I don't care if I guessed your ending; I care if it sucks. (Patreon)
Content
Gen V, the spinoff of Prime’s hit super hero series The Boys, is nearing the conclusion of its latest season. Recently, show producer Eric Kripke said that several fans correctly guessed one of the show’s major twists, and he added that it “irritated” him.
That comment has generated quite a bit of discussion, and I’m about to add my own spin, but I need to acknowledge this up front: I couldn’t immediately find a longer version of the quote, so I don’t know if Kripke was actually bothered or if his comment was intended to not be serious. In the interest of fairness, this week’s post is going to talk in generalities about creators who get upset or think it’s a bad thing when fans crack the ending or solve a major mystery ahead of the official reveal.
My position: Fans correctly guessing a twist or the ultimate ending is only bad if they don’t have fun doing it.
When Solving the Plot is Fun
You feel rewarded for paying attention to the story and the details
The plot point you guessed was not obvious from the start but is logically consistent
You’re excited to see what you guessed actually play out because it sounds cool/satisfying/interesting
You predict the plot twist but can’t predict what it will mean for every character
You enjoy discussing the story with friends and other friends, finding entertainment in the community around the story as well as the story itself
When Solving the Plot Isn’t Fun
A cliche, ultra-predictable resolution is not engaging or interesting
You already feel bored by events and scenes that haven’t happened yet
The outcome is so obvious that it makes most of the story in between feel more like attempts at misdirects instead of actual character development
The outcome is so outlandish that it doesn’t provide a satisfying conclusion to the narrative threads that made the story interesting in the first place
Character choices feel like they bend to serve the plot rather than the plot developing from their choices
A creator or producer of the story you’re guessing is annoyed or upset by fans paying very close attention to foreshadowing and character quirks
Satisfying Endings =/= Surprises
The notion that a reader (or viewer) should reach the very end of a story and find the resolution to be a complete surprise undermines what makes many stories compelling and interesting. Yes, there are places where a mega twist is good for the story and may even be the point, but for the majority of narratives, the reader is spending a great deal of time learning about your characters and their worlds.
If a reader understands a character well enough to accurately predict what he or she would do in high-stakes scenarios, that’s not a bad thing. I have a pretty good sense of what my friends would do in certain situations not because they are flat or shallow but because I have spent a lot of time with them. The more you get to know someone, the more you understand how they see the world and how they make choices.
And that doesn’t make them less interesting to be around. Instead, it becomes the foundation for even more unique and enjoyable moments because of that familiarity, not in spite of it.
Again, are surprise twists inherently bad? No, they aren’t. I think the arbitrary perspective that twists HAVE to be total surprises is a disservice to a lot of great stories.
As far as Gen V goes, I “figured it out” because I actively follow the Gen V subreddit and because the clues scattered through the narrative were genuinely interesting to think about. I had fun thinking about the show that way, and that’s all any of this about it, having fun for the sake of fun.