Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Should the Greater Terran Union reform it's governing ethics? | Stellaris Invicta

  • Xenophobia is outdated. We don’t have to love the alien, but we need no longer fear it. 225
  • Remember the Tyrum! Xenophobia saved the Union, it must be preserved. 70
  • 2018-09-26
  • —2018-09-29
  • 295 votes
{'title': "Should the Greater Terran Union reform it's governing ethics? | Stellaris Invicta", 'choices': [{'text': 'Xenophobia is outdated. We don’t have to love the alien, but we need no longer fear it. ', 'votes': 225}, {'text': 'Remember the Tyrum! Xenophobia saved the Union, it must be preserved.', 'votes': 70}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2018, 9, 29, 20, 0, 35, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2018, 9, 26, 20, 15, 40, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 295}

Content

The integration and acceptance of the Wessari has challenged some of the oldest values of the Greater Terran Union, entire generations have enjoyed lives free from the fear, struggle and hatred that the Union was founded upon. While the recent wars against the Compact have proven that humanity must be ready to defend itself, the overarching xenophobia espoused by Union propaganda has grown less effective. The Wessari have proven that not all alien races are inherently hostile while the oppression of our former allies in the United Clans of Skiron has been widely protested.  Perhaps most importantly, if the Greater Terran Union is to ever cross the vast expanse of the galaxy and bring war to the Tyrum, it may be forced to make common cause with other alien empires. The Marshalls have begun to question if the GTU’s xenophobic policies are still required. 

Should the GTU shift its governing ethics away from xenophobia?  

Files

Comments

Zion Lighty

As long as a Xeno never becomes a Marshall or High Marshall (like those filthy Algans allowed), then I support this decision of lessening our outward projection of xenophobia.

Solus Ignis

We can give the xenos Residency (or caste system residency) instead of Full Citizenship, but explicit xenophobia only gets in the way of building alliances against the vile Tyrum.

Zion Lighty

Then next time the election for a new High Marshall comes around, the observers "guide" the vote towards a Human High Marshall.

Benjamin Sharman

Do not be swayed, the Xeno are not to be trusted, but this extends only to those outside our People, the Wassari have proven honorable allies and trusted members of the Union, one day other Xenos may learn the same but the GTU no longer needs to fear them, certainly not the loyal them

Bouncyrou

I think that we should get rid of xenophobia, bump Humans up to Social Welfare, and give the Wessari Full Citizenship. The Wessari have served the Union loyally, and should be treated as such!

Kyle Limb

If we do not learn from the past we are doomed to repeat it. If we continue on the path of hatred how long until we tread on a younger race and end up like those who violated our society....

Alberich

We need to first suppress the xenophobic faction before promoting another faction.

Jack Maitland

My recommendation is to go with materialism as the replacement. It fits with the hyper efficiency of the Union plus a research boost is always good!

Dejanus

This is foolish. Vote for a more boring Union, guess. Moralism ruins everything.

Ariobesar

GTU is more a meritrocracy than some xenophobe country right. So, just use those alien race to fight those against the GTU. Better fight with one mind and goal rather for some nonsense xenophobe. Well, this is union, the Greater Terran Union.

Izaac Robins

man the stellaris invicta discord is a warzone ATM. But I like the the idea of being less xenophobic I think its a great story and one not often told in sci-fi, or anywhere

Zion Lighty

I trust the Man "Behind the curtain" and The Voice of the Institute (mostly the latter one) will keep a close eye on that.

Sash13

Xenophobia surelly helped us before, but its time to change, it is not said we have to love alien, but as a meritocratic society, we should reward the worthy. Instead of xenophobia, we should focus more on materialism or military.

Iain Howe

Perhaps it is right to cling to meritocracy but wrong to punish those like the Wessari that have proven to have merit? The Greater Terran Union is dead. Long live the Greater Terran State.

Paul Goodridge

We will not wast talent even from a xenos. Let the military gorw in might. For are unity will be in are aremed forcese.

Adolfus Angelbert

The universe is humanitys property by birthright, and it's only theirs. Xeno races will only cause instability.

Paul Goodridge

I may be human first but I am not willing to wast talent when it is there. they don't need to be able to be leaders but advisers are ok with me, begugenly.

Fergus

LADIES AND GENTLEMEN OF THE PARLIAMENT. WE MUST NOT FORGET OUR ROOTS. OUR SUBJECT SPECIES ARE NOTHING BUT A DAGGER WAITING IN OUR BACK.

Paul Goodridge

As Charles Darwin said himself it's not the strongest that survive it's the most adaptable.

Malik Julius Aaju Sandgreen

I as a new member came as fast as i could when i saw this message... And i say that this delusional 40K minority is going too far. But i do like their sarcastic xeno jokes i believe that the actions demanded by the 40K fans (i myself a recent one) has gone too far.. We must send a clear message. Xenoes are to be given a chance. And any who protests is going against the sacred constitution of the Greater Terran Union and the High Marshal. Therefore revoke shower priviliege for such offence... or execution

Dallas Reinhart

"It is time to move on. Xenophobia made sense in the days of our grandparents and great grandparents, but now we are losing opportunities because of our protectionist stance against the alien. If we expect a measure of prosperity in this new environment of galactic nations we must learn to do business with them. Yes! With enough open trade of our goods and the prosperity that comes with it we may someday have no need for the rationing of resources that has been a hindrance to our quality of life for generations! And for that we have to drop these antiquated attitudes. We must get more involved in galactic affairs. Set up trade partnerships with prosperous nation states. Establish diplomatic channels so we have the means to maintain links with other species and avert diplomatic disaster when necessary. And of course maintain our Navy not only to protect our wonderful union... but to become an instrument of peace, justice and order in the galaxy, not just for humans but for all. At first we were like abused children, lashing out violently at the first provocation of our enemies. Now, we are seeing a much larger universe, not one that presents threats from all corners. We've proven that we can handle any threat to our existence. What we haven't proven is the ability to co-exist with those who are no threat to us. Without allies we may never know what secrets the universe has to offer, what opportunities will present themselves, and what sympathy and sanction we may garner when a true threat comes our way. The fact is to exist we must co-exist, or risk being crushed under the weight of the universe. If we die out due to isolation or due to enemies beset on all sides due to our blind arrogance and unwillingness to reach out a hand of friendship... what then of the injustices done to us yet unpaid? What then of the Tyrum? Because our end game is to defeat the ancient enemy, the Tyrum, to see justice done. This cannot happen if we have an entire universe set against us." -Marshall Dallas Reinhart, Canadian Commissariat, Earth, Greater Terran Union

Someone Named Tygget

It’s the Greater TERRAN Union, not the Greater Xeno Union! Our self-reliance was what made this nation great! Without hardship and conflict, we will grow weak and complacent! The Union was made to see Humanity’s rights and power spread across the universe, xenos will always hold us back!

Kan Tun

From a purely practical standpoint, more targets in the field means less chance that you'll get hit. Might get betrayed at a later date but the old foe is our enemy now.

Project-Unity

You can never stop progress, you might delay it but xenophobia is the concept of the old. Humanity and Wessari alike would prosper among the stars together! For our Union!

Matthew Kwaske

Hatred of the alien without merit is fear, and fear is for the weak. We have outgrown such weakness, let the Tyrum fear us. If the alien stands against us, then let him feel our wrath, but if he stands with us, then as the warriors of our ancient past once professed, "For whomever sheds his blood with me shall be my brother."

Paul Goodridge

I'm not saying fully trust the xenos. by all means treat them as suspicions but the wasary have been propagandized enough to fully believe and the Terran Union. If we continue to hold aliens out the more and more enemies we have if we can make some alliances with them, be it short term, we could divide and conquer.

reptile937

we should get rid of xenophobia and become fanatic militarist, don't go for materialist in the lore this would mean the GTU supression of all remainig human and xenos religion, and in the game it would mean that the GTU cannot exploit psionic technology, the GTU is ready to use any means to claim victory on the battlefield, they already use godzilla like creatures it would natural that they would be ready to deploy Psionic Army on the field and maybe if possible a psionic avatar

ryteu

As far as I have seen, the Xenos we have subjugated have content and productive members of the Union - there are Wasari who have even fought and died for it. We should be ever vigilant in the face of the past, but can no longer afford to shun those who mean us no ill will. Who knows what our alien citizens truly have to offer?

JC

Xenophobic policies are outdated, but ought not be tossed out completely. The process of integrating alien species in to a functioning human society is an ambitious project, and will take time. As time passes, and as new species are taken under the Union's wing, integration policies can be improved upon, and expanded. All good things take time. I advise taking the time to ensure that all considerations are dealt with and all necessities are met. Long live our glorious Union!

Daniel Bouchie

Foolish hatred of man's own skin divided us and saw the worst acts of barbarity be conducted. Though the xeno are not human they are children of this galaxy and the universe just as we are. The Greater Terran Union should seek to enlighten all those it can. For if we can not learn to educate others, if we can not focus our hatred, if we can not admit that our blatant hatred for all Xeno cripples us then we are doomed. Hypocrisy comes to mind when we protest the oppression of our old allies, now enduring the unendurable. We must join hands with other children of the galaxy or be swallowed by its numbers and devices alone. The Wessari and other Xeno refugees are proof that our nations creed of unity crosses race. Let us take this Union further and at last secure the Union for All.

Zoldy

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the parliament, I beseech you to hear my words. We are gathered here today to discuss our governments justified distrust of the vile xeno. There are those among us, certain naive individuals, who believe that the xeno is anything less than a verminous plague upon the galaxy, worthy of only extermination and subjugation. I ask you this! Have we forgotten Tyrum? The tragedy of the Algans? The countless human lives lost every day in the void of space? Lost in fighting on dozens of worlds? Are we to forget their sacrifice, to let them and what they fought for wilt away in favour of some wide eyed idealists fanciful interpretation of the universe? The universe has never once shown us an ounce of mercy. Never once has it given us a second chance, a moment to breathe. Every achievement of our great nation has been clawed with blood, fire and steel from the unwilling clutches of a cruel and unforgiving galaxy. If we expose our backs to these xenos, let me assure you that we will soon enough find another dagger in our backs! I then ask you this! Will we turn our backs? WILL WE?!" -MP Fergus

AvengerMKII

The GTU principle is based on pragmatism. Why not take advantage of a potential resource against a common enemy? The Wassari might have a unique perspective on the GTU's military doctrine.

Dallas Reinhart

"I must side with the honorable Marshall Bouchie in this great debate and oppose the honorable Marshall Fergus. We all know the our position in the universe. We all know the dangers xenos can present. But we know good allies, the Wassari, whom have fought by our side. We know of the primitive species whom now we uplift and eagerly await their debut on the galactic stage. We know the protectorates whom have found freedom from the Algan republic. And we know the Skyron, whom have betrayed our trust by using us as a sword for their own personal ends. We know the Khan hordes whom exhausted themselves conquering our rivals to the south. Lastly there is the Tyrum, the great enemy on the other side of the galaxy, awaiting our retribution. WE KNOW WHAT MAKES AN ALLY AND AN ENEMY! And if we follow the example of Marshall Fergus by quivering in fear of the unknown, we will only show the universe that we are still children, uncertain and lacking confidence in our own better judgement! So I say again. We know what makes an enemy. We know what makes an ally. Lets prove to the universe we have the confidence and wisdom to know which is which, and act accordingly." -Marshall Dallas Reinhart, Canadian Commissariat, Earth, Greater Terran Union