Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 554290047.mp4

Downloads

Content

Welcome back to a very special episode of Kiki Lounge, where we do something we've never done before...react to a song TOGETHER, live on air. We're diving into Selena Gomez's brand new single and fondly remembering the last time we did a live reaction with the most gorgeous crowd in Atlanta, Georgia, on THE SNERAS TOUR. Then we scrap. Enjoy!

Coincidentally, it is The Ologist birthday and I am dutifully offline to touch grass, read books, write, and get a massage...TIA for the wishes <3 <3

Files

Comments

nish 🍓

the birthdayologist omg ,,,,,,

Kate!!!

YASS HAPPY BIRTHDAY TREADMILL VIDEO AND AN ATL SHOUT OUT YAS HITTING PLAY RN HAPPY BIRTHDAY

chappell roan

Happy birthday to the second best thing to debut on October 27th 🥰🥰🥰

makanani

STOP this title ??? i'm so excited

Ellajoy

Happy birthday ologist aka Zach 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼

gv

happy birthday to The Ologist!! best of vibes to the snakes today

Rebecca

Happy Birthday Zach!!! 🎈🎁🧁🫶🏼

Dijon🌺

HAPPY BDAY 🎉🎉🎉

L

Elderologist 🙏 happy kikiiii

Mikee Dayrit

I was just having such lonely days for no apparent reason and then this came up and now I feel happy. You guys are the best, happy bday Zach!

Merrie

Commenting my love as directed 🫶🫶🫶🫶

Weronika ⭐️

if you guys do decide to livestream on patreon please reupload it to the patreon after 🫶🫶

Nicolas Productions Inc

happy birthday Zach thanks for the past three years of the best and most iconic moments

elly slaughter

birthdayologist 🫶🏽🫶🏽🎊🎁🥳🎂🎉

Summer BT

I think it’s hysterical (in the nicest way possible) that people like Ed Sheeran and Justin Tranter are responding to your content, Zach.If your opinions mean nothing and you don’t know anything then why do these people with all their success condescend to respond to you? They should be ignoring you. Btw as one of the silent consumers, I think what you both do is amazing and you should both be so proud of yourselves. And the individuals who leave out of pocket personal negative comments and send you and your family members awful DMs are literally either children under the age of 18 or emotionally stunted adults. Their behaviour is akin to a dog that barks at you as you walk past it. It’s not personal- the dog barks at you as you walk past because that is its nature. That’s all there is to it.

Mary Quinn

Speaking now… love you guys 🫶

Bailey Andrea

glitch hate from madeline just silenced me

Lexi

i LOVE watching you guys react together!🫶🏼

S

Cirkut also worked on Mmm papi and many other Britney songs.

Hannah

happy birthday to you zach !! xx

Hannah

HAPPY BIRTHDAYOLOGIST!!! ( from a silent watcher lmao )

Carmel

Watching this as I eat my Nando's like I'm having brunch with the girls and talking shit 🍹

nextleveltom

Wait we need the link to that spreadsheet

ninamae4

I have a tin hat theory of how she pulled it off with Joe none the wiser. It came to me while listening to the 1. She told him it's from the perspective of someone who thought she was the 1. She shifted the pov. Context: I was in a situation akin to Taylor circa Joe/Matty overlap with less press. That's how I would have done it.

phoenix

SELENER IS SO BACK. It's giving 2013-2015 Queen Selena in the BEST possible way. I've only been a casual listener, observer, upmost appreciator; but after Lose You to Love Me, It's Not Me, and Wolves- I really felt that she lost a little bit of the very specific sound and vibe of what really thrived in her. When I heard this song the other day I had to do a double take to make sure it wasn't actually one of her songs from before that just happened to get a random bump refresh in the algorithm, imagine my surprise to see that this is in fact, our proper 2025 Selena

S

I don’t think they broke up that long before the eras tour because didn’t Joe directly say that they broke up a week before the news of their break up hit or something

Tom Lewis

Happy 29th Birthday Zach, one half to my favourite podcast duo! Hope get lots of R&R and is spoilt rotten today.

phoenix

Also, I am not new to the channel but very new to the paywall; I LOVED this one of you both reacting together. The things I love most about your respective reactions seemed to level up and meld for this one and the chemistry is top tier

Lexi

me too it’s one of my most played songs from midnights 🫢

Amber

Commenting from being a silent follower to handheart you guys - I feel like what we all want is excellent pop music, and it can't exist without thoughtful criticism.

Sarah

yesss! Fellow Octoberologist 💜💜💜💜

Sarah

the concept of ed sheeran using his ipad time to tell taylor that her biggest fan is annoying like to be a fly on the wall 😂

Cher

Get that well-deserved birthday massage queen. Wishing you only the most immaculate vibes. xoxo

makanani

guys what's the discord

Alexandra Milroy

I’m a silent follower and I love your content and your criticism. I ran to your Patreon after TLOAS and West End Girl came out, and I was not disappointed.

Lisa M

Happy birthday!!! 🎉🎁🎂🎊🎈 finally a Selena song with a beat 😭🙏🏻

Green Wolf

It's a live chat place. You can get there from your membership, on the top right. Or upgrade to get it. It's very fast going, really hard to keep up. And sometimes disheartening, strangely.

Mischa

HAPPY BIRTHDAYYYYYY

Finley

go on the patreon website and go to connections, attach your discord to your account and it will automatically add you to the discord!

RachB

Happy Birthday! Have a great day!!🎉🎊🎂

Claire

Aw I WAS in Atlanta! Manchild still makes me think of it, every time. So much fun. Come back!

Audrey Paquette

Happy Birthday Zach! Hope you have a great day!

rhi

Zack, when Madeline asked "Do you really want to listen to Better Than Revenge TV?", and you leaned forward and whispered "Sometimes", I just about died laughing Happy Birthday!

S

Happy birthday Zack

Nicole

Big big big relate to speak now being my favourite album because of how much it formed me and the full parasocial of it all

Lucy

Hey Zach and Madeline! I related to what Madeline said about wanting to write a nice comment and then deleting it because it feels stupid, but it sounds like y’all are needing the love so I wanted to thank you for all the hard work you put into the content, the consistency, the kikis, and just elevating the conversation in general. It’s also been a difficult period for me recently and it’s been nice to have y’all as company and a circuit breaker through it. Unfortunately I’m broke af and my Patreon subscription ends today, but I’m hoping to rejoin around Christmas time as it’ll be another solo holiday season for me this year and I just know I’ll feel less lonely watching your videos. Also, as an Australian snake, I can’t wait to go to the sneras tour! So excited for the announcement! Look after yourselves, have a great Halloween and Zach I hope you have a wonderful birthday today too 🎉

chappell roan

PLEAKKKK link the spreadsheet I need it!

Natalie Topalian

Speak Now TV is the best Taylor’s version album I said it… also a Foolish One truther

Gracie

Loved hearing yall loved Atlanta! I was probably one of the more rowdy ones 🤣

Lisa Reed

YAY I loved seeing yall in Atlanta :))

Kendall Swanson

Silent supporter here. Keep in mind the loudest haters are often the least intelligent! Also happy birthday Swiftologist

h

Wait what is the mysterious part of Glitch and Question for you guys? I'm genuinely curious 🙏 to me the mystery was solved with TTPD and the whole Matty interlude. Question (imo) is about looking back at some party they were at years ago, maybe 2014 during their first go around, and asking if he still remembers it and thinks about it too. And Glitch is about them reconnecting while working on their albums with Jack and thinking, oh shit I'm falling in love with him again but I don't even feel sorry about it. Sort of a prelude to Guilty as Sin pining. Am I crazy? To me they're super clearly Matty songs! I would love to hear others' interpretations

Nina

I think you should put the clip of your reaction to the knowledge of Selenas reaction + your discomfort with Taylor perceiving you as a short on your youtube. It has the potential- if they keep taking note of your content - to smoothe the waves a bit, because it shows that you love them both and makes it clear that you haven't turned hater just because you've criticized their latest work so heavily.

Green Wolf

Hi Lucy. You are never alone. I would love to pay your subscription. There is a gift link above, but there isn't a field for a recipient's name. I'm not sure how to do it. I am in Melbourne.

Gregabug

I'm usually p silent but I've been a long time patreon subscriber and love what you guys do! Also happy Birthday Zach😊

Amy C

I disagree with Madeline on the tv albums. I think the redone albums are exactly what had to happen to create the eras tour as it was. And tbh I like the tv songs better than the originals a ton, especially speak now/fearless with her older voice 🤷‍♀️

Kailey IR

love you guys, happy birthday Zach!

Pooh Khanum

I mean they all hated Socrates too

Matt

Such a good episode. Thanks guys!

Moonbeam009

Love y'all! You keep it real and SANE in this messed up hellscape that is the Internet. 😆

Kat

I think her team is in here 👀🧐

Gosia

This the best part of my Mondays! I'm really thankful for being part of this community!

Casey Dodd

You guys should post the Excel thingy for the albums

Susu

Pls do more music reactions together, that was really fun :) !!!

Abby

Evolution of a chats & reacts 😌

Dan

Madeline screaming at Zach is me every time he accidentally interrupts her 😭😭😭 it’s a common habit lol slay Madeline. Also speak now is that girl and I agree with Madeline on speak now tv I’m sure it’s a great rerecord but the original is just so cemented in my body and spirit it’s actually really difficult to listen to the re-records 😭 speak now was the first time an album or artist made me feel very seen and accepted as a 13 year old girl, it made me feel like it was okay that I was super emotional and hopelessly in love with the mystical and whimsical 🪄 also happy bday Zach 🫶🏼

liz liz liz ❤️‍🔥

atlanta mentioned! that show was so fun I was the one who yelled "tell me why" for whatever bit that was ( i forgot divas )

Abby

Massages are the BEST treat, enjoyyy! 💖

brey

Please add a link to the song rater excel!!

Lil

This chat felt more unhinged than usual and I loved it.

Nefelibata

Happy Birthday Zach!!! ✨

Georgea

Just realised I am part of the silent community!!! But I absolutely love u guys and the critical thinking KEEPS ME ALIVE pls don’t stop ok bye

Taylor Rae

I totally agree with Madeline on Speak Now TV. Most of those songs sound bungled to me. The mixing is roughhh. Haunted, Sparks Fly, and BTR are particularly egregious. I felt so alien in the fandom when it dropped bc everyone was celebrating how great it sounded and I was like ????????

Makayla

HAPPY BIRTHDAY ZACH!!! Have the best, most relaxing day. You deserve it!!

Abby

Tbh I think Taylor may feel a similar way about the TVs! I'm sure she got something out of it creatively and ofc they were commercially successful, but ideally she never wanted them to ever be a thing she had to do

hayleywilliamsmademegay

happybirthdayologist!!! been around since the first yearly episodes before folklore came out. have loved seeing your joint and solo slays, and dare i say, the evolution of the snakes

Angelo David

Zach did u see who’s opening for Demi on tour 👀 🫶

Ellen Kay

Yayyy I really needed this on this gloomy blue day 💕

hayleywilliamsmademegay

"its why they like me" well yesss i also read the atlantic, and your honesty and well thought out analyses and wit make you stand out among the jake shanes and the alex coopers and bowen yangs. they like everything, your words have WEIGHT. it's important what you're doing, and the conversations you're encouraging. Braindead people will always be louder, just keep challenging yourself and stick to your integrity and convictions. people will always be around for that. this is me speaking up now

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Zach... Taylor has quoted you so many times in passing. I'm not sure if she is just quoting whatever Gen Z thing she has heard - but so many times it feels very specific. The one thing that sets you both apart from other critics is you give examples of where the artist did it better or give ideas of how it could be better.

Sarah

Urgh i really wanted to go to the atl show but I couldn’t find anyone to come with me since i don’t drive. Maybe I’ll just uber to the next one by myself

gv

rewatching this and all kiki lounges bc y'all bring me joy

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Folkmore - Joe doesnt listen to Taylor Swift. She could have said ANYTHING (She gave so many signs).

Rachel H

Zach, the musings you did about being a critic and being “hated” and not being a best friend—I would love for you and Fantano to expand and talk about that more. I hope there’s another conversation with him in the future. ❤️

Paula C

100% they are

Liv

if my partner of 6+ years refused to publicly say his favorite song of mine when songwriting is my whole thing, I fear I would become the joker!!! she really was handcuffed to the spell she was under 😩

Paula C

I think Midnights has so many loose ends because it was her “hehe I’m about to date a Ratty”

Paula C

Joe didn’t realize or didn’t care “sweet nothing” loool

Winona

Speak Now TV is my favorite TV... 🤭

Makayla

The speak now TV convo. First I laughed… then I serioused. IJBOL love u snakes

Emily Kern

your Charli impression killlled me HELPPP

Aaron

Camilla reverted her rebrand and only god knows what she’ll do next

GekoGeko

Sending love from a silent community member

ala

i’m generally part of the silent community so this is my speak now moment lmao but i think this issue is perfectly summed up in zach’s video on call her daddy - almost everyone in the space is just agreeing with / loving everything so you guys being critical & thorny is why I clap and cheer… it’s just so refreshing to see some nuance and not only blind adoration

Kyla

Happy Birthday Zach!!!!!!!!!!

Cookie

As a massage therapist, I fully support the massage as well as wish you the happiest of birthdays 💜

Cleo Cleo Cleo

zach saying “you have to have a tail” sent me i love u guys

Sarah

I’m so embarrassed I used to be a Joe widow when joever happened. I blame the fact that I joined the fandom during lover era and had a hyperfixation for them —shudders—

Marlene 🌞

I love the content, I love how much thought and effort you put into literally anything you do. I followed you since early 2023 and I am so so impressed how far you've come. I am just never commenting on stuff but I always enjoy :)

Elle Kaye

Replacing Invisible String with the 1 felt too real for me to believe Taylor and Joe were done before they said they were. I think she wrote You’re Losing Me and played it for him, and that’s when he turned the plane around

Chas

I think so too! I think Madeline is picking up on a certain sadness or exhaustion in the TV projects from Taylor and I can see that completely.

Sarah

The fact that I had depression for half this year after my situation ship is insane trying to remember the first half of the year feels crazy

Sarah

as a fan of the 1975 since self titled i think he probably cares a lot but he probably is mad about the drugs as joe would be mad bout his depression. matty is really touchy (rightfully) about his sobriety

Taylor S

The girls are fighting

Elle Kaye

I’m pretty neutral on Taylor’s Versions — like on some the vocals are so superior that I don’t care about the production choices and others just aren’t any of my business. But I suspect why so many people have a viscerally negative reaction to them is because they’re in the uncanny valley

Megan Kearney

Better Than Revenge TV is the worst thing I’ve ever heard Madeleine I’m with you

Nina

Rayes album is on the horizon as well btw

tiamat

Swiftologist and Lizard you are one of the real ones 🫶

Kristi

I agree 100% with you about sombr. and the fact you are being called misogynistic is disgusting and them hating because you think differently then them. the girl was valid to make her first video (where she also shit on the opener for being bad??) and then did not stop and it became this huge thing. also adam is a rat bye

rafaela

I am one of the silent observers of you guys contents, also English is not my first language so that's also a reason, but I love your content. Before meeting you guys I was more of a casual Taylor Swift listener but through you, I have learned more of her lore and meanings of her songs, and now I am more connected to her music, so thank u for introducing me to the taylorverse.

Elle Kaye

For obnoxious as he is, Matty loves music and knows how to write a song. I’m sure there’s some on TTPD he dislikes, but his negging comments imply to me “Fuck. Guilty as Sin and the Black Dog are amazing,” and that’s what pisses him off.

Lexi

Put ur hearts up mention ily Zach

Karen Valentino

Loved this kiki! I love and respect that each of you reserves the right to change your mind.

iLaney90

54:21 I am the girl off the street 😅 I know the song she did for Barbie! That one's on my gym playlist.

Leslie

Madeline : Speak Now TV :: me : Red TV. I just can't with that. It actually offends me.

Leslie

Yeah I always thought they were on the rocks for a few months but still trying to work it out, then whatever happened between the Vegas and Arlington shows (where she played the 1 instead of invisible string for the first time) is what ended it for good.

folkswift

We don’t talk enough about how Mean was absolutely butchered

Dani Herold

It would be amazing to see you guys reaction to the documentary!!!!

Dani Herold

Just saying, I’m also a quiet listener but, honestly, I think it’s time to participate more because the content is, as always, toptier and there’s no one doing what you guys are doing!

Leslie

Yeah I agree, Question especially is super clear to me after she played it at one of the shows he was at and introduced it by saying her life finally made sense lol I guess the only thing that makes it confusing is her interpolating Out of the Woods at the beginning

Nicole DeRosa

(Kinda) silent supporter here - I love you guys and all you do 🩵

lilbirdiebb

CACKLING at “Do you REALLY want to listen to Better Than Revenge TV?” *whispers* “…sometimes”

Maria

As a late-in-life Swiftie I literally heard Speak Now OG for the very first time when she bought her Masters this summer. I thought Speak Now TV was kinda mid but Speak Now OG is way way way better. I can’t imagine hearing it as a teenager.

Holly

I agree except the ootw interlude at the beginning of question keeps me up at night. Any thoughts on that?? Were they just fucking with our heads?

Dijon🌺

We also got Olivia gearing up for a new era!

h

I think that could be her alluding to the theme of OOTW, like they've gone through all these years not able to make anything happen, and now is their time. Like, are we in the clear yet, good, this is our time, finally. (ETA they also met and had their first fling during the 1989 era so maybe she wanted to call back to that album and time period) Or it could just be her saying "I remember" because she's talking about the past, and it's not related to OOTW specifically at all. Orrrr it could also be referencing About You. "Do you think I have forgotten about you?" ......no, and I remember you too. I think the first two options are more likely, but I can't count out the third possibility because she likes to reference and respond to his songs apparently lol

Maria

Why was I only thinking of Pet Cemetery when Madeline spoke about the darkness of the Taylor’s Version projects.

Louise

Zack if you want to see the Ultrasound tour you absolutely should. I was just neutral/slightly positive leaning about Virgin but the show completely rocked me. I cried four seperate times and I was completely gagged by how evocative it was. Not something that can be captured in videos at all!

Louise

OR3 is going to save 2026 don’t worry

Mia Taylor

Help mom and dad are fighting

Gabby Kersey

I'll say it now and I'll say it forever, actual critique is one of the greatest gifts that someone can give you. To have something pointed out to you, that you may be blind to, is true love and respect. Flattery is the real sin.

Nicola

I sat beside the chuckle twins lmao, I remember thinking there's no way. She actually went there. In the Sombr girl's defence, her videos were quite funny, I thought she was pretty self aware and just saying this concert may not be people her age who casually listen and like his songs from TikTok and then just saying it seemed like he was being weird with his young fans idk. Also gonna do as Madeline said, love your videos, love to hear your takes, we love to hear different perspectives and we love to open the cases ❤️

h

That killed me 😭😂

Hope Davis

How do you find the excel song thing?

sarah mcallister

I unabashedly clap like a seal for you guys all of the time! And happy to do it!

h

Yeah there's no way he doesn't like/respect at least some of it, plus the bravery of putting it out there while knowing so many fans wanted to pretend the whole thing was just a blip and didn't mean anything. She doubled down HARD when she could have let it all be forgotten. I don't like Matty at all, but he's honestly my favorite muse of hers, just for bringing all of that chaos out of her

Miss_Lippy

Ms Piggy snout or GTFO! I’m joining Zach on Team Snout lol You’ve got to fully commit to the bit and rock that 🐽!

cheesefries

low key think it was maybe joes idea to not announce the breakup before midnights rollout because he didn’t want the hate and speculation in his life

Elli

Agree 10000%

Carissa

I went to the Ultrasound tour and it was an amazing show! Some of the stuff she did was random and silly, but she was a great performer and a lot of the lighting effects were cool.

Ryleigh Abraham

Happy Birthday, Zach!! Enjoy your day, diva!

Jennifer Lux

Seated for that Dublin show on audio for Christmas gift! Yes please, in our stockings!!

boop

good thing i like my youtubers CANCELLED!

boop

we can only hope. listen to us, team.

Sarah

as a dublin snake alumni YES!

pricila

let me do some hand hearting 🫶🏼, love ya’lls content i don’t agree with all of your takes but the way you articulate your opinions is incredible. Also you guys are funny and are a wealth of knowledge of the taylorverse !

Lisa Reed

Happy Birthday!!

Mara Collins

Member of the Silent Community Here! I listen to every episode and love you guys but rarely leave a comment. Hand hearting from afar.

Marymary08

I’m so happy Madeline called Zack out for interrupting her!! I love Zack but he does tend to interrupt Madeline a lot

pricila

lowkey with madaline, although i love the vault tracks, the production and even the vocals are wonky. For me, the biggest thing is that the EMOTION is no there. Mean, mine, dear john, last kiss etc does not hit the same

cheesefries

ok i loved virgin and then i saw ultrasound made me love it more also cried several times it was amazing one of the best shows ive been too i loved the contemporary dance it was amazing

Liz

As a member of the silent majority I will speak now: thank you divas for giving thoughtful meaningful criticism. It feels like this is the only corner of the internet where I can get that along with the fun kiki - best of both worlds!! Hello!! Keep doing you divas, you are sorely needed!

Louise

It was 100% the best arena tour experience I’ve had which is crazy because I went to Short n Sweet which was an incredible production. It just made me feel so deeply immersed and nostalgic and moved I can’t explain it

Paige Brewster

Silent majority, sorry! Zach, Madeline, I absolutely adore your videos. I have watched reviewers before who are always positive about everything and it drove me up the wall. When I discovered you guys it was so refreshing to finally see some critical and thoughtful evaluations of pop culture and music. You guys are hilarious too, to the point where I've started using some of your silly sayings in my real life because I forget no one else is in on the joke haha.. I have to tell my extremely offline husband that these things are slang that EVERYONE is saying so I don't feel like such a loser haha... Keep up the good work team!

Lee Bowman

i think matty probably loves ttpd, because it’s all about him

Trish Veneziano

Zachary, it’s ironic that I’m going to quote the current purse to calm you over the fear of Taylor hating on you. He always says you have to look for the kernel of truth even when you’re being criticized.

Anna Rama

I love what you two do! I don't necessarily agree with your opinions, but I always learn new stuff, I always come away with new ideas, and I always get to laugh out loud. Thank you both for doing what you do.

Sarah

Madeline yelling at Zack to stop interrupting her is how i feel at family gatherings as the youngest since everyone always talks over me

Lisa

The Twilight shirt is killing me😂

chinese satellite

Hi guys! Silent majority person here and it is my time to speak now - I'm just like Madeline when it comes to leaving positive comments 😅 I write it out and then delete it bc of shyness. I've been following you guys since around the Midnights release and finally joined the patreon at the end of 2024, and it's been so fun being behind the paywall. You guys have made me appreciate music in a way I never did before because I used to be a bit Swiftie-stan-brained about it. You helped me grow out of that phase and I'm so happy that I can now appreciate ALL music/artists in a much healthier way. You two have turned me on to so many artists that I otherwise never would've given a chance (shoutout to Blondshell, ADÉLA, Cece Natalie, Sunday (1994), Charli xcx, Chappell, and Mitski!) because of how you guys talk about their artistry. Thank you two for all that you do for music critique and for those of us who like to appreciate all artists in their own way!! Sending love here bc TikTok and Twitter can be so toxic when it comes to music/artists #teamsombr 🫡

Sarah

I don’t think I’ve played it since it came out

olivia perez

yes Madeline call him out! the little crashout was so real and justified

Chas

Seconded!!

bug

this vid makes me hand heart so hard for both of youu 🤸✨🕺🏻🥳💖 what a vulnerable episode and still staying true to your personalities?? idk i feel healed of something i didn’t know was broken LOVE YALL

Mia_333

Another member of the mostly silent viewers! You guys do such great work and have forever changed my approach to thinking about pop culture. It’s ridiculous how black and white people can be about art, so keep it up! Xoxo

April

I actually prefer speak now Taylor’s version as an older woman, I prefer songs like enchanted with her big girl voice, the songs have a maturity, and the original just sounds too little girl for me

CandaceBryantArt

I am recovering from surgery, and all of the “Speak Now” discussion as of late has been filling my painkiller-laden heart with so much joy 💜🫶

Cameron Van Sant

When Zack started talking about Charli xcx, my Spotify played party 4 u lol

Jasper Murray

I'm a silent watcher and love you guys so much!! Normal people in real life will be just as critical as you guys of stuff, so don't let the idiots on the internet make you feel like you're ever being unreasonably negative. Happy birthday Swiftologist!!

גילה עובדיה

When im told to speak now - I shall speak now. I LOVE your videos and critique. You guys are smart, funny, have a great chemistry and intresting to watch. If you were only glazing taylor - I wouldnt be here. Its the balanced percpective with the funny attitude.

Rachel B

As a normally silent subscriber, I do enjoy that you stand on your opinions-be they positive or negative or agree/disagree with my opinion. It helps me critically think about the subject in general, or how I hope the artist will grow in the future.

Shannon

Madeline, I can tell that the miserable state of everything has been making you more fed up with bullshit, and I'm in exactly the same place. Like, don't speak over me or you're gonna catch these hands energy. 💯💯

Abby H

Silent fan speaking now ♥️ Have loved the pod since at least 2019 when a new episode dropping was a jump scare (in a good way!!!!!!) I remember where I was when Madeline Engaged news made the airwaves! Got my sister onboard and now we have our own secret language of not just taylor lyrics but also EOAS references 🤣♥️

sara :)

happy birthday to our favourite PRICK!!!

Lydia

Snakes, this is my first Patreon comment. I am un-silencing, but I've been here clapping and cheering (invisibly but certainly here) behind the paywall since a little before Tortured Poets, and following the free content since 2023! I don't think I'd be half the pop culture fan I am without you guys. Nobody else in my life really cares about this stuff, but I do. Because of you two! Because you make thoughtful and interesting points that highlight the intrigue behind the internet and pop culture's moments. I'm always able to gag people who dismiss it as non intellectual by my insightful comments powered by YOUR insight. You two spark interesting conversations off the internet you never hear about, because there are so many people out there who are fascinated by your way thinking when introduced to it! 🫶❤️ (now I think I have to go back to silence commenting stresses me out ahhhhhhh but love you guys ok bye)

August

The dublin audio would be the greatest gift of the year

Shannon

Regarding whether Joe was supportive of Taylor, I think that's part of what she was referring to in Honey when she said, "When anyone called me "lovely" they were finding ways not to praise me". That's really a British English expression more than American, so I can just hear him saying, "Mmhmmm yes dear, it's lovely." 🙄

Cameron Van Sant

I put on Willow after Madeline said it's about Matty and the "There was one prize I'd cheat to win" lyric took me out 💀💀💀 (Not saying Taylor did, I'm just saying 💀)

chappell roan

madelineeee it would be so cunty if you shared all the data from the snammys at the end, like literally just post a google drive with ur notes or all the submissions and the votes like I would GAG to see that

Aimee

Zach finally giving midnights the love it deserves I seeeeee

Rachel B

I think an interesting holiday video could be either or both of yall ranking pop holiday singles/albums if you have done that or something like it

Aimee

I need debut tv bad and i need it now

August

Madelines face during the "do you like ethel cain" reenactment is one of the funniest things i've seen

Rachel B

A good end of the year video (whether behind the paywall or not) could be “reacting to subscribers 2026 predictions”

Bi

Omg happy birthday! 🫶

Roberta

wishing you good health 💜

Alex

I also found some of the ultrasound tour videos kind of cringe before I went HOWEVER when I was there in the audience suddenly all was revealed to me and I understood it like never before

Tara

After a long day, I just got home and was about to wind down when I suddenly realized...it’s Monday! Kiki Lounge! My favourite show is on.

Saanal

Yes! Literally a year ago I was a quasi Lorde hater who would’ve never gone to a her concert if they paid me. So when I say in my decade plus of seeing bands and artists live that that was the best arena experience I’ve ever had with an artist it’s crazy to me but here I am…

Saanal

She responded to critiques from them in the very way they worded it in her apple music interview I SWEAR. I wasn’t seeing it given the same way anywhere else

Alex

to me a lot of what she says comes off as kind of pretentious (especially recently about virgin), but hearing her say similar stuff in person it came off way more genuine and I understood the vision

Emily Puckett

It sounds like you need to modify that spreadsheet to also calculate the standard deviation. Standard deviation can be a little harder to think about though.

emmy

I lost it when she did that oh my god🤣

Veyda

The other day I clicked on a deranged real of a Joe widow and I just couldn’t believe that they still do the behaviour. They made a stupid St. Patrick’s Day post into omg he knew she got her masters back and was so happy for her and she told him immediately because they are still good friends and have such a good relationship. They really said that they need to believe that they are still on good terms. All because he posted a cloverleaf. Like did we listen to the same songs? I shouldn’t be surprised. I don’t know what I expected. These deranged people are the reason I can never talk about her music seriously in real life. And I hate that because please let me talk about Taylor Swift!

mikeymasciola

main arguement: happy people dont write dear reader! (love the midnightology that album is so confusing to me it def needs another deep dive feat the bone collector)

Nikki Glaser

Love the talk about your prophecy, Zach!

Bi

as someone who works in the film industry. Yes film people are some of the most annoying people on the planet. I recently had to go to an award show and it was one of the worst experiences of my life having to talk with so many, critics, Sycophants who are just there to smooze and see famous people and D tier actors who act like they deserve the world but haven’t been in anything. Mind you I work pre production concept and visdev work. So I feel super out of place. Everyone has a me me me mentality.

Esteban García

I think Willow is about Matty cause the whole album is about giving closure. She said that in the Zane lowe interview

Anastasia

Your videos are an essential part of my life now so much so I have to use a sketchy telegram bot to pay for the Patreon through fake cards cause I'm in Russia lol What you do makes a difference you guys💃💝

sofia

happy birthday zack!!

Dea

You two are such amazing ‘companions’ to so many of us. To me personally since 2023 :) I have learned so much about experiencing music thanks to you, discovered new artists, reflected more deeply about pop music and culture… all while laughing really hard. I’m so glad you shared a psychosis on tumblr.com and formed the smartest, funniest, most charismatic duo ever 🫶

Dea

THE Nikki Glaser is here?! ♥️👑 We cheer!

Jeanne

Zach you are lying about better than revenge TV and you know it 💀

sofia

also since you requested to speak now, i started listening to the pod in 2022, a few months after i finished high school and moved to a different city for college. i love all of your content, you are funny, smart and have taught me so much when it comes to critical thinking. what you do is so important since there seems to be a misconception that you either have to absoloutely love or absoloutely hate something, with no in between. i can’t explain it well, but you are somehow a pillar in my adult life and i look forward to every episode and video every week. i love you guys!! ❤️

Iana Mergen

Zack is me with the new Selena song. It’s the year of Selena save us!

Almudena

Loved this episode! Sending you lots of support and love from Spain 🇪🇸 Thank you for making my daily commutes bearable guys. I’m always grinning like a loon, specially when you argue (like today 😂) ❤️

lindsey koetze

Here to speak now from the silent community: a critical lens is ALWAYS needed when it comes to art, literature, science, etc. No improvement can be made if there's no opposition. And also it is very refreshing to just hear someone say: "This song sucks" bc I probably thought so too lol. Sometimes, to be a people pleaser and find something good in art that you think is terrible gets very tiring, so I love you guys' honesty! Also, I think your reviews are very fair Zach! Just what constructive criticism should be.

Mariana

Olivia possible release for 2026 mention here! 🫶🏻

nicole

I 100% agree with you, Madeline. SN TV is sooo bad, worst of all the rerecords, I can't listen to it at all.

Yasmin

YESSSSS I WILL BOOK TICKET FOR SYDNEY ASAPPP

Mary Grace Collins

Been getting humbled consistently from ages 22-26 what now 😂

emmy

Charli has done the soundtrack for the Bottoms movie with Ayo Edebiri and Rachel Sennot and I liked it. Also PLEASE do a Halloween video or something, I’ll tune in

Emily 🌻

Silent watcher speaking up!! As a huge hater of stan culture I really love and appreciate what you guys do. I'm sure it's hard when the loudest people out there are so convinced that any criticism of their fave is an act of violence on par with homicide, but I hope you can remember that the vast majority of people are a lot more reasonable and want to engage with pop culture critically! Even if we're not always shouting it from the rooftops because we're too busy spending time offline to stop the brainrot from consuming us too, I promise we're here and we support <3

Rachel

The very minor call out over interrupting was so real and wholesome 😅 just me eavesdropping on something that could really only occur between two people that truly KNOW each other (not to be too parasocial)

Ashley

I’m a long time subscriber and have always appreciated how authentic and honest you guys are. I’m really looking forward to the reactions for the Eras documentary. Thank you for sharing 🫶🐍 Happy birthday, Zack!

Andrew

We want beyonce discography deep dive!!!! You could pre-banked it for Australian tour!!

Paula C

Of course it is! Most of folklore evermore is. He messaged her in the middle of the night and she would bend right to his whims

Lauren

Act 3 is def slated for 2026 possibly after a documentary

TB

Re your role of being a thorn and people liking you for being critical - the outrage algorithms favor it and idk if I’m part of the silent majority but that is what I like least about your work - I’m here for the insightful respectful analyses, deep engagement with the work, connecting dots across songs, albums, context and culture to facilitate deeper understanding and appreciation of the work, nuanced takes, insight about the creative process and the business, and when critiques are delivered constructively and respectfully, as well as your wit and intellect. I think this is your comparative advantage and where I’d love seeing you lean into with your content (and less criticism-focused on balance) - there is no shortage of clickbait dragging of artists and their work and judgy mocking out there - but there is a dearth of the creative contextualized deep insightful analytical lens you bring and I feel that is your value-add to this space

Rachel

Yes yes yes the people want to see it!

Chas

Agree with everything you said, Emily!

Ruby

silent viewer speaking! you guys are the first people i come to for a balanced and critical review on music even if i don’t agree all of the time

Jojobear

he absolutely does. at Glastonbury he referred to himself as a poet. 🤮

Chas

I agree that Travis loves TLOAS which is really all I need to know to confirm my own feelings on the album. Happy birthday, Zach! And Madeline, when you mentioned the 2012 aesthetic with red Starbucks cups, plaid shirt, picture of the cd I almost threw up from nostalgia. What I wouldn’t give to be back there, hearing Holy Ground for the first time. Now we need a deep dive on Dear Reader cos only real ones know and understand.

Abby

Zach ily 🫶🏽

malia

would really love to hear your thoughts on jack and hayley williams rolling stone musicians on musicians - a silent viewer💕

Rosie Huntress

Silent community member here. I enjoy the nuance and critique you bring. Homogeneous or blind fandom is boring as F.

Hazal

Silent watcher here. Your content genuinely makes my day every time! It’s become my favorite form of entertainment. Love you both ❤️

Syd

ZACH you should totally go to the Ultrasound tour, it’s just fun to watch our freaky weird girl do her thing!!!! I saw her and loved it. Definitely some laughable moments but every moment was ENTERTAINMENT.

Catkin Sanctuary

I will speak now as a silent listener; thank you both for sharing your insights and friendship.

Margaret Schinkel

I love you guys. No matter how much shit Adam RATintire speaks on the internet, I will always be supporting yku

leftoutlemons 💖

Thank you both for all the good vibes 🫶 I've been going through it and really appreciate y'all's energy in this time of personal heartache

cami

i agreeee omg it was insane

Joey Caleb

Miss Piggy should host the Snammies!

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

The time magazine article also had sooooo many tidbits. I also felt the Apple interview was almost trying to protect folks like Zach and Madeline - saying "I'm not the art police" was very, VERY insightful !

Ellajoy

Swiftologist influence Justin!!!!!

Ellajoy

We seriously need you in the industry Zach! Like neeeeeeeed. Keep on going! We love you!

Athena Bermudez

I also cheered for a new Mitski album 😩🙌

bluetybloop

Adam is always such a shit stirrer

bluetybloop

Swiftie here and i’ve never seen olivia hateration, sad to see it exists. Nothing but positivity for her. My only critique is that she’s younger, more successful, and hotter than me, which is jailable but i can forgive it

Kathleen Cady

Hey! Silent follower here! I’m definitely someone that just dwells in the background and hardly ever comments, but I look forward to every video from y’all. You have a candor and critical thinking that I find really enjoyable. I also love seeing how you cover both Taylor and other artists. Wanted to chirp up for just a moment. Thank you for being voices in the space!

Jennifer Schariter

@snakes, I would like to send an extra signature for TLOAS to Zach and write a letter to you both. Is there a PO Box I can send it to?

Em Ro

You said speak now so I am! I find both of your voices to be absolutely vital in the zeitgeist… also, I wonder if Taylor (and co) would respect and understand your thorniness. She probably doesn’t always like it, but your takes are sharp and discerning and I think many artists crave that kind of thoughtful, critical feedback

Avery 🐈‍⬛

I'm so glad someone else feels as strongly about Speak Now TV as Madeline does. Something in my body told me not to preorder that album before listening to it.

stephaliceo

i was always a silent non commenter but something about you guys makes me wanna comment all the time 😂 whether it’s defending you or just wanting to be in the conversation, love it 💗

caroline young

Like everyone else speaking up now I also have to share my piece. I’m a mostly silent supporter as well. I love everything y’all put out and listen everyday. I will listen to the same videos 3 times when I run out of y’all’s content because y’all entertain me so much. I love the hot takes, recently obsessed with zach thinking father figure was about joe and Madeline I really am so mad you didn’t say nicole Kidman dead because I think the idea made me cry from how funny it was. Love u snakes. Keep up everything don’t let the fools and clowns and haters bite u cause remember they’re putting their hand in YALLS pit. Good thing I like my friends cancelled.

Katie

I loved seeing y’all just cheesily groove to the new Selena song haha, I had the same reaction!

stephaliceo

also i need that spreadsheet!!

sky

Similar to the excel Madeline talked about, there's a site called My Pitchfork (https://mypitchfork.fun) and it lets you essentially do the same thing :) you can search albums, rank them and save.

Ada

Madeline holding that damn poker chip like a baby the whole time is so cute

Katie

I just got to the speak now part of the episode, so I gotta comment positively, but not delete it out of embarrassment like Madeline 🤣. I love listening to both of y’all talk, you’re so charismatic and fun and genuine. I love when you’re geeking out and grooving to something, and I love it when you’re throwing tomatoes. You seem like cool people and I’m happy to support when I can. :)

Jordan Bailey

you guys make my perspective feel so seen as a fan since debut. it’s so hard to find reasonable fans that were seated through all of the lore, so this podcast is so refreshing and i love the honesty! :)

Katie

Madeline: DO YOU REALLY WANT TO LISTEN TO BETTER THAN REVENGE TV? Zach (panicked whisper): sometimes

Sarah Walker

silent community member here!!! i love you and watch all of your videos religiously. i’m sorry im almost 30 so i am not online and miss so much of the nuance of the recent internet drama 😂

Cassady Lynn

happy birthday Zach!! ✨✨✨

Lia Russo

Madeline scolding Zack brought out a really adorable side of him. When he whispered "sometimes" after she asked if he really wants to hear better than revenge TV😭

Lina

Hi! Silent supporter! I love your content for its critical edge, but i also love it when you love things! You’ve put me onto Adela, Jade, Audrey Hobert, among others and I love them! I think it’s really easy to get bogged down by the negative but you do SO much hand hearting!! The way you love can’t be ignored, it’s ferocious. Kiki lounges are SUCH a blast, I always watch them the day they come out 🩷🩷

Stefan Caiazzo

First thing BTR TV has incredible vocals. It is incredible cunt serve of the century besides the lyric change. Also am I sensing the trials of an eventual brand shift… “the ologist…”- I think it’s pretty damn good

Clara

since he also writes about it i’m pretty sure he’s actually fine with others writing about it too but in a respectful way, not in a way to weaponize it against him or be shameful cause then that gives unhinged fans permission to be hateful about his addiction issues and that not only affects him but also other people who are dealing with the same who come across those types of comments.

stephaliceo

also i am 100% there if you do come to brisbane aus! i need some brissy swiftie friends stat 😭

Clara

well he kinda is lol but he was also joking cause he played chocolate right after he said that with gibberish lyrics on the screen. he’s just always taking the piss and since he has british humor that tends to get lost on some people who take everything he says 100% seriously but also “poetry is in the streets” has been a 1975 slogan since their first album.

Kingskellii

Hi silent patron I love ur vids and the Lizard Review and EOAS. ❤️❤️❤️

Clara

I think 2026 is gonna be a big year for music similar to 2016 (can’t believe it’s about to be a decade since) like rihanna and frank ocean might drop new albums since their last time was in 2016. olivia, lana, harry styles, beyonce, and even chappell might drop at the end of 2026. doechii also working on her debut album rn i think and the 1975 will probably drop an album too, maybe charli too? unless she’s just focusing on her films next year.

Kay

Zach you are always giving constructive feedback. The girlies shoulddd be listening to you

Tina

as a silent community member, this was such a good kiki!! the ttpd point is SO true, such a good album but she was really saying anything on there…

Kay

I obnoxiously comment on all y’all’s videos and the lizard lounge on Spotify 🤣

Brutus

I love watching you two react together to things. I would love to see you two do an album together!!!!

Kitty

omg I remember Put Your Hearts up by Ariana. I had it on my mp3 player and would listen to it all the time because I loved Victorious. I'm not even a stan and didn't keep up with her music career after that (the only album of hers I've listened to in full is eternal sunshine) but I was an OG I guess lol

Kitty

The thing about the Speak Now TV episode that's so funny to me is that that was like the very first episode of the podcast that I ever listened to because I found it through Swiftologist so I knew Zack but not Madeline and she was so pissed off about SN TV and I was like "I don't really like this girl..." lmao of course now I love her and think she's the coolest prettiest funniest girl in the world but that was my very first impression of her lol

Lauren Markland

Hi guys! I had planned to end my membership this month but after the nonsense happening on YouTube I decided to extend it. Sorry thats happening to you Zach, honestly I haven’t even watched the videos because I don’t want to give them clicks but I saw your community post. The internet NEEDS YOU guys to give essays and critical analyses so don’t let anyone stop you. Also remember that the silent majority often don’t want to comment to support you guys because we’re scared of being ripped apart by the insane minority. I just don’t have the capacity to handle it, but I appreciate and love your content ❤️

Kitty

also thank you for what you said about not being too embarrassed to post comments because I do that thing where I type something out and feel stupid and then delete it all the time but I just wanna say I love the snakes ya'll are such a bright spot in my life :)

Bonnie

I was a silent follower for a long time on YouTube, but started commenting more since getting on Patreon 😊 Kind of different scenario but when I was young and learning to draw I used to post my art on DeviantART and get some really constructive critique from older artists. It stung a little to younger me, but I grew so much from it! I miss those times when people would speak their mind when they see an area for improvement… you can’t grow if no one points it out to you. And I feel you guys offer that and it’s getting really rare these days. So keep up the great work that you do, deep down some artists may actually be grateful because you’ve helped them grow!

Niali Oliver

can’t wait to see you guys in Melbourne xx I talk about you guys so much my even my non-swiftie friends are going to come to the show with me !!!

Madeline

i just wanted everyone to know that zach and i are wearing the same shirt

Lizzie

I’m wearing the same twilight shirt rn!

Lizzie

Zach ilyyyy and your honesty and humor. You both make me crack up so much I’m a fan for life!

Zana

no way!

Zana

Yall NEED to film an episode for Halloween wearing ur costumes!!

Jessica

wait if ya'll really want a tiktok for the dublin audio why don’t you get someone to animatee it. i feel like it would make it funnier.

E ✨🩷

I loveeeeee Dear Reader, feel it's underrated. Midnights will always have a special place in my heart because it brought me out of a funk I didn't realise I'd been in as a result of the pandemic. I was pressing PLAY on Anti-Hero constantly

E ✨🩷

Re Folklore/Evermore I do think there are *some* songs that are hypothetical made up situations but a lot of it is definitely from Taylor's personal experience and she covered that up by saying it was this fictional world. Cowboy Like Me? Cardigan? The 1? I feel could all be Matty Healy. Also Happiness??? Peace??? Hoax??? Tolerate It??? Joe and Taylor must have been on the rocks for a long time.

E ✨🩷

Sorry for spamming the comment section but Speak Now was my entryway to being a Swiftie (of course was aware of the Fearless/Debut hits prior) 15 years ago when I was 15. Last Kiss hit me like a ton of bricks!! Haunted, Dear John, Sparks Fly, Better Than Revenge, I was obsessed.

Mega :)

I’ve been in the Patreon for a while now!! Can anyone please help me on joining the discord?

Satu

And the same people are still arguing that most of TTPD is about Joe, because Joe was so important and Taylor would never write so many songs about someone as inconsequential as Matty. But why would they want songs like loml or The Black Dog to be about Joe 😅. The man of those songs does not come out well at all! So they think Joe is the best but also that he is a lying coward?! Make it make sense! 😄

Emmanominon

I was so serious when I said I would move heaven and earth to sell out your perth show. If you guys spoil us with a perth date I will make sure you are fkn SOLD OUT

Emmanominon

My friends are easily peer pressured, my man is a willing victim and his friend group is influenced by proxy. Even if after all that, if I have to buy multiple - MULTIPLE - tickets I goddamn will

Veyda

Omg, don’t get me started. I saw them arguing that Renegade is about Taylor from Joe’s perspective. They really said that she is taking his view on her because he couldn’t possibly be the person she’s talking about because he is the best and he saved her and he’s perfect. I doesn’t make sense! Just take the god damn food about the messiest pop culture moment in a long time and eat it and enjoy it. I’m still clapping. I’m still at the restaurant. I’m gonna say it: The Joe widows arguing that TTPD is mostly about Joe are more deranged than the Tayvis warriors arguing that The Alchemy is about Travis.

Erin

Madeline how could you possibly love Wish List but not like Glitch it’s the same melody 😭

Erin

Oh this is a cute idea!

nam

this is one of the best kiki lounges ever ngl

nam

zachs charli impression HELPPP

Kat

Silent Community over here! Please never change, your content is a lifeline in the hellhole of the internet 💜💜💜💜

JD IHateItHere

Snout is one of my all time favorite words for the auditory joy but also there is just something funny about the image it conjures. I really need to see iconic Miss Piggy from Madeline and whatever Kermit Mason is bringing. Thank you both for carrying us along in these horrid days of online absurdity. You slay everyday. We are better for you.

emmy 🪽

as a silent community member i love you guys ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Laa Toii

You need to link your discord with your patreon account, then it auto join you

Hattie

“Putting someone first only works when you’re in their top 5” Bejeweled says it all. I think it’s safe to assume Joe had very little knowledge/experience with Taylor’s discography before meeting her, and probably proceeded to not engage during Rep/ Lover. Which is astounding to me, especially as he Co-wrote some of Folklore/ Evermore. But, in his words, “it’s like making sourdough” 🥴 Great Kiki lounge thank you snakes! 🐍

Erin

I love how threatening this is 😭 I hope you get your Perth show diva

Emmanominon

Dear reader is like my illicit drug that I stay up to keep snorting in the middle of the night with a complete inability to exercise even a modicum of impulse control over

Mega :)

I did but I’m seeing anything on my discord…I clicked a link posted her but it said it’s expired

Anna

Silent listener / reader since I followed you both on tumblr in the old days and I just love your content always!!!!

Kristin

Silent community member here to share there was a Swiftologist shoutout (positive) on Las Culturistas last week!!

cami

no literally ultrasound tour is incredible pls pls go even if you're not a lorde stan its one of the best shows ive ever seen

Swiftologist

not an og!!! thank you for sticking around <333

Mari P

I'm speaking up as a silent enjoyer!!! i love you guys and i appreciate how honest you always are, i know it must be hard but please ignore the haters because TRUST there are many people who love your content<3 also i love this episode i was dying from laughter at you fighting over speak now tv and zach defending better than revenge tv😭 hilarious ily

Emma Frasher

Can’t tell you how many times I too have gone to leave a positive comment and then deleted it because I felt dumb and weird (why?!)

Emma Frasher

can’t thank you both enough for the breath of fresh air that your HONEST, thoughtful opinions are—this is what being a true, loving fan is! Not just another mindless Stan and yes man🫶

Chelsea Bauscher

I'm a proud, vocal enjoyer of Swiftologist/TLR and when I see a hate train I vocally praise your work without making fun of or belittling people. Big brain, respectful thinking

Chelsea Bauscher

The way I would be so seated for "Snakes Animated" content!!! Creative divas get to work! 🖤

charisma

I am with Madeline on the TV conversation. I wonder if anyone feels this way but I also hate having the taylor’s version in my library because aesthetically they all are not very nice to look at and I hate having to see the titles with parentheses next to them. Especially in my playlists. I need the clean original titles with the original album covers in my library only. Even though I do prefer some of the TV tracks it just is what it is.

Ally ❤️

Would love to see an episode on each of your top 10 Pop Christmas songs of all time lists! What songs just “work” for the holiday? Also a list of the horrific Pop misses would be fun!

Kathleen

I so agree with your feelings on Speak Now! That was the album that made me a Swiftie, I was a freshman in college and songs like Never Grow Up and Long Live hit at just the right time. And then getting to be at KC night 1 for the TV release party was such a full circle moment. 💜

cyryl

I was a silent lurker for a bit but I had to be on your Patreon because I love the sass and the honesty, even when I don't agree. Keep going snakes ❤️❤️ love ya!

Averi

Silent community member here also Atlanta sneras attender. Manchild will always be special to me. Thank you guys for being my favorite content creators and bringing me light within these dark times on the internet :)

Jessica Maguire

Zach saying “I’m canceled” was actually peak humor at the moment. Not sure if that was intentional or not but I cackled. I love a self aware chaos manager. Edited to add: I commented before the context of timing came through during a convo later on, But that makes it even more ironic, holy duck.

Gennie Brown

I used to be a silent community member until I joined the discord (never been in a discord before) and I absolutely love you both and the community you’ve created. Nostalgia fuels my depression a lot, the last few years I’ve been really missing the old fandom days of tumblr. A big part of my youth and of why I fell in love with your content in the first place. It feels reminiscent to that here in a way that I thought I wouldn’t get to participate in again 🫶🏻

Morgan

The real question is how much of TTPD did Matty hear while it was being recorded

Katie

Question…? Was solved! In Ruin The Friendship

Katie

Yes!

Katie

Same!

Katie

Is it miss piggy Disney bounding

Katie

The makeup will be cute fo sho

Gennie Brown

Weirdly it seems like out of all of Taylor’s exes Matty Healy has genuinely stanned her music publicly. I’d guess that he at the very least found it interesting, and because he’s a narcissist probably enjoyed the concept of it being about him even if he doesn’t admit it.

Katie

How do we access the discord?

Beth

Am I the only one who thinks "In the Dark" doesn't sound like Selena? It is so autotuned that a robot could be singing! PS Zack, I follow you and Madeline because you aren't afraid to be critical of artists when the moment calls for it. I didn't have a Patreon until I created one for the sole purpose of subscribing to this channel. That is a testament to how strongly I believe in you & your mission. So that's me speaking now.

zoë lange-pearson

I think this was filmed before the current situation based on the way they talked about sombr here 😭😭 oh prophecologist

Jessica Maguire

I definitely commented before we got to that part but he was probably also “getting canceled” for something else minor at the time anyways. There very few things I’ll cancel a person for in my bubble, so I try to just watch and enjoy the people that fight in comments. 🙊

Jessica Maguire

Yes please post it somewhere we can all get acces too it if possible.

CJ

I hope your Tay warrior never leaves you 😢

Camara Kidd

put your hearts up mention !

Leanna

I’m a silent community member and I love your honest opinions and that you don’t try to appease people. Keep up the good work!

Leanna

I agree!

Liv

Finally someone admitted that Speak Now TV is bad

dumdum

Semi silent viewer here as well…You guys make being a Taylor fan more fun for me. I need the level headed normal opinions on the things Taylor does or else I go crazy

Lisa

Zack this sombr stuff on TikTok is actually insane. These people cannot be real

Anastasia Rose

I would be giggling if Taylor, Selena and Ed takes about you 😂. Also love you all and your sane opinions 🫶

Kiki🩷

This is such a good episode!!! Bad for the people not in the Patreon 🤪

chrissy

Silent member here!!! Love love love your honesty and you’re both hilarious. Please ignore the losers xxx

Ciera-Dylan

The whole sombr situation is so damn ridiculous 🙄 comparing it to one direction is so real I literally remember being 13 at a concert & girls going crazy over Niall grabbing his bulge💀💀 we’re loosing recipes!!

luke!!

speaking up now as a silent viewer i love u both. also zach can u pls drop the strava the running swifties want to follow you!

Lindsay

*whispers* sometimes 💀🫶

Lindsay

zach did!! xx

Jessica

As a silent viewer, I love you both ❤️ Keep doing what you're doing

Britanii

Happy belated birthday Zach!

Angelo Dudum

After you called question hieroglyphics I’ve been saying that so much about like stuff I don’t understand LOL it’s so funny

Angelo Dudum

STOP I so agree with speak now tv like it’s not the sameeee as the og

Angelo Dudum

-“The whole world is not one big Stan twitter thread” CRYING

reckless mermaid

I’ve been seeing it on YouTube as well… maybe just because I used to be subscribed to Adam years ago, idk… but it’s very weird, I don’t think I’ve ever seen this sort of unhinged sm to trade against Zach before (I’m not on TikTok) and I don’t like it!

reckless mermaid

8:31: Zach, you are probably the primary reason that I started identifying as a Swiftie, and it’s because you offer an essential example of a fan exercising critical thinking and respecting their favourite artists enough to give fair and honest reviews. You are a shining star in a sky of sycophantic darkness 🌟

Britanii

Also Madeline telling Zach not to interrupt her and his face was priceless. I watched it more than once lmao 🤣

only spams

Zach im speaking up now!!! i ride for you charli <3 (and yes, the fact that you will say unpopular things means you have integrity which will attract audiences that value that!!!)

Nicolle Trampe

Please please please give us Madeline in her Miss Piggy costume! We need it haha

Marta Boldú

I became more interested in Taylor agaib since I started watching your videos, Zach! It rekindled my love for her and I might not have engaged as much in her new art had it not been for the fact that there was a space where you could have interesting conversations around her. There's no one around that I can talk to about this stuff. So thank you

Cathy Spyr

Can you share the excel with us? Want to sort toooo

luna

speak now tv bad... not in my world!

luna

I NEED THAT SPREADSHEET

Zoe Cane

Madeline is so real for speak now being too sacred to do tv for. I couldn't listen to tv for back to december, last kiss, speak now, mean enchanted, ...

Yaz

I’m speaking now as the quiet community: I love you guys so much for your thoughtful content. Makes me think critically about music and you guys have seriously influenced my vocabulary drastically and nobody else understands..💔 great gowns, beautiful gowns to you both <3

Sean

This isn’t really on topic of the video, but my mom is a certified Taylor hater. She hates like basically every song she does. But, she actually likes fate of Ophelia, Opalite, AND Elizabeth Taylor!!! I’m shocked. She never ever admits or says she likes a Taylor song. So idk what’s happening but again the general public is enjoying it🤷🏻‍♂️

Christina G.

I do always feel stupid for writing that I love your stuff 🤣 glad it’s appreciated

Emrose

I found the spreedsheet they talked about in a Reddit post by searching “reddit taylor swift weighted ranking spreadsheet"

Madeline Kelly

Silent viewer!! I love your content together and alone!!Could not survive in this community without you both. Incisive, honest and hilarious - what more can you ask!! Hand heart

Hannah

circuit … hopefully a producer to be seen more.

Hannah

14:40, the greatest mystery lol

maddy

silent viewer here 🫶🏻 eos gets me through the weeeeek!! i have no friends with the same psychosis about pop culture so y’all are jesus to me tbh

vvc

I’m speaking now!!!! Your thoughtful commentary has been so thought provoking for me and has made music more fun

vvc

Yeah I think either he or his team confirmed that they broke like a week or two before the news came out

only spams

Madeline you snapping at Zach was CATHARTIC FOR ME!! sorry zach but you do interrupt my lizard queen a lot and its really disruptive as a listener and hopefully this wont happen again pls 🙏🙏🙏

rachel☁️

Don't be shy snakes post the link

rachel☁️

The joy for the Selena song purely bc it wasn't bad is so funny

rachel☁️

Sadly this is true love you Zach diva but stop silencing women ✋

rachel☁️

A segment of love to see is going through albums track for track and picking the favourite. Like lover vs showgirl. Lover Track 1 vs showgirl track 1 etc

Lindsay

i saw it here on patreon! it was posted a few days ago “reaction to west end girl” xx

sara

I could listen to like 4+ hours of Joe/Taylor discussion

Pooh Khanum

The funniest thing about TLOAS is... I live In Pakistan and people that have not vibed to Taylor since literally Blank Space are blasting TFoP and Cancelled..... The tay-nothing-knowers are loving this album so far xD

Lauren

Silent member of the patreon here 🙋‍♀️ I’ve been listening for years and your content never feels stale and I really look forward to new episodes. A few years ago I was really struggling with a newborn that cried a lot and you were the soundtrack to many a lonely pram walk and gave me something to laugh about. Thank you.

Marah

Sapphire by Ed Sheeran at EOAS Madison erasure 😭

SatelliteSnail

Maybe I just had a five-year-delayed epiphany… but “Cardigan” could be interpreted like ATW🧣 with the scarf is a metaphor… “🎶and when I felt like an old cardigan under someone’s bed, you put me on and said I was your favorite🎶” ➡️ Matty saying to press that Taylor was an amazing artist, admitting he puts her SONGS ON (vinyl, CD, iPod nano, 🧥etc…) because she is ✨his 💖 favorite✨ … I’d be f*cked up too

SatelliteSnail

Taylor maybe the Pop Diva… but Miss Piggy is THE Immortal Showgirl 🐷🎀👑🪩

Olivia H

Consider me speaking now!! You guys are a breath of fresh air and i am so grateful someone has the cojones to speak candidly. You guys inspire me to be more brave in my life. I have been a silent listener for years and just joined the Patreon. Keep it up!! You guys are such a bright spot in my day.

Amanda

“CAN I FINISH MY THOUGHT 📣” lmaooooo i’m a silent enjoyer so i’m here to say thank you for the giggles and the kiki!!! i’m sorry the internet can’t handle some nuanced and clear-eyed divas delivering their opinions without apologies!! 🫶

Ashley

Wait SOS where is Snammy’s voting???

Bethany is Cancelled in Cleveland!

Don't stress about Taylor's friends hating you. She's open to feedback and she doesn't need her fans to wrap her in cotton wool because she's a pretty tough broad. Reference: Taylor Swift, 2025.

Crista W

Silent listener speaking up 😶‍🌫️ I don’t always agree with you guys (esp over Showgirl) but I will ALWAYS respect you guys and enjoy listening to your well thought out videos 💜

government hooker

my swiftie phases fizzle in and out these days (yes i became a fan during folklore sue me i’m the killer) but u guys rlly keep me in and intrigued. i don’t like tloas and haven’t gone back at all but i’ve sat and watched every single showgirl vid you guys have done thus far😭 u guys are so entertaining and have such great banter!!

Taylor Monroe

The whispered, abashed “sometimes” had me dyyyying, especially along with your face Zach. I replayed many times. Idk if you did that on purpose but that was seriously comedy gold. Too bad Madeline wasn’t able to see how funny that was. Maybe after the fact.. Silent listener, love you guys!

Taylor Monroe

Yes, I loved that part, it was like he was confessing a deep, dark secret and scared of getting in trouble for it. Really cute and charming.

Amanda M

I went to reputation and eras tour in Atlanta! Best crowds for any concert I have ever been too!

thalia

PUT YOUR HEARTS UP MENTIONED IM SCREAMING

Taylor

Speaking now: I appreciate the thoughtful criticism!!

Jordin Millward

Silent enjoyer here, been off and on here for over a year - just wanted to let you both know that I DEVOUR your content despite not being a swifie or even much of a fan of pop music in general. Y'all keep me connected with the culture and make me laugh while doing it. Just thought I'd let you know that the thoughtful, critical, sometimes emotional, but never TOO serious approach you take to pop culture is enough to keep me subscribed, and I couldn't have even named 3 Taylor Swift songs this time two years ago.

Jane Isaacs

silent listener here! just know your realness and insightful analysis is WHY I listen to ya'll so please keep it up!! you do ACTUAL musical journalism not constant hand hearting and I find it so refreshing 💖 it's not I agree with everything you all say but like... that's the whole point 🙃

Gabrielladid

Please do the song sorter or the spreadsheet vídeo!!!

Ivan Cervera

Yall i thought the selena gomez song was okay at first… i cant stop listening to it im obsessed

Fatima

So true about the Charli xcx comments. My cousin is a casual listener of all music; she doesn’t have a favourite band or artist. She had absolutely no idea of brat or brat summer and the only song she knew from brat was apple cos it went viral. Even then I had to play the song for her to recognise it. It’s a good album but it didn’t have as much impact on the general public as the angels might think.

Karissa John

This gave me war flashbacks to the speak now tv podcast ep lmao one thing Madeline will not do is let me enjoy better than revenge tv in peace!! 💀💀

Gaer

Just to lift you up, I absolutely love your content. You are my sunday show, I wanna support you by keeping patreon (one day updating to the $10 tier) and going to SNERAS tour. You mean so much to me as someone who wants to be an artist because of your honesty. Thank you for being you :)

Abby Wandersee

I remember thinking renegade was from Joe’s perspective when he met taylor post snakegate

Lily Cooper

Silent listener here! And your reviews on music/songs have helped me dive deeper into my own listening experience and analysis. I learn so much!

Jade

About your brand of criticism and the weird reactions you get from people: I actually had a really strong (negative) reaction about Zach’s commentary the very first time I saw one of your vids, ages ago without any context. But as soon as I got context (and realized that you were actually making points) it clicked pretty fast. I think my initial knee-jerk reaction was just that there are SO many edgelord commentators out here just shredding music to smithereens for funsies, without adding anything to the conversation. Which isn’t at all what you’re doing! But when I first encountered your takes with 0 context, I just rolled my eyes and was like, “dear god not this again” lol. But! I realized by the end of the first video that you’re actually engaging with the work in a thoughtful and productive way, and offering real and actionable insight to the artists. Which is what criticism should be about! And you stick to and stand by those opinions over time, which I really appreciate. I specifically remember your take on Sour, and the specific things you wanted to see improved. And then when Guts came out and made those improvements, you acknowledged the growth and gave Olivia her flowers. Which I appreciated! So yeah tl;dr I adore the critical work both of y’all do, and it’s helped me expand the way I engage with artwork. It’s helped me think more critically through different lenses as well, and also to reimagine the way I approach my own craft as a writer. The people throwing stones at your work are likely watching short clips with no context, and from a distance it’s easy to think that you’re just another set of voices in the sea of hecklers, but even watching one (1) full vid is enough to start seeing that you truly care about the music you’re reviewing. And nuanced, detailed critical takes on work and artists that you care about is RARE and we need so much more of it!

Myrthe

Silent listener from Belgium here! 🙋🏼‍♀️ I love love love your content! I appreciate the honesty of you two alot, it's what makes it all more interesting in the fandom & as a pop culture lover. I also just laugh so much with the jokes you two make & the sassy, funny way of it all! It's not that I always have the same opinion, but that's the whole point on what makes it so fun! 😁 Keep on doing what you are doing. 😘 xoxo

A.N. Chaney

Does this count as speaking now from a long time silent?

Heather Farmer E

Pls unpack a little bit of "Questions?" Please!!!

Burtasaurusrex11

Re-watching this and the way Zach whispers "sometimes" kills me every time.

Sarah

i’m cleaning up my dressing room for spring and same i re-listen to it and between madeleine yelling because he keeps interrupting and the « sometimes » i’m laughing sm 🤣

Nikhil Nandagopal

your empathy lifted my spirits like spiraling butterflies 🥰