Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

ᶜ'ᵐᵒᶰ, ᵍᵘʸˢ, ᵇᶤᵍ ᵇᶤᵗᵉˢ! ᴮᶤᵍ ᵇᶤᵗᵉˢ! We're back and joined by host of The Socialist Shelf podcast Jacob Dallas to talk about 2025's Mickey 17. We go through the plot, the philosophy and ethics of cloning, and how this movie's attitudes toward class issues and dystopia compare to director Bong Joon Ho's earlier works, say, Snowpiercer. The tardigrade teddy bears were an A+ addition, though. Listen to The Socialist Shelf here and find Jacob's upcoming book They Called Her Rebel here!FTL theme by DJ Danarchy

Files

Comments

ChainsawSnuggling

Having read both books, I think I enjoyed the movie more.

Failure To Launch

Yeah, I think Jacob said something similar about not being grabbed enough by the first book to immediately go for the second.

Aych

aside from all the ways Mickey 8 (in the books) is way different from what Mickey 18 sounds like (for one, there was no 'came back wrong' type thing from loose cables in the books each Mickey was just shaped by his experience which is the point isn't it?) it seems like the movie did the most disservice to the indigenous sapients it just seems like a really important point that THEY were the ones who figured out how to communicate with the humans, not the other way around. the humans weren't even trying. that seems like such an important element of like... so many of the themes the books explore? like kind of the point of the overall story? like maybe the movie is already going for a different point when it's moving away from the diaspora context that makes the beachead colony itself a copy of a copy of a copy (from Heimdall, from Eden, from Earth). like when they make this colony be directly from Earth and make the Mickeys we see be even more estranged from his original, it really feels like a "don't read into how this guy reflects humanity" type distancing. like nah let's not dig into like, how the status quo perpetuating itself necessitates a disregard for other points of view or forms of life or consciousness... let's just dunk on one specific demagogue who's the only thing wrong going on and otherwise the system would be just great as long as everybody followed The Rules. like, if they left out Nasha's family's background and the only remaining reference to the whole story of the New Hope was the sauce, that's just sad