Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

2 shorter books or 1 long book?

  • 2 separate books 4
  • 1 longer book 2
  • Doesn't matter to me 2
  • I need to know more to decide 1
  • 2024-09-30
  • 9 votes
{'title': '2 shorter books or 1 long book?', 'choices': [{'text': '2 separate books', 'votes': 4}, {'text': '1 longer book', 'votes': 2}, {'text': "Doesn't matter to me", 'votes': 2}, {'text': 'I need to know more to decide', 'votes': 1}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 9, 30, 14, 17, 22, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 9}

Content

Hello friends!

We are closing in on all of Dead End Guild Master book 1 being live on Royal Road, and that means early access chapters from book 2 are following shortly as well. You get them first, and then they go live on RR later.

None of those perks are changing, but I've been debating something that I'd like your opinion on.

Book 1 is a little over 100k words, and book 2 is looking like it will land around 120kish. Should I combine them into 1 book or keep them separate?

Nothing about the story itself will change, nor will the Patreon perks. This would primarily affect the end Kindle experience more than anything.

Comments

Notcreepycreeper

Book 1 didn't feel short exactly, but at the end of the day the whole thing felt like a set up for a bunch of plot threads, and so not especially long. whether book 2 is 1 longer book or 2 shorter books really depends on how many plot threads you plan on resolving. Like I don't think the dungeon, orc invasion, and Devontes should all be resolved in 1 book, as it would be a lot. But actual length-wise the same length would probably be ok

Sryanr

Imo, I guess it depends on your goals. Financially, my understanding is that it's typically better for 1 long book if you're doing kindle unlimited (since pages read is the same regardless, and reader retention is better as one book), and since readers in litrpg like massive books. If it's not kindle unlimited, I think it's better to be two books, though

Marshal Carper -- Character-first adventures!

The artist in me wants it to be 2 books, but the financial min/maxer in me (he's there but is like level 2 in experience) wants to do the longer approach for the eventual KU release.

Notcreepycreeper

As I’m thinking about book 2, there’s also one more thing that I hope will be better explained - how do adventurers get stronger. It’s clear that you’re skipping litRPG tropes of of having ppl literally gain levels/XP, instead setting it as a literal experience/skill based system (like the real world). But that leaves some blanks, like how is Becky who is old as hell and smart/skilled such a lower level compared to Hans? What is the criteria for pulling off the exponential growth needed to get to Diamonds in non-mage adventurers? Is it literally just lucking into a powerful magical item? Are they all fighting-geniuses? Manzo seems to have the power equivalent of a modern tank. Can non-mage fighters match her just based on pure skill for an equivelent Diamond rank? Also the mage delineations are a bit murky and interesting. Why do mages super specialize in black/white/blue? It feels like there would be benefits to learning multiple schools (for example protective spells would help Manzo better survive monster attacks she needs to experience). And it’s already been said that mages get to choose their field, it’s not like their aptitude shoehorns them into one role. All that’s a bit scatter-brained, but tldr the progression system just isn’t clicking for me, given the vast gulf between lower and upper levels. I think it’d be interesting if more of the system is slowly revealed, especially as the kids start training/fighting in the new dungeon

Marshal Carper -- Character-first adventures!

I updated the rank descriptions based on this feedback: https://www.patreon.com/posts/announcement-1-113088723 The short version is, my handling of guild ranks is heavily influenced by martial arts belt ranks. Belts are a vague reflection of skill, but it's all too easy for someone to get promoted too quickly or too slowly, so their belt doesn't match a generic expectation of their skill. Soooo people end up judging you for the belt on your waste and not your real abilities. Kind of like Becky is judged for being a Bronze, but how could she rank up with no Gomi Guild Master for many years?