Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Okay, so the other artist was expensive. I could buy a limited license, but then I would need to keep track of sales and pay more if the book sells well. So, I gave it a try myself.  This is a marketing tool, so I need honest opinions. And if this doesn't work, I would love to know of any affordable fantasy artists.




Comments

Marit Hoefle

This works for me, but I have a couple of things I would adjust. 1. A little bit more air around the text at the top and bottom. Pull it a little bit down and in from the edges. That would probably put the H a little bit off the face and the tail of the g at where the ear is and it might frame the face better. 2. I find the black field behind the white text disturbing. Can it be removed? If not (the white text will be hard to read) - can you shape the field around the white dress so that the upper left corner of the black field doesn't cover the dress? 3. I find the font on the bottom text disruptive. Try to find a font more complementary to the main font? I also find the yellow kind of disruptive. Maybe use the pipette tool to pick up a deeper yellow nuance from her hair or just have it in white? The text also needs a little bit more air around it, so shrink it in from the edges. I really like how you've done the title and your name on the top!

Anka Mauderer

I really like the goddess and background. But I would also change the font at the bottom and remove the black backgrounds from the texts in the lower half. Furthermore, I would find a little more distance to the edges optically better. I also noticed that you write here "the goddess who cursed them both" but if I remember correctly you call it "blessings" in the story. If I'm wrong, forget about it, otherwise I would adjust it. I am very curious how it will go on. ❤️

Caroline Stack

I would make your author name bigger so it can be read at thumbnail size on the book selling sites.

Serafima Forsyth

I agree with all the other comments, those were my first thoughts as well. With the words at the bottom, I’d go as far as to break it into two lines without the comma: Gods of Misfortune Book One

Michelle King

I don’t personally like the font. It’s a bit up-and-down. Try something simple. I agree with the others about the location of the text and the content too. Your sketch is good but I think try making the colours pop with a higher contrast or deeper texture. Give it a bit of depth. Besides those few things it’s really good. Good effort for doing it yourself 👍🏼

Claire Findlay

I agree that there is not enough "safe space" around the edges of the text. I also think that the 2 fonts you chose don't go well together. The main font is kind of angular and the title font is very round. The main font is a sans-serif font and the title is serif. I think it would flow better if both fonts were san-serif (or both serif). I work in marketing and sometimes have to put images and text together. I would be happy to assist you with this cover if you want.

Lyn Gala

I've edited the cover with the graphic changes, but I think I need to leave it 'cursed' only because that's how an average person would see the goddess's "help" in this case.

Lyn Gala

I've simplified the test. Some of that was me playing with font sizes, so it was easy enough to simply it. And thank you for the compliment.

Lyn Gala

That's a great observation. I normally hire someone for covers, but fantasy covers are either painfully generic or more painfully expensive. So I've change the font and pulled it in to get it away from the edges. The new version is up now, and I will take any advice you have to offer.

Jennifer

Hello Lyn, I know you have put a lot of work into this and I like to see what the goddess looks like and think you have done a good job in creating her. However, the cover lacks a "professional" feel to me and I'm not sure it will help market your book. I am also not in love with the title as it portrays the book as a standard alien insta-romance and your books are soooo much better than that. Maybe one of the other patrons is experienced and willing to help with the cover? Sorry I don't have any concrete ideas about how to change the cover and I really do like the artwork. (Just my opinion, please feel free to take it or leave it. )

Gemma Dearing

I'm loving the book but I don't think this cover will work as a marketing tool as it's not professional enough. Sorry I don't know any artists or graphic designers to point you in the direction of.

T. Lewison

I think the art itself is lovely. I do agree with the other commenters about the perception of professionalism--and I think we can attribute that lack to the font, unfortunately. I love fun fonts, I adore, embrace, and woo them... but pretty fonts are best used sparingly on book covers. I'd probably use a more 'standard/normal' font for the title and author name. You could keep the pretty font on the series title, "gods of misfortune" because that's icing on the cake, and not vital for marketing. Further suggestions: You might lower the goddess art on the cover, then lower the title and author name further or make the title bigger/more prominent. Doing so, you might lose the lower curve of the... dress? mermaid tail? Not sure, but it's not necessary. I think you want the goddess holding the planet in the palm of her hand--centering that will make it the focus, and make it easier to add text. If you shift the sparkly "galaxy" from the bottom to the top, it would make the dark font more legible. Last but not least, the best advice I've gotten from a cover artist is to reduce the cover to thumbnail size and evaluate: Can you read the title and author name? Does the cover art still catch the eye? Does it look cohesive? Looking at book-size art is one thing--but we need to get the attention of readers who will only be looking at a page of thumbnails first. :)

T. Lewison

Ah--this is a nitpick: I might make the goddess' hand less prominent, perhaps more like a suggestion, because it looks so odd, and my focus goes right to that hand... and her nails, too. I know you're following the muse of the text--but we see the cover first, before we get to know all about odd-digit humans. Without that knowledge, the hand rather looks like a mistake. >.< You might remove the nails? So the eye doesn't go right to them, then linger on the weird shape... Apologies if I'm not being clear!

Ingeborg Aune

I agree with the comments here, but I also think that there should be something on there to indicate that this is a mm-story. Regi is not an obviously male/female name, and nobody will know what a kowri is, so they can’t use that as a reference to judge what the story is. If I just looked at the cover without reading the blurb (which a lot of people do, it is their first impression of the book) I would guess that Regi is the goddess, and that this is m/f, which will put a lot of your target audience off.