HP Trial by Fire, chapters 3, 4 (Patreon)
Content
Chapter Three
Severus felt a shiver go through his wards and he quickly cast a stasis spell over his cauldron. His security would only allow people from Hogwarts or Grimmauld Place into his home, and if his visitor was Albus, Severus needed to get upstairs before the old man got curious. While Severus could dismiss the changes upstairs as the overenthusiastic efforts of a bored Black house elf, Drystan’s expansion of his basement would raise those fuzzy, white eyebrows.
While Severus had been content with his home’s previous incarnation, Drystan had informed him that the mark that made Severus one of Harry’s subjects meant that Drystan’s loyalty to Harry had, in part, extended to Severus.
And he refused to allow Severus to brew in a substandard potions lab. And in typical Drystan fashion, he had gone so far overboard that Severus had to question whether Drystan was a particularly remarkable elf or whether all house elves would be more powerful if not bound in blood oaths and loyalty bindings.
Severus hurried down the long corridor, arched doors marking his ingredient storage, long-term brewing labs, a dark growing room for magical fungi and molds before he reached the stairs. A hidden door let him into the old Spinner’s End basement and he climbed the stairs.
He stopped when he spotted Black standing next to a bright, arched window overlooking the immaculate garden that boasted many rare potion ingredients intermixed with bright flowers. “Black,” Severus said as carefully as he could. This was his young Lord’s godfather, and he could not make enemies inside his alliance, even if Black was ignorant of their current situation.
Black didn’t move. “I wouldn’t have thought you lived in a place like this.”
“Did you expect I would live in a hovel or a dungeon?” Severus crossed his arms.
Black turned around. “This place is cute. Charming.” He hesitated before he added, “Lily would have loved it.” He picked up a pillow and smoothed his hand over it before he put it back on the restored rocking chair that Severus’s mother had once favored.
If Black intended to hurt Severus, he had chosen well. Invoking Lily’s name put a dagger through his heart and turned his self-hatred into a monster that rose from the depths of his soul. “I doubt she would approve of my library.”
Black snorted. “She feared Dark magic because she knew how it could warp a person. She heard enough stories about Bellatrix and my mother to be frightened, but when she and James went into hiding, she asked me to show her every Dark spell I knew. I taught her blood wards and sacrificial magic.” He turned his back and stared out the window as Severus collapsed into the nearest chair. Lily had performed the Darkest of magics. Of course she had. For her child, she would have risked anything.
She had learned to embrace the magic Severus loved, but Severus had so poisoned their friendship that she had still been lost to him anyway. He had no idea what he would have done had she come to him at the height of the war. By that time, he had been disillusioned with the Dark Lord, but he wouldn’t have sided with the headmaster or the Order. He’d seen them as attacking his magical heritage.
“Can I help you with something?” Severus asked, struggling to keep his voice even despite his regrets.
“How dangerous is Castor Black?”
Severus blew out a breath. This was difficult territory. “In general, to those of us who might share his dinner table or to Harry?”
Black turned back around and leaned against the window frame. “To Harry.”
“Not dangerous at all,” Severus said with confidence. After all, his fate was tied to Harry’s. “He sees Harry as his heir, as family, and since he has no other family, he values Harry above all others.” Severus didn’t say that protecting Harry was synonymous with protecting a piece of his own soul.
Black rubbed a hand over his face. “He told Harry that he damaged himself with soul magic and that led him to do terrible things in America. That’s why he came here. Harry asked me if he should confront Castor.”
Panic rolled through Severus, and he tightened his hands on the arms of his chair as he calmed his emotions and tucked them behind his occlumency walls. “What advice did you give him?”
“That if he had repaired his soul, he wasn’t the same person. That he should consider Castor the son of the monster who is wanted by law enforcement in the Americas and watch him to see if he is going to repeat the mistakes of his family since his values might be suspect.”
That was more rational than Severus had expected out of Sirius. His mental health had likely been helped by Grimmauld Place, which was soaked in optimism, but still, Severus had expected that conversation to have ended much differently. The boy Severus had known in their school days would have ranted and railed against anything that touched on Dark magic. Then again, that boy didn’t have a godson who performed necromancy.
“What would Castor do if Harry challenged him?” Black asked.
Severus considered his answer. “He would never harm Harry–not physically. And he wants to ensure Harry’s success, but I am less sure that he understands the elements required for Harry to feel happy. If he felt truly threatened, I suspect he would lock Harry into some fortress he could secure with his own magic and then supply Harry with all the books and appropriate friends he believed necessary for him to have a good life.”
“A gilded cage,” Black whispered.
“Indeed.”
Black grimaced. Maybe he was thinking of his own youth as the spoiled heir to the Black family before he’d chosen Gryffindor over Slytherin. “Harry would wither away.”
“I am aware,” Severus said. “And I have made it clear that if such a conflict were to happen, I would side with Harry over others. That means I no longer enjoy the same access to certain Dark circles.”
“Death Eater circles.”
Severus inclined his head.
Sirius settled on the window bench and rubbed his face. “You gave up your chance to spy on them. Remus said that the headmaster believes You-Know-Who will return. If he does and he finds out that you’ve sided with the Boy Who Lived…”
“My life would be forfeit,” Severus finished. “I am aware. Dumbledore is still under the impression that I am accepted by the Dark as I always have been. He would be displeased with my decisions, but as another who chose Harry over the headmaster, you understand my reasoning.”
Black didn’t look convinced. “I’m doing it because he’s my godson.”
“So, if another, Emilius perhaps, had been blessed with necromantic powers and in danger of being condemned to Azkaban for no other reason than he defended himself, would you side with the headmaster?”
Black visibly sagged. “When did Albus go off the rails?”
Severus scoffed. “He was always off the rails. He ignores the damage done by his policies as long as it serves his greater purpose. People are little more than pawns in his game, although he deceives himself on the matter. He let Harry suffer terrible abuse with Tuney and insists it was justified because the blood wards kept Death Eaters at bay.” Severus had served Albus after the war because his brand of bigotry was less harmful than the hate spread by the Death Eaters, but he’d never been under any illusions that Albus was a saint.
He was a good man who did his best and was willing to put his own life and reputation in danger in order to save the world from what he saw as a terrible danger. However, his judgment was more flawed than most.
Black looked like he had bitten a lemon. “I thought he was such a great leader.”
“Even when he left you in Azkaban despite your innocence?”
Black spread his knees and let his head hang. “He thought I was guilty. He would have gotten me a trial if he’d known I was innocent.”
“So he judged you by your family. He assumed a member of the Black family would be more likely to turn against the Light than Pettigrew.”
Black’s head came up. “That rat deserves to be in Azkaban.” His voice carried unbridled loathing; however, Severus didn’t comment. The Dark Lord would likely protect Pettigrew if he ever showed up. He had vanished out of the Gryffindor dorm and neither Ron Weasley or Severus had been able to find him. Severus could only hope that a stray cat ate him. Perhaps Minerva in her animagus form would do them the favor. Then again, he would likely give her heartburn.
Sirius Black then said, “Going back to the problem that brought me here. Is Castor a danger to people in general?”
Severus had hoped to avoid this conversation until much later, especially since he had so few answers. “That is a more difficult question.”
“Make your best guess,” Black suggested.
“I doubt Castor Black cares about others. I do not believe he would go out of his way to hurt anyone, but I also suspect he would kill anyone who got in his way without a second thought.”
“So he’s a sociopath and not a psychopath,” Black said. “Which might be due to his abuse of Dark magic, even if Nott managed to help him undo whatever stupidity he got up to when he was younger. There’s a reason why Albus thinks that Dark magic should be outlawed, you know.”
“Outlawing magic never works. Teaching people the danger and making sure they understand the damage they can do with that sort of power is more effective.”
Black scoffed. “Tell that to Bellatrix. She knew the danger and she still dove headfirst in the darkest and most dangerous magics she could find.”
“And now she is paying for that folly.”
“Until You-Know-Who comes back and gets her out.” Sirius jumped up, and Severus reached for his wand before he realized that Sirius was only pacing. “When that bastard figures out that she was willing to torture two good people to try and find him, he’s going to get her out. You know the dementors will side with him, especially now that we know Harry is a necromancer.” He paced between the window and the corner of the farthest bookshelf. Six strides one direction, a quick turn and then six back. Again and again and again.
“Even if Bellatrix is removed from Azkaban, she no longer poses a threat,” Severus said carefully, wary of triggering Black’s rage.
Sirius gave Severus an incredulous look. “How can you say that? She’s the best fighter he has.”
“She used to be,” Severus said. “Her mind is broken. She is no longer capable of even wielding a wand. Harry says that your mother took her into the ritual room when she was far too young to hold that kind of magic, and it broke her mind. That fracture is now complete and she wants nothing more than to sit by her tree and watch the sunlight come in through the leaves.”
“Tree? Leaves? Is she out of Azkaban?” Sirius’s whole body was as taut as a crossbow string.
“She is still imprisoned, but a tree is growing in her cell.”
Black looked utterly confused. Severus had no idea why he had to endure the torture of explaining this new reality to Black. “Knowing that Bellatrix was a victim of Walburga, Harry wanted to give her a Yule gift, so he used the Black magic to reach into the prison, nurse a seed and grow a magical tree.”
Sirius blinked. If not for that flutter-fast movement of his eyes, Severus could believe the man had been magically frozen in place. Severus wondered if he had looked equally foolish when Harry had explained what he had done. Even Lucius and Narcissa had been unable to keep their composure, although for very different reasons. Narcissa had been floored by Harry’s capacity to see the child victim of Walburga’s abuse inside the sadistic monster Bellatrix had become and Lucius had been floored by Harry’s deep well of personal magic and his ability to wield the Black family magic.
Severus suspected that Lucius wished he could change his own allegiance. He was ambitious enough to want to attach himself to the most powerful magical leader of his generation, and Harry had this much power before he had even reached his majority.
“He breached the Azkaban wards?” Sirius’s voice shook. “If someone found out…” He grabbed at one of Sirius's shelves and seemed close to losing his balance.
“He is already facing a life sentence for live sacrifice during a necromantic ritual. Will they wait until he dies of old age, raise him from the dead and then sentence him to a second life sentence?” Severus asked dryly.
“James would be having a heart attack right now,” Sirius whispered.
Severus didn’t care about James Potter and his ridiculous hatred for all things Dark, but he was amused that Potter’s son was now a dark lord in his own right. And Sirius’s horror amused him more than it should.
Black was shaking. “He can’t go to Azkaban. He can’t. The dementors…. Harry won’t survive.”
That destroyed the malicious joy Severus had been enjoying at his former bullies’ expense. “We won’t allow him to go to Azkaban. Castor would break him out.”
“Would he get there before the dementors kissed him?” Sirius stood a little taller. “They attacked him. You weren’t there. You didn’t see it. They went straight for Harry. The ministry would never be able to control them. The human guards don’t even patrol.” He started talking faster and faster, and his manic energy made him start pacing again.
Severus had to stop him before he could make a disastrous choice. He stood right in Sirius's path, forcing him to stop. “Enough, mutt. Get control of yourself. Harry will not go to Azkaban. And he has shared his memories with me, so I am very aware that the dementors target him. I also know the spell Harry used to destroy the dementors, and it did not depend on wand movements or rituals. Harry could defend himself from every dementor in Azkaban without having to resort to his patronus.”
Black blinked and took a step backward. At least he now seemed to be seeing Severus instead of being lost in his own mind. “Harry shouldn’t have to kill. We should. We’re the adults. If you know the spell, you should teach us so we can take care of the dementor threat.” Sirius nodded like that was the most logical idea in the world.
Severus appreciated Sirius’s desire to protect Harry, but he was being a typical Gryffindor, rushing in where the situation called for patience and strategy. “And what would the ministry do if the dementor’s vanished? Would the Unspeakables suspect a necromancer? Would they start searching for one? We have to move slowly, Black. Slowly and carefully. If you put Harry in danger, I will kill you myself to keep him safe.”
Black blinked at him, and Severus shifted to counter any attack. After a minute, Sirius sagged. “Right. Right. Albus would be too suspicious. We can’t let anyone know that things have changed.” Black passed Severus and collapsed into a chair. “I don’t know who to trust anymore. Hell, I’m here because I didn’t trust anyone else with the information about Castor. Remus is already uncomfortable. He worries that Harry is going to lose control over his powers, but Harry’s the happiest kid I’ve ever known. I thought it was Dark magic that made people unstable and sadistic. It turns out that was just a Black family trait.”
“That would explain the viciousness of your cousins. I have great admiration for Narcissa, but I trust she would see me dead if I threatened Draco.”
Black sat on the settee. “Probably. So, that leaves one question. How dangerous is Caster to us?”
Severus stepped back and chose his own chair, considering his answer before speaking. “He would not weaken Harry’s position by taking his allies from him. You’re as safe as you can be, mutt.”
Black huffed. “I’ve never been safe. I thought I was at Hogwarts, but the longer I’m away from the dementors and the more time I have to think, I suspect the headmaster always wanted me as one of his soldiers. Otherwise, why would he excuse what I did to you? He should have either disciplined me if he thought I was a danger to another student or he should have gotten me help if he realized I was ritual drunk and not able to control it.”
Severus stiffened. “Ritual drunk? The night you nearly killed me you were ritual drunk?”
Black nodded. “I was trying… Merlin. It doesn’t matter anymore. I was a toerag, and so was James, and so were you. We were all insufferable brats.”
That was an improvement. He still wasn’t admitting that Severus had no hope of defending himself against four attackers, but at least he wasn’t casting himself as the eternal victim anymore. Maybe it was time for Severus to do the same. He could not foster animosity inside his lord’s alliance. However, that was a step too far right now.
“If you are no longer in need of emotional coddling, I need to return to my brewing.”
Black snorted. “Right, coddling. That’s what you call a strategic mission to gather information about my godson’s life. You’re still a toerag, Severus.”
“I shall refrain from telling you my opinion of your less-than-charming personality,” Severus said. Despite that, he was pleased that Black had given up that dreadful name he’d used since first year.
“Right. I’m sure I can imagine the words you’d use.” Black headed to the fireplace and grabbed a pinch of floo powder. “Snape, if something happens and you need someone to protect Harry against Castor, against the dementors, against the Ministry or even Albus…” he stared at Severus, his fears on display for anyone who cared to look.
“I will call you first,” Severus said honestly. “I can see you are my best ally. Lucius and Obstrepan have sons to put first, Lupin is still too close to Albus for me to completely trust, and all the other professors still see the headmaster as the kindly grandfather who wants the best for Harry. As much as I am loath to say this, you are the only one I would completely trust in matter’s of the boy’s well being.”
Black nodded slowly before he threw the floo powder into the fireplace and vanished in a burst of green light.
Chapter Four
It was almost two weeks before Indigo came to find Harry with the message that Castor was back in his office. Part of Harry wanted to hide, but that wasn’t the smartest move. Harry worried that if they didn’t reach some sort of agreement, Castor would start to move against Harry out of fear that Harry would support the headmaster.
But right now, Harry didn’t trust the headmaster. The man had done too much to hurt Harry and people he cared for. But that didn’t make Harry Voldemort’s ally. Even if Voldemort was more Castor Black than the man who had killed his parents.
Harry stopped at the office door. “Castor?”
“Harry, did you and Draco have a nice day?” Castor was pretending that all was normal. Harry wasn’t sure how he felt about that.
“We worked on our potions homework before we went to Malfoy Manor for a lesson in politics.”
“Politics. One of the true horrors of wizarding society,” Castor said. He pushed the book he’d been reading to one side. “I assume you want to talk.”
Harry eased into the room. “I don’t know how to feel about the fact that you killed my parents. And you killed them for no reason. You admitted that prophecies can have multiple meanings, and you jumped straight to the only interpretation that required you to kill my parents.”
Castor pursed his lips. “I’ve said before that I was not in my right mind. I do regret my actions, but it is not in my nature to continually apologize. The three percent of my soul that made the decision to attack your parents made a poor decision. I did not.”
“And all the muggles and muggleborns you murdered?”
With a sigh, Castor steepled his fingers. “Muggles are dangerous. The wizarding habit of dismissing them as amusing little pets will get our community destroyed sooner or later. Muggles are people, and by their very nature, people are selfish, dangerous, and violent. Having magic or not doesn’t change that core truth. However, I have no interest in exterminating or torturing muggles or mudbloods. I used racism as a tool to gain the allegiance of the old families. You will need to speak to the Lestranges or Lucius if you want to address how racism has infected the Dark Alliance.”
Harry frowned. “Do you think it matters to the people who died? Do you think the people who were tortured care whether you did it as a political move or because you believed they deserved to die? When you act in ways that are evil, you are evil.”
Castor lifted his chin and leaned back, and Harry’s hair stood on end. He could feel the danger swirling through the room. “Do you believe me evil?” Castor asked in a whisper.
Harry dropped into one of the chairs, and Castor raised an eyebrow. “I don’t know,” Harry said. “I know you were evil. You were 100% evil, and if my mother’s sacrifice could have sent you to the next world, I wouldn’t have minded one little bit. But Castor Black is just… confusing. You talk about muggles as people, so I know you’re not dismissing them as animals the way Lucius does, but then you call muggleborns ‘mudbloods’ which doesn’t make me feel any better about your not-evilness.”
“My apologies. I didn’t realize a word would cause you so much distress.”
“That word suggests that you still think of muggleborns as dirty and disgusting. We’re wizards. We use words to create magic. You have to know the power of words.”
Castor looked thoughtful. “I shall endeavor to use less offensive words. When I first attended Hogwarts, I believed I was a… muggleborn. I have nothing against them other than their infuriating habit of supporting that old goat who wants to strip the world of Dark Magic. I do not believe that anyone in the Dark Alliance understood the power the headmaster could gather by sitting in that school like a spider in a web.”
That had been a stroke of genius. And it showed how Dumbledore intended to win. His strategy used slow manipulation of attitudes until everyone saw the world the way he did. He was the kindly grandfather supposedly saving them all. It turned Harry’s stomach, but he understood it.
That’s when Harry realized why he didn’t trust Castor. After all, the man hadn’t killed Professor Snape even when betrayed, so that should be proof that he had changed. However, Harry didn’t trust it. “The headmaster’s path to power is to brainwash generations of muggleborns into believing Dark magic is evil as opposed to it just being horrifically dangerous. I know what his agenda is and how he intends to hold power. It’s manipulative and horrible.”
He took a deep breath. “I know that when you had three percent of your soul, your strategy was to terrorize the world into letting you take control. That was evil and vile and unforgivable. And saying you only used racism to get your way doesn’t make it any better. It might make it worse. Lucius killed muggles because he’s a horrible human being who doesn’t know any better. You knew better and did it anyway just because it got you power.” Harry took another breath, and Castor continued to silently watch him.
“I guess I’ll only know if you’re still horrible or evil once I know how you plan to grab power.” Harry finally met Castor’s gaze.
“You want to know my plans.”
“I do.” Harry sat up a little taller.
Castor’s fingertips tapped a rhythm against his desk. “I would be willing to share if I had an unbreakable vow on your magic that you will not reveal my plans to anyone.”
Harry frowned. “Wouldn’t that mean I could lose all my magic?” The idea terrified him.
“Yes. If you keep the vow, we can discuss how to accommodate your… moral requirements. I have no problems shifting my strategy to ensure a broader base of support. If you break your vow, you will not have magic to challenge me, removing you from the conflict. I promise that I will then defend you with every ounce of my magic.”
Of course he would. Harry was a horcrux, so that promise was more about Castor protecting himself.
“I want to discuss your plans with my friends,” Harry negotiated.
“Any of your marked followers,” Castor countered.
“Any of my marked followers or people who take a similar vow to keep the plan within our group.”
Castor stared at Harry for a long time before he grabbed a blank piece of parchment and a quill. Thirty minutes later, they had worked out a vow and Harry had sent a patronus to Professor Snape asking him to look it over and oversee the vow. Harry could see how aggravated Snape was, probably because he didn’t want Harry to risk his magic. However, after Castor and Snape had worked on the wording of the vow, Harry and Castor held hands while Harry spoke the vow.
“Does Severus need to take the vow?” Harry went to sit, but Castor moved toward the sofas flanking the huge fireplace.
“I trust you to enforce silence among your followers. The mark is far more effective than any vow,” said Castor as he settled on the green velvet. Harry sat across from him. This was where he would finally decide whether he could handle having any sort of truce with Castor. If he planned to lead the Dark Alliance to attack innocent people, Harry was going to have to figure out how to stop him.
“Sit, Severus. I dislike you hovering in the corner like a nervous cat. Unless, of course, your lord would prefer you on your knees.” Castor smiled at Harry.
“He can sit,” Harry hurried to say. He truly wished that Castor would stop reminding him that Severus was marked. Severus settled at the end of Harry’s couch. “I know you still want power, so what is your plan to get it?”
“I have no intention of using violence. Our community is too small to suffer more losses.” Castor tugged his pant legs up before crossing his legs.
Harry waited for him to explain more, but Castor went silent. “So, how will you get power?”
“Through politics. Lucius has proved far more effective than Abraxas on that front. Between the dedicated members of the Dark party and the members of the Neutral alliance that are tired of the headmaster’s manipulations, we have a clear path to unchallenged power, and no one need die. Of course, I assume the old goat will still find an excuse to attack, so I do not think the coup will be entirely bloodless, but we will not instigate violence.”
“But…” Harry frowned and took a deep breath. “That doesn’t tell me what you plan to do. If you could take over the country without fighting, why didn’t you do it fifteen years ago?” Harry glanced over to see how Professor Snape was reacting, but he had an utterly blank expression.
“A number of factors would have made it impossible back then, but those in the gray faction are more frustrated now and I am able to plan more effectively.” Castor’s smile was smug. “Far more effectively. A friendly member of the gray coalition will be presenting a bill that will require ritual, crafting, wizarding culture, and alchemy be returned to the Hogwarts curriculum.”
Harry winced. “The headmaster is not going to like that.”
“No,” Castor agreed, “he is not. In fact, he is going to be furious when he realizes that between the gray coalition, the dark faction and those members of the light that have more traditional values, such as Madam Longbottom, the bill is likely to pass.”
“So, you’re going to try to take over the headmaster’s strategy by reclaiming the school?” Harry asked. Dumbledore would still be at Hogwarts, and as long as he was headmaster, he could make life very difficult for anyone trying to pry power away from him. Dumbledore would probably just hire more incompetent teachers for the new classes.
“I don’t need to take such a circuitous route,” Castor said. “As it happens, I have made sure that Dumbledore has possession of a book of archaic Wizengamot rules, including one that describes how the Wizengamot can call for a monarchy vote.” His smile went from smug to downright vicious.
“Monarchy?” Harry’s blood ran cold.
“Oh yes. The old fool has the one-third vote to call for a monarchy motion, and at that point, all business of the Wizengamot is ended, ministry positions on the Wizengamot are suspended and the Minister of Magic is stripped of all power. There is then a one month period to decide whether the two thirds of the non-ministry voting members can agree on one monarch.
“Lucius is the most visible member of the dark faction, and he could never claim the loyalty of that many people, especially given that the majority of his support is in the ministry where his bribes have earned him influence. While the headmaster watches Lucius, he will not notice me moving in the shadows. He’ll dismiss me as too new to the country to have any support. Between my marked followers, those who believe the fool must be removed at all costs, and those we can bribe or blackmail, I will easily have the votes.”
When Harry glanced over to the professor, he had turned a disturbing shade of white. Harry wasn’t the only one horrified by this turn of events. However, Castor continued as if describing the most wonderful future imaginable.
“This country is, in fact, a monarchy and having the wizarding world answer to the mundane queen is a travesty. I will have the power to control the entire ministry as the new king. Instead of having to go through any voting measures, I can simply legalize all forms of dark magic with one signature. I can mandate wizarding traditions in Hogwarts. I can remove muggleborns from their homes at the first sign of accidental magic and have them fostered in wizarding families. I can help our community thrive and grow as never before.” Castor was nearly lost in the glory of the world he was describing, but Harry could only feel horror as he imagined how Dumbledore would react to having a dark king.
But it wasn’t just Dumbledore. Ron and all the Weasleys, Neville, Susan Bones and her aunt, Remus. Sirius. The aurors. Professors McGonagal and Flitwick and Vector and Sprout and Babbling. Madam Pomfrey. Hagrid. How many people would do anything to stop a dark king from rising? Dark king sounded so much worse than dark lord. How could Castor not see the war that would follow?
“It will start a war,” Harry whispered, terrified at the thought.
The smile faded from Castor’s face. “It will avoid the need to have another war,” he said. “I assumed you would appreciate a political solution to the mess the headmaster has made of our world.”
Harry was temporarily at a loss for words.
Castor said, “Severus, explain to your lord that the only solutions are either political or through direct action,” with a bit of a snarl in his voice.
“I know that,” Harry snapped. “But if you declare yourself king, the light side will rally around stopping you. It will mean another war.”
“You overestimate the resolve of the opposition,” Castor said with all the arrogance that had led him to think he could lead his Death Eaters to victory against the Ministry and Dumbledore’s army.
“If the headmaster and the others had only banned those parts of dark magic which are evil, I would never agree to join you. In fact, I would have stood up against you and fought even if it cost me my life. I would become exactly who Dumbledore wants me to be.”
Castor sat up straighter, and Professor Snape made a small grunting noise that was probably some warning about Harry being an idiot. But still. Harry couldn’t back down. He just couldn’t.
“Then we should both be grateful for the path the old fool has taken by banning everything from our religious ceremonies to harvest rituals to historical facts related to the Dark.”
“Exactly. They overreached,” said Harry. “They went so far beyond what is reasonable or respectful that it's hard to sympathize with their viewpoint at all. I would argue that if young people today knew the whole truth, a lot of the fighters that the headmaster is counting on would either side with the Dark or would throw their hands up and insist both sides were too wrong to support.”
Castor tilted his head as though searching for the trap in Harry’s words. “We clearly agree that the headmaster is an old fool. But what does this have to do with your objections to my decision to reform the English government? Or rather, to restore the English government to what it once was. At one point, the Peverells and the Blacks both served as kings over the wizarding world.”
“And now the Peverells are largely forgotten and if people knew that they were necromancers, they would be more reviled than the Blacks, and the Black family… You know full well how people react to the Black family magic.” Even his title as the Boy Who Lived and the defeater of Voldemort couldn’t totally counter the prejudice people held against the Blacks, and Dumbledore had assumed Sirius was guilty so quickly that prejudice definitely had been involved.
“They are welcome to hate me, but they will bend to my rule.”
That didn’t sound arrogant, not at all. Harry had to wonder if Castor had more of Voldemort in him than Harry had assumed. “But if you push too hard, if you back the Light into a corner by taking away everything they hold dear and removing their ability to fight politically, you're just going to continue this war. They’re going to become the terrorists who use violence to get their way, and you'll be the government that they're fighting against. But the war and the bloodshed will continue.”
“That will end when I defeat the last of them,” said Castor confidently. Harry had to wonder if Castor had even paid attention to anyone else when he went to school. He had to have known a few Gryffindors. He must have met a Hufflepuff or two. And yet, he acted like he didn’t understand human nature at all. Harry was bad with human interaction, as Blaise had told him more than once, but Castor was at a different level of cluelessness.
“And how many wizarding lines will be lost? You keep talking about how horrible it was that you almost destroyed the last of the Potter line because the Potters have such a noble history in wizarding tradition. But you would have to completely destroy the Weasleys, the Longbottoms, the Ollivanders and MacMillans and Boneses. Can our community survive if we continue to kill each other over political beliefs?”
“What would you have me do?” Castor’s voice was still deceptively soft, but angry magic began to drift through the air.
“Fight. But fight politically. And you're probably going to lose some of those fights, but you’ll win the majority of them. The Gray and parts of the LIght will vote with you on anything reasonable, so you’ll probably get eighty percent of your agenda without any violence.”
“Why should I settle for eighty percent? I have the ability to bend the world into my will.”
“But should you?”
Castor chuckled. “You wish to discuss the morality of my actions. Sometimes I do grow weary of your obsession with ethics.”
“Next time you should be more careful in your choice of horcruxes, shouldn't you?” The second the words were out of his mouth, Harry cursed himself. What the hell was wrong with him–provoking the man who had murdered his parents. He hunched his shoulders, and Professor Snape was on his feet in a heartbeat.
Castor's eyes narrowed before he leaned back in his chair and studied Harry as if he were a strange and poisonous little bug that had crawled into his study. “Are you that set against the Dark finding a solution that would save our world?”
“No!” Harry said. “I want people to stop demonizing the Dark. I do. But I don’t want the Dark to repeat the same mistakes by trying to take all the power away from their enemies. I can’t sit back and let you do that.”
Castor glared at Professor Snape who had taken a step forward. Then he tapped his long fingers against the arm of his desk chair. “It appears we are at an impasse.”
“How do wizards solve impasses?” Harry asked, although he was terrified that he knew the answer. He had known it since his first year at Hogwarts when Draco had challenged him to a wizard's duel. Back then the best they could fling were stinging hexes, but Castor knew magic considerably more powerful than that. And he doubted that Professor Snape standing between them would provide much protection. Castor’s magic was terrifyingly powerful.
“I can tell by your expression that you are thinking about a wizard's duel.” Castor sounded almost amused.
“The boy cannot compete with you, Lord Castor,” Professor Snape said, his hand near his wand, although his gaze was on the floor.
“He is your lord, surely you have faith in him.” Now Castor was definitely amused.
“I don’t have faith in me in a fight between the two of us!” Harry exclaimed. He didn’t possess enough self-deception or stupidity to bet on himself in a fight.
Castor seemed to relax at that. “It is true that many times wizards will solve the conflict that way. The winner earns the right to claim a boon. The loser is forced to yield on a subject without complaint and without attempting to retaliate. But such a serious conflict would require a trial by combat,” explained Castor. “That requires two combatants to swear on magic that they will uphold the results of the trial, and it requires that each of the combatants be able to win. If you and I attempted to settle this issue through a trial by combat, magic itself would refuse us because you have no hope of ever defeating me.”
“Not unless you wait twenty or thirty years, and if we wait that long, have a feeling you’ll be king and the country will be deep into a second Wizarding War.” Harry stood and put a hand on Professor Snape’s arm to pull him back. Getting between him and Castor was not safe. After a second, the professor retreated back to his couch and Harry sat again.
“I would be king, although I think you overestimate the resistance I would encounter. People will settle for what rights they're given if they see no hope of survival if they fight,” Castor said dismissively. He was as annoying as Dumbledore, although Harry had more common sense than to say that aloud.
“Most Gryffindors and a good number of Slytherins are going to put their lives on the line to keep their rights.” Harry also suspected Hufflepuffs would fight out of a sense of justice, but Castor was weirdly dismissive of Hufflepuff, as if they hadn’t produced a fair number of magical dictators.
Castor scoffed. “Slytherins are wise enough to yield and then work around the laws, much like Severus worked around his vows. Salazar himself would raise a toast to some of Severus's machinations.”
Harry didn’t want to talk about Professor Snape. “If we can't have a trial by combat, then what are you talking about?”
“Are you so determined to throw away our alliance on the issue of other people's freedoms?” Castor sounded genuinely concerned now.
“Yes. Without question, yes,” said Harry. If he wavered on this for even a moment, Castor would wear him down.
Castor turned to Professor Snape. “You have not advised your lord well.”
“My lord has his own agenda.” Despite his words, Professor Snape gave Harry a rather unimpressed look.
Harry focused on Castor. “And I truly believe that you're not ending the war but just guaranteeing that my children and grandchildren have to fight it. If someone has to fight, I would rather do it myself then put it off on children who haven't even been born yet.”
“How did you ever end up in Slytherin?” Castor asked.
“Funny, Professor Snape spent the first two years of my schooling saying exactly that same thing in exactly that same tone. So what are the other options?”
Castor leaned back in his chair. “I believe you are a fool if you attempt this.”
“I've been called worse.”
“Very well.” Castor leaned forward and a small, cruel smile lifted the corners of his mouth. “There is the trial by challenge. The most famous is of course the trial by fire, a rite so commonplace that at one point, even Muggles managed to hear about it and perverted into something of their own.”
“You want me to walk through fire?” Harry had the feeling it wasn't going to be that simple; he imagined fiendfyre, and he was fairly sure he would not survive that. In fact he wasn't sure how a trial by fire would be any different than a trial by combat except fiendfyre was far more likely to kill him while Castor had enough control to limit the damage he did when dueling.
“The challenge is not so simple. However, I should not be the one you ask to describe the ritual. You have advisors of your own, I believe.”
“Professor Snape.” Harry turned to the professor who still looked supremely unimpressed with Harry’s choices.
“I do wish you would call him Severus in private. Constantly repeating his title reinforces a false power dynamic. You are his lord. He will always serve you and be below you in the hierarchy.”
“He will always serve me,” said Harry even though he was still deeply uncomfortable with that idea, “but he is not below me and he never will be.”
“My lord,” Professor Snape said softly, although Harry had heard that tone often enough to know that the professor was thinking about assigning about a million years of detention.
“Your softness will get you or one of your people killed one day,” said Castor.
“I'll worry about it when I'm dead.” As far as Harry was concerned, there were far worse things than death. Helping Voldemort kill his Gryffindor friends would be very near the top of that list of worse things.
“Go, speak to Severus. And when you decide that you have no chance of winning, come back and we will discuss a strategy for mitigating this Light-side rebellion you believe is inevitable.” Castor opened scroll and lifted it to read, effectively dismissing them. This was Harry’s house–the Black family home–so getting dismissed was so very aggravating, but Harry went.
“We need to talk,” Harry said once they were in the dueling room and the office doors were closed.
“We do.” Now that they were safely out of Castor’s presence, Professor Snape had dropped the ‘my lord’ stuff and returned to his normal, cranky self. “Now, Mr. Potter. Upstairs.” With a dramatic swirl of fabric, Snape gathered his robes around him and practically flew up the stairs. Yep, Harry was in so very much trouble.