Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Vote For My Next (Old) New Music Friday

  • Like a Prayer 589
  • Ray of Light 344
  • Confessions On a Dance Floor 249
  • True Blue 94
  • Like a Virgin 403
  • Erotica 56
  • Bedtime Stories 29
  • American Life 25
  • Music 43
  • Hard Candy 30
  • 2026-01-09
  • 1862 votes
{'title': 'Vote For My Next (Old) New Music Friday', 'choices': [{'text': 'Like a Prayer ', 'votes': 589}, {'text': 'Ray of Light ', 'votes': 344}, {'text': 'Confessions On a Dance Floor ', 'votes': 249}, {'text': 'True Blue', 'votes': 94}, {'text': 'Like a Virgin ', 'votes': 403}, {'text': 'Erotica', 'votes': 56}, {'text': 'Bedtime Stories ', 'votes': 29}, {'text': 'American Life', 'votes': 25}, {'text': 'Music', 'votes': 43}, {'text': 'Hard Candy', 'votes': 30}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 1, 9, 16, 25, 26, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1862}

Content

This began with my One Direction, Four revisit a few moons ago, and with the release calendar looking pretty bleak, I want to react to some historical texts! Madonna, Madonna, Madonna. Lots of strong feelings about her. Keep in mind this is my FIRST front to back experience with her so I'd love to capture her at either a massive commercial peak, or a really interesting side quest...

Comments

Claire

American life !!!

chappell roan

i can’t recommend like a virgin enough! it’s my personal favorite

Olga Wadowska

American Life, now more than ever.

S

I disagree. It’s a top 4 Madonna album but it’s too experimental for a first Madonna album

Bon

Her debut album (self titled) is my personal favourite

CandaceBryantArt

Erotica has such amazing tracks, lots of great 90s dance. Such an underrated album, and very much a side quest because of how much controversy the record and the “Sex” book were causing + it being way less commercially accessible like Like A Prayer.

Brandon Thede

Ray of Light is the most interesting to me because it’s the Madonna album most congruous with Taylor’s current age and point in life. Madonna was a little older, sure, but her career also started later and this was possibly the prime example of Madonna “still being able to learn new tricks” when people were starting to say she was losing her touch. And this is still the swiftologist channel.

S

My time to shine. Like a Prayer is her most critically acclaimed album and along with Ray of light is her best album lyrically I think. It is THE pop album. Music is experimental and was released at her artistic peak and truly showcases her artistry and brilliance. Ray of light is my personal favorite and it is a spiritual deep album that was way ahead of its time especially in its production and is considered her magnum opus. And finally Erotica is just an amazing album that shows her humor, her wit, her artistry and her experimental artistry. I can’t choose but those are my picks.

Melinda

I’ve never listened to Madonna front to back so no voting from me but I will say I’m very excited for this! It’s been on my list to get into her it just feels so overwhelming!! Glad to see the great Madonna fans leading our way

Ngan Tran

true blue was my first madonna record and it still is my favorite! ray of light is often considered her magnum opus but it’s too slow for me… couldn’t get into it 5 years ago but now that my prefrontal cortex is developed maybe i can try again…

Marek Flaisinger

Ray of Light is widely recognised as her best, but it’s very heavy for a starter. I’d recommend Like a Prayer. It combines fun production with very personal lyrics about her family struggles and her fresh divorce.

Lizzy

True Blue has Papa don't preach... my personal favorite madonna song of all time. Also Live to Tell, Open Your Heart, and I still can't believe that La Isla Bonita is pretty much constantly sitting at her 1st or 2nd top song on streaming

S

Omg no that’s like in her bottom 5 albums

chappell roan

omg really? i loved like a virgin. ifk

Gaven Guzman

I would personally do -Like a prayer -Like a virgin -Confessions of a dancefloor -true blue -Ray Of Light Then the others in whichever order

S

Why aren’t people voting for Ray of light and why are they voting for LIKE A VIRGIN i’m silenced. Like a Virgin isn’t even a top 10 Madonna album nor does it represent her as an artist in any way shape or form.

Rebecca

80's kid, my vote is Like a Virgin! Second would be Ray of Light!

Celeste

As an 80’s kid, you gotta go True Blue! It was THE album when it came out!

Celeste

I’m not getting why people aren’t going with True Blue! It was one of her best, if not THE best! She was at the top of her game when this came out

Lauren

If Hard Candy has zero fans…

henri

AMERICAN LIFE

Zoe Cane

This is crazy I was just listening to Ray of Light

henri

American life is the definition of an interesting side quest

bubblegumrebel

i would say like a prayer, ray of light, or confessions. imo like a prayer is the first TRULY fully cooked madonna album, ray of light is the more experimental, creative peak, and confessions is her grand return to form comeback. of the 3, id say like a prayer is probs the best to start with, esp cause it’s probably her most iconic visually + has lots of videos to watch too if you mayhaps want to see those

bubblegumrebel

if you want to go down other avenues tho, id say virgin/true blue are her HIT records, just short + have a few disposable songs. and erotica/music are great, but just not what id use to introduce ppl to madonna. imo those would be like introducing ppl to taylor with rep or evermore, or to gaga with artpop.

S

Oh I disagree. Music and Erotica are great choices to understand who Madonna is as an artist. If anything Like a Virgin is the worst example I can think of to represent Madonna’s artistry. Not only was it before she fully gained control over her sound and took full creative control but it is just not lyrically amazing which is what Zach cares about the most.

Lizzy

I agree, was it 1991? This is a top of her game scenario. I love the way her voice sounds on this record particularly, she had a cold when she recorded papa don't preach and it brings this rasp that isn't normally there.

Lizzy

And open your heart reminds me of britney because of crossroads, which somehow makes the song even more iconic!

Sanket Sharma

The way I can tell Zach will LOVE Express Yourself

Lydia

All I know is that I’m obsessed with Miley Cyrus’ live cover of Like a Prayer

bubblegumrebel

oh for sure i agree abt erotica/music, but im also trying to consider what might be digestible for zach as a madonna newbie, and i feel like some parts of those albums, while they COULD hook him, also might not. particularly thinking abt the slower moments on music and stranger moments on erotica fjfkd like a virgin, i kinda see what you’re getting at, it’s for sure the weakest of her first 3 albums, but i feel like the roots of madonna the provocateur are still there. true blue has more flavor while still being a HIT pop record, but idk if id say LAV is a bad choice per se

COLBY

I would die to see Zach react to MDNA

Robin

No one is voting ray of light but PLEASEE.. magnum opus, experimental side quest, major innovation to stay relevant after having a baby and approaching her 40s. I think it’s especially interesting to think of this album as something Taylor could emulate as she plans her next move

S

But we’re talking about bodies of work. The best moments from Like a Virgin came from the live performances and music videos but the album itself I don’t think Zach would like it. This is most likely going to be the only album from Madonna that he’s going to react to and do you really think he should listen to Over and Over, Pretender, Stay, LDLHA, and Shoo Bee Doo to form an opinion on Madonna’s music? 💀💀💀

Fraser M

TRUE BLUE ALBUM OF THE CENTURYYYY

S

I think a lot of the people voting aren’t fully familiar with Madonna’s discography wnd they’re only voting for what they know or randomly which is why as the Madonnologist this poll is silencing me. For example I think the people voting for like a Virgin are only familiar with the singles which is why it’s getting 22% of the votes which is tragic.

Beth

It's not on the list but why not start with her debut??

Chas

Say this! It’s her magnum opus, her TTPD! If Ray of Light doesn’t win we riot in the streets

bubblegumrebel

well when you put it that way LMAO 😭😭😭 tbf those albums were in my second choice comment + i did warn of a few disposable songs, but I get it dhdjd. i think the standard w madonna is just so high that even for LAV which is one of if not her most disposable album musically, im still like “ok but…..that’s still like a virgin” 😭

Luka

VOTE RAY OF LIGHT! WE WILL WIN!

Miranda

Ray of Light is so good I listened recently! Also the compilation Immaculate Collection. Finally Madonna mentioned 👏

La Barrah

For an introduction, defo Ray of Light or Confessions on a Dancefloor. If you want to fully dive in, thats when you go back to the 80's stuff and look up her origins etc, she has some iconic performances and stories... she was controversial! But I think going in chronological for Madonna is a bit of a diservice, you need to dip your toe with her more poppy stuff first.

S

Zack I cannot stress this enough you should really consult the Madonnologists of the world instead of this poll. It’s so clear to me that the people here are only voting for the titles they recognize and not because they’re familiar with Madonna’s discography. This is like asking Katy Perry fans for a Taylor song recommendation where they’d all recommend Shake It Off purely because it’s the only one they recognize and not because they’re familiar with Taylor’s catalog. If you showed the results of this poll to most Madonna fans they would be extremely confused.

JaneyB93

I think as a 90s girlie I couldn’t possible pick just one album! The playlist of singles I reach for over the years would be the below: -holiday -like a virgin -vogue -papa don’t preach -frozen -ray of light -music -don’t tell me -beautiful stranger -Hollywood -American Life -love profusion -hung up

S

Madonna is an album artist where her strongest songs are often not the singles. She creates full bodies of work and making a playlist of only her singles is not the best idea.

JaneyB93

I would agree her albums represent an era in time and are to be enjoyed in full. I just wanted to share my go to’s from the ones I grew up with🫶🏻

Bobby Ray

TRUE BLUEEEEEE PLS HER BEST ALBUM

Alejandro

Have you hear of mototmami

João Xavier

So guys, those who are saying that the true Madonna fans are not voting. We all know Ray of Light is Madonna's magnum opus, however as an introduction to Madonna I did vote in Like A Prayer. I love that album, it really had a huge influence on the sound of pop music and what defined Madonna as the queen of pop, and nobody gives it love. So let's all calm down, from what I know of Zach's taste, his lane is more on Confessions on the Dancefloor either way

Ksenia

ahhhhh I'm so excited. you're gonna love madonna. like a prayer is listed as one of the greatest albums of all time on rolling stone and apple music. you should watch the like a prayer music video too!! they’re monumental and created the blueprint for controversial music videos. i hope you also do ray of light, erotica, and true blue at some point.

Rachel ☔️

I’m still learning about Madonna but Music is a fab song

Sepp

Confessions! How amazing is it to release a front to back pop perfection album so late into your career! Especially since it fully fit the zeitgeist at the time. Also it captures her attitude perfectly.

lily 🕵🏻‍♀️

ik it's not successful at all but it's a cohesive project i loveeee it so much and addison took inspo :P

Sepp

⬆️ this 100%!

Chas

This 💯

Ash 🪻

Zach have you seen the AI artist who made a song about you 😭😭😭

Sobustan

can you react to alessia cara's album love & hyperbole pls

yonka

You should look into Mckayla Twiggs. She recently released her first single and I think more will be coming soon! I think you may like it!

amber

!!!!!

Pamela F

Yes to all of these recs @zach!!

Starbuck1234!

When the music industry prefers young ingenues, Madonna was 40 when she released Ray of light. She hadn’t won a Grammy in 5 yrs, and that was just the video of her world tour. She found a new sound with a new producer. And made music I hadn’t heard from her. I instantly loved it. And it earned 6 Grammy nominations including AOTY. The production on this album…, chefs kiss. At age 40 she reinvented her sound and it is one of my favorite Madonna albums.

Ksenia

American Life is Taylor's tone deaf Lover Era. Ray of Light is the first album she made in her 40s. Like A Prayer was her Midnights and led to the Eras Tour-level tour of its time, the Blonde Ambition Tour. Bedtime Stories was her 'cool' album that gained her a lot of cred with snobs a la Folklore.

cyryl

If it was on the list I would say her first album... Great to see the starting point and my all time favorite Borderline

Bon

YES! I LOVE BORDERLINE!!!

Luuke

i can’t believe like a prayer has more votes than ray of light but maybe i’m just in my twitter echo chamber of that being her best album haha

S

How was American Life tone deaf…

S

Since Like a Prayer is winning I think it’d be nice to give a little background about the album. Madonna made it when she turned 30 which is the age that her mom died so this was an extremely reflective period for her. This was also right after she and her ex husband got divorced. This album mainly deals with motherhood, spirituality, family, abuse, trauma and religion. The song Promise To Try is about her mother who died when she was 5. Till Death Do Us Part is about her ex husband Sean Penn and their toxic marriage. Pray For Spanish Eyes is about her friend who died from AIDS. Dear Jessie is about her producer’s daughter Jessie (and it transitions into the next song Oh Father). Act of Contrition (the last song) is like a prayer in reverse and in it she is rejected at the gates of heaven and what’s cool about it is that the album opens with the sound of a gate slamming so if you finish listening to the album and immediately start from the beginning it would sound like the gates are closing on her after being rejected from entering heaven. Also if you’re reacting to music videos the music video version of Express Yourself is entirely different from the one on the album. The album version is more sonically cohesive with the rest of the album.

Vice

Wow people her do NOT listen to madonna huh Obviously Confessions

bunnyhugger

The Like a Prayer video is mesmerising!

Dani Kingsley

I think it’s just likely the one title people recognize if they’re not fans

Enzo Reis

Confessions On A Dance Floor or Ray Of Light aka her best ones. Also Bedtime Stories is so underrated.

Enzo Reis

We wouldn't have Addison (self-titled album), Lux or any mainstreaming Alternative Artist getting recognition if weren't for Ray Of Light. Ray Of Light to this date in one of the most important albums for pop culture, including Confessions On A Dance Floor.

Seenkvck

Bedtime stories is so underrated imo! Not my diva at 1% sjsjksjskks. I hope you get to listening to it at some point, the breezy 90's rnb production makes it her only album to me that's truly a back to front with 0 skips. And the Bjork influence on the title track!! Sooooooo good

blake

these girls dont listen to madonna. confessions is her best

Mari

CONFESSIONS OUTSOLD PLEASEEEEEE 🙏

jodi schwartz

Sophie's choice between like a prayer and ray of light. 💔

Ahmed

Why is like a virgin so high on votes? 😭 that’s like the album she had least creative control over

Ahmed

I would recommend Erotica, def not a commercial peak but an interesting era she was cancelled in

boop

The Ray of Light album is a MASTERPIECE. It came out when I was in middle school. I still listen to it front to back. I hope Taylor's career can swing towards a Madonna Ray of Light moment. Definitely choose that one!

Joshua

True blue ROBBED

Joshua

I redact my like a prayer vote and will give it to true blue. Papa don’t preach, true blue, La island Bonita, open your heart. These are the things!!!! Also in this life from erotica mentioned by me rn.

Julia Scott

You’re in for a treat! Madonna is the GOAT 🐐

Emily

true blue and ray of light should be clearing what...

Reagan

Madonna is one of my all time faves! I can’t pick a favorite album because like Taylor, each era has incredible gems and moments that shaped culture. You should totally make this a mini series and explore her evolution! Like a Virgin was iconic of course, and her MTV Video Award performance left everyone’s jaws hanging. I remember that True Blue was fun because they did a video contest on MTV so I remember watching throughout the day to see the submissions and loved the one they chose. Like a Prayer is one of my favorites and her video was so controversial but important. Erotica was groundbreaking and I know you’ve mentioned the doc that her dancers did recently which had me in tears. Ray of Light and Confessions on a Dance Floor were incredible…her film work wasn’t Oscar worthy but was fun in its own right especially Desperately Seeking Susan and Dick Tracey… I dunno how you’re gonna choose. She’s controversial but always been unapologetically herself and made a huge impact on pop culture. It always makes me sad to see when people dismiss that so I love that you’re doing this!

Gennie Brown

looking forward to also discovering madonna with you!!

Ruby256

RAY OF LIGHT

Sulacycle

Madonna was for me what Taylor has been for your generation. Their obvious, overt brands are really different in my view, (vulnerability vs. provocation) but they both have an ability to shapeshift and both embody an insane commitment to craft and work ethic. I'm excited for this!

Dainty Donna

AHHHHHHH FINALLY!!!! The critic choice is Ray of Light or Like a Prayer. Zach you would probably like Confessions the best. One thing about Madonna however that is CRUCIAL are the music videos. Billboard named her the GREATEST music video artist of all time. Regardless of era, the music videos are a must.

Dainty Donna

Critics’ choice and a BIG comeback: Ray of Light Peak commercial peak in the USA: Like a Virgin Peak commercial success globally: True Blue Apex cultural gravity: Like a Prayer The album that saved her career: Bedtime Stories PEAK SCANDAL: Erotica

Reiley

Yall are fucking wrong for not voting true blue…

Chris

I wouldn’t be opposed to a whole series on Madonna

ryan

taylor doing trip hop would be the best album ever

ryan

ray of light is madonnas creative peak. it’s easily my favorite album from the 90s and also an all time favorite. i cannot believe it isn’t winning 😭

boop

It really would. She needs to fire and rehire everyone (us). They're leading her astray.

daisy

confessions on the dancefloor is SWIFTOLOGIST TEA!!!! i do believe this is The One Zack would truly appreciate. Everything dated or too experimental. PERIOD

S

Well that’s a lie

daisy

It's my opinion, not a truth or a lie. I'm a huge madonna fan but we’re probably not gonna put Zack on if he doesn't start with the disco pop perfection that that record… if we ease in with Confessions which objectively I think he would enjoy the most, the more experimental stuff is easier to digest?

S

Confessions isn’t one of her strongest lyrically and Zack cares about lyrics more than anything. I think he would like something like Ray of light more, or would appreciate the more experimental stuff regardless of whether he likes it or not (after all he did specify that we wanted something either big or interesting).

S

Also I’ve never really listened to a Madonna record pre Hard Candy and thought “that didn’t age well” Her earlier stuff does sound like the 80s but that’s what makes them good imo

Claire

Read the biography Madonna: a Rebel Life by Mary Gabriel. Also: for real, Erotica is great. Watch the videos

Danielle_Tomi

Like A Prayer is simply the best place to start honestly. I wouldn’t extend past the 90s so soon because you need to see her milestones in her upcoming career before her iconic confessions album. She’s the ultimate career shapeshifter 🤩

Dainty Donna

As someone who is fluent in Madonna’s discography, I completely agree. Regardless of where he decides to start, I feel it is CRUCIAL to also watch the mvs. Even if it looks outdated, if you cannot find the appreciation for the cinematography and high-budget production of ‘Express Yourself’ then idk if you can be helped 😂

Jesse Martin

Hi :) I’m late but I definitely wanted to comment on this haha. Zach, I love your videos so much, I love your nuanced opinions and jokes. They could never make me hate you! I wanted to suggest you react to a Mariah album :) you may enjoy the Daydream album the most, for classic Mariah. But if you’re interested in a more modern Mariah sound, I kinda wanna say you should listen to Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel :) you know she’s a song writer, but do you also know she’s hilarious? So many jokes to be found in that album’s lyrics. Regardless, any Mariah album you pick is worth a listen. Thank you :) ❤️