HP and the Trial by Fire, chapters 6 and 7 (Patreon)
Content
Chapter Six
Harry was nervous. Draco had been his first friend in the magical world–sort of. He’d been a bit of a prat back then, but still, he had stood on that platform by the train and talked about how Harry should have been raised in a wizarding home. That meant a lot to Harry. But he also knew that Draco was close to his father. Sometimes Harry thought they were too close because Mr. Malfoy was a bit of a jerk. Still, he knew there was every chance Draco would side with his father.
Maybe he should have let Theo stay. Theo had already told Obstrepan that he planned to help Harry, and the older man had told Theo that he was proud of raising a son who would stand at the side of his chosen lord. The lord stuff made Harry uncomfortable because he wasn’t one. Sure, he was the head of the Black family because he held the family magic, but that wasn’t the same. But Harry had been afraid that if he and Theo confronted Draco that Draco would feel obligated to support Harry. He did tend to fold in the face of peer pressure, which was ironic because he was always trying to pressure others.
The floo flared, and Harry stood a little straighter as first Draco and then Mr. Maloy came though.
Mr. Malfoy brought his cane down on the floor, commanding the room’s attention. “Harry, I’ve missed you at our tutoring sessions this week. I know politics is not your strongest subject, but a young man of your position must be able to handle himself in the Wizengamot.” Mr. Malfoy gave Harry a stern, almost fatherly look.
“Weirdly, that’s what I wanted to talk about–politics.”
Mr. Malfoy smiled. “Excellent. Shall we get comfortable?” He walked to one of the sofas and sat, not even waiting for an invitation. Harry struggled with pureblood manners as much as he did with politics, but even he knew that was rude. Draco, however, blithely joined his father without even a twitch.
As usual when a Malfoy came to the house, Kreature appeared with the tea cakes and mini sandwiches and tea. Harry suspected he would rather be a Malfoy elf with a house full of purebloods to serve, but Harry had freed him from blood bonds and he chose to stay, so Harry didn’t comment.
“I know what you and Castor have planned,” Harry said. Mr. Malfoy froze, one hand resting on the end of his cane and a perfectly blank expression. Draco looked from Harry to his father and back.
“What?” Draco asked.
“This is not an appropriate conversation right now.” Mr. Malfoy tilted his head toward Draco.
Harry snorted. “I don’t think the plan is appropriate at all.”
Mr. Malfoy drew a long breath. “I fear I am not at liberty to discuss it with you, but rest assured that Lord Castor and I have this under control.”
“The plan will probably work, but that doesn’t mean anything is under control,” Harry said.
“Father?” Draco asked, but Mr. Malfoy waved him off with a casual flip of his hand.
“Have you discussed this with Lord Castor?”
“I have,” said Harry, “and I challenged him over it.”
Draco shot to his feet. “You what?” he screeched, his voice breaking in the middle.
Mr. Malfoy put a hand on Draco’s arm. “Magic would not honor any agreement based on a duel between Lord Castor and Harry. The disparity in their magic is too great.” Mr. Malfoy now tilted his head toward Harry. “No offense.”
“I’m a teenager. Saying I can’t keep up with someone who has decades of experience and as much raw power as the headmaster feels too accurate to be offensive,” said Harry. He still couldn’t figure out how the headmaster thought he could go up against someone as powerful as Voldemort. If the headmaster wanted him killed for good, the headmaster could do the killing as far as Harry was concerned. Mr. Malfoy visibly relaxed at his words.
“But… then, what is going on?” asked Draco.
“A trial by fire,” Mr. Malfoy said softly.
Harry nodded. “Or by challenge, anyway. I don’t know what he’s going to do, and I’m not entirely sure that I want to go through with the challenge. Professor Snape thinks it’s Gryffindorish of me to even consider it, and I’m pretty sure that is a synonym for stupid in his mind.”
“Challenging a dark lord as powerful as Castor is stupid,” Draco said, eyes wide.
Mr. Malfoy settled back. “I rather agree. Do sit, Draco. You’re making a scene.”
Draco muttered something that made Mr. Malfoy give him a vicious side-eye before Draco sat.
“I know it’s dangerous, but I don’t know if I can go along with your plan,” Harry said.
Mr. Malfoy pursed his lips. “And I doubt Lord Castor will change his plans to accommodate your concerns.”
“He said we can discuss small changes, so he isn’t shutting me down, but…” Harry let his words trail away. No amount of compromise would fix anything if Castor declared himself king. But Harry couldn’t push too hard, because like Professor Snape said, they had to be careful until such time as they openly declared the challenge. The longer they could hold off, the more outdated Castor’s information on Harry’s skills would be.
“Then compromise with him,” Draco said in his most obnoxious “of course” voice.
“Maybe,” Harry said. “But maybe not, and Theo pointed out that if I’m unhappy with Castor, I have a problem.”
Mr. Malfoy glanced toward Draco with a calculating expression.
Draco frowned in confusion, but Harry was already explaining. “I can’t talk to Theo when he has an obligation to his father and his father is committed to Castor.” Harry avoided words like enslaved to, even if he thought the mark came close to that. “So Theo and Obstrepan and I have talked, and Theo has decided to take my mark and cut his obligations to his father.”
Draco’s mouth fell open. Harry assumed that it had never occurred to him that Harry and his father might end up on different sides–that he had to make a choice. The silence continued, the ticking of a grandfather clock marking each heavy second as it slid past.
“I don’t expect you to turn against your father,” Harry assured Draco. “I just don’t want you to feel hurt if we have to leave you out of some stuff. I’m going to talk to the Gryffindors tomorrow and tell them that I’m considering a trial by challenge because I disagree with something you plan to do, Mr. Malfoy.”
“What? Why are you blaming my father?” Draco demanded.
Again, Mr. Malfoy put a hand on Draco’s arm. “If any of the Gryffindors speak out of turn and the headmaster hears of it, that story will preserve Lord Castor’s plans. I approve.”
Draco still looked furious.
“I’m not going to tell them your father is evil,” Harry said in exasperation. “Even Castor and I aren’t going to start throwing curses at each other just because we disagree. I’m going to tell them that I found out about something your father wants to do and I challenged him because I don’t have the political power to stop him any other way.”
“I will confirm that if anyone asks me,” Mr. Malfoy said. “Do you plan to tell people that this conflict is likely to cause rancor or create a permanent divide?”
“No. Of course not,” Harry blurted. Sure, Mr. Malfoy was a bit of a racist, but he was also Draco’s father and Narcissa’s husband and the man who had taught Harry Dark magic. Harry wasn’t going to villainize him any more than Mr. Malfoy villainized himself with his weird pureblood prejudices.
Mr. Malfoy nodded. “Draco, you should take Harry’s mark. Tell your friends that you have sided with him against me because you have different political beliefs.”
Draco turned to his father with fire in his eyes. Harry had never seen him get angry at his father before. He’d avoided Mr. Malfoy during Dark magic lessons, and complained about him in private, but he never challenged his father. “What? No! I’m not going to tell everyone that you’re wrong!”
Mr. Malfoy pursed his lips. “We’ve discussed the advantages of attaching yourself to Harry, but this will allow you to distance yourself from our family’s reputation. Despite the obscene amounts of money I’ve donated, at least half the wizarding world still believes I am evil.” He ran the fingers of his right hand up his left sleeve, touching the Dark Mark. “The division between us will never extend beyond politics, Draco. You will still be my son–my heir. We will even continue to discuss politics over the breakfast table. The only change is that you will be obligated to keep your lord’s secrets, even from me, just as I cannot reveal Lord Castor’s plans to you.”
Draco looked from Harry to his father.
“It’s your choice,” Harry told him. “If you choose your father, we’re still going to be friends, and as soon as this conflict is settled, you’ll be back in my confidence. I just made a vow to Castor to not tell anyone who doesn’t have my mark.” Technically that wasn’t true, but Harry didn’t want to be the cause of Draco losing his magic because he got mad and accidentally broke an Unbreakable Vow. Draco didn’t have great self-control.
If anything, Harry’s words made Draco even more upset. “If father and Lord Castor believe this is good, why don’t you?”
Harry sighed. “Because I don’t. Or at the very least, the plan Castor has right now pushes things too far.”
Mr. Malfoy looked like he had bit a lemon. Maybe he thought Castor wasn’t going far enough because he had given up muggle baiting and indiscriminate murder now that he had his sanity back. Mind you, he was still planning on kidnapping magical children from their muggle parents and enslaving the wizarding world to him as king, so he wasn’t a good person by any stretch, but he wasn’t the demonic force Voldemort had been. Harry wished he knew what Mr. Malfoy really thought of that.
“Draco, you will offer yourself to Harry,” Mr. Malfoy said in his most imperious tone. Harry grimaced because it sounded like Mr. Malfoy was giving Draco away.
Draco nodded and slumped down. “Getting my mark was supposed to be a celebration, not something like this.”
His father sat up a little straighter. “You are absolutely correct. It should be a celebration. Emilius and his father can come, the Carrows, the Goyles and Crabbs, Obstrepan, Theo, Invictus Jugson and his wife, of course Lord Castor and any guests he wishes to invite. Harry, speak to Lord Castor about having the marking at dinner tonight. I must go and speak with Narcissa. She is likely to demand large gifts of jewelry for forcing her to put together a party this quickly, but needs must.” Mr. Malfoy was in a good mood as he headed back to the fireplace, calling out for Malfoy Manor even as the floo powder hit the flames.
“Did I just get sucked into marking you in front of an entire crowd?” Harry asked in dismay.
Draco’s grin was positively sadistic. “You’re the one who decided to argue with father. There are always consequences for that. Is Theo in the library?”
Harry nodded.
“Good, I’ll go tell him, and I’m getting marked first. The ceremony will be at my house, after all. You can tell Lord Castor.” Draco darted off before Harry could object.
Castor always made it look easy to get people to listen to him; that was one more area where Harry couldn’t compete with the older wizard. Grabbing one of Kreature’s finger sandwiches, Harry headed downstairs to the dueling room. He needed to talk to Drystan about securing the family floor against Castor or anyone who wasn’t part of their scheme and then setting up a dueling room up there.
Instead of having a long, lazy summer filled with a minimum of summer homework and some revision on Arithmancy to make sure he didn’t fail again fourth year, he was going to be dueling and learning as much as he could before Castor announced the challenge. Once he had his friends on his side, he was going to have to talk to Sirius and Remus, too. They could help a lot, but they both hated Mr. Malfoy. Harry was going to have a hard time keeping everyone civil.
Then again, he’d managed to keep Hermione and Draco from killing each other and Sirius had stopped using childish names for Professor Snape, and Professor Snape now bit his tongue rather than publicly humiliating Neville. Harry was actually getting rather good at stopping people from killing each other. He just had to hope he could apply that particular skill well enough to avoid a second civil war.
No pressure.
Chapter Seven
Neville was the first to find his voice. “Do you have any idea how serious a trial by challenge is?” His voice rose to a near shout.
“Why is it so serious?” Hermione asked. They were all sprawled across the floor of their new second-floor dueling room. Drystan had outdone himself, and arched windows overlooked all of Grimmauld Street and the park across the way. Harry wondered how much Drystan could expand the house before the massive interior collapsed into a black hole, either the magical or astronomical version.
Draco sat next to Hermione, scratching his hip. He insisted that Harry’s mark didn’t hurt, but he kept touching it. On the other side of Neville, Theo didn’t even twitch, even though his mark was the only one as large as Professor Snape’s. Maybe Castor could control where and how the mark appeared on his followers, but Harry had friends, not followers, and they seemed to control the size and placement of the marks. Draco’s was smaller than Emilius’ mark and much easier to hide because it was on his hip. Theo’s was on his left arm, just like Castor’s marks.
Emilius answered Hermione. “Challenges magically require the loser to support the winner’s position. If Harry wins, Mr. Malfoy will have to back off. But if Harry loses, he’ll have to support or at least step aside to allow Mr. Malfoy to pursue his political agenda.”
“I wish you would tell me what Mr. Malfoy wants to do,” Hermione complained. Harry had told the three Slytherins the full truth, but they all had his mark now, and apparently that would prevent them from talking about the subject because Harry had made an Unbreakable Vow. Castor explained that they were bound by Harry’s vows just like Castor’s people would be bound by his vows.
“I can’t. I literally took an Unbreakable Vow,” Harry said. “It was the only way he would tell me the whole truth.”
Neville looked at Draco. “Are you sure you’re okay going against your parents?”
Draco shrugged. “I love my father, but I think Harry is right that he’s getting too aggressive in the Wizengamot. I think he assumes that everyone is a Slytherin and they’ll change sides if he can make it too uncomfortable to oppose him.”
“That’s not likely,” Hermione said.
“That’s why I’m on Harry’s side,” Draco said, showing full support for Harry in front of Hermione and Neville even though in private he told Harry that the wizarding world would be better off with a king, even if he agreed that Gryfffindors were too rash to understand that and Hufflepuffs were too likely to take up wands and fight the second a friend or family member got hurt.
“Everyone here is on Harry’s side,” Theo said, “which means we all have the same problem.”
Neville was ghost-white. “I have a book that talks about all the people who have died doing challenges. I’m going to bring it to you. Do you know how many people have burned to death during trials by fire or how many have been eaten by magical creatures on some quest?”
“My father is not going to set a challenge that will get Harry killed,” Draco snapped. “Really, what sort of monster do you think my father is?”
Neville didn’t answer, but he did stare at Draco in awkward silence. Draco huffed.
Theo spoke. “Mr. Malfoy is going to make the challenge as hard as he can, but magic will award Harry the victory if the challenge is unwinnable. That means the other side will make it as hard as possible while still being theoretically doable, but our problem is that Mr. Malfoy knows all Harry’s strengths and weaknesses. He knows Harry’s grades, and he’s practiced dueling with Harry–”
“He has?” Neville blurted.
Harry rolled his eyes at Neville’s shock. “Every summer since I started Hogwarts, I’ve escaped to vacation with Draco and his family, and there’s a lot of summer tutoring. Of course I’ve dueled with Mr. Malfoy. I’ve dueled a few times with Narcissa, and I duel lots with the summer tutors they always hired.”
“Mother is a terrifyingly good duelist,” Draco said proudly, “but then she is a Black, and they have certain standards.”
Hermione scoffed. “Bellatrix Lestrange was a Black, so I’m not sure I’m as impressed, but Theo’s right. We have a problem. If Mr. Malfoy knows all Harry’s weaknesses, he knows what to target for the challenge.”
“Exactly,” said Theo. “He knows what Harry could reasonably be expected to do, so we have to convince Mr. Malfoy and anyone he might talk to–my father, Castor Black, Narcissa–that Harry is thinking about backing down. That will give us time to tutor him. We then need to figure out what his weaknesses are and fix them.”
“Arithmancy,” Harry blurted.
“I can teach that,” Hermione said.
Draco huffed. “No offense Granger, but you understand the topic so well that you’d be terrible teaching it. Emillus would be our best bet because he’s passing without doing so well that he won’t understand why Harry is stuck.”
“I can’t tutor Arithmancy!” Emilius said.
“I can work with both of you,” Draco offered. “Working together should make it easier for both of you. Harry is stronger in runes, so that might be something you can work with him to improve, Granger.”
“I can teach him specialized shield and warding spells from an old grimoire I borrowed,” Theo said. “They’re difficult spells, but I’m sure Harry can master them.” Theo looked at Harry and raised an eyebrow. Apparently it was time for Harry to learn the Slytherin spells the woman who married into the Black family had brought with her.
“I can teach him to recognize plants,” Neville said. “Challenges often include a quest or search, and knowing the flora can help you identify threats or even form impromptu weapons. Many magical plants can be used either as traps, so I can run through the ones he’s most likely to run into on a quest.”
“Can I tell my father about this?” Hermione asked.
“What? Why?” Draco demanded.
Hermione ignored him and looked at Harry.
“Will he tell the headmaster? He’s still trying to control my life. Professor Snape found out I’d been taken out of crafting and put in divination. He had to fight with the headmaster to put my schedule back, so if the headmaster finds out I’m getting involved in politics, he’s going to make me miserable.”
“I thought Headmaster Dumbledore didn’t like Mr. Malfoy because of his reforms. Wouldn’t he like it if you took a position against him?” Hermione looked from Harry to Draco.
“I don’t want the headmaster paying attention to me at all,” said Harry.
“That’s best,” Neville agreed. “Hermione, Harry cast Dark magic to save us, and he’s a necromancer. We can’t let the headmaster get close to Harry. If he thinks Harry is taking an interest in the Wizengamot, he’s going to start watching Harry to see what position he’s likely to take on lots of political issues.”
Hermione grimaced, but she didn’t argue. When she’d been a first-year, she’d thought Dumbledore was perfect, but she’d tempered that admiration with a little more skepticism about some of his mistakes, starting with the third-floor corridor where the Weasleys had been injured first year going all the way thought to the dementors and the way the headmaster had never gotten Sirius Black a trial.
“Fine, I’ll tell my father he can’t talk to anyone magical, but he was in the army before he went to school for dentistry. Lots of times wizards get so focused on their wands that they don’t think about other forms of self-defense. He taught me how to throw a punch when I was in fourth grade, and I can’t tell you how often I’ve been tempted and how easy it would have been to punch at least half the kids at Hogwarts. They don’t think about protecting themselves from a physical attack.”
“Physical attacks? Really?” Draco wrinkled his nose.
Theo conjured a ball of light and flung it at Draco. It hit Draco’s chest and then exploded with a silent flash of light that made Draco fall backward and shriek. “We use whatever resources we have available, and if a punch can win the challenge, then I say we teach Harry how to punch. Hermione, I would like to learn from your father as well if he’s willing to teach me.”
Hermione smiled at Theo. “I’ll ask him. I’ll have to explain to him that in the wizarding world, the heads of ancient families function a little like lords and that they’re expected to take on adult responsibilities too young, but do remember that he’s a muggle and muggles believe that young people should be protected from adult decisions like this.”
“That’s fine,” Theo said. “I can respect other cultures.”
Neville studied Theo with an expression of slight bewilderment.
“We should ask Remus and Sirius to step up our training and hide our improvements from Castor since he’s one of Mr. Malfoy’s friends,” said Harry.
“Oh, and potions,” Draco said. “The way I got so good is that mother would tutor me on a brew and the next week Severus would come over and tutor me again. That way I wasn’t annoying him with basic questions and he had the patience to teach me the nuances of each brew. Harry, I can tutor you on the second, third, and fourth year potions, and then we can have Severus come in and help you refine your skills.”
“Could I sit in with the first part of that tutoring?” Neville asked. “I don’t want to spend extra time with Professor Snape, but I know I need practice with my brews.”
“Magical creatures,” Emilius blurted. “We don’t have anyone who can tutor Harry in recognizing magical creatures or learning to defend himself from them.”
“Then we hire a tutor,” Draco said. “I can ask mother–”
Theo cut him off. “I have access to my father’s contacts. I can hire a tutor and have him sign a contract to not give status reports to anyone outside this group. Draco, do remember that your family is who we’re trying to keep this secret from.”
“We’re keeping it away from my father,” Draco said. “My mother is perfectly capable of keeping a secret.”
“Yes,” Harry agreed, “but since Cissa is my cousin, I would feel guilty about asking her to keep a secret from her husband, so let’s avoid putting her in the middle.”
Draco huffed, but he seemed to have given up the argument.
“Why do I get the feeling that the next three months are going to be worse than the school year?” Harry mourned.
“Well, you could give up the challenge and let my father have his way,” Draco suggested. Everyone in the room glared at him, and he held his hands up in surrender.
Neville cleared his throat. “None of us can afford to burn out, and if he burns out, Harry won’t improve the way he needs to in order to catch Mr. Malfoy off guard. I think we should all pick fun activities and then agree to either take one day a week off.”
All the Slytherins looked at Harry with horror, clearly expecting him to shut this down because wanting to goof off was clearly far too Gryffindor to be allowed, but Harry agreed. He’d seen how both Hermione and Draco had fallen apart when they pushed themselves too hard, and he wasn’t a quarter as smart as Hermione or half as smart as Draco. He couldn’t handle that study schedule. He smiled at Neville. “That’s a great idea. I always wanted to go to an amusement park. My muggle aunt and uncle took my cousin every year and he talked about the rides and the food.”
“Huh.” Theo got a thoughtful look on his face. “It might also convince the adults that you’re not serious if they see us wasting time. We could plan a recreational activity for a couple of hours, but talk about it as if it had taken all day. It’s a solid strategy to hide the extent of the summer tutoring we’re doing.”
Hermione said, “I would like to go to some movies. Most of you never get into the muggle world, and I think you’d enjoy movies. I bet Ron would be up for some time in the muggle world. He loves the new muggle studies teacher.”
“The dragon reserve,” Draco blurted. “Definitely the dragon reserve, and I can ask mother to get a portkey for all of us, but not Weasley because he’s not part of the friend group.”
Hermione rolled her eyes, but she didn’t argue for Ron’s inclusion. Emilius spoke up next. “I read about a muggle sport that sounds like dueling. It’s called boxing or kick-boxing. Sometimes I read one term and sometimes the other, but I want to see muggle fighting. Hermione, if your father taught you to punch people, do you think he could get us tickets?”
“Um… maybe? He might think it’s too violent. Remember what I said about muggles protecting young people more, but I can ask him.”
“I’d like to go to a professional Quidditch game,” Neville said. “Gran always kept me away because she didn’t want me to grow up admiring players. She thought if I wanted to play quidditch I would fall off my broom and kill myself.”
“Father has connections with lots of professional teams. I bet he’d get us seats to a couple of games if only to prove that he isn’t going to hold a grudge over the challenge.”
“And if we’re going to quidditch, get Ron a ticket,” Hermione ordered. She narrowed her eyes at Draco, and Draco glared back.
Harry sighed. “Draco, if the only things Ron will do with us are the movies and quidditch, you can be a good sport.”
Draco huffed. “Fine, but if there are too few available seats, he’s not getting an invite. Theo, what do you want to add to our summer agenda?”
Theo blinked at the group, clearly caught off guard by the question. Hermione smiled at him. “Surely there’s something you like to do in summer.”
“Read,” Theo said.
Hermione laughed. “I’m the same way, but I know I need to get out sometimes. I added movies to our list of summer activities, so you have to add something as well.”
“Why?” Theo asked.
Hermione blinked at him, clearly unprepared for that question. “We’re all adding something.”
Theo looked around at the group and everyone was staring at him. “We could take an afternoon and read quietly.”
That made Hermione chuckle. “I’m pretty sure you and I are the only ones who would enjoy that.”
“What does enjoying it have to do with anything?” Theo asked. “I doubt I will enjoy muggle dueling or an amusement park, but I’ll attend to support my friends.”
Hermione looked to Harry as though silently asking if this was some weird Slytherin thing, but Harry shrugged. Theo had always been a little odd and his Hogwarts house had very little to do with that.
“Theo, if you try something and don’t like it, you should feel free to stay back if we do it again. But isn’t there anything you enjoy that we might all like to do together? What do you like besides reading?”
“Research.”
“Which is another form of reading,” Hermione said.
Theo sighed and tapped his fingers in aggravation. “I like music,” he finally offered.
Hermione’s smile was incandescent. “I love music, and so does my mother. I’m going to ask to see if there are any concerts or symphonies in the next few months. It sounds like we have a plan.”
Emilius turned to Draco. “No offense, but your father is going down.”
Draco scoffed. “Why would I be offended? I’m on Harry’s side.”