Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Four Shows Enter. One Show Leaves

  • Atlas 164
  • Bestiary 43
  • Audio Log 72
  • Debates 134
  • 2018-05-22
  • —2018-06-08
  • 413 votes
{'title': 'Four Shows Enter. One Show Leaves', 'choices': [{'text': 'Atlas', 'votes': 164}, {'text': 'Bestiary', 'votes': 43}, {'text': 'Audio Log', 'votes': 72}, {'text': 'Debates', 'votes': 134}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2018, 6, 8, 19, 1, 47, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2018, 5, 22, 19, 49, 18, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 413}

Content

The time has arrived! We hoped you enjoyed our week of pilots, now you must choose... but choose wisely! 

Comments

Felix Argyle

But can I not just vote for all four? xD

Philip Wurzinger

Debates because discussing controversial topics improves society in general.

Stephanie McAlea

As a professional cartographer I'm a little biased :)

Chris Whittington

I did not vote for debates because I feel bad for Marc and didn't want to see Larissa stomp him every episode

Kamendachi

I rather enjoyed Debates. I liked hearing both sides discuss the pros and cons of their own argument as well as their opponents.

Amigo1016

Debates is a nice change of pace. Makes light of the good and the bad in a sci-fi favorite without being biased to either side. Both raised excellent points.

NukeDuke'm

When you realize percentage dropped for Marc :c

Kairon R Woulfgang

I kinda like the idea of a Bestiary but that's only because I'm currently working on that in my own world. Atlas would have been my 2nd choice but I think I'm going to vote for Debates because it's uncommon for YouTube videos to share multiple points of view on a topic.

45 Eugenia

I voted for debates because they could finally settle whether or not Magnus did anything wrong

Veyktor

Debates are AWESOME !!! (can't wait to argue for hours with other multiverse experts :D )

Marco Kloek

I found debates to be very limited. I am going for atlas this time. But audio made a close second.

Alain Vollant

I'm going for Atlas... but I've noticed you've skip the Overview of the last pole...Are you giving up that motion?

lilLambie

While I like Debates, I feel like it's too fast paced of a video but do remember we will ( probably ) get another opportunity to vote. My vote goes to Atlas because of the idea of maybe explaining capitals and major cities, plus we can see castles and forts. ( demonstrated in the last poll with Skavenblight.)

OnboardG1

Debates was great, but as I said on my YouTube comment I think you need to change the format to something closer to US Varsity Debating to generate proper clash between the two debaters. So you have a two minute opening statement and then a minute of cross examination each to rebut the other's argument, then a summary with opp getting the last word.

Pasglop

I personnaly support Audio Log, as it will allow to expand to other universes that cannot be done in normal format (In fact, Manticore was my dream episode for this). That being said, none of the choices would disappoint me!

Peter T

Audiologs has so much potential it snot even funny, i´d like to see more of it.

Dejanus

I am posting this with one arm, as the other half of my body has completely Salinized after Marc's repeated assaults on glorious Battletech. Vote Audio Log.

Codex

If the poll ends up being tied (or nearly tied), will you be holding a second poll with only the top answers? Since Atlas and Debate are so close right now, it seems like one might end winning by only a few votes, which may not be the best way to decide which series stays and which ones don't.

The Templin Institute

We do have a bit of a backup plan in case of a tie or near tie. We'll be in communication with everyone here on Patreon though to make sure people are okay with it.

VonJerch

"The Templin Institute investigates alternate worlds and realities". Don't let Debates win because it doesn't follow the Institute's moto. The Templin Institute shouldn't be a place of argument but a place for seeking knowledge and learning every detail.

Kan Tun

I was originally going to go for the ATLAS but then when I heard the Debate, decided that this was the way to go.

Patron

Debates are fundamentally a form of investigation. Only through thoughtful discourse do truths that are not simply obvious get found. In many cases, a discussion or debate can lead to conclusions and understanding beyond just the obvious information.

Codex

Thanks for your reply! I'm glad to know that you guys have a decent system for this.

Andy

my personal favorite is the bestiary but debates is a close second because its very interactive in a fun and easy to do way so it gets my vote

Soundwave119

I do like all these pilots but my favorite is Audio Log since they covered Star Kingdom of Manticore from the Honor Harrington book series written mainly by David Weber. The book series is a space opera, in many was its similar to the "The Expanse," in that how people travel and fight in space is made to be as realistic as possible and with 2000 years of technological advancement. I would like audio log to win but if it doesn't win that's OK.

Marky6

I'm going to go for Audio Log, just because I feel it's the closest to what I like about this channel, explaining the background lore and history of various universes. Atlas and Bestiary kind of fall into the trap of being mostly lore exposition anyway; half the Bestiary episode was about setting up the world, not the actual creatures; Atlas was better in that regard, but possibly only because it was based in Star Wars, so no world introduction necessary; Dossier kind of has the same issue as well. As for Debates, I think it could be interesting, but the pilot was kind of boring, I think the format could use some more work, maybe have more rounds of point-counterpoint, instead of just one long segment for each side.

Joshua

I was perfectly happy with the debates as is but they should at least have cross examination and rebuttal.

jordan kester

I think debates is the most interesting, and I look forward to more.

Curtis Shea

Yep debates all the way, though I have to agree with more rounds of point-counterpoint.

Jean-Luc Loiselle

If you pick debates, then your altering the institutes motto and objective. You all should un suscribe if you go with that

Christopher Kennedy

It is so hard to choose between these pilots cause there are a ton of future videos I want from each series. Just a handful of ideas (really just my wish list) Overview: The world of Avatar the Last Airbender Atlas: Asgard from the MCU Audio Log: The Race from Henry Turtledove's WorldWar Series Debates: Should the Wizarding Community from Harry Potter have stayed in hiding and/or the benefits of if they had revealed themselves (but the good guys not like how Grindelwald or Voldomort wanted to reveal themselves)

Andy

I don't think that's how this works buddy. The Institute made the debates topic themselves so obviously they're okay making videos in that style. Even more than that, Debates is a great way to show off how the two hosts can play off each other as well leading to interesting discussions and amazing audience participation.

Christopher Kennedy

Just a couple more ideas (and then I promise Im done) Overview: Fables Comics and Fabletown Atlas: Isla de Muerta from Pirates of the Caribbean Audio Log: Republic of America from the Legend/Prodigy/ Champion Trilogy Debates: The idea of superhero/superhuman registration which is apparently all the rage Other ideas Id love to suggest include a Dossier about Indiana Jones and Templin videos for the Assassins Brotherhood and Paradis/Walled City from Attack on Titan perhaps. These are obviously a lot of requests but my point still stands that it is hard to choose between your pilots because they all hold so many great ideas for vides. (OK I didn't suggest anything for Bestiary but I just like to be surprised for those). Anyway may the best one win this poll and hopefully they all get made someday. Keep voting everyone.

GhostReaper

I would go for debates because it provides a nice change of pace and allows the audience to be much more involved in the action.