Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Just kidddinnggg it’s my notes app ranking of the vault songs after only two listens!!! 

Timeless - greatest song ever made …. makes the other songs look like jokes by comparison. 

When Emma Falls In Love - totally a driving song like windows down driving song. Best way to describe it. I LOVVEEE the writing on this song and feel like it’s such a familiar old school style Taylor song!! TOTALLY exceeded my expectations. 

I Can See You - not sure where to rank it yet but stuck it here…when I think about it I’m like ohhh that song is great so sexy!! But when I really listen to it I’m sorta bored, but I think it will grow on me!!!! Love the production!! 

Foolish One - this is a grower, too. I really like some things about it but I also find it a little boring at times too, I just gotta give it time to hit bc I do think it’s a sweet song etc etc just not clicking 100% for me yet 

Electric Touch - I think this song is ALMOST really good, it’s just missing a few things to be really really good. It’s missing a big epic moment I think, and that’s def something you’d expect at least from Fall Out Boy!! 

Castles Crumbling - as it stands now…the single most egregious disappointment of my lifetime. No questions at this time please… I am grieving … 

What are your guys’ early rankings?!?!?! 

Files

Comments

curtis

1) electric touch 2) I can see you 3) emma falls in love 4) castles crumbling 5) timeless 6) foolish one

hannah

timeless best song ever SPEAK ON IT!!!!!!

Melodie Roehrig

1. Foolish One 2. Timeless 3. When Emma Falls In Love 4. I Can See You 5. Castles Crumbling 6. Electric Touch

Courtney Camden

1. foolish one 2. castles crumbling 3. i can see you 4. electric touch 5. timeless 6. when emma falls in love 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

Megan

Timeless at the top with Castles Crumbling on the bottom is simply the most unhinged thing i’ve seen all day

laura

1) I Can See You - Saying "we kept everything professional" and then proceeding to repeatedly declare oneself dickmatized? Relatable. 2) Foolish One - The progression from "I could see you up against the wall with me" to "Now I'm slidin' down the wall with my head in my hands" hurt my feelings and therefore I stan. 3) Electric Touch - Taylor heard Electric Feel, got horny, and broke out her thesaurus. Not bad. 4) Castles Crumbling - Not good. 5) When Emma Falls In Love - Actively bad. 6) Timeless - I cringe.

Kevin

Honestly omg, I was so mad when I heard castles crumbling 😭💔

Cara M

Electric Touch I Can See You Foolish One Castles Crumbling Timeless When Emma Falls In Love

Cayla Daniels

Can I rank them all the same because I seriously love each one. 🤣 I think she nailed the vault tracks.

Bryson Moran

castles crumbling is like nothing news kinda ugly and boring little sister

Bryn

I think castles crumbling is the most emo song she's ever written...as in I don't even want to listen to it LOL

Hannah Landry

I didn’t have expectations for castles crumbling and I love it- I think it’s very rep coded and incredibly accurate in predicting the 2016 cancellation. My ranking is: I can see you Castles crumbling Foolish one Timeless When Emma falls in love Electric touch

Vanessa Vieites

1) electric touch 2) foolish one 3) castles crumbling 4)when Emma falls in love 5) timeless 6)I can see you

Liz

Guys timeless what?? A laughable song 😭

Vanessa Vieites

I thought castles crumbling would pack more of a punch with Hayley’s vocals. I think she should’ve come back with a bang in the last chorus instead of just being on a verse

Sugar Plum Failure

Timeless I Can See You When Emma Falls in Love Foolish One Castles Crumbling Electric Touch

Vanessa Vieites

Castles crumbling sounds like it could be on rep. It’s giving my castle crumbled over night

Vanessa Vieites

I can see you reminds me of a commercial. all I hear is IM YOUR FIRE, YOUR DESIRE 😂 that or a bruno mars song lol

Lauren

1. I Can See You 2. Foolish One 3. When Emma Falls In Love 4. Timeless 5. Castles Crumbling 6. Electric Touch

lavendersnake

To those who rank foolish one as #1: who hurt you? I say as someone who would have put this first if this album came out like four years ago

lavendersnake

1. I can see you 2. When Emma falls in love 3. Timeless 4. Foolish one 5. Electric touch 6. Castles crumbling

Gracie Day

1. When Emma Falls in Love 2. Castles Crumbling 3/4/5 (interchanging) Foolish One, I Can See You, Timeless 6. Electric Touch (definitely last for me)

Luke Alexander

castles crumbling was so good :'( <3

Gracie Day

Wow, it’s crazy how all our orderings are wildly different

Jordan

1.) I can see you, 2.) Castles crumbling, 3.) When Emma falls in love, 4.)Foolish one, 5.) Timeless, 6.)Electric touch

sleepy bubbles

Castles Crumbling is dead last in my ranking too

JamieMcQ

1) Timeless 2) Electric Touch 3) I Can See You 4) When Emma Falls in Love 5) Castles Crumbling 6) Foolish One

Blueasice24

I declare Castles Crumbling a grower

GW

When Emma Falls in Love is Drops of Jupiter. Its the first thing I heard when I listened to it and soooo many people agree. If Train decide to copyright claim it, Speak Now will no longer be entirely self written.

Mr. Watermelon

1. Electric Touch 2. Foolish One 3. Timeless 4. I Can See You 5. When Emma Falls In Love 6. Castles Crumbling

Ana Facha

1. i can see you 2. timeless 3. when emma falls in love 4. castles crumbling 5. electric touch 6. foolish one also i'm so happy to be back but i have to say coming back to like two months worth of content to binge is chef's kiss

Lexi

1. I Can See You 2. Electric Touch 3. Foolish One 4. Timeless 5. When Emma Falls in Love 6. Castles Crumbling

Cathy Stephens

Interesting! I loved Castles Crumbing. BUT I also don’t have years & years of anticipation attached to it.

sam

these are impossible to rank to me rn but i cannot fathom the disrespect foolish one is getting…

aubbie

I can see you was upper tier for me, but then I saw the MV… straight to the top! 🤩🤩🤩 the imagery added an element that blew the rest of the vault babies out of the gaddam room. loved & looped playing over and over - I live. will marinate in the rest of the songs more in depth later 🤞🏻

Lizzy

I like Foolish One the best. Love how she sings the chorus at the end again in a lower key once she's lost her hope. Feels like a direct time capsule back to 19 year old taylor. None of the others impress me that much, but they're all OK / not bad

Paigelinagina

1. Foolish one / I Can See You (sorry can't choose) 3. When Emma Falls In Love 4. Timeless 5. Electric Touch 6. Castles Crumbling

Vrishti Hasija

My ranking is 1. I can see you 2. Castles crumbling 3. When Emma falls in love 4. Timeless 5. Electric touch 6. Foolish one

Dia

1. Timeless 2. I can see you 3. Foolish One 4. Castles Crumbling 5. Electric Touch

Courtney A

I'm not sure of my rankings, yet, expect for Electric Touch and Timeless. They are my top two from this vault!!!

Ty

I can see you, electric touch, timeless, castles crumbling, when Emma falls in love, foolish one

Lou

My ranking is everything over Haunted TV which is a crime against humanity

Iman

I can see you Electric tough Castles crumbling When Emma Timeless Foolish one

Clara Mae

Justice for Timeless fr!!!

Clara Mae

1. Timeless - sobbed my eyes out on first listen 2. I Can See You - SHONKED me I was like who is this singing to me??? 3. Castles Crumbling - growing on me more with each listen 4. Electric Touch - sounds exactly like I thought it would! 5. When Emma Falls In Love - it’s cute … 6. Foolish One - idk it’s a little juvenile for me 😭 but I don’t hate it!!! All the vaults are really good imo

Nadine

I am losing my mind. When I listened to Timeless the first (and only) time I thought This is it. This is the new worst song she has ever released. And now almost everyone on SM ranks it first?!?!?!?!?!?!?! WHAT IS HAPPENING

Nadine

Emma is cute. It's a bop. Just like Drops of Jupiter which she copied for it. I swear the verses are the same. But still! Bop!

SwIfTeA

1. Timeless 2. I can see you 3. Castles crumbling 4. Electric touch 5. When emma falls in love 6. Foolish one

Mad Esme at the Plaza Athénée

1. I Can See You 2. Castles Crumbling 3. Electric Touch 4. When Emma Falls in Love 5. Foolish One 6. Timeless - ICSY slaps, total slay, can't say enough about it, I'm obsessed. Everyone is scandalized that Fearless Taylor wrote that, but come on, have you seen her performance of "Put Some Sugar on Me" with Def Leppard? Have you ever been an 18 year old girl? Seriously, we know how vivid her imagination is, of course she went there, at least in her mind. And mature experienced 32 year old Taylor knew just how to deliver it. - Castles Crumbling is beautiful and painful, heart-felt, angelic harmonies. It wasn't exactly what we expected from that collab, but we'll take it. A pleasant surprise. - Electric Touch doesn't go quite as hard as I had hoped, but it's good. I was expecting something similar to their VS performance of MSKWYDITD, but it's still very catchy and I think I'll love it even more with further listens. To be fair, this is Taylor's album, not FOB's, so it makes sense that it comes across as a Taylor song with a FOB feature rather than the inverse. - WEFIL has a beautiful melody and a sweet and slightly self-deprecating message. I appreciate it even more now that she made it clear it's about Emma Stone and I've seen the clip of her answer to an interview question back in the day about who would she be if she could choose to be anyone, and she answered Emma. I love these types of full-circle fathomings. Singing it now, when Emma is married with a child, it adds a whole other meaning to "I wish I was her," especially after YLM. - Foolish One is a decent song, but I don't relate to the lyrics and I feel like we've visited this theme enough times before, I would have preferred another banger. - Timeless is sweet I guess, but it feels like a story or spoken word put to music, too many details, I don't feel like it flows as a song. Similar to Starlight but not as good, and that's saying a lot.

Starbuck1234!

1. Castles Crumbling; 2. I can see you; 3. WEFIL; 4. Electric Touch; 5. Timeless; 6. Foolish One