Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Last time I cross-posted my Fantano video y'all had FUN in the comments. Cross-posting here so the Patreon community can kiki again !!

Files

I Made Anthony Fantano a Showgirl

anthony fantano has entered the dressing room! Anthony’s TLOAS review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sx4hnxRGQwU&t=1s IG: https://www.instagram.com/afantano/ today, we’re chatting about what else…the life of a SHOWGIRL. taylor swift’s most polarizing album yet. I resonated with a lot of his critiques in his review, so I wanted him to expand on his insight for you guys!! we cover a LOT of ground here: the songwriting highs and lows, fan hysteria, production struggles, and the current landscape of pop music in 2025 and beyond. enjoy!! Don't be a stranger! 📸 INSTAGRAM: http://www.instagram.com/theswiftologist 📹 TIKTOK: https://shorturl.at/buzG3 💰 PATREON: https://shorturl.at/uILT3 🎙️ MY TAYLOR SWIFT PODCAST: https://spoti.fi/3U1pu06 📸 PODCAST INSTAGRAM: https://bit.ly/3QDNt2x 💌 EMAIL: swiftologist@fwbtalent.com

Comments

Tanner K

Meaty conversation

Bonnie

I loved the conversation between you two! It’s so nice to hear your reflections on the album so far. It hasn’t been the easiest time with this album as it’s really not resonating anywhere near as closely as her previous, so I think more content like this is what I need to help process it all.

Brandon Thede

Personal opinion: I find this was just a tad bit too much of “I will agree with almost everything you said” -Ologist. I understand the situation, and that there’s a sort of civility expected… but I’d love to see you argue in favor of Taylor a bit more. Was this a bad record? Not her best for sure. But I find that this conversation implies that it’s practically a throwaway record within her discography, without any real future for any of its qualities. To some of its qualities, I agree: but not all. I find no problem with any of the actual issues and talking points you discussed Zach - I just felt we could’ve had some more optimistic points as well, instead of simple asides. To be clear. This was very well done. Just a nuanced criticism… of your criticism… of his criticism. 🤣☺️

MA

Loved your critique for the album since it was coming from a place of appreciation to taylor's work where you truly believe in taylor's art and you know she is used to light years better than this instead of just hating and discrediting all of her life's work

Billy K

I remain flabbergasted that he places LOAS above TTPD but that’s none of my business. This was such a fun convo and I hope you guys have more in the future!

Allie J

agree !!

Swiftologist

I was definitely very much still processing the record and hadn't come to a clear idea of what I thought about it when we chatted, so I was more looking (as an interviewer) to hear Fantano's opinion & coax out his thoughts more. You'll definitely hear more tayoptimism about TLOAS in my official review when it's ready :-) I have gone one a JOURNEY with this record...

Brandon Thede

I appreciate that you can take an honest word for what it is :) thanks Zach. I genuinely do come here for serious journalism. And you do deliver .

Swiftologist

I love constructive feedback when it is in fact constructive lol <3 thank you for caring enough to say so!!

megha

This was one of the only conversations about showgirl I’ve heard so far that has managed to separate the art from the artist (vs every other review both - positive and negative - spend way too much time on Taylor the IRL person than Taylor itself).

Chloe

You’re a really thoughtful and engaging conversationalist and interviewer, this was such an engaging watch. I thought Fantanos insights were actually so interesting, as he isn’t a swiftie but has actually engaged enough in the art that he has context for his thoughts/criticisms. Really hope to hear more conversations between you two divas!! Much love xo

Chloe

Ok didn’t realise I wrote ‘engaging’ so many times but I guess that’s my truth!!

Emma Scott

Fantano placing Lover in his top Taylor Swift albums was not something I would have ever expected. Kind of gagged at that. I love this episode! I think your questions were very interesting and I loved the discussion. Even if I am a bit more Showgirl positive lol. You definitely have a way of bringing out the best in Fantano - which I very much appreciate because while I appreciate thoughtful music criticism he oftentimes is too much of a scalawag for me. And thank you for the reasoned takes TLOAS here it is very much appreciated!

qdominik aa

The last 4 minutes fantano is spitting some facts

Sarah Vandy

We need a full TAYREWIND feat. Fantano!!!

kale

Lover being in Fantano’s top 3 and him liking But Daddy I Love Him okay bald headed scallywag!!!

Stacy Davydova_13

Honestly loved the interview! And I was very surprised how generous and thoughtful Antony was towards Taylor and Showgirl this time around (considering the material he could have been and in my opinion should have been way harsher). I support every comment begging you two to make it a regular thing. Don’t no if Anthony is on board with that and you have enough material to do that, but once every 2-3 month would be SOOO cool

Rae

Im realizing now as you talk about the sea of only male producer/song writer collaborators that Taylor has worked with for a decade, if having other women in the room could have expanded the scope of Taylor’s expressions of feminism and womanhood (the man, eldest daughter, even thank you aimee and female rage the musical) and prevent them from sounding so dated and detached from how we (women) talk bout gender issues socially. Like none of those men have the capabilities to discuss that with her. That isolation is present in her music because it’s present in the room the music is being made in. GET THE MEN OUT TAYLOR.

Karisa

I personally find the more time spent with this record and the more time spent with the lyrics and even listening to the acoustic versions of some of the songs make the lyrics stand out way more than they do with the pop production on the songs. I like something about all of the songs. I think 7 are really great songs and have thoughtful TS lyrics… and 3 are just good, 1 that I like the production so much but some of the lyrics are a bit cringe but overall without that it would be great - bet ya know what song I’m talking about here.. cough. Then there is 1 that is just okay for me. None of the songs are “BAD” imo. I think after TTPD with so much lyrical poetry and so much content that this release felt a little underwhelming at first… but at that time we didn’t get all of the interviews… and I have been enjoying those. I just think when people sit with the record longer… they might change their minds a bit.

daphne

tbh, WCS, Clara Bow, Father Figure and The Manuscript are some of her most profound musings on womanhood and the struggles of operating in a patriarchal society. she’s well capable of doing this regardless of who her collaborators are. the issue with the songs you mentioned is what they aim for, imo

Karisa

Oh I forgot to add that I really liked this conversation… great interview… but I can’t wait to hear your REVIEW! I’m dying for it. I even joined Patreon because I’m just dying for more Swiftologist content at the moment and I don’t want to miss anything! Loving it so far!

Rae

Folklore/Evermore has such a rich expansive world filled with true crime, historical figures, fictional love triangles, and really consistent themes and motifs throughout the sister albums. It was a (semi) fictional world that blossomed under the analysis and meth-math because strong stories can always be delved into. It seems like Taylor is trying to maintain the way we interact with her music (under a detective’s spyglass) without giving us a world to explore. It worked for midnights (partially because the eras tour was its own world to explore and analyze) but also because of Taylor’s obfuscation of her dying relationship, giving audiences a case to solve. TTPD was a like a surprise 40+ episode documentary finally giving us answers to a 10 year old cold case with a plot so juicy that it’s lack of imagery, lyrical refinement and world building could be tolerated. TLOASG does not deliver on any of these fronts. No unique world to immerse ourselves in, no MATCHING imagery that expands on the actual themes of the album (they are cunty and delicious tho) plus the songs overall lack major quality control lyrically and sonically. I don’t need Taylor to let us in on her whole world, I do need her the give us clear moments to live in. Father Figure and Ruin the Friendship do this beautifully. Both fully realized situations with specific characters and point of views.

Leni Doom

🙌🏼 it’s the engagement buzz 😇

Jojobear

I feel like I go on a journey with this record everytime I listen to it. It's interesting because I actually quite like it, I don't think I absolutely hate any of the songs (definitely have some skips), not like I hate some of the songs on Lover (lover and rep have always ranked low for me. I'm debut/red/the 'ores/TTPD forever. So I think showgirl will sit low with those two & I don't see that changing. but I'm trying not to let that be because of the craziness of the internet now). However, Lover still ranks higher for me because it' has some of my absolute favourite songs, death by a thousand cuts moved me in a way none of these new songs ever could. When I heard that song for the first time.... I knew the woman who had been singing me through my life since we were both teenagers, was still there. I didn't get that with showgirl at first. But I keep finding her in places on this album now. Ruin the friendship, father figure, the bridge of eldest daughter (shame about the rest of it), the chorus of honey. I have the most fun with this album when I imagine these songs as showgirls talking to each other in the dressing room. Like I'm a fly on the wall getting little snippets of things that affect showgirls, but only in fleeting conversations between rehearsals & make up reapplications. I'm not getting the whole truth but I'll dance along anyway.

alexander

i do sense some bias against taylor that fantano might reserve , just as swiftologist obviously has some bias towards her since he is the swiftologist. which creates an interesting discussion for sure

Rae

Opalite is the LOASG’s Change

Rae

Not like money like as in the song from fearless

Stacy Davydova_13

Brilliant take. It feels like this time around her reputation is doing more of the heavy lifting than the actual material. I keep thinking about her recent comment on Easter eggs and how she’s “trained us well” to look for them. With those record-breaking numbers and public comments like “You didn’t like something before and look at you now” or “I know what I made, and I adore it” it kind of puts anyone who’s not into this album in a tough spot. It almost makes you gaslight yourself into streaming it more and trying to find something that just isn’t there

Jojobear

ooohhh I like this take & Im heading towards a more positive relationship with this album, but I thought this was really well put. Maybe that's why more casual listeners like this album? my husband is not a lyrics guy (I had to explain the f the patriarchy keychain to him, he thought she was just randomly singing it mid song ha), & while I was playing showgirl yesterday he said "this is fun. Sounds like she's happy" (I will say I am heavy on sad music. It's TTPD/the 'ores, Phoebe Bridgers, Noah Kahan, 00s emo etc over here everyday. So maybe he is just happy to not hear trauma through the speakers for once!) I definitely wanted more storytelling from showgirl. I'd have loved another song about Kitty, an abba super trouper style story about the showgirl spotting her new love in the crowd, I'd have loved for her to expand more on cancelled (I think the song wouldn't be getting so much hate if the storytelling was better. we know women get held to higher standards especially with the internet, so tell us more of these stories.

Tony

His Lover appreciation is fascinating to me.

Jacinta

This was such a thoughtful and thought provoking conversation, and like everyone else I would also love if this turned into a regular or semi regular thing about music and pop generally. I think you both have such interesting insights when it comes to music.

Hilde

thank you for uploading here!

SF

Thank you for posting here! The ads on youtube make videos almost unwatchable for me, so I appreciate when you double post!

h8red__

are ad blocker not working for you? :/ i never get ads

h8red__

i felt like in this interview he was much nicer than i expected. and his bias is for pop music in general i think.

h8red__

yes last year around this time i really thought that debut tv could do a lot for taylor. we saw beyoncé going country, lana who announced a country record, sabrina and chappell with country influences. maybe with some sonically updated vault tracks it would’ve really fitted the trends we’ve seen.

Simon Frilling

Heyy, new member here, can anyone tell me how to get access to the discord server?? I cant for the life of me find any information on that

Miss_Lippy

One thought I keep having now that I’ve sat with this record for a week or so: TLOASG is truly a *VIBES* album. I can think of a lot of big name artists who also sometimes release albums with clunky, incoherent or rudimentary lyrics but no one even cares because the vibes are good (off the top of my head: Rihanna, Miley, The Weeknd, Selena Gomez, Nirvana, Gaga, Radiohead, Lana, etc etc) But maybe we aren’t used to extending the same kind of courtesy to Taylor these days because our expectations are so high for her? And with LOASG there really are still some great lyrics & meanings in there, but they don’t knock you over the head the way some of her others do. I also think this album was an overcorrection response to the feedback she got from TTPD (too long, too emo/sad, too intellectual, too verbose, etc) and now that she has maybe overcorrected a bit and the fans want her lyrics to shine more, I think TS 13 could be a really great in between sweet spot if she can take the feedback from the 2 and create something more down the middle. Personally, I’m still loving it even just based on it’s sonic appeal alone & while it’s not a “no skips” album for me, I’ll still play 10 out of the 12 songs on my commute & it really is just a great record to roll the windows down & vibe to. Lastly, I think people have not been giving her enough flowers for her vocals on this one either! She is doing some of her best vocals on some of these songs. Her voice sounds so mature and there are some out of this world harmonies on this too that i haven’t heard people talking about- presumably bc they are too busy shrieking about how Taylor is maga now 🙄 but fwiw most of the negativity I’ve heard about this album has been on this Patreon and TikTok. FB & IG seem to lean more Taypositive and the non-swiftie “normal” /irl people I talk to all love it too so there’s something to be said for that.

alexander

i respect your opinion but ive watched several of his reviews of other pop artists and taylor always gets put under a microscope or her lyrics are often just not given the thought that other artists are given. this could be just because hes holding her to a higher standard but theres definitely some sort of bias there lol, whether he means to or not

Sheridan S

Commenting so I can get help with this too 😅

Miss_Lippy

Another thing I’ll say for TLOASG, and for Taylor in general, is that she has this really amazing and uncanny ability to sound remarkably different on various tracks while still sounding so recognizably and uniquely “Taylor” too. I’m not sure how she does it, bc it doesn’t *feel* intentional or forced either. When I’m listening it just feels like it’s almost second nature or intuitive for her. My problem with so many other pop girlies is that after 3-4 songs, it becomes apparent that it’s going to be yet another album where all the songs start sounding the same and blending together. I can rarely find other modern pop artists with great melodies that also have dynamic vocal ability to keep my interest in that way throughout a whole album (Chappell Roan would be another one who does accomplish that for me but even Audrey Hobert’s latest album too; she also has that enticing Xfactor thing) and ironically, the girlies who l thought were an example of artists who start to sound very repetitive in their albums was Renee Rapp & Addison Rae -whose praises y’all were singing on this video lol Say what you will about TLOASG, but even after listening to many of Taylor’s songs in a row, I am never bored with hers the way I am with some of these other people.

h8red__

i tried to reflect yesterday what i think the weakness of the album is. and i actually believe it’s partially the length. first of all i’m in general less forgiving if a song is mid when there are only 12 tracks, and what i always recognise is that people have very different favourites throughout the fandom. songs i love others don’t like at all and the other way around. of course taste is different so that’s normal but i rarely see a real unity about which song is great. and while ophelia is a great lead single we also know that choosing singles is not always taylor’s best skill, that could be very real for also choosing a track list. then for such a short record i think track 1 & 3 are thematically basically the same. something a bit more interesting here could’ve been nice. father figure & showgirl have a nice concept of a character study like thing, with a switch in perspective which is good 👍. i actually love the bridge in eldest daughter and i think sonically it’s great but just like other songs with more “cringy” lyrics the issue is not only that they exist but that they are the chorus. i think you can see eldest daughter as a message to the fans or the girlies that come after her, but on a first level interpretation it’s to travis and i wished there was a bit more depth to it. also the song could end after “now you’re home”. cancelled could’ve been clearer in messaging but if you ignore that it’s actually a really enjoyable song and i feel the same about actually romantic. there is a really great song in Wood, if it didn’t took the dick route. it’s really catchy and the knock on wood reminded me of the pen click in blank space. Taylor talked about that max martin said every great pop songs has to have smth really “annoying”, wood has some potential there. wish list is the weakest song for me i find sound of the “boss up, settle down ..” really satisfying but that’s kinda it. honey has a sweet concept, that transports a very simple message in a nice little package and actually becomes really vulnerable esp the part about matty (i assume).

h8red__

i remember the (i think) evermore songwriting interview with zane lowe, where she talks about that the pandemic gave her a lot of mental space to create and be creative. she said that usually with an album you have so many things to do around, plan a tour, a stage etc. which is all creating but leaves less space for the music alone. she said that was a true learning for her but i think she fell back into old patterns. while the tour was obv great and i also really love the music video it feels like the music became less of a priority which shows.

h8red__

and as i said in another post, i think she tried to target a new audience of millennial or older men with this album, which i guess business wise makes sense but disappoints fans. maybe she overestimated people’s loyalty, at least from what i can see in fans reactions.

Lisa M

I loved this so much you have no idea!

chappell roan

Has anyone here read the swiftologist fantano fic on wattpad?

Elise Cooper

Listening to this interview really made me realise I was expecting such a Chicago (musical)/Burlesque (Film) sound to this album. More jazz, more show tunes. I wanted Taylor to do her own version of Cell Block Tango, I wanted the riffs of Burlesque's he-eh-eh-hey

socksforkim

It was interesting to hear Fantano voice critiques that I really agreed with. The written Taylor we have come to know and love is scarcely on this album, and the lyricism is not up to par with her other work. I don't feel the need to read further into 75% of the album. If Taylor relinquished control to let Max Martin and Shellback do their melodic math, perhaps we would obtain better songs from The Fate of Ophelia and others.

ella

im sorry what?

chappell roan

My first reaction as well. It’s an entertaining read, to say the least.

socksforkim

I enjoy Swiftologist + Fantano's dynamic a lot, and as we neared the end, I was hoping for generalized pop culture takes! I hope in a future collaboration the discussion is less Taylor focused. Great video and the one on Fantano's channel is great too.

Chelsea Bauscher

Make sure you subscribe to a Patreon tier high enough that includes discord access

Rachel

I never could have predicted the lover praise lmao

Tony

He just wants a little pink in his life so he went straight to the source lol

Lisaboo

Tbf to lady Gaga she also has an amazing and uncanny ability to sound (on one song) exactly like Taylor Swift 😂

Enzo Reis

Guys, has Zach heard Jake's Shane "Puss and Poems" album? I did and got two earaches. I desperately need Zach's reaction and opinion on this.

Selina

I hope you gave him a stern talking-to about Ruin the Friendship off the record. lol 🫶

boop

Yeah, I really don't mind the bad lyrics.

Kylee

I clocked that he got the most heat for his Midnights review, and I can’t even give you a reason why I thought that. Im probably just projecting my own complicated relationship with that album. A nod to Wood: I’ve yet to hear it the way I did in the theater, but it went off there. I’m a production nerd, I love to hone in on certain aspects of it, and it actually sounded like people were knocking on the walls of the movie theater. P.S. I’m the older millennial woman who also was completely prepared to find out what happens after a big sweaty man writes mine on her thighs with God only knows what. I’ve strangely been on a similar dating journey as her, but I’m still chilling at the Prophecy. And truthfully, I’m not sure I want the big sweaty mine thigh man. But I’m also not going to pull a Fifteen and set myself up for failure, so don’t quote me on that. By the way, I’ve had some things I’ve said lost in translation here, but this was also a bad joke for anybody that was wondering. OK, I’m done.

Enzo Reis

This album honestly feels like it should’ve been called The Life of a Popstar. Songs like The Fate of Ophelia, Elizabeth Taylor, Opalite, Father Figure, Actually Romantic, Honey, TLOAS, Ruin the Friendship—even Cancelled and Wish List—would make so much more sense under that name. The title would capture that mix of chaos, vulnerability, and glamour that runs through the whole tracklist. Visually, I’d scrap the “Showgirl” aesthetic completely and go for something that channels late-’90s to early-2000s Britney, but with that groovy-funky ’70s flavor—think glossy, sweaty, hyper-feminine, yet nostalgic. It would still fit within the same cinematic universe as the Eras Tour ambience, but with a looser, more rebellious energy—like a popstar who knows the performance is both her crown and her cage. Zach, think about the cover of The Life Of A Showgirl (Deluxe): Life Is A Song Acoustic—that exact photo as the album cover, but with the title changed to The Life Of A Popstar or something along those lines, and keeping the aesthetic of that specific image. GORGEOUS. BELÍSSIMO. Would resonate way more better with the material itself and the sounds that we heard in the record.

Kd235481

The point about taking time between albums was super interesting - I’m really excited to see the review/reaction to Olivia Rodrigo’s 3rd album bc I feel like she is the one girl that is truly taking her time

Heather

So grateful for this conversation! You both can vocalize the issues with this album that I am interested in discussing, without the TAYLOR SWIFT IS DEAD, I'M LEAVING THE FANDOM drama that I am sick of seeing. I particularly like what Fantano has to say about the intent of the writing. I think a huge part of why the album is so polarizing is because the messaging is super unclear. It's a failure on Taylor's part as a writer that people are interpreting the music in vastly different ways.

Shanice Marie

I joked about The Fate of Ophelia music video being so good I wasn't sure if Taylor actually directed it. I think that's why some of the album feels incredibly disjointed. The video is exactly how you would think the album would sound. Each track being every iteration of a showgirl going decade by decade would've been so cool. As well as being so Eras tour coded. I'm still confused how this album is the book end of the tour in that regard.

James

COUNTRY TAYLOR PLEASEEEEE

Miss_Lippy

Oh yeah! We clocked that one on Gaga’s latest album too haha

hayleywilliamsmademegay

"you have to feel the wind coursing through your hair... but you cant" hahaha the way i cackled, loved that fantano can take it. what a riveting discussion, full of great insight and banter - and you asked amazing questions and led the conversation so compellingly! who said great music criticism was dead?

Mallory

Totally agree!

AledoTXAllStars

First, I think you are great! I love that you are exploring why some love this album and some don't. I will say that I connect more with this album than others. However, I'm older, I got married around Taylor’s age, I had a successful career before getting married (Of course, not as successful as Taylor), I love a good diss track, I love the overt sexuality, I love the upbeat songs, etc. She is older and she seems to be ok if people clutch their pearls when she says something that a lot of 35 year old woman says all the time. Also, I wanted to give you another perspective. One thing that Taylor continues to do is redefine what is possible/expected as a female. Women are making more money these days and the definition of roles in relationships are getting redefined. Many women in this situation are dealing with very messy relationships because of the changes in money and power. However, this relationship with Travis is a great way that Taylor is showing women how they can be amazing at their job and be soft / traditional with their relationship without the spouse feeling over powered by them. This may not resonate with you and I can see why you feel it is cringy, but I think she is having fun with this album. She’s been cheeky and overt for a reason. As I’ve gotten older, I find it a lot more fun and realistic about relationships. I would have dreaded a bubble gum pop love story that isn’t realistic. Keep doing you! Love it!

h8red__

fair, i haven’t seen that many. tbh i just remember his horrible Halsey review

Jess

Fantano confirmed as a But Daddy I Love Him stan

Christina Ingham

This album is pop gold. I love it but I guess I’m just not much of a critic. I just love vibing to it. It is bringing me so much joy.

nayakyra

out of 10 i'm pretty sure he always goes out of 10

Syd

LMAOOOOOOO it begins

chappell roan

It’s genuinely the funniest thing I’ve ever read. Begging for them to blind react to it for a Kiki lounge

Swiftologist

I think this is weird and creepy plz stop sharing it x

chappell roan

I'm truly sorry, I genuinely thought you would find it funny and my intent was NOT to weird you out by sharing it... in hindsight it was an awful idea to even entertain it just because I found it somewhere and its like common sense that its weird?? im genuinely like shocked I didnt realize that before I hit send on my (unfortunately many) comments. if I can explain myself, I have seen other creators in the past make content by reading/reacting to fanfics about them, and when I saw it I thought it would be funny for a Kiki lounge which is why I shared it but what I didn't realize is all those creators did that on their own accord, choosing to read that, with their own boundaries, and it was not okay for me to share this with you. im really, really sorry, honestly, im a huge fan and supporter and the last thing I wanted to do was weird/creep you out,.

chappell roan

I messaged the person who wrote it and they took it down btw

Valentin Bellegarde

There is something about Fantano. He has led so many young people astray. I remember when he gave Kendrick Lamar’s ‘untitled unmastered’ an 8/10. I was around 17. I thought, “This guy knows what he’s talking about.” So, I listened to the album on a long car journey, not once but twice, because initially I thought it was crap. But how could it be? Fantano knows best. Ah, poor Valentin. You weren’t to know. There is something about the way he pins the album cover to the wall in his videos. It reminds me of that novel ‘The Collector’ by John Fowles. Here’s the blurb: ‘Withdrawn, uneducated and unloved, Frederick collects butterflies and takes photographs. He is obsessed with a beautiful stranger, the art student Miranda. When he wins the pools he buys a remote Sussex house and calmly abducts Miranda, believing she will grow to love him in time.’ (The first half of the novel is told from Frederick’s point of view; the second shifts to Miranda’s, conveyed through a series of diary entries.) After being abducted and moved to an underground cellar, Miranda is confused. Frederick doesn't want sex and he's not after a ransom. He goes into London and spends lavishly on books, classical music records, painting supplies - items that mean nothing to him (he is a philistine) but that she has requested or that he thinks she’ll like. (Btw I’m not calling Fantano “withdrawn, uneducated and unloved” or a philistine 😭 – I’m just setting this up.) Miranda surmises that he wants to collect her: ‘I am one in a row of specimens. It's when I try to flutter out of line that he hates me. I'm meant to be dead, pinned, always the same, always beautiful. He knows that part of my beauty is being alive, but it's the dead me he wants. He wants me living-but-dead.’ Miranda, like a lot of art students, like a lot of young people, is simultaneously precocious, ignorant, annoying, and endearing. She says very adolescent things, like: “I hate people who collect things, and classify things and give them names and then forget all about them. That's what people are always doing in art. They call a painter an impressionist or a cubist or something and then they put him in a drawer and don't see him as a living individual painter any more.” But the passage that really reminds me of Fantano is this, from the first half of the novel (context: Frederick lied earlier and told Miranda his name was Ferdinand. He also promised her that he would free her on a specific date in the future): ‘Another day she drew a bowl of fruit. She drew them about ten times, and then she pinned them all up on the screen and asked me to pick the best. I said they were all beautiful but she insisted so I plumped for one. “That's the worst," she said. "That's a clever little art student's picture." She said, "One of them is good. I know it is good. It is worth all the rest a hundred times over. If you can pick it in three guesses you can have it for nothing when I go. If I go. If you don't, you must give me ten guineas for it." Well, ignoring her dig I had three guesses, they were all wrong. The one that was so good only looked half-finished to me, you could hardly tell what the fruit were and it was all lop-sided. "There I'm just on the threshold of saying something about the fruit. I don't actually say it, but you get the idea that I might. Do you feel that?” I said I didn't actually. She went and got a book of pictures by Cezanne. "There," she said, pointing to a coloured one of a plate of apples. "He's not only saying everything there is about the apples, but everything about all apples and all form and colour." I take your word for it, I said. All your pictures are nice, I said. She just looked at me. "Ferdinand," she said. "They should have called you Caliban."’ The interaction is retold from Miranda’s perspective in the second half of the novel: ‘This morning I drew a whole series of quick sketches of bowls of fruit. Since Caliban wants to give, I don't care how much paper I waste. I "hung" them and asked him to choose which one was best. Of course he picked all those that looked most like the wretched bowl of fruit.’ I feel like, with so many of Fantano’s reviews, he is only ever providing or selecting the drawings that look most like the bowl of fruit. Do you feel that? His typically ham-fisted take on ‘Ruin the Friendship’, his big idea being “I hope this doesn’t give fans license to wantonly cheat” – bro. He talks about nostalgia, which is such weak sauce. Nostalgia more like Mortalgia. That Tolkien quote: “Human stories are practically always about one thing, really, aren't they? Death. The inevitability of death.” I mean what do we actually get from the Fantano review? We get ‘Taylor Swift is a Rorschach test’ (gee it's almost like everything in art that isn’t an airport thriller or a realist painting is a Rorschach test), then a play-by-play of the various songs (collecting each one), the low-hanging fruit (‘Actually Romantic’ is about Charlie XCX), then a leap from ‘CANCELLED!’ to the Epstein flight logs, and then whoosh bang it’s over. Album collected. And Taylor pinned to the wall like one of his butterflies. 🦋 P.S. What if there’s something more? What if, in that dialogue between Zack and Fantano, they talked about “Max Martin production,” but never “Max Martin songwriting.” It reminds me of the McCartney song ‘Walking in the Park with Eloise.’ From www.the-paulmccartney-project.com: “In downtime from a mid 70s Wings Nashville recording session […] Paul duly dusted off this jazz/twenties inspired ditty which was actually written by his father James ‘Jim’ McCartney – he must have been attached to the song as years later Paul chose it as one of his Desert Island Discs.” Linda McCartney (Paul’s first wife) recalled: “While in Nashville we recorded about five tracks… one is a song written by Paul’s dad called “Walking In The Park With Eloise”, just music. When Paul was a little boy, about 10, even younger, he remembers sitting at the foot of the piano while his dad was playing this song.” (Note: “just music.” No lyrics.) Asked about his dad’s reaction, McCartney said: “Oh, he loved it. He really loved it. He wouldn’t ever admit he’d ‘written’ it. He said it was just a piece he played on the piano that he’d ‘made up’. And I said, ‘Well, we call that writing these days!’ I think he meant that he didn’t physically write something out in notation.” You see, melody is not WRITTEN down, therefore it is not songWRITING. Lyrics are the thing written down. Melody is the thing remembered. 😏 This is only a small part of what I call the horcruxification of songwriting. Fantano touches on it at 5:23 in the above video, when he mentions the “blatantly untrue” accusation that Taylor “doesn’t write her own stuff.” We are reminded of Damon Albarn saying precisely that about Taylor Swift. And Taylor rightly clapped back with, “I obviously do write my own stuff.” But what was Damon talking about? Well, when we think of Blank Space, Shake It Off, Style, 22, We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together, I Knew You Were Trouble, Bad Blood, the songs that launched her into superstardom, Taylor can say, “I wrote those songs,” because lyrics are the thing written down. But did anyone break out the treble clef and notate the melody? No. Music is not written down. Think about that Blank Space voice memo. It’s on YouTube, everyone’s heard it: “So, this next clip is from a session I had with Max Martin and Shellback, and what we like to do is we like to run a recording on our phones of everything we’re doing when we’re putting a song together, just in case one of us blurts out a cool melody and then we forget about it. We wanna go back and replay the tapes so that we can remind ourselves what exactly we were saying. So, I brought in this idea called ‘Blank Space,’” Pause. Do you remember the exchange between Taylor and Jimmy Fallon just a couple of days ago? They talked about the song ‘Wood’: Jimmy: “All these are great tunes. By the way, do you come up with tunes before… for this exact song, did you go [mumbles tune with dummy lyrics]?” Taylor: “No, so I brought this into the studio and I was like, ‘I wanna do sort of like a – I wanna, like, do a throwback kind of timeless sounding song, and I have this idea about, like, ‘I ain’t got to knock on wood’ and we would knock on wood.” Now, let’s look at those quotes side-by-side:
“I brought in this idea called ‘Blank Space,’” “I have this idea about, like, ‘I ain’t got to knock on wood’ I believe Taylor’s ideas in both instances are lyrical. Back to the Blank Space voice memo:

“So, I brought in this idea called ‘Blank Space, and this was me playing it for Max and Johann for the first time.” Pause. Virtually all Swifties take this to mean that this was the first time Max and Johann had ever heard the song. I am certain she is actually saying it was the first time she played it on guitar for them during a break in production. It was the first acoustic version they had heard, not the first time they had heard the song at all. They had already been working on it in its synth-pop form (the version that would eventually be released). Rick Beato has a great video on Nirvana’s Smells Like Teen Spirit, where he analyses the melody of that song. At 13:18 in the video, he talks about the “flat 6th down to the 5th” over the F power chord in the chorus (“here we are now…”): “There’s the beauty. It’s so beautiful, so haunting. That’s what I call a ‘haunting tone’, that flat six on minor, the Aeolian, that really gives the sound [its] sadness.” When Beato says “there’s the sadness,” he’s talking about a prevailing mood, a veil that hangs over the song and makes it grunge, with those two notes acting as the keystone. It’s like the glue of the song. Max Martin has his own glue, and it’s not melodic math. It’s a melodic tell. (And a harmonic tell – but harmony led by melody, for as Johann Philipp Kirnberger said: “All the parts of harmony have as their ultimate purpose only beautiful melody.”) Zach says about the Ariana album Eternal Sunshine at 34:25: “I can hear Max Martin all over that.” About ‘Blank Space’, that lift-off in “got a long list of ex-lovers”? That’s the same lift-off you get in… - “you’re the one that I ever needed” from the chorus of Robyn’s ‘Show Me Love’ - “there’s nothing that I wanna do / but try and make it up to you” from the chorus of Daughtry’s ‘Feels Like Tonight’ - “give me a siiiiiiign” from the chorus of Britney’s ‘…Baby One More Time’ - “but I just can’t refu-ooOOse” from the chorus of Ariana’s ‘Don’t Wanna Break Up Again.’ And so many more. Back to the final part of the Blank Space voice memo: “They’re shouting out these production ideas like, y’know, the ‘Oh!’ at the beginning of the chorus, and that ended up in the song. So, this is the very beginning stages of a song on the album called ‘Blank Space.’” Reading the above, you’d think the 21st century’s most successful songwriter and greatest tunesmith contributed a few “Oh!”s, maybe. Lyrically, it certainly is the beginning stages. But melodically, it’s all there. And it’s all Martin. Except we don’t know, because the studio is a black box, another part of the horcruxification of songwriting. If two songwriters go into a black box and come out with a great song, and if melody is the essence of music and tunes the pinnacle of melody, then how do we know who handled its essence? Fallon very deliberately asked Taylor about “tunes,” not melodies. He picked that word because it gets at the horcruxification of songwriting. Taylor pairing up with the greatest tunesmith of the 21st century. The black box we can’t see inside of, except when we get these voice memos that are equally as deliberate in their wording. Do we talk about “Max Martin production” instead of “Max Martin songwriting” so as not to detract from “Taylor Swift songwriting”? But if “music is collaborative,” then what does it matter? Except music isn’t collaborative. That’s just another thing people say. If someone listens to music by himself and makes music by himself, how collaborative is music for him? 
“Ah, but for most people!” – for most people what? When people heard the Taylor Swift album for the first time, how collaborative was music during that experience? “Ah, but it’s a conversation between Taylor and her fans” – no, it isn’t. In the instance you listened to that album for the first time, you were by yourself, experiencing it alone. There was no conversation; you did not talk back. “But afterwards we talked about it together in groups” – but nothing. “But afterwards,” what about during? Like how AirPods immediately stop playing whatever’s being played when you take one out of your ear to ask someone who just said something to you to repeat themselves. Because in that instance you have to go from a solitary, insular experience to something collaborative i.e. talking to someone. What about your actual experience of the music? What about when you make music by yourself, alone, like every single composer that ever lived and a ton of songwriters as well? “Ah, but composers need an orchestra” – ok and when Ravel composed the melody to the slow movement of his G-major concerto ("That flowing phrase! How I worked over it bar by bar! It nearly killed me!") – how collaborative was he when he was at the piano by himself writing the thing you can go away singing after a couple of listens? https://youtu.be/dt1TZj1DnfU?si=WYt5CPI09cBIptuE Music CAN be collaborative (playing in a band or orchestra, writing a song with people) and it CAN be solitary. But to say, as Zach does, that “music is collaborative, it’s supposed to be this shared communal experience,” like it’s a precondition, something intrinsic, that music ought to be this way. I don’t buy it. Music isn’t supposed to be communal; I am, “for man is a social being, and designed by nature to live with others.” Anyway… to conclude… Does Fantano know the difference between a tune and a melody?
Does the AI technocracy? 🤖 I agree with Zach (in the latest Phone-a-Snake) that you can’t put the genie back in the bottle when it comes to AI. But when the funeral is held, sometime in the future, will we even know what was lost? What if Tchaikovsky and Mozart are holding hands with Max Martin and John Williams (93 years old) and Paul McCartney (83 years old) through the spirit world? Because, finally, what if we’re about to lose the essence of music, and “the internet’s busiest music nerd” doesn’t even know what it is? Because he calls it “production.” (Of course, production is one of the things that will be lost also.) But it’s like that line from Silence of the Lambs: “When your little girl is on the slab, where will it tickle you?” https://youtu.be/RZAkOfxlW6g?si=_npZ0_JkyRLDlNpE When music is on the slab, where will it tickle us? In the part that cares about production? Certainly. But where will it tickle us most? In the part that cares about lyrics? Naturally. But take away lyrics and what are you left with? Music. Take away music and leave the lyrics? You are left without music.

Valentin Bellegarde

There is a 1988 film called ‘The Vanishing.’ From Rotten Tomatoes:

‘Rex (Gene Bervoets) and Saskia (Johanna Ter Steege) are enjoying a biking holiday in France when, stopping at a gas station, Saskia disappears. Confounded, Rex searches everywhere, but to no avail. Three years later, he's still obsessed with finding her, pleading his case on television, putting up posters and ruining his new relationship in the process. Eventually an unassuming chemistry teacher, Raymond (Bernard-Pierre Donnadieu), approaches Rex, intimating that he knows what happened.’ Right at the start of the film, before her disappearance, Saskia tells Rex (who drives them through a dark tunnel) about a recurring nightmare she’s been having in her sleep:

Saskia: “My nightmare. I had it again last night.”
Rex: “That you’re inside a golden egg and you can’t get out, and you float all alone through space forever.” Saskia: “Yes, the loneliness is unbearable. No. This time there was another golden egg flying through space. Far away. And if we were to collide, it’d be all over.” Music has been travelling all this way. The oldest musical instruments go back 60,000 years. It travelled through Ravel and everyone else to get here, today, this moment. Ravel is dead, he is dead forever, if you believe in Heaven (as I do) or reincarnation or something else, you may believe he’s alive – but you can believe or disbelieve, it’s up to you. The point is, we are contemplating something Ravel and Mozart didn’t have to contemplate. 60,000 years, and if we’d been born 125 years earlier, we wouldn’t have had to contemplate it. But if a machine can produce something as beautiful as Laudate Dominum, or as catchy as Crazy Frog, in a matter of minutes, what will music mean then? What will theneedledrop give everyone-in-the-world-becoming-a-max-martin out of 10? A strong what?

Elle

Really loved this conversation!! Really interesting points made about the album and you really got down to the nitty gritty and I discovered the depths of my own issues with this album. don’t get me wrong I love songs on it! But parts of it simply disappoint me. Fantano needs to go to jail for TTPD though haha I also really loved midnights first listen too- but maybe I’m just not much of a showgirl girly- we all have our thing and songs that resonate right?! Haha It’s the first TS album that hasn’t automatically clicked for me right away so I’m having a really hard time atm because I don’t want to jump on the hate wagon-but hearing my inner feelings validated by your thoughtful critique really helps! Love you guys!

Brandi Shook

Went into this interview already side eyeing Anthony because he had a terrible take on the new Sleep Token Album. Actually ended up enjoying this interview so I guess surprising things happen.