Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Harry followed Professor Snape up to the second floor where he and his friends had claimed the family library as their private space. Professor Snape stood next to the door frame scowling at Harry as he passed him to enter the library. Theo looked up from his book, his eyes widening when he spotted Professor Snape's furious expression.

“I should give you some privacy,” Theo said.

“Or you could stay,” Harry said hopefully.

Professor Snape made a sound that imitated a werewolf growl rather effectively, which was a little ironic given Professor Snape’s position on werewolves in general.

Theo looked from one of them to the other.

“Please stay,” Harry said. He needed the emotional support, and of all his friends, Theo was the best at keeping secrets. Blaise was the best at finding out secrets, but Theo was the best at keeping them.

“Stupid boy, have you already forgotten that you made an unbreakable vow? How long do you think you will keep your magic if this is how blithely you treat the issue?” Professor Snape slammed the library door hard enough that it would have knocked the pictures off the wall in a muggle home. Thank heavens for sticking charms.

Theo's eyes grew wider. “An unbreakable vow?”

Harry sat in the wingback chair next to Theo's. “With Castor,” he said. Theo's eyes grew wider, and now he looked on the verge of panic. Then again, Theo was one of the few who knew that Castor was Voldemort. “And Castor said that I could share information with anyone who took an Unbreakable Vow to keep a secret.”

“So you would trap others the way you were foolish enough to allow yourself to be trapped?” Professor Snape snarled, but Theo had already taken out his wand and raised it in the air.

“I swear on my magic that I will keep anything said in the next thirty minutes secret under the conditions agreed to by Harry James Ophiuchus Potter-Black and Lord Castor Black otherwise known as Voldemort.” Light flared, and Harry felt the magic settle around them.

Professor Snape’s shoulder’s drooped. “Mr. Nott, I had thought you had some sense. You do not even know what conditions Lord Castor demanded.”

“No, but I trust Harry.”

That inspired another of Professor Snape’s withering looks aimed right for the spot between Harry’s eyes.  “If you wish to keep your magic, you may wish to temper that with some Slytherin self-preservation.” Professor Snape now glared at both of them.

Harry wanted to sink into the floor, but there was too much at risk. He would not step back and watch his friends get thrown into war the way his parents had been, the way Theo's older brother and his father had been, the way an entire generation of wizards and witches had been. Their world had lost too many good people already, and war just made bad people, like Mr. Malfoy, feel more justified in their general shittiness. If Castor passed a law taking muggleborns away from people like Mr. and Mrs. Granger, Mr. Malfoy would get all self-righteous and hate muggles even more.

“Theo, Lord Castor says that I cannot share information about how he intends to take over the wizard in the world with anyone except my marked followers and those who take an Unbreakable Vow.”

“Well I’ve taken an Unbreakable Vow.”

Professor Snape glared at Harry. “You have been a terrible influence on an entire generation of Slytherins.”

Harry really hoped that was fear and aggravation talking and that Professor Snape didn't actually feel that way.  “Castor has found a way to trick Dumbledore into having the Wizengamot vote for a king, and Mr. Malfoy is going to make sure Lord Castor has enough votes to pass the resolution.”

Theo looked from Professor Snape to Harry and back. “Please tell me he's kidding.”

“As much as I believe Mr. Potter has a dearth of common sense, I do not believe he would joke about this situation.”

Theo blinked dumbly for several seconds before whispering, “The headmaster’s head is going to pop off.”

“I don't care if Dumbledore's head falls off and rolls along the ground. He sent me to an abusive family and never checked on me, and he’s the one that’s getting more and more strident instead of trying to find some middle ground. So he can drop dead for all I care. But what is Hermione going to do when she finds out that there will no way for her to make any political changes in the wizarding world? How is Neville going to react to someone with dark magic being king of the country and not letting the light have any authority? Will the Weasleys accept a dark wizard king?”

Theo closed his book without even slipping a bookmark between the pages, which was a fairly sure sign that he was silently freaking out. “There's going to be a new civil war.”

Harry looked at Professor Snape hoping that he could see some solution that didn't include a trial by fire, but the professor was conspicuously silent. Harry nodded. “That's what I think. However, I have done something to try and stop that from happening.”

His comment or many his tone made Theo wince. “Why do I get the feeling I don't want to know?”

“Well it isn’t a wizards’ dual.”

“Of course it isn't. Wizards’ duels are fought over far lower stakes. It would have to be an official challenge to be magically binding when the consequences are the political destiny of an entire country. Merlin. We’re talking about the future of the whole country. We’re talking about how history is going to unfold.”  That seemed to terrify Theo more than Voldemort or challenges.

“Lord Castor explained that I couldn't challenge him because it wouldn't be a fair fight. He is so much magically stronger than me that he would wipe the floor with me, so magic wouldn't see the challenge as valid.”

“Even with the Black family magic?” Theo asked in a startled voice.

“The Black family magic is too unpredictable. You saw what happened when I was trying to learn to cast my Patronus. Sometimes I overpowered the spell and exhausted myself and sometimes I couldn't get it to work at all. Black family magic is not stable.”  In that way, it matched members of the Black family itself. Harry wasn’t sure how Narcissa had escaped the curse, but Sirius and Bellatrix were a few spells shy of a grimoire, and from the stories Sirius told of his youth, that wasn’t entirely the fault of Azkaban.

“And even if I did have the magical strength,” Harry continued, “I still wouldn't have decades of experience in dueling to fall back on. Me versus Castor is never going to end well for me.”

Professor Snape tucked his hands under his arms in his best ‘I’m watching you’ pose. “I'm glad you recognize that despite your godfather's habit of limiting himself during duels.”

“Wait. What? What are you talking about? He limits himself?” Harry whirled around.

“Black and Remus Lupin are both adults with decades of experience. Do you really think you could win against them in a duel?” Professor Snape raised his eyebrows.

Harry looked at Theo who was equally shocked. “No, but we come close.”

“You come close when you surprise them. However, their unwillingness to use dangerous magic means the fight is not an accurate representation of how a real fight would end. You are a talented group, and I believe that you will excel at dueling some day, and I believe you would win against the average witch or wizard and could probably hold your own against those like Lucius who tend to favor style over substance, but you would not be able to survive a battle with the likes of Lord Castor or the headmaster or dueling experts such as Filius or myself.”

“You are not improving my confidence,” Harry complained softly.

“Rational analysis of objective strength and weakness is far more useful than confidence.” Even if Professor Snape was right, Harry really wished someone would give him come irrational comfort right now.

Theo rested a hand on Harry’s arm. “I know you will not stand back and allow Lord Castor to condemn our world to one more war, so explain what is going on and we can make plans.”

Professor Snape sat heavily on the end of a settee next to the window. “And here I thought I could guide my Slytherins to take the rational approach and avoid fighting. I promised myself that if I accomplished nothing else, I would mitigate the abuse and neglect that sometimes drives children to join Slytherin, and I would keep our house from being turned into fighters.”

“I'm not targeting Theo to be a fighter,” Harry said defensively. He never wanted his friends to fight for him.

“You are also one of my Slytherins as well, Mr. Potter.  I do not want either you or Mr. Nott in this battle, but you insist on putting yourself in danger, and by coming to Theo, you have declared to both Lord Castor and Theo's father that you are claiming him in this ridiculous conflict you have set for yourself. You have agreed to a trial by challenge.”

Harry felt a niggling of guilt.  He had kind of dragged Theo into the mess with him.  “Will it be a trial by fire? Should I look up fire spells?”

Professor Snape grimaced. “The challenge could take any form. It might require knowledge of spellcraft or dueling, it might be a quest to find a particular item or a race against either the clock or opponents. But for magic to accept the terms of the challenge, it must acknowledge that you had at least a chance to win. As the one who has been challenged, Lord Castor may set the terms, but if he makes those terms too difficult, magic will reject them.”

“You mean the challenge won't count against me if I lose?” Harry asked.

“No, magic would demand that Lord Castor forfeit. Therefore, he will ensure that whatever challenge is in front of you, you have a small chance to succeed. But he is not obligated to make the challenge fair in any form. As long as you have a 1% chance of winning, he is free to make sure that you are 99% barred from success using any means at his disposal.”

Theo nodded slowly. “That means that anything he knows right now is going to define how difficult he makes the challenge. He's not going to risk a default, so what are your weaknesses?”

“Arithmancy,” Harry said immediately.

“We need to make sure that we work with you to strengthen that skill immediately. Do we know when he's going to issue the challenge?” Theo asked.

“No,” Professor Snape said. “I assume that he will hope that cooler heads will prevail and that Harry will back down.”

That made Theo scoff. “He's clearly never met Harry. Quite frankly, sometimes I wonder how he avoided going into Gryffindor given how stubborn he is.”

“Are you suggesting Slytherins aren't stubborn?”

“Not like Gryffindors. I swear by Merlin himself that Gryffindors would walk to their death rather than back down for two seconds.”

“That's a stereotype.”

“A true one,” Theo insisted. “But we have a bigger problem than your arithmancy skills.”

“I can't handle any bigger problems right now.”

“I am a liability,” Theo blurted.

Shock robbed Harry of words. “No you aren't,” he eventually said.

“I am. The old families have ways of ensuring that the heirs obeyed their head of house. My father is a marked follower of Lord Castor, if Lord Castor orders my father to assist him, I could be forced to do anything from sabotage you to reveal sensitive information about how far you've progressed in training so that Lord Castor can make the challenges as difficult as possible.”

“Your father wouldn't force you to do that. Your father adores you, Theo.” Harry had seen the lengths Obstrepan went to for his son. Even when he was moving stiffly and hiding his pain, he would come to watch Theo practice dueling moves and smile at him over dinner when he couldn’t eat. Everyone knew he was dying, but he refused to stay in bed or potion himself, insisting he wanted to spend time with Theo before he had to go back to Hogwarts.

Theo closed his eyes for a moment. “Yes, he does love me, but he's growing weaker and Lord Castor is his sworn Lord.”

“Are you suggesting you can't help me?” If Harry was alone in this, he was fairly sure he was going to lose the challenge, no matter what it was. His strength came from his friendships. Luna had once told him that when he was isolated he was weak, and she was right.

Theo sat straighter in the chair. “You need to mark me now. If I am sworn to your service, my father cannot use family magics to force me from your side.”

Harry's mouth fell open. “No,” he said after a second. “We talked about this. The traditional time for dark followers to take a mark is always after they turn seventeen.” And once his friends had that birthday, Harry intended to find another reason why he absolutely could not mark more people.

“Mr. Nott is right,” Professor Snape said. “Mr. Nott and Draco are both weaknesses in your defenses because of their fathers’ politics. Blaise’s mother is neutral and she is unlikely to take a stance even if Blaise were to reveal that something was happening politically, but Ostrepan and Lucius are committed to Castor's side and both have access to formidable family magics that will prove effective in controlling their sons.”

“Exactly. So, step one, you need to mark me and Draco. Then we have Emilius over and the four of us decide how much to tell the rest of the group. We can't reveal the full plot, but if they know that there is to be a trial by challenge and that you and Castor are in disagreement politically–”

“It is best to use the same ruse that Lord Castor plans to deploy against the headmaster,” Professor Snape said. “We tell them that Harry is in political opposition to Lucius Malfoy and his allies.”

Theo nodded. “That will keep Lord Castor’s secret better and ensure that there is no chance of violating the Unbreakable Vow.”

“We must delay Lord Castor as long as possible,” said Professor Snape “We convince him that we are trying to argue the wisdom of yielding in order to negotiate better terms for the Light. That way we have longer to tutor Harry so that Lord Castor's information about Harry's magical prowess is inaccurate.”

“Hermione and Neville need to know,” Theo said. “They are Gryffindors and physically unable to mind their own business, and I don’t think we want them investigating.”

“So, we have a plan?” Harry felt much better now. It sounded like he was going to spend all summer studying arithmancy, but that was better than seeing his world descend into an avoidable war.

Professor Snape sighed. “You must prepare yourself for a potential loss. A trial by fire might be theoretically winnable in a way that a duel with Lord Castor would not be, but it is most likely that you are simply going to serve suffer a humiliating defeat, potentially in public, for the sole purpose of easing your guilt when Lord Castor insists on taking the route he and Lucius have set out for themselves.”

“Thanks for the vote of confidence.”

“As I have explained to you multiple times, confidence is a foolish Gryffindor concept. We are Slytherins. We deal in reality and strategy.”

“But sometimes, we win against all the odds anyway,” Theo said and he gave Harry a huge grin. “After all, we went against the Dementors.”

“That's right,” Harry said. “And I'm not ready to sit back and let other people determine the outcome of this war. It's like Lord Death told me, I need to use this life to create the reality I want for myself.” Harry grinned, but when he looked around the room, he realized that both Theo and Professor Snape were looking at them very oddly.

“What?”

Theo shook his head and gave Harry an amused smile. “Only you would talk about Lord Death as if he were someone that you just hung out with.”

“Well, technically…”

“I am going to send Emilius and Draco a message, and inform Lord Castor that we are attempting to talk reason to you. I will leave it up to you to contact any Gryffindors given that a missive from me might give them a heart attack.”

“Thanks Professor,” Harry said, but it was too late. Professor Snape had already fled the room.

Comments

Astrid Jørgensen

Did you change Harry's new name to Obfuscius, or am I just confused with faulty memory? Does the vow still count if the wrong name is used?

Lyn Gala

Oops. That's supposed to be Harry James Ophiuchus Potter-Black. My dictation program clearly doesn't know constellations. But the vow will attach to Harry since that would be his name if I could spell correctly

Trace

It is an interesting challenge to come up with something that gives an opponent a chance of winning while simultaneously ensuring that they lose. I look forward to seeing what castor comes up with.