Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode of Sister Songs, we trace Taylor Swift’s evolving relationship with love through three songs: Ours, Daylight, and Opalite. From the starry-eyed defiance of Speak Now to the self-conscious optimism of Lover and the quiet assurance of Showgirl, we explore how her writing moves from love as resistance to love as refuge. Enjoy! What sister songs should we do next?!?

Comments

chappell roan

Can’t wait to listen! This combo is insane! I have a suggestion: the fate of Ophelia X the prophecy ??

basicallyenya

really need madeline to open the case labeled "don’t blame me x elizabeth taylor"

Mischa

yayyyyyy

Maria Zuccarini

cant wait to listen! ❤️ also i think a cool ep would be father figure and my tears ricochet comparrison would be amaze. unless im crazy and no one else thinks theyre related 😭

moi_la_desi

Was thinking about those, too. 'Vigilante Shit' (for the kinda movie scenario) and 'Happiness' would work with them, too.

ryan

also, ours music video is underrated imo

lily

I would love an exploration of the idea of love needing to have both people present at a table/restaurant. This running thread can be identified in begin again / right where you left me /tolerate it eras set staging / gold rush / elizabeth taylor / opalite

Sophia

My mother accused me of losing me mind and I wrote ours ☺️

Amanda Moreno

you don’t know how bad I needed this ep!! to speak my truth, I have only been captivated by Taylor during ttpd (crazy). idk why but I didn’t really care for her growing up and only knew the big hits/she dates too much debacle.. so I had no idea about the absurdity surrounding the John Mayer interlude. I was sooo gaged and scared listening to shouldve couldve wouldve for the first time. and I had so many questions, like how the fuck ppl around her let that happen? now I feel that I understand it better 🫶🏼

Carmel

Opalite has the best opening line, thank you Austin Swift. Unfortunately the "ah-ah-ah" takes me fully out 😭

Hattie

Lover possibly being titled ‘Daylight’ gagged me because that would make the album title ‘Midnights’ make a lot more sense…

Liv

Question…? x COSOSOM x Ruin the Friendship pleak!!

Bailey Andrea

suggestion for the next sister songs: chloe or sam and sad beautiful tragic… retrospective sadness about what the relationship has done to her, the legacy it left both in the world and on her psyche, but also acceptance that it’s over

Claire

For me the reference to lightning strikes is a clever nod to « This is what your came for » ⚡️😄 Genius!

Sophia

A surprise tayvisology! What a treat

Magee

Madeline needs to upload the tradwife video to youtube. It would be the perfect youtube debut I'M SAYING IT

Kaitlyn

Lucky One, Clara Bow, Elizabeth Taylor.

Erin Hastey

Would you ever do a sister song from another artist? I cannot hear Maisie Peters’ History of Man without thinking of The Prophecy and You’re Losing Me. Very Joe Alwyn coded.

Joan Rood

I loved Ours when it was first released and it is still on my TS favorites playlist.

Kayleigh

Today is my birthdayyyy 🎈 so this Thursday’s pod ep is especially 😙👌🏻 happy early bday Zach!!!! and happy beginning of Scorpio szn for all 🫶🏻😌

Katie

I would suggest a sister songs episode about London boy x wi$h li$t but it would be about 5 minutes long

Jessica

Thank you for this, going back and listening to Ours was fantastic. Speak Now needs to be in my rotation more!

Anna Rama

Loved this episode so much, and I'd love to hear your sister song ep. on Invisible, You Belong With Me and Ruin The Friendship. I have been listening to Showgirl a lot, and I'm intrigued by the line 'Don't you ever end up anything but mine'. I've been comparing it a lot to 'You're the best thing that's ever been mine', which is an interesting development, but at least in both of these cases she has power or agency, unlike in her Matty interlude where she first wants to be claimed/posssessed by him in Guilty as Sin, but then comes out of that experience completely broken, as if she was abducted by aliens, cast away as a broken/boring doll, or hung up on a wall etc. Then again, she does call him 'never not mine' in imgonnagetyouback (echoing the Style narrative), but that's a girl living in denial/delusion moment. What I'm trying to say is, I'm interested in her view of possessing or being possessed by her object of love. I even like the double meaning of the word 'possession' here because both ownership and being haunted are themes that are all over her discography.

Miranda

You should use the intro music for an outro as well, I’m always like “oh is it over now?” lol

Anna Rama

Yes!!! That line in Ruin The Friendship 'always answer the question' stood out to me immediately. So she's saying she doesn't regret asking the Question and having it answered so painfully/embarrassingly.

Lana

When I first heard Opelite I kinda saw it as a grownup New Romantics. I love sister song episodes because there are some connections I never would've thought of 🫶🏽

Nicola

Had to pause the podcast and listen to speak now cos she really is the girl!!!! I mean give me something that will haunt me when you’re not arounndddd

Anna Rama

My theoryis that she has a document or notebook where she jots down all her album concepts, some of which eventually develop into albums. That's why/how she manages to Easter Egg years in advance.

PK

One sister songs idea: Karma vs The Prophecy?

Dev

potential sister songs: 'Ruin the Friendship' and 'the 1' am i cooking?

Elle Kaye

Add in Question…? too!

Dev

Oh my god, absolutely!!!!

Stellafera

on most romantic line in Taylor's discography - I'm gonna take a stand and pick "I'd like to hang out with you for my whole life" from Stay Stay Stay

Hannah

I cannot understand WHY Taylor pays Speak Now dust. If I popped that one out when I was 19 years old you bet your ass I’d be talking about that for the rest of my life. And completely solo written???? We genuinely need to be asking her why she never acknowledges it because if she’s not proud of Speak Now my world would be over

Hannah

And I’m a folkmore girlie!! But as a swiftie since 2008 the reason I loved folkmore so much is because it felt like a return to form, not because I thought it was something completely revelatory that she’d never done before….she would never have been capable of folkmore had she not written the entirety of Speak Now alone

Samuelline

My sister songs recommendation is Labyrinth and Guilt as Sin

Dan

Something that made my brain crazy when first listening to ttpd was how original, quintessential taylor it felt just more mature I was shook, I remember thinking this is fearless-red Taylor and that is why ttpd will always be that girl

Laine Wagner

I would loveee to hear ruin the friendship x question x chloe or sam or sophia or marcus through the lease of taylor’s inability to dodge fleeting thoughts and uncomfortable questions. I think there are many examples of this through the discography. the title track speak now could also maybe be a contender.

Lisa M

Yezzzz!!!

Leslie

Yesssss

Ana Hampu

I feel like my brain has been dewormed after listening to this episode. I never thought she was happier with Joe but I did think what they had was deeper, more serious. But maybe that was just the anxious attachment going into override. It makes for better songs but it’s not sustainable to be this anxious all the time and it does make you miserable. I still think Joe was her equal in ways Travis isn’t (as in, you wouldn’t need to explain the plot of hamlet to him), but in terms of showing up for each other, Tayvis for the win.

Rachel

Great episode but not why I’m commenting. I screamed YESSSSS and startled my cat when Zach mentioned that the Taylor is Not a Tradwife episode of Lizard Review needs to be on YouTube and TikTok. Madeline, I know those aren’t your platforms but Zach is right - the people need to hear it! And I love your Substack BUT this episode needs to be beamed everywhere for everyone to get it through their brains! Much love to you both. Keep doing what you do 🫶

Bella

Forever winter x Question x prophecy x ruin the friendship (they are quadruples ok)

Girl so in love 💝

I would love to see Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me x Father Figure

Renee Darline

She has her sword out...."dropped my sword..." "but if someone comes at us, this time I'm ready..." Long Story Short needs to be in this mix....

lottie

COMPLETELY AGREE!!!! This work of oratory art needs to be delivered to the masses! it is SO well done , SO articulate , truly bravissima work and a really truly grounding perspective which , clearly with the true dangerous delusionism running rampant out there in the streets, everybody needs a dose of! We clapped we cheered!

sarah mcallister

Halloween coded Sister Songs?: the sinister side of living/growing up in the spotlight: Elizabeth Taylor, Nothing New, Who is Afraid of Little Old Me, Clara Bow, The Life of a Showgirl......

Lil

The innocent little sister of "You can be my forever night stand."

Mandy Brafford

I think that blank space and father figure are sister songs!

vivsoftie

I know this won't actually happen, but I would really love some content on comparing similar themes that pop girlies share and how they attack them based on their own artistry. Something I've been thinking a lot about recently - since the Showgirl release and me putting Halsey's discography on repeat to prep for Badlands Anniversary Tour - is the connection between The Prophecy and Darwinism. I also in general feel like Halsey has a large enough discography and large thematic threads that a similar thing can be done just for their work. Obviously this isn't necessarily Tay related at all, but since Zach is a Halsey fan like me, I would enjoy a video on it from him.

vivsoftie

Yes Zach! Now that we have Ruin the Friendship, we NEED a sister songs about Taylor toying with friends to lovers. Ruin the Friendship, You Belong with Me, It's Nice to Have a Friend, Question.... and in my opinion, YOYOK.

Bianca Millan

Taylor refers to Joe as a ghost as early as Reputation! In "...Ready For It?" she says "But if he's a ghost, then I can be his phantom"

Maria

I think when she says never made someone like you she's getting religious again 😄.." Oh my Lord never made no one like you before"

Savanna

“We tayvis more than we toed” is an all-timer line

JD IHateItHere

Loved this. Going to Lizard Review now. Thank you for feeding.

Trish Veneziano

Daylight = your love story Second line = everyone looked worse in the light

laura

Nailed it! I think Taylor saw Ours as relevant to Matty too, because Ours was one of the surprise songs Taylor sang when Matty flew to Texas (from Mexico) to watch her on March 31, 2023. Her speech before the surprise songs included: “I love this one, and when I love something I don’t really care what the feedback is, so I didn’t check.”

Celiaarrghh!

How about Mary's Song, Lavender Haze & Wi$h li$t?

OneRainyWish_Again

I’m enjoying this episode a lot and simultaneously engaging in acute Beatles-fan behaviors, I have to speak my truth

reckless mermaid

Maybe Zach already saw this but someone mentioned on the Patreon that You Belong With Me might also be written about Jeff Lang and I was seated… it would be cool to look at her songwriting arc through that lens; I suspect we’re on the same page because he also mentioned it with Ruin the Friendship and even Forever Winter

Lizzy

The pull of wish list is the melodic math. The frequency of the song is addictive pop. I want to listen to the music but the lyrics are so confused. "We tell the whole world to leave us the fuck alone and they do." didn't you try that with Joe i thought it wasn't working lol 😅

Gabriel

I’m saying Tortured Poets is Speak Now 2

Lizzy

Ruin the Friendship is maybe my favorite song on this album, but for a while I couldn't figure out ... why a song like this on an album like this?? Then it clicked. "My advice is always answer the question" ... this is her getting the last word in on the matty healy interlude. She said all these things about him in ttpd. She lost her twin, he was the loss of her life, etc. Maybe she felt the need to explain her madness a little. To take us back to this formative experience that made her simply unable to leave a compelling question unanswered. In Dear Reader, confused, indecisive taylor told us not to take her advice. In this song, she offers it with confidence. No matter what happened, she's at peace that answering the question was the only way.

Stella

Just wanted to say thank you to Madeline for being the voice of reason with the Lizard Review episode (Taylor is not a Tradwife). As a mother, I needed to hear it, so thank you. 🫶

Leslie

Matty wasn't at the shows in TX - that was a fan rumor that turned out not to be true. He took a pic with a fan in the Mexico City airport. The fan was on route to Eras in Texas but Matty was flying elsewhere in Mexico and was photographed still in Mexico at the time when he was supposedly in Texas. I looked into all this when those rumors were going around because I went to Eras in Arlington and I was like, wait, was Matty at my show? lol. But he was in Mexico that whole weekend. I do agree that she probably had him in mind when she played Ours that weekend though.

Taylor Losche

*** ruin the friendship and tis the damn season ***

Hattie

My assumption is because the album is mainly about the devil John Mayor and she doesn’t like to be reminded of those times 😭

Eli

Consider: the lucky one, Clara bow, the life of a showgirl, maybe more… maybe too straight forward ahah but definitely sisters

Katie

Wow I just galaxy brained after reading this

Jojobear

fellow mother here and same. stay at home mother too,so the trad wife thing actually did start to get it me when I'd read articles by other women that made me realise, while I'd been routing for their choices, maybe they don't actually route for mine.

Stella

I know were you're comig from. I've felt the same recently. The internet can be so brutal to mothers. But I try to remind myself that what these conservative forces want is to divide women, and that the real world is full of good people and women supporting each other. I'm a working mum, but I have so much respect for stay at home mothers. It's a 24-hour job. Rewarding, but hard. You're doing an amazing job 💪 ❤️

Brianna Tullius

I know you guys have mixed feelings on this album but I have been really enjoying it and had a lot of fun with this episode! You guys are the best!

August Santos

Am I the only one who thought Taylor swift seemed really similar to Selena Gomez in the Jimmy Fallon interview? Like her movements and idk the way she was acting.

Ja Ma

The Lizard Review Episode was fantastic. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Layne Hunter

Hear me out — I Look in People’s Windows, Question…?, Ruin the Friendship

Chloe

Whenever Joe is mentioned i picture him as sad cat meme thanks to Madeline

Kiki🩷

The usual daylight hates hurts meeee 😭😭 (it’s okay I love to listen you talk)

DrEmily

Sister song theory (bear with me) - Teardrops - You Belong with Me - Mine - Forever Winter - Miss Americana - This Is Me Trying - Evermore - Bigger Than The Whole Sky - I Look In People’s Windows - Ruin The Friendship The sister songs of Jeff Lang. (Some are more of a stretch than others but I truly believe Teardrops - You Belong - Mine - Forever Winter - Ruin The Friendship. Bigger Than The Whole Sky also has its appeal. It would have been ridiculous to force 1989 and Rep to have one, although the Rep Vault tracks may be illuminating.

DrEmily

I’m truly certifiable at this point because I now think a case can be made for Teardrops (thanks to Madeline) - YBWM - Mine - Forever Winter - Miss Americana - This is Me Trying - Evermore - Bigger Than The Whole Sky - I look in People’s Windows - Ruin The Friendship. (Nothing from 1989 or Rep, but maybe Rep vault tracks?) I’m either crazy or a genius, I can’t tell.

DrEmily

Trying to justify another tattooed bad boy that people (and parents) are trying to talk her out of- sounds familiar

Brooke

Ana, I’ve been mulling the same thing. As Zack said —-so much of the music about Joe is more dynamic, but can see how that dynamism is fueled by so much anxiety and conflict. As someone who appreciates Taylor’s intellect, I’ve been puzzling speculatively too about her match with Travis, but I’ve been captured by some good writing by Lainey here about how we can discount emotional intelligence and how Travis has a lot of that. His ability to tune in, listen, be openhearted, help her feel seen and spacious is a kind of intelligence, and I like that idea! https://www.laineygossip.com/taylor-swift-travis-kelce-give-us-best-episode-of-their-rom-com-yet-in-buenos-aires/75123

Lorelai Fraisová

Is it too obvious to pointe out King Of My Heart and Ophelia? Haven't seen them conpared anywhere, but they're literally the SAME song! "I've been lonely and heartbroken for so long and just as I was coming to terms with it there you come and save my life"

Peter

Please do Elizabeth Taylor and Cornelia street

Rachel

And if I said Wi$h Li$t and Peace....?

Nova Franklin

since taylor is eligible for the songwriting hall of fame how cool would it be if you did an episode about that (for example you each pick one song about each era that showcases the best songwriting) or just show your nominees

Jojobear

I totally agree with you. The world is so so brutal to mothers, we cannot win. I just wanted to say I have complete respect for working mums, you're expected to work like you're not a parent and parent like you don't work. You're also doing an amazing job 💞

oh_annie___

I’m 99% sure Opalite will be the next single (this came to me in my dreams… I wish I were kidding 😅) and I texted myself my anticipated details earlier this week. It was already called out on I think the BBC1 video that it sounds very “holiday season” (I immediately heard the “oh oh oh oh” as “ho ho ho,” and there are production tinkerings I can visualize in a MV)… this wouldn’t probably be the worst single decision, but I’m scared of the potential MV 👀

Tzivie Pill

Better than revenge, the black dog and actually romantic

Julia K

“This love is difficult, but it’s real” lyric from love story is 2008. Crazy that ten years later she had the same perspective.

reckless mermaid

🤯🤯🤯 I was wondering if a good number of her older songs were about him. I didn’t join the fandom until she pivoted to pop mostly because I can’t stand most country music, so its hard to look back and analyze those songs. I thought it might be a reach because I know she did have interest in other boys in high school… But I’ve been thinking about ‘this the damn season… is she speculating what things would be like if he hadn’t passed away? I know parts of those albums are supposedly fictionalized and I think that would be a compelling angle to write from

Arden

dear john and father figure

Kat

It really is fascinating how she ignores Speak Now and new Swifties overlook it. Does anyone have any theories about why she overlooks it so much? I thought maybe it could be because her breakup with John was so painful but she clearly loves Red even though she was miserable through the period of her life

Jaida Gehring

I'm always Tay-positivity. I agree with your sentiments on the midness of Showgirl, but you know what the silver lining of that has been for me? I'm divingggg back into Folklevermore, Midnights, and TTPD ravenously enjoying the lyricism. I was never a Midnights stan but TLOAS has given me new appreciation for Midnights as its much more lyrically rich counterpart. I'm sure in a week or two I'll go back to jamming tf to Opalite and Honey, but I'm grateful for TLOAS for putting me knee deep in the Anthology and 3am tracks :)

Chas

Welcome to the cult of the anthology and evermore! 🍁🖤

Chas

You’re cooking 🧑‍🍳

Chas

I’m seated 🪑

tomatotime

Hi it’s so great to learn more about legal action and what is legally valid and isn’t, it’s grate that you are giving your opinion ¿as a lawyer, what would your expert advice be on Zack‘s intention to get the video or parts of the video where he’s getting potentially defeated deleted? Specially when it comes to the YouTuber saying that he’s gonna start a conspiracy. I would love to learn more about law from you.

Amanda

omg we NEED the you belong with me, teardrops, ruin the friendship, invisible, etc. sister songs episode im so serious!!!

Lauren B

I think Ruin the Friendship and 'tis the damn season are sister songs