Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Note: I saw a bump in Patreon subscribers recently, so if you're new here, I do these behind-the-scenes posts most weeks, but they aren't required reading. If you're new, you also might have missed 20 beta chapters of a new project (The Center for Dungeon Management) available only to Patreon subscribers. Read it here.

Chekhov's Gun is a well-known concept in storytelling: if you show a gun in act 1, it better go off by act 5.

Several ideas are baked into this sentence:

Audiences have expectations based on what information you reveal to them.

An interesting nugget in a story is meaningless if you don't do anything with it.

Spotting a Chekhov's Gun (CG) early or being surprised by a CG at the conclusion can both be entertaining for readers if handled properly.

Chekhov's Gun is an important concept for any writer, but I don't feel like I hear enough about the Invisible Reverse Chekhov's Gun: if something cool happens in act 5, you better have set it up in act 1.

This isn't about avoiding the unexpected or spoonfeeding readers the plot to make sure they don't miss anything. For me, the real takeaway is that big moments are the most satisfying if the reader can connect them to previous scenes. The gun going off in act 5 is cooler because the hint was dropped in act 1.

Threading the Needle Between Obvious and Surprising

The challenge is that obvious CGs aren't as fun, and the same is true of the CGs that are easily overlooked. In both cases, the audience doesn't get to experience a buildup of tension that the story then resolves in an entertaining way. Knowing the twist from the start is boring.

Conversely, a twist that seems arbitrary or like a deus ex machina is frustrating because the story itself doesn't seem to resolve the conflict. By act 5, you've given the reader a small world of content. If the resolution does not come from or build on that content in some way, you've completed the puzzle for the reader, but they still have pieces in their hands.

Having extra pieces when you finish a puzzle ruins the gratification because you aren't admiring the puzzle when you place the final piece. You're looking around trying to think what the hell you did wrong for there to still be pieces left rather than enjoying the accomplishment of finishing the puzzle.

Hiding in Plain Sight

In my mind, the best CGs are the ones that are right in an audience's faces, but the audience doesn't realize they have seen a CG. Later, when the conflict resolves, the CG suddenly feels obvious. Now that all the pieces have come together, the full picture is better than you imagined it would be.

Example: The clock tower in Back to the Future is a CG in my opinion. From the jump, we learn that the clock tower was struck by lightning years ago and no longer functions. A savvy audience recognizes the emphasis on that factoid, but why it's important isn't immediately apparent.

Guns are boring CGs because they can only really do one thing. The clock tower, though, is not as obvious. At first, it could just seem like a little bit of worldbuilding that the clock is broken. Then we go back in time and see that it's working. Maybe you remember the exact date and put together that the story is only a few days away from that moment. If you're really clever, maybe you connect the dots when Doc Brown talks about not having enough power, but even then, you can't guess exactly how everything goes down.

I suspect very few audiences saw the flyer for fixing the clock tower at the start of the movie and thought, "I bet they're going to use the clock tower to redirect a lightning strike into a time machine to power a flux capacitor."

You either get it, or you don't, but either way, you have fun

Back to the Future is one of my favorite examples for this because it so clearly demonstrates how entertaining a well-executed CG can be for audiences who figure it out and for audiences who don't.

If you pick up on the plot points that build up to the lightning strike, you feel rewarded for having paid attention. You get to feel smart for sussing it out and making all the right connections. That's a gratifying feeling for an audience because it's made the story a more interactive adventure. They engaged with the story, they paid attention, they thought about what the storyteller was sharing, and they understood the final twist perfectly because they saw the buildup without the resolution being completely obvious.

The audiences who miss some or all of the clues of a CG aren't left out either. Feeling blindsided by an ending is entertaining when you can reflect on the story and pick out all the little moments that set up the finish. For one, being able to make those connections after the fact is fun in its own way. For two, the surprise doesn't feel cheap because getting fooled is also fun.

Magicians are entertaining, in part, because you know there's a trick. As soon as one picks up a deck of cards, you know what you're in for, so you get really invested in the performance. You watch and listen closely. You look for little tells and movements. And the whole time, there's a sense of suspense--Will the magician get to the end of the trick and surprise me? Then poof.

That's what getting to the end of Back to the Future before figuring out the clock tower is important feels like. The audience gets to go "Ohhhhhhhhh" as all the pieces finally click.

Crafting CGs

When I say "invisible reverse," I'm talking about a specific kind of writing process: A writer develops an amazing conclusion and then works backward to set it up in a satisfying way.

I have no data for this, but I imagine most CGs are fired in act 5 before they're written into act 1. The kind of tight storytelling you see in something like Back to the Future isn't a one-draft masterpiece (typically). A writer might be partway through act 4 and get an idea that only works if they go back and adjust several previous moments in the story. This is normal, and it's definitely something I do as well.

Many of my major story beats are planned, so I usually go into a project with a vague sense of structure and an endpoint in mind, but I'm also happy to pick up new opportunities along the way. Writers often grumble about suddenly finding themselves in a narrative corner, but there are just as many unexpected narrative springboards. You need to be on the lookout for both, and addressing either the problem or the opportunity effectively is likely to involve some level of revision.

CGs in serial fiction are uniquely challenging for writers because a release schedule puts an expiration date on every chapter. If you come up with a cool idea that requires a revision, you can only go back so far before you're changing parts of published content. This challenge is even greater, I suspect, for so-called "pantsers," which are writers who don't have a structured plan when they start to write and make it up as they go along.

Matt Dinniman (Dungeon Crawler Carl) describes himself as a pantser, yet he still builds satisfying narratives. His stories are well-structured. He teases and sets up big future moments. The adventure always feels like it's moving forward, like it's going somewhere.

From the outside (I can't say for sure what he does in his process), Dinniman handles the CG problem by planting them all over the story, so he has them to use later, but the trick is that he keeps them top of mind for the reader by referencing the myriad of CGs Carl has in his life from time to time, even if they aren't critical at that exact moment. Then Dinniman is creative enough that the payoff he comes up with later is fun and unexpected yet follows the established logic of the story.

Give Yourself Room to Work

I'm sure revision is a part of his process, but this, to me, is the key to CGs for any writer who considers themselves a pantser: Make sure your character is seeing and doing interesting things even if you don't know exactly how any one CG will resolve, and then keep those CGs top of mind for yourself as well as for your audience.

Carl gets his Doomsday Scenario device way early in the story and, after several books, still hasn't used it. However, Carl often considers if, perhaps, this is the moment where it makes sense. Nope, not yet, but now the reader remembers it's there, so when it finally does matter, the reader won't be thrown off balance.

For any kind of writer, pantster or not, I also recommend a deep backlog. If you're writing chapter 50, and chapter 49 went up yesterday, you're walking a tightrope without a net. Pulling it off is possible, sure, but you've also made it far harder on yourself than it needs to be. The farther you can go back for revision, the easier it is to solve unexpected narrative problems.

CG Misfires

If you want an example of a CG falling completely flat, the Sith dagger in the Rise of Skywalker is one of my favorites. If you're not familiar, the heroes find an oddly shaped dagger. That dagger then perfectly aligns with ship wreckage if viewed from a very specific place that the heroes happen to find immediately, revealing a secret place they needed to find.

Never mind that wreckage will shift and decay, so that nice map could be inaccurate even the week after it was made. The audience didn't get to participate in the mystery of the knife in the sense that there aren't breadcrumb clues for how it might work or even that these kinds of maps are a thing in Star Wars. Suddenly, the shape of the horizon matters, and the characters just do it.

Sith lore is loaded with weird, cool shit that could have been incorporated into the knife. Even the cliche lightside-darkside conflict could have been the solve. Perhaps Ray has to channel the darkside to activate the dagger. Maybe the dagger requires a sacrifice. Or it's a clue in a riddle.

Even the horizon shape idea could have worked if they went about it differently. Maybe Ray buries something early in the series, and she remembers the exact spot by tracing the horizon. And then the thing the dagger aligns with is more static, meaningful horizon.

A well-executed CG isn't easy, to give the team behind the Star Wars films a little bit of grace, but I hope that this breakdown either improves your writing process or gives you another way to enjoy your favorite stories by deepening your understanding of narrative devices.

Files

Comments

Tom Pulk

I have to ask what is the world building category of a CG? The reason I ask is 4 authors I think do this well are Terry Mancour, Jim Butcher, Martha Wells, and Carol.Berg. What I mean is they have CG's and plot peaks in their singular novels but the series as a whole builds and has an even greater payoff. I can see this in your own works to an extent.

Ezidium

I have never heard this described as the invisible reverse chekov's gun, but I love it. This is the heart of any good mystery, imo. Wake Up Dead Man nails this multiple times over.

Paul Jan

The principle of Chekov's Gun is that when an author draws attention to something, it has importance later on, or the audience has been disrespected by having their time wasted. Wake Up Dead Man is wonderful for having these to the point of becoming a more traditional mystery than the previous 2 Knives Out movies. The Rey Skywalker trilogy on the other hand, sacrifices good writing for hot visuals. It feels like they wanted given scenes and littered breadcrumbs to get people there, rather than actual puzzle pieces.

Jess

Look at those cuties!