Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 570921747.mp4

Downloads

Content

Many calls to return to a format we've had to put aside due to a lack of topical Taylor news, but we've cobbled together something to replace this week's public episode as we all give thanks. On the agenda: this flop Chainsmokers remix, Ophelia tying Blank Space for Taylor's second longest #1, the White House debacle, the acoustic album, Fantano's Taylor op-ed, wedding rumors, and an update on the Ticketmaster lawsuit. Please keep it cute and respectful in the comments! We can all disagree civily and politely if necessary... <3

Files

Comments

Kate!!!

REAL TREADMILL VIDEO EXACTLY YASSSSS HAPPY THANKSGIVING TO ME AND TO YOU AND TO SINGAPORE AND MONTANA

Ellajoy

Great timing just got off work 👻

Susu

omgg yeah I'm so excited for this1

Jess

First of all, thank you guys so much for the episode, I honestly wasn’t expecting one this week. I agree with your points about Taylor and her place in politics but I have to disagree with your comments about Beyonce. This is not coming from a place of hateration (she is a Queen) but does she actually live by what she preaches?? She was sitting at the same table as Ivanka Trump and her husband just a month ago at Jay Zs own event...

Jonna Kristina

I agree that it would be nice for her to say something about the tiktok thing, but I think it’s incorrect to say everyone else is speaking up about it. the white house is using every popular song ever on their tiktok and most people say nothing, like kendrick, sabrina and charli xcx. again it would be nice for her to say something but I don’t like that she’s being pointed out like she’s the only one ignoring trump’s shenanigans.

fiona

thank you so much for giving the patrons an ep this week instead of skipping ilysm, NEED

S

It does look bad now that I think about it because in Miss Americana when she felt like she was starting to fall of she felt brave enough to be political but now that she’s more famous than ever she’s back to what she publicly vowed not to be again….

Carla Ferreira

Can I just quickly say that I appreciate you guys so much? Like everytime there's something new on this Patreon my day just gets better. I love to disagree with you and I love to agree with you. I just love the conversation.

Aaron

I actually think the lack of noise on that topic is correct. They were meeting in an environment where they wanted to get work done on a political issue important to them. It would just be nice if the same grace and good faith responses were extended elsewhere.

fiona

we LIKE this kind of taylor talk stop apologizing for it ! this is exactly what i want, discussing whats at the center even if it's unpleasant. thats what sets you guys apart , youre fans who love her and DO NOT curb their cognitive dissonance like e.g. ally sheehan, always positive and defending no matter what

Jess

I just don’t think a glamorous charity gala packed with billionaires and taking place in a casino is where any real political work happens.

Chelsea Bauscher

Please release the acoustic reaction for the swiftologist deluxe tier I have it almost exclusively for Taylor reactions! 🫶🏻🫶🏻

Michelle M.

A Thanksgiving gift?! Amazing! Thank youuuu

Aaron

I think there is just a strategy of not responding to the Internet Noise of the Week, for better or worse. Unfortunately the one thing that actually cuts through (variants) is the one she continues to take actions on and not in a good way.

Marco Rubboli

Taylor's indifference towards the state of the world is baffling

Jeanne

Randomly awake at 6am and I was served a Thanksgiving feast. Bless the snakes 🐍

h

Thank you for the political part. I'm so tired of seeing people defend her silence on this. She enjoys having people on the left and right believing she could be on their side, or at least that she doesn't openly oppose their views. Personally I think she's a corporate democrat who is technically left in the US but would be considered right wing in Europe and many other parts of the world, and I don't think you can actually be considered progressive if you're a billionaire, but that's neither here nor there.

nish 🍓

i WILL be seated for taylor talks both of the taywarrior and taytrier varieties trust. critical thinking for the win

Jordan 🌻

I love listening to you guys chat about hard things. Hand-hearting 100% doesn’t feel genuine right now and it’s really refreshing to hear normal humans have a rational conversation about what Taylor’s been presenting to us. Thank you for this!

Jess

Anne

Everyone who enjoys concerts should be cheering for the Ticket master lawsuit. Period. They are doing it on behalf of all music lovers to hold this powerful company accountable

Hattie

Love that your microphones didn’t pick up the audio for the Chainsmokers version 😂 I heard all I needed to on Taylor’s story 🫢 Thank you snakes for the Taylor talk, love your honesty and opinions as always!! 🐍

Ellajoy

Ditto!!!

Jeanne

I bet she gets in the studio to xmas up the production, change a couple lyrics and release Opalite (Christmas version)

Abby

I think from her perspective, she has made it clear how she votes and the rest is just noise that she doesn't need to comment on or amplify. That's the strategy - whether it's the right one is a different matter

S

I don’t stan Olivia but she truly is the bravest of them all.

Jordan 🌻

I’m so glad you mentioned they clearly didn’t get Sabrina in the studio for the The Life of a Showgirl acoustic version. I mentioned this in the Chats & Reacts Patreon when the girls said it was all new vocals and the swifties over there flayed me alive. Lmfao

Beth

Guys my theory on the marriage location rumours is that they come from the source! I think they want to flood the press with multiple incorrect locations for the wedding so that the real location isn't unveiled! It's a good idea, that way even if it does leak it's just one of many rumoured locations!

Christina Ingham

That woman is damned if she does and damn if she doesn’t.

Zoe Cane

In the airport right now, flying home for thanksgiving break . This is perfect timing.

Jojobear

I'm utterly baffled by the effect of this god damn album release. It's making people insane. It's okay for people to not like it! My best friend loves it, she's put it in her top 5 Taylor albums (we've both been swifties since debut for context). I knew I wasnt going to love it since the podcast, just knew it wasn't going to be my era. So I was pleasantly surprised when I was able to add 5 songs to my rotation (but it's still my least favourite album to date) & then felt absolutely blessed with the eras doc announcement, because, for me, she can, harp on about the eras all day long & I will keep giving her my money, because the eras was music history being made & girl WORKED HARD. Me and bestie have had zero arguments over showgirl. it's okay to not agree with people, it's okay to not love everything your favourite artist does. I actually don't feel like she needs to talk about the white house tiktok, however I'm not American, I also sympathise a little bit more with the fact she might be scared, we don't know her, she is a stranger to us, we're not in her emails or meetings or around her dinner table. It's also a relatively new (ISH!!) problem, as we've not really had such a provocative & emotionally charged political climate being played out on short form content media platforms, so it's a, again, relatively new issue to tackle. but it's OKAY that others don't feel the same as me, I accept my opinion comes with a big old side of privilege too. we don't need to tie ourselves in knots over it either way. It's music. It's good to discuss it but when it just turns into rage bait, name calling, stone throwing etc... I just have to switch off

Clay Thornton

The White House thing is particularly strange considering she’s talked so much about the importance of having her distribution rights…idk if social media counts as distribution per se but it is similar in that you want to control in what context your music is used. Seems like something she would care abt from that angle as well

Jenna Robertson

I have to disagree with your take on fate of Ophelia. In my opinion, it is the one that really fits what I envisioned a Max Martin and post folklore Taylor Swift hit would sound like. It is incredibly catchy and there is very solid story-telling (even though it may not be accurate to the Hamlet reference). And I do not hear Tay British 😂

Jojobear

Edit to add: my long ass paragraph was to say, it's nice to have content creators say "hey we don't personally like this one aspect of what she's doing right now, but we do really like this (the acoustic versions etc)". Instead of either being "she's absolutely perfect and you're allergic to fun!'' or "she's an evil maga wife and I'm burning all my merch".... Side note: don't burn your merch as that will absolutely not be good for the environment

Bailey Andrea

the outro of atw being “so brooklyn” is 100% true. my ex is from brooklyn and i am silenced every time that part plays… because i was there, it was rare, etc etc… it’s enough to put a girl in a straitjacket

h

I think she just set a bar for herself that she no longer reaches. She released a documentary that focused a lot on her coming out as a Democrat and saying she was wrong to be silent before and that going forward she wants to be on the right side of history and speak up for what she believes in. So it feels hypocritical for her to be silent on this use of her music, more than these other artists who never claimed such things

Maria

What a lovely holiday surprise. Grateful for you turkeys! 💖

Abby

I get that people want taylor talk but I’m Madeline rn… I don’t want to say anything I’m really thinking and I don’t want to even partake in discussions LMAO

Jojobear

Also Madeline, I was invited to a Thanksgiving (early due to it not being a holiday in the UK) in London (American UK residents friends) over the weekend. & we had to do the go around & say what we're thankful for. I froze & said something generic like my family or whatever. But before hand my husband said to me "please don't say something like you're thankful for Taylor swift getting her masters back" & thought it was kind of cute he remembered that even happened this year honestly.

Solly E

Madeline I also REALLY dislike ophelia... and I dont want toooooooo When I started listening to showgirl the first time and I heard track 1 it killed my vibe from the get go Idk whats wrong w it for me and I like tracks on showgirl like father figure and Elizabeth taylor I just cant w ophelia and it ruined my first listen lol soz to be dramatic it set me up for failureeeee

Bell

I invite the snarkyness cause I know it comes from a place of long time love ans cause I’m in a similar space with Taylor at the moment. So thank you always for your good faith honesty

Bell

we all are. It’s about being damned by what people. I’m ok being damned by racist misogynists, Billie Eilish is ok being damned by Elon Musk, Olivia Rodrigo is ok being damned by MAGA. It’s not about other people.

Jasmine

Towards the end of Wish List, can anyone else hear what sounds like Marjorie singing in the background?!

Aimee

6am, playing catch up on y’all’s videos, on my walking pad….its gonna be a good day

Noni

I hate the message of Fate of Ophelia, but the song is such a bop. Max Martin went off!

Malcolm

Not the silence during Ophelia 😭😭😭

Jojobear

I agree but I do think Taylor gets damned by both sides at the same time sometimes. this president really did tweet a lot of hate her way for a while. Hasn't Elon also had a pop at her? not to mention all those explicit deep fakes of her last year. So she has been damned by those people & didn't retaliate. It does seem like that's just her thing now (I'm not saying that's right or wrong by the way)

Aimee

Ruin the friendship & father figure mean so much to meeeeeee <33333 On the real though, I’m feeling a big disconnect from Taylor right now and that’s making me sad so I’m trying not to think about it too much. I think the eras tour doc will reinvigorate me…hopefully.

Jojobear

She also made a big part of that new heights podcast letting us know she's no longer online for her mental health. I think we're holding our breath for anything like the past behaviours towards politics/accusations. I think the girl is done. now it's just deciding as a fan if you're alright with that, and I think either answer is okay. It's your emotions, time, money etc that goes into being a fan. It's okay to decide what you want from your artists

Alex

I was just thinking about how much I miss this segment!! I was about to start going back into the catalog for some older episodes but this is so much better 🫶🏼

Grace

periodddd

Lisa M

The flop chainsmokers remix is bad, loud luxury remix is the better of the 2 (or is that chainsmokers too)😬 This is a good episode 🙏 I am with Madeline on this album cycle 😔

Bell

anyone else hate Ruin The Friendship? It's like nails against a chalkboard. The verses are good and fine, but the melody of "And it was not/An invitation" and "And it was not/Convenient, no" it sounds so weird and like forcing a melody where there isn't one and then just saying "Should've kissed you anyway/Should've kissed you anyway" three times, the chorus sounds so bad. and then repeating the "Don't make it awkward in second period..." section twice with nothing different between the first time and the second time she says it. It also just feels like forced vulnerability and forcing another deep moment on the album the way she did with Eldest Daughter. It also didn't happen during the eras tour so its place in the album doesn't make sense.

Jojobear

I agree with you. I think it's up to the individual fans if that's something they're okay with. Some will be and some won't & I don't think either are wrong.

Abby

I do think she set herself up by what she said in Miss Americana - but I'm also not sure if holding her to that for eternity is fair. I think she said it with good intent but without thinking through what she was really committing to - stupid to do as a public figure, absolutely, but not unforgivable

Tom

Opalite is horrific

Ashley Tobin

I don’t mean to be rude but you do not seem to have a clear understanding of IP law here. There’s nothing illegal whatsoever about the white house’s Tik Tok use of her sound FROM Tik Tok. I work in law so I’m just personally irritated by people going around making these pronouncements about why Taylor isn’t saying anything when they don’t even understand what use is and/or is not illegal.

Ashley Tobin

You are assuming that the reason she isn’t speaking out is (or solely is) because she wants to keep MAGA people as fans, which we have no evidence for. You aren’t considering her thoughts and circumstances regarding safety - I know Americans think that since MAGA are stupid they can’t be dangerous but I’d beg you to remember they almost overthrew the entire government on Jan 6. You also aren’t considering whether she’s thinking about the strategy of throwing herself into the public convo and then having all the news pivot from things like Epstein and food stamps to “Taylor and trump culture feud!”

rhi

Elizabeth Taylor is my fav song on TLOAS but i just can't w the acoustic version. The first time I heard it, I was like why does it sound like there's a choir of ghosts singing the bridge and the "Elizabeth Taylor" parts in the chorus

Solly E

I like the song but I do dislike the way she says 'convenient' to make it fit

h

Once I heard someone describe it as Target commercial music I couldn't unhear it lol

Clay Thornton

No I get you! That’s why I said “idk if social media counts as distribution” because it’s an unfamiliar area for me :) I was just appealing more to her desire to have power over how her music is used in an artist sense rather than through a legal lens. I don’t expect her to take any legal action because yeah obviously if it’s on TikTok then it’s available for anyone to use. I just think it would be reasonable to think she would want to make a statement to clarify that she doesn’t support her art being used in this way since she has stated in the past she cares about how her art is used.

Stroop(wafel)

I feel like its a classic but very average taylor song and people only like it because compared to the rest of the album...

h

I agree completely. I don't like it at all. And the end where she summarizes the lesson as if it wasn't crystal clear the whole time feels like such bad writing. Just slapping the listener in the face with the meaning for no reason lol

Bell

exactly! It's very How You Get The Girl in that way. "My advice is..." as a line is crazy to me 20 years into her career. Compare that to Dear Reader which has an interesting subversive take on giving advice and lesson giving from pop stars.

Tom

Truly and it starts off so strong but what it turns in too…

Stroop(wafel)

I think the majority of what we are seeing from taylor in terms of weird behavior, hiding at chiefs games, lack of opinions on anything, is due to a concern for safety after the Vienna situation. I think in the past before Taylor got so big she talked about how Andrea was paranoid about her safety. I think that, maybe its possible now there is a reality in the world of regular assassinations etc, maybe they are just trying to lie as low as possible outside of her music. I don't necessarily agree with it but I feel like I can find a more charitable take that there might be things going on that we just dont know or understand.

Stroop(wafel)

Like I love Olivia Rodrigo, but Trump isnt going after Olivia and sending the psychos in her direction.

Dajah

I needed this for my Thanksgiving prep day thank you Snakes 🙏🏽

Hannah Traveller

How Madeline feels about Fate of Ophelia is me with We Are Never and ME! I haaaaate those two songs and they PMO so bad. I actually low-key love Fate of Ophelia.

Laila

I wonder if Taylor's approach would be different if Only the Young and YNTCD didn't flop as hard as they did.

ala

imo Taylor continuously strives to be more famous and publicly reminding everybody that she hates trump would alienate a big part of the target audience - it’s always money please

gv

i haven't listened to Fate of Ophelia since it came out and yet it's always stuck in my head

ala

so she’s banking on longtime swifties remembering her miss americana days and hoping that they’re secure enough in the belief of lib Taylor to not need constant reinforcements from her which allows for the strategic silence so the republicans won’t remember she’s not one of them - it’s like plausible deniability for both sides 😭

Jane

Thank you for this video today ❤️❤️ I’ve been catching up on old episodes and this was a treat to see in my notifications!

Sarah

I like TFOO because it reminds me of my ex, who felt like she saved me from a really painful situation — kind of like the story in the song. I wish we were still talking when it came out, because I would’ve loved to show it to her and gush about how much it reminded me of us. She wasn’t even a big Taylor fan. Instead, we ended up breaking things off the night before LOASG dropped, mostly because my family didn’t like her… and that still gets me a little. 😫💔

Syd

I get what you’re saying but I kind of like the syncopating rhythms, it feels almost like some weird rhythms and melodies she played with on evermore.

Quinn

Did the audio get copyrighted??????

Syd

Same :(((

Stroop(wafel)

Feel it in my bones. The snakes are my secret to productivity.

Kim Wooder

She has no courage when it comes to speaking out - love her music but she is not a musician for change. Compare her to someone like Dua Lipa on the issue of genocide in Gaza.

Maria

Madeline I’ve always connected to you over a mutual love of Track 1 songs. Willow. Ready for It. Etc. This is where we diverge because I truly love Fate of Ophelia. Like really love it! It gives me that in-a-trance feeling I love. Ha!

Leslie

I think their software filtered it out as background noise

Jojobear

things that haunt me in the night are thing like imagining a non fan thinking "okay let's give Taylor Swift a go'' and the first song they randomly select is ME! makes me want to die inside as a swiftie. I NEVER tell people to watch miss Americana mostly because she focuses so hard on that monster of a song. Whhhhhhyyyyyyyy. Cruel Summer is just sat there and she's focusing on ME! ?!?!

liv

I know many Swifties get worked up over people constantly ribbing her about politics, but truly, the blame can be laid at the feet of the Miss Americana documentary. You can't be so explicit and loud about how you are now going to be this activist and mouthpiece for human rights and democracy, and then just completely disengage from it. It makes her look opportunistic, not to say she is the only one that has done it, but the scale of it... You just have to laugh.

reincarnation of helen keller (avery)

its hard to defend taylor when she has a ft w/ the chainsmokers we really are in a flop era. lover couldn't imagine this type of flop

lottie

Can we just add a “Four score” to “16 years ago almost today Taylor Swift was walking around NYC with Maggie Gyllenhaal…” 😭 I’m dyyyyying thinking about Madeline rolling out a scroll at the Thanksgiving table and starting to read the lyrics to ATW with an accompanying picture of Taylor and Maggie 🧣🤣🤣🤣 *and throwback mention to Madeline’s mom reading O Captain! My Captain! 😆never forget!

Leslie

Exactlyyyy

Erin Hastey

Based on Taylor saying she wanted a big wedding and dropping random invitation promises all over the TLOAS press tour, my brain has cooked up a special nightmare in which the wedding is at Arrowhead Stadium and it’s a live-streamed event and the whole thing is monetized. I want to be wrong, but would that not be the logical direction of this era 😭🤮 Where is my classic, classy queen?

E ✨🩷

Took some time away from TLOAS and listened to it back to front yesterday and can't lie I was really enjoying it!!

August

What we need is a breakdown of every taybritish moment or other adjacent moments to “tis locked inside my memory” that just take you out of it in her songs 😭 every time Madeline does that impression it kills me

caroline

Madeline I am once again asking what your eyeshadow brand and color is

bubblegumrebel

“elizabeth taylor” was definitely doing good for a bit, staying in the top 10 for a couple weeks, but “opalite” is absolutely the emerging hit. it’s stayed in the top 5 of the hot 100 since the albums release, and it’s already top 20 on pop radio despite no official release yet (z100, the country’s biggest pop radio station, is spinning it ALONGSIDE “ophelia”)

Lia Russo

I interpret the beginning of Wish List as Taylor telling us she isn't trying to be an actor anymore. I could see a time where she thought she had a shot at being a Gaga or Cher level actress on top of music. I also think "video taken off the internet" is a shot at Kim doing everything to get her tape offline when it obviously never will work.

Tom

That first verse puts me right there but once the chorus hits I’m suddenly 5 meeting santa at the mall

Swiftologist

This is from the galaxy chic palette by BH cosmetics 🤓

Sarah

wait is my audio not working or you guys muted the chainsmoker?

Sarah

the way i’m sat for this video 🤝

Sarah

theres a lizard video where she talks about her palettes i believe

hannah

nah. no way would they do this. a people magazine spread months later maybe but a livestreamed wedding does not seem in the realm of possibility at all to me, let alone at arrowhead stadium lmao.

Sarah

omggg style acoustic like the « lover live » version i would have PASS AWAY

Sarah

Miss Americana is so mid anyways it such a shame the rep tour movie was taken down and that flop stayed

Swiftieologist

For me, the song I really don’t like that everyone seems to adore is yoyok. I hate the way she sings in it. It’s so whiny and the melody pmo. Does nothing for me. And it was my surprise song and everyone lost their mind and I was frowning 😭

h

Well said. This is what I think too. It's easy for liberals to go off the Kamala endorsement and Miss Americana and feel comfortable that she's on their side. And the right wing can see all the talk about her being maga/tradwife and see her featured in Trump propaganda and see her not rejecting that publicly and think maybe she's secretly on their side. Or they just see nothing political from her and don't have the confront the question of it at all. She has everything to gain from keeping both sides thinking this. Unfortunately there are a LOT of trad Christian Swifties she wants to keep around for the $$$

Sarah

I’m with Madeline, I can’t even hear Ophelia anymore without hives. And the endless variants… WHY. Leave me alone, song. Stop chasing me!

Pearl Dennis

The guy who was stalking her and whom she has a restraining order against has disappeared with no one knowing where he is, so that is decidedly part of why she's being careful. And yeah, the MAGAs are sending her literal death threats daily. Like why would she want to do anything to ramp up the very real threats on her life right now?

h

Lol I like it just fine, but I don't understand the intense love for it either. But my unpopular dislike is Death by a Thousand Cuts. The lyrics feel so obvious and predictable, like heartbreak songwriting 101, and the production has so many annoying noises in the background lol. The live version is definitely better, but I still just never reach for it

Kd235481

Love y’all‘s, Taylor talks and I agree, the main reason why I subscribed to y’all‘s Patreon is because you guys are sanely neutral with a hint of swiftism, which I love

Lizel

Not defending, just asking, but has anyone checked if Taylor has maybe sent a legal document to the White House to tell them to stop using her music? Would that be a publicly available document in America?

anna

It honestly saddens me that you guys don‘t feel comfortable enough to go totally unfiltered anymore :( I joined the Patreon when it started and I do miss those days but I understand that with a growing audience it might not be worth the hassle anymore :/ either way!! Great episode as always!! Have missed this format. Loved the Phantom Thread reference. And can‘t WAIT for the Miss Americana deep dive!

anna

I think that‘s a very fair assessment

caroline

Thank you!!!

ala

yes exactly! we keep on perservering because we cling on to that Kamala endorsement which was quite recent while I think it’s enough for the other side that she’s besties with brittany, Travis says that he’s honored to have trump at the game, she’s not reacting when trump uses her songs etc. - so I don’t think republicans claim her but I think that with the change of her social circles / lack of any anti-trump moves they lowkey forget she’s historically been a democrat 😭 and so they buy/stream/support. And I am not even talking ab the MAGA lunatics - I think they’re deff against her simply because Trump has publicly hated on her many times (and they follow his word like the gospel) I’m more talking about the regular republican who doesn’t like democrats. And because she’s aiming for unprecedented amount of fame / success she has to pander to all audiences, the biggest of which unfortunately being the right wing because of the current political state. Also let’s not forget the NFL of it all…

RJ

i agree opalite PMO!!!!! elizabeth taylor will be the style of TLOAS

Lizel

It sounds as nerve-racking as when we were little kids and had to read out loud in class. I would count the kids and the paragraphs over and over to make sure which one was going to be mine, so that I could be prepared. I'm pretty sure this is where all of our collective social anxiety started.

Sarah

omggg same! i was so sad during Madeline reaction of showgirl when we saw the moment she sensored herself! it is supposed to be our safe space of diehard hand-hearters with actual critical thinking

Swiftieologist

DBATC was always a skip for me when lover first came out. I didn’t like the production at all and I feel like the bridge is overhyped. I love the line “paper cut stings from my paper thin plans.” That might be one of my favorite lyrics of all time, but I feel like people just like the bridge because it’s fast and wordy. Marjorie bridge clears it but yet no one talks about it. I’ve warmed up to DBATC a lot and will listen to it from time to time but I highly agree it’s overrated. I feel like my lover opinions are very controversial because I also think cruel summer is a tad overrated as well.

Kat

If you guys think there aren’t maga Taylor fans you are soooooo far off.

Jojobear

truly awful. I used to get the same feeling when I used to go to in person spin classes & the instructor would try & hype is all up & ask us to shout some sort of motivational quote or be like "woooohooo" or whatever. i saved up and got a peloton membership so I never had to do that shit again.

Genna Salstrom

Re taylor not speaking out: I think she is genuinely terrified of maga since they have proven to be homicidal and violent. And yeah, that makes her a coward...she's a billionaire who can afford a ton more security than any other politician or activist speaking out.

Lauryn

I saw a post on Reddit the other day that was wondering why the showgirl cardigan didn’t sell out like the rest during the cardigan drop… I commented something like “probably because it’s an ugly color, made of plastic, and the fans don’t like this album as much as the GP does” and the showgirl warriors were reading me for filth 😭 like can we not just look at the evidence in front of us?? If it’s not selling out there’s a reason… scary times out here

h

I totally get what you're saying and I'm frankly scared of maga people too lol. But I think it's strange still because if history has shown us anything, it's that the people most hellbent on harming celebrities are their biggest fans, who end up obsessed with them. Like what happened to John Lennon. Have there ever been assassinations of pop stars by those who oppose their politics? Journalists and activists get killed for their views, but I've never heard of it happening to a famous musician, and plenty of musicians regularly speak out about politics. I'm open to being wrong!

Genna Salstrom

I'm not sure, but if we are to believe the internet, she was apparently really triggered by charlie kirk's assassination (not because she liked him but because he was a public figure like her so she's scared of being super public)

Gregabug

Loved this! Honestly didn't mind a more "negative" taylor talk, as I've been feeling similarly on a lot of the issues. I especially agree that I think it wouldn't hurt for her to simply say "white house don't use my music." I don't think she needs to speak on everything all the time, but this seems like a super easy, close to home thing she could combat, yk?

h

Yes I've seen that too. She's human so I get why she could be scared of that even if it's super unlikely to ever happen to her. CK was out having open air events with minimal security and saying incredibly inflammatory things on the regular, which she would never do, but there could still be the emotional reaction that's hard to shake. The cynical part of me thinks she just doesn't want to alienate her more right wing fans and wants to be as big as possible at all costs, but hopefully she's not that dark sided. Who knows

Genna Salstrom

It just reminds me about how people were pissed about her waiting to comment on the bomb threat at her eras concert overseas. And then she basically said I'll never comment if there are safety threats impending. Or something like that lol. But I think it's a mistake in this case. She is tayfeminist in a time of fascism, and her fan base is skewed bery liberal. She would be fine, and people could stop overanalyzing.

anna

and like i hand heart for z&m too irdgaf what they say i honestly just wanna hear it even if i disagree

keelin🩶

cold as you is one of her best songs, i neeeeeeed debut tv so i can hear it with her vocals now like i need air

Qweefeeweefee

I can see wishlist being in the background of makeup videos

Holly Noel

I'll say it. I think Taylor is socially liberal but fiscally conservative (capitalist queen) with at least one conservative parent who she loves dearly. Aside from some social issues, I think she's wildly apolitical. We know she doesn't care about the climate, where her merch is produced/by who, and she's great friends with open trump supporters. The only reason she said what she did in Miss Americana is because people were calling anyone who didn't publicly denounce Trump a nazi back then. It had become a cancellable offence and she was terrified of that after "being cancelled" a few years prior. And even then, it took her so much longer than it would take anyone who was clearly passionate about this issue. I honestly cringe at those scene in Miss Americana because Taylor trying to act passionate about politics reminds me a lot of how Zack scoffs at her attempt to be a gay ally. Taylor is passionate about her career and getting people to like her, even if those people are bad, wrong, or evil. I honestly think it's kind of sad how much some fans cling to her Miss Americana statements as if she hasn't proven herself otherwise on nearly every other occasion. If I had to choose which one is the real Taylor and which one was put on, you know which one I'm picking.

Qweefeeweefee

Have y’all ever heard the recording version of shake It off acoustic? It’s honestly so good

Jasmine

🤷‍♀️

MR

Like Fantano touched upon, my main issue with the White House music stuff is the fact that, throughout the re-recording process, a key narrative that she highlighted was control over her music and who gets to use or license it. She made it very clear that she is aware of how and when her music is used, and that she desires to control that completely. And yet, in this situation, people want to believe she suddenly is unaware of its use/ is above commenting on it?

noicingcupcake

I hear you on the fact that the Ticketmaster thing is very low priority in the grand scheme of everything going on in the world but at the same time, and not to be dramatic but they can't just keep getting away with this... Like, getting tickets for anything right now is RIDICULOUS and yes it's all for entertainment but it shouldn't be a nightmare for the average person to access that entertainment while both Ticketmaster and scalpers profit off of fans

Shiv Patel

Did anyone feel uncomfortable in her statement where she endorsed Kamala Harris and Taylor said I’ve made my choice and now it’s time to make your choice with voting? Previously, she was fully endorsing the left side of politics, including the Democratic Party and giving reason reasons as to why the other side is bad. But this time she just said I’ve made my choice and now you guys can just vote for whoever the hell you want.

Shiv Patel

Like when she said, I’ve done my research?? girl what the hell?

emmy

Sadly I know plenty of MAGA (against my will) who are like “Taylor’s secretly one of us” and they are doing all this meth math and what can I say? It’s so irritating to say the least. Beyoncé is an interesting case because she’s a black woman and after she used the black panthers in her half time show she was flamed on black Twitter because her using the black panthers in that show is actually everything they stand against. You’re right about Cowboy Carter though it is political but it’s still flawed because it can still read as performative especially since she’s an incredibly wealthy woman marketing these political statements for more money. Kinda like Taylor Swift in that regard. F.D Signifier has a really good video essay about Beyoncé and artists getting into politics while still under capitalism if you’re interested on that subject and how she walks the line. Kendrick did the same thing, the one political performance in the Grammys where he showed up in chains in 2016 was extremely polarizing that the Grammys basically scrubbed it online and Kendrick had to cut up some parts when he reposted it, it’s why on the half time show he did just enough but not enough, at least for the culture.

Leslie

I really appreciate you guys providing a "safe space" to be a little Taynegative when the mood strikes. I've become pretty disillusioned since Showgirl came out, with the album itself but also with the relentless commodification and the increasing sense that the music now exists to serve the brand rather than the other way around. I find myself increasingly checked out of swiftiedom, and yesterday I found myself thinking that at this point I'm more of an EOAS fan than a swiftie. I can never check out of swiftiedom completely because I love you guys and this community so much 🫶 I will always keep one foot in Taylor fandom because I will always be a Snake.

Leslie

Also, Madeline I share your feeling on The Fate of Ophelia. Can't stand it. Hate it more every time I hear it. I can't even pinpoint why, but something about it grinds my fucking gears. Also as someone who used to write listicle slop for a living, yes, they are absolutely rage baiting on purpose.

CamilleC

I actually like when you speak your mind, i found you very measured with what you say. There is a lot to say i think right now she pmo a lot and showgirl show case lyrically the bad sides of her to me. Some songs she sounds condescendant and i don't know if she wanted to sound exausted but at times it comes off unbothered to me. Or pretending to be unbothered cause she's mad about a lot of things imo, the bitches to est the chihuahua to the west i guess. And some other songs it's like the average writting was an exercice almost idk it's weird it's not the lightning in a bottle by 3 masters of their craft i'm sorry Tay but no.

Roberta

I was gonna say the exact same thing! I’m inching away from being a Taylor’s fan but even if I phase out completely, at least I got EOAS out of this whole thing ;’) I’d never stop listening to you guys!! I was like is it weird me being a bigger fan of EOAS than of Taylor atm lol

Leslie

Yeah lol I had the realization in the shower last night. I was thinking, you know, I'm not having a lot of fun as a Taylor fan right now, I should just check out for a while...but I can't do that because I'd have to give up the snakes 🥲 Maybe the documentary will get me back to a place of hand heart.

cyryl

When we're in this space you guys should let your hair down. We appreciate your honesty even when we disagree. Speaking as someone that loves fortnight lol 💀

Anna

Lots of artists have come out against the Trump administration using their music for its own rallies and campaigns so it’s not like it’s a huge major risk never been done before if she releases a statement about it using her music ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Anna

No lies were told and I’m obsessed with you both 🫶

CJ

I like antihero. I don’t like that it’s the top #1. I do love that Ophelia cleared Shake it off though as SIO is to me personally what Ophelia is to Madeline x100 lol. If any other songs deserved that spot besides Blank Space from 1989 it was Style and New Romantics 🩵

Jojobear

as a side note, I saw a clip of a video of travis' SIL... Kylie? Anyway, she said she didnt mention her political leanings before (which she them described as aggressively left) because of security fears, & that they'd experienced threat around their house etc. I do definitely think it's got to feel like a lot on your shoulders. & Yes other celebrities have spoken out & been fine, but maybe she just... Doesn't want to take that risk? the thing is, it's all speculative. I don't think we'll ever know why she does or doesn't do something.

Beth

This. I totally agree with you. Concerts are a communal experience that everyone should get to enjoy, but now there are lots of people who can't afford tickets because Ticketmaster has made it so expensive. The Ticketmaster CEO was saying a few weeks ago, why can't concert tickets be as expensive as court-side seats at a Lakers game? He actually wants that to be reality. If we're not careful, music will become yet another thing that only the super-rich can enjoy. Bit by bit, the greedy corporations are taking away the communal spaces that hold society together.

Jojobear

I think it's just obsession in general, I don't think it's a love or hate thing. I've only peaked once into the snark subreddit & it's pretty whaky over there, they think about her A LOT. I don't think fears of safety is a mute point personally because I can imagine having hundreds of thousands of people everyday saying how much they hate me, could really mess with your head. however, the world feels pretty bleak right now & it's hard to feel sympathy for someone so on top of said world. But I try to remember all the other stuff she's done to show there's human decency there, is well documented too.

Erin Fietz

Dancing with the Stars did an acoustic version of Style and it is haunting highly recommend you guys check it out

Liz A

Ophelia is a bad song because of the modern lingo mixed with the Shakespearean stuff

lilbirdiebb

So well said 👏👏👏

lilbirdiebb

Wish I could hear the chainsmokers remix 😿

Jennifer Schariter

I never get in internet arguments but with the possible Snap crisis in my state and my position as a therapist, I saw a swiftie influencer post a fundraiser for food insecurity, I typed under it that I wanted to see Taylor do more. She has so much money and I live in the state of TN. I am personally giving people gift cards and taking up donations because many of my clients didn’t receive snap benefits. And since she is so concerned (historically or performatively) about her one of her states of residence - I would love to see a donation towards housing insecurity and food insecurity. Well. I got obliterated in the comments, I want to see her speak up. Say something. Or let her art speak towards her values, or at least TLOAS be an album that was a decent piece of art to analyze and hold on to for a much needed distraction when so many marginalized communities are suffering right now. Billie donated 1/4 of her net worth towards food insecurity. Where is the Taylor Swift foundation? I am not holding her to any standard that she did not previously set for herself. During the government shutdown when people are furloughed, the poor and disabled are unsure if they will have food , she’s pushing more fucking variants. Plus there’s the merch since showgirl came out. It arrives broken, it is poor quality, and since the resale market can be so promising for turning a profit, swifties buy, including me at times. I couldn’t believe the personal attacks on my character in those comments. People actually said I should pick a new profession. Well, I am a damn trauma therapist. You try watching the suffering of the poor and know that if billionaires did more then it would be different. I was also told I had no critical thinking skills because I said there are no ethical billionaires. I guess what I am getting to, is where is the balance? Where is the balance between standing by your values and being a businesswoman? It makes me question if it is only about money now. And her release of so many variants and merch was so tone deaf to me about real issues happening in the US. I am stepping off my soapbox.

Ivan Cervera

It frustrates me beyond belief that olivia, a much younger artist, with more to lose in her career, can show more integrity, conviction, and im sorry but literal maturity, than this established artist with a 20yr career. I try to defend her but im at the point of just giving up bc she doesnt care so i cant either 😂💀

Kelsie Smith

Tbh I think part of it too, is that once she says something ab one thing, it becomes a hellscape of "well you talked ab that, why not talk ab this?" kinds of demands. And then shes stuck to either not talk, talk about every little thing thats demanded of her, or tip toe around which things are "deserving" of her speaking on. Id like her to speak on more things too, but I dont hold anything against her for not.

Lauren Pollini

Bestie I think DBATC is sooooo overrated, I do not get why everyone loves that bridge, meanwhile Marjorie is over here making me choke up every time I hear “should have kept every grocery store receipt, because every scrap of you would be taken from me.” 😭

Liz

I love this style of Taylor talk - not snarker but nuance - it’s what we come here for!! I do think it’s worth considering that Trump’s team openly said the Ophelia TikTok was bait they wanted her to respond to. Remember that when she does anything anti-Trump, he is able to control the news cycle and do a ton of fundraising off of “woke cat lady Taylor swift is attacking me”. It’s how he operates. He would rather be talking about “Taylor swift hates me” than the Epstein files. I can understand the logic of, let me just grey rock and ignore him instead of giving him the attention he has openly said he wants from me.

Bob Billy

GO OFF DIVAS! If people don’t like what you’re saying they can get off the Patreon

Ada

Thank god for this community. Normal Swifties or Swift haters are actually deranged and reading everyone’s takes in this comment section is just so refreshing.

K

I actually don’t think the Swiftie lawsuit against Live Nation is something to cringe at. Is this the most important issue right now? No, not even close, but I still think it is a cause worth fighting for. If the judges/jury rule in favor of the Swifties this could not only change Live Nations’ monopoly on ticketing, but have further implications on other monopolies; Google, Meta, utility companies, etc. Challenging corporations in courts, especially in this case where the plaintiffs’ are not looking for monetary compensation but a change in policy, is almost always a good thing. I don’t think the lawsuit makes Taylor look bad - although I think her lending her support in someway would look better.

Cassady Lynn

Taylor is untouchable at this point, she would lose nothing by making one small statement not to use her music.

h

Same, well said

Alex Iscream

it's crazy to me to hear that Zach and Madeline have to hold down their critical thoughts to avoid crisis-swiftie in the comments ?! I just ended my subscription here because to me, they were not enough critical anymore ! I mean.. I've been a big swiftie for many years, but at this point it's insane to keep on defending her on so many shitty out of touch tonedeaf billionaire behaviours ! TLOASG album and era raised many issues at the surface that are hard to unsee now. I dont even feel like i want to listen to her anymore, which makes me sad obviously. I hoped here could maybe be a place where fallen -out of delusion swifties could chat and be really critical of her, while finding ways to still enjoy some of her work maybe and discussing her career and such but yeah , no it's not apparently. and according to what she show us since recently - her friends and acquaintances, her lyrics in showgirl, her hyper-capitalistic marketing of everything, her silence on ANY social issues and such.. well YES we have to consider that she's leaning on the maga side of it all ... and dont get me started on the apolitical thing. simply being that rich and not doing anything of substance with your money to help people/the world AND continuing to sell more and more variants and shitty merch etc.. is already a really violent and anti-social thing. that on itself makes songs like wis$hli$t (and TLOASG overall) really problematic. I find myself disrespecting her on so many levels at this point. I cant believe i got to this point where 2 summers ago i was crying and screaming at the Eras tour!! Miss Americana really let us down thats for sure LOL well. quite sad to leave i have to say, but i dont wanna pay for people who are still to me too much clapping and cheering for a woman who acts against about all my principles at this point, (and dropped a lame, un-creative and problematic last album..) so got to do what i have to do.. {: Eventhough i find a lot of their content good and interesting and funny. still be watching some free content for sure. 🧃bybye , and long live all the swifties that became ex-swifties after TLOASG existed :')

Meli

People who are criticizing you for being critical of Taylor I believe joined at the peak of hand heart EOAS because, there is no way you guys saying loasg sucks is what’s getting these people’s panties in a twist. This isn’t the “Taylor swift is a perfect human being and everything she does is correct” podcast

Töns

Exactly, I think they are doing a huge public service trying to change this resale practice and of course it has been a long time now, but they of course did not file the lawsuit in 2025 (I found a CNN report about it from March 2023). These legal matters always take yeeears (you’re adults you should know that 😂😂)

Abby

For me, I would like to see her DO more and put her money where her mouth is - openly supporting organizations and raising up other voices. Just saying stuff is pretty meaningless unless it's backed up with action. I find the internet's obsession with famous people 'speaking out' kind of odd, especially if we accept it doesn't actually change things politically. Taylor is not a political activist, but she does have money and influence (see voter registration). I understand not wanting to support someone who goes against your values (I don't!), but sometimes it feels like fans just want to feel morally superior and be able to say their personal favourite popstar is a 'good person', rather than caring about the actual issues

Helunky

Jesus christ - please leave indeed

Helunky

I hope she doesn’t speak out. I’m tired of her needed to jump when people snap their fingers. Let’s not forget there are plenty of other liberal artists also not speaking out. She made a mistake being political, she can be called out for it, but I hope she stops doing it. Loved what Jlaw said about her approach. I don’t need Taylor to be perfect at the end of the day as there can be things said about everyone. I feel like both options are neither wrong or right in some way. Love you both though I’m not demented and like having a disagreement!! 🫶

Marianna D

For me my rage bait song is eldest daughter. I can’t with this song. I never felt like that about any other Taylor’s song. This was my first Taylor’s song that I blocked

Sydney

I get not being to get wishlist if you didn’t get it from the start but I hear it as lines 1-3 is what one of her friends wants, lines 5-7 is another friend, and the other verses continue the same way. It’s not random lines, we know she didn’t write that way. The number of different “they” people in the song is just 4

Aaron

R/travisandtaylor is the place if you want delusional people to confirm your priors and give the most unflattering read on everything Taylor says and does (or doesnt)

Beth

You hit the nail on the head when you said the music serves the brand now. I am also disillusioned with Taylor but it took me time to parse my feelings. Now I've figured it out: I'll always be a fan of Taylor in some capacity bc it's impossible for me to disown albums 1-11 (it would be akin to disowning 16 of the most important years of my life), but right now, I am not an active fan of Taylor (AKA I can't/won't support her in the TLOAS era). I am & will always be an EOAS fan. As for the future with Taylor, I suspect TLOAS is the turning point that I'll look back on in a few years' time & say, 'that was the moment I stopped being an active fan of Taylor Swift'. That'll happen unless she undoes all the damage from the past year or so. Taylor has to start by saying she doesn't support the White House's usage of her music bc there are few things I abhor more than cowardice (I can't listen to The Fate of Ophelia & Father Figure anymore thanks to that bc they make me feel repulsed). That alone won't be enough for me, though. She is a billionaire, so she needs to start putting that money to good use with serious donations to charities ($100,000 is nothing to a person with her wealth) and take time out of her charmed life to give back in other ways (starting with a visit to the nursing home in Omaha so she can meet her 95 y/o fan – speaking from experience, spending time with the elderly is easy to do, and it is so important & special to them). She also needs to put her music first – either make a serious effort with TS13 (by 'serious effort', I mean equivalent to any of the first 11 albums) or stop releasing new albums until she feels she can give her music the attention it deserves. And cut it out with all the album variants – people are worth more than the money they spend. Long story short (pun unintended), Taylor needs to start acting like a human being again.

VK

I feel like The Fate of Ophelia would be a better song if handled by Florence and the Machine

Danielaaaa

also what a privilege to think the White House thing was not that serious and just laugh it off… said with love and lights girls I’m just saying what comes to mind lol

h

The first time I listened to the song I immediately thought, why does this feel so weirdly patriotic? Mentioning "pledge allegiance", football, plus the land/sea/sky thing immediately made me think of the military. So it was not that shocking but still absolutely nauseating to see it used in that exact way by the white house and show the fucking military and flags while it played 🤮

Dainty Donna

This is the thing. I LOVE my sister, but she is a hardcore Republican/Trump praiser. Yet SHE LOVES TAYLOR! She is her favorite artist and TTPD is her favorite album (she is 40, financially well off and in an affluent neighborhood to raise her athletic children in-basketball hoop and a driveway if you will). Taylor is too big at this point to have support from only the left. I think Taylor thinks if she says nothing, at the end of the day people won’t feel alienated enough to cold turkey her music. It’s still confusing tho considering Trump has said to Taylor in plain English “I hate you” but that doesn’t stop my sister from streaming

Sugar Plum Failure

I mean Beyonce may have released CC as a political statement, but she was also at dinner chatting away with Jared and Ivanka lmao - I really have low expectations for these people atp. the vast majority of the artists whose music has been used by the White House have said and done nothing afaik. Even so, I still agree with you guys re: Taylor not saying anything about the White House stuff though. Initially, because of what the White House press team said (that they specifically used her song in the tiktoks to make it a publicity thing and have people report on it), I thought perhaps Taylor was not saying anything because she didn't want to add kerosene to the flames. I still do. I'm not affected by her not saying anything, but I get the criticisms. Because equally, the point is that the whole situation DID get a lot of publicity as it was. And either way, your music is being used to promote this admin's horrific fascist policies!!! Which are hurting tons of people including your fans. And those fans are watching and are alienated by her silence especially at a time when the gap between ordinary people and people like Taylor is just becoming starker and starker, especially with many previously loudly liberal celebrities conveniently choosing silence just as the culture was shifting rightward. It smacks of hypocrisy. And unfortunately she really dug her grave with the Miss Americana stuff - I recall in this moment that story about how she felt the need to voice a commitment to queer rights because of that convo with Todrick where he asked if she would be ok if she had a gay kid (leading her to realise that she hadn't properly clarified where she stood on the issue). And yes she has made it clear where she stands on social issues and everything, and she endorsed Harris (big whoop endorsing a genocidaire, but this is America so that was the good option ffs and from where Taylor's situated I get it), and I have no doubt that she isn't in support of what the admin is doing, but equally, given the craven silence of so many celebrities in the face of it, and the fact that Taylor is at the pinnacle of her powers, is out in public frequently, and has previously said she wants to use her voice to some effect, I totally understand why people are criticising her for saying nothing at what is essentially the perfect opportunity. Because from a purely practical perspective, for Taylor herself, it would absolutely not hurt her to speak out about it and be like wtf, shut up and stop using my music, you're disgusting. The administration and the President are historically unpopular right now. The swing back towards the left in the culture wars seems to have begun as well among the general public, with No Kings and the Jimmy Kimmel stuff (putting pressure on Disney no less!) and the historic unpopularity of the Democratic Party among their base for refusing to stand up to Trump. I feel like that demographic does overlap with Taylor's most hardcore fanbase? Liberal white wine moms and their daughters? I mean how many MAGA fans diehards does she really have left at this point? Maybe I am wrong. She will be in the spotlight again for the doc and I think the criticism will probably heighten online by then. But I think she is now in this place of refusing to speak on anything unless she chooses to. And I think her attitude is probably that her saying anything will make no difference??? And it won't. But I think people aren't under any illusions about that either and that's not why people want her to say something. And more importantly, her verbal silence on this issue would not matter at all if she were just publicly using her wealth to support important causes to protect vulnerable people - queer people, immigrants facing deportation. Which is what she should be doing

Leslie

"On the land, the sea, the sky" is literally a US Marines tagline. Very weird phrase to put in a song, along with the other patriotic references. I guess she's trying to be cute about the fact that she's dating an American after a long line of Brits? But it definitely feels tone deaf.

Justice

Ugh I wish The Queen of the Seasons (Madeline) loved Opalite as a Christmas song

Miss_Lippy

Taylor is absolutely doing the right thing by not feeding the troll and giving it more publicity or attention

Jojobear

as a Brit, I did not get that reference & feel I don't have much say in this conversation at all really (I'm not about to tell Americans how they should be feeling all the way over here like "it's fine! Relax!"... Because it doesn't seem to fine & that's not cool). I did read an article that said this release highlights the effects of time of creation vs release. when she was writing this album, the political situation was different (& I believe it was when she'd just endorsed Kamala if that adds up?). I wonder how it would have been received if the vote had been a different outcome. again, I am not in a place to talk about American politics or culture but I just thought that might be an interesting point to add.

Jojobear

I just don't get it! And all I've gotten back is "it's an eldest daughter thing" and I asked my sister (who is an eldest daughter and a swiftie) & she's like ".... Um yeah I guess I suppose, not really?" 😂 the thing is it could have been such a good, emotional subject. even the aspect of how people dehumanise her on the internet, I was so up for that discussion as someone who is super sensitive to online apathy. but it just went nowhere. & The bridge could be so pretty on a speak now song about something completely different. It's a song that truly baffles me. It makes me not spin my showgirl vinyl a lot of times because I can't skip it on a turn table. Spotify I just removed it

Luiza Lodder

YES omg ive been gaslighting myself for thinking the land/sea/sky reference gave off this weird imperialistic/militaristic vibe, thinking "no it's just a dumb song; youre acting chronically online" but im glad other people also spotted this

CJ

Hating the Fate of Ophelia that much is definitely more of a personal issue, and I think artists can’t put out music and decide to tell certain people not to listen to it or use it. She put it out in the world for a reason. People need to actually just leave her alone. Because seeing Olivia say something and Billie get in a twitter war with Elon did absolutely nothing and didn’t make me want to listen to them anymore than I already do which is never and I hate Donald Trump so…

Maria Scaletsky

She literally said it was a personal taste thing. LISTEN

Carlos Galindo

I think in hindsight, we are going to look back at showgirl as the album that caused the most demented reactions Like this album brought out the people gagging over Eldest Daughter and the return of Nazi Barbie discussion Two VERY different ends of the spectrum.

ImogenLucy

I would love to see Taylor doing some public charity work. (Disclaimer: she may very well be donating behind the scenes) She is a BILLIONAIRE! The impact she could make and in a non political way (FYI I would love more political activism but I don’t even dream). Like could we open some schools? Fund research into medical treatments to help disabled children? Cat sanctuaries?! I’m just saying

Ivana

Beyonce literally sat at the table with Ivanka Trump at some random gala few months ago. Then she went to Kris Jenner’s bday party organized by Jeff Bezos, smiling big with other “democrats supporters”. Like, willingly! I wont even go into that Diddy ickyness. If we are going there, just go all the way. So please, just stop this nonsense that Taylor “must react” to rage bait just to prove a point that is very obvious if you have eyes or you are not deliberately choosing every negative angle possible in order to justify “being snarky and critical”. If after a masterpiece that was ttpd you assume that any man can make TS suddenly stupid, then you are a problem. Criticizing is ok and it is a must if you are talking about art. But this is BS, sorry.

Lisa Adams

I enjoy you both. I might not agree sometimes, but your points are valid and give me a different perspective. It’s so nice to be swift-ish!

Mallory Starrett

Do they have a Miss Americana reaction/review?

Hanna

Opalite is kinda annoying musically. I think it's because the vocal melody and the instrumental are so similar that it gets too much for me.

Maria

I’m just gonna be honest I don’t give a fuck if celebrities speak out politically. If she wants to fine but I don’t expect it or really care. I thought she was adorable during her Showgirl promo. I love to hear her talk about the creative process I’m pro-Showgirl, I like it. But…the millions of versions and variants of The Life of a Showgirl is so over the top it’s seems manic almost. The music and merch explosion has kinda given me the ick if I’m being honest.

Karina Artamonova

Someone gotta say it: Zack is interrupting Madeline too often.

Allie J

Can I just say, I appreciate when you guys share your thoughtful critiques of Taylor and I love this space because it’s a place for non-cupcake swifties to have nuanced discussions and approach our fandom through a critically engaged lens, (not meaning we don’t stan Taylor, but that we have a healthy dose of perspective on it all). So don’t feel like you have to silence yourselves!!! This era has had its missteps and I think you guys discussing that thoughtfully is great and doesn’t mean we are doing hateration ! Sorry to hear you guys are feeling gagged by online craziness x

Swiftologist

It has already been said and I am actively working on it

lilbirdiebb

Okay I take it back now that I’ve heard it 😂

Matteo

It’s Madeline letting us hear the song and us not hearing anything for me 😭😭😭 maybe that’s for the better tho…

Cathy Spyr

The fact that more recent singles do better can just be accepted as coming from the fact that she has more eyes now than she ever used to, not that it’s better, right? Can we all not agree on that? Like how every movie now is the highest grossing ever just because ticket prices are higher?

Kelly Schwartz

I personally love hearing Chester's meows in the background ❤️

mikayla attanasio

Ruin the friendship acoustic was offensively beautiful..I cried too and I don’t tend to cry to music..

Heather

I am WAITING for a Taylor Swift Foundation

Maddy

I honestly don't think you guys went far enough in terms of criticising Taylor. Ever since this the rollout of The Life of a Showgirl, I've had the ick. Sure, the initial visuals were amazing and Taylor served absolute cunt! However, the music itself was an utter disappointment and frankly false advertising. Showgirl was so overhyped and its been crickets since release week. The endless 'limited time only' variant releases, and fugly and ridiculously overpriced merch drops have absolutely given me the ick! The fact that The Fate of Ophelia is tied with Blank Space for Taylor's 2nd biggest #1 hit drives me insane! How on earth is this reality?!! The album is a flop. Sure, there's a couple of okay moments on the record, if I'm being generous. But I do not understand how Showgirl is so commericially successful. What is artful., meangingful and timeless from this album? Everything just feels like a constant cash grab these days. Taylor's continued silence and absence during this promotion cycle is deafening. And so with all that said, I don't think you guys go far enough with this 'fair' criticism and it's clear you are holding back your true honest thoughts. I can understand this approach with public episodes, but on Patreon, behind the paywall, please don't feel like you need to hold yourselves back all of the time. Say what you want to say.

treesap

To me, Showgirl felt more like a capitalistic endeavor than an artistic endeavor. It felt like it was made to sell rather than because she had something to say or art to express and explore. I really love hearing your thoughts and think your thoughtful criticism is always well constructed and delivered with sincerity! Thanks for sharing (and would love to hear even more tea if this is you holding back)!!!

Momo

fate of ophelia pisses me off too it sounds AI generated 😭

Sophie

To me, Ophelia portrays her in a way that’s not interesting at all. It’s definitely her right as an artist to portray herself as this flat character without any sense of agency or independence. But it’s so opposite to her self-portrayal before, most famously on fifteen and call it what you want, that all I can say is that I hope we see more of that consistent character/world building coming back for next albums. As for the WH thing, I totally agree that celebrity politics shouldn’t make much of a difference BUT in her case, 1. She’s known for being litigious about the use of her songs and 2. She went on and on about how she’s never gonna go silent on this type of stuff since lover. So, either way, she kinda sets herself up for this…