Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

We’re finally doing it: ranking Taylor Swift’s post–Big Machine albums, from Lover through Showgirl, using a semi-serious “scientific” system we built to avoid pitting Old Taylor against New Taylor. In this episode, we break down cohesion, execution, longevity, and overall Snakeology to figure out which version of independent-era Taylor is truly operating at her peak. The addition of The Life of a Showgirl complicates everything in ways we didn’t expect, and the final ranking surprised even us.

Comments

max

oh i’m gonna LOVE this one

nam

second

joe_ll_ig

before hearing this and if evermore is not number 1....mamas we is pitchforking

Emmanominon

Ahhhh😍 I’m so excited for perth Australia besties

Wilson Neal

this one is so important to me i’ve been considering the distinct differences between these two eras of her discography for a minute so this will be fun

X

Number 1: TLOAS. Her post big machine magnum opus. Potentially her best work ever from a craft perspective. True execution of both great melody and strong lyrical storytelling. Elizabeth Taylor best pop song she's written. I know ya'll don't like this album, but I forgive you. Commercially her most successful album to date. Taylor believes it's her best work. Fate of Ophelia outselling. First four tracks is the best four track run of any TS album. Justice for Honey. Midnights: This album got better every single year. Has hits. Saved her career by bringing the pop fans back into the flock. Anti-hero, you're losing me (this track alone elevated the whole album), karma, lavender haze, paris. Lover: Really, Cruel Summer carries this album. Good album overall. It just isn't hard to be ranked above the other three. Me! stains the legacy here, but the fact that Taylor doesn't even put it on the set list acknowledges that fact. Death by a Thousand Cuts and Cornelia Street are all-time greats. TTPD/Anthology: between the two, there is one listenable album of content. this album is redeemed by Showgirl, which properly canonized the matty healy interlude as a setup for Fate of Ophelia, Opalite, Ruin the Friendship, and Honey. Down Bad, Chloe, Guilty as Sin, loml, prophecy. i was originally a matty healy who?/denier but i appreciate the album more now that i've learned the lore. last: folklore. this album is boring. it increasingly has no legacy. if everyone wasn't depressed from the pandemic, i don't think this album makes any impression outside of the fandom. the subtlety of this album was clever, but it's not taylor. she's not subtle. unrankable: evermore. hitless. taylor wouldn't even release it today. we're never going to hear about it again. the only good song is the bonus track right where you left me. has a significant part of the fandom confused about the difference between a song and a poem.

Kiki🩷

Jack Antonoff when is it over now: 💥📣📣🦅🦅🌊🌊📣📣💥

Kiki🩷

Is this rage bait? 😂

X

post your top 3

Chas

Prediction before I press play: TTPD or evermore as #1; TLOAS last place. Lemme get my coffee and settle into this. ☕️

Rimon Nisan

I cannot stand by The Great War slander! It’s one of her best written songs I’m kinda shocked

Noelia

Armlyricology mentioned! Best podcast episode ever 🫶

izzy

folklore ttpd evermore midnights lover showgirl I really agonised over midnights v lover though, really depends on what mood i’m in

Fifi

I do consider ttpd to be her magnum opus. It’s tied with evermore as my favorite Taylor album. But I really really disliked robin until the last two months. I thought it was boring and had nothing important for me in the lyrics. Then I found out that I’m having a baby boy (first child) and something clicked. I found myself listening to robin and crying. Even my bottom tier song on ttpd aged well which is a testament to its greatness

thehorrorhomo

Weird to rank these in reverse but go off.

Miranda

Think she’ll start her own label now she’s done six with both BM and Republic?

Hattie

Oh to be a fly on the wall when y’all were having your ‘come to Jesus’ moment before filming Showgirlology

Chas

Girl, I thought the same thing.

Morgan

Evermore TTPD Folklore Midnights Lover Showgirl

Katie

Wait wait.. I’m no Joe widow but cowboy like me is giving forever is the sweetest con my relationship that i locked down. Matty healy dgaf about a fancy car I feel

Katie

Midnights IS the key. Champagne problems and others make me think there was a mini breakup (the Great War).

Katie

The Great War is like a movie. Much to dig into there

Maya

champagne problems I have heard is about hiddelston

Katie

Joe Alwyn wrote it?

Carmel

Florida slander 😭😭😭 it hurts so bad 💔

Katie

Florida!! Belongs 😭

Katie

(I’m from Florida and so bias) but it’s stinky like Florida so it cleared. Also it’s a feature she didn’t screw up

Katie

I feel like I don’t even hear about showgirl anymore. Those numbers gotta be riding off the Eras tayvis high.

aliciaaa

the two of you discussing evermore LITERALLY made me switch off this episode and stream the album front to back… now THATS impact

Dea

I'm also becoming an Evermore truther after Madeline's relentless (and necessary) campaign! That is tangible IMPACT!

Dea

Posting this episode when I'm in the midst of a huge work deadline is a serious crime. Nonetheless, we cheer!

Katie

It’s too bad gaylors ruined Dorthea I love that song it’s so girlhood and peaceful. Actually romantic undid any progress tho lmao

X

well yes, come take a hit! assuming hits are something ya'll still care about...

Morgan

You said the lakes twice for folklore top songs

Chas

My exact ranking too

gv

my ritual with these is listening to the podcast version to wait for the video version, then going to watch the video version when it drops 😅🫶

Morgan

Midnights was made for stoners and I’m telling you listening to it with a joint in the outdoor shower in the summer is one of the best times you’ll ever have in your entire life

Carla

EVERMORE HIVE RISEEEE

Hannah

Zach’s hatred of Dorothea is so baffling to me but I let him cook…but I find that song sooo beautiful and cozy

gv

i love evermore, but i was in the mental hospital when it came out lolol so it took me a while to listen to and appreciate it

Liv

TLOAS gave me a newfound appreciation for Midnights. In the days after TLOAS was released I was like wellll maybe Midnights did deserve AOTY and maybe it is in fact the greatest album ever made lmao! jk Midnights stole TTPD’s aoty and that’s on period

aliciaaa

that was me and TTPD…

Lindsay

VIVA LA EVERMORE!!!!

Abby

I came into contact this weekend at a birthday party with a person who said TLOAS is their favorite taylor album and if I don’t like it I’m just jealous of her success… I’ve never been so disgusted by someone in my life I actually gagged in their face .. that’s impact

Ada

Came here to say Evermore best song ever made

Ada

‘tis the damn season and Ruin the Friendship sister songs when?

Katie

Same here… but give TTPD a few more years to cook and she could encroach

spencer

Labyrinth top 10 taylor deepcuts of all time I’m opening the case.

Bel Burns

If 1989 is the pop blueprint, then evermore is the melancholiac academic blueprint— and that’s been my truth since December 2020

Wemdu

folklore evermore Lover (purely for the highlights... the lows be low) TTPD Midnights Showgirl

maddie coleman

Folklore TTPD Evermore Midnights Lover Showgirl

reckless mermaid

I mean the album opens with Lavender Haze… funnily enough my friend who grows his own made a new cross and he let me name it and I deadass named it Lavender Haze…in 2021. It’s an album to smoke to for sure ✌️🍃

Morgan

I love that

reckless mermaid

Ps I live in Canada and we’re allowed to have four mature plants for personal use… I did not just confess to a crime ftr 😅

reckless mermaid

Ok I know we might not have a lot of Florence and the Machine enjoyers here but since she was mentioned….. I am BEGGING someone to listen to One of the Greats off her new album. I swear she wrote it after spending a day with Taylor because it’s legit a cross of Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me, The Man, and the music video for LWYMMD. Like the lyrics are so Taylor-coded I’m surprised she doesn’t have a writing credit😅 And the bridge goes harder than anything I’ve ever heard. And for the record yes, FLORIDA! Is by far the worst song on TTPD. It’s the one song I’ll go out of my way to skip; it does not need to be there.

Courtney Camden

folklore evermore midnights ttpd lover showgirl

Josieee

ivy is in my top 5 favourite Taylor songs of all time, so pleased to hear her get her flowers

Midori

Lover not last mention ☝️

Rachel

I'd love for you guys to rerank showgirl in a year using the same system! Like just tacked onto a showgirl one year later episode or something I think dividing up new Taylor and old Taylor this way makes sense because she switched her record labels, but Lover is still so old Taylor to me just based on vibes.

Morgan

lol I’m no rat. And I live in New Jersey where it’s legal for use

Erika Fern 🌿

TTPD Evermore Midnights Folklore Lover Showgirl

Erika Fern 🌿

Yes!!!! I smoked a joint for my first listen and wow it was the perfect vibe. I saw someone say it was rep on a gummy and I was like EXACTLY

Leslie

I'm kind of the same way. evermore came out during probably the worst month of my life. I wasn't in a headspace to receive or enjoy new music. I listened to it once and then I don't think I revisited it at all for like a month. I love it now, and objectively it might be better than folklore, but I just have so much more happy nostalgia tied to folklore and such bad memories tied to evermore that it's hard to be objective.

Leslie

fr. Release the tapes!

Leslie

Congratulations! I have two boys and yes, Robin speaks to me. I think it's a beautiful song and sentiment about wanting to preserve a child's innocence and sense of wonder. But I understand why others don't like it .

Jasmine

Need to listen to this still but... TTPD forever 🫶 Folklore Midnights Evermore Lover Showgirl

Jojobear

I recently watched an interview with Florence where she confirmed that One of the greats is inspired by Buffy the vampire slayer. She was rewatching season 6. but I also think of Buffy when I hear who's afraid and the prophecy so, maybe there's something to that!

Jojobear

Congratulations! I have a daughter. She has had the "Taylor swift method" playlist on Spotify to fall asleep to see she was 4 months old. Robin is on that & it makes total sense in that context. I just found it strange on TTPD. But the " all this showmanship to keep it from you" line hits hard as a parent.

stella

i feel like maroon does makes sense because it’s burgandy t shirt + wine red + blood rush cheeks scarlet == maroon

Wemdu

Midnights was the first record where I, as Madeline describes, had to delete songs from my library because I hated them, and when I allowed it it was so liberating. I felt my swiftie shackles come off, and I went back and I deleted Change and Innocent and felt truly happy.

Wemdu

and thank you aimee was deleted after one listen.

Wemdu

is it the pun on marooned/ being left alone or abandoned? It was so bright red and intense it left me marooned when I lost it? idk

stella

i like the layers of them both!

reckless mermaid

Oh that’s interesting!! I’m a new fan of Florence so I don’t have a lot of context for her writing