Developing Ideas Part 3, Example Workflow and Draft (Spoilers) (Patreon)
Content
So far, our deep dive into developing ideas has covered identifying what kind of ideas you're looking for and how to approach brainstorming based on how much (or little) you already had figured out. We have more theory and technique to explore for this topic, but I often worry about essays like this because they have a tendency to get very abstract. To help avoid that, today's post is going to walk through one of my actual brainstorming sessions from start to finish.
I had a vague idea of what kind of story I wanted to tell, but I was stumped on specifics, so I busted out my notebook and put all of the stuff we've discussed so far into practice. That exercise then led to the scene draft I've attached at the end of this article.
Warning: I've redacted specifics like character names and such out of my notes to make this less of a spoiler, but you should know that this particular piece of content will not be published for several months, and I don't believe there are any major plot points revealed in these notes. Personally, I don't think reading this will ruin anything for a reader, but we all have different tolerances for spoilers.
Bigger Warning: The excerpted scene does not have these redactions because it makes the story difficult to read, and thus, makes the excerpt a poor example for what brainstorming can produce. So, yeah, SPOILERS here too. To repeat myself, I selected this example specifically because I can share it with you in isolation and not ruin a plot for you.
The End Result
We're going to look at where the brainstorming stopped first and then walk through each stage of the process. These notes aren't likely to make a ton of sense without a decoder ring, but I do think it's helpful to have an idea of where we're going before we step off of the starting line.
The problem: I knew I needed an idea that provided characterization as well as developed the setting. I wanted to show two characters interacting and facing challenges together to reveal more about them as individuals as well as the evolution of their friendship. At the same time, that story also needed to reveal key details about the setting that become important to the story later.
Here's where the brainstorming ended:
Total mayhem, right?
My handwriting is terrible. I know. It looks like someone gave a five year-old a concussion and then asked them to write a story. That's always been the case, but a few broken fingers and then some arthritis and finally the realization that I shouldn't give a shit about handwriting aesthetics made it as bad is it is today.
Last week, I shared that I like to use both pages of a page spread when I brainstorm. I do most of my "active" brainstorming on the right page, while I use the left page to frame key guiderails, which are the ideas and objectives I need to keep in mind as I ideate. I refer back to those guiderails any time I have a lull in my thoughts, and I often develop those guiderails as I go as well.
Poking at an idea often helps to make those guiderails even more clear, and that's helpful, so I make sure to write those developments down.
Here's a rough breakdown of how I came to fill these two pages (we'll drill into each section later):
1. Pink Blocks = I wrote down my guide rails and began to make a list of potential ideas.
2. Purple Block = I hit on an idea I liked and began to develop it into the makings of a scene.
3. Blue Blocks = I thought more deeply about the details I needed to bring the scene to life, which include descriptions about the setting as well as moments of action that sounded compelling to me. I ended up thinking of more setting details as I moved into the green blocks, which is why you see a blue block in the middle of the left page and a bunch of arrows detailing how they connect.
4. Green Blocks = Where I thought this new idea fit into the large themes and plot of the story.
5. Orange Blocks = Random thoughts that I didn't want to lose but weren't necessarily directly related to the immediate problem I aimed to solve.
1. Pink: Starting the Brainstorming Process
On the tops of both pages I wrote down the next major plot development (left) and wrote down the next type of characterization I felt the story needed (right).
Then, I wrote down the abstract criteria I needed this anecdote about fighting a monster to include (left). I knew that whatever story I told, it would have to:
Include a scenario that wasn't immediately deadly
Involved ranged attacks
And that one character asks the other to pick what monster they fight
Next, I began a list of dumb/simple monsters that matched the noob-level encounter I was after. In one column, I wrote down the monster, and in the next I wrote down what ranged ability they might use.
Slime stuck out to me as being a good fit (hence the question mark attached to it), but it felt too cliché, so I scrolled through a bestiary of Final Fantasy enemies for more ideas, leading to the rat, roach, and bunny lines.
Doing this exercise helped me to uncover what felt like a clever twist on the classic newbie slime encounter, so I abandoned the list and moved into fleshing out a slime scene.
2. Purple: Fleshing Out an Idea
I asked myself where slimes might be found, and swamps came to mind, but I needed my characters to stay close to a specific city, so I decided they didn't have the money to do any significant travel. You'll notice I had ideas for using their financial status as another means of fleshing out the world, so I made the note at the bottom that these characters recognize they are poor, feel trapped by it, and see adventuring as a way to escape it.
The characters end up working through these same thoughts in the story, showing how they arrived at the conclusion to look for slimes in the sewer.
At this point, my idea for this sewer scene was as developed as you see in this section of notes. So far, all I was (relatively) certain of was the following:
The story had to take place in a sewer
This slime had an ability that launched goo so sticky that it was akin to being paralyzed. Once it hardened, which happened quickly, it was very difficult to break. Get gooped in the knee? Sorry, you can't bend it anymore.
But one of the characters being frozen and simply removed from the battle as a result was boring. I wanted more complications to drive more tension and more action, so when one character gets frozen by slime goop, she falls into the sewage. Since she can't move, she starts to drown.
The other character jumps in and saves her. The details about what that looked like and exactly how it happened didn't exist yet, but if a character is drowning and can't move, someone probably has to go get that character if I don't want them to die.
Then I thought about leaving a city sewer after going for a swim and how people might react to the state of the characters. I thought it might be funny for our characters to run into some guards and have to explain why they were covered in poop at three in the morning.
That wasn't much, but it was may more than I started with. It felt like the bones of something worthwhile, so I continued the process.
3. Blue Blocks: Fleshing Out the Scene
On the right page, I started to write down more details and action that would bring the scene to life. I needed the scene to be interesting in isolation, but I wanted it to very much connect to the larger world, even if those connections were small. My characters are surrounded by other people with their own lives and their own objectives, and outside characters reacting to or outside forces affecting the action of the scene help to make the world feel more lived in. To me, at least.
The sticky goo mechanic was the catalyst for the interesting part of the story (two characters swimming in sewage), so I started to think of ways to double down on that idea, leading to the line: "Fights with a frozen [charactername] stuck to his shoulder."
When the rescuing character jumps in to retrieve his friend, he discovers that the goo is in fact still sticky, so when he grabs her to get her out of danger, she ends up stuck to him. Now he has to swim, fight, and escape with another person attached to him.
Which led me to ask myself, Okay, so they get stuck together. How would they fix that?
And then came the next idea that I liked so much I put a star next to it: "Had to see the [redacted] infirmary to get [charactername] detached."
This was an extension of the guard encounter. Our characters were in a ridiculous predicament and needed a way to resolve it, so they end up going to a Healer for help. I thought that conversation had the potential to be funny, but I wanted the embarrassment and absurdity to go a little bit further.
Out came the idea that resolving the sticky goo was actually really really simple. Pour some vinegar on it, and the goo dissolves immediately. Other characters in the story believe this is common knowledge, opening the door for some more humor by poking fun at our characters for being such massive noobs.
Then I thought: Is sticky goo really bad enough to trigger all of these moments?
So I decided that: "Slime sticks through clothing to skin."
Yeah, my solution was to make the sticky goo stickier. Shut up.
But that made me think, Wait. What's the slime monster doing in all of this? Surely it would still be attacking? That meant one character had to rescue the hero without themselves succumbing to the same sticky fate.
So what would someone do if they saw their friend frozen stiff by slime, knowing full well that if the same happened to them, they both would die?
"[charactername1] uses [charactername2]'s body to block more slime."
In my mind's eye, I pictured one character using the frozen character as a shield. That was a practical solution to the problem, but it also opened the door to more humor. The frozen character just has to take the abuse and might have some strong opinions about that tactic when the fight is over.
Next, I thought about the details that would make the scene feel more immersive, so I looked up the major chemicals in sewage and what they smelled like, leading to the list on the left page that begins with "hydrogen sulfide." I also wrote down how just being in the presence of those chemicals would affect our characters, such as burning their eyes or making them dizzy. Yeah, everyone knows poop stinks, but to me, that's not enough to make it feel like the reader is splashing around with our characters.
Doing that little bit of research made me ask another question to myself: What would make this setting even more miserable and gross? Bonus points if it further emphasizes the newbie nature of our characters.
Answering that question gave me this: "Chose the week of a festival to go into the sewer, regretted the volume of waste."
Our characters, without thinking about it, chose to explore the sewers in the middle of a giant city event, so not only were there more people in town to put the sewers to use, they were also partying really hard, giving me another opportunity to extend the comedy of errors.
4. Green Blocks: The Rest of the Story
I know this is weird, but I wrote the bottom block of green first. Gray slimes were a part of another plot point, so connecting this flashback about newbies fighting slimes seemed like a potential tie-in, and then I thought about when and where this flashback would be introduced. A bunch of adventurers swapping yarns seemed like a good idea, so I decided that might happen during a dedication ceremony.
Interesting sidebar: I ended up not using any of that lower green block.
The second green block, the one at the top, came about when I realized there were bigger thematic tie-ins into conversations characters had before and into ideas that we already know are important to our characters. This material also went unused, but I still like the concepts in that material, so I'll likely use it later.
5. Orange Blocks: Unrelated Brain Chatter
I have diagnosed ADHD. I take the medications. I do regular check-ins with a psychiatrist. I used to try and fight my mind's tendency to bounce into other unrelated ideas, but that never worked very well. Now, if I have a thought that my brain insists is important yet I'm certain is not relevant to the task at hand, I write it down.
That's enough to convince my brain that I'm taking the idea seriously and that I won't forget to come back to it. Once it's down on paper, I find it much easier to go back to what I was really working on. As a result, my notebooks are filled with entries like these orange blocks.
And these thoughts come for me when I'm drafting as well, so I always have a running list at the bottom of my drafts for the same reasons. I need to write the ideas down to get my brain off my back, so if I get hit with one during drafting, I scroll wheel down real quick, type it out, and then scroll wheel back to where I was.
I Don't Care How You Do It
I've said this in my articles on writing before, but I needed to hear it a bunch of times of myself before I believed it: What your process looks like doesn't matter if it works. To borrow some words from the poet Taylor Mali, you show your work in math class. You hide it in writing. No one will see your manifesto-looking notebook and terrible handwriting unless you're dumb enough to take pictures of it and put it on the internet.
But, if you're like me, you're self-conscious even when you are 100% alone working on something no one will see unless you deliberately show it to them. I used to feel a little bit crazy drawing arrows all over my notes and writing down a disconnected thought in that corner and then another somewhere else. My own embarrassment about my process stunted my growth as a writer.
Writing got a lot easier when I recognized that the writing process isn't as prescriptive as some educators may lead you to believe. Do what's right for your brain. Nobody cares if it's weird or goofy. They only care about the story that comes out of it.
Super Spoiler Bonus: The Story from the Brainstorm
Like I said at the opening of this post, I worry that explorations of the writing process don't do enough to demonstrate the concrete application of methods and techniques.
To address that, I'm attaching the actual scene that came out of the process we just walked through. This is a spoiler in the sense that you'll learn something well ahead of its appearance in the books (if it makes the final cut at all), but I also selected this spoiler specifically because it doesn't reveal major story developments.
It's entirely up to you what you're okay with, but I have one other caveat: This draft is a little over 24 hours old at the time of my writing this. It hasn't been revised or proofed, and even just the act of pasting it in here made me see several points I want to address in revision.
So it would be cool if you didn't leave me a Royal Road review based on what you read here:
Spoiler Story Excerpt: Friends Stick Together
Hans sat outside in one of the quads on the Adventurers’ Guild flagship campus. This particular spot was popular among adventurers because it had several huge trees for shade and a mesmerizing water fountain. The footprint for the fountain was as large as Hans’ apartment, and it was commonly referred to as “the sword” because a natural rock formation in the middle of the fountain vaguely resembled the hilt of a sword.
He always thought that was a big leap in imagination, but the sword was more than just a landmark. Every adventurer to earn Platinum had their names carved into the stone. Hans could spend hours going from name to name, just soaking in adventurer history.
Mazo dropped her bag and joined Hans in the grass.
“I have news,” she said, failing to repress her grin.
“Yeah?”
“I’ve decided to focus my studies on Blue Magery.”
Hans studied the halfling’s face. “You’re serious.”
“Why wouldn’t I be?”
“I heard most Blue Mages get themselves blown up or worse well before they get to Bronze.”
“That’s true,” Mazo said.
“And Blue Mages have to ‘experience’ the monster ability they want to learn, right?”
“Also true.”
“Mazo…” Hans searched for the right words. “Halflings aren’t known for their durability.”
“I don’t care. I’m going to do it. A Bronze Blue Mage typically knows monster abilities comparable to an upper Silver Black Mage, so I’ll be punching well above my weight on jobs. Blue Mages can’t share their spells the way traditional wizards can, so no two Blue Mages ever have the same arsenal. Lastly, Blue magic is really rough on your mana pool. If you can get through the growing pains, the long-term rewards for the mana pool alone are huge.”
“Are you going to obsess over poisons like Master Hardrob?”
“Fuck that,” Mazo replied. “My skin is too perfect, and I like the drama of bigger spells.”
“Sounds like you’ve got it figured out. Being an Iron next year is going to be a lot of fun for the both of us.”
“I’m not waiting until Iron. I think I have the Lore spell kicked, but I need to test it.”
“What does Lore do?”
“That’s the spell Blue Mages use to learn abilities. You’re going to help me get my first Blue spell.”
Hans looked up, chuckling. “I’m doing what now?”
“First, we need to pick a monster we can handle with just the two of us. The ability it uses needs to not kill me, and that ability needs to be ranged.”
Rubbing his bare chin in thought, Hans eventually asked, “How about a rockworm? They make their projectiles out of rock they’ve eaten and spit them. Apparently the big adults are comparable to heavy crossbows when they spit.”
“Where’s the closest rockwarm?”
Hans pulled a bestiary out of his bag and flipped through it. “Looks like the closest option is here.”
He turned the book’s map to Mazo and pointed at an area just southeast of Hoseki, but what looked close on a map was a two to three day walk.
“I like the idea, but one problem,” Mazo said. “Do you have gold for camping gear? Rations? Lodging?”
“I’m broke as fuck.”
“Me too.”
Hans flipped through his bestiary, looking for inspiration. “How about a black slime? They throw pieces of their own slime. When that slime hits, it sticks like glue and then hardens. They’re uncommon but not rare. They’ve been observed in the Hoseki sewers on multiple occasions. That ability isn’t deadly, and slimes are easy enough to kill from what I’ve read. Chop, chop and you’re done.”
Mazo took the bestiary and studied the entry on black slimes. “I’m not ecstatic about trapesing through a sewer, but I think you’re right that this would work.”
“We could probably tag along with some Irons when the next sewer job pops up. I’ve met a few nice ones that I don’t think would mind.”
“Pfft,” Mazo responded. “We’re going tonight.”
“...We aren’t allowed.”
“So?”
“I don’t want to get in trouble.”
With a heavy sigh, Mazo rolled her eyes. “I’m doing this tonight with or without you. If you don’t see me tomorrow, it’s because I died. Then you’ll have to live with depriving the world of its next top mage.”
“Fine.”
That night, well after sunset, young Hans and young Mazo met at one of the access doors for the sewers. Hans carried a longsword and wore a new gambeson–not exactly top of the line, but it was better than nothing. He saved up for months to afford it.
“Is that new?” Mazo asked.
“Yep,” Hans said with a proud smile. “Sewer rats aren’t biting through this.”
“Won’t it get gross?”
“Probably. I’ll wash it.”
The halfling put a finger on the flat of Hans blade and held up to inspect it in the moonlight. The edge was chipped and rust dappled nearly every inch of iron.
“I know it sucks,” Hans said. “It’s my dad’s. A new one is out of my price range.”
“Once we start taking real jobs, we’ll have more money than we know what to do with. Okay, Mr. Frontliner, lead on.”
Mazo used Create Fire on two torches and handed one to Hans.
Hans didn’t know it at the time, but they picked one of the worst possible times to do a sewer run. A summer flower festival was in progress, and the Capital was packed with visitors from all over. As a result, the Hoseki sewers worked double, perhaps even triple, duty to pipe the waste through the tunnels and out of the city. That meant that several platforms that were typically dry were now partially submerged. Walking over those was like walking through a giant puddle.
Of shit.
For the first three hours, they encountered rats and green slimes. All of the rats ran from the duo, even the giant ones, and Hans felt like a proper adventurer hacking and slashing at the green goopy monsters.
Finally, they found a black slime.
Black slimes aren’t actually black. They are an incredibly dark brown that looks just like black under torchlight. Their food in the sewers allegedly gave them their color, and they reportedly used methane similar to how Mages used reagents in order to create and fire their sticky projectiles.
The plan wasn’t complicated. Mazo would cast Lore, get hit, and then Hans would step in and chop up the slime.
Their first mistake was underestimating the slime’s size. They saw a black slime small enough to fit into a beer stein moving along the edge of the sewage but did not realize that most of that slime was actually underwater.
So when Mazo stepped into harm’s way to intentionally get gooped up, the glob that broke against her chest was a gallon or more in volume. Smaller black slimes by comparison shot gunk that wouldn’t overflow a tea cup.
The pair might have recovered control of their sidequest had Mazo held her ground. Instead, she made their second mistake.
In her shock of getting drenched by black slime, she turned to retreat. The goop hardened in that pivot, freezing her arms and legs in place mid-stride.
Mazo stared at Hans with wide eyes as she slowly tipped over and fell into the sewage. Unable to move any of her limbs, she promptly began drowning. Hans jumped in after her.
Hans made the party’s third mistake when he scooped Mazo under his arm. In the moment, that made sense. The sewage was about three feet deep, and that grab was the fastest way to get the halfling above water.
Had Hans done his research, he would have known that the hardened slime that froze Mazo was still unsafe to touch. Since he didn’t know that, Hans’ left arm was looked in the shape of a tea cup handle, and Mazo was glued securely in place against his ribs. He couldn’t lift his arm. He couldn’t put her down. The halfling was securely attached to the human.
Doing his best to keep his wits about him, Hans knew that they couldn’t afford a fourth mistake. If the black slime locked him up the way it did Mazo, they were both dead. No one knew they were down here, and no one was likely to even find their bodies. So his top priority was to avoid the goop balls and then set up a retreat.
Hans paused his story and looked up at a green-faced Olza. He laughed.
“I basically used Mazo as a shield. If I was about to get sludged, I spun that side of my body into its path to keep the rest of me mobile. She got hit another three or four times, but we got out. A guard patrol almost arrested us, just two kids running around covered in shit, but I think they wanted an excuse not to. So when we told them we were adventurers in training they let us go. Keep in mind Mazo was glued to my body for this whole discussion.
“Finally, at like four in the morning, we get to the guild infirmary and ask for help.”
“You couldn’t find vinegar? Works pretty quickly.”
“No, Olza, I did not look for vinegar because I didn’t know there was a solution that simple. The Healer in the infirmary also thought that was pretty funny. But we lived, Mazo got her first Blue spell, and I ruined a brand new gambeson.”
“And that’s why you hate slimes?”
“And that’s why I hate slimes.”