Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 543887406.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hi divas!! Thank GOD for this cunt serve. We been needing this. Hope you enjoy my little ramble afterwards lol x

Files

Comments

Karibunt

yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Faith

I genuinely think for once she nailed a music video. I was nervous when she said it was written and directed by her. But it was honestly so much fun!

Karibunt

Saving this when work is done ☑️

Kaitlyn MacGilvray

the music video is so good!! wish how passionate she was abt the visuals for this album translated to the music. to me it feels like she almost rushed through the writing of showgirl just to create an aesthetically pleasing visual.

Em ✨️

Its SO good!!!! ✨️👏👏👏👏

Warren Searle

Been so excited to see this! Def best music video since LWYMMD

Joe McVey

She finally directed a good music video

Erin

5 business days, omg yes!!!!

Stacy Davydova_13

This is really her best self directed mv! Still love blank space etc better, but it is the best mv we’ve seen in years, so thank you

Angel

Yay thank you! This was such a serve

Britt

I’ve been waiting for your reaction cos I knew you’d be loving this. Top five music video of hers ever maybe best. Her in a brown wig is incredible 🤌🏻

em

the music video is SOOO good. honestly will be a strong contender for music video of the year

Cassandra Blalock

You are my fav accommodations EOAS! Im glad I can choose who I get pop culture hot takes from you all are the best!

Cassandra

Now that’s a Muziiiiic video

Leslie Eliden

I loved this music video, she nailed the dance and visuals it was amazing!! 😻

Maddy McDonald

The snakes have been working overtime 🔥🐍

Ali

I’m new here ☺️ love you YT Channel and I bit the bullet and joined here and IM LOVING IT! Love love love your content and I’m so happy to be here (finally 😉)

Marianna D

This is her best directed video for sure. The visuals are eating for this era. But unfortunately only the visuals. The album is a definition of “we’re so back, we’re so over” roller coaster. It’s fun, I don’t hate it but I wish it didn’t have such a low lows

jaana

watched this in the theatre and absolutely gagged, she looked STUNNINGGG on the big screen and it was exactly what i wanted for the song and era in general!!! theatrical, cunty, slightly meta but not overly complicated. SHE SERVED

Marianna D

I screamed from a “Swiftologist moment” comment 😂😂😂

rhi

"I'm a swiftie, I hand heart...but we need to talk about the other things" describes how i feel about this album

jaana

also im so endeared by how the eras tour evidently made her more confident with choreo like this lol. i loved it. tiktok dance away queen you look GREAT

fiona

10 zara fans 😭🤚⛔️

SJ

Have been waiting for the HBIC to react to this gaggery

xKami

sending you love and hugs god dammit, why are people so insufferable sending offensive messages to your mother? can they touch grass? it’s never that serious, not to the point of contacting family members. jesus have they lost the plot. don’t like? don’t interact

Meghan Cisar

personally I really have loved the album- it’s sonically so different and personally reminiscent for me- and the lyrics are simple but layered. But I can appreciate the different opinions and know that here it’s a respectful discourse

Sean

the swiftologist/lizard review spaces are pretty much the only safe havens from the hate train rn and we have to cheer for that at least, the people are LOSING TOUCH with reality

Cassandra Blalock

Wrote this after the first 30 seconds of the vid. I’m super concerned about the abusive online shit. Like it’s hard to watch given the culture of political violence (at least in the US)

PandoraNicole

When I saw her in the bathtub at the end I said, "Swiftologist mentioned!" ☝🏼

Valeriya N.

Zara Larsson stan is something I didn’t know existed. I was surprised at how deranged and messy all the european fans got. Truly shows that democracy is not a thing here anymore. You either have one opinion or you’re a bigot. Truly disturbing. I’ll be really sad if you tone down your criticisms towards anyone… I love your reviews so much. I discovered Jade because of you and it’s truly an iconic album for me this year. Along with Addison ofc.

Amy McCraith

King, I'm so sorry these psychos are abusing your mum and you! Keep doing what you're doing I think you (and Madeline) have the best takes - honest not shrouded in delulu and actually constructively critical 👑✨

Flor

I love this musicvideo. I was SHOCKED in the cinema and just excited for your reaction. It was sooo good. I think also in the behind the sienes you can see she didnt do it ALONE. The collaboration was also strong (I hope you can see it soon!!)

Marianna D

I had a thought recently that maybe the issue is not necessarily in the muses but in the fact that there’s no one around her to criticise her and help her edit herself. That’s why there’s such a dip in quality since Lover. Life of a showgirl is a combination of both not having such intense feelings to write about and her being too big for even Max Martin to edit her.

jaana

the thing that kills me about this whole thing is that no one wants to admit that a mid taylor swift record would be a CAREER HIGHLIGHT for any other artist rn... zara larsson could only dream of writing even wishlist. its absurd.

Archie

I’ve been saying Ruin the friendship is the real track 5. A reminiscence of a big regret with no way back of a showgirl and with a lesson learnt

Foxlebt

it's so telling how the two groups of people are: people who can appreciate and / or tolerate swiftologist content... and people who make and send nasty abusive threats. oh gee i wonder which is the group that proliferates hate

Archie

And the storytelling is so beautiful, breaks me to see so many people saying it makes no sense on the album

j m

I've gotta say although I don't love the album. I really find that certain songs really aren't getting the praise they deserve. Like Opalite, Elizabeth Taylor, father figure , ruin the friendship, and fate of ophelia and the life of the show girl are good. But really feel the other songs bring these ones down. Like those songs I can genuinely enjoy and listen to. I just feel she needs to really work on the marketing and stop trying to sell things that there not. Also the Easter egging really needs to stop.

Erin

Actually Romantic, yeah it was written with Charli as the immediate muse. But the hateration from the world she’s getting about this album paints that song in a new way for me. Like she is making the money, she’s really happy, and DGAF what the world thinks. Eldest Daughter is the most disappointing song, maybe in her discography, for me. It is rambling and has no plot and I think Ruin the Friendship was the only track 5 on the album if she is trying to stay on that train.

rhi

I am sorry to hear about the abuse towards you and your mother. I hope you know we appreciate what you do! I will always handheart for Swiftologist. random side note, I have a friend who is a Joe widow and she appreciates your commentary lol

luna

i would like to see you talk about what you think she should or will do next. I KNOW I KNOW "and the crowd was chanting more" i'm not asking for anything anytime soon because i just know that if she takes her time she will make a comeback proving everyone wrong um hello we've seen her do this multiple times :) BUT i want her to work with max and shell back to actually make BULLET PROOF POP!

Karen

I’m so sorry you receive that sort of hate.. you are my favourite content creator and I need your reactions and videos in my world.. thank you for everything you do for us 🫶

Ruby

For the Fantano video, I'm curious on how the hell did he manage to do music reviews all of those years while being authentic to himself and not affected by the outside noise? I mean I disagree with most of his takes but I still respect the bravery of putting it out there despite the rampant stans

Cassandra Blalock

“Cuckoo banana”….lol. Perfect phrase for both Taylor haters, the world rn, fucking every 10th person you meet these days. 10/10, would recommend Zach to capture the cultural zeitgeist with a snappy turn of phrase. I want more unpacking of Wi$h Li$t and cancelled. For me, sonically, these are 100% bops…even Wood. 🤮 Unfortunately, unless you have zero auditory comprehension, you can’t listen to the auditory bop and not hear the crime against humanity that is her releasing that abomination into the world. 💯% that song belongs in their bedroom alone and if they had left it there, no harm no foul.

Valeriya N.

Because you either clap and cheer for any woman and her craft or you’re automatically a bigoted hater. No in between sadly and it’s not just in music. This trend is everywhere. People these days hate different opinions, especially when they don’t match with their own. Dialogue is dead I’m afraid…

Erin

Yeah weird that so many times she’s calling people “bitches” and this is the same person who had a decade long meltdown over Kanye calling her one. Girl.

Pooja Nair

If you can expedite any of your videos, I'm begging for in love through Rep & Lover versus in love through the Life of a Show Girl. That's the thing I was trying to figure out when I heard Wood and compared it to Dress and So It Goes or even Wildest Dreams and I was like at what cost AT WHAT COST??! my ear drums??!

Cookie

Ruin the Friendship FTW

Zoë

woman fighting with wall 💀

Maxi Schäfer

Now I wonder if you like Midnights or Showgirl more

Leslie Eliden

I really love 8/12 songs, one I like (Actually Romantic), one it’s not for me, melodically (wishlist), Wood the production is fun, the clean version I like it better as ridiculous and cheesy as it is, but the song that hurts me the most is Eldest Daughter, biggest disappointment by the lyrics, except that bridge… one of the most simple yet beautiful and real lines, I cannot get over the fact that it’s in this song, we could’ve gotten the 180 of So Long, London…So that’s my biggest loss. I’m really enjoying the rest of the songs, I’m streaming with love. The internet right now is levels of crazy I didn’t think it would get after TTPD, I’m sorry for the horrible comments you’ve been receiving. I personally not going to fixate on the muse discourse (mostly because people can’t separate between criticizing her writing different emotions, and laughing at/belittling her partner, and to the point of saying she didn’t write folklore…), it has to do with her choosing not to edit and work with some songs a bit more, and the way she wants to combine love writing with fun/cool lines and a pop concept. So that’s my overall feeling.

Clementine

i would love a showgirl/lover video !! in regards to the album tho im really having fun with it. i deleted Cancelled from my library and honestly that helped a lot because now the worst song is eldest daughter an that's palatable to me because the melody is so pretty. love most of the other songs tho, but once i go back and start bleeding in her discography again maybe that will change idk but i think its cute and fun to sing along to in the car

Nika

I tend to agree about the "midness" of the album. It's low effort on Taylor's part. The production does all the heavy lifting on this album and even then, it's almost TOO formulaic. There's no risk taking in the production but it's super clean and super safe.

Ashley

I was so excited for you to see the music video 🫶

shedaris

I just wanted to day in case you don't know, but Fantano was reacting to actually romantic leaks...not a crime, but that says some things about him as a consumer

Miss_Lippy

Serves on serves on servesssss! ❤️🫶😍

Cassandra Blalock

Unfortunately, I think with her transition into this relationship and the new folks involved (not a Tayvis hater, I listen to New Heights religiously and love both Kelce brothers. But Trav is “dickmatized”…vagina-matized so while I’m confident someday he’ll tell her the hard truths, today is not that day

Samantha

I think for so many years there's been so much lore/lyricism to unpack with her albums and there just isn't with this. You can just tell she has no desire to leave anything open to interpretation which has definitely thrown people. I really like this album but it 100% suffers under the weight of her own past work.

shedaris

By reacting I mean quote tweeting a picture of a lyric book from the vinyl

Marianna D

It would be very interesting if you’d do an episode on deconstruction of some takes about the album or in some cases agreeing with them P. S. Yes, it’s my tenth comment or something but I’m just writing it while watching the video 🫣

Emmanominon

Oh Zachary, I’m so sorry to hear your mum got hate messages, fucking illiterate troglodytes. Good for you for having strong boundaries, fuck that noise honestly. As for Swiftologist blowup 👀 I’m afraid you’re the diva, King, don’t let anybody underestimate what you’re doing. Not to be doing too much, but applying genuine critical analysis, from a place of sincerity and education, to *literal* pop-culture creates a gateway for people to developing media literacy and critical thinking skills. Life imitates art baby ✨🫶🏻 head snakes need their flowers sometimes and though it just might be nice to hear 💐♥️🐍

John Santana

Appreciate your insight and resilience to all the crazies online right now. For the Anthony fantano interview, I think just talking about how he’s personally dealt with the rising scrutiny and backlash that reviews can get since he’s been doing it for long. Also asking if there are songs of Taylor’s he personally goes back to.

Bethany is Cancelled in Cleveland!

"You don't know the life of a showgirl and you're never gonna wanna". Your talk on the internet chatter is the point of the album. Being a Showgirl can be hideous, polarising and she says in the poem that she has to log off to keep her sanity. Eldest Daughter is about how she was one of the first on the internet and had to navigate that and logging off has given her freedom. The first verse is written badly on purpose, I love it, but it's ok to not. Every other song is leaning into the discord of internet chatter, like Blank Space did about her lovers, but now that's not all they talk about so she's had to go all out on a full album. You said it yourself "it always goes back to highschool". She may not have executed it well, it could be entirely intentional to "thin the heard". Who knows. 🤷‍♀️ I'm just going to sit here and hand heart.

jaana

really appreciate your honesty and how you create a space for us to think about these things!! i've been having similar thoughts especially re: lover/rep vs. showgirl - i think in the past she has written about the tension in and around love in a really interesting way, even love songs in the past had an undercurrent of complexity. my first thought about this is that i don't think she WANTS to interrogate the tensions that exist in and around her relationship with travis, at least not in depth in song for the world to dissect, which is 100% her right, given this is her forever. folklore was a great cover for her to do that with her (deteriorating..?) relationship with joe/matty(?) but she wont really be able to do that again. so who knows.

KimberlyEason

Love the idea for charli and Taylor friendship timeline. For fantano please ask about his idea of what a good Taylor swift album is and what he expects from her.

Carla Ferreira

I think long form is the way to go. For the first time ever, a friend of mine in real life messaged me to basically say that she's a mean girl to Charli because everyone already thinks she's boring and so there's no need to diss Charli for also agreeing with that. And that since Charli is such an it girl, it just backfired on her. Did this person even listen to album? No. Like why would you go out of your way to tell me that? It's just such bad faith criticism and it just reminds me of getting bullied as a kid for liking Taylor. IF SHES SO BORING WHY DO YOU KEEP TALKING ABOUT HER UHHH??

Jessica Maguire

I think it was misconstrued becaue we took it as behind the scenes of eras. That would be about showgirling. But she meant behind the showgirl, is just normal Taylor being a chaotic cunt and deeply in love. 🤣

Maxi Schäfer

I would cut Wood, Wish List, Cancelled, Honey, Eldest Daughter and switch those for actual SHOWGIRL songs… The fact that I would switch half the album is crazy considering she acted like this was bulletproof concise pop.

Erica

Can we talk about the dancing! It’s simple but I’ve never seen her dance like this

Stacy Davydova_13

My ONLY feud with this song is that it’s so speak now coded… it’s beautiful but it had no place on showgirl record…

Sarah Stokeld

I deactivated my tik tok account yesterday.

marissa x

questions potentially for anthony: has he changed his mind at all on how he feels about reputation since his review? even if he still doesn’t like it, does he see why reputation is so well loved, especially among swifties, and why showgirl seems not to be loved so much?

Märta Florentina

(Side note: LOVE your Cruel Intentions t-shirt! One of the theme songs, Placebo’s Every Me and Every You, carried me through eighth grade. Haha)

Lunarlakes

After lover, which was definitely a decline in quality, we got folklore and evermore. So while this is definitely a downgrade from ttpd and even midnights, I’m still relatively optimistic about the future. And for now, I’m having sooooo much fun with the better songs on the album because I really do think they’re great. Side note, the people attacking momologist deserve prison and they will get time

Bella

Zach you are very resilient in the face of a lot of unwarranted comments thrown your way. I’m happy you continue being honest and keep posting but it must be hard

sullivan meaghan

maybe the album isnt great but atleast the fate of ohpelia is the best song ever made

Miss_Lippy

I honestly feel like the reason why the cvnty visuals don’t fully match up with the music content is because Taylor just really wanted to serve and I say that’s her gd right!!! 😍 She’s been feeling hot, happy, healthy, fulfilled & she’s really just exuding confidence, which is sexy as hell no matter who you are, and she probably knows this might be the best her body will ever look (esp true if she’s planning on having a whole block of mini Travs in the near future 😆) and then a sad orange man went & said she wasn’t hot anymore and she said “BET” & so we got this haha And honestly I’m not even mad (except for maybe Wood bc I’m still a little mad about that one 😭 lol)

Beth González

I think you should really talk about why this wasnt a good moment to drop the album in. there’s political outrage everywhere you look , a genocide in gaza , ICE situation in america, right wing propaganda... It’s a bad time to hop on the world stage and say ‘buy my brand new album!!’, an album with one of her laziest work and songs like CANCELLED, wi$h li$t & actually romantic - which all come off tone deaf. With this album it’s become much more clear to me that she is a billionaire (i knew this of course, but it’s a bit like she flaunting it to us) and that if i were to meet her right now i would like the person she is, because of how dislikable she comes off.

Claire

Love you Zach and Madeline you are both such great positive people that give me a good laugh in this stressful world! :) xxx

Stacy Davydova_13

I seriously reconsidered my opinions on lover after listening to this album… even midnights is better Pitchfork just gave it 5.9 (and the article was written by swiftie) and this is the worst rating she ever had there 😭😭😭😭

Claire Cassidy

Love you. I’m so sorry that you’ve gotten so much hate energy! Well done drawing your boundaries!

jaana

also something i'd be interested to hear about is how her personal standard/benchmark of pop excellence has shifted? like it really feels like her standard has shifted down to midnights taylor, while the rest of us are still at 1989 taylor. when you said karma was about as good as the pop songs on this record that kinda crystallised it for me. bc wtf was she talking about then when she said showgirl bulletproof pop? do words mean nothing to her anymore... i'm just curious about this. part of me wonders, when you're your own competition and standard, how pushed do you feel to innovate and actually one-up yourself. like she literally has everything she could ever possibly want or need... it makes one wonder

Nicola

Zach what do you think about the comment that this is the first album of hers that feels like a product first and piece of art/music second? Someone said it on TikTok and I can't get it out of my head. I remember she got some criticism for the whole Midnights clock set but this time around the Money Pwease feels even more egregious. Or am I totally off? Glad you liked the MV. ❤️

Kaleb M

I don’t know if this this would count as a how to murder your career but I would LOVE to see you take a look at Lizzos career as of now and if you think she can have a comeback and maybe a solo or podcast episode on the current male pop stars and if they have the potential to become superstars.

Tara

I’m so sorry you’re getting so much hate, Zach. People are stupid. There are so many young people on TikTok being absolutely crazy — and the app itself is designed to encourage this kind of behavior. You’re absolutely within your rights to defend yourself! Try to interact as little as possible. You probably want to stay on top of your content and uploading, but your well-being matters too. I hope you can find ways to cancel out the noise while still doing the work you love. It’s brutal out there at the moment. Sending you love ❤️

shin nia

IMO she marketed it the wrong way since the "SHOWGIRL" ❤️‍🔥 concept and aesthetic was way more interesting than lover 2.0 Since LOVER 🩷 succeeded REPUTATION 🖤 (dark night to daylight, revenge to love, black to pastel) it was still an interesting idea. But I think she didn't have any better theme/idea for lover 2.0, so she just rode the wave of eras tour and linked this to showgirl. And I also think she just didn't care that much for this particular record, just wanted to put something fun/poppy out. She has also reached a stage of IDGAF about everything(GOOD FOR HER)

E ✨🩷

love it so much. I love all the sets and practical effects - that is SHOWGIRL!!

Yana

I would love to hear you discuss with Anthony the state of music criticism especially the 'hateful messages towards family members' aspect because it's siiiickk. And also the concept of people not being able to handle criticism when they like something but praising hateful content when they don't like something (this taylor rollout for example), so there is no middle ground in this anymore

Meryem Çalıkoğlu

Please watch Fantano’s reviews before having him on for info. His favorites are definitely folklore, evermore and red. He hates reputation and ttpd. I remember he kinda liked Lover. I like that he’s critical but the sad thing for me is that his opinions feel so bad in faith sometimes. Like when he talked about The Black Dog in his Ttpd review, he said that “a normal person or someone with boundaries or respectful privacy” would just turn the location off and it’s just “gross and obsessive and weird”. I think he has the tendency to see the worst in her lyrics. Like if someone else wrote those lines his commentary would be different.

Ashley

I need a print of her in the painting ✨

Anna K.

Thank you for your hard work so far! Loving the content, as always, and I look forward to what's to come this era.

Lunarlakes

Omg I’m so glad you also noticed the references to bitches cuz it confuses me!! In my (parasocial) view of Taylor, I really didn’t expect her to use it in the ways she has here- especially in honey. I really dislike the use of it there even though I like the song. Kinda prefer the clean version because of that 😭

Roisin Shy

Also another thing that people should remember is she was doing this while she was on the eras tour. I’m sure she was exhausted but inspired and that’s what we got. I am hoping her next album would be more folklore because she won’t be on tour and she is taking a break and will have more time to devote to this. I feel like the trouble started really because of her over hype in comparing it to Eras tour. If she didn’t do that and was more honest with herself of what this album was then our expectation would not be so high. This is why this album is growing on me because each listen I am hearing it with more of a realistic ear.

Lorenzo

video idea: reaction to the pitchfork review

Izzy

Please could you ask /talk to Anthony Fantano about how being a public facing music critic impacts how you engage with music on a personal level. I would be interested to know from both of you if the pressure of having to do a public review changes how you engage with music and how you approach a review, heart or head, or both ❤️

Johanna

In the cinema, I knew you would be loving the video!!

Cassandra

Video idea- I really love JADE’s album and think she has been and is a true pop princess. As an American I did not know much about her career or Little Mix in general. I’d love to hear your perspective on Little Mix and JADE in particular’s rise to fame and what the story is within her new solo career and how this debut is truly masterful… like a rise to popularity type video.

Nicola

Just to all my fellow snakes here writing insightful comments record them for phone a snake!!!!!

Emma

I think overall the album is fine I'm having a great time listening to the first four tracks and just sprinkling in a couple of the other ones occasionally. The music video was an absolutely gag I completely live for these visuals 😂

sullivan meaghan

taylor should have been meaner in actually romantic.

Deeksha Agnihotri

It really does feel like a tough time to be a Swiftie online! Everybody has an opinion, sensible or not, and the negativity is overwhelming. You’re right, Zach, Taylor doesn’t need defending; she’s the biggest artist in the industry right now. But as fans, the negativity hits even harder when the album feels subpar compared to her usual calibre. For me, it comes across like she rushed putting out an album? She was really trying to prove she could still have a pop moment after TTPD. But without a clear overarching statement, it ended up leaning too much on “I love Travis” without breaking new ground. So more than “can she write well if she’s happy” maybe its more that “did she consider if she has something of substance to say?” In the bigger picture, I think this record will just be remembered for a few fun pop tracks, not as one of her defining works. Honestly, I’d rather see her take a couple of years off, regain perspective, and come back with sharper songwriting and a stronger concept. She’s admitted before that she listens to constructive criticism, and I really hope this feedback helps her grow, because she’s capable of so much more. 🫶🏻

Jenny

Just leaving some love, you don't deserve all the hate you're getting Zach. Actually no one does. People are so weird on the internet. You might even say they're being punk. lol.

nish 🍓

i’d like to see a fergie how to murder your career actually that sounds pretty interesting

Katya Art

yay excited to get Fantano on Swiftologist !

Rachel Limpus

I enjoy the album, but I think she was trying to do too much with it. When she said it’s inspired by the Eras tour, I think she was trying to pull from each previous album. She also seemed to be trying to add in music from different decades. She seemed less focused on purely good writing and we ended up with some really bad lines.

Vasudha R

Hey Zach, I just said the same thing this morning on the lizard review comment section. I don't know how you guys do this job honestly. I've been drained and emotionally exhausted talking to someone on the comments section. So thank you so much for your work. It's so good. It's really nice how you're able to maintain objectivity. And thank you for making me feel sane during this current extreme discourses about this album.

Bianca Fodor

I have a question that I think would be interesting for you and Anthony to discuss: From a Birds Eye perspective, the gp seems to LOVE this album and by that I mean offline people (my mum, even my dad and manager at work mentioned it) but the swifties seem to be struggling with it or any terminally online fandoms. The opposite happened with TTPD as we know. Do you guys have a theory on why that may be?

Miss_Lippy

I personally disagree bc sometimes art & entertainment spaces feel like my ONLY escapes from all the sad, scary stuff in the world. I don’t think the world being in a state of unrest means that artists shouldn’t be sharing art (some would say quite the opposite) and many of us did not see any part of this album through the same lens as you, while others here do appear to share your view, but Taylor is a mirrorball & I’m not surprised that some are finding certain bothersome meanings in things where others do not. I just actually never felt like Taylor was flaunting or taunting us with her songs and I just tend to plug into music to “zone out”, enjoy it for what it is (entertainment) and clap for Taylor serving looks because that’s kind of the whole point to me.

Kat

I’m in a place of - this album was a real disappointment for me BUT that doesn’t mean I hate it or her career is over or any of the other extremes people are going to. I’m disappointed by her use of AI in her promo videos when she’s been a champion of art and owning it. I’m disappointed that I was hoping she’d have a bit more to say at this particular point in her career. But I like several songs a lot and the visuals of course. Of course, I said some of this online and have been getting hate from children who weren’t even born when I started listening to her💀

Miguel Mejia

We didn’t know how good Rep was till Lover came out. And we didn’t know how good Lover was till TTPD came out, and… now TTPD sounds real good as Showgirl comes out…

Katya Art

question for Fantano: if he was doing it the Swiftologist way, meaning going hard for and mainly focusing on one artist/band in his work who would that be?

sullivan meaghan

this album just cements to me how much i love ttpd !

Alexandra Jung

I would love to hear about The bad marketing: marketing it as something it isn’t, which made it much worse than it is , overselling the bangers , making it showgirl, and also the overhyping through endless countdowns that are just new money grab variation releases and how it could’ve gone better. I’d also love to dive deeper into the „personas“ of ts. I don’t recognise her here it often sounds like a parody of herself. I don’t feel she’s being authentic, but I don’t know, I don’t know her personally, just a feeling of removedness and not in a good way but in a I have no personality beside my man kind of way.

Julie Chu

Please Zack just don't change we love you

charisma

As an eldest daughter, I’m sorry I don’t think she actually relates to “eldest daughter” woes. The song is disappointing and horrible.

Alex

Really interesting rambling afterwoords, I resonated and feel the same with pretty much everything you said. I think her next album is really going to determine how I view her as an artist in this day and age. I'm hoping this was just a misstep and not a sign of things to come. If we continue to decline then I truly dont know what to say but theres never been more of a distinction between the "old" and "new" taylor as right now, and its not just the music either.

Rachel ☔️

I’m so sorry to hear about the haters and how it’s also affecting your family!! It breaks my heart and just know how much we appreciate you and all the work you do! I love listening to your opinions and analysis and I am rooting for you!

Khalil Lune

It’s weird.. but almost every song on showgirl, including wood kinda grew in me.. I enjoy listening to most of the album now (not honey and wishlist tho), but the rest of the album is much more fun now..

charisma

she does tay british when she says “like a toy chihuahua bahking at me” in AR

lucy

for anthony i’d kind of like to hear his thoughts on reputation vs tloas as “concept albums” and which he thinks was executed better as someone who’s not as immersed in the lore! sooo excited to watch that once it comes out. also side note i’m sorry about how vile people can be online and hope ur mum is okay too 🫶

Kendall Schaefer

I feel like if she can make more music videos that give showgirl, the album concept will be better perceived, maybe? Video ideas: no need to listen I’m just riffing Personally I loved the video where you fixed the TTPD album rollout. Because I think public perception of this album would’ve been a lot more positive if the rollout was better/more honest. Definitely a video comparing lover/showgirl. And then maybe dive into how she could’ve added depth to showgirl without leaving her relationship vulnerable. Maybe she could’ve written about “how can she ever tour after eras” or “how it feels to meet someone you know you’re going to marry? Like does that make you feel valued?” When you know you know and when you don’t you don’t.” Like lean into that idk I like this album *for what it is* but it’s like the focus was solely on how the songs sounded and not necessarily the meaning of the lyrics.

Tara

Dare I say: Happiness makes a bad muse. However, now that she’s settled into a truly happy relationship, being with Travis might give her a sense of security — one that sets her free creatively and allows her to explore muses beyond romance. I think we can genuinely be excited for what’s to come. Lest we forget, fellow swifties, folklore and evermore - two of her most acclaimed works — came after Lover. 😌

Anita

I never understood why people are legitimately demented towards you. I’ve been tuned into you and Madeline’s content for a very long time, and just had the opportunity to subscribe to the Patreon (yayyyy waiting for you guys to tour to Canada <3) I think you are one of the only people on the internet that actually give constructive criticism, and I don’t mind some mean takes as long as it’s funny (like Maisie Peter’s, I love her music but every time you guys talk about her I can’t help but laugh). The homophobia in your comment sections is very concerning. I am sincerely sorry for you and your mum. Looking forward for your content this month <3 I personally liked most of the album, reminds me of the weaker songs on Lover but still a fun time, just not a great Taylor album. People are being demented because it is Taylor swift. However, the one thing I think is worth discussing is her marketing team using AI, because it very clearly is what those promotional videos are. As someone who has championed for artists to own their work and be properly compensated, it is very hypocritical of her to use it for her promotional material when she has enough money to pay 3D artists. And yeah maybe she didn’t know, but it’s still Taylor swift and she does have control of what is put out under her name, more than any other artist. It just hits really hard for me, as an artist myself. It is just very disappointing, kinda sums up this whole era for me. Disappointing.

Alli Johnson

I'm glad you mentioned the New Yorker article. I thought that was one of the better critical reviews. I think it would be great to deconstruct the criticism in the various reviews for points that are valid, vs those that are in bad faith (or in the case of Rolling Stone, blind praise).

Sabrina

I'm so happy to be on patreon right now because it feels like we can be critical about the album without being absolutely deranged. it's such an ugly time to be on twitter and tiktok as a swiftie, since the album came out i've logged off my socials because everybody wants to have an opinion and the craziest think piece, and I think it was kind of ruining the moment for me

Roxanne Metivier

This is so true, the first four track run is really strong and quite good, and then... cricket. I actually think that either track 4 or track 6 could have been a track 5 for different reasons. But Eldest Daughter is my least favourite song on the album, and the worst track 5 out of all the others track 5.

Ashley Taylor

We adore you Zack! Your work does not go unnoticed. I’m shocked at how much content you have gotten out. I have had favorite creators in the past and none that have given such intellectually stimulating conversations. You’re so intelligent. Don’t let the hate get you down. Anyone going after your family is absolutely disgusting. You deserve the best.

Rachael

I’ve been thinking about how the experience of the Eras Tour might have affected her artistry—for good and bad. In many ways, her actual life has shrunk as she has created the monster on the hill. I think both the physical and mental exhaustion of the tour might have taken more of a toll on her than we realized. For two years, she was existing in a repetitive, endless cycle of commodified, old versions of herself. That’s always been a part of her brand, but particularly intense during this time. She’s talked about the tour a lot during Showgirl promotion. That led us to think she would write about the Eras tour on the album, but I believe it was to justify not touring anytime soon and convey the downsides of her life/why she’s clinging to an escape with Travis. I think Showgirl reflects some burnout/exhaustion with the “Taylor Swift” persona. And it’s why the album has such a shallow focus on Travis is good and fuck everything else, whether that focus was intended or not. I don’t think many other experiences were happening for her. We see the “basketball hoops” suburban marital bliss vibes as very reductive (and I totally get that! I cringe a bit too). But for her, that’s felt as out of touch as it would feel for us to picture ourselves in her position. This comment is getting way too long, but I think the experience of the Eras tour and re-recordings helped bolster the appreciation of the lore and beauty of her earlier work and has enriched projects like TTPD. But I think she needs new experiences to propel her work forward now and get creative inspiration from new things. I think she truly needs to move past the “eras era”, and I have faith she will! I agree that Travis is seemingly a boring muse haha, but I believe she can mine a lot out of living life. She just needs some space to actually do it!

maryna

I think the album is superficial because it was rushed and I personally feel like she didn't really want to make an album but was just a bored with performing three and a half hours of eras every night and also, we kind of forced her into making a better album because ttpd was not really met with excitement. And knowing her and her imposter syndrome (for lack of a better word, obviously I'm not a psychiatrist or anything...) i think she thought "oh I can't have the greatest tour of all time and be considered the biggest pop star of all time and then have an album that is flopping with the music critics, so I gotta make a better record and I got it do it quickly...". I honestly think that the level of her stardom is blocking her from listening to what she really wants and it puts her under pressure to constantly deliver and I think she is crumbling under that pressure and showgirl is proof of that for me. The fact that she still talks about how physically exhausted she was during eras hints at the same thing I think. I think we quickly forgot or not even aware of it in the first place how insanely hard it is to to have that much pressure on you. But that's just my two cents...

Noelia

There's a interesting thing about listening to wish list when you have paid an overpriced movie ticket. Same thing with cancelled and the whole rich lady vibe that Madeline pointed out in your latest video. It could be an interesting topic to talk about, how the billionaire thing has made her sound kind of tone deaf. Love your videos, thank you for saving me from taynegativity 🫶🫶🫶

maryna

Not us complaining how short the album is after we have complained that ttpd was too long 🤣

Julie Chu

Yes the Joe widows are truly pissing me off

Anabel

Sorry to hear about the haters. We appreciate what you and Madeline do!!!!

Octomew

I wish she took a break after the Eras tour, got married and had kids like she wanted and came back with an amazing album after people had time to miss her. Imagine what a high note to leave on, alas...

Satu

I really think (and hope) that the issue with the creative quality with the album is that it was created in a short time frame during her off days from the tour. It really does feel like a first draft. Father figure is probably the only song that doesn't need rewriting. I think she should have said that the true lightning in a bottle was that she was on the same continent than these great swedish producers, and they had this short winwod to create something together. And what they came up with was this fun album full of dancable songs. We would probably feel nore forgiving for the quality of the lyricism then. The album sounds great tho.

Roisin Shy

I sorry you and your family are getting hate comments. People are the worst sometimes. But I am happy to have found your Patreon because I can tell it is so much fun here. I joined a lot of new Patreon channels for the unedited review of the album and I know I will be staying here even after this month.

Finley

id like to see comparisons to lyrical lover vs tloas differences, i think it would be a good way to dig into how taylor divulged info on lover vs how she held back on it with this record and the different impacts that has on fans who receive it. i also really do feel like we couldve had a cruel summer on this album… like this was your most crazy time of life, you went from im the happiest ive ever been - lets play question to crying in the surprise songs, you had messy breakups and then you met your “dream guy” - thats a story. and it feels like she simply didnt want to do any storytelling on this record about that. theres very few mentions of how her previous experiences have tied into this one and how it felt for it all to happen so simultaneously. also random info since i know you didnt see the movie, she says in the film that honey was the first song she wrote with them where she went “yup. this is our new sound for the record.” so just interesting info to know

Tara

A new phenomenon is being experienced right now in the music industry. Taylor Swift is arguably the first artist in history of music to reach a level of success that grants her COMPLETE creative freedom over her work. She isn’t bound by industry expectations or dependent on collaborators anymore. No artist before her has ever been in a similar situation. If others had that level of autonomy — would Beyoncé have created Renaissance and Cowboy Carter? Would Lady Gaga have made Mayhem? A new dialogue appears to be emerging from this. To what extent do artists benefit from complete creative freedom and the isolation of their ideas?

Anja Dott

Regarding How to murder your career: I think Avril Lavigne would be an interesting case. Everything after the best damn thing famously fell flat even though she had successfully managed the image shift to a "girlier" more feminine version with TBDT (which is more true to who she is as a person I think, the skater girl persona always had those pick me/not like the other girls vibes a lot of us teenagers during the time had). I still to this day think her vocals and melodies have gotten better or always been strong. But her downfall really were the songwriting/lyrics (she desperately needed cowriters but somehow that didn't work out?) and possibly her public persona (not engaging enough with the fans, not fostering the parasocial relationship enough). Maybe she also realized upon becoming an adult she wasn't interested in being a main or even B tier pop girl and satisfied with being a C tier pop girl. Regarding Anthony Fantano: I would be interested in a brief discussion of Father Figure and her reclaiming that she built this legacy and not the men behind her. A really powerful theme running through her career has been men claiming her work, so that would be interesting. It's also the only song with a powerful message as a woman on the record sadly, the rest is really regressive unfortunately. Another topic that would be interesting to me with AF would be what he thinks about the alleged interpolations on TLOAS and how similar they actually are to other existing songs. And whether it's just lazy songwriting/production which leads people to hear other songs in this (similar to Ed Sheeran, sorry to say) or if it's an issue with the genre she's trying to impersonate, how her label makes sure, the songs aren't too similar to already existing ones... (I'm just rambling at this point).

Matteo

Literally one of if not the best music video she’s made since she started self directing. What a serve to see in the cinema

liv

fantano recently did a tier list of famous rap beefs n diss tracks so i would love to kno how he would rank actually romantic on that list hehe

vvc

Yes it’s better to disable comments on your videos 😭 people are so weird on there

roscentbreeze

I'm convinced Taylor Swift (Taylor's version) is coming out next year on its 20th anniversary

Finley

me too, youre not alone. ive felt exhausted and cant seem to escape the hate no matter where i go. i hardly even engage in taylor content outside the patreon & discord and now all every social media i have is serving me hateful “think pieces”. its hard to process and enjoy the record with all thats happening

Finley

honestly feel like thats why the second verse isnt as well done as the rest of the song, she was trying to keep it as a light hearted roast lol. it wouldve worked better if she went harder

Stacy Davydova_13

I simply can’t stop thinking how great artists (like David Lynch, Hitchcock for example) said that happiness is essential for making good art. And they were great at what they did. So happiness is not the main issue here I fear…

Bob Billy

It’s actually romantic how much they care (this comment maybe cringey, but it’s true)

Nicoline

knew you would love this video, gag of the century etc. the serves, the cunty fits, she slayed. but yeahh, probably worst track 5 she's ever made - the archer clears. but it is very interesting with the travwife thing she's cooking up, even with Joe she wasn't like this 5 years into the relationship. "Give you my wild, give you a child", vs "Have a couple kids" etc is a really interesting shift in mindset, like she wants that life now more than ever. Good for her, seriously, but it's an interesting shift in a showgirl album

Kate

Hey, Zac, recent Patreon subscriber and attendee of the Evolution of a Snake tour in London here😊 The fact that I have recently met the hateration of Swiftologist IRL was so bizarre to me. I had to be a Swiftologist warrior for a moment to protect the right of free speech and criticism online.

NikiaFalcon

Do Mariah Carey cuz this new album was supposed to be her big return and she flopped

Jessy Allison

Ruin the Friendship is soooooo good! I completely agree!

Caitorade

I don’t like the whole “got the whole block lookin like you”… tradwife vibes of wish list. It makes me uncomfortable.

Katy O'Brien

I'm so sorry you get so much psychotic behaviour that is not okay!!!! Lovinggggg your showgirl opinions and thoughts Xxxx

maryna

To me it seems as though she wanted to appeal to a different audience and make sure that she's still hip and cool and trendy with them by trying to use their language (which failed) and be more free with sexy topics (which also failed). I think this album was for other people and but not for her. And obviously when you make an album you want to do a good job and you take into consideration the people that are gonna listen, but not to the point where you lose your artistic identity...

Irulan1528

I’m so glad I joined your patreon. It’s been hard to actually enjoy the album release anywhere else on the internet. I really appreciate the honest and objective takes here, because loving our diva doesn’t mean being yes men. Even divas drop a mid album sometimes. Overall, it just feels rushed. I’ll take anything from Taylor, but this one needed to marinate a bit longer. She’s said in interviews that she’s tired, and honestly, it shows (which makes sense after the Eras Tour). It does feel as honest and as close as she can be with us at this point in her career. The release party wasn’t great either. We all knew what we were in for, but sitting through the lyric videos (especially the clean versions) was rough. She gave us moments, her best music video direction yet and some real bangers, but something still doesn’t sit right. I just hope she takes time to enjoy her life and comes back with something stronger.

Jessy Allison

I have also been thinking a lot about the difference between the song writing about Joe and her love for him compared to now for Travis. It is honestly worlds apart from each other.

maryna

How to murder your career - Lana? Not because of her albums but because of her behavior... (?)

capla

I think that when Taylor put out TTPD she was already in a different space in her life which I think made her want to put out a I love you Travis record just to stop associating her brand with TTPD. This is coming from a Showgirl enjoyer btw

Vasudha R

Yeah exactly, I need to learn how to disengage from all the other spaces and just interact with the community on patreon. It seems like the only sane place left

starstuff

I love the music video! She looks fantastic, I’m obsessed! I don’t feel disappointed in this album, which surprises me considering that I’m a new Taylor fan and I became enamored with her folklore/evermore lyricism. Partly, it might be because I had no actual expectations. I was just hoping not to hate it lol. The first 4 songs are amazing. Father Figure and Elizabeth Taylor are the stand-outs for me. I do find it quite jarring how many times women are referred to as bitches in the different songs… Feels very much not like Taylor Swift. I love Honey for the weirdest reason, the way she say “honey” 🥰… I don’t know if you’ve seen any of the radio interviews she’s given in the UK (they’re all on YouTube), but in a couple of them she talks about the fear of happiness affecting her writing, and she says “that’s not the case at all”… Look, I’m not gonna lie to myself that this writing is at the level I got used to with Taylor, but I also don’t think it’s the worst thing ever. Yes, she did say this is album she's been wanting to make for a really long time and I'm happy to go on this journey with her. These songs makes me happy and they make me want to dance. Tbh, I’m happy not to be a critic, because I can just enjoy it for what it is.

mindyrose

I would really love y’all to do a Patreon “safe space” video to dissect the album ! Bc I keep feeling defensive by people ‘out in the wild’ hating on it for unfair reasons, but I’m also genuinely frustrated by some of the things she is saying on the album. I don’t want to use these words and sound overdramatic, but for brevity sake the album feels classist and somewhat misogynistic—and also weirdly antagonistic? Wish List and Honey are like rage bait to me. But there are weird narrative threads throughout the whole album that I find unpleasant? Like I said, this is very conflicting so I need the Patreon bubble to be normal !! Plz send help !!!!

Simon

The swiftologist vs midnight sun hate videos im being served on my fyp are soooo annoying these ppl are acting like they gave birth to midnight sun they take it so personally

Abby Dorey

I'm a fairly new Taylor Swift fan but I'm so surprised at the civil war that appears to have broken out within the fanbase over this new album launch. I've seen a lot of Swifties saying that Reputation, Lover and TTPD also got a lot of flack on release, but for those that have been in the fandom longest, has it always been this bad in terms of fans having such a divided opinion? From what I've learnt, Lover and Rep got backlash more due to the production rather than the lyrics which seems to be the case this time with Showgirl?

Lucy

I’m so thankful that I found you Zach (& Madeleine too). I’m so sorry you are getting this horrific abuse and your family as well. It’s good that you are drawing the boundaries, I hope you can continue to do your analysis in an entertaining way without this affecting you too much - I couldn’t imagine how difficult it would be. In this day and age with such uninteresting, shallow “opinions” about pop culture - the Patreon is such an amazing safe space!!

NikiaFalcon

Disagree with this. It was the right time for something fun and unserious in a world of chaos. The same reason beyonce gave us renaissance after the pandemic and why we needed a brat summer. Sometimes ppl just need a fun escape

Morgan

The music video IS so good. The visuals eat.. the music not so much

Lina

Yes - maybe, "how to alienate your fan base"? Or I don't know, I just find the case Lana so interesting. Because she is kind of living the life she describes in her art, but it's somehow much more harrowing come to life.

Jenny

Also I would love your take on if Taylor has nothing to fight for anymore. I feel like even though she's not looking back at her big machine time in the most positive light, her having to fight for certain songs and genres made her music better. Her wanting to be THE popstar with 1989 is what made the album so perfect, because she wanted to achieve perfection while also having a lot to lose, she was taking a big risk. Then came the big freedom with switching labels, which turned into lover, arguably not a fan favorite. Then wanting to prove that she's the best at her craft still with folklore and evermore, but also still the HBIC of pop with midnights. I fear she's lost the critical voices inside and also around her and she doesn't really give a damn anymore because theres also no one to compare her to other than herself or legends that aren't around anymore. I don't know. TLOAS just falls so flat for me in every aspect. I listened so many times over the last couple of days and I just have to accept it's not for me.

Lise Caillaud

This video is amazing and really captured what we were expecting from TLOAS. Keep holding on your critical thinking as it is your most precious possession as a content creator (and maybe as a human being as well!)

maryna

When I saw the music video for the first time I so wanted to love the song but on its own it's just not fascinating enough... It's so frustrating to have a new album and not go crazy over it 😥 with ttpd I could not wait to go back and listen to the songs again, like it was a physical desire to hear them again as soon as possible...

Cosmic Clarity Circle

I LOVE your videos. I was seeing your TikTok comments and wondering how you handle all the hate. I think it’s part of reaching a wider, more general audience and just shows that you have a big impact and a lot to say. I personally love your takes and your way of thinking intelligently for yourself, even if I don’t agree with everything. Please keep up the good work! I hope you can tune out the hateration, because you are doing the lords work 🙌

Shannon Simon

I think that if she had spent another couple of months on the album, we would have had a very different outcome… instead we got this project that was pumped out as a first draft in the midst of the most physically and mentally demanding feat of her career. It’s not surprising that her best work didn’t come from spending a couple of weeks in the studio at the tail end of the Eras tour. I think there is also something to be said for the people who enabled some of this to happen too. I refuse to believe that anybody else listened to Eldest Daughter and truly felt like it deserved to be included. I wonder if she’s maybe (in a way) too powerful for her own good, leaving people reluctant to give her genuine feedback and resulting in some sub par work. Don’t get me wrong- I enjoy the album and it has many great moments and most of it is on replay in my house! But the lows are truly bleak. A “sexy baby” or “stronger than a 90s trend” here and there I can take, but when the entire track 5 is…. Whatever Eldest Daughter is…. Yikes.

Cynthia

Thank you for all the content with this album release. I really love all of it- and have always since way way way ago. Love you and Madeline.

Salgado

I've said in one of your tiktok videos and I keep feeling it - I think the closest paralel of this album is actually reputation - and no, I'm not comparing quality or saying it even comes close, but more in the subject of the songs. Lover was promoted a love album, but there was also a lot of obfuscation going around. Her and Joe having troubles and her not being ready to admit it to the world, while reputation was truly just the story of her and joe started. reputation was how they started and the real problems still hadn't kicked in, with just a couple of settling scores songs thrown in. This is the same (in SUBJECT) but for Travis - how they started, how hard she fell, how she's fully commited to him. In Lover, there were already signs they'd had their issues. I know the vibe of Showgirl most resembles Lover, but in subject alone, I link it to reputation.

xKami

i would love to see a video kind of comparing songs from TLOAS and their more successful/better written counterparts. like, for example Actually Romantic is a better version of Thank You, Aimee, etc.

Ella Clarke

Yeah when I heard eldest daughter my first thought was about max Martin and shell backs reaction. Like surely they don’t approve??

Isabela

I think Normani would be a great candidate, but also Chloe + Halle would be interesting? Great duo career that went sideways once they went solo.

libakri

I'd love the idea of doing lyric analyses for specific showgirl songs, especially father figure and ruin the friendship. It's sad to me that the weak spots on this album seem to overshadow some of the really great moments, because songs like father figure, ruin the friendship and elizabeth taylor are really straight to the canon moments for me, and i do love writing on some of the other songs (especially the imagery in tloas, like "glowing like the end of a cigarette" was like hello evermore taylor to me). And it's a great way to stay positive during this shitstorm yk. Anyway, i'm a new patreon subscriber, love your content, the podcast literally gets me through my shifts at work and has me laughing out loud!

Eleanor

I WISH she had done a follow on to the prophecy to make the idea of “you saved me” more interesting/complex. Something along the lines of I had gotten to the point where I really felt like no one would ever be able to deal with the enormity of being with Taylor Swift™️ and it broke me inside. I felt like I just had to accept it, BUT then you “saved me” from the fate I had resigned myself to. I think she could have built on the good moments in eldest daughter (like the bridge) and removed the truly humiliating lyrics and had a genuinely poignant song about how she had resigned herself to being single forever but was then able to find that uncomplicated love she had thought was out of her reach

Róisín

You're at a point now where haters are spiraling because of how nuanced/hilarious/media literate you are and they also can't retaliate at your level! LOL! Hope you know everyone's just obsessed with you, King!

JB

Cass

perfectly stated wow

RachB

I’m so happy to be here. Ruin the Friendship is so beautiful. Thank you for all you and Madeline do.❤️

Roxyy

I don't know if she counts as "murdering her career" cause she kinda just stopped, but Rihanna would be interesting to me- Normani would be great too

Rachel Kibler

I think this is one of the best self directed video she’s done!

Emma Jacobs

thank you for all of your hard work!!! it is so appreciated!!! but enjoy your time off at your bestie's wedding you're more than earned it

Ash

I’m hopeful that Travis isn’t a boring muse and she’s just figuring out her boundaries with the fans for this relationship. I wonder if The Prophecy still haunts her and maybe there’s a fear that writing about her relationships in the past had a role in them ending. Not that it’s true but we all have fears and I’m wondering what might be playing in her mind as her writing approach evolves.

Anna F

I think Taylor has really leaned into the idea she's a POET but I kinda disagree. Her best songs are when she leans into the fact she's a STORYTELLER. Bastille recently did a project & that was just a bunch of stories through literature and history. I think something like that is the path forward (or at least as an album between Taylor centric albums - gives her a little more time to have events and process)

Maya Reads

Its funny cause i love your commentary and I agree with a lot of it. But i love this album, i am having the time of my life listening to it. Wood is my fav right now 😂😅 Your the only bad review video i am watching Edit : also who the heck is Lara Larson 😂 thats it bye

Morgan

Was actually just watching your how to murder your career videos this weekend and I love them and seated for whoever you talk about.

Sasha 💘

As soon as I saw the wigs in the cinema I was like "ooohhh Zach is totally going to comment on the wigs" 😭😭 you crack me upppp ly x

Lin

Tha P

Lover vs Showgirl...... yes!! I'll be seated for that analysis

Tony

If you think about it, it’s the greatest EP of all time. 😂

Madelyn Fornia

Yes please do the Charli and Taylor relationship

Bee Elle

I was so very happy with the music video, it was exactly the energy I was expecting from the album. I am a mixed bag of feelings but I am still ultimately happy to sing along and enjoy it, despite it not being the start to finish banger

liz liz liz ❤️‍🔥

I loved seeing all the eras tour family in this mv it felt like a full circle moment and a real end to the eras tour 😭🫶🏼

Tony

Also… I know this is a platitude, but it doesn’t make it any less true. People love to take a pretty girl down. And the worst calls come from inside the house. Examples… Britney- What happened to America’s sweetheart? Mariah- What happened to out talented 90’s queen? Taylor- What happened to our writer girl? Idk, some of the really online “fans” act like these girls are committing war crimes. I’m really glad Madeline did her showgirls content because it was a good history refresher. That’s why I love your content and like it here. We can kiki without actively routing for the downfall of the girls. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Joan Chan

Video ideas: 1. Reading and analyzing the full Showgirl poems from all the vinyls - they really speak to the behind the scenes of the show that you talked about expecting from the album 2. Doing a “fix it” video for Eldest Daughter - perhaps pulling from her other songs that speak to the different (too many!!) ideas that she was trying to jam into one song. The idea of her being stuck in an eldest daughter role and then reconnecting with her inner child is so beautiful and really wish that was the song we were given instead of punk on the internet looking fire nonsense 😢 Also the chorus: what does “I’m never gonna let you down” have to do with anything else she’s talking about actually??? If anything that plays into the eldest daughter role trap. As an eldest daughter I would know lol.

Ohdearjon

I like the music video too but I’m like you finally did it …. For this.

Cynthia

Would you address her massive financial budget at this point which this album reflects clearly. Do you think this album is all visuals; fantasy visuals and strange songs possibly quickly written. Was this album to quickly change the narrative from TTPD to showgirl?

Ohdearjon

Im fine with non Taylor content right now. Im exhausted and it’s depressing right now

Sarah

A couple of thoughts: - A lot of artists have a two to three year gap between albums so they have life experiences to write about and give themselves space from project to project, which is not what Taylor is doing here. It feels like she needs to put out every idea she has, regardless of quality. - While I was not surprised this was the “I love Travis” album, given the way she talked about it, I was really hoping for more of a concept album, with Taylor using her experience/life on the Eras Tour to create a storytelling narrative of a showgirl from being young to her grave. I really want her to do that kind of “proper” (for want of a better word) narrative storytelling album at some point. I’m so sorry you and your family are getting abuse; it’s completely unacceptable, regardless of what your opinions are. EDIT: Her directing skills seem to be levelling up; this gives me a little more confidence about the movie. Maybe doing a project in an alternative medium will help give her some space.

Tony

Interesting!

Ohdearjon

How to murder your career doja cat although I don’t think it’s murder. It’s just on life support

splendidvie

very interesting thoughts and topic!

Tha P

"This isnt what she said it was" - clocked it!

Margot Touitou

I really wish she would've pre-released this video BEFORE the album came out. It really tied the showgirl theme in, in a way that the lyrics and songs on the album alone did not do.

Miss_Lippy

I assumed the chorus was her trying to make a more grown up version of white horse “I’m not a princess, this ain’t a fairytale…I was a dreamer before you went & let me down” and in her trying to make current & “mature” that sentiment she went with cringe millennial internet slang translation 🥴 so it didn’t land well

newtdog

I'd be interested to get your thoughts on how Taylor's production inclinations have been shaped through working closely with Jack, and how that rubbed off on this record - I want to be a fly on the wall of how Taylor, Max and Shellback worked on the production.

T

Imagine being the only swiftie in your life and your defending her and her artistry for YEARS to everyone pointing to her best work and writing and then she drops this..... its like, very deflating. Can't defend it at all and its so bad you have to wonder why you ever did in the first place

Sophia

Sister songs my tears ricochet and father figure!!! Thematic similarities but a different perspective. Sad vs angry. Child like vs parental.

DemiMarie🤍🖤

Her Cuntress Cup has spilith over on this MV 🙌🏻❤️‍🔥

Chelsea Bauscher

Thank you for reacting! Stay strong and honest among the discourse, at the end of the day it's about musical opinion, you are valid and above it. Keep it up!

Sarah

i saw a comment on tiktok that said « at the end of the day i’m a swiftie » and that’s my mood right now. i didnt like it because i know what she can deliver and that’s not the kind of music i’ll be interested in any artist. even one i adore. i feel exactly the same way as i did after me came out. so i’ll be in this corner of the internet, watching the swiftologist and waiting for tay’ to give me back what i feel in love with. (as a fan since OG red)

N.PAVLIDOU

I would love a Justin Bieber video for how to murder your career because I think his discography has not aged very well.

ella

i think individual songs on the album are great songs but as a whole idk if it’s an amazing album ,it’s not in my top 5 taylor albums but i like it and don’t think it deserves all those twitter discourse but then again every time it’s taylor release there’s a small hate train so 🤷

splendidvie

I would like a video that discusses how (or if) Taylor takes and works with criticism, and how it affects her art. I feel like she took all of the TTPD criticism completely to heart and created the exact opposite in response — even sacrificing some of her craft to drive home the point she wanted to make. This has happened before, for example, from reputation to Lover. If she could find some middle ground, I think she could create a truly well-rounded, timeless album that showcases her skill in every aspect.

Sarah

Fantano> during his Lover review he mention Paper Rings was his favourite Taylor song up until that point.

Renz Averion

New member here! Love all the content

Ashley Taylor

I'm so sorry you've been getting so many disgusting comments and hate videos. But if it helps, listening to Actually Romantic and all of Taylor's Advice on the podcast about how she deals with negative comments it really makes these Haters actions so ridiculous. Like they took time and effort out of their day to not only watch your videos but then think and type out hate comments . I especially find it crazy the people who spend so much effort in making hate tiktoks. For someone they claim to hate they sure do spend alot of time thinking about you. Like I don't understand how they're not embarrassed of their actions especially towards your mom. Also side note I loved your reaction to the music video it was literally all the same thoughts I had.

No Thoughts

Love the music video too! She is so beautiful 😭. As always love your view points on the album, we love our well spoken king ❤️

Claude Favor

i hope father figure is next

X

oh i love this take (the album being mid) because I disagree so much. this is her best album since reputation. and the end of the video changes the way the album needs to be interpreted entirely. this is not a happy album. the happiness is the artifice on the surface. just like the savage bad bitchness was the artifice of reputation. a lot of people haven't gotten to the next layer yet and i'm so excited for when they do.

Tony

True! I also think the issue is more complicated now because not all of the criticism is good or relevant. From Red to 1989, the industry gave a valid piece of constructive criticism- not sonically cohesive. From TTPD to now it’s different because she’s astronomically huge, so literally everyone will have an opinion. And not all of them will be good.

WhiteWalker68

I thought your comments about TK as a muse were really insightful. I'd love a video on the differences in her approach to the writing for different muses. Is it the fact that she pathologically people pleases? Is the new album exactly what she thought TK might want, or is it the vibe of the relationship that sets the tone, or something else?

Mia Sternoff

I would love to hear your thoughts on the juxtaposition between how Taylor throughout the decades has been THE relatable artist and her success is thanks to the ability of her fans being able to resonate with her through her lyrics. This album makes me feel so alienated from her because she is so un relatable, and the fact that she’s said Wish List is her favorite song is something that’s insane to me….

Hammie

I’m sorry about the hate you’re getting this week 💕 Excited for Fantano on the Swiftologist! Jon Caramanica from the NYTimes also gave Showgirl a better review than TTPD so I would be curious what Anthony wants from Taylor too. As a TTPD obsessive, I went in knowing Showgirl wasn’t going to give me the vulnerable diaristic Taylor I love (though we still got a few things to hold on to), but I also don’t think she made 12 bullet proof pop hits for the fans who wanted that?

Roisin Shy

100% if she would have said this everyone would just appreciate the fun of this album and not take it too seriously. I think the album should have been called Opalite and that should have been the single so it would better reflect this should be a fun album and not too grand like the life of a showgirl

Jordan 🌻

Thanking Abraham & Allah 😭😂

Roisin Shy

If she would have said to everyone - just appreciate the fun of this album and not take it too seriously. I think the album should have been called Opalite and that should have been the single so it would better reflect this should be a fun album and not too grand like the life of a showgirl

Sarah

In terms of video/episode ideas, I’d be interested in something about Taylor’s journey with critics. We’ve gone from a lot (not all) critics saying “I’m not interested in reviewing Taylor’s work”, the inflection around 1989 and the Ryan Adams cover album, to “I’m going to give this a positive review no matter what” (not read a huge number of reviews for LOAS, so I’m not sure of the general vibes). Thank you both for all your hard work.

X

i think this album is basically a continuation of the prophecy. at the end of the fate of ophelia video i think she's alluding to the fact that she has not (yet) figured out how to change the fate of ophelia. she is just distracted for now, again.

Elizabeth

Like “Actually Romantic” might be embarrassing, but is she wrong? Even when Taylor isn’t part of the convo, people insert her. Like she is always in people’s minds.

Lydia

Loved this rant ❤️

shannymac

I think now that my brain has reacted and adjusted to what the album is vs. what we were told it would be (12 bullet-proof songs of folklore lyrics + perfect pop production), I’m enjoying it. Definitely mid-tier on my album rankings but I enjoy it more with each listen.

X

taylor was cancelled during reputation and lover. so the criticisms were so unhinged and moralistic. and they were coming from a place of not wanting to understand her at all. it's like people were bonding over dunking on taylor and making her fans feel bad.

splendidvie

Absolutely. The real power and art lie in deciphering which criticism to take on board and what to ignore. It surely doesn’t help that she’s been pumping out albums in such a short amount of time. We could have waited a bit longer and really reflected on the work being put out. Oh well. I'm hoping she really takes a break now and comes back stronger (without the 90s trend).

X

is travis her forever arrangement, or is she elizabeth taylor and about to get married and divorced 8 times? i think taylor is asking herself the question.

Emma S

I’m so grateful for all the extra content throughout this rollout!! 💗 always appreciate you

Juna

Keep going diva, we love you

Rhajaa Wright

Echoing: How to Murder Your Career (Justin Bieber) if you can consider that. I know he’s had a lot of personal troubles. Or maybe Demi Lovato. And also echoing marketing of Taylor’s albums, versus reality, and receipts on how it was first perceived and how it changed over time!

Katie

I’ve been thinking about this too!!

Taylor Westbrook

i think some people really need to realize that you can still be a swiftie and dislike some of her work. the tiktokification of taylor has really distorted our critical view of artists. we are absolutely allowed to “not like” a segment of taylor’s work. everyone seems to think that it’s an all-in situation, and we see it with the zara larsen drama as well. you’re allowed to not like something that taylor puts out, not everything is going to be perfect- and by giving thoughtful criticism, it makes her a better artist!!

Katie

Oooooh yes love this topic

Stacy Davydova_13

Zack, a thought for future episodes. Can we track back the lack of quality on her records? Starting maybe with re records?…. Especially 1989 tv?………

T

ROTFL thank you for sharing that just made my day

cait andrews

Please, if you do a comparison of Joe and Travis love songs you HAVE to go to Rep. Lover, the honeymoon phase was pretty much over. You have to compare apples to apples. Rep has the horny omg you saved me love songs for Joe and we have that again on Showgirl.

Erin

I mean I would loveee for this to be true but I personally don’t think it is. Like she’s said a few times that she was really happy making this record and that it reflects the exact place her life is in rn… the end of the MV is intriguing but I don’t see that theme of false opulence/gaudy artifice applied consistently in this record

X

i also feel like people aren't reconciling with the fact that tortured poets was not "crafted" as an album she just put out like every song that she wrote with hardly any editing. folklore and evermore were similarly not crafted. she was just playing around. In contrast, Life of a Showgirl is Taylor getting back together with the best songwriter in the world and crafting what she's described as her best work. And so I think looking at it through that lens requires resisting the temptation to stop at the distraction of a happy album.

davy-sheymour

i don’t think it’s the worst album ever made, some people are just anti-taylor but the thought of it being the last taylor swift album the people have in mind for the next 2 to 3 years (or more) surely gives me pause… we gotta come up with something quick

Rhettica

I've also been trying to put my thoughts about this album into words because it is kinda difficult for me to decide how i feel about it. I definitely enjoyed it. The whole production is a vibe and i can see myself putting this on just to have fun. It's very simple lyrically but the only song i didn't really understand was Eldest Daughter - it seemed all over the place. We didn't need to hear Wood but it's very catchy. I enjoyed Actually Romantic, it's one of my favs. The most interesting song to me was Father Figure, that one had so many layers and was probably something she wanted to say for a while given all the power structures she's had to endure throughout her life. She really has had to hold so much in over the years, in fact, i don't think i've ever seen her lose it in public before. That's gotta do weird things to you, holding in all your negative emotions like that because you're being watched all the time and even when you're home or alone, you're never truly alone - there's always someone nearby. I was kinda impressed to see her go a bit dark on this record, though i suppose it's safest now for her to do so given she's now one of the the biggest stars ever. The only song that made me pause was Cancelled because it seemed like Taylor was saying that it's okay if you're not that nice a person and do bad things to others, just be better at hiding it and if you can't i'll show you how. The lyrics on that made me wonder about the situations she's not been caught in over the years and i didn't like to think about that. I suppose when you can only hang out with people in your industry, you have to learn to adapt your expectations but still... I also wonder about her labels involvement and her contract with them sometimes. The brutal schedule she's had over the years of putting out music and then touring it and repeating over and over again. Is she somewhat contractually obliged to do this? I mean she wrote TLOAS during the eras tour when she was flat out doing the show and changing it to include TTPD. How is she not fully exhausted by now? It also seems like most of the songs mimicked other artists songs or styles and i don't know if that was intentional, like a nod to other 'showgirls', or if music producers have just run out of ideas. Anyway, thanks for all your reactions, I love watching them :)

Ashley Taylor

I really want to see your reactions to the acoustic version of some of the songs like Elizabeth Taylor. Wish List's acoustic version is actually so much better than the normal version in my opinion.

Kait

At the risk of this sounding mushy, I think your honesty and journalistic integrity on this demented internet is very courageous, and I really admire you for it.

Rachel

How to murder your career: Zara Larsson lmaoooo

Zoë

Yeah I think this makes Elizabeth Taylor more interesting as a song as well. Maybe I’m missing something but I’m not hearing all this supposedly blissful happiness on the album, I think there’s still a lot of anxiety, doubt and bitterness in some of the lyrics. Like it’s not giving peaceful and secure to me.

Miss Liz

You aren’t. I LOVE IT and I don’t care who knows it!! And we don’t have to have shame AND we don’t have to disagree there are issues. Having a tacky broach that you just love is showgirl.

oPaulo

This time the discourse feels insane (it always does) but I remember when I listened to lover, I had a similar feeling tha this isnt good and I liked a few songs and just kept going back to that. I want to do the same with this album, but the discourse is driving me to almost love it you know what I mean? Just out of spite LOL. I miss the time when I could listen and have my own thoughts.

leticia hernandez

I feel she was still feeling insecure with Joe even when the relationship was new & with Travis she has always felt secure, more free to be herself so there's no angst

Hannah H

Is there any chance that the morning after hate that was everywhere gaslit you from your initial joy?

Jasmine

People on the internet are gross, I'm so sorry 😢

Megan

Okay, one more thing about Travis's d*ck. This is the first time that he is her muse and I wonder if he didn't really understand what it would feel like to have this in the public. Maybe a lot of this language and slang is part of their communication at home or with friends but it is definitely not the same quality of writing (if she had not over promised, I think it would feel less jarring as you've discussed). I'm just wondering if Travis is actually OK with a song about his d*ck and sex with Taylor being in the world like this? He has a career and is active online and has to live with it just as much as she does. I'm just curious if he will ever comment about that maybe long-term down the road.

Kylee

Eldest Daughter is first pancake behaviors and on behalf of all eldest daughters I say, she’s not with us. 😘 I’ll save the rest for phone a snake.

Bella

Yes yes yes totally yes bump I want this discussion I totally agree

Maeva

The music video is what Bejeweled and Karma feat Ice Spice wanted to be. Serving, gorgeous showgirl!

Kylee

Actually, Gwen could be really interesting If you start from the No Doubt album, Tragic Kingdom, It literally took over the 90s. If you would’ve asked me in 2002 where Gwen Stefani would be today I could not even begin to guess where she ended up. It’s a completely different person.

Kat

I'm sooo seated for a comparison between Lover and Life of a Showgirl. Thanks for the video!

Megs1986

I think there is such interesting things going on in the people who hate this album. And I love your perspective because I feel like it is a different perspective than a lot of others have on it. It would be interesting to do a video on it, because you have: 1) those that kinda fall into the “how did it end?” Those who only think that her writing is good/interesting when she’s absolutely tortured. So they find this boring— but sometimes I also think that’s because people want company in the disasters of their own lives. 2) People who on boarded only as certain albums and only want that style. She’s made a career out of being different at almost every album and so they love or hate the different styles. She probably has one of the most widely diverse support groups. 3) people who are only here for their version of “feminist” moments. Like the fact that she wants to get married is how somehow wiping away that she’s wanted to be the girl boss historically. Their actual TikTok’s of people who say, they feel betrayed by her now wanting to be gratified in this aspect of her life. 4) combo And etc. I don’t mean this list to be exclusive because obviously there’s combinations, and a ton of others but I’m finding just the different reasons for people’s feelings so varied and interesting.

Kat

Does anyone else think she's going to do another folklore/evermore type album after this so she can keep her private life under wraps but get better at writing again?

Luiza Lodder

I agree with you that the optics of the album's lyrics and general vibes aren't good, especially now (but also, was there ever a good time to write songs like wish list and cancelled?). It feels tone deaf. But I think this has less to do with tragic world events, which taylor has no control over to be fair to her, and more to do with her seeming inability to read the room, actually examine what she is writing and putting out artistically, and adjust the messaging accordingly. People say "it's just music, it doesnt matter" but it does matter. She doesnt live in a vacuum and neither do we.

Ellen

Hi Zach! I’m one of the new Patreon joiners and this was a super fun watch. Maybe unpopular opinion but I think that if this album was marketed as an EP then I think it would have been more well received. I’m not sure what the consensus is for bigger artists and EP’s but I think it would have been fun to just have a little interlude before her break create a tone for upcoming projects. I think EPs have 7 tracks or less so it would be even more super concise without the pressure to be bulletproof. I also think the ‘showgirl’ aspect wouldn’t be the main theme but still scattered through out and I think it would be fun to have the title be Opalite or ruin the friendship (I dunno could be an interesting theme to perceive it under)

Rhaven Moon

Jus to potentially help with the lover/showgirl comparison and adding to what you’re mentioning at 19:45, she talks about being happy and writing sad songs in her tiny desk as well lol, I watched it yesterday and it’s VERY telling

davy-sheymour

And I also would like to know if you guys think her shift to pop and folkmore were enough of depatures, many times while listening some of the songs on showgirl I noticed melodies or inflections in her voice that I had heard before. This is her 12th album and 5th in 5 years and I personally can tell… when I think of the most iconic/successful artists, madonna, for example (also very adamant about writing her songs), there were different musical phases, playing with genres etc… I’m not saying taylor should go full electronic or ambient haha, but she is 20 years in now... and I feel that discussions about her being a one-trick pony, while not entirely accurate, are somewhat justified.

Jordan kuzniak

I can’t believe that Zara Larson Stan’s out of everyone is giving you this much back lash 😂

X

One way I've come to think of what the "Life of a Showgirl" is for taylor is: to get all these things she says she wants with these enormous cinematic highs, and then still feel like she's drowning. And realizing that she might be doomed to ride this roller coaster over and over again until she dies. happily ever after in a house with a basketball hoop or in a bathtub with an overturned oscar on the floor. that said, I didn't get tortured poets until this album came out. i only liked Down Bad and The Prophecy, so that for sure colors my interpretation.

Prepropro

I love the bastille record!

Kayla Pickles

diva i NEED you to know how obsessed with you and how much i respect your reviews and opinions. WE NEED YOU pls don't listen to the deranged comments.

Krista Dabel

I genuinely am most disappointed in what we got for eldest daughter. I thought this was going to be a “Surface Pressure” by Jessica Darrow moment… but from a mature, poetic Taylor Swift. Surface Pressure had me gutted in the middle of an animated kids movie - that song so perfectly captured the eldest daughter experience. Taylor could have done so much with this one. Every eldest daughter was the first lamb to the slaughter, tell me more about THAT. Can we go back and make THIS the song? It honestly feels like she wrote 2 songs, threw them in a blender, and put it on the record. The messaging is so choppy. I think the song sounds pretty and the sentiment behind the Travis lyrics is very sweet… but I get completely taken out of it when she goes back to “but I’m not a bad bitch and this isn’t savage.” 🥴

Diaries of Creativity

watching you watch this made me SO HAPPY because I felt the EXACT same way I was like girllll if youre making me go to a THEATRE for this it better be fucking GOOD

Emily Taylor

Agree about calling women bitches - so weird to me!

Octomew

I hope I can explain point 3 a bit, I don't mind if she's getting married but it's a really weird feeling she starts calling women bitches as soon as she gets a ring, a huge part of Taylor was loving love AND being the diva. As mentioned a bit in the video, it feels a bit like she's done pretending she cares about feminism/girlbossing at all. It's totally a downer if you liked that element (which was a core aspect of her branding for over a decade), especially when other artists manage to find a balance like Beyoncé. I HOPE I'm reading her situation wrong 😅

Erin Howell

I would love for you to ask Anthony what,in his mind, is the most realized version of Taylor and her artistry. What would he want to see from her in the future that would make him feel like she is using her gifts and her impact to their highest and best use. Such a fan of the both of you! Your voices are much needed in music criticism

Maria Zuccarini

im sorry for how hateful some people are to you 😭 like taylor said, "they wanna see you rise but not reign" ❤️

Savvy

Omg im so so sorry about the hate you are getting... that is cray

Kat

I'd also love to see a video about fixing the tracklist and maybe also the rollout and visuals/marketing!

stephaliceo

the masses suddenly acting like she’s never written happy love songs is killing meeeee. a comparison not just with lover but with her best love songs would be so interesting. love story vs ophelia etc!

SW

I don’t know if you’ll see this. But the fact that they are hating on you shows your success. It will calm down. Not that it doesn’t hurt. But like Taylor, just ignore…..and make that money honey!

Rhaven Moon

And to add to that, she mentions that if she couldn’t find inspiration in a happy relationship that she’d write about what’s going on in the world around her…UHM?! The world is a mess rn 😭 how much more inspiring does it need to be

SW

You’re a SHOWGIRL darling!!

Alexandra S

Adore your Cruel Intentions shirt btw.

Kayla Pickles

i agree! i was shocked when she said wi$h li$t was her favourite, it's so NOT a taylor song

Natalia

I’m so curious to see you compare with Lover as I think of Showgirl as Lover’s cringy sister. I think, based on the radio interviews, she made this very quickly and with *zero forethought*. She said I’m happy and I do NOT care about anything else. Like maybe if she’d given it a year she’d have the benefit of hindsight.

Kayla Pickles

oh yes I've been thinking about this, it's almost like she wanted to make an album for locals and travis?

stephaliceo

ooooh yes i’m not too aware of critical reception of most of her albums (i simply never read them)

Elle Kaye

Good writing demands conflict and I think that’s why so many of her Joe love songs (even the goofy ones) land better. Even when she’s swooning over him, she’s incredibly anxious about it. I’m really curious how she’ll write about Travis, if at all, in future projects. Tbh I think it’s going to be a few years before the next album, and that’ll be good.

Taylor Pearson

How to murder your career: Jesy Nelson

Moonbeam009

I 🫶 Swiftologist. Been here for a couple years now, and I ain't going anywhere! Love you, Diva. Remember to take a break from scrolling.

Jasmine

I'm with you, I keep changing my mind on the album. Opalite is so joyful, I like the theme of creating your own happiness and 'dancing through the lightning strikes'. Some people are saying it's just Taylor having fun and the production is good, so are we overthinking it all? Maybe for some but the writing for me has felt disappointing overall so far 😢 Is the writing issue due to timing, how it was produced on tour, was it too rushed to be thought through? Lots to think about but also the fact the album is not as advertised I think hasn't helped with the disappointment! However the video for Ophelia is amazing, your reaction was awesome thank you 🫶

j.bean

This is how I’m coping with it 😂I’ve hidden the worst offenders on my playlist and am saying it’s just an EP ✨

Elle Kaye

I think the diva is just tired. Her creative output since 2019 has been absurd. Folklore/Evermore came out of the first real rest she’d had in a while. Also she said writing this album was like a creative project that kept her going and focused when tour got boring. The bitches with the headshot on the wall wish they could write something like this in between their 3.5-hour sold-out world tour.

Savvy

Glitch is the better song compared to wish list 😆

Kenna

SO good

X

I think she is being honest about where she says she is right now. and that is both in love and constantly terrified that this could be doomed to end badly and she could be doomed to keep doing this over and over. so i see that opulence/gaudy artifice applied constantly from the start. for example, right after she's starting to drown again in the bathtub next to an overturned oscar on the floor at the end of Fate of Ophelia, Taylor shouts "Elizabeth Taylor!", who got married and divorced 8 times. like we're on track 2 and she's already asking what if i get divorced. but make it opulent and luxurious.

Megs1986

I can understand that. I suppose I’m also trying to take in the fact that behind the scenes of eras she has said she did nothing but sit in a hotel room to write her mashups, recuperate, have Travis moments, and that was about it. Buying back her masters would have been after she finished this- right? Or am I wrong? Maybe the reality is that it would’ve been better to hold off writing music until she had more life experience than the Eras Tour and hotel rooms essentially. But on a more personal side- as a career woman who feared that was all I’d have, I think it’s pretty normal to go bonkers excited that your going to get to fulfill that other aspect of your life too. And we know she always wanted it. I think she’ll eventually find the balance. Now that I think about it- in a weird way We’ve always said that she went bonkers dramatic writing over what everyone thought was a fling, and now she’s gone bonkers dramatic on the absolute opposite side of things. 😂 Two sides of the same coin. that’s cracking me up!

june

i've been having such a complicated relationship with this albumm. i think my main main issue is not that it's bad-ish, because i think most artists have some terrible misses in their catalogues it's bound to happen at some point. and there are good moments here. what is bothering me the most is that the amount of money pwease behavior surrounding the album does not match the quality. she always does it of course but when the music has downgraded in quality this much, the money please behaviors start to especially annoy me. like the album already lacks a clear thesis and narrative, when you do the i'm having a theatrical release for a glorified music video i start to think oh so this whole thing is to milk the fans lmao. that's where the disconnect starts, especially when you combine it with some of the out of touchness of the album. the optics are not good for this one. i appreciate you guys' honesty and sincerity regarding the album thanks for all the great content!

AmyJN

Coming for Mum-ologist is unhinged. We ride at dawn!

Savvy

I feel the same! But its because his negative review is centered not super negative and not super positive and i can appreciate that even if i dont fully agree. Some of the hateration going on in other parts of the internet is crazyyy and i need to protect my headspace

Anna Tierney

I would love a Justin Bieber or Justin Timberlake how to murder your career

Oona M

He has already made a how to murder your career video on demi lovato!:)

Elle Kaye

Oh serve! I’m very excited about Fantano coming on. That Socratic back-and-forth will be so compelling, and I’m sure you’ll be able to talk about the catalog beyond LOAS.

mikeymasciola

i really do appreaciate the checkin, i feel like the swiftologist nation could really use a state of the union after all of this settles down in a week and we have more clarity!

Pete

I went on a similar journey to you Zack with how I've felt about the album, but I'm currently in a place of hand heart while acknowledging its (concerning) flaws. The good songs are really catchy, (I'm having trouble falling asleep because ELIZABETH TAYLOR keeps jolting me awake) and I can still enjoy the clean versions of several of the others. That five track run from Fate of Ophelia to Ruin the Friendship is my everything (Eldest Daughter was swiftly excommunicated from the record). I'm finding the differing reactions to Showgirl really interesting. The Online Stans HATE it and are being foul, the general public and casuals seem to really like it, Swifties are polarized and the critics are surprisingly fair, even the Pitchfork review was very reasonable (because it was written by a woman thank god). So that could be interesting to talk about in video. You covered my other main concerns in this Patreon space which were the likelihood of her only making 12 tracks and saying "we're done here" and calling other women 'bitches' in Honey and the title track. Okay Ms. "Don't Call Me That!!!" I see you... As for other video ideas, I think a How to MAINTAIN Your Career for Lady Gaga would be really fun, and could go into how she stepped into some acting roles in between album cycles. Also, Grammy nominees are announced November 7th so it would be good timing to do a vid on her (Mayhem AOTY). Hopefully you can take a break and enjoy your best friend's wedding and come back with a clearer perspective on the album. Take care diva!

cat

that’s the part I personally am having the most difficulty moving past, like I want to enjoy honey for example bc i LOVE the melody of that song but the bashing other women for lack of a better term just kind of makes me a bit … idk uncomfortable? in a way. i just don’t think the constant referring to women as ‘bitches’ was necessary or expected and it’s leaving a bit of a sour taste for me. but also to edit - like i cried through the first few songs (bear in mind it was 6am) bc of the parasocialism of it all, like her happiness with travis is so clear and i am so pleased for her, it’s nothing to do with that it’s the bitches thing that really gets me. just unnecessary and kinda mean for no reason i thought

Aly

I just don’t understand the lack of detail. 1989 was arms length but details like “20 stitches in a hospital room” are still great writing moments. This album is also creating a working theory in my head that it’s not happiness that’s the writing block, it’s just that Taylor is uninterested in inner growth. I think who she is is settled and she doesn’t have the desire to grow much more… so without strong external circumstances to reflect or inner exploration, she’s stuck retreading the same paths emotionally, and sometimes even regressing. Ruin the Friendship is the first somewhat new Taylor insight and that’s why it sticks out but also feels fresh. Every other concept or takeaway she’s done before and even better in another song. it’s the downside of having such an extensive catalogue

madelon

Im les than a minute in and WHERE IS THE DIVA HEADDRESS?

SW

Talk to fantano about his review of Halsey….. Also Taylor’s music requires knowledge to truly appreciate and enjoy. Maybe since your interview, he appreciates her music more, thus his more positive reception of this album. Because he’s more informed.

june

how to murder your career on any of the ex 1d members except harry could be interesting. comparing why harry succeeded and the others kind of flopped etc.

Tonya Lynch

I'm confused where you thought she was supposed to serve "showgirl". Did she not say this was what was going on off stage?? Wasn't it supposed to be what was happening in her LIFE, hence Life of a Showgirl ". I'm new to the Swift universe and maybe that's why I like it. ❤️‍🔥 I do also appreciate your view and outlook bc you're honest

Spencer Frederick

I was really sad to see what happened with your Zara Larsson review, I kind of had the reaction you guys had to getting abuse for calling Mike Posner a flop, like we’re doing all of this for Zara Larsson? I saw someone say it’s fucked up to call someone a B tier popstar like we have truly lost the plot. And all over a review of an album it’s just such insane jobless behaviour.

Sarah

AT DAWN!!!

Bailey Wilcox

I know you said this, but would love a Father Figure breakdown!!

Elle Kaye

Tbh I think she felt compelled to put that out into the world because it would help insulate him from a lot of comments in his industry. There’s always going to be locker room teasing and outright barbs at the line of scrimmage. But how do they get at him with “yo, I hear your dick is huge and brought your superstar fiancé back to life.”

Jaime

Agreed. This may trigger some people but the money pwease behavior for a low quality body of work feels like taking advantage of the fans. I’m not saying that’s her intention- but it reads that way to me, sadly. I felt this way at the theatre being charged $20 for Spotify song clip lyric videos. Girlie has enough money, she could have released the behind the scenes for Ophelia as a gift to the fans for buying all the variants, spending a lot of money on eras tour tickets, etc.

j.bean

I honestly think Taylor has everything she ever wanted now - Eras tour was world stopping, she has more creative control than ever, she has a legacy no one could ever take from her, she got her masters back, she got engaged and seemingly is going to start a family in the near future, she’s not a victim in the press in the same way she was in 2016. So why is there a current of bitterness and like she’s manufacturing drama on this album?

X

interesting takes! one way i look at cancelled is noticing how she finds kinship with people who have survived a cancellation like she has. she's one of the first big stars to be cancelled and come back from that bigger than before. so i see it as: for taylor, part of her life of a showgirl is going to involve being kind of a community elder of sorts mentoring others who go through a cancellation. maybe she even realizes that this is a role she plays for her fans too who feel like they've been through a similar thing at work/school ect. so i see it less as being moralistic and more as recognizing that being cancelled is something that can bring her closer to people and allow her to give advice for how to survive from a place of experience.

SW

What if you did deep dives on senior divas, Whitney, Mariah, Celine, Cher…..

Areyna Schmidt

Marked unsafe from the internet —> 🙋🏼‍♀️ THIS IS WHY I COME TO THE EOAS PATRERON FOR THE REAL DISCOURSE!! I’m sorry they’re messaging you and your MOTHER like wtf?! And this is about MUSIC, yall. Like it’s truly not that serious, we’re just here to have a cute time in our sparkles but also talk about it critically because that’s what we should be able to do 😭 let people enjoy things MY GAWD!! Thank you for continuing to feed us, Zach 🫶

Ellen

So true. I learned my lesson from having a solid expectation from ttpd and all I decided I wasn’t gonna be disappointed if there was nothing deep because she did write it while on a massive tour. I was in it for purely vibes and I think it paid off on that front 😂

Elle Kaye

This!!! The Patreon is my only real form of internet/social media (I’m not even in the discord anymore because it was taking up too much of my time lol). My initial, positive reaction to the album has stayed the same because it’s my ~genuine~ reaction. My friend who is the most online of the whole group started out saying it was amazing and now she’s turning on it, and I 100% think it’s because her FYP is full of hateration.

Stella

I think the first four tracks + Ruin the Friendship are great. The rest of the album is ok-ish with a couple of bad tracks (looking at you, Eldest Daughter). But when you've only got 12 tracks, then half of those can't be mid or bad. 1989, in comparison, is front-to-back. Blank Space is so well written, but also songs like Style and Wildest Dreams are lyrically simple, but neat, sexy, and clever. I'm missing that kind of writing on Life of a Showgirl, even if the production is good.

X

i think you're cooking on this. i think this album is what taylor and max martin decided to do instead of Reputation TV. and I think it almost picks up whether the story left off, ~8 years later.

Inés

I would be super interested in the idea you mentioned of comparing her Joe love songs and Travis love songs. And not only the love songs, but the songs written during the relationship. I feel like the muse being so supportive and tuned in makes her want to please the muse, and unfortunately Travis loves silly bops. Also, I can’t imagine him being too happy about her writing about any other man. I don’t think he would have let Question go on the album… Of course, implying that Joe wrote her songs is crazy, but I would love for you to share your thoughts on what the purses bring out of her as an artist.

Maya Reads

Yeah, maybe it's also since I've been watching Zach for 2 years ish, i find his humour hilarious. Wood is my fav and I loved his reaction it's fun. Poeple need to live a little and chill. I am NOT going on tiktok with this album, its scary

Alec

Hi Zach, I have a silly idea that’s kinda inspired by the third folkmore sister video. I was thinking about u and Madeline making a tloas inspired album of songs from tay’s previous albums that ACTUALLY fit the theme of tloas "what was going on behind the curtain".

Elle Kaye

She 100% wrote AR about and for the Swiftologist (in the same way she wrote Fate of Ophelia about and for me)

Nicole Ouimette

I’m sorry Zach about all the hate you’re getting, that’s just unacceptable. In terms of this album…. The songs are so catchy and I find myself singing them in my head and out loud, but I do need to turn my brain off to listen to them. Which is too bad because Taylor has always been the pop artist who makes pop songs that mean something. I do agree Travis is a terrible muse and I also believe everyone around her just tells her how great she is.

shelby

The thing I’m most baffled by is Taylor saying that each of the 12 songs are so integral to the album that you couldn’t add or remove one… there are at least 3-4 songs that repeat the same theme and it definitely could’ve used a few better tracks to strengthen the album

Eliza Nieset

I love that you’re going on to talk with Anthony Fantano about the album. I’ve always felt that around the Midnights era, Anthony’s reactions were shaped a bit by the negativity surrounding Taylor. It seemed like he was softening his critiques to push back against that, which I totally relate to because as a Swiftie I sometimes catch myself doing the same thing to counteract unfair criticism. Since then, he seems to have adjusted his approach, so I’m really curious to hear how he balances giving an honest review while also pushing back against the blatant misogyny that often accompanies critical discussions of her work.

Erin

You make some good points! I wish I could reach the place you’re at with it 😩 I love this concept and would have loved to see this veneer of elegance on top of grime explored more (like the whole vanilla perfume/sweat thing). I definitely see it on Elizabeth Taylor, Father Figure, Ophelia, the title track, and even Honey (comparing a sweet term of endearment to the condescension she’s used to from industry people) but not so much the rest of the record. But I will listen again today and cook on your thoughts…

Liz

Video idea: is there a case that Eldest Daughter is the worst song she's ever written? (I think there is.) And how much would the album's problems be fixed if Eldest Daughter was of the same quality as the first 4 songs?

Jill Brockhoff

you are in love is a great expression of happiness and love that she’s written. if we were going to do “I love travis” so much on this album I was hoping to get something as well written as that…

Kat

Agreed! I think the mid song-writing quality in some (not all) of these songs are probably explained by the fact that she was on an extremely demanding mega world tour at the time. And like damn, people expected showgirl SO literally. Taylor is saying "here is an album of my personal life in-between having to be on stage". Guys.. she fell head over heels in love and is happy. I am so happy for her, and I personally really enjoy this album. I only don't like 1 song and thats OK. It's also ok for everyone else to have a different opinion on the album- dislike it fine. But for Zach to indicate that he thinks that this is showing a DECLINE in her overall artistry?! Gimme a effing break. It's not. This whole thing is not that deep

Kat

I think the mid song-writing quality in some (not all) of these songs are probably explained by the fact that she was on an extremely demanding mega world tour at the time. And like damn, people expected showgirl SO literally. Taylor is saying "here is an album of my personal life in-between having to be on stage". Guys.. she fell head over heels in love and is happy. I am so happy for her, and I personally really enjoy this album. I only don't like 1 song and thats OK. It's also ok for everyone else to have a different opinion on the album- dislike it fine. But for Zach to indicate that he thinks that this is showing a DECLINE in her overall artistry?! Gimme a effing break. It's not. This whole thing is not that deep

Ilina Jha

So sorry to hear about you and your mother receiving abuse and threats - the internet can be such a vile place :( Keep those boundaries up and keep protecting your peace, diva! 🙏

Elle Kaye

I hate that we’ve reached the point in society where a woman saying “I’m so happy I found someone to spend my life with.” Or “I want a lot of kids” is perceived as some sort of alt-right tradwifery. Like, do we want an Idiocracy? We should want intelligent, liberal people to raise part of the next generation. Taylor did a great interview yesterday about how “shockingly offensive” she finds the fan “fear” that this is her last album because she’s getting married. She also mentioned that she and Travis work in large part because they’re so career-obsessed.

Elle Kaye

She could’ve released the second coming of Folklore and the taynegativity would still make the internet say she’s cooked. They want her to rise but not reign.

Sarah

I think she very explicitly stated she only wrote these 12 songs. Is because she knew if she said she wrote more. The crazies would’ve been begging her for them

Sarah

Madeline did one

Reay

I think she needs to allow more life to happen between her albums. Bring back the 2 year album cycle. No one can keep creating at that level for this long.

Sarah

If we get debut tv we should get the rep vault as well pleek

Kim Vu

Swag I & II are amazing! Career revived

Fi

You made me laugh out loud so many times while watching this

Elle Kaye

To be fair, no romantic partner in their right mind should be ok with a song like Question…like the turkey really would not admit that they were sick lol

Jojobear

newbie to the patreon here, Swiftie since debut. after having my daughter & dealing w/ pp anxiety that was fuelled by the internet & algorithm, I came off social media a while ago (got recommended evolution of a snake on Spotify & loved it). I decided for this album release week I'd be a little bit more 'online' & man, I just really really regret it. I enjoyed the album on first listen, definitely knew it wasn't going to become a favourite like ttpd did (debut/folklore/speak now girl). But I thought it was fun & sort of... Goofy? After 12 albums, I already knew this one wasn't for me but I was happy to dance with my 3 year old to Opalite & it got me a bit excited for Christmas. I honestly now feel dumb in really loving Cancelled on first listen. Spooky, witchy & I did something bad/the man vibes is what I got. Now I've seen articles saying it's basically her telling us she's conservative? I don't know, I feel so deflated. And now to know people are sending hate comments to someone's mother.... Over a pop album? truly vile behaviour. Makes me remember exactly why I deleted all the social media apps. I thought all the interviews she did in UK were sweet & fun. I feel like social media has just made me feel sad about this album. But maybe I just don't want to believe Taylor is someone who is actually not very nice & not being truthful of who she is. Which I didn't actually hear the first time I listened to cancelled, wish list and actually romantic. But maybe I've just been too offline to know all the nuances etc.

Robin

I would love a free pop star advice for Taylor.. taking the weak points of showgirl/showgirl rollout and giving her a constructive roadmap forward. I think this album marks the end of a very structured time in her career (every 2 year album release + rerecords) and the world is her oyster now that she has her masters. Would love to hear your thoughts on where she should go from here, quieting a bit of the deranged Taylor’s career is over discourse

Hunter

I will never hate on you Zach. You're levelheaded and those obsessed gremlins are not. They can try all they want to get their rat-brained dopamine release, but the best response is none at all. At the end of the day it's not about who's winning, it's about who's happier & having more fun and well, we are.

Bianca

I’d love to hear Fantano, Madeline and you talk about the path forward in the music criticism industry. What should traditional media, content creators/critics and the public do in order to keep music criticism alive in the current “anti-criticism” climate?

B

the concept of being like “I can’t wait see what the swiftogolist has to say about this lol” and everyone in the comments agreeing like.. babe you’re literally a fan. you are an avid watcher. the fact that everyone tunes into see your reviews despite claiming to be haters. it’s the same way all of taylor’s haters have to listen to her album the second it drops. instead of just not consuming the content they claim to hate.. so odd.

tori

I have to agree Travis isn't a good muse. Like I feel like I learned absolutely nothing about their relationship (not that she owes us personal details, but she does owe us interesting songs lol) Even tho eldest daughter is horrible, the part about him being youngest and their dynamic with that was the only slightly interesting observation that maybe in a different universe could have made an interesting song

Jasmine

I really like wishlist and cancelled skfjfj

shelby

Would love to hear you talk about (with Fantano or otherwise) how Taylor likely needs an editor and her producers aren’t giving her the pushback she likely needs. I remember a 1989 era review said that album was so good because she doesn’t use any modern references or slang which makes it timeless. That makes me question her current writing and overuse of internet slang and brand mentions bc she obviously knows the importance of transcending contemporary references.

Emma Wells

People are messaging your MOTHER over an ALBUM REVIEW ?! What has fandom even become???

Abbie Elliott

I agree. She has clunky weird lyrics in almost every album she puts out! Its not that serious in my eyes.

Kat

I can't wait until Taylor writes a lyrically masterful album when she's not writing simultaneously with a demanding world tour, addressing all of the hate she and this project is getting to show that she isn't declining. Zach will then be happy, and I want Zach to be happy!

Hattie

Loved the casual catch up! I'm so sorry about the hate you and your Mother (!?!) are getting, people.are.crazy. No one is doing it like you guys, thank you for always keeping it honest, its sooo refreshing. Love that this feels like a safe space for you too, as it does us patrons <3

Maria Chavez

I feel like if people didn’t like Mans Best Friends, and A LOT of people didn’t, they are not going to like Life of a Showgirl. You can put both into one playlist and it sounds like one big anthology

Kat

My question exactly!! It wasn't called "On STAGE with a Showgirl" lol 🤣

Kat

Snaps for you and this reply 👏🏻✨💕

Fi

If she used current slang instead of bad bitch / savage, the song would still be just as bad I fear 🥲 I’m stunned that this one made it on the album…

Sarah

zayn has depression and is a man of color. the rest is not talented enough to rival the momentum of what 1d was. there done!

Pamela F

I can’t believe she didn’t use the Eras tour as a muse AT ALL. Anything about her life on the road? Any heartfelt or funny moments with her dancers and team or Mom or Travis backstage?? Any notable crowd interactions? Any musings on what the emotions of recovery were like the day after a show or even what it felt like to be done???? I was so confident about this album bc of the way she COOKED on Clara Bow, I thought she had a lot to say about the life of a show girl 😭 I don’t dislike the album, I really like 8 songs, but the showgirl concept was juicy as hell and it’s like she didn’t explore it at all. I was excited to hear about her feelings for the Eras tour.

Alexa Laine

would LOVE a video breaking down Father Figure (ESP! from your perspective that it’s about Joe Alwyn cuzzz that’s what I thought (and kind of still think) as well and i felt so validated when you said the same thing)

Dainty Donna

I mentioned this in Madeline’s reaction but here’s my take. Even tho I am of the age where the first TS song I remember hearing was “Teardrops on my Guitar” in my girlie friend’s basement in 2006, I never really did a deep dive or anything. I actually discovered most of her discography on this channel because I just LOVE you and Madeline’s takes when it comes to all things Tay and pop culture and THAT is the #1 reason why I am here regardless on if we agree/disagree. I am on the path to salvation, but I am not nor have I ever been a fully converted/“true” Swiftie. That being said, I think my sense of removal from her persona/discography actually allowed me to enjoy most of (maybe 7-9/12 tracks) the album and it’s crack-like earworm effect. A lot of my friends who are either casual fans or “self-proclaimed” swifties (but imo they don’t really care about music/culture in general in the same way that I do-it’s not that deep to them. Music is for vibes/background mostly) enjoyed the album with really not much to say. I have yet to talk to my sister on her thoughts however and she is a DEVOUTLY devoted Swiftie and I’m very curious on her thoughts (like she regularly listens to all 31 tracks of TTPD) TL;DR, I find the contrast in our experience on the album very interesting as there appears to be a correlation between levels of devotion to Taylor and the reaction/response to TLOASG. I’m so curious to keep learning more/hearing more perspectives! 🫶

Jasmine

Ask him about his Halsey review and why he was very dismissive of her cancer

Alexa Laine

Plus, 2 video suggestions!! 1) Ranking all of Taylor’s music videos (and perhaps fixing some of them?) and/or a critical discussion on Taylor as a director, especially since she’s got that movie coming out at some point 2) Sister Song rankings! Specifically for the songs that cover almost exactly the same material as others. I.e. mirrorball and eldest daughter RE: “i’m trying to be cool but i’m not” or maybe the “i am so in loveee” songs like you discussed here

Alexa Laine

Yes, this!!! And maybe if there were any songs of TLOAS that you think fit the vibe, you can keep them, but otherwise need to fill the album with older songs. (I did this in my own free time and would LOVE to your guys’ thoughts) 🧡🧡🧡

Krie

I have a question about the online talk about sampling and credits and I don’t have enough knowledge to have an opinion. Everyone saying there are obvious samples in the music that are not credited. But I think there is no possible way she or her team would make a mistake like that

Abby

It's personally unrelatable to me and a bit cringe, but I don't see how it gives tradwife - wanting kids that look like your partner is a normal thing to say

Coniferous

I would love for you to ask Anthony what he finds to be his perfect pop song. What does he want to get out of pop music, that he can’t get anywhere else?

Dev M

for me the sadder part would be that if this album actually is on theme it says a lot about who she is lmao, you're a part of the biggest tour in the world and also at the highest of your career (when you've never been sure it's gonna last this long in pervious albums and have a crippling fear of being forgotten) and all you've been thinking of is Travis? like girl bffr if that is actually the case then I can't defend her she explored it a little bit in some of the songs but never fully committed to the theme it would have been different if there were more songs on side B of the album that included wish list, honey etc but also explored the actual theme - but with only 12 songs and her claiming that they all fit together like puzzle pieces it would actually be very sad if these songs are the only thing she has to say

krissy

I’m curious for people like Fantano what tracks stand out to them on first listen and how much he listens to the whole album, just once? It always takes me -a dedicated swiftie like 3-4 listens to absorb it all and give an opinion. I was Madeline on first listen, if anyone was around me I would have felt on smack cam but now I’m bopping around having fun with it. Taylor albums are journeys more than most artists lol

sara

my friend sent me a tiktok edit of M*rgan W*llen with Cancelled as the audio..........

Lynn

Thank you Jesus Allah Mohammad is KILLING me.

Alexa Laine

Open the case! I’ve really started to notice Taylor repeating her own melodies in these last few albums. We’ve got Wi$h Li$t and Glitch (and the verses kind of sound like the Man, especially from that Miss Americana clip where she’s writing it with Joel), plus the chorus of Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me? is EXACTLY the same as the verses from You Belong With Me…

Rebecca Robbins

I have to say, as someone who went through a string of toxic, unhealthy, avoidant men to the point where I was singing my own version of The Prophecy, when I met my husband, and we had a healthy, easy relationship it felt even more euphoric than it would’ve otherwise. In the recovery space, there’s a concept called “the pink cloud” and it describes the feeling people get in early sobriety where food tastes better, colors are brighter, jokes are funnier, and you’re just experiencing your senses fully for the first time in a long long time. This is what it’s like to find a healthy love after being decimated by toxic relationships. Taylor is in her pink cloud phase right now, so I’m gonna let her live. The album is definitely mid for her, but, for me, if you can just listen to it brain off and take it for what it is on the surface , it’s quite fun. She also wrote all of it before Trump was even elected so I think some grace needs to be given in that respect. I think she needs some time off. She said on Graham Norton that she used making this album as a way to help energize herself enough to get through the last leg of the Eras tour. I think she was creating this on empty and that’s what we’re feeling paired with a mismatch expectation between the description prior to release and the reality of the music. It’ll all be fine children. Deep breaths 😉❤️

kc

so glad we agree this is the best taylor-directed mv

kc

i think a video about where solo careers go wrong vs right in boyband and girl groups would be everything

Ro2207

Absolutely this. A common accusation being thrown around is "you just don't want Taylor to be happy and only like her when she's writing sad songs." But as someone who is feeling disappointed in this album (for a myriad of reasons), my issue is not at all in the fact that she is writing about being happily in love. So many of Taylor's great songs are about falling in love and being in love. Some have conflict and anxiety built into the feeling of falling in love (common on rep/Lover etc). But there are plenty of songs that are lighter and joyous. Off the very top of my head, I am immediately thinking about songs like Fearless, Sparks Fly, Enchanted, State of Grace etc. For me, what I find missing on TLOAS is the specificity and storytelling of falling and being in love. I would happily lap up an entire album of joyous love songs, but for some reason there is just a superficiality and distance to the way she writes the love story of TLOAS that doesn't quite work for me. She is so often inspired by the act of falling in love but the writing doesn't seem to capture that feeling in a way other songs have done in the past.

Jasmine

I just read 'When you are happy you are kinda dumb, because you're happy! And that's Taylor right now' 😄

Jemsss

I would love to hear you talk more about Taylor sounding so bitter and even pretentious on this album. Obsessed with the haters, internet trolls, calling people bitches... I don't get the vibe that she's super happy and carefree.

Marissa

I just want to say: thank you Zach, this space has been so great to have in these confusing Swiftie times.

kc

⏰

Abby

What’s so annoying is I posted about how I do not like this album and now all the people are coming out of the woodworks, sending me these deranged think piece TikToks like … just because I’m not hand hearting for this album does NOT mean I am one of you!! Get awayyy

Abby

Based on things she said lately, I think she now no longer wants to overthink things and second guess herself creatively, which on the one hand is great and must feel very liberating - however, there is a balance to be had and I fear the lows on Showgirl may demonstrate the downsides of that approach...

James Meyer

People contacting your mother is beyond unhinged, what do they even expect to win? Toddlers shouldn't have access to the Internet.

TiKiToPia 🙂

Q. "What topics would you like to be touched on?" A. POP Divas from Sweeden -Tove Lo (i.e, her artistry) / Robyn (i.e. career rise and....fall?) Good / Bad idea?

Karibunt

I KNEW YOU WOULD LIKE IT

Katie

Almost every song on this album (especially the Im in love songs) feels like it’s has a better counterpart in Taylor’s catalog. It feels like she wrote LoverGirl

Joan Rood

Zach, I’m new to Patreon but not new to your content on other platforms. Your analysis has allowed me to analyze Taylor’s work with a more critical eye, even though I tend to like different songs in Taylor’s discography than you do. We can’t get balanced, reasoned assessments of Taylor’s work from anyone else besides you and Madeline.

Hilde

You and especially your mom Never should get any hateful messages let alone abuse over album reviews holy shit. I am with you on so many points, not on every tho. Love your thoughts anyways. Eldest daughter is not my fav, it’s about her speaking to the fans I think. Cancelled to me is so great as a hymne for women unfairly written off. Also I think sonically it’s a banger. But I also think father figure is the best written songs on the record it’s so great, the perspective shift (Scott to her) is brilliant. And I loveeeeeee fate of Ophelia 💕 that one was great. Life of a showgirl is great, too.

elly belly

she sounds very much bitter tbh

Rachel

I do feel relieved that we know this album was rushed and during an intense tour. Im hoping she takes the constructive criticism on her lyrics and spends time cooking her next album and brings in collaborators.

Katie

Her loves songs are falling due to Disney Princess syndrome. “I’m just in love and I am not yet explaining why!!”

ashton

Zach I think when you do the video talking about all of the songs and critiquing, you should pick out a song from a previous album that is similar and explain why you think one works and one doesn’t. I think that would be a really interesting way to go about it and provide context (like the Lover vs TLOAS video you mentioned)

Susu

After a while I would love a new deep-dive to Max Martin versus Jack Antonoff, because many of the critiques of this album have also been directed to Max Martin - some reviews say that the production is a little general (and imo it sounds like Jack Antonoff sometimes XD) so I would be really interested in hearing more thoughts of the production of the life of a showgirl!

Jane

Hi! I just wanted to say I really love your content and thank you for making it!! I’ve learned a lot from you since I found you on YouTube a few months ago and I’m really grateful!

Katie

CANCELLED! very original tho i fear. Sounds crazy and is SO showgirl

ashton

This comment made me so sad! Don’t feel bad or discouraged for liking it and having fun! A lot of the discourse is DERANGED. Like these people are mentally ill. And regardless, you are not a bad person for liking something!

Katie

She can have golden retriever or tiny chiauaua but not both!!

Tyler Drake

First off, the amount of derangement that other people have, and the audacity that they have to go after your mother is absolutely insane. Second off, I completely agree with you, on the first listen of showgirl, I really didn't like it because it's all just "I love you Travis" which is fine, but it can only get you so far. But I've been able to kind of get past that and revel in the astounding production (mouth kissy Max Martin) and just kind of ignore the shallow lyrics, except for the obvious ones like Father Figure, etc. I had high expectations because Taylor set them up for showgirl and we were fed but only for a handful of songs that don't even really fit the concept at all. I know this won't be the end of her career, but if this is the material that we're getting, I'm gonna be a little concerned for the next era. Unless she just throws this shit out of the window and gives us another folklore/evermore, which would be the gag of the century.

Katie

She’s screwed up because she had the Showgirls show up in their feathers and then she served to the LoverGirls too

Elle Kaye

Zach, I know you’ve touched on this before, but I’d be interested in a deep dive on the importance of limitations in creativity/art. As receptive as Taylor is to criticism, she has unlimited money and no one to really tell her no because they’re a friend or an executive who knows whatever she does will sell. There are so many issues with how the industry and labels work, but now she has total creative freedom — is that a good thing?

Katie

Normani yes!

Bree

I think the way she’s talking/slang she’s using on this album she has picked up from Travis. I think the haters take everything way too far and Joe definitely did not write Folklore or anything, but I think there is a little grain of truth to her picking up things from the people in her life (as we all do) and I think she way she talks/writes is affected a little. There may have also been a little bit of her trying (maybe subconsciously) to write in a more sophisticated way when she was with Joe. I’m curious to hear what you think about this, or if you think I’m being a hater too lol.

Katie

A Charlie deep dive with actually romantic and father figure

André Dinis

Enjoy the wedding! That seems so so fun!

James

I think my main kind of issue with the album is that I always saw her as an albums artist and even 1989 has a theme the songs tells stories and not every song has to but as you said it just seems shallow like life of a showgirl is such an interesting theme that just isnt on the album it just feels liks a collection of songs she liked. I am defo warming up to it and like a lot of the songs but im still dissapointed about the theming. Also feel like the production and vocals could have been more dramataic if its only 12 songs like were are the gag moments.

Abby

This is where I am at, and my opinion changes all the time. Even though the writing is not where I would like it to be, I am going to take it for what it. There are more songs that I love or like than skips. Like the lyrics on wood, gives me the ick but I really like the production. I agree that on the 12 song record if you don’t like 3 or 4 of the songs that’s not good.

elly belly

I agree it rubs me the wrong way

Krista Dabel

Ok, serious question, what if all the cringey outdated slang lyrics went away, would this be a great album? I want my poet pop queen, where is she?

Wilson

lol I literally starting playing this at work thinking it was in my headphones but I accidentally blasted “Heyy Divas” across the office 😂🫶🏻

Jadz

My unpopular opinion is I actually do think this record is brilliant! It has her best vocals ever and the instrumental production is incredible. I also think she successfully writes from the perspective different characters (each are exaggerations of herself) on father figure, cancelled, and Elizabeth Taylor. I do agree that eldest daughter and wish list are poor writing. If she'd have replaced those with ACTUAL backstage showgirl songs (like Mirrorball or lucky one or down bad), then this would be top 3 albums for me. Great writing, great production!

Andreja

Comment about taking her 5 biz dayss to learn the choreo made me laugh! As a dancer I’m so happy how she dances in this video! She has gotten really good! 🥰

Janelle

One thing she said during the bts movie when she wrote Ophelia she was scrolling through her notes app of song ideas and how she just liked how the word Ophelia fit together with the melody. And that’s a bit how some of the album felt, forced together out of convience than an actually fully executed idea that needed to be expressed. to me that showed she wasn’t feeling inspired and put this out to prove to her everyone (mainly her exes prob but also haters) like guess what I’m hot and happy now. I’m happy for her too but I highly doubt she’ll do this again, this feels like a one time flex album.

Carroll

I don’t understand why people feel the need to be nasty on the internet. Do I agree with every take of yours? No. But I enjoy your work regardless.

shedaris

Honestly I kinda wish she takes a breather. It feels like she's been living like a hamster in a turning wheel. Hence sometimes questionable or rushed creative decisions. She's always been reactive, but now the cycle of "work -> feedback-> reaccess-> work" has a shorter run through time, so the responses have become sporadic. Due to her brilliance her best work still shines through, but not as consistently. I think that having some time "off", as in not chasing the next career goal would only do her good. The time away doesn't have to be long either, but if it's relatively free of career brain activity, she'll reset

PK

Justin Timberlake for HTMYC!

HaleyJean ASMR

this video is TAKING IT! only second to LWYMMD in my mind ⭐️✨📣

Claire

My take on TLOASG that I think you could address (I really like the album but I agree it’s not her best): Taylor had her own record to beat and she did everything she could to get there. It worked. She knows the songs weren’t as good as before so she put all her effort on the videos/packaging/interviews to compensate and generate hype for all of us to buy it. In the end, she has a product to sell us… She’ll use every tactic in the book to do that and break her own records. Moreover, she has a schedule to follow and probably had to put out something this year to stay relevant after her « hiatus ». I think this is a good transition record - a palate cleaner as you said… We just got scammed on the quality of it just so she could make sure she could hit that next target she had set for herself. Numbers matter to her… maybe more than the quality right now…

Kelsee Cat

She shouldn't have called it the life of a showgirl. I think the album would have been better if she named it the fate of Ophelia tbh or something else

noah

Any thoughts on Taylor saying in the BBC Radio 2 interview that 'still no one knows what she's even talking about on the black dog', and that 'they think they do know but they don't have any idea' ????

Ariel

Maybe this isn't relevant anymore, but would you consider cooking on the writing in Ruin the Friendship vs Old Phone in terms of writing about "dead friends"?

Meeeeeg

The melody of Wood is catchy and fun and I love the first verse a part chorus. Maybe I’ll just have to listen to half the song haha

Tyler

Murder your career video should be on avril lavignes recent albums. Biggest fan of her but tbh the quality dropped and the streams show

Christopher Marshburn

I honestly loved the album and it’s growing on me more and more with every listen. But the first 4 tracks could have been an amazing EP on its own with “The Life of a Showgirl” as a bonus track. This music video though. If it doesn’t win Video of the Year something is seriously wrong. Although I’m anticipating another potential contender featuring both Taylor and Sabrina.

Meeeeeg

How to murder your career - Justin timberlake

Paula C

I’m telling you, the marketing was TOO good, the reach TOO far. It made its way to random people that now feel like they’ve been attacked by the album’s existence and feel the need to have an opinion. Like, bye lol

Mandy ✨

Love this reaction! So sorry you are getting such disgusting messages, but it's hilarious how you live rent free in their minds.

Kylee

Once that red wig made an appearance, I completely blacked out watching it in the theater. And then anytime I would come to, she would throw shit at me like Wildest Dreams Taylor in an outfit made of ropes. It was almost too cinematic for me to handle in that moment. I lost my swiftie shit. 😭

Grete

Same here! Has she really said everything she wants to say about the Eras tour? Will we hear about it in the future/is it something that takes time to sink in and reflect on? Or did it really not inspire more songs...

Lauren

I've been a silent watcher for a while and I always look forward to your nuanced takes and analyses of Taylor and other artists. It's helped me articulate my own opinions on music and art. But I don't think Tiktok is conducive to the kind of conversation you are aiming to encourage. That is where most of the hate and vitriol seems to be concentrated, because it's easier to take short clips out of context and Tiktok encourages short attention spans. It may make sense to maybe cut down on what you post to Tiktok, and instead use clips that encourage people to check out your Youtube channel more often! Or maybe a short voiceover review that points to a written review? That's just my two cents tho!

marissa x

yeah it just feels really unnatural and unnecessary; the clean version where she says “chick” in honey is muuuch better

14sipsoftea

Can I just say I so appreciate how much content yall put out and how quality it is? I really feel like I got what I paid for and then some! Your hard work is excellent

Marilyn

Best video I’ve ever seen of hers. One of the best videos I’ve ever seen period.

Lauren

Also I'm sorry to hear about all the abuse you're getting. Please take a breather if you need one!

Cadee

I’m new to the Patreon and I’m so happy to be here! I also found the calling of other women “bitches” confusing. I really like the clean version of the title track because she changes it to “witches.” I feel like “witches” is a better lyric because it adds to the other women’s description. It makes them seem more ethereal and calculated. Plus it captures the idea that they’re out to get her in a less demeaning/dismissive way because the idea of a witch is a woman who has powers rather than “they’re just mean”

Hila’s safe space

but i think that she isnt tryimg to be deep and serious, also i think its fitting that she has less dount in her relationship with trav as she feel secure in it in comparison to with joe when she never realy felt secure even from the start. So i dont take this album so seriously and just vibe to it cause if i want something deep i have so much like TTPD, folklore which arent even old, so i really listen to this album more with the intent of boping along. Like she just released my favorite song of all time I Hate It Here. its really helps. Also people are really crazy out there that is absolutly crossing the line.

Christopher Marshburn

I agree with you about the concerns for Taylor’s creative artistry. This might be the very first Taylor album sans anxiety. I almost feel like this album could be seen as a victory lap for winning the pop music Olympics and it’s time to take a break and shift genres. For a 36 year old Taylor with a family a full circle return to Country makes perfect sense, and Debut TV could be the springboard.

Niamh

Im an eldest daughter and middle child and the song is unclear and stupid

LWales97

I want to share my perspective on why people shouldn’t rush to judge Travis or label this relationship as “bad news” for Taylor. We’ve all witnessed how complex Taylor’s relationship with love has always been — not just in her personal life, but in the way she’s processed it through her art. For years, her understanding of love has been shaped by a blend of romantic idealism, emotional self-protection, and the lessons she’s learned from being constantly seen and analyzed. She’s had her own vision of what love should look like, the kind of man she believed she deserved, and what she thought it meant to be loved the “right” way. But now, her life seems to have shifted in a major, almost transformative way. She appears to be in a stage where she’s choosing peace and stability over chaos and mystery — choosing a person who, from all we can see, treats her with genuine care, respect, and lightness. And I think that kind of change — especially for someone who has built an entire emotional universe around the idea of love — doesn’t just happen overnight. It reshapes everything. To me, it feels like her entire belief system about love, partnership, and even her own emotional identity is quietly reforming. It’s not just that her views are changing — it’s more like she’s rewriting the foundation from which she’s always written and lived. This relationship seems to mark the beginning of a new emotional era for her, one where she’s not trying to decode pain or heartbreak, but to understand what peace, safety, and joy can mean to her. And because of that, I think her songwriting — which has always been the mirror of her internal world — will take time to catch up. She’s in the process of discovering a new emotional language, one that fits the woman she’s becoming. Finding the right words, metaphors, and emotions that meet her own standard of honesty and artistic depth will naturally take time. So instead of deciding too early that this relationship isn’t “good news,” maybe we should give her the space to grow into this new version of herself — both as a person and as an artist. Great art doesn’t always come from heartbreak; sometimes it’s born out of peace, clarity, and rediscovery. And that’s the chapter I think Taylor is beginning to write now.

bubb

It felt legit & substantial with Joe, though. His D was making her forget exes names, and didn’t “have to save” her. This feels almost numb & disconnected.

Kelsee Cat

Ashley Simpson, Christina Aguilar, Sia, normani, Fergie.....those are all really good suggestions for the "Murder your career" video!

Erin Howell

As someone that has watched Anthony’s reviews for many years, he definitely listens to the album multiple times through and really sits with it before making a review! He definitely has his biases, but he does give every project a fair shake!

Lana

One of her best music videos since cardigan imo

CHRIS 01 🪽 #HOUSEWIFE

how to murder your career: zara larsson PLEAASSSE, my question to him is what is your stance on everyone reviewing an album the second it comes out and people saying thats cruel and unusual today.

Maria

I think the influence that her relationship with Joe might have had is just the art that they would consume together; movies they would watch, music they listened to, also her reading and just talking to someone who's more educated maybe? Travis and his friends probably use a more basic vocabulary (bitch, fire, etc..) and they probably just listen to bad music together and she's Baking instead of reading lol so the inspiration just isn't there like during Folklore/evermore

R

I looooved the music video and all of the call backs to classic films and the pre-raphaelites. I was unpleasantly shocked on the first couple of listens but now that I know that it is deeply unserious I’m rocking with about 1/2of the album. Even if it’s reductive. Just hoping for Folklore 2.0 next. I also think she needs to take an extended writing break and experience some more things to have something fresh to pull from.

Marilyn

One thing I wish someone would talk about - she said she wrote this late summer/early Fall 2024 - that was the height of ppl thinking she and Travis were in a fake relationship - how did that impact her writing? Like feeling she had to prove they were real?

stolitzsilas

I think the hard part is if you compare it to the bar Taylor set, it's disappointing. If you compare it to what else is out there (this year) and/or just bopping along and vibing, it's fun!

Elle Kaye

There are dozens of us 🫶🏻 (JK there’s millions of us, just not on TikTok)

Marilyn

I went to the movie - the clean version is so much less cringy and more palatable

Niamh

For fantano: does he have any history with production/writing? His favourite pop star ever? what does the pop star do for him that Taylor doesn't? I know he loves Kendrick and that's it

stolitzsilas

oof this is such a good point. Everything is so pretty but it could have been better :( And also, why did Martin and Shellback co-sign this?

Elle Kaye

The vocals really are not getting the flowers they deserve. She’s been dogged on that her whole career, but when she improves, they’re silent.

Lilly

The Normani video idea is very interesting and id love to hear you speak on it in depth

Will

The lover/life of a showgirl comparison would be superrr interesting. Maybe to put in the fixing the rollout vid you could "fix" the album, keeping the good songs and name other songs you think could've fit the vibe of the better from previous albums

Elle Kaye

“Attacked by the album’s existence” is brilliant

elly belly

everything you said 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

Laurahogan

I love that you touched on this idea that the critics are so loud because she has been so prolific and there is so much to compare TLOAS to. I love the bops and am having fun dancing around my house listening to it over and over again. I also personally don’t need to be a critic - that’s why I listen to swiftologist - because he will provide needed context, critical voice and a dash of swiftie love.

ProvoloneWanderer

People saying JT for HTMYC - I would love to start at “wardrobe malfunction “ and look at both JT and JJ

Josey Hotchkiss

I think she felt energized to make an album but had no real thoughts to explore, even on the title track she went into no detail about what is bad about being a showgirl, just that it is. It feels like the conclusion to a different album where those themes were actually explored.

Nicole Russell

Did anyone hear the popcast review of TLOAS? I thought they talked about it like normal people lol

Cassidy Valenzuela

Can you discuss how Taylor Swift’s age might be affecting the perception of this album? I’ve seen people critique how she’s STILL writing about high school as a 35 year old woman. Would the album have been perceived better if she was in her early or mid 20s?

Laurahogan

Wait this is THE take - no notes 🔥

Jack 's weekly music reviews

Being a swiftie and especially being a taycharli right now shows me how bad stan culture is. Like you have people saying she's a republican for getting engaged (literal tiktok btw) and then swifties saying you're a trumpie if you disagree with her (literal tweet i saw) it's just horrible.

Sharanya Sharma

Hi! Loved your content a long time & always appreciate your takes even when we disagree. 1) saying horrible things to you & going after YOUR MOTHER is deeply horrible behavior, I’m so sorry. 2) I loved this album from first listen and with each subsequent listen I appreciate it more for what it is — a fun pop moment that allows me to put down my existential crisis for 2.5 seconds so I can dance in my living room. I’m clapping and cheering! I do think 90% of your critique on the album is totally fair though, and I completely, 100% agree with you about Wi$h Li$t & Wood 💀. I disagree with you on Eldest Daughter and CANCELLED, which are currently two of my favorites. 3) as a Desi can confirm that South Asian weddings are THE BEST!! I hope you have an awesome time. Thank you for your thoughtful takes!

HaleyJean ASMR

we NEED a charli x taylor timeline deep dive !!!

Sara Sweet

Something I’ve thought about as well!

Rachel

You’re right that this album has the worst parts of TTPD writing. And the thing about TTPD is that the types of directly candid or blunt or messy lyrics worked a lot of the time because that was the point. The album was designed to be a complete cracking open of Taylor’s inner thoughts, wants, and fears. It fit and it made sense, and she still wrote a huge majority of that album in a way that felt true to her as an artist. This album feels like it’s swamped with “Charli Puth should be a bigger artist” type lyrics and hype beast slang.

Jack 's weekly music reviews

I think with TLOAS she really overhyped it. The concept of the album in the way she talked about it and the artwork for this album really promised something different. I think it almost promised lover but better in the way that songs like DBATC and SYGB were focusing on things outside of her relationship like you said. This just isn't that.

Sara Sweet

Dare I say there’s some interesting camera work and directorial choices………

Marilyn

YES - I think if it was “Fate of Ophelia” you could actually connect a theme most of the way through

SwiftySteph

I really love this album. It’s fun, I didn’t feel like I was emotionally abused and need therapy after. I looooooved TTPD do not get me wrong here. But I take her albums as where she is in life. When she wrote this she had just come off the crazy emotional roller coaster from breaking up with Joe, the Rat and just all the energy being focused on the Eras Tour and then dishing us out TTPD. It was like we were her therapist and she just word vomited everything to us. Then entered Travis and her whole word changed and she gave us TLOAS. She is in her cringy I love Travis Era and it ok and wouldn’t expect anything less. Is this her best work, nope, but still loving it anyway.

Tammy Sawyer

I do think when she wrote these albums affected the quality. When she was writing Lover, she had all the time in the world. She wrote Life of a Showgirl, while on tour. (Exhaustion and time between shows probably had an influence.)

Almudena

Fergie is an amazing option for a How to Murder your Career video!

Nicole Russell

Yeah I agree with this. I think the tour exhaustion combined with the euphoria of a new relationship led to the more “shallow” songs on this record. I am enjoying it for what it is right now knowing full well Taylor will deliver us more depth in the future. I think Zach is on to something when he says it’s a palate cleanser album from tortured poets

André Dinis

I have some video ideias: I would love for you guys to do a whole video about new generation artists that people should actually pay attention to. Like Audrey Hobert for example. Artists that not only are new, but are also more interesting than other more famous one's that are not that innovative in your guys's perspective. You can also include artists from this new gen that you think are actually relevant (Billie, Olivia, or wtv you actually believe in). Also, in this same generations theme, I would love fro you and Madeline to do a whole video/series about the different Pop generations – from madonna, to britney, to taylor, to billie or wtv. Explain the differences between does, who do you think influenced the others, who is in the same artistic lane or occupies the same space in the culture (like Olivia/Billie and Avril for example). Hope you like the suggestions!

Nicole Russell

Yeah I agree with this. I think the tour exhaustion combined with the euphoria of a new relationship led to the more “shallow” songs on this record. I am enjoying it for what it is right now knowing full well Taylor will deliver us more depth in the future. I think Zach is on to something when he says it’s a palate cleanser album from tortured poets

amandasoul

the zara comment section part 🤣🤣👏👏👏

Simply Miraculous

a video deep dive on Justin Bieber would be interesting!

Tiffany Grace

I think there’s something to be said about the rushed nature of how the album was created. She was writing/recording on her days off from an already mentally and physically exhausting tour… that’s not a great foundation to create greatness. I’d also be curious to learn how far apart she wrote TTPD and Showgirl. If it’s much later in the tour, exhaustion definitely would have played a role. I almost think she’s so proud of this album because she was able to accomplish it despite her exhaustion and if that’s coloring her belief that the work itself is actually excellent. I will say - it’s definitely not her best writing… but it is SUPER catchy. The more I listen the more I love it for fun vibey background music that puts me in a good mood.

Kb8248

Zach, Joe/Travis love song comparison video is interesting. Angst and anxiety vs health and nurturing (based on lyrics and Taylor’s own description of how Travis makes her feel).

bug

I saw this take elsewhere but I think it’s so important to remember (especially when criticizing the decline of her artistry) that she recorded this album during the most demanding tour of her life, while coming up with 2 new surprise song mashups for each night. Of course it wasn’t going to be her best work!

Helen ✨

I’m so happy I joined this Patreon 🫶🏻

j.bean

Then why did she choose to release it so soon since she usually holds her music to an exacting standard

splendidvie

This is going to ruin the tour

Tiffany Grace

Also- I’m so sorry people are being demented and awful to you and your family. You’re a human being - a thoughtful and intelligent person and you don’t deserve to be treated the way you are. People can be awful. I’m sorry this has been happening to you. 💔 You are loved and respected by far more people than you realize. The clowns are always just the loudest.

Rachel

Last night I was thinking about this album and realized something. In all other albums, she has almost always approached subjects with some amount of class. Any discussion of intimacy was always done with discreet detail that made it feel truly sexy and mysterious (Scratches down your back, carve your name into my bedpost, his hands are in my hair his clothes are in my room). Any ill feelings she had toward someone, she relied on strong songwriting to call them out on what they did, not just calling them cheap insults. This is the first album where she sounds uncomfortably un-classy on most of the songs. Even in a song like Honey, which I love, she didn’t have to use the term “bitch.” It’s that type of thing that’s like… who is this? It just doesn’t even feel like her sometimes.

Vicky

I agree with most of the things you said about her writing on this album it's really not great but if I'm being honest with myself I don't really care because the songs are so addictive. I always felt like Taylor's writing was for me the most important when I listen to her songs but idk with this album it's different I just love the vibes so much that at this point i don't even care if the concept is lacking, maybe that's stupid but it's just how I feel.

Hope

Video idea: Making a new TLOAS 12-track album using existing Taylor songs... So what songs in Taylor's catalog do you think would make a more compelling album based on the "life behind the curtain" premise? Which tracks would you place where?

froot encore

i’m saying we will all be looking back on this album in a different light especially after we get more mvs

Rachel

That’s such a good point. The title track feels like it’s supposed to wrap up a story about the trials and tribulations of a showgirl, but then we heard next to nothing about that.

Nathan Prescott

It’s me, hi, I’m the eldest daughter shooter.

Riya

I got the Marilyn Monroe and Ethel Merman references (I have no idea if y’all are too young to get the Merman one) but is there someone specific she’s referencing in the scene where she is on the boat?

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

I'm starting to love this album more and more once I dig a bit more into the lyrics (even the small amount there is). It's a grower! 🪭

Syd

I am always HAND HEART with the Swiftologist! 🫶🏻 Zach these haters coming after you so viciously need help… can’t decide if I pray for their downfall or for therapy… 💀

M Dav

I recommend you watch her interview with BBC Radio 2. She addresses the whole retiring, taking and break, and marriage thing. It’s hard to properly evaluate life of a show girl as its own self contained work because her discography is so prolific and I can’t help but compare it to everything before it. I think I hold Taylor to a higher standard than I would say, Sabrina. Imo tloas has fewer duds than man’s best friend, but I’m still more critical of tloas, which I think is probably unfair of me. I can’t help it though when I’ve been a fan since 2008. I do want to say that I don’t know if it’s entirely fair to compare the quality of Joe and Travis as muses when Travis has like, six or seven songs under his belt and Joe has multiple albums that include “hits” such as ME!, New Year’s Day, and Endgame. I’ll wait a for a bit more content before I try and evaluate them as muses. I still get what you mean though, of the 6 or 7 songs we have, about half are a bit shallow save for the first three tloas tracks, which I think are quite good.

Kisha

If you’re doing a HTMYC video…can you do a pop boy? I love it when you cook pop boys 😂

Nayelis Morales

I want to touch on the fact Travis isn’t a good muse, but I was dissecting some of the lyrics about him on TTPD and TLOAS and honestly………… He might not be AS compelling as J*e in terms of “muse”, but considering how different and dare I say difficult her relationship with the turkey was, I think those complicated feelings of deep intense love and insecurity overall inspire DEEPER songs, because being deeply in love and also feeling instability at the same in a relationship is more INTERESTING. HOWEVER. Travis is not a bad muse. When you really dissect the lyrics about Travis, what I see personally, as a person that values a true healthy relationship, is… finding someone that is so in awe and appreciative of you, finding your Prince Charming, being scared but feeling hopeful. There are some really deep, introspective lyrics about their relationship and I think you kindaaaa have to be a Tayvis Stan for a moment to really put yourself in that headspace and understand what she is writing about and what she is saying, truly. She hasn’t written songs this hopeful and fairytale-like since Fearless. He’s taking her hand and dragging her head first, fearless.

Alyssa

Taylor has a track record of responding to constructive criticism well. However, I’m nervous with this one. She confidently said before release that this is one of the favorite things she’s ever done and doesn’t care with people think…I hope she doesn’t shut out any criticisms here because she’s standing on extremely thin ice now. I fear she has too many yes men in her circle.

Kisha

I think a really interesting video idea would be “Anatomy of a Main Pop Girl” - what separates the Main Pop Girl (ie. MPG) from B and C-tier pop girls? What does it take to be an MPG? How does one go from being a lower-tier pop girl to an MPG, and who has successfully made the transition (eg. Sabrina)? How can you backslide from MPG status to lower tier, and who is an example of this (eg. Katy)? When should an artist not aspire to be an MPG, and instead just thrive in their niche? Who should step out of their niche and try to go for the MPG tier? As social tastes change through time, how does one maintain their place in the MPG tier (eg. how has Taylor managed to do so for 20 years)? And finally…what is it that pop girls in general, from MPGs to lower tiers, are doing that pop boys just aren’t right now? Why are pop girls taking over the music industry right now but pop boys just aren’t, apart from legacy acts like Bieber?

Rose

I’m so sorry for the abuse you are facing Zach. The work that you do is important especially in this moment in pop culture when media literacy and nuance are being targeted. I hope you know that there’s so many people that appreciate your work and who you are as a person. The work that you and Madeline do always puts a smile on my face, makes me laugh, and most importantly makes me think deeply about the art that I’m consuming. Stay strong and don’t let the bastards get you down.

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Ruin the friendship is one of Taylor's best songs ever. Full stop. It's on my "Lying in bed rotting" playlist, but it's really great.

Aline Tschopp

sorry this is happening to your mother, unacceptable behavoir.

sam

its the same thing that happened to taylor swift people love to hate but stay turned in because they want to see what she’ll do

Sara Sweet

For Fantano: how does he feel about his fan base and their general misogyny and harsher criticisms of female artists? I’ve seen him tell the chat to calm down etc. so I wonder if he has become mindful of how he engages with female artists to discourage misogyny

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

People saying Joe was writing for her have not done their homework 🫩

Cameron Van Sant

Three thoughts: - Thank you Zach for the content and best of luck out there in these mean streets! - I wonder if Max Martin's high rate per song and her desire to work with only him (which, to be fair to her, is what we the people wanted) is part of why this tracklist has so many duds. Obviously she has the cash but I'm sure after doing 12 songs inbetween Eras Tour shows, I wouldn't be surprised if she's like... do I have to spend another $100,000... (or whatever it it is now) - I would love the Normani video and the history of Charli and Taylor video!

Syd

Zach I second an earlier comment that I’d love to see you and Madeline go through the Charli / Taylor timeline.

Lisa

Your reaction made me laugh out loud! Every time you post, I. am. seated!!!

Lauren B

I agree but it's interesting because I feel like the writing was so much stronger on TTPD which was also written and recorded on tour. In that case though she really was writing out of necessity from a place of devastation, I dont think she had much to say this time around but did it anyway. Wish she would've sat with it longer.

Aimee

I do really love parts of the album but it’s not her best work, and it’s not even close. All of the euphemisms for Travis’ wiener in Wood actually has me icked out and I can usually get through about any cringe lyric ever. Here’s to hoping she listens to the criticism and does better on the next one 🫠 or if she takes a break, god save us debut tv

Esther

She's not a conservative, people are just being deranged. Don't let others make you feel bad about liking this album - I've loved it since first listen, Canceled included.

IrishSwiftie

She needed to deliver on this music video and she did

Angie Lott

I try to imagine her writing “Champagne Problems” with Travis as the muse….. it just doesn’t work. Those days are over lol I agree

gv

so sorry about all the abuse youre getting, over an album :( the divas are here for u 🫶

CaRo!iNe

YASSSSSS I love this music video so much! The Fergie content would be entertaining. The fumbling of the US national anthem is a classic...lmao And YES talk to Fantano about how the internet mistreats music critics and his favorite song and why <3

c.

i feel the same!

Marah

Zach and Madeline it’s comforting to know that I’m not alone in the disappointment. It’s insane how people are attacking those for having critical thought about the low points of this album. Thanks for being honest and I’m sorry your family is being attacked. 🫶🏻

Brianna Tullius

I don’t think the writing on this album suffered because she is happy or Travis is a bad muse. I think it suffered because it was essentially a rush job and she did it in the middle of the Eras tour. If she kept the same concept and took more time to work in the songs, they would be better

Love💞ness

Zach 🌟 sounds like Chappell Roan overwhelm. Sending gratitude for your work. We will hold comments people make about you Accountable here, even if they don't "out there". I look forward to bring my sister to see you & Madeline someday - she's going to Love[!] you two together. 🤍 Proud to be in the Swiftologist community!!

Beth

Someone said to me that the cringey lyrics on Eldest Daughter are the point and make it good... honey

Jackie Gray

It feels like the intention of the album was to give theatrical showgirl vibes in the first four songs, transition with a vulnerable track 5 of inner thoughts, give a peak about the realities behind the curtain, and then end with showgirl finale. Unfortunately, the execution from track 5 through 11 didn't succeed in their intent. Eldest daughter was at times vulnerable but confusing in message and so rambling. I can appreciate ruin the friendship as a song, but it felt weird for her to bring up high school at this point in her career. I think we almost needed some Jack Antonoff help in the second half and I didn't think I would be saying that.

Sol Gorlero

For me, The Life of a Showgirl unfortunately comes at the bottom of my album rankings. It’s not that I dislike it, but compared to albums like Lover or Reputation (which also took time to grow on me), this one feels like it’s missing both a strong concept and that one masterpiece song. The showgirl idea is great in theory, but it doesn’t really shine through the songwriting or production for me. Some songs touch on it (Elizabeth Taylor, Father Figure, The Life of a Showgirl), but others feel disconnected (Wish List, Wood, Honey, Ruin the Friendship). The production also feels a bit subdued for the concept. I also find some of her weaker writing here. Eldest Daughter feels forced — it’s very unclear what it’s trying to accomplish, it’s all over the place. Elizabeth Taylor has potential but doesn’t fully land the metaphor, and Wood just crosses into cringe territory for me. And I really don’t buy the idea that people who don’t love this album “hate seeing Taylor happy.” That’s not it at all. I love lighthearted Taylor — Honey, for example, is a really well-constructed song that’s simple, cute, lighthearted, catchy, and well written. But one of the main issues in the album is that it lacks vulnerability. And that’s the issue because vulnerability is what Taylor does best. And vulnerability does NOT mean sad or tortured, you can be happy in love and be vulnerable . My Top 3 are: Father Figure, Ruin the Friendship, and Honey. Those are great Taylor songs, though I’m not sure they soar to the top of her catalogue as overall standouts. I suppose in time we’ll see how well this album stands the test of time. I don’t think, like some haters say, that it’s the worst thing ever — of course not. It’s Taylor, and there are always incredible things to take away from her music. But I also think it’s one of her weaker albums in terms of how the concept comes together in the songs, the construction of the theme, and some of the lyrics. The production just doesn’t hit the way I wanted it to.

Patricia Vela

Thanks for your thoughts. Even though I don't always agree I always appreciate. Take care of yourself and your peace. Do what you have to do to protect yourself.

Mel B

"This writing is the bad part of tortured poets" - yes, exactly. It pains me, but it needed to be said. This album is a bizarre mix of Charlie Puth clunkers and the overwrought language I didn't enjoy on songs like how did it end. But at least on ttpd, the flowery phrasing was part of the concept, and she balanced it with genuinely exceptional lyricism. There's a lack of intentionality on this record, which is ironic considering how she emphasized the opposite. My favorite thing about Taylor's writing is how she's able to say so much by saying very little. Here, she's saying a lot but also nothing at all, with the exception of Father Figure. Even Actually Romantic is quite clever. I can't help but feel like the ttpd criticism got to her, and she went into this album with the same mindset she had while making lover. It's kinda giving "let me write what I think people want to hear." Sadly, the love songs have that same contrived quality as daylight imo

Alina

omg, THANK YOU for addressing the constant referring she does to "bitches" throughout the record. that is one of the things that has rubbed me the wrong way about this record. the FIRST thing that came to mind when i heard her constantly referring to these women as "bitches" is the Miss Americana documentary when she talks about how important it is for her to "deprogram the misogyny" in her own brain, and then she literally says "there is no such thing as a bitch, there is no such thing as a slut" etc. and how she has to reject these words and ideas. so for her to now do this is so incredibly concerning.

VictoriaReadsss

I fear I need Taylor Swift to start wearing that black wig (rope scene) out in public

Jenna Dale

You keep me sane Zach

Abigail Wilson

I want to know why fantano seems to hate taylor so much. He always retweets taylor hate. He's always coming for swifties on twitter, he routinely dismisses her mental health and struggles. when the chappell stalker thing happened last year he was sad for her but when a swiftie said "but when taylor sang about it you said you didnt care", and he said yes. His reviews of her seem to come from a place of dislike and resentment for her as a person.

halfmoons

Hope you feel safe and comfortable speaking your truth. Your insight is needed and valid. Take care out there! xo

Hannah

I think another creative issue I’ve identified is that Travis seems to be her ONLY muse right now or at least the only one she cares about. I don’t know where ruin the friendship came from. I would love to see her consume new art and talk to new people and have new experiences and then come back with commentary. She even just said in an interview that as she’s gotten older there are fewer things that matter to her, which is concerning to me. I think her world has become very insular and comfortable in a way that’s detrimental to her creative writerly mind. She shouldn’t be in danger or wallowing in misery but as an artist she should at least want to be challenged

Lauren B

I think if you want to do a video on how you'd fix TLOAS it'd be interesting to look at it through the lens of "Is TTPD really The Life of a Showgirl?" Because if the TLOAS song is the thesis of the album, the story of TTPD fits way more than with the majority of songs on TLOAS. So maybe you fix it by getting rid of songs you dont like and adding songs from TTPD to fill out the tracklist and build the narrative.

Fernanda Suarez

I agree that Travis is not a good muse 😂, like she said she writes best the worst men. I really like the melody and production in many of the songs but many of the lyrics feel off. I think the best lyrics are for Ruin the Friendship. I wish she would stop using football slang or just slang in general, because it feels really dated, is giving that "how you do fellow kids" . And I wish she would stop with the I don´t care about money, because girl, come on.

Veyda

Something that is on my mind a lot is the kind of “lol I’m rich” behaviour (I don’t really know how else to describe it) on CANCELLED and at the same time the kind of “I’m above all of that” on Wi$h Li$t. It kind of itches something in me. I don’t fully have the words for it yet. I am a new Swiftie. The first album for me was TTPD. I was really excited and invested and binge watched Swiftologist videos to get in the lore of Taylor and her older Albums. The only albums that are hard to get for me are Debut, Fearless, Speak Now and Red. That’s the old Taylor and I wasn’t around because I was a bit too young. I want to get into them eventually and have that experience but it’s not the same. Of course I know and love the classic songs. Point being I’m not truly familiar with that part of Taylor and it’s not my place to have strong opinions about that part. However with 1989, reputation, Lover, Folklore, Evermore, Midnights and TTPD that’s a bit different and you can get familiar with them in hindsight. I am so glad that I got to experience TTPD as a Swiftie. It’s still everything to me. The thing with this new album for me is that I was really hyped by the concept Taylor presented us and on the first listen I was confused and afterwards I was disappointed. I remember that with TTPD there was some discourse around Taylor being unlikeable on it. However I really connected with TTPD Taylor and like the hurt she was going through because it was so human. Also the other emotional territory on that album like But Daddy I love him for example. That was a way better clap back than the throwing around “bitches” on TLOAS. I kinda have to say it: she is a bit unlikeable to me on TLOAS. I think that’s why this album threw me off at first. I do enjoy some of the songs now and I occasionally get up and dance to them but it don’t have the urge to play it all the time. I still have that urge with TTPD (and other albums too). Like I said the rich girl behaviour but also saying actually I am above all that and I just want my man. And kind of the subtle hating on women (not talking about Actually Romantic). This line in honey about “the bitch was telling me to back off cause her man had looked at me wrong” I’m like really? Like why punch down on another woman? Why not punch down on the man who actually does it? Maybe have a bit of empathy for a woman with a shitty man? Like I think we’ve been there a few times. And yes I get it in the concept of the song but I am sure Taylor could come up with a different situation. In the title track too: The bitches who wish I would hurry up and die. Okay, sure. I just think there is so much more to it that could be explored. Like yes she is the monster on the hill and that has its challenges and I like to hear that perspective. But there is also the other side of standing next to the monster on the hill. And it’s not a nice place to be in for everybody involved including Taylor. I’m thinking about Father Figure here where Taylor actually explores the power dynamic from different perspectives. Why not do it here too instead of just throwing bitches around to I don’t know sound cool and not caring? I think it would fit the concept of the life of a showgirl. TTPD had such depth and we know from folklore and evermore and father figure and many more examples that she is capable of exploring perspectives that aren’t hers. TLOAS lacks that for me completely. And please don’t get me wrong. I am so happy for Taylor that she is in a happy place especially after like everything we heard on TTPD. But even the happiness on the TLOAS lacks depth. I’d love to shake my ass off to happy Taylor. And I do. I like the truly happy moments on the album: the opalite and putting in the work for happiness, the reshaping nicknames because you now experience them in a loving way and the your love gives me something that money and material things (and for Taylor fame) can‘t. These are things I think almost everybody can relate too. The problem is that you have to search for it. What I also want to illustrate is that for me happy Taylor is not the problem or the main issue. It’s more like the less emotional depth there is the more the billionaire and mega fame side comes through and the Swifties or at least I just can’t relate to that and honestly sometimes it puts me off. Of course that’s a big part of her life and I don’t agree with any billionaire behaviour from anyone. Correct me if I am wrong but this kinda is the first time that we see that side of Taylor really prominent in her songs. CANCELLED especially is so tone death and out of touch and like how can you seriously be so unaware of the message you are spreading with this. Like yes she was cancelled and it was wrong. But like some people are massively criticised for a reason. I don’t want to go into politics but we all know what is going on right now. Her branding of being relatable stops working here. And I think in hindsight she was trying to really emphasise that on the New Heights interview with all the bread baking. She still does it on interviews and even did it on the release film. The album just isn’t that. And it didn’t need to be if it was actually in the concept of the showgirl of it all. But it’s not and even the Lover Travis Version is not truly executed in my opinion. I treasure Taylor’s emotional depth and intelligence and the writing and perspectives that come from it. I always will. I really miss that on TLOAS and that’s my main issue. But as Madeline said: TTPD, evermore and all the beautiful girls are still there. And thank god for that.

Klara Ipek

Love u Zach, enjoy India, you deserve a rest!

samantha

after i listened to tloas….i was so underwhelmed. lmao.

halfmoons

Those questions you’re thinking of asking Fantano are all perfect. The state of criticism would be good too bc he’s cancelled like everyday

Fi

Ruin the Friendship is Red TV leftovers and I will die on this hill

Jomazel

im really excited for all the content to come!!! have fun at your wedding!! busyologist!! 🫶

Fi

Not just lyrically but sonically

TB

Love the ideas of a deep dive into father figure, the title track and her relationship with her work, and Charli’s and Taylor’s dynamic. Still don’t understand what the concept was with the severed hand thing. Also curious what scandals she has been covering up for borchetta referenced on father figure and potentially who’s afraid of little old me. I think there is also an interesting story arch of her past music framing love as fate, prophecy, predetermined where she has little agency to now feeling she has more agency (Ophelia, opalite, wood before the euphemisms begin). Since you said you are interested in feedback and value criticism, as someone who has been subscribed and on the Patreon since the beginning, watched everything and have respect for what you do here, can I say I hate the idea of putting ideas out there things like her artistry is in decline, Travis is a bad muse, happiness is bad for her artistry — those aren’t *constructive* criticisms, the assumptions for these things to be true require vast extrapolating beyond the information we have and are still forming opinions about, and she is still a person and she has said herself how damaging the idea of misery as a requirement to do the thing she loves most is to her and honestly it comes off a bit cruel to publicly ponder on that especially given your platform I think your voice has more weight in driving conversation and social opinion on her than perhaps you’d like to think, and much of the hot takes surely gets back to her, so I really appreciate that you are considering how to put content out without feeding into a pile-on. You are so smart with some great insightful analyses and I think your best work, most enjoyable, and most interesting is when the critical notes are constrained to thoughtful constructive criticism and don’t veer into unconstructive insults — you are way too clever and witty to need to stoop to being mean in order to be funny and interesting

Linneae

All of this is exactly how I've been feeling as well, tysm for the effort of writing it all down! I'm so glad Zach mentioned her throwing around "bitches" on this video, so I'm sure we'll be getting some discussion about that soon enough!

Corban1127 Hutcherson

I’m in love with the sound of this album but I really wish she had another writer to kind of rein her in a little bit. Eldest Daughter was the track I claimed but I was so confused when I first heard it.

Renee Darline

This is all a marketing issue/ song selection issue. I think it makes sense she did NOT say that in promo she was trying for a "sonically cohesive" album. it's definitely all over the place, and I agree the first half is stronger than the back end. (I think this is reflected in the track streaming. The only reason title track is higher up is because of the Sabrina collab). I wonder if Taylor sees the difference between her writing on TTPD and folklevermore? I enjoy Wood a ton -- the clean version is a little less cringey for sure. And I think Honey and Cancelled are like 2/3 of the way to being show-stopping songs, otherwise we can just stop the record at Ruin the Friendship.

Miranda kay

I would love a lover/showgirl analysis at some point!

Justin

Me! And eldest daughter are sister songs

Elle Kaye

^^^Yeah I’m curious if he ever interrogates himself and his biases. He did the same thing to Halsey. He’s been generally kind to Sabrina but doesn’t give her credit for her intelligent — e.g., he said it was embarrassing how low her standards were and that she was so self-unaware on “Tears” when the whole point of the song is that the bar is in hell. He also seems to justify his dislike of artists based on how politically active they are with their platforms. Aside from the fact that I agree with Zach’s points and the data on how that’s usually a bad thing, it’s a slippery slope. He loooooves Charli, but Charli pals around with the Red Scare girls. It really seems like he just looks for excuses to justify his personal dislike of artists (usually female pop stars).

Sarah B

I was reading the lyrics along with the first listen and I was also incredibly confused about what point she was trying to make

Hannah

the real indicator for me that i am not connecting with this album is the fact i’m streaming literally anything else. usually with a taylor release that’s all i’m spinning for at least the first 2 weeks… on friday night i was listening to ttpd. IJBOL

Bailey

I totally agree that Travis is not a good muse. The sounds of all of these songs, and even So High School, are super catchy and fun but the lyrics range from mostly just fine to atrocious. I blame him for this album being one of her weakest. Although I personally think she's settling with him, I am happy she's happy and I hope in the future she can find some inspiration that leads to lyricism on par with even her other better pop albums (1989, Reputation, and even Lover all have better lyrics).

SM R

Love you my Swiftologist and I am so sorry people are being abusive on the internet. Block liberally and often!

Sarah B

“Swiftologist coded” *hand heart*

Veyda

Thank you so much for saying that. I just had to get it out and I don’t have any Swifties around me in real life so everybody thinks of me as deranged when I ramble about Taylor Swift for too long 😂 I’m so glad I am not alone with this feeling!

Billiexoxo

Sorry to hear about the hate, we love the whole you here.🫶🏼

Solène Skoczek

I kinda want to let it grow on me, because I do think that what is throwing us off is the lack of very good writing, but she made a focus on creating hits, and on the production and I think we can cheer for this. Like having hits from Taylor swift, that you can have fun to, it's been a while... I think, exept for the theme of the songs, this it what she advertised : pop, fun, upbeat. And it kind of delivered. But I admit I really can't with eldest daughter and wish list so I juste ignore 😭 Also my favorite albums are ttpd and folklore so I love a devastating song. It's just not what she said she was doing and I'm glad she is doing different things, it must keep it fun and experimental for her!

Christina

How to murder your career: Shawn Mendes please!! Also I think this album isn’t about HER experience in her relationship with Travis or HER experience during the Eras tour, it feels like it’s written with the gaze of Travis (as in songs he would think are a “bop” or ones about him) and the public in mind, which I think is why it feels so shallow. Which is disappointing. I want to hear her thoughts, her depth of emotions and meaning. Not what she thinks people want

Heather

Seeing this music video on the big screen was so worth it

VictoriaReadsss

its so funny because ALL OF UR THOUGHTS I feel like your reading my mind, I feel the same exact way, and ive gone on so many journeys with the album of at first I was like CUNT SERVE, then I was like oh no I kinda hate these lyrics, and I went back n forth til I ended up somewhere in the middle

VictoriaReadsss

what really gets me is her saying its folklore and ever more writing... um girl...

Terran Milne

There’s an Aries full moon tonight (Oct 6) which is fueling the combative feelings that are going on right now

bug

Yes! I am befuddled by this too. I don’t think anybody needed or expected this. Maybe it was finally convenient for her to work with MM and Shellback again.

SM R

+ would really love to see that video comparison of Taylor in love on Lover vs Showgirl.

bug

like none of this feels like she had anything to say :/ just feels like she wanted to make something and maybe that’s not where her best work comes from

Lauren

Converting my best friend who is not even a swiftie into a swiftologist fan ❤️ let’s go king

Zoe

i would definitely ask anthony what he thinks about taynegativity periods. if he is particularly against inflammatory ideas from the general public about a ts project…because that is definitely a beast unlike music journalism. and even reviews these days can be very hateful and come across social media ragey. i’d want to know if he’s against that or how he thinks it could be improved / how negative reviews should be navigated.

sara :)

you're always right and that's why they're hating

Angie Nichole

Excited for mentioned upcoming videos! I was curious to how long it took to write previous Taylor albums vs how long was spent on this album? How many hours could actually be spent writing and creating flying back and forth between countries during Eras? Do you think that it was just rushed and so quality suffered?

Tiffany Grace

As far as a views perspective goes - I’d definitely do Charlie vs Taylor! Currently relevant but more about Charlie than Taylor, so could be a nice brain break for you.

Genevieve Smith

My thoughts on all the internet opinions is that it is never that serioussssss yall 😭 I personally love TLOAS, but bet your ass I was giggling up a storm at Madeline’s reaction video and having a Kiki!!! If you love an album, great! If you hate it, fine! If you don’t want to see someone negatively review or give critiques to an album or artist you stan, THEN DON’T WATCH!!! It is not that serious I promise

Caroline Crampton

Do we think if she had dropped this video with the album, rather than delaying for the cinema release, it would have affected the reaction at all? Haters were always going to hate, but I wonder if it might have helped scotch the "not showgirl enough" takes

Chas

Wish list made me miss so high school which is not something I expected to feel! Bottle and Aristotle!

Colleen

Lover vs TLOAS love comparison...please Swiftologist I need this. Lover's one and only fan here and ready

Tiffany Grace

I’d love to hear your comments on the prologue vs the actual album. I feel like her prologue hit the concept way more than the actual songs did.

Maya Rodgers

I refuse to acknowledge eldest daughter exists. But see how I just move on and enjoy the bops?! Thank you for being normal Zach

kc

i am begging you guys to react to the new rolling stone taylor song ranking 😀😀

Jojobear

Aw thanks. It seems nice here,so I'll stay. And I don't mind at all that not everyone likes the album, art is subjective etc. It's definitely not going to be a top 5 album for me either. it didn't grab my heart instantly like ttpd did. But I do mind that people are being rancid & vile to her & to other people! That includes swifties to non swifties. & Now that I know actually romantic seems to be about this one person, it makes me feel awful that she might be getting abuse or hate too. it's just horrid behaviour & taints what was supposed to be a really fun time! I didn't go back online at all at ttpd release and I'm so so glad I didn't because this has not been fun!

Trish Veneziano

Some thoughts: 1) she needed an editor because she was writing while exhausted. 2) she has effectively formed a loop back to rep era, erasing Matty and Joe. 3) it’s not Travis as muse that is the problem, her audience has merged with sport culture and this album is a sport anthem album. His friend group is also athletes and adjacent figures. 4) Can you revisit the CHANEL fashion choices as showgirl cosplay? Love you, they hate you because you’re right!

feeb

Thoughts on Pitchfork giving TLOAS such a low score? Lowest than any other of her work apparently. Agree not her best album but feels v harsh

Kat

Zach do you think might do a music video ranking at some point and include the Fate of Ophelia in it? Perhaps it could be a ranking of all of the videos that Taylor herself has written and directed since the ones pre Lover are so different

Tiffany Grace

Absolutely. Writing to process your way out of misery is way different than writing once you are actually happy. I write WAY more poetry when I’m diva down. I know I wouldn’t have a career if I had to write when I was actually happy.

Jojobear

thanks! just want to also clarify Zack and Madeline didn't make me feel bad for liking it. I really appreciated their first thoughts episode. But other online spaces.... Yeah I re deleted those apps real fast today!

Kylee

Give us the top 3 in order?

Kylee

Father Figure number one? I would go and look myself, but it’s more fun this way.

Eeeee

I think majority of swifies are not obsessed about the album but they’re fine with it. Other fandom are seeing that and having a blast which is annoying

Marianna D

Exaaactly. The prologue if you combine all the poems is much more showgirl coded than all the lyrics on the album

VR

Do how to murder your career about Demi Lovato.

Eeeee

Also if you compare this album to other albums that released this year how do you think you’re gonna rank it? For me I think only gaga’s is better

Erin Archbold

ugh I’m so sorry people are harassing your mom

Carolina

A deep dive on The Life of a Showgirl as a concept album would be great too how the marketing promised one thing (spectacle and glamour) but the album itself leaned softer and more romantic.

ryan

this video is an undeniable serve

kc

he ranked all of taylor’s songs, but from showgirl is highest placed tracks are 1. ophelia 2. elizabeth taylor 3. eldest daughter (he says eldest daughter is her 21st best song of all time…..)

Emily Olivarez

Taylor said multiple times she wanted to make an album to stimulate her brain because she’d gone on autopilot during the tour. This to me sounds like she made this album for fun and not because she had anything profound to say which is why it is so different from everything beforehand. I think swifties have come to expect a level of craftsmanship in lyricism because Taylor has branded herself as a poetic writer (not even talking about recent times this has spanned her whole career). And with keeping everyone at arms length her only thing she wanted to share was about her master, Travis, and respond to drama on a surface level. Honestly I don’t think she could have ever written an album about the eras tour while still on it there just hasn’t been enough time for her to reflect. She just used the showgirl branding as a creative choice because it tied the eras era together in a neat bow and made sense to market the album as such. People who like this album like it because it’s pop music not because they like the lyrics which is why it is hard to defend to haters because the lyrics are what they’re attacking. (Ps I love this album so take this all with a grain of salt)

Sierra Walter

I’m sorry you’re getting so much hate 😢

Chelseylake

Being inspired by your description of your difficulties with enjoying TLOAS for what it is in isolation from Taylor’s entire discography, a question for Anthony Fantano has popped up in my head: Given that he has been reviewing soooo many albums from soooo many different artists, by breaking down the songs into sonic elements and explaining how they affect the listeners, at this point is he able to just enjoy a pop song for what it is? E.g. getting addicted to a hook without a second thought of why it is addictive.

Sarah. Armstrong

Oh Zack, I didn't know they sent that stuff to your mother. That's horrible.

CMP

LITERALLY I was GAGGGED at her hair in the first scene she looked so GOOD 🫶🏻

Carolina

I’d also love a video exploring when Taylor’s writing really works versus when it doesn’t. Eldest Daughter is probably the biggest miss for me, even after her explanation, it still feels like too many disconnected ideas crammed into one song. It’s also such an interesting case study because Track 5s are usually her emotional centerpiece, and this one just doesn’t hold up next to songs like YOYOK, All Too Well, or Tolerate It. A comparison of all her Track 5s and how their vulnerability has evolved over time would be such a great discussion.

Lizzy

I think that London Boy is cheesy camp in a way that feels like pure Taylor. Wood, while a sonic jackson 5 bop, feels like Taylor is copying Sabrina's shtick and so it lands different. It doesn't quite feel like Taylor. But i also think Taylor isn't taking it that seriously. Who knows, maybe the NYT gaylor oped made her say, that's it, I'm gonna write a song about how much I love 🪵.

Chelseylake

Another question for you and Madeline: I’ve seen people talking about how the order of the songs actually calls back to the showgirl theme of the album. They said that the title track is the iconic finale of a show, and that all the different songs before the title track were just different scenes of a showgirl’s performance, or a facade kind of thing, which is exactly why they are shallow. They are what a showgirl thinks what the audience wants to see. In other words, we were just too stupid to understand Taylor’s mastermind or the intentional nature of everything that she puts out. What do you think about the theory, and does it even have any significance in terms of the quality of the album?

pricila

the tay negativity is so bad, tik tok and twitter and even the locals in my circle are not liking this album. But idc im kinda with your POV, its mid but i have my favorites songs and im jamming to those. The MV is a serve!

Mikey

if you need a probably easier non taylor video i would love to see an olivia rodrigo song ranking

Maria Juko

I get all the criticism but I'm also having a grand time jamming to (some of) these songs...Ruin the Friendship (despite its high school theme which I find to be over done; that plot twist!) is a standout to me, as is Wood (TS just horny on main?! Why yes! And that production!!!!), while songs like Cancelled or Actually Romantic haven't clicked with me personally. I think the scope of sound scapes is much bigger here and thus also the risks she took. Perhaps that's why it's so polarising, she wanted to hit all the marks, address all the audiences and in the midst the so-called concept just got lost....

y

suddenly i feel like a fool in my headdress is entering my daily lexicon

Julia S

how to murder your carer Shawn Mendes might be interesting, or one on Dua Lipa maybeee

Ellie

I am cackling at your reaction. That music video is THE GAG

Jaqi Jarboe

I’ve been saying he’s a terrible muse. Matt best muse sorry not sorry

Ohdearjon

This is not even making it on my year end list

Tea Terzin

I'm dying for the lover/life of a showgirl comparison!!!

Renee

I’m SO excited for Fantano x Swiftologist. I was flabbergasted by his generally positive feelings on this album compared to TTPD so I really want you to ask him 1) What is it about TTPD that captures what he perceives as Taylor at her worst, and 2) What makes a good Taylor album for him.

Lorin

I was reading Eldest Daughter in the song as in her career/taydaughters like the forerunners of pop girls needing to look implacable so the hate in the internet towards women in music

Lexi

Actually romantic was really written about all of the Swiftologist hate

Lexi

But seriously leave momologist alone these people are disgusting

Gabriela Cameron

I'm excited to hear you discuss the state of music criticism with Fantano, also talking about Rockism vs. Popism and what that means today

ella

It's not really about Taylor specifically but I think it would be really interesting if you could ask Fantano how the feedback from his misogynistic approach to reviewing female artists has changed the way he approaches it now (or a nicer more eloquent way of saying this lol). I basically want to know if he took in the feedback and if/how he's looking to adjust his approach, especially considering that if he's being interviewed by you he's looking to take in more of a female audience.

Robert Reuhl

Please do a how to murder your career for christina augliera!

t

"No CGI here!" But is there AI like all the recent Eras videos :((((((

Gigi

ZAYN

Mar

Yesss there are so many styles and genres on this not very long album, for better or for worse! Wood production S tier

VP

Thoughts! The album is just deep cuts. I don’t think a single song is “single worthy”. They can work as singles if you want them to, but they’re not. 1989 was endless singles. Reputation had so many tracks that could have been singles - I did something bad, Don’t blame me, Gateway Car etc. This album? Nope. And that is fine if that was the intention. Which maybe it is, it’s meant to be the behind the scenes, not the stage. But Taylor marketed it as bullet proof pop, every song is there for a reason, Max Martin is back, it’s banger after banger. When it’s completely the opposite. So if you reframe the concept - if there is one - then I can enjoy the album for what it is. But it is not what I expected, nor what I wanted. And it’s fine. What I end up feeling is did we need this album? TTPD was needed, it was an exorcism, nobody had any idea that we needed it but we did. This album? I’m glad it exists, and I’m enjoying the songs, but it’s the first album from Taylor where i feel like I could also have lived without it and be fine.

Cecilia

I’ve been thinking about what you’ve been saying re: this isn’t very “back then I swore I was gonna marry him someday but I realized bigger dreams of mine,” and it’s very much “all that’s ever mattered to me is getting married.” I think at that point in her life being on the Eras Tour, she literally got everything on her Wish List: the biggest tour in history, 4 album of the years, critically acclaimed, literally drowning in money (money pweaseeee), dedicated fanbase, the freedom to create whatever kind of music she wants. She’s one of, if not the, biggest artist of all time; something she could only conjure up in her wildest dreams. So, not only did she realize, but she achieved these bigger dreams, and this was the last thing on the Wish List. I agree, I would have loved for her to share more vulnerability about how she was terrified she wasn’t going to find her forever person, but I think she was so in the moment writing this, she didn’t want to look back outside of the “Alls well that ends well to end up with you,” gaze at the relationship. Just my thoughts on that! Stay strong out there divas! I’m glad we’ve got a corner of the internet where we can talk about this album thoughtfully. Can’t wait to see the content y’all will be pumping out around this 🫶

Angelica B

I ❤️ u, 🖕🏻 the haters.

Septima

I would love to hear your thoughts on the weight / importance of the artist's intention versus the audience's interpretation. In a world where Taylor has been trying to assert control over the narrative and the internet seems to lack any kind of reading comprehension, I find the topic of who gets to decide what art means really interesting. (Only if that resonates with you obviously 😁)

Molly

How to Murder Your (Music) Career— JLo??

James

I love how much Taylor in the bathtub looks like Zack 😂😂😂

James

There's some songs that I think are very good for a storytelling MV like but daddy I love him and then songs like this that are meant just for looks

Deli

Ugh why is this album so misogynistic. I hate the word bitch when it’s used to talk down to someone and she did that a heinous number of times. Honey is so much better clean for this reason: She’s pissed that women talked down to her with the word honey but then she goes right back around and called them bitch (a word with violent history and undertones imo) So Zach I get the hesitation on that part

Sulacycle

Oooh, I was thinking that "I write the worst men best" comment too! Like Matty was in her own words, a paradox, and a fellow songwriter and that need to dissect and impress made her work her ass off.

netsirk

The visual is creepy

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

TLOAS has 10 tracks in my house, and it's one of the best album ever made 💅

A.N. Chaney

You should do a deep dive into Kesha’s career instead of a how to murder your career

Erin

So surprised Tree Paine didn’t “caution her against such a strong misogynistic message” LMFAO

netsirk

This is a great question

kyla

i really needed that stay strong out there 😭 like you said, it’s very hard to defend taylor right now against the haters because what they’re saying is rude but sadly there’s some truth in it

Leslie

An interesting thing to me about how she writes about Joe vs. Travis is that she's almost trying to shoehorn some of the Joe sentiments into Travis songs. Like Eldest Daughter almost seems like Sweet Nothing 2.0, Wi$h Li$t is very King Of My Heart (come on girl, "say you fancy me not fancy stuff" might have worked in the Joe era but you can't pull that now when you're both drenched in designer), Elizabeth Taylor and the obvious Ready For It parallels, etc. TO BE VERY CLEAR I'm not saying she's still hung up on Joe or that she doesn't have real and deep feelings for Travis. I just think she is so guarded about her relationship with Travis that she's approaching writing the songs more strategically. And in kind of scrounging her brain for "how to write about love" she's landing on ideas she's used before.

aditi

How to murder/revive your career suggestions: maroon 5, lizzo, Christina, Shakira, Mariah, Kelly Clarkson, the weeknd

Chas

I would love a video predicting what Olivia’s next album may sound like

Taylor

Love the how to murder your career videos. You can tell how much time you put into those--they are great!

Kylee

This has actually rendered me speechless. I was listening to Man’s Best Friend today and We Almost Broke Up Again Last Night reminded me of what a good ballad should sound like. Such an underrated track from that album but back to this bs….Eldest Daughter is truly all of the reject verses from YOYOK or just me? Where does he have the other two? It’s just a question[s]. 💀

Monique Ocampo

I definitely agree that Showgirl is a mid-tier album, but it's not her worst overall. I love the visuals for The Fate of Ophelia! This is the best music video that she's directed so far.

NicoleWithoutTheH

Can you talk about the acoustic versions of some of the showgirl songs?

Alan Roxburgh

oh a sister song episode I think would be interesting is right where you left me - I look in peoples windows - ruin the friendship all following the theme of being stuck in the past of what could have been, still at the restaurant - addicted to the if only - always answer the question better that than to ask it all your life. I like that in them she casts aside her feelings of fate and wonders about how the choices she's made have lead her on such different paths than the others

Margaret Schinkel

Oh my gosh I recorded a phone a snake for you guys about bringing Joe back to the writers room but it was a COMPLETE joke I had no idea people are even saying he wrote her stuff wtf!!!!?

Naomi Hyde

My non-Swiftie friend loves the album and I think it’s because he had zero expectations going in so is just enjoying the production and fun vibes for what it is! I had high expectations for this album and was initially disappointed, and I do think she overhyped it in the podcast, but the more I listen to it for what it is the more I like it!

Kylee

And one more thing….💀 How are they ranking these amongst the discography already? Premature if you ask me, Rolling Stone, but ok.

Rachael Evansco

I honestly think this is my favorite music video I've ever seen. 🔥 🔥 🔥

Chas

Love this idea!!

Linneae

Exactly! Plus the whole Kimye drama was all about Taylor herself being offended by being called "that bitch"! I'd also add the line about fat asses when she has been very public about her own struggles with body image and disordered eating... It's like she's regressed twenty years mentally and is back to the being the girl who wrote the OG Picture to Burn and Better Than Revenge.

Kylee

Go listen to We Almost Broke Up Again Last Night for a ballad palate cleanse and we’re good to go.

JD IHateItHere

I do think there is a very Midnights cohesive approach of A showgirl. Not THE showgirl or all Showgirls. It is a showgirl over the the spectrum of her thoughts and wishes and moods. A showgirl is going to ask what ifs, wish for a simple life, come for an enemy who disrespected her professionally after being given the stage, the thrill of new love, the excessive love a la Elizabeth Taylor. The feral protection of professional accomplishment and the softer moments of doubt and fatigue. So is it a slam dunk? No. Is the vitriol toward Taylor merited? No. Did she set herself up with the bar she set? Yes. Do I love this album? I have to say I do, and those of us who do shouldn’t be shamed for saying so. Zack should not be demonized for being critical nor should his family be attacked. By anyone. The internet is vile, and I think the polarization of the world is playing out writ large because Taylor is one of the few monoliths remaining. I must request the “Now I feel foolish in my headdress” with a picture of that face and headdress on a a tshirt because we all get tomato to the face as a Swiftie. I add that as an older person, I’m hearing much more love for the album from people with more life experience, tolerance for being uncool, and a longer view of what is classic or good. That’s not me loving all the word choices, but I do see the showgirl behind the curtain all over this album if the showgirl isn’t cliche. The show girl is a showgirl. She wants to love love. Favorites are: Ruin the Friendship. Opalite, Fate of Ophelia, Actually Romantic, Life of a Showgirl, Elizabeth Taylor, Honey, and I’ll say it, Wood because musically it is so, so good. Don’t love the lyrics, but the music is great and the lyrics are allowed.

Kylee

Hot take: Father Figure & Elizabeth Taylor on TLOAS is Cruel Summer & DBATC on Lover behaviors.

Kylee

Probably not but a showgirl can dream

Aleksandra

As an eldest daughter, this song was offensive. I was having really high hopes because I love Taylor’s writing and all we got was this slop.

Justus 🤍

Personally I find it a top 6 album. It’s right by 1989. I think the first 4 songs are all VERY good and will do well. Then I have 4 more I really like. Wish list and honey really goes

Justus 🤍

Zach is just very sensitive to writing. Fontano is as well but he knows pop better.

Linneae

This pretty much sums it up.

Dorene

Given that you can’t fix the album by just rearranging it… Can you and Madeline ideate 2-3 new songs Taylor should add to the album? There’s so much missed potential had she truly leaned into the showgirl theme.

Abby

Taylor is getting so much hate and a lot is ungenerous and over the top but at the same time she has really made career decision after career decision that were calibrated for her to have maximum reach and maximum exposure and be on the biggest stage under the biggest spotlight. So unfortunately when you’re on everyone’s feed and in everyone’s ears and on billboards in everyone’s cities then a lot of those people going have an opinion about the work they’re seeing you put out. I wish that more people who weren’t interested in her work chose not engage but she is literally everywhere all the time and it’s hard to look away and I do think she’s made her bed in that regard.

Michelle Kate

There’s really something to be said about the showgirl having written this album, almost removed from taylor swift. this record feels like the mirror of what the public’s perspective on taylor swift is more than her own narration. it’s like mirror ball meets blank space the album

Leslie

I don't know how much you know or care about them/country music in general, but a "How to murder and then eventually revive your career" on the Chicks would be super interesting. Someone who maybe inadvertently murdered their career with a comment but the backlash was undeserved and they eventually overcame it.

Taylor

Thinking about sister song possibilities. --Father Figure could be compared to Who's Afraid of Little Old Me. FF could also be compared to My Tears Ricochet or The Man. --Clara Bow vs. The Life of a Showgirl. --The Prophecy vs. The Fate of Ophelia. or Love Story vs. The Fate of Ophelia. --Lastly, I don't know if there's enough here for a full episode, but there is something similar about the lyrics in Elizabeth Taylor ("don't you ever end up anything but mine," and "I can't have fun if I can't have you") and imgonnagetyouback ("even if it's handcuffed I'm leaving here with you," "whether I'm gonna be your wife or gonna smash up your bike...I'm gonna get you back").

Wilderhardt

"Suddenly I feel like a fool in my headdress" would have been a better lyric than 75% of the ones on this album, that's gotta count for something. In all seriousness though, appreciate your commitment to honestly and critical thought when it feels like the internet has hit abominably low levels of literacy.

Bi

We live in a world where critical thinking, subjective thinking, and nuance have left the table. Every take is seen as a personal attack. How dare this person I’ve never met not like the album I like. Let me throw genuinely hurtful comments at them. The real clock is kindness has left the room and people can’t help but be animals to each other. In a world that’s so black and white I appreciate your grey takes on media. Willing to allow yourself to find things you enjoy and didn’t about what you are reviewing. I have different takes from you but I can always hand heart an honest review.

Linneae

You said it perfectly!

Sulacycle

A huge part of the enjoyment of this album for me is the music part, irrespective of the lyrics which I will admit are uneven. Sonically though, I find it uniquely interesting. Some r&b, some disco, the shiny plastic French Riviera vibe of the early songs. Those who have been on this ride longer, are there comparisons, parallels?

Dorene

Reputation and Showgirl are similar in that they both marketed one thing but ended up as love stories. We praise Reputation for being a creative and strategic misdirection. Showgirl just seems like a marketing failure. Was she trying to do the same thing?

Jenny Kansas City

Murder your Career = Lauryn Hill pleassssse....she was the first diva holding all the grammys

Cathy Spyr

I hear so much musical theater influence in some of these songs, why was she able to repress this better before but not now?

Brenna

Interested in your thoughts on Rolling Stone's new ranking of Taylor songs..... egregious in my opinion.

hayleywilliamsmademegay

sending hate to momologist is DIABOLICAL!! sorry you have to deal with these crazies. i've been mostly offline for this release, thank you snakes for this space for respectful critique and great discussions <3

Stamkitty

To me the song Elizabeth Taylor shows her worry/vulnerability. It asks the question we are all thinking - is this really forever?

Mariana

Im an eldest daughter and the song SUCKS! But the only songs I go back to our GOOD SONGS: Father Figure, Elizabeth Taylor, Honey, and OKAY song Actually Romantic. 😭 i literally removed half of the songs on the album from my playlist.

Lindsay

This might be my favorite music video and I have died at several of her past MVs

Rocio R.

I appreciate your perspective, per usual. I am a die-hard Swiftie (since Should’ve Said No), but this album isn’t her best work. I keep telling myself that when you have a large discography like hers, there’s tiers/ranking—inevitably. This happens in other media, too, like TV shows. The important thing to remember is that one bad season/album doesn’t always kill the show. If this is Season 8 of Game of Thrones for Swifties; I get it. Season 8 killed the show for me, too. But I also hated season 4 of Buffy, but it didn’t turn me off of the show and just skip it when I rewatch. TLOAS isn’t a skip for me. I am enjoying it but can recognize it’s not my favorite album nor Taylor’s best work. Similar thing happened with Gaga’s Artpop, which I ALWAYS loved. Ppl hating on it never stopped me from enjoying it.

Cody Head

Some content I would actually enjoy is some more content on beyonce, kinda just a career autopsy of some sort. Or a video on the impact of lemonade

Amber

I thought the same thing re: the choreo 🤣 GO GIRL I'm impressed!

Stamkitty

So she wrote TTPD on the first leg of the tour and TLOAS on the second leg and came up with all the mash ups and surprise songs and remembered and performed her whole Eras tour set night after night. Liking to stay busy doesn’t begin to describe it.

Dorene

You’ve asked several times ‘where is the girl who will do things greater than dating the boy on the football team…and who doesn’t need a man to save her?’ But you need to follow that with The Prophesy, then the current trajectory makes sense.

Eth

Would LOVEE the how to fix showgirl episode. Also for future episodes maybe a how she could navigate the rest of this era and deal with the negative reception from swifties (would love an eoas episode where you choose singles and come up with mv ideas!!!)

Bethan

Zach, I'm so appalled to hear you and your family have been getting such heinous abuse. You don't deserve that at all. Keep doing you. You're providing such a refuge for a lot of us atm. 😅🫶💖

Mariana

The sweat and vanilla only applied to the song wood, if ykyk 😭😅 (this is also a joke, but the only way I can see those being incorporated)

Bethan

She's made music Travis will like because RESPECTFULLY Tortured Poets will have gone right over his head.

Eth

Also when the dust settles around showgirl maybe a virgin/lorde career analysis… the albums has been cooking + need your opinion ‼️

Kd235481

Love all the content!

Sulacycle

I like that, and not that Zach is suggesting it in my opinion, these should not have to be binary choices. I think this is the pendulum swinging all the way, and maybe, hopefully we will see something in the middle in TS13.

Kelsie Smith

I feel like the only person who just genuinely loves the album? Thats its fun and a bop and I feel like I get both the serious lyrical songs and the silly "badly" written ones. Im just having a good time, the album is exactly what I expected and what I WANTED. I guess I just simply can not care that other people think its embarrassing if im having the time of my life 😅

Hey12345

Can you let us know when you’ll have spots open at your highest tier? Really loving your Patreon 🙏

VadersPetPig

PLEASE consider reacting to Florence's new album on Halloween 🎃 🙏

Savanna

One thing I will say about Anthony Fantano is I remember from his lover review he said paper rings. I just think that needs to be reiterated lol

Kelsie Smith

She has done things bigger than marrying the boy on the football team AND shes marrying the boy on the football, AND shes going to continue to do things greater than that. Its not mutually exclusive!

Shannon

I will say today was the first time I listened while singing along and this album is SO FUN to sing if you ignore some of cringey lyrics

Kay

Hi I’m here! I agree! 🫶

Archie

Zack your voice is now so powerful, please be careful with what you say outside the paywall. Try to focus on finding the flowers to give to this album while criticizing it because the hateration going on is already too much, if you pile on in the wrong way, it’s gonna make all the actual haters feed of your critique to be like see, even the swiftoligist hates it. Like I get it people don’t like it, me personally I LOVE it and it’s sad for the people enjoying to have so much hate going on already. I do believe there’s a lot of flowers to give to this album and i don’t think that there’s any other artist in the world capable of writing such good pop songs and lyrics 🩵

Dora Paczur

So hear me out: ive been thinking about Eldest Daughter a lot. To be honest i found the lyrics repulsive… but then now im thinking… we all know what a genious she is. My take is she knows exactly what she is doing using that millenial terminology (and im a milleanial myself, exactly 2 days older than Tay) that makes some of us cringe (bad bitch, savage, we looked fire etc). Its meant to make us feel as if she is outdated, cringe, as at some point, this is exactly what happens to the showgirl. Its kinda foreshadowing how at some point every showgirl becomes outdated. Is anyone with me?? Is this truly genious what she is doing or just bad writing?? Imo she MUST be doing this on purpose, to create this very specific feeling from the listener…am i cooking? Or the dish is cooked, it is what it is? Note: no hate to those who love the song of course- you do you honey! ;) i just wanted to see if anyone is going through the same thought process…🧡Taylor🧡

Kelsie Smith

I think its interesting to see the fact that people's track listing are SO different. Like we could have the same #1, but your #2 is my #12.

Shannon

I feel like a better way to incorporate a Travis love song would be something like his hands massaging her sore muscles at the end of a 3 show weekend. This would be Wood but actually Showgirl related haha

Emma Gardner

You know a Taylor album is disappointing when Zach starts praising the concept and writing on lover. Jokes aside, I understand why this album drop is difficult for you as a taylor swift creator, take your time to think and handle your upcoming content the way that feels right to you! We love you zach!

Sulacycle

I love it too. And recognize that I can love something that isn't perfect (I would hope so, since nearly nothing is). I listened on a hike yesterday and was embarrassingly dancing in the woods. I skip Eldest Daughter, but on every TS record (or ANYONE'S record) there is at least one song I skip.

Ana

Zach I am SO SORRY the level of hate you've been receiving on the Internet esp tiktok. It does definitely show your level of power& influence but it's terrifying at the same time. You have so much to positively contribute to these conversations and I hope to see you keep doing it for a long time! I'm glad you are very active about filtering and turning off comments. People are vicious and genuinely deranged.

Kelsie Smith

I really feel like the marketing and photos set me up to expect what the album was. The songs are about her LIFE as a Showgirl, mostly her falling in love, issues with friends and ppl talking shit, wistful thinking ab how her life could look if she didnt take the risk, ect. But the SOUND is luxurious, its sounds expensive, and big and over the top, and sparkly, and gritty, and dark. Shes dressed as a Showgirl in the photoshoot, but shes always backstage, or in the bath, or in the hotel room. Idk, im just not shocked at all, its totally what I thought it would be 😅

Ana

Lover (the song) is one of my favorite of hers of all time and it was written out of something positive and happy, but there was also longing and uncertainty and layers to it. This album definitely seems like she's wrapping herself in a sparkly blanket of perfection because some part of her is still so scared of how public scrutiny could destroy what she has with another person. She's in such a unique position as the biggest pop star alive. I want to see her come out of this, but I think you're right that her artistry as a whole seems to be on a downward trend. Of course this means all the evil locals will say see!!!! See!!!! She's never had it!!!!! Always mediocre!!!!! Always bad!!!!!! Which is the most infuriating part. But I'm glad some of us can be honest with ourselves about it without being deranged 🙃

Kelsie Smith

Yeah! Also, really loving 3 to 4 songs on a 12 track album to me is a win! 3 to 4 that immediately go into my regular rotation, 3 to 4 that'll grow on me or ill enjoy on shuffle, and 2 to 3 skips; thats a total win for me 😅

Abby

Agreed honey is a tough listen for me when it literally didn’t have to be

Kelsie Smith

I sort of see like that too. Shes making a point about how shes always TRYING (all I do is try try try) to be a bad bitch, or be cool. Its something we've seen a lot in her discography. *however* theres something to say about being able to do that without coming across as cringey even if thats the point. But I also dont think her careers over bc she wrote a cringey song 😅

Dora Paczur

Fully fully agree with you! I personally think (at this point i might add after 20ish listens) that the album is kinda mid and does not live up to the hype/my expectations, but oh well- lets just say its not for me although i love seeing her happy 🧡 i personally will be going back to her older catalog and thats okay too - its also okay if the new album is totally ur vibe 🤷🏼‍♀️

Bonnie

The music video made me appreciate the album a lot more! I love it so much 😍 Sorry to hear about the hate you’ve been getting 💔 Patreon will always be a safe space!

Leslie

There were so many ways she could have written "I love Travis" but make it showgirl! Their love story is really unique...two people at the height of their success falling in love while navigating long distance and intense touring/game schedules. There was NOTHING to mine for inspiration there?

Kelsie Smith

I saw someone articulate Ruin The Friendship's place on the record as her taking in the massiveness of her life during the eras (like how on the pod she talked ab it being the first time shes let herself feel how huge shes become) and that causing her to spend more time thinking about what her life could've been like if she HAD taken that risk, if she had ruined the friendship. Its not just a song about a specific person; at its core its a lesson. And I think its a lesson that success of the eras tour had her really pondering on. I think thats why it ended up here.

Evgeniya Kuzmina

Justin Timberlake or Fergie or Enrique Iglesias !

Kelsie Smith

Not the passive aggressive honey 😅

kc

i believe ophelia is 10 and elizabeth taylor is 16

kc

it’s that crazy rob guy that is obsessed with her but has horrible taste

Elli

I read the Pitchfork review and I thought it was….fair? Would be interested to hear you chat about that. Also so sorry to hear people are being deranged, I hope you can unplug a bit too!

Lisa Reed

PLEASE CHARLI X TAYLOR vid!!

Kelsie Smith

I sort of agree. I think they ARE extremely well written songs (father figure really stands out to me) that I love for the lyrics, but even the ones that aren't flowery and poetic (wood) are still a bop to me and I simply dont care 😅 its just not a concern to me whatsoever lol

Lisa Reed

OMG FANTANO ALSO?? NICE how does he feel about the mismarketing for this album? is that even on his radar?

Leslie

I think there is a good case to be made for this being her worst album.

Leslie

" it’s not Travis as muse that is the problem, her audience has merged with sport culture and this album is a sport anthem album. " This is a really good point I hadn't considered. She's gained a whole new demographic of fans and her music is reflecting that.

Katelynn

yes exactly! like i thought an interesting concept could have came from her leaving the japan show and going straight to the superbowl then he returned that favor when he randomly surprised her by showing up halfway through a show. that video of her on stage realizing he was there could've been a perfect classic TS song

Kathleen Faye Amorado

Same! I love this album too! Been on repeat since release and it just brings me joy! 🥰

Katelynn

wait why is this sooo true tho hahaha

Maren

Not a fan of the idea of Normani for how to murder your career. I think it's a failure of industry and marketing more than anything, particularly with racism. I like other people's suggestions for artists that have had a career, like JT, J-Lo, even Gwen is still interesting when looking back at her older catalogue and her cultural impact, while letting the younger women just be.

James

Where is the girl who wrote made a rebel of a careless man's careful daughter

Becky Hall

I personally love most of this album but totally respect your opinion and love hearing your reasonings. You are one of the best reactors and I am so glad that I have joined your Patreon! Please be safe out, people are so messed up these days!

Kelsie Smith

Me thinking ab how people were also mad ab the writing on down bad bc she used the phrase down bad and talked ab crying at the gym 😅 But also sometimes her songs just have lyrics like that (and always have), I *like* them a lot of the time even though I love her flowery poetic lyrics. Its just different 🤷‍♀️

Kelsie Smith

One of my biggest Taylor critiques is that it seems like shes always putting her strongest, beltiest vocals in the BACKGROUND. Like girlie I wanna hear it 4D plzzzz

Bella

I would loooove a deep dive examination of the Taylor swift character in the songs. I feel like she is another person writing this album, like the old Taylor swift is DEAD for real.

James

You and Madeline should do a sister songs episode about forever winter bigger than the whole sky and ruin the friendship

stevie

i truly appreciate your candor on this polarizing album, it’s a tough situation as a swiftie to be in because you could always use the quality of the album to defend the backlash. on the other hand, ever since her time magazine interview where she discussed her lack of fear of overexposure or backlash, i maintained amongst my inner circle that she can obviously not foresee that any of it will be her own doing due to a decline in quality of artistic output and not because of some outside force (à la snakegate) acting upon her. like, they’re just waiting for her to make this kind of misstep. it’s almost done so cleverly that you have to entertain the idea that its performance art haha, because it is absolutely so haphazardly put together and off brand for her to make an album this .. low quality. but, i can’t wait to see what discussion it creates here with the snakes and the swiftologist content! 🫶🏻

Elle Kaye

It doesn’t change the impact of the word, but for a small glimpse into what she was thinking: She did a radio interview where they asked her how she chooses to add a swear word or not. And she said she has two criteria: (1) If it has an alliterative or other poetic impact on the line or (2) if she thinks it’s true to what the character in the song would say. So I think Honey is 1 (alliteration with “back off”) and TLOAS is 2 (Kitty’s POV). But again — totally not negating your feelings about her use of the word. It’s loaded and I’m sure it upsets a lot of people.

Sabrina 💖

thank you diva for all you said the taynegativity is so extreme, i can't believe the harrassment you're getting, I'm very grateful to have these safe spaces where we can discuss without severe mental illness occurring

Kelsie Smith

The poems very much go into all these things

Cole

i sorta feel like this album is the first time i’m seeing billionaire taylor swift… she’s always loved sales but i think this is the first time ive really felt like sales have outweighed any artistic intention. almost like she’s been so focused on packaging and aesthetics and the music was an after thought. i think there are some bright moments and i think what i enjoy most about it is that her happiness seems genuine and i think that shines through in the songs. but yeah this has been kinda tough as a swiftie.

Cecilia

I haven’t thought of it like that before! The production of it gagged me so I bet acoustically I would have gotten that a little sooner lol

caroline

Agreed. Another comment put it perfectly. Capitalism is sucking the life out of all of us, but capitalism gives her life force. She’s been unrelatable for a long time in that way, but this is the first time it’s been mask off not hiding it, which is antithetical to her relatable girl next door image.

Kelsie Smith

Same! Ive been having a hard time in some of my typical favorite swiftie spaces, bc as much as people who dont like/are disappointed in the album are fully entitled to have and share and discuss their opinions; its still always gonna suck a little seeing so many people say theh dont like something thats bringing you so much joy, just human nature! (Obvs that in no way means to take those emotions and attack others for feeling differently! Those ppl need to learn how to sit w & process their emotions 😅)

RiskBat

So happy for you getting all the mainstream reach lately but so sorry your family is dealing with some BS because of it. I would be curious to hear from Anthony about similar things (how being seen as a hater has gotten him thousands if not millions of haters and how that impacts his career and life). Also would really like to know if he's ever felt differently about Taylor when he could relate to a song. Like beyond analyzing it is there anything that just hits for him because he could personally relate to it.

Cailee

You've mentioned before that there are songs on this album where you felt like she touched on the topic better in other songs. It would be fun for you and Madeline to do a battle of the songs - which song did it better sort of thing - like father figure vs whos afraid of little old me

mage

I'm not sure it's fair to say her artistry is on a downward trend because of a single project. I don't think we should go doomsday about it. And we can see with Lover that it had layers because she didn't 100% feel safe with him. TLOAS is like a transitionary period for her where she's adjusting to being actually happy and secure. We don't quite know yet what that will look like.

Viktoria Nagy

There’s a poem you can piece together and read if you buy all four variants. And honestly, it’s better and more on-theme with the backstage showgirl concept than anything on the actual album lol. That’s where the “vanilla sweat” perfume comes from.

nevo

I would love a grammys predictions episode. Also, I've asked this before but what did you think of Kali Uchis Sincerely? I know it wasn't full pop but it felt pop adjacent enough to be considered.

mage

I feel like she didn't give herself enough time after writing TTPD.

Midori

Its crazy hearing "lover writing good" coming out of Zack's mouth but I'm here for it as one of the 8 lover defenders in the world 🙂‍↕️

mage

Okay that's deep! Very interesting. My take is that she is referring to herself as this generation's eldest daughter of the music industry. Like they saw how I got torn apart and they armored up to avoid falling victim the way I had to. That's my most interesting and redemptive interpretation but I really like yours.

Katelynn

something i find interesting w fantano is that he LOVES kendrick and at time i think his writing can be clunky like TTPD was at times. so i would love to know what it is specifically about kendrick's writing that speaks more to him

Ivonne Deliz

Good thing I like my friends CANCELLED!

Katelynn

would love for you to do a "fix the album" video but maybe trim down the songs and add "your songs" like have a concept for different songs to add to the tracklist to remove the ones you dont want. for instance i would have had a song surrounding the pain and exhaustion of the tour like what it felt like and how she continued on

Brooke Guido

Good for you for protecting your peace. That is vile that people are reaching out to your mom... It's like... get a life... why do they feel so strongly to go and do that it's ridiculous honestly.

Emanuel

You should do a how to order your career for Rina sayawyama

X

just wanted to loop back and say that i really appreciate how honest you are about your opinions, regardless of what others think about them. Even though we have almost the opposite taste in great taylor albums/songs, I've found new appreciation for them through your videos.

Chloe

I think during a time of increasing political and social unrest, songs like Wishlist reallllly show how out of touch she is. Cancelled too, and I really loved Madeline’s commentary around that. Im certainly not saying that I want her to address political issues because I don’t, but I think that she inadvertently is highlighting issues around privilege/wealth disparity etc those lyrics. That’s only going to hurt her when people are looking for someone to blame for all the bad in the world. ET is a perfect song on the album to me because it’s dramatic and tongue in cheek, also completely serious, but it has self awareness. Plus it goes hard af

Eric

That hate comments are unfortunate but please do continue to speak your mind! We need free thinkers

Rachel

My experience is how to murder your career videos are recommended separately to your Taylor swift content. Your Prince Harry memoir review was the first video I saw from you. YouTube did not recommended your channel until I searched for Taylor specific content

Carolina

you’re cooking here!! love your perspective

Book Witch Kristina

I’m so sorry you’re getting this level of hate, Zach. I always appreciate your thoughtful insights even if I disagree with some of your assessments. I like thoughtful dialogue and different perspectives. You keep being great!

Rachel

I wonder what Lana influences Fantano sees in Taylor. He drew the comparison on Fate of Ophelia. I don’t really see it on that track

DrEmily

Saw this in the movie theater and knew you would just love it

Hanna Cannon Colm

You screaming “AH” is my favorite thing ever

phoenix

I'm so so sorry Dr Swiftologist for the shit you're going through online. I am PhoenixStartsOver on yt and been riding with you a long while and realized I regard you just like my besties so I now belong to the patreon (the one and only paid sub I have for a channel). I can't imagine how hard it is to be targeted like that and I'm so sorry.

KAM

Long time fan of yours Zach, but first time subscriber to Patreon! You are a very gifted speaker and speak so eloquently. I was a little disappointed when I upgraded so that I could hear Madeline’s reaction. Not so much about her opinion, as we’re all entitled to our own opinions, more the lack of voicing her opinion! However, after watching you both talk yesterday, it was great to gain some clarification as to why she felt too flabbergasted to speak! Your intelligence is evident and I’ve always admired your articulation, even when I don’t agree with you! It blows me away that people are threatening you and your family. I’m so sorry that this is happening to you. I rarely comment online, as my skin is not thick enough to deal with the keyboard warriors, but hoped that this would be a safe space to share my admiration of you! Please continue to be vigilant about keeping safe. Looking forward to more content!😊

chelsea blair

I’d love to hear how Anthony Fontana deals with critiquing music that is largely listened to by men vs. by women. Also how he might balance giving true music criticism based on the actual music that doesn’t steer into the indie boy who likes records much cooler than yours.

L. Kelley

I'm so sorry to hear you and your mom are dealing with all that hate. I don't always agree with you but your insight is valuable and deserves to be shared. Enjoy your bestie's wedding! Maybe taking some space from everything will bring you more clarity when you return.

phoenix

There's a lot of good on the album! But the points of "oof 🫣" on it, unfortunately overshine the good. A lot of the production is fantastic - but a lot of the lyrics are very oof.... I think if she would have just said "hey I made a project for fun and also really wanted to have a Burlesque dancer photoshoot, so I did 🤷" and promoted that way- the reception would be COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. If we were not expecting it to be a "masterpiece" and instead had been informed that it was her being silly and making a project out of impulsivity and burst of boredom -- it'd be completely different.

phoenix

I am also constantly floundering between "this is so fun, it's a kiki (except eldest daughter 🫣) it's just her having a moment and the production is great!" And then being like "this is... enormously out of touch and out of pocket for right now"

Alison

Omg Zach! The hate I’m seeing about you on my twitter timeline is breaking my heart!!! Just know this random girl from NYC loves you and highly values your opinion

phoenix

It deeply saddens me the most that the production and vocals are so good. There are some very good jams and sonic glitter here. But so much of the lyrical content is like "hmmmm....I don't know how I feel about that". Like separating most of the lyrics out, this is a solid LP sonically 😭

phoenix

Zach, just remember that you built this empire 🫵🫶 We have your back ♥️

Elena

I love how the last part of the music video is Taylor herself, the eras tour showgirl, with her band, backing vocalists, and dancers. And then she goes to take a bath as she said she did every night after the show, with the imagery (her in the water) that ties it back to the beginning of the video. Point #2, I remember listening to Gaga talk about how she wrote 50 songs for mayhem and had to really flush it out to get the album tracks and Mayhem is perfection. When Taylor was talking about her album, I got a feeling that she only wrote these songs which is guaranteed to have some misses. Maybe she wrote more, I don’t know but I got a feeling that she didn’t write too much.

Lauren Blagden

King I’m so sorry the internet is being so unkind to you!! Esp their homophobic bs, adjust ur crown, we got ur back!!💖💖

Ellen Kay

Sydney Sweeney and Scooter Braun needs to be discussed next Kiki lounge 🤢

Cathy Stephens

Thank you again for being sane about this album. Like, it’s disappointing. I think that the combination of the Eras tour success, her intense insulation from any normal person, and being with a (very nice) football player has maybe broken her brain a little?

Elena

I’m sorry Zach that you get so much hate. I don’t see that side of the internet as I don’t have TikTok and barely use IG (got really bored with it) so I am completely unaware. I will never understand this culture. I disagreed with some of your opinions about the album, but I giggled through the reaction and moved on. Not once did I have the urge to say “well, actually, Zach …” Keep on doing what you are doing. You are good at it!

Tara Cessford

Wait.....as someone with no twitter... why is Zach getting hate online? They hate him cuz they ain't him? I don't get it. I thought Zach's reaction video was largely positive and fun. Are they mad because he liked (some of) the album? Or that he didn't like it enough? Sigh. It's just not that deep.

Meli

Zach, I'm so sorry your family is being dragged into this. I know you can hold your own, and you have grown to drown out the negativity, but those losers going after your family have no sense of decorum. family is the one thing you dont go after

CyrusNomadix

I paused this video and stopped part of the way through Showgirlology yesterday because I am not in the space to hear the criticisms in this moment. This album is giving me hope and joy while I live in a particularly hostile environment. Protecting my peace until I feel safe(r). I'll come around to the not-positive stuff eventually

Mary Massed

Ok WHOA so my algorithm doesn’t really have showgirl hate on it but I just realized I’m getting gaylor content for the first time. I didn’t even notice it at first, they are so subtle! 😅

Toryana Frazier

I'm excited for the Fantano interview especially, but hang in there with all this busy stuff going on! I would ask him who he thinks the scariest group of stans? I don't think it's Swifties, I think it's (redacted due to fear of ______)

Rachelle Longpre

I love Taylor, but this album is so disappointing. Maybe there’s a connection between two great female songwriters (Lana & Taylor) whose work kinda went downhill after getting engaged or meeting "the one". Not saying they’re the same — Taylor’s got way better work ethic — but I can’t help seeing a parallel: two heartbroken girls who turn a bit shallow once they finally get what they wanted. Food for thought. I would’ve loved a happy, catchy, dancy, dramatic, SMART album. To me, it’s her cleverness that’s missing, it just feels lazy. Taylor, whyyy :(

X

he says the people who hate taylor want to say its a bad album and rub that in his face because he likes taylor.

dolp

"thank you LORDE"

Sophie

"Evolution of craft is not a focus of this album" is such a fair way of putting it! You spoke on so many things that have really upset me about this album. She just seems kind of checked out and going for cheap tricks like the "bitches" thing and throwing away the more complicated sides of love. If this is how she leaves things before fully disappearing for a few years I will be pissed.

X

you're right that a lot of pop albums curate from like 30-50 songs. max martin doesn't work that way, though. max martin works a lot closer to: anything that he finishes he thinks is great and expects to be released. that applies to all artists he works with, not just taylor.

Elena

Very interesting. I know he is very particular about a lot of things, but that’s all I really know. What you said makes sense from what I do know about him. He wants his work to be out there making money.

Lisa M

This video is so fucking good. Yes it’s I do agree the project is a pallet cleanse. 12 tracks. I don’t dislike it though. Some songs are ehhhhh and I don’t like the slang and the bitches talk either. I think she is in love now so she doesn’t have to try. Yes. Not masterful. I am an eldest daughter of my younger sister and I do not relate to that song at all. I’m glad there were a lot of other great albums this year from pop divas. I definitely would like to hear more from Anthony Fantano, because I appreciate his work too. And I loved your interview with him.

Katy Anne

Curious what Fantano would say about his recent Halsey review.. any regrets? or is he sticking to the main character commentary?

Miranda

Just realized this album is the first pancake with Travis as muse instead of *cough* someone else she consciously cut ties with. That makes it better for me lol

dolp

I think its more of a instagram thing because i am on twitter and i dont really see any hate for him

dolp

Wi$h Li$t is one of the best songs on the album imo, it just has such a emotional impact in my mind

Emily Silva

I can see why many people including Taylor fans don’t like like this album but it’s crazy how people will take things they don’t like and take it to the extreme and harass others from it. That’s insane. I personally liked it for the most part but I respect others that don’t.

Sunjana Finn

Can the bone collector come back and collect some dirt on the Karlie Kloss Taylor Swift friendship or maybe now the Charlie XCX Taylor relationship?

Paola Portes

So sorry to hear they targeted your mom, Diva! After a weekend of re-listens to make up my mind lol I honestly do like the album. It’s just very catchy. Are they her best written songs? Obviously not. Do they get stuck on your head? Well yeah. And maybe that was her intention?! For the songs to be just about the vibes lol and not the lyricism?! There is a market out there for that as well.. and that may simply be her target this go around. She keeps saying how tired she is after the eras tour. Taylor is such an easy target to hate, because of all of her success, that her having a mid album makes the maniacs go absolutely bananas. It’s crazy out there, so I cleaned up my instagram where I only a handful of creators. I don’t think it’s fair of us as fans to judge her as harshly as some are out there, just because she’s in love and her songs become more upbeat. Some are not just critiquing her writing (WHICH VALID) but judging her because suddenly she’s no longer miserable, and writing ultra emotional, sad songs. Love your commentary, as always.

Laura M

Been having fun with the album and have sort of been distancing myself from most of the negative chatter because people cannot be normal about it. I think there are legitimate criticisms but it's so drowned by the crazy.

calm98

I personally love the album but I can understand why people don't vibe with it. It's not her strongest lyrically but the production and vibes are soooo good. Ophelia has been stuck in my head constantly. But also the people harassing you and your mum is insane 😭 that's pure mental illness from the haters

Ellajoy

Always love to hear your unfiltered thoughts Zach! So sorry about the hateration especially on your mum.. that’s terrible. Guard your peace! Agree with the lyrics… it’s just not there in this album. Interested to see how she’ll write going forward. Hopefully not like this…

Erin

I would loveee a full bone collector ep on the crook who was caught!

Amber

✨ Have a couple kids got the whole block looking like you ✨

Sara Klein

YES to ruin the friendship

Gabrielladid

Im so sorry for the emotional distress deranged people are causing you. You are the reallest person on this internet, you so unnafraid to speak you opinions in the most clear, well spoken and respectful way. Is there anything us “snakes” can do to help?

dolp

No cause that's a good line hear me out

Katie

You deserve your flowers for speaking authentically and for leading thoughtful discussion that critically engages with Swift’s (and other artists) work. And I deeply admire your ability to set boundaries with how viewers engage with YOUR work. Thanks for sharing with us all!

Elaine

This video is EVERYTHING! Best video since??? Oh my days! I can’t remember. Blank Space?

Elaine

I listened to the album about 5 times before I read the reviews, and it was by far the best decision made. I was reading the negative British reviews and I just didn’t get it. American reviews were for the most part more positive. But I believe reading any review could have ruined my listening experience. I also managed to avoid spoilers, which helped tremendously

Mo

I’m really enjoying the album as a whole! Some weak moments, but that’s true of every album (with no one around to tweet it). I reject the idea that fun and good humored= unserious, and I was pleasantly surprised by the new and fairly insightful view on love through the album. I think “Had to make my own sunshine, but now the sky is Opalite” would serve as a thesis statement for the overall POV on love on this record, but to each their own!

Sara Klein

For video ideas, a "year in review" of pop girlies, not just ranking but more like a meta review of if this was a good year, what was up this year, etc

Hayleeeeeee

yeah.... the divas will stay!!!!

Hayleeeeeee

the internet is always a dark place, but I love your attitude and will continue to stan! ask fantano about The Great Impersonator pls

Ash Owens

I’ll defend you to the grave

Ash Owens

Showgirl mid BUT has given us the best Taylor music video in half a decade

Sara Macc

Such a good video! Def up there with Cardigan and Willow for me! 🧡

Rachel Bullock

Her best self-directed music video yet. Sincerely, truly.

Rachel

Omg pleeeease lol we need to hear it

Rachel

I love this idea because I feel like the only deep dives on Karlie are from gaylors. Please inject some sanity lol

Sofie DLC

I'd love to know Fontano's approach to critiquing music and if it has changed with the current anti-critic landscape

Sofie DLC

Maybe with Showgirl and the underwhelming songs you could directly compare them to songs of same thesis but done better, and explain why the Showgirl songs are worse and show a decline.

Sofie DLC

I totally agree, and think it was pretty diverse and comparatively unique to her previous pop stuff. I just can't jive with some lyrics.

A

Thank you for your thoughtful commentary! I agree, TFOO is most definitely her best self-directed music video by far. Honestly the bar is set so damn high for Taylor that at this point it is so hard for me to critique her writing lol

Becky

I just had to google Zara Larson.

Reagan

Aw I hope you get some rest and enjoy your life!

Cassidy Robbins

I love your critiques. I feel like you are the only person who gives TRUE and HONEST feedback. People hate to see someone have correct opinions. Hand hearts all the way home🫶🫶

Chelsea Rose Riggs

The fact that she’s done so many interpolations from artists who have struggled to get their masters etc. is something to think about

Ohdearjon

He can’t string a sentence together. How much is there to mine?

Chas

This is a large part of how I feel. For some reason, this upbeat album makes me feel confused and even a little sad. Zach called the album “unfocused” and that’s a big part of it, I think. There’s something with the exception of Ruin the Friendship that feels inauthentic in terms of her writing and what she’s actually trying to say. I’ve listened to TTPD more since the album dropped to help me re-connect with her. Really like 5 songs on TLOAS but the other half of the album (second half + Eldest Daughter) is truly some of her weakest, laziest writing to date.

Kat Johnson

i’d love to hear anthony clarify on his halsey review since his verbiage was a bit tone deaf in relation to her illness. i don’t think i ever saw him address that.

Victoria

The only credited interpolation is George Michael. The others are likely coincidental similarities

Tammy Sawyer

I hear everything that you and Madeline are saying, but the songs are living rent free inside my head! My brain has stuck them there and enjoying them, all day!

Anna Rama

Like you and many others here I have been and continue to be on a journey with this album. I don't want to go into that too much. I just want to say, at day 4 post release date, I think the most interesting theme of Showgirl is power, another reason why Father Figure should have been track five like you said. Obviously, she goes on about the power others have exerted over her (music industry, past lovers, online comments, cool kids, fate), but she also very openly leans into her own power (again, in Father Figure, but also in Elizabeth Taylor, Opalite, Actually Romantic, Wood, Honey, Cancelled! and most gloriously in The life of a showgirl). In TTPD she displayed her most embarrassing thoughts and emotions about love, here she's showing her complex and unflattering thoughts about power, embracing the glory, privilege and the ugliness of being thé Diva. Eldest daughter and Wishlist are her 'I'm too soft for all of it' moments in a world of Bejeweleds, Karmas, and Who's afraid of little old mes. I agree with you that the actual lyrics are disappointing.

K.C.

🙏🙏🙏 this is where I go for real discourse and to feel sane 🙏🙏🙏

K.C.

bless but you cannot hear the Jackson 5 groove and say it's a coincidence. and, honestly, on the 1% chance it is--that's a bigger problem for Taylor

K.C.

and from a place of wanting the best out of the artist and art!

Yohaha

Using my boyfriend & a lot of male reactors (who could be just lying for views) as a reference (limited sample size ik): normal people/straight male/people who never read into lyrics love this album. My bf said this album has some of his favorite taylor songs on first listen.

Chelsea Rose Riggs

I’m mostly saying that currently majority of the songs have a relation to artists who have fought for their masters etc. & she was so obsessive about it being 12 songs because she has 12 albums. “Ruin the friendship” pays homage to a Lenny Kravitz song & he also dealt with fighting for his masters & Zoe is friends with Taylor.. it’s starting to all click a lot more for me personally lol

stephy j. moore

Agreed - and something that feels almost talked about invertadly on Showgirl. I've been thinking about what the character of a showgirl looks and imo it's someone struggling to get by while trying to become a star. To me, Taylor is a star cosplaying as a showgirl. I wish we could've written from the perspective of her dancers like a Blowin Smoke by Kacey Mushraves type thing. Also there are so many iconic showgirl-to-star examples and she chose to make up a story for the title track to somehow "prove" she's the best showgirl of them all. And I do think Taylor deserves the success she's attained and acknowledge the struggles she's had to conquer to get to being the most powerful diva on the planet, but she also had resources most showgirls don't get and I think TLOAS could've showed that sweat and grit through a real life lens of showgirls in less empowered places.

K.C.

✨ topic to discuss: the lack of narrative tension on each track. FF has some, but she's also in her dominant mode. GOOD WRITING requires tension -- a desire, an obstacle, a mystery. I love the mental exercise of going through each track and considering the missing tension that would improve the writing the most. Ex: Fate of Ophelia -- where's the writing of the man (men?) who almost made you go crazy? Who played with your sanity the most? Where's the **water**???

Chelsea Rose Riggs

and on genius there are several other songs that are credited for interpolations!

Jack

Wait this is so interesting what other songs have u cooked this up for

Jack

Literally me with Ophelia today I’m confidently singing pledge allegiance to your hands your team your vibes Idccc

Clara

I hope you're doing ok Zach. I'm genuinely shocked and appalled by how much hate you are receiving.. I hope you know there's many of us who are rooting for you! Swiftologist positivity! ❤️

K.C.

oh thanks! I love thinking in terms of editing notes & what global note would have the most impact on improving a piece of written work-- Opalite--there's a gesture towards vanquished tension but it's not defined. something was overcome, but what exactly? there's an attempt with the "you were in it for real / she was on her phone" & the table/dinner/starving extended metaphor--but it kinda lands without clear emotionality (think of her better writing: "Do I really have to chart the constellations in his eyes?" to express romantic exhaustion). So I'd say for Opalite the tension missing is clarity of the vanquished emotion--loneliness? solitude? hopelessness? what does the Opalite sky therefore represent by contrast (warmth, union, joy, future) vs a vague feeling of "all good now"? Eldest Daughter -- lol would love this rewritten as a defense of millennial cringe at large BUT WITHOUT BECOMING IT. Morrissey has the better lyric: "it takes strength to be gentle and kind". fight the feeling, not the language.

Kiki🩷

I just wanna say it’s insane Taylor release an album everyone dislikes and people make it your problem!!! How is this your fault? 😭💀 people know Taylor swift won’t read their comment so they ship their hate to you

P.R. Dayvonne

So I'm having a real disconnect with the theme sometimes, but I just watched her on Jimmy Fallon and she said quite a lot about the concept of this album and how she's bringing it to the world - like some sort of performance art lol? idk I think it's like the showgirl part is the chaos of this album - still mid tho. Ouuu, I'd be curious to hear Anthony's thoughts on her re-recording process and buying back her music, and also if his opinions on any of her albums have changed over the years?

K.C.

ooo HOW TO MURDER A CAREER: MADONNA. so many other legacy artists retain their respect. Madonna is a crazy study in not letting go of youth culture

H

I thought Fantano's review of Showgirl was actually very well considered (as opposed to his Halsey review, for example). I'd like to hear him speak more about his onions on Taylor's early work (debut to red)

Blake

Pleaseeeeee Gwen Stefani how to murder your career. The material is there!!!

Natasha Nelson

I agree with everything! So well put

K.C.

ooh or Nicki lol

Maxine Carter

The hate you’re receiving is just soooo disproportionate!!! You critique music, you’re extremely entertaining, if people don’t want to watch you they don’t have to. They need to calm down no pun intended 🤣

h

This is so funny because I saw a comment recently, don't know if it was here or Reddit, that said Taylor and Sabrina's most recent albums should have swapped titles. It was just a joke, but it kinda made sense a bit lol

katiecrow

New patreon member here! So sorry to hear that you and your family are receiving so much hate. Love your takes. Can confirm as an eldest daughter that the song sucks

Megan

Sending you and Madeline love, people have no thought

h

It's true, I agree

KattyAnn

I immediately liked this album and have been trying to come up with reasons I can articulate. It’s hard because it’s a vibe thing and then I realized that’s exactly what it is. This album sounds, looks and feels great. In full disclosure - I am pretty flexible when it comes to Taylor in that I like pretty much all of it for different reasons. On this one, I am just not fussed about some of the details that made me love TTPD or prior albums. I just like it because it feels good. The production and her voice both sound amazing to me. The visuals are chef’s kiss and I love them. Are they super connected in a cohesive way? I guess I don’t need them to be? Too busy jamming and feeling good vibes to spend too much time on it. Maybe that’s a luxury, but it’s one I am willing to accept. 😊

h

About the settling comment, I feel mean thinking it but I agree. These songs really don't communicate to me anything about being true soulmates and him being the love of her life. I think she just wants to get married and have a family, and he's nice and fun and likes her a lot. It all feels very shallow. I find it interesting how a lot of fans are saying, well that's what happens when you meet your true love. It's not very exciting to talk about because it's safe and calm and stable. But I don't feel that way at all about my husband. Despite the safety and security of it, I could go on and on about how thrilling I still find it that we found each other, how deeply we connect, the pure magic of our bond and love for each other. I think a lot of people who have also settled see something familiar in this and like it, but I find it a little sad coming from someone like Taylor who seems to truly want a once in a lifetime love that feels like magic

Rhajaa Wright

Wasn't impressed with Swag I, but gotta check out Swag II

hehe

as a male who NEVER cares or thinks about the lyrics, i dont mind the album, but there’s no reason for me to stream this over her much-better 1989, reputation or midnights. the first 4 tracks are good, everything else is subpar to what she has already created.

Green Wolf

Could it all be intentional? What if she intends to share the royalties with the artists? If she had credited the artists, the record companies would have to get a cut, I believe. However, Zach doesn't want to talk about this element.

Vivian

Why do you think Taylor Swift sparks such strong opinions, especially from people who don’t even like her? Crazy behavior from fans is common but with Taylor it feels like it’s everyone: haters, casual listeners, random men at my office with a strange need to come tell me that they think she’s mid lol. I wonder why she triggers such strong reactions?

Chelsea Rose Riggs

I think this will come out regardless & my will all be legal. I also wouldn’t be surprised if her & Charli do a feature with actually romantic lol, especially because Lorde is basically interpolated on CANCELLED

e

girl omg what was the budget for the music video aahhhhh

Angela

I agree with you mostly but I think the difference I’m noticing in this album is the lack of anxiety surrounding love. I’m not sure if that’s a good or bad thing for her art in the long term. I also think it was maybe not the best idea to do an album in the midst of the most grueling tour almost any artist has ever done. Either way, i hated Lover and survived. I happen to really enjoy the album but I have confidence those who hate this one will find something to like again.

Chas

Fascinating topic to explore!

Linneae

Omg I think you cracked it thank you!! This is exactly why I'm so bored by this album already!

Ella Clarke

Apparently Joe is about to star in hamlet idk if the fate of Ophelia is supposed to be a reference to that but if it is then she’s a little bit genius for that

Nicola

Have to give it to Fantano, his review is very fair imo ... sigh*

Jojobear

this is the part where I just get sad if I'm honest. Whether it was die hard 'fans' or people who hate her, it is completely unacceptable to spout hate like that. and it just makes consuming art not fun anymore. all this over a pop album by a pop star? it's insane to me. The comedian Ronny Chieng really was speaking the truth when he said having access to all the world's information in your phone is making people dumber.

Trish Veneziano

Thank you Leslie! I also saw your comment about Joe. I think Taylor realized Joe never really fit the narrative she wrote about him and she’s reimagining that era with Travis as the real invisible string.

Vanessa Gutierrez

I share your “disappointment” with the concept of the album too Zach… the way she spoke about it on the New Heights episode led me to think of a more glamorous take on the concept. Of course her personal life was going to be reflected in it but I wasn’t expecting it in such simple lyrics, I was hoping for a more nuanced take on those days backstage of the eras tour. Once I leave those ideas behind, I enjoy most of the album and I agree the visuals are excellent!!!!

Tanner K

It was so satisfying to see Zack get exactly what he wanted.

Vanessa Gutierrez

BTW I just saw a clip of Jimmy Fallons interview explaining how she approached the writing of this album and it aligns better with what we got

Riss Power

Thinking about the interviews surrounding the Miss Americana doc where Taylor was like "I dismantled the misogyny in my own mind. There is no such thing as a bitch, there is no such thing as being bossy there's just a boss." What happened to that mindset, Taylor?

Jared Little

Oooo what if you did a side by side analysis of sympathy is a knife and actually romantic? Like “Sympathy is ACTUALLY a Knife” or something like that

Lynn

Please do Lola Young. I love Messy! X Omg, enjoy your besties wedding Zach! Have a lovely time, have a lovely dance, shake that ass. Rushing around the content creator version of the ERAS tour lmao. I love how to murder your career so will be looking forward to that. Thanks Zach!

Lynn

I agree I thought it would be different, but then again behind the scenes she was falling in love. Tbh I don't mind some of the more simple lyrical choices she has made. Especially after tortured poets which was incredibly nuanced and full of lore. This album can be enjoyed by everyone who doesn't know anything about her. So im kinda happy with album. I like over half of the songs so I'm good with it x

Lynn

I agree with this. I think this album is a palate cleanser after tortured poets. I'm enjoying the album so far. Love the video for fate of ophelia! I don't like them all but like enough to make it worth it. Lover was not my favourite album either

s.gbl

The most annoying thing about these past few days is that people disguise pure hate as criticism... which sucks because valid criticism gets lost between all the crazy takes. It is obvious that people are uncomfortable with Taylors success and are just waiting to see her fail. Also a lot of people just post blatant hate about her because they know it will get views. I am interested in hearing a more normal discourse within the fandom in a few weeks, when people are no longer in our business, because I do think Taylor is at an interesting point creatively and I think it will be interesting to see how she responds to the criticism because we know she usually does...

s.gbl

omg especially because the concept is sooo interesting and we know what she is capable of and it shines through in some of the tracks but it definitely lacks the details and the essence that makes Taylor so special. If the album was more focused they really could've made a great pop album. I don't know where they went wrong tbh maybe it was done to fast because Taylor was on tour?

Abby

I think comparing Lover and TLOAS is interesting but I think there is also some interrogation to be done on Taylor creating art that will appeal to her partner. She’s been with pretentious dickheads in the past who I think made her question her taste and her work and if it was really art. But Travis wouldn’t be doing that, TLOAS is exactly the kind of album that would appeal to him. Even if they weren’t together he would be bopping to this. And I do think this is an album she made for him. Is this album up for contention for the Grammys? If she released it outside of the window…I think that’s interesting.

Helia Bressler

I feel like I need your thoughts on every second of this promotional release and just overall!!! This album has me needing constant hand holding…..🤔

Ingrid Cruz

Hi! New here — I really enjoyed the video exploring how Taylor’s perspective on cheating evolved across her songs. I’d love to see a similar analysis, but focused on power itself — how her view of power has changed through the years, culminating in Father Figure.

h

It's interesting that we got yet another song that talks about cheating here, in Ruin the Friendship. I was kind of shocked when I heard the part about "your girlfriend was away, should've kissed you anyway" 😆 like OMG Taylor why do you love cheating so much hahah

Abby

I’m surprised Fantano wanted to come talk about TLOAS after his meltdown about Actually Romantic…

Anushka Mishra

Not to put baldheaded scallywag on the spot, but exactly that, why does he brings morality into his every review? He expects ARTISTS, specially females, to behave like mother Teresa, have purest and righteous feelings, and that is the only things acceptable to him when they put out songs. Honest feelings are only acceptable to him if it fits into his rose-colored right and wrong, black and white (like old Taylor). For example, he didn't like Ruin the friendship song because to him Taylor is suggesting to audience to make out with a guy who is dating someone else. Like there is so much more depth / layers to that song. (its my favourite)

Fiona

ooh it'd be interesting to compare Father Figure to Change

Kaitlyn

I think the way a lot of people are approaching this album is not how Taylor intended it to be approached. This album is supposed to be fun and light hearted. Do I think some lines are strange to say the least? Yes. This album is not made for us to completely unpack and try to decipher like TTPD though. She just wants everyone to have fun with this album and I hope everyone can.

elena

yo jo

Becca

I’ve been thinking the same thing about this album vs like reputation and lover. She’s not scared she’s gonna lose Travis it seems, unlike the anxiety in basically the entirety of Joe and her’s relationship. So we got a lighthearted bop filled album because that’s a reflection of how she felt a year ago and now, as she has said.

Agata

I love your commentary on the music industry, so my idea is either for an interview with Anthony or your individual content. I've noticed that, in general, music podcasts and celebrity interviews are very lackluster. The hosts (I don't want to call these people reviewers or journalists) are more likely to pander to the stars than ask them interesting questions or provide insightful reviews of the albums they produce. The plethora of Taylor Swift interviews currently on YouTube are simply wasted opportunities for good questions. Nothing interesting. How many times will we learn that she bakes bread? I'm curious why this is happening and why content creators simply don't have the courage to say something constructive.

K.C.

🤗 yeah Zach said it more plainly^ that she doesn't want anything on this album. it's boring to me, too, sadly. at least TTPD (which took a min to grow on me) was wrestling with something in every song

Marylovesowls

I would love a sister song episode with father figure/my tears ricochet/or any other songs about the subject!

Mary

Where did you meet him?

SeraRose

She keeps saying that this album encapsulates how she feels in the moment and I'm considering that maybe she does just predominantly feel "la la la opalite I love Travis life is great at the moment and I'm vibing". Like, maybe we're not yet considering the complexity (or as you say she's just writing around the vulnerability inherent in protecting the relationship hasn't quite hit on the best way to do so yet)

SeraRose

I would like to hear what you think about what she says to Zane Lowe regarding how the perception of art is subjectively received and how it changed over time

SeraRose

Her comments to Fallon helped clarify to me what she thinks the album is about

Katie

Video request with a playground for Female Rage: The Musical. What are your A & B storylines? Which songs from the TS discography are you including? What musical is it most similar to (like Mama Mia campy love story??)?

Jojobear

I was hoping for an abba - super trouper vibe song. "Somewhere in the crowd there's you". I think wish list could have been so much more about how she was falling in love with this man who was making her think of having kids & a house, while being mostly apart from him & doing a huge tour. I imagine she had moments of "this is what everyone wants, what I have right now, I have it all... But I just want this man & a life with him". From experience, when you first meet the person who is changing your wants for something like marriage & kids, everything feels insignificant until you're back with that person. "Work? Friends? I don't care! I just want this person!" Imagine that while you're on the biggest tour in the world.... I can't imagine it Taylor! That's why I want you to tell me while you make me dance.

Chris

How to murder your career: Justin Timberlake

Jojobear

Oh man I hated season 4 of Buffy too! Seasons 1-3 are my everything though. Rewatch them every October!

Jojobear

I truly truly wish I'd stayed off the internet this album release and just spun my little orange sparkly record in the safety of my own home & enjoyed the album for what it is. this has reminded me how vicious and unhinged the internet has made some people. Where people get off sending threats to someone.... Over pop music!! horrid.

Terry B

Zach you gotta copyright your image and Swiftologist trademark name! Ppl are using your name as click-baits 😡 Soon, you and Madeline will need lawyers for "C&D" + security guards (Drew! 🤣) maternal insults are unforgivable 😡 shame shame Ophelia video $$ galore on big screen! cast ERAs dancers extra bonu$$ Girl Boss rewards loyal staff 🙂‍↕️ Sword ⚔️ fight on Long Boat 🛶 my fav scene (She LOVES Red hair eh?!) She had fun during the production 🙂‍↕️

Terry B

Taylor’s obviously fascinated by old Hollywood. Screen siren Esther Williams' biography is darker: after filming, she swam her life out of pool to avoid handsy co-actors 😱! Also, 2 stars wrote Big, tall Katharine Hepburn (had suffragette parents), took no sh** from studio exec's audition couch 🛋️ & evil costars e.g. John Barrymore said let’s rehearse in his trailer. She stood over him, shame-staring 😒 til he mumbled, “Uh, see you on the set” 🤣 CONSCIENCE needs no defence 🥳

Manjari

NO. DO GWEN STEFANI. Truly. Even if you don’t care about her that much, she would be the perfect subject.

Saadia Sajjad

yes, i couldn’t have said it better myself. the rest of the review was ok and most i agreed with but the commentary on Ruin the Friendship really pissed me off. Like can we not act like the morality police for 5 seconds? Also later in the song the girlfriend becomes an ex sooo. This song is obviously about the regret and guilt for not speaking up when u had the chance. p.s. does anyone think You Belong With Me is about the same guy??

George

the hooks are fucking catchy and that's it

Manjari

Hi! Nice to meet you 👋 I just joined the patreon today because I am DISTURBED and exhausted by the vapid discourse from every angle of the internet since Friday. Longtime follower but now was the time to get out of there. I just want to say that I am so sorry that you are being targeted to this degree and to the point that your mother has been dragged into this. I want to talk about this album of course but that was just shocking and heartbreaking to hear and also scary and insane, and I needed to virtual hug you as a human. The psychosis of this one album has genuinely made me question the intelligence of humanity as a whole. ❤️

Manjari

Here’s my album hot take, totally up for discussion. And the album is impossible to discuss without Taylor herself, the entity and the celebrity, which makes it feel impossible to be objective. Without “her,” it’s mid at best and I’ll grant you that. But with “her,” I believe there’s more than meets the eye, and has an underlying greatness. She purposely set out to create a pop album presenting a much lighter version of herself. After 11 albums of soul-bearing, this is the one she never felt like she could make. Wood?! Cmon. She took her image way too seriously in the past and had the constant need to prove herself. That facade feels gone here. It oddly feels more free and vulnerable in the “cringe” as they say of it all. The terrible 2016 jargon she uses is I believe satire and a commentary on internet speak and trends past which if she used current language the satire would be lost. She’s truly shedding her known image on this record and THAT is so interesting to me. I get your criticism about the concept not being executed accurately but also, I have found peace with her take on it even if my hand needed to be held for it lol. It’s her 12th record. I don’t want or need or expect perfection from her. I trust and enjoy her journey. I legit like TLOAS, like a lot. Is it bad? No. Is it groundbreaking? No. But oddly for her as an entity and celebrity , it kind of is. She’s giving us shock value, scandal, infectious bops and bizarrely safe lyrics. I’m still unpacking but this is where I stand today. Oh, but Wish list and cancelled are forever skips though.

Andrew Gomez

I was so shocked by the production I truly thought we were getting big bangers with max Martin maximalist production. I thought the whole album was going to sound like the first 4 tracks.

Alma

Would LOVE a deep dive on Wi$h Li$t! So curious to hear your thoughts on the psychology of writing this song as a billionaire, the tradwife overtones, and why she has said it’s her favorite song in every interview. Stay strong! Thank you so much for your wonderful content 🙏❤️

Pooh Khanum

My two cents: I don’t think the song is incoherent or dishonest to Ophelia. Yes, a huge part of the character is thematically prisoned by the patriarchal constructs of her society and the men that entrap her in their mousetraps. But you cannot isolate her from the ongoing action. The play starts medias res. We know that Hamlet and Ophelia were in love and wrote each other letters. Hamlet is the one who says “I loved thee not” — to Ophelia’s surprise. But this is the same girl who went to Hamlet a few nights before (the suggestion being she’s there to warn him). All of this sounds too much like Taylor’s whole life for since she started dating Joe. Both Joe and Matty did this to her: they made her believe they loved her and that this love would last forever, only to then leave her and ask her to get herself to the nunnery. And she did (the asylum). Before Ophelia drowns, she sings a song too sprawling and hysterical to even be a song. It is more of a cluster of intense vibrations that convey more than a message a feeling, an affect. This would be TTPD. The final sing before she drowns; and then, her HEART was saved from the fate of Ophelia. It did not drown, it was saved. Where is the servitude in the song? She has a voice, she has agency. She has literally written her OWN songs her own way and sung it how she wants. But yes, she did need help. This man is no Hamlet, doesn’t perform soliloquies she’ll never see. Is Hamlet not also a critique of men? You would much rather the status quo be upheld? I don’t want to politicize a TAYLOR SWIFT song; but if you wanna go there… I understand that often times Taylor gets lost in the sauce. But I always identify the story, the intention. Because one thing I know for sure is that Taylor is neither dumb nor is she inane. She can get distracted, but the song gives me a solid interpretation not only of Ophelia but Taylor’s own life. And it is great that the song sounds so cool. I assume that had Ophelia been saved, she, too, might have done a full 180. She would have been dug out of her grave. You do not come back from such an Event to do more of the same. Every repetition has something truly new to it. We blame the text, but never the reader.

Leni Doom

That’s what I thought too!

Becki

Intriguing that Adsense increases in August onwards. I would love a video that delves into the financials of being a content creator as everyone seems super cagey about this

cbd1996

I love this take, because the whole idea of her being saved by a man and that this upholds the patriarchy, takes me back to the quote from The Perks of Being a Wallflower, "we accept the love we think we deserve". The way I see it, having had toxic lovers in my past, a person traumatized by love needs to have agency to let herself be loved right, to change her own mindset and understand that she deserves good love, real love, and accept that love.

Bianca Bee

15:03 I believe there's a difference in quality because her love for Joe was still kinda complicated, so she still had so many issues to untangle and go through. There's so much anxiety woven in her relationship with Joe, while that anxiety is nonexistent with Travis.

Kylee

(See me original comment from his reaction video) Hey ChatGPT has Maxx worked with Zara Larson? Yes? That’s cool. Hey ChatGPT? Who’s Zara Larson?

Kylee

I think that’s kind of the point though too. I saw somebody comment on the Elizabeth Taylor visualizer that they were excited to go and Google who she was after. I replied I was jealous that they got to discover who she was for the first time. In my opinion, they were about to get their mind blown twice that night. Elizabeth Taylor was arguably the most famous person of the 20th century. She has her own deep lore + works to dive into if someone so chooses to (hence the reason why Taylor has pulled from it throughout her career). These are not boring or frivolous themes or ideas to have to research, and it’s not like we live in a time when looking things up are strenuous. Just ask your phone, learn something new, and move on. It’s that simple. Also, why does it have to be 1989? I’ve had this discord before, and trust me, I’m guilty of it too. At this point in the discography, if you’ve been following along, then it’s almost impossible not to want to compare or categorize a songs into a previous era. We all do it, I even do it with song that aren’t Taylor. But we got to take a step back and use the (500) Days of Summer rule of thumb: what are our expectations vs. reality? Try to remove those expectations from your next listen of the album, and you might find something new about it for yourself to connect to.

Nina Evan Penny

my feelings on the album have been ricocheting back and forth too but i think where im landing is that ive made my peace w a shallow album full of bobs. Im bopping! The more i let it just be fun and silly and not take it too seriously, the more songs i love.

Kylee

‘Daisy’s bare naked, I was distraught. He loves me not, he loves me not’

Nina Evan Penny

Also i dont think shes given up on bigger dreams and is now saying all she ever wanted was a man. She got the things she wanted, Check ✅. Theres practically nothing else she could strive for in her industry bc shes achieved so much (tho she will keep striving). This is between the lines of Prophecy imo- ‘i put my dreams at the top of my list and now, looking back w everything in my belt, i wish i had someone to share it all w.

Kylee

The idea of Ratty as Hamlet is kind of sending me. 💀 👌

Nina Evan Penny

My takes: - opalite and honey are flawless pop and wouldnt be getting hate in another context. - just let wood be camp. Its fun, silly, ppl will warm up to it bc its got a great beat and is catchy as hell. - wishlist and eldest daughter are the only necessary skips - father figure is my track 5 - i love the subtle presence of the rat thru out. Almost every song has a reference to him. Id LOVE a swiftologist decode of this

SatelliteSnail

Suggestions… How to Murder Your Career: ABBA* How to Save a Career Brainstorm Session: Kesha *not throwing shade at ABBA but I genuinly want to learn about the group

Dancho

I would be very interested to hear your opinion about sort of the “death” of the music video. We’re all aware of the significance that music videos held back in the day and up until the last decade maybe. But in the past few years I’ve noticed that no one seems to care about music videos anymore - a fan might watch it once and that’s it. They accumulate the amount of views in a year they once did in a day or a week. I just find that interesting and was wondering if it’d be a topic of interest for you to explore. When do you think this all started? What do you think prompted it? Just a suggestion! Take care!

Carrie Steffen

If Taylor gets a ton of “no substance” feedback for Showgirl, then her next album will be focused on being deep and substantial.

Rachel H

I am brand new to the Patreon and I love hearing you talk like this. It’s refreshing and I feel like I’m seeing the real critic. You’re not keeping me at arm’s length like you understandably do on YouTube videos. I agree that this album is mid. I’m going to explore more around here and thank you (and Madeline) for all of your hard work.

Juby

It would have been an interseting song approached ifshe spoke to how hardthe eras tour and how she low key hated some parts of it throughthe eyes of a show girl. that would be a heightened version of vulnerability to break this constant need for her to voice how grateful she is about the tour. There are ways to be vulnerable outside of her love relationships. i just feel so silly telling everyone this alumb is going to be pulling all the energy from the tour and capslating it into an alum. IF yiu dissasociate you can pretend she's talking to us but only in like 4 wongs or so. SorrY typos phone is acti g slow

Aly

Some months down the line, I'd love to see a podcast episode where you and Madeline discuss your most played TS songs. I noticed when I binged a lot of the older podcast episodes that went into her previous albums there were a lot of comments along the lines of "I love this song but I don't play it much" or conversely "I listen to this one a lot but it isn't a favorite" and it would be interesting to see the difference between ranked favorites and most listened to songs.

Ash

It may be too late, but I would love to hear Anthony Fantano’s take on how Taylor makes each new album with criticisms from the previous album in mind, and which of her albums he feels were most successful in addressing its predecessor’s shortcomings. What do y’all think she will try to change on the next album based on the chatter around TLOAS?

Stamkitty

I like Actually Romantic but do think she wrote it in part because it’s Matty adjacent. She can’t write another song about him but there is still a whiff of him and that energy. Old habits die screaming. Ready for the Swiftologist decode

Stamkitty

“Can I go where you go, can we always be this close” captures that perfect moment tinged with the lurking worry. “Tell me for real, do you think it’s forever”. Elizabeth Taylor asks the same question.

Jordan Stevenson

The "should" is doing a lot of work here. What she said in the New Heights podcast is that this is the complex folklore storytelling + a beat and like babes, that's exactly what this is. So what you're saying is essentially she *should* make something that is less complex/interesting/unique because... that's what 1989 did? On showgirl, there are lines that make you think (when you know, you know/and when you don't, you don't), things that make sense only once you've heard the whole song (everything on ruin the friendship), and things that most people might have to google (I'd cry my eyes violet/elizabeth taylor). It's funny to me that the majority of the criticism I'm seeing is that the lyrics are bad, but then I'm also seeing that the lyrics are too complicated/weird/hard to understand. Like, because my husband (and me!) loves Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor, he heard "cry my eyes violet" and it had immediate resonance and meaning for him, a special kind of romanticism and imagery that is transcendent. That moment I had when I heard "we can plant a memory garden" in the great war. like everyone likes different lines/different things about taylor songs, that's what makes her so brilliant. just because you're not connecting doesn't mean she "should have" done something different.

Rachel

When TTPD came out, I had a feeling that this album would end up being absorbed by the Eras Tour in the general public's consciousness. I'm feeling this way about TLOAS as well. To a casual fan, there's nothing memorable about either album. They'll become albums for fans looking for deep cuts. I kind of feel like Taylor is too big now to have another album that truly captures the world again, like 1989, folk/evermore, and to some extent, Red. I may even lump reputation in there too, if for nothing but the shock value. It's interesting that she seems to be trying to make TLOAS a big thing, when really, I think it's going to be lumped in with the Eras era, rather than being something show-stopping that stands the test of time. I have mostly enjoyed it, but it also sounds like she put it together in haste. I think it shows that she wrote it in the midst of tour.

Rachel

I almost wonder if, similar to Midnights, TLOAS will make more sense to us in hindsight... not in terms of a breakup, but, maybe it needs to simmer

Rachel B

I think it’s only natural for any artist to be so prolific in such a short time period, to have the work eventually suffer in the quality. I still enjoy the album but yeah there’s a level of camp or seriousness that’s lacking. I wish there was a song that truly reflected the positive version of I Can Do It With A Broken Heart of her views of the eras tour. Thats something that I feel like the album was lacking.

lovelivvv

I asked all my friends to wait until Friday night to listen for the first time together - the way I continued to get sadder and sadder as the album went on, the back half is especially a let down… the amount of name brands, the word bitch and weird slang, the cringey Travis dick song… trust me I love a good euphemism, but more winky and clever than this… it just felt lazy, like did she rush to put this out to coincide with a potential engagement? Agreed first 4 songs, actually romantic, and show girl are the only songs I really enjoy revisiting… 🥲 Thank you for the safe space to share these thoughts!

Elle Kaye

Yeah I get being disappointed with this album (I’m not), but the handwringing I’m seeing in some places feels like way too much. Taylor’s whole thing is taking the note — that’s how we got this album! There’s something uncomfy to me about the whole “Travis is a bad muse” or “her artistry is declining because of the company she’s keeping.” That so decenter the diva. She went from me hee hee to folklore. She put out TTPD a year ago. She’s gonna do something different next.

boop

Binky

I came in ready to fight you with that first sentence but as I kept reading I actually kind of agree with you in a way. Like in some weird way I think she is doing the most with Travis in part to "get at Matty and maybe even Joe" but I know it's probably just our delision but idk...there's something to what you're saying. It's just all sooooo fast.

boop

I appreciate your measured response! I do believe in "when you know, you know" and there is no "right timeline", but I don't think she knows with this one. There is an undercurrent of hesitation and anxiety, and it looks like it's boiling underneath her skin, which is why I think everything feels rushed. And I want to be clear that I do not think Matty is the one! I think he is demented. I think Taylor is the one. Taylor healing is Taylor choosing Taylor.

T

I honestly think that Taylor centering Elizabeth Taylor is an indication that she's anxious this relationship won't work out. She's leaning SO far into this relationship being public, into becoming the kind of wife that someone like Travis Kelce would have, but she's not really providing any depth with her Travis songs... it's all shallow. It's all physical. It has been with every song she's made about him except the ones where she talks about him saving her. I think in hindsight we will look at this album and say, holy moly she was incredibly anxious that her relationship wasn't going to last forever, and there were a lot of red flags of her using Travis as a life raft in a stormy ocean .

Terry B

She could be listening in 🤣 she’s always curious looking 👀 through windows 🪟 seeing what others are doing 🤣

Terry B

yes it feels mid; lyrics are hit or miss, saved by Martin Shellback crisp pop production propelling up the music charts 📈 This time she picked hit singles correctly, unlike Lover 🤣 1st single should have been The Man / Lover 🙂‍↕️

Terry B

Reliable journalism requires time to research, digest, and objectivity from the host and the audience. Currently fragmented audience is susceptible to mob rule sentiments and cliques. Before technology made DIY content possible without studio equipment and journalist employment, cable TV interviews were 60 minutes in depth Q&A. Interviews are human interactions. e.g. Job interviews: ppl need to warm up before diving in deep conversations. 15-20 minutes short attention span ads-clicking streaming culture / business model simply don’t support that. YT, Google search AI summary want us to skim through topics, click ads, then gather our algorithms and usher us to the next product / site. Deep thoughts prevent impulse buy, frequent reposts and viral marketing. Modern social business model is about rapid, shallow sharing quantity over quality. At first, ppl were fascinated by social media capability to instant global communications and experience; then we got info overload and exhausted 🥱

Terry B

As a counter argument to Tay-naysayers about her songs being samey: it’s like Doritos chips: we fans like the taste and will finish the bag. We aren’t gonna skip a chip coz it’s broken off / incomplete, or there’s too much / too little spice🧂 on it 🤣 We know the chips vary in shapes and seasoning 🤣. We get fed and wait for the next bag 🤣 and there’re various flavours: extra spice, extra cheesy, but the OG vanilla is the most popular; but she’ll always put out variants to keep product shelf and market share 🤣 💰

micky

I don't think Showgirl comes anywhere close to Taylor's best album, but I also don't think it's bad by any stretch. It's different from what we had before. And idk what it is about Taylor but it seems like her music always takes time. I feel confused about it right now but I know we're going to be feeling really differently about it in, like, 8 months. I imagine next album will be folklore-y in that she's telling stories about imagined people and I'm excited for that cherry on top of my fun, brainless, pop Showgirl album.

micky

But I also think working with Max Martin and Shellback again was a step backward. Working with them we knew it was gonna be pop bangers, but I think we also had to know that it wasn't going to be pushing any envelopes, and in many ways her lyricism and themes were going to be leashed.

micky

also i think itd be funny to give fantano a "list of pricks: swiftologist" shirt lol

Justine Paulette

Completely agree with your thoughts here, I think what upsets me the most is she seems SO out of touch, like truly. She seems like she’s been navigating a world that isolates her from things that matter rather than fuels her. I know this sounds harsh, and then again, I do like some songs on the album, and I am genuinely happy that she seems so happy, but I just can’t hear her say in an interview ‘I don’t know how to thank you!’ Well I can think of a million ways but okay, or ‘you’re telling me we had to break an antique chest of drawers’ or whatever it was she said. I’m like, girl, get a grip. Ok you’re rich and sexually content, is nothing else going on in your life right now? Stuff are going on around you at least, like I agree with Madeline concerning Cancelled, etc. Not to say she should take a stance politically or any of that, but this just feels stratospherically out of touch whilst trying to use current internet linguo, + the bread bit is like ‘BUT LOOK IM NORMAL’. It’s just this feels like an album for a white dumb dumb loaded with money to dance to. Fine. But then don’t market it as this masterpiece of music and songwriting we’ve all been waiting for 🤷🏻‍♀️ I love her but damn it’s difficult right now. Sorry for the rant, I do love her.

Eddy

Her jumping into the water right into the bejeweled esk scene like how she goes from ss to midnights on the eras tour iktr

itsbritneymitch

i really love your honesty in this video and it really encapsulates the “mixed” nature of this album. i’m watching this late but i thought her interview with zane lowe was really good in addressing it. anyways you don’t deserve the hate! none of them matter. ❤️

SatelliteSnail

Discussion/video with Madeline Idea: what would you re-name each album based off your interpretation/impression/best matches in your opinion?

SatelliteSnail

My own answer: My Guitar, Love Story, Wonderstruck, Scarf or Burning Red, Blank Space, Getaway Car or Karma (no NOT playing conspiracy bingo I just like the word in LWYMMD), Fever Dream High, no other, happiness, Question...?, loml, and The Fate of Ophelia

Betsy Doran

okay so for the how to murder your career you could do Timbaland, pussycat dolls, cassie, Avril, Chloe Bailey as a solo artist, xtina, or Kanye and Kanye would be good of your YouTube views because your a swiftie and obviously that would get the people going but I would love to see a Kanye one because there are so many angles you can go from especially with the new documentary

Léa

I'm so sorry about your mum and the homophobia. It's terrible.

Elizabeth Wellman

I support the freedom to express consternation and constructive criticism of the album but the comments about her not really loving Travis, etc, feel icky. Again, all power to everyone to share whatever they think but I genuinely am just here for whatever Taylor wants to share with us. Shallow, deep, whatever. Nobody has to think it’s good if they don’t but here to say I (personally) think it’s good.

Ellen Skelton

I'm curious on what your opinion is on her purpose for writing this album and how that affected her songwriting. Specifically how she was saying that she used the creative process to keep her mentally stimulated during the eras tour, but she was really exhausted and probably exhausting herself further. Was her mind really at the master of her craft level during this time? Is the shallowness really related to travis as a muse or just that she didn't have enough energy for her usual emotional depth. I am interested in what she comes out with next specifically because she will have hopefully had more time and energy to focus.

Rachel Kottkamp

Possible sister songs with New Years Day and Elizabeth Taylor “Please don’t ever become a stranger”/“Don’t You Ever End Up Anything But Mine” such different vibes of the same sentiment Maybe there are other songs with that “don’t you ever buddy” vibe

Rachel Kottkamp

The “Stay strong out there” at the end 🤣 really needed that. Every time I open my phone my FYP is BRUTAL

Chas

Yes, TLOAS has a very rushed feel. It doesn’t feel condensed and tight. It feels thrown together. A mix of too many conflicting ideas with a true lack of clarity and vision.

Rachel

I'm not sure if I agree with you, but there is something to the rain show of "I'm the happiest I've ever been..." and we all know how that ended. Now she's saying she's happier than ever again.... And she has seemed to have lost some depth

boop

My psychological analysis is that she was in limerance with Matty Healy. Limerance is more about the person experiencing it rather than the object of their affection. This limerance indicates to me that Taylor's soul has an edge to it that her brand prevents her from exploring. The way she thinks of herself vs. how she is perceived are at odds. And she isn't able to experience natural maturation or initiations into adulthood due to the gravity of her life. The only way she is able to mirror someone for self-actualization is in a romantic relationship. Matty mirrors something Taylor wants to embody. Travis is safety. Travis is a container. Travis will likely be her husband. But he does not mirror anything to her that she doesn't already know.

Beth

Now that you mention it, I was listening to Elizabeth Taylor today and thinking to myself, "She seems awfully anxious and insecure for someone who's engaged." That song echoes Blank Space ('So it's gonna be forever, or it's gonna go down in flames' vs. 'Tell me for real, do you think it's forever?'). I was stunned by her going back to all the petty feuds in TLOAS (I do NOT include Scott Borchetta in that category – that hadn't been fully resolved in song) and calling other women "bitches" because I thought she was happy...but I think you might be right, I'm not sure she is. This album is Reputation & Lover coded because she is so insecure about this relationship, like she was with Joe. I'm so sad to say this, but all the signs are pointing to things ending the same way in this relationship as they did with Joe – a breakup. I'm also stunned that she seems to be throwing all common sense out of the window and not thinking things through. She has so much to lose in a marriage, and we all know she possesses serious business savvy. None of her behaviors right now are aligning with that. One would think someone with that knowledge would be really fucking sure before getting married, because rushing into marriage never ends well.

boop

His stench is in Elizabeth Taylor too! "But I've never had two. And I can't have fun if I can't have you." She has Travis. Travis is had. The only person she doesn't have that she wants is Matty.

Vegan Venus

This is my first Patreon sub I've ever gotten and I've been watching EOAS for a couple years now. So happy to be here 🧡🐍

jorja

Okay yall let me cook. I don’t think that Travis is necessarily a bad muse and I have one singular example of this. The albatross. No one talks about this being a tayvis song but I am a full and complete believer in it idc. I think it depends on which aspects of their relationship Taylor wants to speak of. I think in regards to this album she was very much la la la ki ki about their relationship which led to a lot of very bland generic lyrics. However I think if she wants to mine deep she can come up with the better material. And I think we will see that on the next record.

Stamkitty

By chance I am off to see Hamlet (play) tonight at the National Theatre in London with three other Swifties. We will be paying attention to Ophelia. We just missed the London film festival screening of Hamlet, the 2025 film version with Joe Alwyn. Not to be confused with Hamnet, a 2025 movie with Joe Alwyn about Shakespeare losing his son Hamnet then writing Hamlet. Given the long lead time on films perhaps that is why Taylor had Ophelia on the brain?

Layla Hill

Do you think she will do other music videos? Why does she not do more?

Justine Paulette

Completely agree, and also,- if I may - what it feels like is that she went from complete isolation and down to earth, ‘normal’ life (away from the limelight that is) with Joe to overexposure and fame and business and ambition with Travis (no wonder the songs are shallow…) Obviously, she ended up being unhappy in her former relationship but the pendulum has swung haaard. Like from cave life to 30 radio shows a day. Like the snakes said in one of their videos she also needs to feed the creative side of her, not just the business part… she is the ‘I hate it here’ / ‘the lakes’ diva after all. Not just the mirrorball. I also don’t care if she doesn’t write about her life, just write good songs girl. Ruin the friendship is amazing. DO THAT. Where is sheeeee

boop

I think it's her Dad. Her Dad is forcing it. She's talking herself into it.

CaRo!iNe

PLEASE DO A LILY ALLEN REACTION 🙏 or review lol. I just want to listen to it with you! I'm floored. It's so GOOD!

domdodom

you're retard If you think Taylor is in this patreon and paying the rent of zach please be serious

lulu

love your content and always appreciate your perspective on things and i agree theres no point in pilling on. i know the hate can be a lot, so even though i dont usually comment i wanted to say theres a lot of quiet support out there! much love

Gaer

Every since I've watching your videos, I've gotten tired of Taylor hate. I don't wanna say a lot of it is misogyny because I understand why a lot of black people have a problem with Taylor Swift, especially with the idea that The Life of a Showgirl out of all albums Taylor has made outsold Lemonade, but you can't be mediocre and survive that long. An example, Zara Larson. You definitely do have a positive impact that makes to comment positive things and make more critical videos like you do.

Olivia G

I think I’m interested in the growth and change in how she’s written about women this album. Especially after the very feminist stance she took on Lover and Miss Americana. I’m interested in what you think has caused the shift in her writing and psyche.

Olivia G

I’d love to see a deep dive into Tate’s career and back ground too. I’ve been following her since she was dancer as like a pre teen… she always wanted to be a dancer. Music blew up and became the primary. And it’s such an interesting thing because most people don’t fall into being a pop star. She did. I think there’s a story there. Maybe How to Launch a Career? W your takes about what she can do for this next era to go full pop girl at the end.

ella

Exactly tho! “*i’m* the life *you chose* and all this terrible danger” at the end!