Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Should the Antares Confederacy allow the construction of artificial lifeforms?

  • Allow the construction of artificial life. 324
  • Prohibit the construction of artificial life. 104
  • 2021-01-19
  • 428 votes
{'title': 'Should the Antares Confederacy allow the construction of artificial lifeforms?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Allow the construction of artificial life. ', 'votes': 324}, {'text': 'Prohibit the construction of artificial life.', 'votes': 104}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 1, 19, 20, 1, 56, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 428}

Content

The Antares Confederacy has had the capability for over a decade now to potentially create artificial lifeforms. Various interest groups have opposed these efforts, but with a dawning labor shortage and a growing diversity of inhabited environments across the Confederacy, public support for robotic life is growing. In accordance with the Confederacy’s charter of Rights & Freedoms, any such life would be granted citizenship and be afforded the same protections and responsibilities.

Files

Comments

Jordan Harris

This Retivan votes Aye! Let us supplement our population’s labour with artificial lifeforms.

Jesse Berg

Only if we also grant them rights.

Neutralguy

Lets be fair to them so we could build a better antares together.

ZedtheObsidianCake49

Many Antares has died in senseless wars. Building synthetic life could bolster our numbers in any future defensive wars.

sporkit

Synthetic life is life. They must be afforded all the same rights and responsibilities of any citizen of the confederacy

Count Thalim

If the Pneuma are sentient then synthetic life can be too.

Cmdshadow

We can't allow artificial intelligence into our systems. Since man made machines we feared that they could take over our systems and use our assets against us. Why should we take that chance? Were in a spot where if an A.I. tried to take over and we stop it, that delay might cost us. Safer to remain free of A.I.

Norvin Fisk

Humanity has had a fear of machines for centuries. Regardless of intelligence, we have feared change and progress. In very few cases have such machines caused real harm. We are not in so luxurious a position that we can afford to have such an archaic belief hold us back. The Antares system holds great resources, resources we shall require to further build our society. I see no reason why Synthetic life should not be allowed to join us in this great effort. Synthetic lifeforms could colonize world's we never could, and perhaps could create solutions to problems we still struggle with. It is my belief that Synthetics are a part of the Confederacy's future, and we should welcome them to our society as equals. (tried to write in-universe, but haven't been keeping up super well lol.)

Casey Bell

Diversity is the strength of the confederation, why limit ourselves when further diversity is possible?

Dark Forge

I'm afraid I must vote no on this. While it is true that these synths would allow us to colonize worlds that we could not survive on and would help with our labor shortages we must be cautious on the ramifications. To allow a machine to take the place of a person would only guarantee less work available for our growing population. Machine's should aid the worker, not replace them. These synths would do exactly that. Replace the living individual and replace it with a machine. I can not in good conscience support this. If this passes I pray that I'm wrong.

Jack Nathe

I'm sure it's a gameplay reason but I don't see why we need to make them sentient. We can create complex machinery without needing to make it sentient

Brian Henderson

But, Dark Forge, our population is not growing fast enough to meet the pace of our growing nation. If we allow a gap to develop between our economic needs and our labor force we open ourselves up to the dangers of stagnation and failing to keep pace with the other races and factions of the galaxy. We have already fought three wars that showed the effects of a lack of preparation and material. I say we approve this measure as long as the government invests in programs to help uplift all biotic citizens so that a permanent underclass does not develop.

John Strange

During my days in the Senate and as Tehnali Minister of Trade, I advocated enshrining the rights of artificial sentient beings in our Confederate constitution. Since leaving politics over my disagreement with our involvement in the Vrul conflict, I have continued to advocate for their legal protection. If the nations of Antares go ahead with this project, legal protections accompanied by educational and tolerance campaigns must be written into Confederate law.

PJ Mitchell

The added labor is vital to the economy, within limits.

Darrell Bell

While I'm in favor of automation, I don't believe it need go as far as self awareness. Simple automatons can serve most of our needs for production without the complications of sentience.

The Ghost of Avalon

While I wholeheartedly support the creation of artificial life I must urge caution from my fellow senators. While I am heartened that the proposal promises full rights to our proposed new citizens. I feel there is still a danger that the nature of their creation may cause some to look upon them with objectifying eyes. To see them as more product than person and abuse and exploit them as such. We must make sure to fight to preserve their rights just as fiercely as we would for any other citizen of the Confederacy! They especially will look to us as their Mothers and fathers and we must look after them as such. We must also be responsible for the rate and quality of their creation. Some of my fellow senators have voiced concern that the production of these artificial men may worsen the growing labor issue and I see that as a valid concern. As I mentioned before Corporations may be temped to exploit this new labor force for their own profit, especially if they are allowed to control the creation of A.L. We must ensure that they are produced at a rate that helps the confederacy achieve it's goals without harming our current citizens ability to contribute themselves. This may prove a difficult tight rope to walk between balancing their rights and the needs of the greater Confederacy so we should act with tremendous responsibility should this proposal pass. We're looking at the beginning of a new era my friends. We must prepare well.

J.D. Locke

I'm skeptical. The goal of automation should be to improve the lives of Antarean citizens, augment our capabilities, make work safer and more productive. *This* sounds like phase one of a plan to diminish and replace free citizens with something more docile and easily controlled. Let's stop and enjoy the benefits of our existing technology - and think through the consequences - before we charge blindly down the path of progress.

Andrei Chira

As far as artificial intelligence is concerned, I say let it come. And let it flourish as all other life has. We're not playing God any more than parents play God by producing children. And just like our children, artificial life is entitled to pursue its own destiny as equal to our own. Artificial life is already granted the full rights of citizenship under the Confederate Constitution, as they would have under the Constitution of Retiva. I will fight to ensure that the rights of an AI are not trampled by anyone, the same as I'd do for any other species of life.

ReaverCity

How I Stopped Worrying and Loved the Machine

Peter T

If it is at all possible to construct such self-aware machines, then they are inevitably going to be built, either in the open or hidden from view, i argue that, if this is the case we have an ethical obligation to opt for the first scenario. My reasoning is as follows: If it is inevitable that such machines will be built, then we are ethically obligated to build them in a enviroment that will forment their intergration into our Confederacy, rather than to let them be built onc landestine facilities and possibly allow for sentient-rights violations. We have a moral duty to provide those new beings all the liberties and duties they are entitled to as sentients.

Ph501

It is important to legislate for the rights of artificial sentient beings before we create them to prevent the abuses that are bound to happen in an unregulated environment when we make their potential potential a reality.

TemplarWarden

The construction and propagation of a new form of artificial life is something that must be carefully considered. The existing Artificial Intelligences that populate the galaxy must be consulted and studied to understand the extent of our actions and the connotations. The history of human literacy has countless tales of man playing god, creating life carelessly. Why must we make this step, are we fully prepared as a republic to fairly and properly represent the rights and lives of our own creations. Creations for the sake of boosting a workforce, slavery in unfavorable terms. I vote to prohibit the construction of artificial life because I do not feel the government or citizenry of the Republics understand or even are capable of taking on such burden.

Cyborg_V2

I believe we already did that, as the Confederacy already has Rudimentary Robots within but it is important they have rights, we are not the UTP after all!

Cyborg_V2

As a representative of the Trans-Human Initiative I say this is an important step towards mainstream cybernetics and perhaps, transcendence into machines ourselves. After all we can only truly be equal if we are all the same.

Michael Stevens

I believe the idea of artificial intelligence is great but only used in a capacity to serve humanity's interests than create the very thing that may bring about our demise as a species. I welcome our new metallic servants, as our aides, domestic servants, our workers, and as soldiers in the Confederate military to help reduce human involvement, so more people can go home to live life in peace than to die in war. I don't agree with robotic citizenship but agree in the idea to produce them as basic servants and as a alternative to human or other Xeno soldiers in the field.

Rhys-Johnathan Robertson

I agree with my fellows here. However believe we should not alter ourselves. by all means improve ourselves but we shouldn't push to improve on our human form.

jay

yes but no nanites please