Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

This week, we’re reopening Miss Americana and giving it the forensic rewatch it deserves before the End of an Era docuseries arrives to rewrite the narrative all over again. We dig into Lana Wilson’s direction, Taylor’s unusually heavy involvement in shaping the film, and the emotional architecture behind its most revealing moments—her struggles with body image and disordered eating, her anxieties about ageing and motherhood in a pop-star machine that demands perpetual youth, and the shaky, newly forming political voice she lets us witness in real time. Five years later, the documentary feels even more confessional and strangely prophetic; it tells us exactly who she was becoming long before the rest of the world caught up.

Comments

Carmel

Been waiting for this 🫶

Dev

So excited to get into this!!

Jojobear

I wasn't down bad crying at the gym either, but I spent WAY too much of my youth on a smallest man, so TTPD was & still is on repeat in my house. & now, a lifetime later, that why Honey is my favourite song on showgirl 🫶

Jojobear

sorry I'm adding notes. Andrea and Taylor's relationship is so important to me. As a "mama's girl" myself, mother & daughter relationships can often be portrayed (& also be!) as complicated. I have a 3 year old daughter now & I see how much impact that relationship has. A friend of a friend who worked in security during the eras at the final leg of Wembley told a story that painted Andrea as very "demanding and a bitch". It was to do with extra security & this was just after Vienna. I thought "Id also be a demanding bitch if that was my daughter & her life". Taylor might be this dominating force who owns the music industry to the world, but to Andrea, she's still the little baby she grew & raised. sorry to get all soppy on here (my kid had her preschool Christmas concert yesterday & I'm totally projecting she's the next pop girly because she smashed it lol). Anyway, big Andrea fan here.

Evelyn Crothers

The cover of her looking down in the black top was a cut out from a scene of her staring down at her phone in the movie lmaoooo

Hattie

Oh I’m seated

Lisa M

OMG YESSSSS

Sarah

maybe it’s because i watched it a couple days go but as i’m at the begging of this podcast (18’ mins) the whole good girl think is so reminiscent of Glinda good girl skits

Chas

Phew girls this coming out on the heels of Sabrina lashing out at the White House for using her songs while Taylor stays silent….🧃

Sarah

so when she’ll say in the eras doc that « i made TLOASG after the superior TTPD didn’t win anything » what then? the pattern is so well noticed (?) red/1989 rep/lover TTPD/TLOASG and to be frank, only one did it successfully and we all know which one it is

Beth

Joe was there at my shows, I remember thinking he was very good looking in person lol

Nadiiia

waiting for the video!!!!

Dainty Donna

Ahh…that intro music is just perfect. I haven’t heard it in…about 8 hours ago since I watched the mv 😂. I haven’t seen Americana so I’m definitely curious for this one🫶

Sarah

as i continue to listen to this episode no matter what i will always love this woman, even if it’s the ghost of taylor past she will always be that part of who i am

Miranda

I’ve been listening so much you two (and dadologist??) were in my dream last night. We did dinner and a movie 🤣

Swiftologist

I actually totally believe in this phenomenon LMFAOO I remember I never thought John Mayer was attractive and then I saw him in person and GAGGED … it was like SHOCKING how good looking he was in real life

Syd

Lmao I’ve had a dream that I joined the podcast 😂 Parasocial out here 🙋🏻‍♀️

Sarah

the way that we all know that’s Madeleine because she got caught taking a picture of him 😂💜

Beth

Yeah like say what you will about him as a person, such is your right, but I see why Taylor wrote Gorgeous because when I looked at him I felt like I got an electric shock and then I felt guilty for coveting Taylor's man for split second 💀

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

I'm just starting this so maybe you get to it, but I did feel that her lack of politics, good girl complex, and age disphoria comes from remembering who she is and where she comes from and how she has been influenced by growing up in Pennsylvania and then Nashville. She is almost trying to appeal to the girls left behind there. It's politics and explanations are simple and empathetic to those that still have a worldview that is only someone else's option -which usually defaults to conservative. I think many people (did) underestimate how religious, and conservative much of the US is as Hollywood is very liberal. Even "Only the young" speaks to the fact that children are still impressionable and we can offer them the idea of choice, whereas most adults you cannot hold a political conversation with. Admitting she is only just learning is not a new idea, and it's not only embarrassing, but it shows a nieve humbleness in the political climate at the time that someone needed to say.

Jojobear

You're right Zach, it would be really nice to see Taylor pick her subject she's passionate about & just stick with it. It looks like even Travis has that with his charity for helping young people in communities. I'd even love to see her pick something like artist's rights when it comes to ownership of art etc. particularly as when you hear her talk about these topics that are clearly super personal to her, she's so articulate and informative when she talks about it, you can't help but think everyone in the room would stop & listen to you if you picked your cause & ran with it. she's charming and intelligent... that (plus continuing to routinely donate, which to be fair there's evidence of her still doing this) would have a decent amount of impact & I think people wouldn't care so much about bait thrown at her from politicians on tiktok

Sophie M

Such a good episode/analysis ! Ty for feeding us

Katie

Idk if anyone else follows the writer Hunter Harris but she is always talking about how hot he is in person

Kayleigh

You two always do these eps so beautifully and thoughtfully!!!

Miranda

What’s wrong with us?

Valentin Bellegarde

I don’t know if I buy the thing about Taylor saying she thought they were booing her. On the telecast, when Taylor Lautner says, “And the Moon Man for Best Female Video goes to… Taylor Swift,” you can hear and see everyone applauding. Then, when she’s handed the award onstage and says, “I sing country music, so thank you so much for giving me a chance to win a VMA Award. I–” you can hear people cheering. No one is catcalling or booing. Taylor herself is very happy and smiling onstage. The idea that Kanye gets up, says his thing, and then Taylor believes everyone goes from cheering and applauding her win to booing her, and not him - idk. And I know she was 19 and actually there in the room whereas I’m watching it on YouTube, but I reckon she would’ve put two and two together. And it’s not like Kanye left the stage and people kept booing. Kanye exited and the booing turned to a low rumbling commotion as everyone chattered excitedly about what they had just seen.

Eliza

Nearly 2 hours! The snakes are so kind and so loved

Tracy Erin

She was young. Little!! Don't forget that. When I saw her at the Grammy's that year, we didn't know who she was. She went out with other girls her age instead of industry afterparties. Taylor was a teenager! A room of boos would be terrifying. Even if she only felt like that for a few moments in front of that crowd on live television - and people watched television for this back then- 💔

Tracy Erin

and I run a site literally calling out her bullshit funding zionists to kill kids, so I'm not overly nice to her. It's good to question her!

Tracy Erin

You're all good 🫶

Tracy Erin

Both Taylor and Sabrina make money for white supremacist zionists at Universal Music Group. Lucian Grainge, Bill Ackman, etc are evil. I hope Taylor and Kendrick with others leave and start their own. Only Hayley Williams is a killing-kids-safe musician in Taylor's circle. Tay has one album left with Republic/ Universal Music Group. I really hope she parts ways after that, but am not holding my breath.

Wemdu

She is 100% waiting until she can pull this doc off the internet, especially once the eras doc comes in to replace it. I fear the eras doc will be equally stage managed - her desire to control all her output has only increased since Miss Americana.

Liv

I never realized she actually said “I couldn’t find you and I got so sad” in the doc when she’s running to see Joe after the rep tour. I thought that was fan fic that people made up lmao!! Just re-watched the clip and well yes she does in fact say that now does she

Alexandria Roswick

This is a really interesting point. thank you for this comment. it kindof just clicked some things for me. It’s so easy to say “republicans in red states are uneducated.” Yes. They are. They often, as you said, do not think for themselves and resort to following traditions from the culture surrounding them. I live in northern Wyoming in a town of 6000. My partner is a college music teacher. We are often invited to 3 weddings minimum per year just from his 19 y/o students. And then by their sophomore year, they are usually pregnant. We’ve seen this happen every year. They talk of aspiring to housewifery. Often, when he has music festivals or events they must attend, these young women are very afraid of driving to the “big city” aka Billings MT. This all runs so deep. Sorry for the rambling but it’s just really interesting to put into perspective. It’s not ever going to be simple to reach these conservatives. Taylor’s Girl boss feminism in this documentary may seem basic and performative to a lot of us, but maybe it did affect some young conservative women. I wish she would continue with that, even the bare minimum, like she said she was moved to. I do think with her platform she could empower a lot of these specific types of conservative women. Idk!

folklevermoretpd

Best episode yet. I'm a silent subscriber but this episode NEEDED a comment. Love how you give her her flowers while really holding her accountable. Cannot wait for your honest take on the eras doc.

Alexandria Roswick

We been needing this!! You all never disappoint. And the timing is truly significant! Zach made a very compelling point: if she could just choose one issue and focus on how she can make an impact, because it would no doubt accomplish what many of us can only wish we had the power to. That’s of course not to say we are powerless and can’t make change. We absolutely can and hope is important, whether her song about it was cringe or not (it was). To any fellow advocates out there who are feeling paralyzed by how many issues plague our society today, my advice is to listen to what Zach said. Pick one or two issues that you can put all your focus into. Know your talents, even if you think they are unrelated to politics, never underestimate the impact of small actions moving toward a greater goal. Never underestimate your ability to make an impact. Focus on what your goal is, and get involved in a community with the same goal. Communicate with people in the ways you are able to. If you don’t want to be a leader or speaker, you can assist them. Every role matters. Choose one thing you really know/care about and keep bringing awareness to it. You are necessary. 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻

Chas

Love your user name btw!!

Mary Grace Collins

I never thought I would hear reference to Mao's Cultural Revolution on EOAS but here we are 😂😂

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

And just look at all the girls Taylor is now trying to lift up... Most of them are from Pennsylvania or small small towns. I do think she is trying to mentor these small town girls who get targeted and taken advantage of by big record executives. I do think Taylor does soooo much more good behind the scenes. Over the years I've realized that Taylor really does play the long game. 🩷

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Wow! Thanks for sharing your experience! That is so wild that you have seen this pattern in real time. It's so interesting! 🩷

Tayswiffer

On the part about her speaking about starving herself: I do think she had planned to speak about this eventually in the documentary and maybe it just came out in the car because the situation itself triggered her to do it, hence why it doesn’t sound so polished. The reason I think it was absolutely planned is because in the Lover diaries that she released, there’s maybe 1 or 2 entries she’s included where she writes about exercising/feeling fat or something along those lines. I do think the Lover diaries were carefully curated to tie in with the documentary which she knew would come out later in the Lover album cycle because there’s multiple themes being explored in the doc that directly tie in with what she included in the Lover diaries (I have all 4 editions and re-read them obsessively each year).

Lucy Anne

I never clocked that she went from vmas 2009 straight to red ... the disrespect speak now receives continues to baffle and amaze

Lucy Anne

there is one piece of the doc that has always stuck out to me and i've never really seen it spoken about. In the board room scene at the start there's a pause after taylor speaks about the the new album and andrea encourages everyone to clap. for a doc that is centred on the idea she constantly needs approval and applause i find it so interesting. how do you even begin to shift away from that way of thinking when this is what a business meeting looks like for you

Erin Caracci

I would love more info/insight into this!!! As a fellow girlie who lives for the applause.

Jojobear

can I just say I really enjoy reading comments like this. I'm not from America & we do get told "republican voters = uneducated" . After learning a lot more about the country, even just geographically, I find it easier to understand. I can also relate it back to small working class towns in the UK & how the often lean towards more right wing voting habits/views. I'm from a small mining town in Wales but I've also lived in London & Bangkok, so my friends vary from had their first baby at 18, barely ever leaves our small home town to child free by choice 45 year old progressive feminists who's travelled the world & pretty much everything in between. I do think Taylor could be a good "meet them where they're at" activist for a lot of young girls. Unfortunately I think she might be kinda fed up of getting it "wrong" everytime she tries something.

Jojobear

The content creator Leena Norms has wonderful videos on this and also has a book called Half arsed human. She is a big advocate for picking your passion & helping in the ways you can. She gave a great example of "say you have social anxiety or you are unable to do door to door flyering for the cause you care for, but another person is able to but they have a child care issue, offer the child care", that IS activism. Grass roots activism is still so so important.

Jackie Lehman 💅🏼

Yep I feel she definitely feels that, and I also think that people underestimate threat of actual physical violence for some folks that speak up. Vienna shows that there are people that want to hurt the idea of girls and women having fun. The Eras tour (although yes, a capitalistic venture) also showed people what a safe space feels like, and I think that is an act of resistance that some extremist groups are absolutely afraid of. I work in social work in Canada and I've also had clients that have told me their horrendous and heroic stories of breaking out of religious upbringings. It is WILD, and there are places in the US and Canada that are still very rooted in this ideology and being too left won't get through to them. That's how I see Taylor, although she plays it safe, it's because shes not stupid, she knows its delicate (🎶delicate...🎶).

Rachel

I kind of feel like for the Eras doc, it will under deliver what we hope and expect... kinda like TLOAS itself.

Rachel

I remember seeing the scene on the plane where she's walking onto her private jet wuth her cat in her backpack and thinking "this is a rich kid who has no idea she's a rich kid." I'm wondering if the eras tour doc will also unintentionally show similar sides of her in an unflattering light.

Ceara Norton

While I absolutely agree Taylor could do so much more in terms of advocacy, I feel like people saying “she’s MAGA now look at her hanging out with all these MAGA folks!!!!!” forget about her huge instagram post from just last year where she endorsed kamala and LGBTQ+ rights, women’s rights, etc. and made it very clear she does NOT endorse trump or his policies/beliefs…… idk

Gracie Day

Something that’s not ever talked about in regards to the Lover era is that it was Taylor’s first entry of work since her split with Big Machine. The optics were terrible for anyone already doubting the fullness of her authorship and business decisions. “Me!” and “You Need to Calm Down” were godawful songs and business decisions. The latter at least had cool bass sounds, but it didn’t speak well Taylor’s independence from a team (with icky Borchetta) that never missed this hard. She was too big to fail, of course. Taylor had so many very young fans at the beginning of her career. I bet her team was worried that even though the existing fans were growing with her, not enough new young fans were globbing on, hence Taylor’s shift to focusing on something kids would love. I mean, surely art-snob Joe knew how cringey those songs were and that was an impetus for the next phase. It’s NEVER just been about the music for Taylor, contrary to what she implied in the poignant crying moment, and the Lover Era is a great example of that.

Bella

I’m bracing myself for this ngl

Bella

Yes!!! How amazing would it be if her specific causes were 1) advocating for victims of stalking and 2) getting women into songwriting. It would make perfect sense, do so much good AND she’d be able to relate to both 🩷

Bella

I actually really like how Joe isn’t featured in the doc and only briefly / hardly shown. Wish it was the same for Travis in the eras doc I don’t care about the purses !!!!!!!!!!!!!! I care about the divaaaaaaaa

Bella

My current algorithm is lots of Wicked edits set to Taylor songs …. a lot are eerily fitting!

Rachel

I had a similar thought with the BTS of Fate of Ophelia. She walks into a room where all her dancers are waiting and everyone cheers and is like "wow, you look hot!!" It made me wonder if this was staged, or if this is somewhat of a norm for her walking into a room full of people working with her... 😬 Not healthy

Lucy Anne

oh my god i know it was so odd ... and her billboard woman of the decade speech as well is a great example bless her

Tracy Erin

Just went to that and it's painful 😬 I didn't remember it being so bad