Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Harry collapsed to the floor of the dueling room, breathing heavily. Professor Lupin held his hand out. “This really isn’t a fair fight,” he said as he silently offered to help Harry to his feet. Harry put his hand in Remus’s and let his professor haul him up.

Hermione rolled to one side and propped herself up on an elbow. “Oh yes, and fighting a horde of dementors is such a fair fight.” She groaned. “My bruises have bruises.”

“That’s what you get for fighting a werewolf,” Theo said. He was trying to look cool and collected, but one side of his face was turning purple.

Sirius shifted out of his dog form. “Hey, what am I? I’m the one who tripped you.” He bounced on his toes. Today was a good day for him.

Emilius sent a stinging hex his way, and Sirius yelped, turned back into a dog and then went bounding after Emilius. Emilus knew exactly what Harry’s godfather was likely to do, and he scrambled to his feet. However, he was too slow. Sirius knocked Emilius to the floor and then licked him. And licked him. And licked him. The whole time, Emilius flailed and yelled.

Finally Sirius decided he had gotten his proper revenge and he turned back into a human and offered his hand.

“So gross,” Emilius complained.

Theo had already helped Hermione up and was stretching out his shoulder. “Another round?” he asked.

“Absolutely not,” said Remus. “This is high-level training. I understand that you want to defend yourselves, but you aren’t old enough to train for long periods, not magically or physically. So I recommend that everyone take some time in the sauna and then go for a swim to stretch out the muscles.”

“Part of me wants to argue that we can handle it,” said Hermione, “but most of me thinks I need time off before I break something that won’t heal.”

“Sometimes rest is the best training,” Theo agreed.

Hermione gave a rough laugh. “I’m trying to imagine what the me of a year ago would have said to myself. I completely underestimated the importance of self-defense. How could I have been so clueless about the dangers around Hogwarts? I mean, there was the troll, and then Ron was nearly killed in that third floor corridor our first year, and that was before the dementors…. How many times do I need to brush up against death before I catch a clue?”

“It’s harder for muggleborns,” said Theo. “They’re used to having police. Our Aurors hunt Dark wizards, but we don’t have a policing body the way muggles do; we have to protect ourselves. Hit wizards might investigate Nocturn Alley, but they don’t sit around waiting for someone to floo call for help. Most of the time when we get in trouble magically speaking, we’re in areas where we can’t call for help or behind wards the ministry wouldn’t be able to get through.”

Hermione rubbed her elbow. “Which is why I’m going to learn how to protect myself and my friends.” Her face was set with determination. “And I thought it was Knockturn Alley,” she said. To Harry, those two names sounded the same, but Theo clearly recognized the difference.

“A nocturn is a ritual done at night. After Grindelwald, the Dark names were replaced, and the Ministry changed the name to Knockturn.”

Hermione grimaced.

“None of us are going to keep fighting today,” said Remus. “You all need to rebuild your magical reserves and use some bruise balm before we go back to sparring. So all of you, head upstairs. I’m sure Indigo has the bruise balm waiting for you.”

“Hopefully she has a washcloth, too,” said Emilius with a dark look in Sirius’s direction. He barked out a quick laugh. Clearly he didn’t feel guilty about slobbering on Harry’s friends.

“You guys go ahead,” Harry said. Since Sirius was in a good mood, Harry wanted to talk to his godfather while Castor was out.

Castor. Voldemort, more like it. Sometimes Harry could forget, and other times, the thought circled around his head until he couldn’t think about anything else. And Harry knew he couldn’t tell Sirius about everything because he still wasn’t recovered from Azkaban, but he had walked away from his family when they were doing the wrong thing, so Harry thought he might understand.

Remus smiled gently at Harry and Sirius. “I’ll be upstairs watching the others,” he said.

“What’s up?” Sirius asked. He walked over to a shelf and pulled off a towel before throwing one at Harry. If Harry was going to end up bruised and sweaty, at least he had the pleasure of knowing that he and his friends made Sirius and Remus work for their victory. They weren’t easy targets. Given that Remus was a werewolf and Sirius was an animagus who had trained with the Aurors, Harry was pretty damn proud of that.

“I wanted to talk about Dark magic,” said Harry. There were benches along one wall, and he headed over there. His legs were still a little unsteady from a blasting spell Sirius had thrown before the fight had devolved into muggle-style wrestling.

“Big topic.”

“Yeah.” Harry took a deep breath. “It’s just that Castor has confessed a few things, and I don’t know what to think about it.”

Sirius came over and threw an arm around Harry’s shoulders. “He can be a right wanker, but he cares about you. When Dumbledore sent that letter trying to remove you from Crafting class, I thought he was going to break off a corner of the table as hard as he was holding onto it. You have a lot of people who care about you, Harry.”

“I know.” Harry sighed. This was not going the way he’d planned it. “It’s just Castor did some stuff that was really bad.”

Sirius was silent for a time. “Bad sounds bad.”

“It is.” Harry struggled to find the right words, Sirius tightened his arm around Harry’s shoulders. “He was a little older than me and scared because there was fighting going on and he felt like he was getting dragged into it and no one was trying to protect him.”

“That sounds familiar,” Sirius said dryly.

“Yeah, but you wouldn’t have done what he did next,” said Harry with certainty. “He found a reference to a spell called a horcrux.”

A frown flickered across Sirius’s face. “I don’t know that one.”

“Well, he might not have ever done anything because step one in the spell is to kill someone, but he turned a dangerous creature loose in his school and it killed someone, and I guess the spell counted that as him committing murder.”

“Ah.” Sirius rubbed a hand over his face, and Harry felt guilty. Sirius had been having such a good day up until now. “I feel like I should judge him, but Severus is only alive because James caught me, so Castor and I might have more in common than I’m comfortable admitting. Getting someone killed is… I won’t say unforgivable, but it’s something I struggle with. I was ritual drunk and stupid, but still… I might have murdered Snape and gotten Moony executed. I don’t think I’ll ever totally let go of that guilt.”

“Ritual drunk? I didn’t think you liked rituals.”

Sirius grimaced. “I don’t. But I was trying to find something really important, and I thought it was worth the risk, but it turned out…” His voice cracked and he looked away.

“Walburga had killed them,” said Harry softly. It made so much sense now. Sirius had done a ritual to find his children, only he found they were gone.

Sirius huffed. “Sometimes I forget you’re the head of the Black House now. That gives you far more secrets than a kid your age should hold. Yes, I was looking for my kids. I promised myself I was going to be a better parent than my cursed mother.” He tightened his arm around Harry. “It doesn’t matter anymore.”

“It does. We could add them to the tapestry or include them in Samhein this year.”

“Samhein would be nice, but you’re going to be stuck at school that night. So, other than killing someone through stupidly turning a creature loose, what is this horcrux?”

Harry shifted, struggling to figure out how much he should say. He didn’t want Sirius to guess Castor’s identity, but everything Sirius knew, Remus found out, and Remus was scary smart. “It lets a person split their soul and put part of it into an object. As long as the object is safe, the person can’t die.”

Sirius sucked in a quick breath and turned to face Harry. “Soul magic? He broke his soul?”

Harry nodded. “He found a reference in Herpo the Foul, but Herpo had copied it from an Egyptian text without keeping the whole ritual together. So Castor didn’t know he was supposed to split his soul three times and then reabsorb the largest pieces. He was left with half a soul.”

“Sweet Merlin on a constipated mare. What in the…” Sirius scrubbed his hand over his face. “Okay, Castor doesn’t seem stark raving mad, but I might not be the person to judge that. Did he undo this spell of his?”

“Sorta.”

“Sorta?” Sirius’s voice rose at the end.

“He split his soul a couple more times, but that’s when he did things… things that I don’t know if I’m okay forgiving him for doing. And he’s okay now because Obstrepan showed him the full ritual and he realized he’d screwed up and started undoing his biggest horcruxes…. But…”

“You don’t know whether to blame him for what he did while his soul was shattered,” Sirius summarized.

Harry nodded, mutely horrified. If he couldn’t deal with Castor, then he would have to go to Dumbledore. Professor Snape said he was the only one with enough power to fight Castor, but he had also warned that Dumbledore would make Harry take a vow. He might make him vow to fight the Dark or relinquish his Black family magic or to follow Dumbledore’s orders. Professor Snape said Harry could limit the potential damage by deciding ahead of time what vow to make–that’s what he had done. Instead of giving his vow to Dumbledore, he’d decided to make a vow to protect Harry.

But Harry wasn’t willing to give up as much as Dumbledore would likely demand.

But he wasn’t strong enough to stand against Castor and he wasn’t sure he was forgiving enough to look at him without wanting to curse him, and the man could only avoid the house for so long before someone started to wonder what was going on. Having Sirius and Remus around was great, but Castor’s excuse that he was on a business trip wouldn’t last all summer.

“I don’t have an easy answer for you,” said Sirius gently. “It sounds like he was an idiot when he was young, but as another former young idiot, I would prefer that you find a way to forgive that. But I also don’t know what he did.”

“Killing, torturing, burning people’s houses because he thought they didn’t have a right to put a house on land sacred to the Dark. You know, same old, same old.” Harry tried to make a joke out of it, but his voice broke. He wished he could go back to not knowing.

Sirius whistled. “That’s… that’s pretty bad. It would also explain why he was willing to walk away from his life in the United States and cut all ties. Do you have evidence of this? Something you could take to the Ministry or law enforcement?”

Harry shook his head. “No. I know he’s hidden everything. He’s too smart to tell me any of it before he made sure I couldn’t get him in trouble. If I tell people, I’ll probably just look like a liar.”

“He does seem like the sort who would have sorted Slytherin if he’d been in the UK.” Sirius’ eyes grew large, “Not that I’m suggesting there’s anything wrong with being Slytherin. You are a very respectable little snake.” Sirius ruffled his hair.

“I don’t know what to do.” Harry whispered his confession. “I feel like I should want to fight him because he did to people what Voldemort did to me. How can I be in the same house as him? Shouldn’t I hate him? But I’ve also dueled him. I had to pull on all the Black family magic just to not get flattened during a duel, so it’s not like I can challenge him to a wizard’s duel.”

“Hey, kiddo, you don’t have to hate anyone,” Sirius said. “Maybe Castor deserves to go to prison, and maybe the Americans will track him down and you’ll have to make a decision about whether to allow them on Black property. But you’re a kid. You don’t need to put yourself in a bad situation trying to do an adult’s job.”

“It feels like I should.”

“You should do what’s right. And as the head of the Black family, you have some options. You could try to keep him confined to the property. My mother did that to me plenty. Castor has a lot more magic than I did, but you’re the actual head of the household and my mother was only usurping the power. You could also hire someone to watch him. I know Castor hangs out with some pretty questionable people, so it might not be a bad idea to keep an eye on him. Heck, I can spy for you. And if we find evidence that he’s repeating his mistakes, we can take them to… um…. Someone. I don’t know who, but Remus would.”

Harry sighed. “That sounds smart, and I know I should be doing the smart thing, but part of me feels like I’m being weak or cowardly.” Harry wondered if that was Ron’s voice he was hearing. Ron defined ‘right’ as being much more straightforward. Ron probably would have cursed Castor the second the sacred had come out. “I should fight evil.”

“That sounds like you’ve been listening to Albus too much,” Sirius said in a dangerous tone. “Remus told me about the prophecy. Albus is trying to get him to train you for some final battle between you and the Dark Lord, and I don’t mind telling you that it’s bullshit. You don’t have to fight anyone. You definitely shouldn’t fight Him. I fought You-Know-Who. I faced him, and his magic was…” Sirius gave a full-body shiver.

“Professor Snape said that he’ll help me if I want to fight Voldemort, but I have to study for a few decades. He said I’m not allowed to fight Voldemort until I’m forty.”

“Severus might have grown into a reasonable human being while I was in prison,” Sirius said with a grimace. He might be coming to terms with Professor Snape, but he still didn’t like him. “Getting back to our current problem, do you think Castor is still violent now that he undid this horcrux ritual?”

That was the very answer Harry wished he knew. “I don’t think so, but how can I trust someone like that? He killed someone, and maybe that was an accident. Maybe. But he split his soul. He killed other people intentionally. But he was a different person when he only had part of a soul.” Harry stopped as his brain started spinning in the same circle. He should hate Voldemort for what he did to Harry’s parents, but the Voldemort who did that was ninety-seven percent different because most of his soul was stuffed into objects.

Sirius sighed. “He shouldn’t have put this onto you. You should be able to be a kid, even if you are the head of House Black. Harry Potter, the head of House Black. Yeah, that still sounds weird.”

“To me, too,” Harry agreed. “And just think, Narcissa never would have taken me to the ritual room if she hadn’t been terrified that you were trying to kill me.”

Sirius wrinkled his nose. He still avoided the Malfoys, and Lucius made strange faces if Sirius so much as walked past a room he was in. It was like the adult version of the peacemaking Harry had to do between his Slytherin and Gryffindor friends. And if Harry rejected Castor, Lucius was going to be on Castor’s side and he would definitely turn Sirius in to the Ministry. Harry assumed Narcissa would stay neutral, but that might be wishful thinking.

“He didn’t want me to find out later and then think he was lying.” And he definitely wanted to make sure Harry had even more reason to fear Dumbledore. If the headmaster had any idea that Harry had chosen to live with Voldemort, he was going to put poison in Harry’s treacle tart.

“So he’s trying to do right by you,” Sirius summarized.

“I guess. Maybe.”

“But you don’t trust him.”

Harry turned and flopped down on the bench, his head in Sirius’s lap and his feet on the boards. “I don’t know what to think. Professor Snape just talks to me about what’s most advantageous and how I can best protect myself and what my life goals are and how I can meet them.”

“As much as it pains me to say this, and it pains me to an infinite degree, it sounds like Snivellus is right. You have to put yourself first. You can’t run around accusing people of murder without any evidence, so listen to Snape.”

“Yes, but he’s not talking to me about what really matters. How do I forgive? I mean, I can’t ever forget, but how do I get my heart to stop lurching every time I look at him? How do I go back to thinking about him the way I did a week ago?”

“You don’t ask the easy questions, do you?”

Harry looked up at Sirius.

“I don’t know that I’m the best person to ask for this kind of stuff. Remus is the smart one.”

“Remus trusts the headmaster. I’m not sure I trust his judgment.”

Sirius wrinkled his nose. “Luckily for both of us, not as much now as before. Working at Hogwarts revealed some unpleasant truths about the old goat.”

“But you’re the one who had to deal with a family that was not only Dark but also evil. What do you think I should do?”

“Do you think Castor is evil?”

“I don’t know. I mean, I know he was evil, but now he’s giving me space to figure things out, and that doesn’t feel like something a villain would do. But even before he split his soul, he got someone killed and he didn’t regret it. You would have.”

Sirius sighed. “I hope I would have regretted it, but I was a wanker. Your mother used to call me and James toerag one and toerag two, and she might have had a point. I mean, your father was great, but we were both raised purebloods with all the weird beliefs about our superiority. I don’t think we really understood that we weren’t the center of the universe until about halfway through year four.” He got a distant look on his face.

“What happened?”

Sirius was silent for a time, guilt and shame rolling under his skin. Then he shook his head. “Ask me when you’re an adult, or if you start acting like as much of a little shithead as I did, I’ll pull you aside and tell you the story. We were just lucky that Lily Evans had a mean wand hand and was willing to put us both in our place. But right now, you have enough on your plate. But you asked me about Castor….

“I would treat Castor like the son of the murderous American Jonathan Donahue. They share some values because they were brought up in the same house. There are little bits of Jonathan Donahue in Castor, just like there are little bits of Orion and Arcturus and even Walburga in me.”

Sirius and Harry both shivered in horror at her name.

“So maybe you’re more cautious about Castor because you know he has the capacity for something horrible, but maybe you also give him a chance to prove he’s something more the way your father gave me that chance. The way your mother gave both James and me that chance.” Sirius stood, rested his hand on Harry’s shoulder for a second, and then said, “Race you upstairs.” In a blink he was a giant, black dog and he bolted for the stairs with a joyous bark.

Maybe Sirius didn’t feel the Black magic as much as Bellatrix, but Harry still suspected his godfather needed to practice occluding. He was clearly soaking up a little too much of the family magic, but at least that meant he was getting joy, not the toxic sludge of hate and superiority and revenge that Arcturus and Orion had left behind. That was one thing Harry had gotten right, at least.

Comments

Belle

I just reread books 1-3, and I was wondering if there was a way you could create a pdf or epub version of book 4. I’m going to read it on Patreon anyway, but there’s not a great way to adjust font or size on here. I love this series, and I’m so happy I finally have time to read the end of Trial by Fire!!!

Moux

❤️