Trial by Fire 17 (Patreon)
Content
At my heart, I am a romance writer. I want people to find someone to love, but when I read JKR, I don't see any relationships that feel strong. Hermione and Ron fight in a way that doesn't feel healthy, and we never see them transition out of being children. They're bickering like siblings one day and kissing the next. And we never see why Ron likes Hermione or the other way around. Harry and Ginny feels even worse. He loves her enough to leave her behind. Huh? I would think he would want a partner that would fight beside him. And why would Ginny allow him to leave her behind if she's going to be his partner? If you love canon pairings, good on you, but I don't. But I do want some pairings, and so even though I had a different chapter 17 rough drafted, I wrote this instead.
------------------------
Chapter Seventeen
Theo caught up with Hermione halfway up the stairs that led to Gryffindor tower. “Hey,” he called as he cut in front of her. “Are you okay?”
An older Gryffindor who had been several steps ahead turned and came charging back down the stairs with fury in his eyes. Theo stretched his arm out ready to cast his wand into his hand, but unwilling to draw first. “Why are you harassing her? Get away from her Slytherin.” The boy spat out the last word as if it were the worst curse he had ever heard in his life.
Hermione whirled around, her hair growing frizzier with the force of her uncontrolled magic. “How dare you assume that he's harassing me! What is wrong with you Gryffindors always making judgments about people based on what house they’re in! Do you really think Gryffindors are so perfect that we’ve never had a dark wizard come out of that precious tower? I can promise you that's not true.” She moved forward, poking her finger toward the older boy the way a more violent student might poke a wand. After having seen the training Hermione's father provided, Theo did worry that she might throw a fist.
He caught her by the arm. “It's okay, Hermione.”
“No! It's not!”
The Gryffindor boy backed up several steps before saying, “Whatever. Fine. You're on your own.” He charged up towards his common room.
As soon as he was gone, Hermione sagged. “What's wrong with me? I just can't keep control of my temper.”
“I think that's normal.”
Hermione scoffed. “No one else gets upset. Are you suggesting the rest of you are not normal?”
Theo laughed. “You haven't seen a tantrum until you've seen Draco throw one. He keeps his mask up in public, but in private he is not that well put together.”
Some of the fury seemed to leach from her and she leaned back against the wall. “I hate this,” she whispered. Theo suspected that the this in question had more to do with the tournament than Draco's words.
“Come on.” He led her to a fourth floor corridor and then into a small abandoned room with a wide window seat and a view of the Quidditch patch. She went over to the window and collapsed onto the seat. That caused a cloud of dust to rise around her, and Theo cast a quick spell to banish it.
“Thanks.”
Theo cast another cleaning spell before he sat beside her. “You're welcome.”
They sat in silence for a while before Hermione sighed. “I hate that I can't help him. Worse, I hate that I feel like I'm part of the very thing that's hurting all of you.”
“What do you mean?” Theo asked. This is not where he'd expected the conversation to go. He’d thought she was upset that Draco had called her weird, but she had no business blaming herself for anyehing. Hermione was one of the most loyal people he'd ever met. Her loyalty and her strength and her sheer magical capacity made her insanely attractive to anyone who is not a racist piece of crap. Victor Krum liked her.
“Draco is right,” Hermione finally said.
“There's a first time for everything,” Theo joked. “So, what is Draco supposedly right about?”
Hermione wrinkled her nose. “If someone had said blood magic before I got to know you guys, before I took the crafting class... I never would have guessed that nicking yourself on the tools made the magic more powerful, but it does. I never did it intentionally, but a week ago I slipped when I was carving. It was just a small cut, but ever since then, it feels like my tools are more a part of me.”
Theo drew in a sharp breath. “For it to happen that quickly, suggests you have an affinity for blood magic.” Theo's own family was renowned for their blood magic and their blood wards. Other than the Snyde family, few could match them.
Hermione nodded. “That's what I mean. Blood magic isn't evil, and apparently I have a natural affinity for it, but my first year at Hogwarts if you would have said blood magic to me, I would've assumed you were talking about evil wizards and covens of witches standing the moonlight sacrificing virgins to the devil. I'm a muggleborn, but I can't deny the fact that muggleborn prejudices are part of the problem.”
Theo rested his hand on her forearm. It was a horrible breach of etiquette if she had been a pureblood girl, but Hermione was far more tactile than any of them, and Theo quite enjoyed that. Touching had never been easy for him outside of his father. But with Hermione, it felt so easy and natural, and he wished he knew the words to say that to her.
She smiled weakly. “You should go find Harry. You know some Hufflepuff or Gryffindor is going to aim a hex at his back. And here I thought Gryffindors would be more fair than that. I thought they'd support Cedric as the Hogwarts champion but respect that Harry was representing the heirs. Clearly I’m an idiot.”
“Some of the Gryffindors support Harry,” Theo said, but he couldn't deny that Hermione often guessed wrong when it came to understanding people.
Hermione snorted. “Sure, me and Neville. Everyone else is horrible.”
“That's not true. There are a number of heirs who have quietly sent us messages of support and a few parents who have commented that they hope that this tournament highlights the deficiencies in the curriculum.”
“Really?”
“Yes. So don't think that your whole house is against us.”
“No, just most of them.”
Theo grimaced. He couldn't exactly deny that.
Why can't Harry just be a kid?” Hermione asked.
Theo cast a privacy spell to make sure they were alone. “In the last war, my brother was only seventeen when he went into his first battle. He hid behind a silver Death Eater’s mask, so I like to think that Aurors who chose to throw an entrail expelling curse at him didn't know that they were killing a boy who hadn't yet taken his NEWTS.”
Theo's voice trembled and he had to stop and take a few breaths. He had no memories of his brother, but he had grown up in the shadow of his father's grief and his father's impending death. The war had always been part of his life, even when no one was fighting it anymore. That was why Theo would stand with Harry. At least someone was trying to avoid having more children pick up wands and go into battle.
“Oh Theo,” Hermione said softly. Strangely her sympathy didn't feel like pity as much as it did when it came from others.
“My father's the one who really suffered. I can't even really remember him.”
“But he was your brother.”
Theo nodded. “He was. He hadn't asked my father permission to join the Death Eaters, so my father thought he was safe at home. My father thought that if he died in battle, my brother would be there to raise me.”
“And instead your brother is gone and your father has been dying your entire life,” Hermione said softly. “And I can see exactly what Draco is talking about when he says muggleborns’ prejudices were part of that.”
Theo took a sharp breath and centered himself. “Lord Voldemort’s madness was most of it. I don't know what dark magic he abused or what psychopathy he was born with, but he enjoyed destruction. He wanted people to die. My father talks about what it was like there at the end. He would torture people to death for annoying him or for retreating in the face of overwhelming odds. They weren’t his enemies, these were his allies and supporters.”
Hermione grimaced. “Torturing even your enemies is wrong, but I can see that torturing your allies is less explainable.”
“Very little about Lord Voldemort was explainable.”
“But without the prejudice and discrimination, he wouldn't have been able to find followers. Maybe he would've turned into a serial killer, but he wouldn't have had the power to start a war. Before I came to Hogwarts, I read Hogwarts a history.”
Theo knew exactly where this is going. His father had always told him to know his enemy, so he had read that cursed book. It made Gryffindors sound like the second coming of Merlin and Slytherin sound like a training camp for villains. Ironically, Merlin had actually been in Slytherin, not that you could tell from that book. And no one seemed to wonder why Slytherin would be allowed to continue if one quarter of the school population was evil.
All of Slytherin’s greatness – the Ministers of Magic, the researchers, the professors and explorers who had walked out of Slytherin and made the world a better and richer place were all removed from the chapter about Slytherin and placed in a separate chapter about famous alumni while the Gryffindors who had made a difference were all listed proudly in the chapter that described that house.
It was a masterful piece of manipulation, and Theo might've believed it had he not been raised to see argument as a verbal battlefield that was another form of war that his father expected him to excel at.
Theo told Hermione, “You were eleven. You couldn’t have understood, and you know better now. You know how they slander Slytherin.”
“But how many muggleborns never figure it out? How many of them go along with the idea that blood magic or mind magic or necromancy are evil?” Hermione asked. “How many of them never even consider the alternative, and how many of those people would automatically kill a necromancer without asking any questions and then congratulate themselves for being good and righteous and protecting the wizarding world?”
“Many,” Theo admitted. “But that's why Harry's approach is the best. We educate people.”
Hermione snorted. “I thought that was Mr. Malfoy's approach.”
Theo shrugged. “It is. Mr. Malfoy and Castor talk a lot about which classes they can reintroduce without pushing the light too far and endangering Mr. Malfoy's position as Inquisitor. However, I agree with Harry that their willingness to take more drastic political actions could be dangerous for the wizarding world.
“That's why I support Harry. I trust him to have the wizarding world's best interest in mind, even if the best interests are not exactly what I would want. Personally, I would like to see all forms of magic legalized and taught, but I can also understand Harry's concern that some forms of magic are inherently dangerous and should not be taught at Hogwarts.”
“Harry thinks magic should be censored? But he’s a necromancer.”
“He's seen things in the Black family library that he says people shouldn’t study until they’re old enough to be grandparents.”
“I’m not going to abuse dark magic. Do you think he would lend me the books?”
“Not until you're at least thirty and have occlumency shields that could withstand any emotional upheaval.”
Hermione didn’t look happy, but she didn’t argue, either. Good. He didn’t want her to nag Harry because he gave his friends more than he should, and Theo would mourn for a long time if Hermione lost herself to dark magic the way some of Voldemort’s followers had.
“Why isn't occlumency on the curriculum? It’s not just about protecting yourself from having your mind invaded. It's also valuable for organizing your thoughts and improving your memory and handling the overwhelming emotions that sometimes drown a person.” Hermione looked right into Theo's eyes, and Theo felt his emotions surge out of control for one split second. She looked at him with emotions that Theo could identify.
He'd never wanted anyone the way he wanted her. He had considered contracting some wife who would give him children to carry on the Nott name, but he had never considered that he might find a partner, someone who would challenge him and fight beside him and confide in him and listen to his confession.
For one second, his emotions were too big for him and he tightened his grip on her arm. He had to wait until the crest of the wave had passed, until he could find his voice again. “Occlumency is the first step in learning Legilimency. And that is illegal. So rather than risk students taking a skill and misapplying it, they choose to not teach the skill at all.”
Hermione sneered; it was an expression that would've looked more at home on Pansy Parkinson's face. “Driving is one of the skills that can contribute to drunk driving. Muggles don't deny everyone the right to drive just to avoid some people abusing it and driving drunk.”
“But the adults who survived Voldemort’s war, who survived Greenwald's war, tend to think of the world in terms of good and evil. If legilimency is in the evil column, so is occlumency.”
Hermione shook her head. “I’ve thought about this a lot since we found out about Harry's family gift. I'm not sure there is such a thing is good and evil. I think good is what happens when you are reasonable and you take other people's feelings into consideration.
“If I was in a coma and someone used legilimency to find out if I was still in my body or if there was a way to communicate with me, I think that would be good. The tool itself might be easier to use for evil, but I don't think anything can be declared evil without context. Maybe most necromancers use their powers for evil. They raise infiri armies or they summon the dead to get blackmail information. That’s what I read when I found books on necromancy. I even snuck into Knockturn alley, and there was not a single book that would admit to necromancy being a tool for good. But Harry saved us. And he said that once his occlumency barriers are strong enough, he wants to talk to his parents. How can an orphan getting to speak to his parents be evil?”
“It's not,” Theo said. “I plan, one day, to ask to meet my brother.” Theo felt another wave of emotion capture him, and he blinked back the tears that tried to form.
Hermione scooted closer to him on the seat. “I think you should. I think he’d be proud of you for what you're doing to protect blood magic and all the other forgotten forms of magic.”
“I like to think so,” he said.
Hermione broke eye contact and looked down to where Theo's hand was still on her arm. “Would he approve of me?” She asked in a tiny voice.
Theo took a long breath. “At first, no. He would probably associate muggleborns with laws denying him the right to practice blood magic. But if the dead are capable of learning, I believe he would learn to approve of you.”
Hermione offered a shy smile. “That's what I love about you,” she said. “You never give me a wrong answer just because it's the easy answer.”
Theo smiled back. “I know you well enough to know that you would never choose easy over right. It's the best thing about you.”
This time Hermione's smile was bright and easy, and it quelled the storm in Theo's chest. “You should probably head down and work with Harry. I think I'm going to go talk to some of the muggleborns in Gryffindor. A couple of the sixth years are in the other crafting class classes. I bet they’d listen.”
“I bet they would. Between Mr. Malfoy fighting to bring things back to Hogwarts and you explaining them, I bet we could do a lot to help Harry avoid another war.”
Hermione sat up a little straighter, and Theo could see the warrior in her. God she was beautiful.
“That's exactly what I'm going to do,” she said. “See you later!” Sounding enthused and ready for battle, she dashed out of the classroom and he could hear her footsteps pounding up the stairs to Gryffindor tower.
Hermione was the sort of warrior that any man would be proud to have at his side, and Theo fully intended to be that man.