there is no way that John and Paul would have known that.

Lynn Poole

The way I interpreted it is that fun is the emotion you feel when you do something enjoyable. Fun and happiness are two separate emotions. But I'll agree that it is a bit confusing. I think the emotion definition supports that you can't buy fun but you can buy something that is fun. Wonder if John and Paul spent time thinking this through. Knowing them, they might have.

TangoEliott

Yes, I see what you mean but I consider fun as something you go and have. You can have fun but still be unhappy. I appreciate your input.

Graeme Frew

I always just assumed that the "man from the motor trade" was her boyfriend, that possibly her parents didn't like.

Lynn Poole

No question you can have fun but be unhappy. Interesting that their lyrics used both happy and fun. I assumed the same about "the man from the motor trade".

Rea Lavi

Perhaps the "appointment she made" was to buy a car - a symbol of independence/freedom, esp. at that time, esp. for a young woman at that time? Either that or they just liked the alliteration...

Rea Lavi

Yes, they wrote songs in their 20s that it takes some people (including myself) decades until they can appreciate what it is they're talking about. This album in particular is a good example of that.

Mike Clancey

That was a mouthful, but you nailed it! Personally, I only "rediscovered " this song a couple of years ago and instantly loved it . When I saw your first, first listen earlier this year I was a little taken aback. Glad to see that it has grown on you.

DJ Marquis Marc Rambeau du Tacoma

Had to look that up, Rea... are you... um... BLUEISH (I mean, British)? Etymology 1 Origin uncertain. Noun dog's bollocks pl (plural only) (UK, Ireland, Commonwealth, vulgar, slang) Something that is outstandingly good. Synonym: (euphemism) dog's dangly bits That new flat screen TV you bought is the dog's bollocks. See also bee's knees cat's pyjamas cat's whiskers duck's guts mutt's nuts

Rea Lavi

I lived in Blighty for a good chunk of my life and I'm a British citizen, but culturally I'm maybe 30% British (English, really). I love the humor and music especially

DJ Marquis Marc Rambeau du Tacoma

Rea - you mentioned something I have often wondered about: Okay... so I get that England is a subset of Britain. So, clearly, all Englanders are British, but not all Britons are English. Simple enough. But I've often wondered, for those who live there, is England/Britain pretty much used interchangeably in common conversation? Are there some (of course there, but you know what I mean) who take offense if addressed incorrectly? I've never been outside of the U.S., and I was just wondering...

DJ Marquis Marc Rambeau du Tacoma

"Fun is the one thing that money can't buy." - John Lennon. Hmmmm. This line alone has generated SO MANY comments right here, and it surprises me just a little. To me, this line has always meant (in line with my own personal philosophy, I suppose) that one cannot purchase an emotion (as opposed to a short term experience) with legal tender, or something along those lines. (Yeah, I never really thought it through before.)

TangoEliott

The first time i heard that line i did a double take. I was 15. I found it disappointing because fun can be bought. I don't know now fun is considered an emotion. Certainly there has to be a better word?

DJ Marquis Marc Rambeau du Tacoma

At around 51 minutes, you showed the painting The Corner by Andrew Wyeth. My uncle was (first a commercial, and then) a fine artist who introduced me to a lot of wonderful art. I'd say that Andrew Wyeth (along with John Singer Sergeant and the impressionists and post-impressionists, Paul Cezanne at the tippy-top)... is one of my favorite artists of all time. This was a nice touch in your video.

DJ Marquis Marc Rambeau du Tacoma

3rd (and final) comment here, and it's a surprise. At about 54min, you say you dislike this song in the sense that you said that you "dislike the experience that it is expressing." Wow! What a statement! On the one hand, I totally agree... and that is EXACTLY why I never listen to The Wall (other than a few isolated songs like IS THERE ANYBODY OUT THERE?) - because it transports me back to a depressive time in my life - and who the heck wants that??? On the other hand, and there is ALWAYS another hand, isn't there... if I only listened to music where I liked the experience of what is being expressed... well, I'd have almost nothing to listen to! It's a fine line, isn't it - this idea of music providing a trigger for a prior experience, huh? A most interesting conundrum, if I do say so myself.

DJ Marquis Marc Rambeau du Tacoma

No doubt there is a better word, here, TangoEliott. But, think about it, Paul was writing the lyrics... would he have done a deep philosophical dive into happiness/fun just for the sake of this lyric? If so, kudos, Paul!

DJ Marquis Marc Rambeau du Tacoma

Hey Rea... just a thought: so, were the Beatles REALLY that far advanced, psychologically speaking, or... did they just CHANNEL the philosophy of the songs they were listening to at the time? Enquiring minds want to know!

TangoEliott

He should have. He wrote money can't buy me love. Maybe he could have said" fun is the one thing she never tried"

Johnny Voodoo

Well that’s a can of worms. The non-English Britons get offended if Britain is referred to as ‘England’ and they certainly don’t like being referred to as English. They also don’t like it if people say Britain when they specifically mean England (it implies that the other nations don’t count). And who can blame them? It doesn’t happen the other way round - nobody would refer to an English person as Scottish, for example. There is a casual disregard when referring to the other nations from some English people which is quite rude and triggering.

gwool

so good ! Thanks Amy and Vlad