Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Playing God 8 Charlie Foxtrot Oberyn was a wonderful entertainer. Really, he was as charismatic as I’d been led to believe. He had a thousan

Playing God 8

Charlie Foxtrot

Oberyn was a wonderful entertainer. Really, he was as charismatic as I’d been led to believe. He had a thousand and one questions for me of course, but with each question, he told me a bit more about himself in exchange.

He told me about all the places he’d been and things he’d done during his travels. He told me about a bar fight in Bravos and a pirate raid he’d helped fend off while he sailed from Essos. He told me about how he forged chains at the Citadel, which I recalled was their equivalent of a university here. A chain link was akin to a degree in a specific subject.

Most of all, he spoke of the most important women in his life. I got to see Tyene’s face flush red when he described in sordid detail exactly how he met, and seduced, her septa mother. He spoke of Obara’s fine spearmanship, of Nymeria’s love of knives, and Tyene’s quiet mastery of poisons that rivaled his own. He also told me about daughters I hadn’t known he had, eight of them in total!

Sarella, the next eldest after Tyene, had a thirst for knowledge like none of the others. Elia, eldest daughter of his current paramour, was the “Little Lance,” a young girl with a love of knights and jousting. There were also Obella, Dorea, and Loreza, who was the youngest of them all. She was only three years old.

“I hope you know that I’m not going to remember them all,” I told him truthfully. I flew along, keeping my feet just far enough off the ground to make me eye-level with the riders. After all, they hadn’t expected to need to bring a third extra horse.

My casual display of magic, and clearly unnatural tails, had yet to settle in the minds of House Martell’s guards. Many of them eyed their swords and spears warily, and it was only their liegelord’s friendliness that that reassured them.

I admired that. It could be quite hard to project an aura of safety before the unknown. Oberyn was a good leader, or at least, a well-respected one.

I could have refrained from any overt displays of magic. Ariane offered to let me ride behind her. She smirked teasingly, as if riding behind a pretty girl would be emasculating. Then again, this was Westeros; a grown man allowing a woman to ferry him like that would probably be seen as a sign of incompetence or poor education according to their sensibilities.

Instead of playing along, I chose the casual display of magic. I’d continue to do so. There was no need to hide my tails, and that also extended to my many gifts. If anything, I hoped to desensitize them via overexposure. Eventually, they’d learn to shrug and say, “Charlie’s being Charlie.”

Oberyn chuckled sheepishly. He really did have a roguish charm about him. I could see why so many women had fallen for him. “You’ll have to forgive me, my furry friend. How can I not boast with daughters as fine as my own?”

I laughed along. “Of course. Family is everything. It is good that you know what truly matters in the world.”

“Aye. We must treasure those who are nearest and dearest to us, lest time break us apart before we are ready,” he said, mood darkening. His fingers twitched towards his spear.

“How does a fox like you defend himself?” Obara asked as she urged her horse to ride alongside us. It took a moment for me to realize that she was purposely trying to change the subject, and why. “A traveler should never be unarmed, no?”

“That is true. Life can be harsh and we don’t always get to choose our battles,” I agreed.

“Yet, I see no arms on you, not unless you have a dagger hidden in those flowing robes.”

“I have my magic of course, and I am much stronger than the average man as a virtue of my race. But I am also much like you. When I must engage with a worthy foe, my preferred weapon is a spear.”

That drew her interest in earnest. “Truly? A spear? I don’t see it. Do you keep it in that not-space with your grill?”

“Yes. It is a jeweled spear, as magnificent as the heavens and as mighty as all the world put together.”

“Must be quite the spear. Next you’ll tell me it can raise the dead and turn sand into gold.”

“No, don’t be silly. I can do that without the spear.”

“Funny,” she scoffed.

“Yes, we kitsune are known for being quite clever,” I replied with a knowing smirk.

As we traveled, I wondered.

Elia. Not Elia Sand, but Elia Martell. She was Oberyn’s sister and his daughter’s namesake. She died horribly during the sacking of King’s Landing. I wasn’t clear on the details, but I knew that one of the Lannister knights, the one called the Mountain, murdered her two children before raping her to death.

I could raise her from the dead. True Resurrection was a ninth-level spell, and appropriately overpowered. Unlike lesser resurrection spells, it needed no body, merely a name and a clear idea of who I was aiming for. It could resurrect anyone at all, so long as they died in the last two hundred years, and for any reason save old age. Elia most definitely qualified.

And yet, should I?

If there was ever a way to prove my godhood to the Martells, this was it. I’d have their unquestioning loyalty. No, their eternal devotion and worship. I could build a shrine here on Doran’s dime and he’d kiss my feet for the privilege.

But I didn't want that kind of blind worship. Back when I thought I was destined for the New World, I'd decided that I didn't want to be like Momonga or the six who formed the Slane Theocracy. The politics, the constant bowing and scraping, that wasn't for me.

And yet, was my reluctance to accumulate worshipers a reason to deny Elia life? I’d already decided that I had no intention of hiding my abilities; I could always refuse worship, or if it came to that, outright smite the morons who tried to act in my name. This favor done for House Martell did not necessitate starting a cult, that was just one possible direction.

Another way of looking at it was that Elia had lived already. She wasn’t special. She wasn’t owed a second chance at life. Yes, her death was tragic, but so were the deaths of tens of thousands of others during Robert’s Rebellion, people who were younger, people who had even less agency than she had. A pretty face and a noble birth didn’t entitle her to a happy ending.

I was free, truly free, to make my own decision. Dorne could offer me nothing of true substance, certainly nothing that could be called a fitting compensation for the life of their princess.

At the same time, I wasn’t trying to hide, either. Maybe I should raise her simply because I was a good person? Wasn’t doing a good deed without expectation of appropriate compensation the meaning of charity?

We continued to make idle conversation, and soon enough, we reached Sunspear and the Shadow City beneath.

It was a spectacular sight. Twin towers stretched above a hilled city that was surrounded on three sides by the sea. One of those towers, the Tower of the Sun, was appropriately capped with a golden dome. It was from there that Doran Martell ruled. The other tower was called the Spear Tower, and was equally tall. It held highborn prisoners apparently, though the rooms were mostly unused for the moment.

Beneath the towers was the Old Palace, and nearby, the Sandship. The Sandship was the oldest structure in Sunspear, and the original keep that once housed House Martell even before Nymeria and her thousand ships of the Rhoynar sailed here.

All these buildings were wrapped by the Winding Walls. They were three, concentric walls that wound in and throughout the Shadow City. The only way to pass through the walls without traversing the dark alleys of the city was through the Threefold Gate, a straight path up to the Old Palace.

I smiled as Arianne waxed poetic about these things. The frigid air she’d adopted to spurn her uncle vanished like the morning dew as she told me about the home she so dearly loved.

I drew plenty of eyes but I didn’t mind. None of the guards dared stop Prince Oberyn and Princess Arianne. They had the looks of hotel security guards who’d decided that they weren’t paid enough to question my presence.

A thousand and one scents assaulted my nose. There were the usual smells I’d expected, shit, piss, and sweat that came from so many people and animals being crammed in one place, but also a great deal of new aromas. I smelled cumin, black pepper, cinnamon, and more. Dozens of spices and scented oils competed for my attention, no doubt wafted from the nearest bazaar.

Still, I remained with the princely party. I wasn’t quite rude enough to run off on my own to explore, no matter how my ears twitched in anticipation. I had to get down and walk; our progress slowed as we entered the Threefold Gates.

Soon, we reached the Old Palace. There, I saw a group of people waiting for the prince and princess. They were led by a man and a woman. The man was obviously a castle guard of some stripe, what with his yellow cape and steel, spear-shaped clasp.

It was the woman who drew my attention. She was on the taller side for women around these parts, with cascading waves of thick, brown locks that framed a shapely figure. She had big, brown eyes and long lashes that gave her an effortlessly seductive flair. Given the babe in her arms and young girls who followed her like ducklings, this was Ellaria Sand, Oberyn’s paramour.

“Welcome home, my love,” she said with a warm smile, so loving that I almost felt as if I was intruding just standing there. “And to you as well, princess.”

“Hello, dear sister,” Arianne responded with equal warmth. Whatever grudge she had against her father and uncle, she didn’t seem to hold any animosity for Oberyn’s lover.

I found her address a little odd and leaned towards Tyene with a whisper. “If Ellaria is Oberyn’s lover, wouldn’t ‘aunt’ be more appropriate than ‘sister?’”

The blonde leaned into me in answer. “No, it would not. ‘Aunt’ would imply that father and Ellaria are married, which holds political significance. Yet, they are close, and so ‘sister’ it must be.”

“Ah, I see. Thanks, Tyene.”

“It is no issue. I am happy to act as your guide in Sunspear.”

“And should I wish to explore the Shadow City beyond?”

“Then I will accompany you, though Nymeria might also come along. She knows the city’s back alleys better than I.”

Her elder sister, paying half an ear to our conversation, nodded. Then, one of the young girls trailing behind Ellaria bounced forward. She had a deeper tan than the others, a shade that was closer to mixed Caribbean than pure African in my old world. Her eyes glinted with a light I knew well; this one was as curious as a fox.

“Father, who is your companion?” she demanded as soon as it was polite. “Are those ears real? And the tails! He must be a famous mummer.”

Oberyn released his paramour and nodded. He gestured to one of the guards. “You, grab bread and salt for my guest. And he is no mummer, daughter-mine. This is Charlie Foxtrot, self-professed fluffiest fox in the world.”

“I dare not doubt him then,” she said with a giggle. She looked at me with searching eyes. “Tell me, are those real? Do you have four ears or just two? And how do you find room to attach nine tails to your rear?”

“You’re a curious one,” I chuckled. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw another little girl circle around. Her eyes were locked onto my tails like a cat chasing a toy bird. “In order: Yes. Two. Magic.”

“Magic? Really?”

I pulled out a carrot from my inventory and fed the nearest sand steed. “Of course not. Don’t be silly, child. There is no such thing as magic.”

“You just made a carrot.”

“It’s just a trick of course, a masterful sleight of hand. I merely pulled it from my pocket.”

“Mhmm… I’m watching you,” she muttered, her nose scrunched up in an adorable frown. I resisted the urge to pat her head, but only just.

“I have heard many learned men say that magic is for fools and charlatans. Everything in this world has a logical explanation.”

“That’s not what you told me last night,” Arianne said with a snort of laughter.

“It is not,” I nodded. The young girl, about ten or eleven, was closer, nearly ready to pounce. I swayed my tails even more, tempting her onward. “I always said that there is a difference between intelligence and wisdom. And formal learning, despite popular misconceptions to the contrary, is proof of neither.”

“Oh? So how do you distinguish the two?”

“Intelligence is knowing that foxes are fluffy, and that this fox has nine tails,” I said. My tails lashed out, wrapping the little girl in a cocoon of floof. I drew her to me and began to tickle her. “Wisdom is knowing better than to try to ambush one.”

“Hehehe! Haha! Stop!” she squealed as she squirmed in my tails. She was cute, in that gangly way that all children were. Judging by her facial features, she was the eldest daughter of Ellaria, which made her Elia, the Little Lance I’d heard so much about.

“Hello, little one. You are too young yet to hunt as mighty a beast as I. Sharpen your lance, and perhaps you will not suffer this indignity in the future.”

“I don’t have a lance,” she pouted. “Father won’t give me one.”

“I gave you one,” Oberyn said with an exasperated, but fond smile.

“It wasn’t real.”

“You’re too short for a real lance, Elia.”

“Am not. I totally would have got him if I had a lance.”

I chuckled as I bounced her around on my tails. “You know, I could give you a lance.”

“Really?”

“Not until she can mount a horse without help,” Obara said.

We were interrupted by the returning soldier. He had a plate with a loaf of bread and some coarse salt. He first presented it to Oberyn with a respectful bow.

Oberyn tore off a chunk and dipped it in the salt before handing it to me. In a formal voice, he said, “I bid you welcome and offer you guest right so long as you mean me and mine no ill will, Charlie Foxtrot.”

I nodded in thanks and did likewise. The bread was coarse and hard, though I supposed it had its own, rustic charm. “I accept your hospitality and promise not to harm any of your people unless I am slighted first… Did I say that right? Is that what I’m supposed to say?”

“Do you not observe guest right where you’re from?” Oberyn asked curiously.

“Not in this exact way, no. We don’t have a ritualized format like this, but it’s understood that providing hospitality to guests and travelers is considered a sacred task.”

And, it was. Greeks called it “xenia,” and considered it a divine obligation to provide travelers with a meal, bed, and bath. Or at least a bowl of water to wash their feet with. The Jews had something similar. It was the “for some have entertained angels unawares” part of the Torah that bled into Christianity and Islam as well.

In Japan, we had “omotenashi,” which was meant to conceptualize a deep, wholehearted care for guests. Though it didn’t have a singular religious origin, it was a deeply rooted part of my home’s culture.

After a bit more smalltalk in which I was introduced to the rest of Oberyn’s brood, I was finally welcomed into the Old Palace proper. Now that I stood at the base of the Tower of the Sun, I estimated its height to be about a hundred and fifty feet, give or take a dozen.

“Impressive, isn’t it?” Arianne said smugly as we began our climb. “The Spear and Sun Towers are the first sights anyone sees of my home, be it from land or sea.”

“I pity the servants who have to climb it multiple times a day,” I replied dryly.

“It is their job, and they are compensated richly. Besides, father does not rule from the throne room these days.”

“He doesn’t? Why are we going up there?”

“He only sits on the Spear Throne when he welcomes important figures. He undoubtedly received word of your magic by now.”

“Then I should feel honored.”

“Indeed. You will be the first in months to see him seated there. Usually, he receives visitors from his solar, or the great hall at the base of the tower,”she said, somewhat bitterly.

Next to us, Oberyn eyed his niece with pursed lips but said nothing. I gathered that this was a power play on Doran's part. It was like when my old superiors made me wait at the company I used to work at. “My time is more valuable than yours. If you want to talk; you come to me.”

And here was Arianne, ruining her father’s power plays. No doubt that she knew exactly what she was doing. She was getting a few jabs in while she could before she got put under house arrest. 

Then, I remembered. “Arianne, doesn’t your father have gout?”

“He does. It is why he does not rule from the throne room often anymore.”

“Then how did he get up here?”

“Areo Hotah, father’s captain of the guard, likely carried him up while we were talking.”

“Ah, I see. I suppose appearances are important.”

Author’s Note

So, should he? Should Elia come back? Keep in mind that this isn’t a “waifu poll.” I”m not asking if Charlie should dick down Elia Martell. That’ll be a separate matter entirely, if it comes up at all.

Arianne calls Ellaria “my dear sister” in the books.

Animal Fact: Foxes typically have eight nipples. However, this differs widely between species. For example, Arctic foxes have sixteen while gray foxes have six.

And, as per usual, the nipple-to-litter-size rule applies. On average, mammals give birth to half the number of pups as the number of nipples they have. A gray fox averages around 3-5 pups per litter. Red foxes average around 4-6.

However, Arctic foxes are a bit odd. Alaska Fish & Game says they average around 7 pups, but I’ve also read 11. Apparently, they can give birth to a maximum of 22 pups on occasion, which would probably be a death sentence for both the mother and entire litter.

And now you know more about fox nipples than you ever wanted to.

Comments

Monzter E

More moral questions... but I need more to be satisfied

Demitas

I feel like Christmas has come early getting another chapter of this so soon

AlphariusOmegonXX

It’s a shame this isn’t a regular story, I love Overlord and Asoiaf, so the combination is delightful

RandomAsian

Having Elia Martell back would help ground Oberyn and Doran. Especially since both of them are being idiots at this point in the story. Not to mention Arianne could benefit from having a positive female role model.

Awdyr Storm

Of course he should. Imagine the chaos! The reactions! This is a trickster god we're dealing with here!

Dumbjoker

Bringing back Elia is unimportant. Same as bringing back someone else. Generally you should stick to bringing back people you are responsible for or have a use for. Otherwise bring back as a payment to others, as a favor, or as 'one per person' kind of deal. If you raise people who shouldnt have died, youll be there forever.

Zerak

Old Arab customs were that when a traveler comes, you don’t ask them about their business there till you have hosted them for 3 days (of course there are exceptions but if not urgent that’s the custom). Hospitality was a very big thing, it was something they use to compete on. I vote he brings her back. Because why not.

Jos Mar

Yeah rez her. I completely and utterly disagree with the notion that resurrecting someone attaches some sort of responsibility to you. Like, who made that stupid rule? He's—as far as I can tell—chaotic good, so let him do good if he wants to do good! They have nothing he wants, however, he doesn't NEED anything either. It really grinds my gears. Every character in every piece of fiction with the power to resurrect people goes on this moralistic, introspective mental journey and then uses this power for fuck all. Use it!.... Sorry for venting.

Sumgai101

If you do bring her back, make it the trolliest option possible. Point behind your onlookers, go "who's that". Then boop, one ex axed princess. No explanation whatsoever, because you've already run off.

Ian

I think he should but only when he’s leaving. Specifically as a sort of “this is not a debt to me, this is not because I demand worship, this is because I had a nice time staying at your house, now have your dead sister back,” type thing. If he does it at all before then, I think it’s going to cause him problems and I like the idea of a trickster god who just leaves others to deal with his chaos.

Dumbjoker

Before you do anything major, I should remind you that the Yellow King sleeps beneath Carcosa

Definitely not a racoon

Hmm...Could be interesting to bring her back if Doran or Oberyn try to play the dead sister card

Temp Email

Lol, the first thing that’s gonna happen if he resurrects Elia is Elia asking for her children to be resurrected.

ha vu

Well...sure he can and should bring her back...he is a god after all. He doesn't need to do anything but also does if he wants to test his power of resurrection...maybe he should. Elia is politically safer than her children. Could tell everyone that this is a fraud but Doran and Oberyn are too sad to care about that

Dr.Dragon

Resurrecting her is going to be an issue if he also ressurects her children. Doing so could (and with Robert and Tywin alive would) set off a war (even if accidently ruining Varys' Blackfyre plan would be hilarious), not doing so would be cruel, if she is with them in whatever passes for Heaven in Westeros. If Charlie has a spell that lets him to talk to her, he could see if she wanted to be ressurected. If not, he could set the spell up in a room for Oberyn and Doran and let them say their goodbyes properly and privately.

Enthessi

I think he should revive Elia and Rheanys at the least, besides he’s basically a god so why would he care about the ramifications of his actions? Plus the goodwill he could gain would make Sunspear a place he could drop of at on occasion just to visit. If he really cared about how his actions would look then he likely would have been more careful in regards to how he treated Louise during his earlier jump. Basically? Do it lol.

Nicolae

seeing how you pointed that out: so what type of fox is MC: 2,4,6,8,10,12,14,16 ?

Geemot

I adore all your work but Playing God really scratches the whimsy in me. Would love to see more if possible!

Ravioli Stromboli

Got some inspiration for this one have you? Neat. Honestly this character gives me SI vibes so honestly do what you would do. Resurrect her? Sure. Don’t resurrect her? Sure. Wont change much in the long run if this story is going to be a world hopping one.

Tiz Goldeye

So the problem with ressurection is you start to get into the moral and ethical dilemma's around Spider-Man, Superman, and Pancrea about what to do with the power you have, if you should use it, how you should use it, when you should use it, and why you should use it. It is generally considered morally correct to administer medical treatment to the dying. So if you have magic to ressurect the dead from injuries or disease so they can live the rest of their lives before natural age claims them, shouldn't they receive this medical treatment from a moral perspective? The problem arises that once you have ressurected someone you need to create a justification for why you aren't ressurecting everyone as part of a higher moral good. Most realistically, the problem comes down to yourself being the source of this ressurection and the fact that you can not be everywhere an once, always, to save everyone. However, even trying to save the people you can leads to burn out and guilt in trying to save the world through your actions. A better way to handle things is to create a society, network, or automated way of ressurecting people as without a single failure point the need to solve death doesn't fall solely on you. However, as more people gain the ability to come back from death society might be unable to adapt which can create more issues. In the limited understanding of what to do with a singular character who can control ressurection I would limit when they do so to two cases. First, in times of great crisis. If there is a heroic figure who can demonstrably effect the world by curing an uncurable disease, defeating an invincible monster, calming a natural diaster about to wipe out all life, beating an alien invasion etc. then it's worth bringing them back to save everyone. Second, as a reward to another for a incalculable selfless service, preferably that you can verify was selfless with magic. In this case if someone has noticeably helped the world without asking anything in turn but lost someone along the way, it might be worth it to make your own karma. Alternatively, in a more personal view to that character with ressurection, a person who either without knowledge of the character's ability to perform ressurections or without expectation of reward earnestly offers companionship. For someone who enhances another's life though the joys of friendship freely offered it may be worth it to enchance their life in turn. After many years of friendship, and swearing them to secrecy (since they are neither a notable war asset or a selfless person who helped the earth people would have reason to question why someone was ressurected for them) ask them if there is anyone in their life if they want ressurected.

CrackCocaineDemon

I think he should resurrect her. But set a „Limit“ or Price if they want more magic. If elias back he‘d definitely have an easy stay in sunspear.

Anbhas

Oh I loved seeing a second update of Playing God so quickly. It has a fun lightness which contrasts with the severe setting so well. Hmm...Elia being brought back to life would complicate a huge number of things. Also...would she resurrect with the full memories of exactly how she died...because that would be deeply traumatic, and unless Charlie also resurrects her children too it would be doubly cruel to bring back a mother but not her children. Her death at the hands of the mountain and after seeing her children killed...perhaps better to let her rest in peace. Likewise, Charlie would be opening a huge can of worms because Elia would be a further political threat to the current Baratheon crown, and her kids would be potential rivals for the throne too if resurrected. Essentially their resurrection would throw more gasoline on the tinderbox of explosives which is Westeros under Robert. Also, once Charlie publicly resurrects one person, he would inevitably be inundated with others asking for their relatives to be given a second chance, from the lowliest servant to other nobles like Tywin trying to find leverage or a price to see his wife resurrected. Yeah..that would be a headache of political and emotional baggage. all around. If Charlie really likes Oberyon and the Martells then healing Doran's gout and helping Oberyon avenge Elia by killing the mountain (maybe even helping covertly assassinate Tywin) without it costing him his life would be less problematic boons he could offer.

Menthewarp

I second this analysis. At minimum, speak with the dead spirit in private. Otherwise, reserve the action only for those you humanly care for.

Menthewarp

Suggested shenanigans: install a magical elevator platform, have the king ride it down, THEN heal his gout and arthiritis.

Lictor Magnus

Even if he did bring her back ideally it would be with some form of memory wipe of the last hour or so of her life. She’d be heavily traumatized from seeing her children die and being raped before her death.

Prognostic Hannya

No, I don't think he should bring Elia back. It would derail the story from fun, light-hearted shennanigans as every single person he would meet from then-on would beg him on hand and knee to bring someone back.

swishmcfish

Bringing her back without her kids would be cruel, and raising her kids would ignite a war. Better to just heal Doran's Gout, that's already a miracle to repay them for their hospitality, and tell him to stop drinking Lead-Sweetened Wine so that he won't get it back. Also, resurrecting someone might get the attention of the other LOVECRAFTIAN entities in the setting, like the Yellow King in Carcarossa or Rhollor or the Great Other or The Drowned God, The Black Goat with a Thousand Young, who might follow after you in your world hopping, would spoil your trip.

arsha

No she should not

Son-Of-Scorn

I think Charlie looks to deeply into the whys and shoulds, if he wants to do it then do it, if he doesn't then don't, that's all he really needs to think about, but once he's made his decision he should stick by it, if he brings back Elia and her children (which i think he should) them I think he should also make sure that they're not gonna start a war but then again Robert Baratheon isn't gonna live that long anyway and a massive war comes after his death so maybe it'd be better if Charlie just had them hide until Roberts death and then have them join the new war as a the targ faction, should be easy for Charlie to help put them on the throne if he wants

ArtHunt

I think that's an issue all Oc/Si’s face. They become too introspective and often go multiple chapters considering how their actions will affect the future rather than actually doing anything. It makes sense because it benefits your protagonist to change the future as little as possible so that they still know what's gonna happen and there's a chance your audience won't know the setting or all the details of the story the MC is in, but it's really infuriating and slow if you do know the story. I'm starting to see it in a lot of the stories I read but I'm not sure what the answer to it is.

Son-Of-Scorn

Most of the time it resolves itself quickly but some times It drags like a bitch so yeah I get you 100%, the only real way to try and resolve it is leave comments that highlight the issue and authors should hopefully take the hint

Joan Casado

This is the only correct answer. Forget about what is considered right or wrong. He’s the closest thing Westeros has to a physical god who’s also a Trickster. In the great words of a dick obsessed, hyperactive blue horned prankster - “Let chaos reign.”

X Blade

Do it do it do it. Also please heal Doran and educate him on gout

Maglad

Iirc overlord is super heavily based on d&d. If you don’t tesurrect her, at least giftthem a tool with unlimited speak with the dead, keyed to her alone.

geogio13

I think ot should be brought up, but with the knowledge of what the costs are. True Resurrection costs: a diamond worth 25,000 gold, several hours continuous casting for the ritual, and most importantly the soul's willing return. I feel like they should know that Elia would have to come back with the full knowledge and experience of her death without the softening that the afterlife provides. They would basically force her to relive the last moments of her life.

UncrownedKing

He should live with no regrets. That's all. If he think he'll regret not reviving her then he should do it. If it's just a passing thought and not one he truly cares about then leave it be. I don't believe in the saying that if you have the power you should use it, but I do think if you have power you should use it as you please.

Shadow king

Honestly if you want help to decide this put it you as a poll but don't let that result decide for you. Have a poll so you can see where the majority sides and see the argument for and against it.

Bring

I think he should resurrect her what’s the point of going to these worlds if not to either A fuck with them and B do whatever you want

Grimm

while i think it would fit his current character to resurrect her for the heck of it, i also don't see it going too well. after all, her last memory before death wasn't exactly pleasant, and she would just start begging for her children to also be resurrected.

Hi Hi

Does Charlie know about those entities? I thought he only watched the first few episodes to not spoil much.