Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

What should be done with the Sword of Terra?

  • Decommission the Sword of Terra 97
  • Retain the Sword of Terra 150
  • 2019-01-30
  • —2019-02-02
  • 247 votes
{'title': 'What should be done with the Sword of Terra?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Decommission the Sword of Terra', 'votes': 97}, {'text': 'Retain the Sword of Terra', 'votes': 150}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2019, 2, 2, 21, 57, 36, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2019, 1, 30, 22, 38, 58, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 247}

Content

The unsustainable losses in both men and materiel incurred against the nations of the Stellar Axis have left the Greater Terran Union in a perilous situation. With the economy and national reserves still recovering from the AI rebellions, it is unlikely that we can expect to regain the momentum in this conflict within the next few years.   With foreign interstellar opinion widely opposed to the actions of the Greater Terran Union and generally favorable to the Stellar Axis, it is critical that no other nations enter the war against us. Therefore, a proposal has been submitted to the National Council, suggesting that the Sword of Terra be decommissioned. The arguments are as follows:   

Decommission the Sword of Terra: With the Tyrum destroyed, the Sword of Terra has fulfilled its purpose. By retaining this weapon, we only incite fear and hatred in foreign powers who might otherwise be potential allies. Dismantling it would be a vital first step in normalizing foreign relations and preventing currently neutral nations from joining the war against us.   

Retain the Sword of Terra: With the very survival of the Greater Terran Union in doubt, the necessity of the Sword of Terra is higher than ever. There is no certainty that among the powers with which we are currently at war, there is not a weapon of similar destructive power. By keeping the Sword of Terra fully operational, we ensure that we can immediately respond in kind. To dismantle it would be a display of weakness which we currently can ill afford.

Files

Comments

lanceblazer18

I say dissmantle it our forces are strong enough to take any hostile planets and be a wast to distroy a planet if it has resorses on it. The gtu don't need big guns to win but we do need the power to keep the army up

Ethan Naftalin

The Sword of Terra has served its purpose. Yet its creation threatens our own survival. As long as it is still an active part of the GTU Navy, foreign powers that might be allies, or at the very least trade partners, will be turned away knowing humans are willing to create and use a creation meant only for the annihilation of billions of beings. I therefore place my support in the decommissioning of The Sword of Terra.

JohnnyElRojo

The damage is already done. Even if we decommissioned the Sword of Terra now, our foreign relations and exterior image have already been damaged beyond repair. We can only defend ourselves, and keep our word about its use. Right now, is our only bargaining chip against other nations that might be thinking about attacking us, but that remain too fearful of the weapon and the memory of Byrum to do so. Get rid of it, and we expose ourselves even more.

Xentus

To whom much is given, much is expected. It is clear that the responsibility such power places on a nation is too much for it to bear. If there were another SoT out there, then allying with it's owner would be wise. But as we are the only ones, the rest of the galaxy will turn against us. From there it simple math. When there is one clear and present danger, old enemies become convenient allies. To quote Tolkien "To bear a ring of power is to be alone."

Vandiyan

"There is no shame in deterrence. Having a weapon is very different from actually using it." - Gandhi: Civ6

Ariobesar

Like Grand Admiral Thrawn strategy. Why do you need such big weapon which hard to maintain? With such resources, you could build another battlegroup or fleets to maintain your borders and devour your enemy. Such weapon still could be destroy by hundreds of ships. If you have thousand ships with great firepower, who will brave enough to attack you?

DimirtisTaramas

Let me give you a lesson right out of history(Ancient Greece Athenians vs Spartans) No matter how weekend you are, especially when you are that weekend, you don't destroy your best defence/weapon.

Kyle Limb

Though it would pain me to see the ship decommissioned it is rarely used, and the cost of maintaining such a ship could be better spent else where. It's sole purpose is to destroy planets, and it was determined that we never use it against anyone who didn't have similar capabilities... Turn the scrapheap in to profit, We must rebuild, and then once we have restored our glory, build a new one, one that we will actually use.

Thomas Low

star nuking planets in fact.... no first use policy has failed. Humans must not be enslaved just as it was over 200 years ago.

Leninerme

I vote to decommission it. Not out of fear but out of pragmatism. We can rebuild it whenever we need or please or need. Our nation is built from our might to protect humankind, and our pride shall never be over human lives.

SilverLotus

Chances are as soon as we decommision it we will need it most. As long as we don't build unnecessary constructs we can stand to have one weapon of destruction

Elijah Figueroa

Glory for the GTU, keep the weapons that wrought destruction on our greatest enemy

Jesse Berg

It is not a weapon of war, it is a weapon of vengeance and terror. It takes so long to deploy, and we face so many enemies, that we could not use it if we wanted to. The time it would take to use, and the fleets we would have to deploy to cover it would leave the Union vulnerable, all for the cost of destroying one, and only one, of the many worlds arrayed against us. Even if destroying it would win us no friends and no reprieve, it would still make tactical sense to dismantle it, since we cannot use it, and it clearly does not fulfill the function of a deterrent, otherwise we would not be beset on all sides.

Todd Voigt

The Sword of Terra is a weapon whose sole purpose was revenge against the galactic plague that was the Tyrum. it has no use but to destroy and instill fear in our otherwise peaceful neighbors. History has shown us that fear more often causes wars than prevents them. Dismantle this relic of bloody relic of vengeance so our would-be enemies know that we would defeat there inferior Military's with unity and strength, not by threatening the worlds that they love and have sworn to protect.

Allister Lynn

Maintain it as a strategic reserve, if things turn towards being unwinnable return to the roots of the GTU. Humanity must survive at all costs. Show temperance in witholding it's use until it is most needed.

DimirtisTaramas

We must take the path of Psionic Ascension. It will take time But It will be worth it especially if we consider how few resources we have right now.

DimirtisTaramas

Okay I admit you make a good point, But unless we have a guarantee that It will pacify the other nations defanging ourselves is out of the question.

DimirtisTaramas

Eating might be too late for that. If only it was possible to find an agreement with the others.

Silkwolf Frostsaber

It has served it's purpose and can not be tactically deployed without a hugh covering fleet. Decommission this weapon of terror.

Kaiser Lowendachs

The sword adds nothing to the navy. Humanity needs battleships and destroyers not glorified drilling rigs!

CheeseySword

Resources must be freed up for more ships to fight the Stellar Axis! The Sword served its purpose by striking down the Tyrum and now this war requires a different approach.

Valdonero

Resources are better used to expand the fleet and our defensive perimeter rather than pool manpower and materials on maintaining one weapon!

James

What kind of a interstellar fascist government would we be if we didn't maintain our doomsday arsenal?

Jack Maitland

At the risk of sounding unpatriotic, it is a necessary sacrifice. It has fulfilled its purposed and sent it's message, but now it's existence just paints a big target on us. If we aren't going to use it then it's time to let it rest.

Joshua

We're being attacked again so our point hasn't been made. Not only should we keep it but as model of modern Fascist State maybe we should think of using it?

George Sulea

Considering the enemies we've made, this would be too much like tossing our sword aside amidst a cavalry charge; suicidal.

Gete Star

Let the enemies of Terra paint their targets; it shows us which direction to fell our mighty sword next.

Someone Named Tygget

The technology exists in the galaxy, and though the Greater Terran Union is currently unique in its access to it, other nations will soon catch up. If we dismantle this powerful device, then the only thing we have accomplished is making ourselves vulnerable to whomever or whatever constructs the next one.

Jack Maitland

@Joshua If we really must keep the Sword of Terra then we should use it, but alas our hands are tied by the law to only use it on enemies with similar weapons.

DimirtisTaramas

That's what I have been saying, Thank you.

DimirtisTaramas

A grim and a bit fatalistic way of seeing things but also realistic.

Cmdshadow

Fellow esteemed members of the state, it has became clear that with the destruction of the Tyum, humanity has had a clear and just reason to use the Pride of Humanity technology, engineering, ingenuity, our will to survive, and or vast economy. But with the weapon that can make a world inhabited by tens of thousands to millions at the bare minimum. That has sent a message to the rest of the galaxy that well send this enormous station to their worlds for submission or blood. These messages both are very impactful to us, our people and the rest of the known galaxy. If we laid to rest the destroyer of our enemies it'll show the galaxy we just had one target and any other word was an act of self defense, however with the large portion of military and vast larger civilian losses, the decommissioned platform would not make an larger enough amend. Keeping this weapons might show the galaxy that were here for blood and fire. Both choices are hard, with pros and cons... it is my opinion that regarding "The Sword of Terra" we keep her. Now is a time were war and distrust lingers on every world, in every heart and mind. We have shown the galaxy that we will not show mercy for those who have wronged us, for if you have. We will show the might of Humanity. Regarding the economy, recessions aren't uncommon. With time and superior planning well make a profit again. It would cost most to break The Sword down and build more ships then to keep her afloat. And now regarding the war. Firstly to any if you nations we are warring against our plan is not to use our weapon for mass slaughter, on rare uses will we fire. Secondly, members of the council if we keep this weapon, our foes will make a go to destroy her them self's boosting their relationships with other "threatened" nations. We will use their lust for glory to destroy their fleets and render them combat ineffective and win without firing her anymore. Keeping her will show our people that we will never back down to our enemies, to those who wish humanity harm, and that whatever our fight is against; either Xenos who want to enslave our people, robots who want to state a fable of their superiority or to a recession. All will fail at the hands of humanity. Form our Naval might to the effectiveness of our armies. From the heads of state to our vast workforce. HUMANITY WILL PREVAIL! Thank you again my fellow esteemed members of the state.

Zachary Antill

My friends, we are LOSING this war! The losses we have suffered in the twin disasters of Xuukanis and Soao were crippling, and we no longer have the ability to replace them. If this war continues to drag on it will pose a serious threat to mankind as our other enemies could join the fight against us at any moment. If that happens we may not have the means to stop them... The question we must ask ourselves is will this bring peace? Will the Florians agree to peace if we decommission the Sword of Terra? If by this action we can secure peace the path is obvious... We must decommission!

DimirtisTaramas

So far the best comment! You presented the pros and cons of both sides and the only one of us to have the decency of making a suggestion about strategy and give a few words of hope. You may need to work on your grammar.

The GOAT rizzard

FELLOW HUMANS I STAND PROUDLY BEFORE MY FELLOW MAN,WE WERE ON THE PRECIPACE OF BEING RENDERED EXTINCT BY ALIENS AND THEIR GENOCIDAL WAYS BUT WE SENT THEM RUNNING BACK TO THE HELLHOLE THAT THEY SPAWNED FROM BUT DID WE LET THEM GET AWAY WITH GENOCIDING US WITHOUT CONSEQUENCE, NO WE FOUND THEIR HOMEWORLD AND WE DID TO THEM WHAT THEY COULD NOT DO TO US, WE SHATTERED IT ALONG WITH THEIR RACE, WE ERADICATED A GLACTIC MENACE AND YET OUR NEIGHBORING CIVILIZATIONS DENOUNCE US AND TRY TO FORCE THEIR WAYS ONTO US? WELL I SAY NO MORE, WE WILL NOT KNEEL NOR BOW TO ALIENS, OUR MIGHTY SWORD OF TERRA SHALL SHINE BRITHER THAN ANY STAR IN THE SKY BURN BRIGHTER THAN ANY FLAME AND SHALL BE A SYMBOL OF THE POWER OF OUR GLORIOUS UNION TERRA INVICTA!!!!!