Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

We're back with a crucial, lengthy episode. The Life Of A Showgirl is here, and it's causing meltdowns left, right, and center. Here on Evolution of a Snake, we try to find the middle in the midst of the chaos. So, here are our unfiltered first impressions of Taylor Swift's 12th studio album. It's time to unpack it all: the Tayvising, Charli hateration, bad bitch/savage of it all. Please remember to engage kindly with your fellow Patreon snakes <3

Comments

Mikee Dayrit

I HAVE BEEN REFRESHING HELL YES

Alicia

Seated. Sat. Been excited for this...!!! Let's goooo

Greg

Yassssss

Eden McFadden

Can’t WAIT to listen to this divas 😍

Carolina 🦋

ON A CLEANING SUNDAY!?!?! WELL YESSSSSSSS

Maura M

Honestly, my favorite review was Dan Cash’s first reaction, which was that he felt like he was hanging out in the lobby of an old, luxurious hotel. Of all of the initial reviews, that was my favorite.

Julie Chu

I agree with you so much on the "ttpd lyrics with catchy prod" instead of folklore lyrics like shes been saying!!! The lyrics like rambling going on wordy really sounds more TTPD for me

Karibunt

I love being here

Claire

I hope Zach talks about whatever he said on the deleted live

Erika

Sonically - I felt PREPARED for this album bc I spent the last 5 days packing & cleaning & listening to broadway showtunes! On first listen it was giving Heathers, Spring Awakening, Legally Blonde, Mean Girls. Production wise this fits the theme!!!! If yk the vibes & essence of orchestra/ guitar/ live stage productions, TLOAS checks the box & I could see it turned into the next Mamma Mia. HOWEVERRR, yall clocked its wordy, it’s complex, for new ppl to Tay the choruses are fantastic & catchy but the verses you need backstory & insights and it slays for analysis purposes I love peeking at her diary, but it’s not Pop Bible that ppl grocery shopping can digest all that info. Loveeeee yall!!!!!!

Erika

I stand w the expectations we’re behind the scenes here’s what toll stage life takes & I wanted background dancer perspectives & tiny bug in front of 60k crowds so that was disappointing. Really relied on production to fit the theme bc without it I don’t see showgirl

Ruby256

Guys I know it’s literally just not the time right now but just wanna know have you seen the Addison performance on Fallon yet?!!!!

Jadz

What I will say about Cancelled is the interpretation that it could be about MAGA/used as a maga anthem feels so far out. Swift has long been disavowed by staunch magas due to her vocal endorsement of the democrats. The song (to me) is so clearly about the cultural witch hunt of successful women. She's playing a character (much like in a lot of rep and in songs like Florida) and supporting the women who have been "cancelled" for becoming too successful. It truly feels like I did something bad part 2. Just my thoughts!

Devori Kimbro

I think the first chorus of “Opalite” is meant to be her mother saying that there’s never been anyone like Taylor, then she goes on to tell Travis that she’s never met anyone like him before. The lead in to the first is “and my mama told me,” and the second is “that’s when I told him.”

Paula C

Same 🥹

Devori Kimbro

There’s a very “I now realize my mom was right and I want to share that energy with you” thing happening.

Chels :)

Father-figure-is-about-Joe truthers STAND UP (I’ve been standing since I heard it.)

Paula C

Me!! Dishwasher. ✅Vacuuming. ✅Throwing kids tchotchkes away. ✅

Paula C

I think her marketing and REACH was so good and expansive that random ass people heard about the album, the variants, and now think they are supposed to have an opinion. So if her marketing wasn’t so good we would never hear from them 🤣

Jadz

Magas also could (and do) co-opt anything and everything to validate their message - even something like 1984, for example. Just because they might willfully misinterpret a piece of art, doesn't mean the art is to blame (especially when it's clearly anti whatever message they're pushing)

Leslie

Worst album ever made, no. Worst album Taylor has made...I think possibly but I need to sit with it more.

stephaliceo

god i love you guys, the charli imitation 😂 100% agree with you on all points honestly, there’s a lot to like in this album and a lot to pick apart, and that’s okay 🤷🏻‍♀️ tay laughing all the way to the bank, and we’ll be seated for next era.

Mikee Dayrit

The way I thought Lorde's Favorite Daughter and Taylor's Eldest Daughter would be spiritual sisters....... in that sense Favorite Daughter is a straight A student, valedictorian, found a cure for cancer and Eldest Daughter is the black sheep of the family that got kicked out of the house for being a druggie

Kelsea's Comments

People are overthinking the title/theme. It's the LIFE of a showgirl. She said it was more life than showgirl. She said that. No one listened. It's literally just what was going on in her life while she was showgirling on the eras tour. The album is EXACTLY what she described.

Miss Liz

Here!! If we look at the original Father Figure and flip the plot because the love interest turned out to be the worst? Yep that’s what I think

Mikee Dayrit

u cant blame folks for being misled because of the photos and videos she used for promo. not many people watch her interviews or have read her quotes. it’s not good marketing.

Kelsea's Comments

The photos were part of the point. On the outside she was showgirling. The ALBUM is what takes you behind the scenes to what was going on in her life while she was showgirling. The promo was showing us the showgirl. The album takes us into her life and shows what the human being was doing and feeling and dealing with. It makes perfect sense to me. That's the whole point of a showgirl. In public you're the character. You're the showgirl. No one wants to see the human. The promo was on purpose and makes perfect sense, people just misinterpreted because they don't get what she was saying. That's no one's fault but their own.

Leslie

But also that's fine. Some album has to be the worst. There are still things I like about it and I still trust Taylor as an artist. I think it makes sense that some of her weakest writing is on the album she made during the most demanding stretch of a two-year tour that by all accounts burned her out mentally and physically. 🤷 She'll make something I love again at some point and until then I let her rock.

Abby

Agreed x1000! Cancelled is kind of meaningless as a word at this point - some people who get cancelled deserve it, others don't (which is what she's driving at in the song), and then there are plenty of people still around with careers and fans who should have been cancelled loooong ago. Interpreting the word cancelled to mean republican/right wing/MAGA feels bad faith to me, especially when you actually look at the rest of the lyrics. And you can't not make art because someone might misinterpret it, that's just how it goes.

Andrea Peterlechner

I get you, ive listened to this album twice now and at first i thought was atrocious, now id give it 4/10, melodys are catchy but definitely not my vibe. Feels like music that plays on the store radio. I usually go to taylor for profound lyrics and most of it fell flat for me. it feels rushed and just not what i expected. Im really dissappointed with this album. Its like she hunted down a trend instead of following her gut

Jess

This is a really sane take. Every artist with a career as long as Taylor's is gonna have peaks and valleys. When she said this album was gonna be all Max and Shellback, people probably expected 1989 Part 2. She's never gonna make another 1989 or Rep but that's OK!

Jess

To me it gives Olivia Rodrigo (specifically her little sister kind of relationship to Taylor at first, then how it changed sometime in 2021) and everyone thinks I'm insane.. I know Z&M said she wouldn't sing about that situation again but I think anything is on the table when she's still singing about Kimye.

Jennifer

crying at 1:01:27 🤣🤣

Miss Liz

Y’all are EXPERTS!! I left FB/IG when TTPD came out because the hate scared me (that was not the only reason). When I LOVED this album I was really scared to get on Patreon and YouTube today. I knew it would be safe to hear your assessment, agree or disagree, and learn something I didn’t know before :)

Sheryl Guerrero

But also- which visual is her actually on stage? (I could be wrong) Everything is either off stage, in a hotel room, or a dressing room. yes she is in showgirl costumes but it’s not on stage?

Anna

Does anyone think Wi$h Li$t is referring to Travis’s ex as well as Joe? The things that they want??? Am I crazy??

Katie

Haven’t listened to this ep yet but I did listen to the live, he was mostly just disappointed and said that there were good songs on the album but not great ones, maybe he’s changed his mind since then. We’ll see!

Tyler

The “showgirl” part of the album is the fact that it’s not relatable at all, it’s completely an album about being out of touch and the most famous woman alive. I like the album, it’s not my fav but it’s good. But it’s unique to her other albums because at no point is she trying to be your relatable best friend or is she playing the good girl, she’s leaning even more into the fame thing than reputation did

Tyler

I would love to hear you guys talk about Taylor writing while in love. I know she was trying to prove a point that she can still write good while in love, and she can, see cruel summer, but there’s something so fascinating about lover and showgirl being bottom two albums when they’re the two “I’m finally happy” albums

Jen

I actually think the misalignment of the visuals to the songs perfectly captures the concept. What we see of the visuals represents exactly what we think a showgirl is, but the life of a showgirl is exactly the opposite. She is falling in and out of love, she’s wishing for things beyond the glitz and money, she finds loyalty so rare in her life that she offers fierce loyalty, she has drama with people loving and hating her. And in the end people admire her, and want to be her, but she wishes she could just warn against it.

Devori Kimbro

I think we have to take her at her word on TTPD - it’s the worst men that she writes the best. I think she writes diagnostically - why is he doing this? Why did I do this to myself again? What is he feeling? Travis wears everything on his sleeve with her. It’s the same reason we only have one song about Taylor Lautner - he was an open book. The Travis songs are never going to be hugely introspective because he lets her get out of her own head. And as an over-thinker married to a man who does thoughtful stuff like Travis, is my ultimate hype man, etc., I am thrilled for her. Remember how so many of us love the line, “If I loved you less I might be able to talk about it more?”

Claire

Kill me from Haylee Williams is soooooo much better too!!

Devori Kimbro

But “Cruel Summer” isn’t a love song. She’s in love, yes, but she’s anxious as hell that she’s going to ruin it simply by telling him/others. Songs about being in love are not inherently love songs, IMO, because being in love in an uneven relationship isn’t relaxing or edifying. It’s a tightrope.

Jemsss

the thing I don't like about this album is that she sounds bitter, cynical, and pretentious. calling women bitches, complaining about everyone hating her and how mean the internet is, wanting everyone to leave her the fuck alone after saying she needed out of the basement and to be bejeweled.. she does not sound "the happiest she's ever been".

Hattie

Thank you Snakes for this very long, very much needed, initial reaction 🙏🏻 Agreed with everything you both had to say. (Zach I also think Father Figure is about Joe!!🫢) This album is not for me and that’s okay. I’m a sad autumn girly, so you’ll find me in the Evermore woods, telling Folklore and painting in Red at Midnight with my Tortured Poet. Enjoy, Showgirl lovers, as that’s the beauty of Taylor, she has an album for everybody 🪩

Leslie

Ok but the title track, which is supposed to be the thesis statement of the album, is about the costs that come with choosing to perform for a living, about passing wisdom down to younger artists and about feeling like you've secured your legacy in the industry. I think that's the kind of "behind the scenes" look people were expecting, but they only really got it on that one song which is the title track despite not being representative of the album. TTPD has more of that sort of insight than this album does. You could say any of her albums are about "the life of a showgirl" because they're all about her life and she's a showgirl. I find that a bit of a cop out personally.

Paula C

Hey so something I just realized…… go look up a close up of Travis’s eye color. Now look at the album cover, the OG. That greenish/hazel. There was also an obvious weird Easter egg sounding “the color of your eyes sweetie” on the podcast. This album could just be how Taylor feels seen by Travis. Through his eyes

Sara Sweet

The thing that keeps successfully ragebaiting me is saying that “if 1989 came out today yall would hate it”….. I’m like……… enough

Sara Sweet

You are right that this album is more for the normies like TTPD was for the mentally ill swifties

Erika Fern 🌿

I think if the album was titled Actually Romantic and she never uttered the words folklore or storytelling this would have been a fine (albeit still a bit childish lyrically) album with some fun bops, a few flops and nowhere near her best work but a fun time overall!

Leslie

Yeah there's a palpable bitterness running through the album and I'm not sure where it's coming from

Leslie

The last bit of this episode is pretty much a summation of what he said on the live

Leslie

We been needing this

Hannah Spencer

Long time listener, new subscriber… unsubscribing… this is not the vibe I was looking for at all, everyone’s miserable 😔

Jenny Wikstrand

Agree on Wood in clean mode! But still, the way she pronounces ”rockkkk” always icks me. It’s like her mouth is watering or something, it’s a very specific sound I can’t unhear even in the clean version. But still the song is stuck in my brain nonstop. I pray for ”Wood - kindergarten version” where ALL penile innuendo is removed and it is just a insanely boppy song about being scared that you won’t have physical chemistry with the person you love but it turns ut that when you’re in love it all works out.

Miss Liz

And Madeline said it’s ok for me to like Wood!?! See this is my point.

Nicole Ouimette

Soooo when is Olivia coming out with her third album?

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

The Father Figure theory that it "switches perspectives" also makes no sense to me. I would not described young Taylor as "wayward, lost in the cold", and certainly not Scott as someone with any pull in the industry. She was basically his first client and the only reason his record became a big deal. She also continues her use of "I was your father figure" like, if it switched perspectives, it would make more sense if she said "You were my father figure, we drank that brown liquor" etc. "You made a deal with this devil..." Scott did not make a deal with Taylor as the "devil", it was the other way around. It seems like It's written from the perspective of the father figure and stays that way. I think the muse of this song is not Scott, but perhaps someone else that Taylor viewed as a prodigy. The only line that relates it to Scott is "This empire belongs to me, leave it with me" but that could apply to anyone who served as a prodigy that Taylor let into her world. Also IN WHAT UNIVERSE would Taylor remind Scott of his younger self IJBOL.

Deb

No way Father Figure is about Joe. Scott Borchetta. The song starts with SB promising to make her a star, (the brown liquor...he owns a whiskey business) then he sold her albums (the bad decision). Then she is the one with power and takes them back (the empire) Joe never had enough going on to make business decisions and fight about an empire lol.

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

I disagree. If by "bitch" you mean "I'm not a bad bitch" on Eldest Daugher, Bad Bitch is just an endearing phrase used to describe cool, attractive women. It's popular slang. The biggest point of the "leave us the fuck alone" lyric is "AND THEY DO". She's saying that when she doesn't want attention from the internet, she should be able to say that and have her boundaries respected. Which is completely fair considering the level of attention she's gotten recently. I think that maybe if you've been living under a rock and haven't seen the level of attention or hate that she's gotten, then those lyrics would seem odd to you. But they make sense in context. These are basic human emotions and "wants" that she's describing.

Miss Liz

I just figured out why Actually Romantic is reminding me of high school. It’s my self titled Weezer CD. That guitar and sarcasm but with crazy crap going on in the background that I had no idea about. Undone as an example :)

Emily Sawich

Such a spot on review! Thank you for ripping apart eldest daughter it really was so disappointing lyrically... love to hear both your opinions!

Chas

It’s a space where open, adult discussion takes place which means it isn’t just constant, blind praise. It’s probably best you look elsewhere if that’s not what you’re interested in at the moment.

Chas

I’ll be joining you in the woods with my velvet cloak on, lighting candles in the cabin!

Sydney

This person is most likely referring to “the bitch was telling me to back off” in honey.

nevo

We really need the last two Taylor's Versions and the a break from her for two years. When she comes back, I need her to work with four different groups of producers, and not two producers (not Aaron, Jack; Max, Shellback). Also, I'm ready to not be embarrassed by a Taylor album. There have been one or two lyrics the past two albums where I want to hide in a hole.

Jemsss

yep. as well as the lyric in the title track.

reckless mermaid

Yes, agreed. I don’t actually hate the album overall, But it’s not lost on me that in this album she reserves her biggest drags for other women and even if it’s deserved, it’s not a good look overall. I suspect that Charli had it coming but combining the diss track of the century with the way nearly all the bitter references on Honey (the irony of a song called Honey being so bitter) are aimed at other bullying women: “passive aggressive at the bar/ cus her man had looked at me wrong” and “she was saying that skirt don’t fit me.” Like come on Taylor, you couldn’t think of a time when a shitty industry dude called you “Sweetheart” or “Honey” as a young wannabe star?? It’s very mean white lady coded, which fits her upbringing but if I were the lyricist I would pause and think of better examples that aren’t just women being bitchy. Lastly, calling the other show girls bitches waiting for her to die…. Like I’m sure these are all her experiences, but the optics suck. Cancelled! would have saved it some if she hadn’t given it such a right-wing coded name; because she does seem to be focusing more on the way women are “cancelled” for nothing, but she never really gets around to making that point directly. Over all, I think this album really shows how the person she’s dating has an influence on her work. When she was rubbing shoulders more with the “coastal liberal elite” or whatever, she was heavily influenced to drop the catty pick-me antics and position herself more as a girls girl feminist. Now that’s she’s spending more time around Travis and his crowd, she’s definitely reverting to more of a middle American women are bitches perspective

Jeanne

To be fair, she literally always says the newest album is her favorite and greatest thing ever made

Elaine

I concur with whoever says ‘Ruin The Friendship’ should have been track 5. Not only that, it is the standout track on the album and I agree with you that it seems a little out of place. It’s one of the most emotional tracks I’ve heard from her, and it makes me cry.

Elaine

Miserable because many people don’t think this is the best Taylor Swift record ever made? Isn’t it ok to truly dislike a song here or there? I don’t like wood (explicit) and will never play it again. Madeline will never listen to Cancelled! again. For me, most of the album is a bop, but not liking one or two songs does not make us miserable. This is a good space and most people have thoughtful and nuanced opinions on here. It would be a shame for you to miss out, because the commentary on here is so much more interesting than on other platforms.

Sarah B

Bahaha wood kindergarten version 😆

Jen

I don’t get the issue with wishlist. I wouldn’t say it’s top favorite for me, but I didn’t get the same vibe. For anyone who has gotten what they wanted, at any level, you realize that either it wasn’t what you expected, or you look to what’s next. A wishlist is always evolving. For most of her life she’s been chasing adoration, fame, money and now she’s found someone she loves. Love changes people and their priorities. It doesn’t mean she wants to throw everything she has away, it just means her priority is different. Again, we think the showgirl wants diamonds and mansions, which of course she does, we all do, but she also wants true love and a normal life. Both can exist and be true.

Anna F

I heard opalite and my first thought was "oh this is made to be covered by a wedding band" Overall, I think there are some really decent high on this album but some LOW lows and it doesn't balance out well.

Karibunt

Wayward can refer to the rawness of talent. Not domesticated for stardom. Like raw potential. I think this is clearly for Scotty Bruchetta

TayLiviaAddisonAudreyNatalie

Ahhh okay, that makes sense. Even still, I don't think Scott possessed nearly enough power or industry pull to be the mafia-style father figure that Taylor's describing.

Karibunt

Bebe go to chats and reacts for always celebrating. They don’t say they hated it! They are giving their opinionnnnns.

SP

Thank you. This is exactly it. And not to be cliche but when you know you know and when you don’t… you don’t. Just because her priority is love right now, doesn’t invalidate everything else or even mean she won’t ever want anything material again. We are all human!

Kate!!!

I am getting whiplash between what people are saying to me vs what people on the internet are saying but I liked the album! I think a large part of me liked it bc it was what I want to hear about my favorite character in a tv show i’ve been watching since I was basically 7 years old. In that sense, my opinion is hard to pull apart from the attachment I have to the journey of the narrative arc of the character of Taylor Swift that I will never actually know LOL I thought there might be more eras tour BTS stuff on it than there was but I had a feeling when she announced it on the podcast with Travis and emphasized Travis a lot as being a part of her life in that podcast, that it would very likely be lover 2.0. Eldest Daughter has a really good bridge but the rest of the song arghhhhh the internet slang made me burst out laughing but I do like the heart of the idea that she’s never felt more herself than she has since being with Travis bc she’s intrinsically “cringe”. She says stuff that can make you recoil like “noooo naurrr just say the normal word not fire” I actually really do believe she isn’t online bc the internet slang she was using was 2020 and I can’t see how someone like her could stay sane while scrolling social media. Overall, I haven’t been able to form an opinion but I feel like all I could say is that I’m happy for her 😹 I don’t think the songs on this album are worse or better than lover but i haven’t sat with it long enough to say. I think Elizabeth Taylor and Fate of Ophelia are very good songs and I wouldn’t call anything a “skip” except for maybe cancelled dhdhdh I wish the internet wasn’t so cruel bc my entire twitter and tik tok is FILLED with people being so unkind that it puts my head into defensive protective mode bc it’s all the people that already didn’t like her suddenly feeling empowered. You would think she just released 143 with the stuff people are saying in comments and online and then you switch to see her interviews and stuff and she hasn’t done them in so long, she just seems so happy, so it makes me sad bc I do know she can write better but the way people are responding is not sincere, it’s purely just to “get her”

Leigh Anne Harden

All of Zach’s songs also are on my list. Except add opalite. I love the way wood sounds -and Zach I saw your face when the song started!! You were into it ;) It was good. Until…. I could’ve handled knock on wood. That’s about it. And what’s a shame is the theme of this song is so good because with Travis she finally breaks out of the prophecy, and fate, and invisible strings, and pennies, and wishes etc etc that she’s been singing about for years. So why did his 🍆 have to be so involved?!

SP

I see where you are coming from even tho I disagree and align more with the OP commenter’s perspective. I will say- what you thought the album would be is what I personally hope the Eras documentary will be. So fingers crossed we still get some of that eventually!

K.C.

this Patreon is my safe space ✨ this breakdown is already more thoughtful than NYT 🙏🙏🙏

Leslie

I'm a huuuuuge Weezer fan and it immediately reminded me of Weezer!

Leslie

" Like come on Taylor, you couldn’t think of a time when a shitty industry dude called you “Sweetheart” or “Honey” as a young wannabe star??" THANK YOU! I can't believe I haven't seen anyone point this out yet.

Hattie

I can definitely see that it’s more about SB, but some lines are giving the heirloom turkey “my dear boy” “to fulfill your dreams you had to get rid of me” “pay the check/ find your card cancelled” Maybe it’s a composite sketch 🤷🏼‍♀️

Linneae

You summed up my feelings PERFECTLY.

Jemsss

she was just being dramatic and doing her folklore storytelling thing

Hope

LOVED your discussion of Actually Romantic I'm so disappointed that Wood turned into a Trav innuendo song because I love the superstition premise of the first verse, prechorus and chorus. Like can we just erase the post chorus!

sara

I think in a couple months a lot of people confused by the theming of the album missing the mark (myself included) will look back and see parts of it click. midnights is so midnights to me now but when it was released i was like "the music doesn't match the visuals" 🤷‍♀️ time will tell!

Greg

I’m afraid this might be objectively the worst Taylor swift album. Not in the sense that it’s sooooo horrible but that it really doesn’t stand up to the rest of her work in terms of quality. Even lover has crazy highs like cruel summer to balance out the me! What’s balancing out eldest daughter? Hm…? 😭

Rachel

My rose for Elizabeth Taylor is that snarly moany little adlib before "be my NY when Hollywood hates me" it's sooo gooooood

Rachel

My hot take is that I miss Jack 😂 now, I never ever said she needs to stop working with him so I was always this way, but I don't think there's a single song on showgirl that I thought couldn't be improved as a Jack song. I'll never understand why she did this 70s-esque sound without him because it seems so up his alley. Realistically I'd like to see her with someone COMPLETELY new but if we're rehashing old producers, welllllllll it's always going to be Jack for me.

Noelia

I think people wouldn't have a breakdown if the Ophelia music video would had aired a week earlier and the track 5 was track 5ing

Megan Dohm

Vibes aside, listening to the lyrics in Wishlist has me feeling like Richard Gere in Runaway Bride. “You do not want to climb Annapurna!!”

Cloudyskies

I honestly think it’s because of the way Jack writes- what he is able to pull out of her. She didn’t really want to give anything more personal for this album, hence no Jack. But I miss him toooooo.

Emma Gardner

This podcast dropping marks the official end of release weekend which means I’m free to go back to TTPD where it’s safe and warm. No but for real the albums not that bad I do like it

Emma Gardner

I agree I always think Taylor is best when her songs are reactionary and made from a necessity to write (e.g. my favorite albums are Red and TTPD). That’s not to say she can’t write when she’s happy but when Taylor is hurt, song writing is her clutch, the same can’t be said for when she’s happy. Hopefully in the future she finds a new way to challenge her writing like she did on folklore. Not to say she should stick to non diaristic songs again but a new challenge

Aubree Grace

Yall the title track sounds like We’re All In This Together in HSM3 😭

Chas

It’s 🙌

Spencer Frederick

Something that’s irritating me about the discussion of this album is this ‘well people said they didn’t like TTPD and now they love it!’ refrain I keep hearing. I didn’t like that album, I’ve tried but it’s just got too many problems for me to look past and I DID get it, it was just poorly executed. I think people have this idea that everyone likes that album now and they’ll do the same with showgirl and it just is not the case. I like showgirl more from 3/4 listens than I do TTPD having listened to that two dozen times - showgirl isn’t very good as an album but it’s nowhere near as bad as people are saying it is, at least half the songs I’ll be coming back to

Julia K

I lowkey thought father figure might be about Dylan O’Brien? Can we open that case

Rachel Kottkamp

I LOVE the Joe analysis for Father Figure and appreciate having that as a way to see the song. After hearing that perspective i actually cried in the last part of the song (with good cathartic anger lol) about my ex who took advantage of me after I payed all the bills for us, handled our whole life together, and covered up all his scandals and when we broke up I was like fine I’ll tell everyone what a dirtbag you were and cut you out from all my circles forever. Even if that’s not what she was thinking about it helped me connect to that feeling soooo much

Kate!!!

this is literally like the only safe space left, i am trying to stay off social media bc it just makes me sad rn LOL

KL

Am I the only one that loves Eldest Daughter lmaoooo

Melissa Ann

Completely agree! I think it’s such a cute and fun premise to explore especially in the context of the prophecy. I LOVE the pre chorus and the production where she literally knocks on wood. But then after that I feel like we completely loose the plot 😂 when I heard the clean version in the theatre I was like oh this is actually such a cute fun and campy song now.

maryna

So, English is not my first language, but can "i like my friends canceled" not mean "I like to have my friends canceled"? This is how I heard the first (and only) time I heard the song and assumed that it was ironic... But now that I think of it it doesn't actually make sense... Maybe I wanted to give her the benefit of the doubt or something...

🍰

As much as I want a new Olivia album, I really like the time she takes between projects. It feels healthy and thoughtful.

Jasper Murray

The summary of topics in eldest daughter was sooo funny, also this whole podcast felt like thoughts taken from my brain when I listened to the album 🫶

clarasuedi

Hold up i'm not tuned in regarding this! Can you give me some more information?

🍰

I can’t imagine what someone would want out of the Swiftologist Patreon if not serious, critical engagement with the music.

Cathy

I like Fate of Ophelia as the lead single! I feel like she finally made the right choice and the self directed music video was good this time!!

Carrie Parker Gastelu

For straight women-so true! I love it but I get exactly what you are saying.

Phoebs

I’ve seen so many people say that the lyrics sounds like genAI wrote them and then I saw the new CD covers for these acoustic variations and I truly feel like I am falling down a rabbit hole. I am so confused about wtf she is doing. Truly.

Chandler Kate

It means that she likes to have friends who are cancelled, not that she likes to cancel her friends! I see where that would be confusing if English isn’t your first language haha

Rocio R.

TLOAS isn’t her best album by far, but it’s clearly the one she wanted to make. If she’d wanted to wait and cook something stronger, she would have. Instead, this feels like pure joy after years of intense discipline from the Eras Tour and scrutiny from being the biggest pop star in the world. The songwriting may fall short, but the happiness, silliness, and playfulness in this album is unlike anything we’ve heard before. As someone who loops “Dear John,” “All Too Well,” “The Prophecy,” “happiness,” “Last Kiss,” and “tolerate it” a little too often—I’m just glad she’s happy. It’s a win for the girl inside the showgirl, and a reminder that her discography is so vast and versatile that every listener finds their own favorite version of Taylor.

Jasmine

Just showed my 8yr old daughter the new pretty music video and all she says is 'The Taylor Swift song I prefer is Cruel Summer' 🤦‍♀️😅🫶

Melissa Thomson

this comment just reminded me to take my meds 🫡

Sara Sweet

Tbh I think she just wanted to serve in the outfits and I get it but damn 😭

AK

Did anyone see the movie and clock the intro to father figure? I thought it was total shots fired at Olivia re song writing credit (which is still insane imho). And Taylor says she sees herself in both sides of the father figure story. I think it’s about Scott and Olivia

Brianna Tullius

Thank you for your thoughtful takes as always. I was scared to watch this after spending the weekend watching people absolutely overreact to not liking this album and it has been so depressing. There are things I love, and things I don’t love too much in this album. But mostly I love it and am grateful to be bopping along to happy Taylor music again.

Brianna Tullius

I love it! It’s not perfect, but it makes me cry. I really appreciate her talking about how women are expected to be perfect (every hot take is cold as ice) but also a bad girl at the same time and if you are feminine, sweet, or romantic the world will roll their eyes at you and demand you be sexy. The part where she says “shimmer that innocent light back” is so beautiful.

Charlotte💕

I don’t know how I sensed it exactly, but I had SUCH LOW expectations for the album. When she said that she wanted to make a pop album, and that Max Martin wanted her to write more like how she did on folklevermore, I was like “isn’t that just what she did with Midnights?” and Midnights wasn’t exactly aoty, if we’re being honest. I’ve thought about it more after listening to the album, but leading up to release, I wasn’t even that excited. Tloas showed me my truth… and that’s that I’m really only here for the music. I also became a swiftie during the lover era when I was 11, so I don’t have that connection that older swifties have, and it’s a lot easier for me to be objective. I think you two are pretty self aware about your biases, but there’s some things that non-swifties understand that swifties don’t.

jordan

I would like to submit White Horse and Eldest Daughter for a sister song episode, the interpolation made me pause and I see the vision (also track 5). I feel like you guys could really cook here

Stacey Campbell

What did the intro say? I kind of hate that Taylor would do that to a new person to the industry, it leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Taylor has all the power. I was hoping it was just about Scott Borchetta.

Sarah B

Genuinely curious: what made you guys say she’s “going to do another folklore, 100% … that’s coming”? I’m intrigued

Abby

Hey Madeline for some reason I think you’d really like the album mother road by grace potter

WhiteWalker68

I like the opening too, especially since she chose superstitions that point at her previous partners - pulling petals off a Daisy (now I'm you're daisy), and flipping an unlucky penny (throwing pennies in the pool). The whole 'my man is huge' theme is a slap at the Smallest Man. Pity about the heavy handed innuendo, though.

V

I guess my main issue with fate of Ophelia is that she is objectively wrong about the story. 1. Ophelia didn’t go mad, it’s Shakespeare’s way of showing how after being gaslit for so long and she is impregnated by hamlet who murdered her dad, then she understandably becomes depressed but is dismissed by men as mad. Like her fate has nothing to do with heartbreak, it’s abuse by men. It’s not oh she’s so sad she was single and in love with someone she couldn’t have. That’s ironically what the men say about her bc they are supposed to be sexist characters. So it’s sad to reduce and objectively misinterpret her story as “driven mad by love”. No serious Shakespeare scholar would everrrrr say that and again this is proven and objectively not true. So that PMO. Like it’s fine if Taylor wants to misinterpret it but don’t go around schooling ppl on a play you get wrong. Idk just had to vent. My dad’s friend is like a renowned Shakespeare scholar so this just rubbed me the wrong way about the song.

liv

maybe too soon, but episode idea?? would love to hear your thoughts on what songs in taylor’s entire discography could be “the life of a show girl” to make a frankenstein album to fit the concept

Leslie

Excellent recommendation

Clarita

So I agree with everything except for two takes- One- Eldest Daughter. Not about Travis. It’s about holding down the fort. Never leaving the person is all about being loyal despite self sabotage. Two- across the board regarding the lyrics not being up to snuff- as a woman, can’t we be all the things? Have a sexy, silly, unserious moment and also have all the deep albums to prove our competency? I feel like men get to be all aspects of themselves, and women we can only be the highest level of ourselves, or else we have gone downhill. Yes, Tayvis is silly and horny and not as eloquent. After all the misery of Joe and company, can’t we take a beat and have some fun? Even if that means going off theme?

James

I'm calling it... the next album is not going to be pop

No No

guys the discourse around this is so bad… I just saw a TikTok where someone said “onyx in the sleepless night, but now the sky is opalite” is racist and is a dog whistle… surprisingly the pitchfork review was actually such a fair and accurate review but we all know these demented people are just going to co-opt the score without reading the review

AK

She spent a long time saying how she went to George Michael’s estate to get permission and kept them abreast of the song and direction the whole time because it’s so important when you take another’s person’s creative work. She took a long time on that and it seemed very obviously directed at someone/something (Olivia)

M

May I humbly suggest that perhaps you replace Wood with the clean version, maybe you'll like it more... My first listen of the album was at the theater release party and it was all clean versions (it hadn't even cross my mind until I listened to the explicit afterwards) and I feel it makes the song more tolerable (hypnothized instead of dickmatized, opened my eyes instead of opened my thighs...)

Kris

Omg I’m on TikTok and they’re saying that the Opalite song is racist. Oh no

Kris

They’re saying that Opalite is about Taylor being jealous and insecure that Travis only dated black women before he dated Taylor and then they use the “I’m not a bad bitch I ain’t a savage” line… and before he reached out to Taylor, he (Travis) shot his shoot with Megan thee stallion before

Ayla Rios

I actually saw someone on Threads going like "Taylor Swift compared a biracial woman to a DOG 😱" and it actually killed like 4 of my brain cells. People will reach as far as they can to hate on something they're just determined to hate no matter what.

Ayla Rios

Every single time I think of Eldest Daughter my brain goes "I'm not a bad bitch, this isn't savage, I'm not the one you sweep off her feet, lead her up the stairwell - no, WAIT"

Paula C

None of the discourse matters when she is set to dethrone Adele this week… she’s immortal now

Chas

And say that!!

Pecegna

Love this episode! Thank you for feeding us so much, it really enhances the experience of a new Taylor album. <3 Will you maybe do an episode talking about all the interviews she did with the promotion of TLOAS? I feel like she said a lot of things and would love to know your opinion!

Megan Zemke

The metaphor in Opalite of onyx-Opalite darkness to light doesn’t make sense as a racial jab though because it’s the same metaphor she uses in the first verse about herself, before Travis is even introduced in the song. The metaphor is kept the same thru the song no matter the subject. I feel like this is basic middle school diagramming of sentences. The kids have truly been left behind.

Megan Zemke

Oh I would be interested in this too! Great idea!

Kris

Sorry, I think it was Opalite and eldest daughter? The track that has the line about not being a bad bitch

Megan Zemke

I think it’s okay if Taylor was like, “I just want to make a happy album full of radio hits that is going to remind the public I’m not just the sad girl crying about breakups, I’m a charts dominator who will own the radio waves for the next two years with these earworms”. I agree with your last statement that it’s not that deep of an album but it’s not supposed to be! The way she has been promoting this album has basically been “I was happy when I made it, I’m happy now, I think the lyrics are funny, also have you seen my ring?!”… like she isn’t trying to make this The Cultural Moment. After trying to prove how serious she is as an artist with Joe breathing down her neck, and all the other art boys she’s tried to prove herself to, maybe she just wanted to allow herself to be silly and have fun bopping in the kitchen with her fiance. And it’s all gonna be okay if there aren’t any lyrics that need a dictionary.

Abby

I suspect it may have been because George Michael famously fought to own his masters but failed, so maybe that's the connection she was making - if we assume the song is about SB

Andrea Peterlechner

Gotta be that damn new heights interview where she reaches out to max martin