Interview: NFT archeologist Adam McBride talks about the unearthing of Curio Cards (Patreon)
Content
Amy Castor and I have a post going up shortly, about Curio Cards - the first Ethereum art NFTs, before CryptoPunks.
This is an interview with Adam McBride, which we're making available to our patrons 'cos you're nice and we like you. An exclusive!
----


Interview: NFT archeologist Adam McBride talks about the unearthing of Curio Cards
Amy spoke with Adam McBride on June 2, 2022, to learn more about Curio Cards — the first NFT art on the Ethereum blockchain.
McBride, who has lived in Costa Rica for the last 20 years, describes himself as an “NFT archeologist.” He is obsessed with the finer details of these early projects, and consequently spends up to ten hours a day researching them.
Curio Cards pre-dated CryptoPunks by six weeks. Many people think of CryptoPunks as the first NFT art on Ethereum, but Curio Cards — which saw a second wind in March 2021 when they were rediscovered — predated Punks by six weeks.
Amy’s Zoom interview with Adam went so well and was so informative, we decided to transcribe the entire thing. We are posting the interview on our Patreon accounts — with edits for clarity.
Q: What is your title?
A: NFT Archeologist. I think I was the first to use that as a title.
When we started talking about historical NFTs, the general response was, “You guys are stupid. You are trying to create value where there isn’t any.” A large percentage of crypto Twitter was very much anti what we now call historical NFTs.
People came to understand how NFTs were built over time. It wasn’t suddenly that Vitalik launched Ethereum and here we have the modern NFT. This was built over the past decade by people making strides into digital ownership, and it was really driven by artists. It was an artist-led movement. That is often missed because the modern NFT is so art-focused that you lose track of the fact that NFTs were developed by artists. It really was an artist-led movement. They understood how bitcoin created this provenance layer and they were trying to basically tie art onto bitcoin.
And it moved between blockchains. It went from bitcoin, which they couldn’t get to work. They went with these things called “colored coins.” And then they moved on to Namecoin, which was another chain, and then back to bitcoin on CounterParty, and then to Dogecoin, which was another chain, and then finally to Ethereum, where we have what we would call a modern NFT.
But all of this work happened as artists were basically trying to create a provenance layer for their art. It is an amazing story.
Q: Were Curio the first art-based NFTs on Ethereum?
A: I would say it is the first. For me, calling something art, intention matters. Earlier projects have tried to lay claim to the art label. Principally, there is one called Etheria. Many people agree that it is the first true NFT, meaning “NFT” from a technical standpoint.
Q: But Etheria was selling plots of land, right?
Exactly, but now we use the term NFT to indicate a digital collectible — something that is digitally collectible from the blockchain. But there are people who are NFT maxis who require the technical definition of an NFT. Etheria, because it was land. You could actually put something on the land. The developer of that project put an image on one of his pieces of land, like a horse. And he’s like, “That’s art!” And, well, the project wasn’t made for that. It wasn’t an art project. You could consider anything art, right? But it wasn’t an art project. The general consensus is that Curio Cards was the first art project on Ethereum.
Q: How many cards were in the Curio collection?
A: They created 30 cards. They actually created 31, because there was a misprint: 17b.
Card #17 was actually done twice. That is a whole story on why that happened. So 17 has two versions.
Q: How did that happen?
A: They did basically a burn mechanism. They were trying to create FOMO. So if you bought the cards early, you got them for 25 cents in Ethereum. If you waited a day, it was 50 cents. If you waited two days, it was a dollar.
They were trying to create a drive for people to buy these cards. So for that, each of the cards had multiple contracts. What they were doing was revolutionary from a contract perspective. Because there was no standard. You or I could create an NFT today in 15 minutes.
Q: That’s why they pulled in Rhett Creighton? They were trying to manipulate ERC-20?
A: That’s right. The NFT maxis would say these aren’t NFTs because each one isn’t uniquely identified and unique. But the Curio guys were looking at it like baseball cards. Yes, they are interchangeable within a card.
Q: Did you talk with the founders? [Thomas Hunt, Travis Uhrig, and Rhett Creighton]
A: Yes. I spoke with everyone on the Curio team but Rhett. He was involved in some of the ICO stuff and he gets brutalized on Twitter, so he drops in and out of Twitter. He is like a super genius. And the whole team was early.
Rhett, basically, enabled it to take place. Before his work on Curio cards, the idea that you could have a collectible in a smart contract was not well defined. He basically had to create the contract that would allow this to happen. Including a trading contract [called a Vending Machine] that would allow me to sell it to you and to get it securely from each other in the trade and track the ownership. None of that existed.
Q: I understand they brought Rhett in at the last minute?
A: I don’t know about that. They [Tom and Travis] were trying to start the project and then they were like, “How are we gonna get this done?” And Henri was able to…
Q: Who is Henri? [Rick “Henri” Chan]
A: There was a guy who was basically a consultant. I don’t know how much of a team member he is considered but he definitely was part of the project. So he is a nice guy. He would be happy to chat. He is the one who knew Rhett and brought Rhett in. Thomas founded it.
Q: So Rhett did the tricky contracts?
A: Yes, that turned ERC-20 into an early version of an NFT. Whatever you want to call it. The community has just decided we are going to go with it and these are all NFTs. Although technically not NFTs by today’s one-of-one standard. The same way that Rare Pepe’s are the same. You have a Nakamoto Pepe — it is the very first Pepe; there are 300 of them. They are not uniquely one and uniquely identifiable, but we call them NFTs. It’s a digital collectible. I’m clarifying this because we spent three months battling this in the historical NFT community, to answer the question: “What is an NFT?”
Q: Tell me about the Curio Card number 17.
A: Basically, each card had to be manually put on Ethereum. There was no automation. So each one had multiple contracts. Because they were trying to do FOMO ramps or early bird discount type of things — where once a certain number was reached or a certain amount of time expired, it would burn the remaining supply. I don’t think anyone knows exactly what happened with 17b, but it was briefly released. One person who is actually in the Discord was able to get, I don’t know how many 17bs, before they realized their mistake and turned off the contract — or whatever they did, but some person back in 2017 actually did claim a couple of 17bs back then.
Q: So a full set would include a 17b?
A: Yes. Even though it is not in the official Curio Card’s wrapper, 1-30. 17b is done separately. But all collectors consider 17b part of the collection. Rhett did the #17 contract. He did all of them.
Q: Curio Cards is considered a failure. It goes dormant for 4 years. Sometime in 2021, it gets rediscovered. Who did that?
A: It was a Twitter user called @DieAping. [He is no longer on Twitter.]
He is the one who I believe located the contract. [“Bob” was the other, according to this Tweet.] There was a week in April last year when a project called CryptoCats was rediscovered. Then two days later, another project called Mooncats was rediscovered and then the very next day, Curio Cards was rediscovered. It was this wave of people locating these old contracts.
Q: Was it because they figured they could buy them cheap and sell them for more once the discovery was announced?
A: Yeah, most of these were free or cheap. Definitely inexpensive. You have to take yourself back to this time in March or April last year, where the NFT narrative was CryptoPunks. That was the narrative. If you looked at the CryptoPunks bio on OpenSea, it said, “The world’s first NFT.”
When we found CryptoCats, which were at the end of 2017, people said, “Holy cow, look at this. These were only 5 months after CryptoPunks. These gotta be of some value and they are free. Go grab ‘em.” Same thing with Mooncats.
And when Curio Cards were found, people said: “Oh, my god, these were actually before CryptoPunks. How much are these going to be worth?”
Punks at the time were $20,000 each. “How much are these going to be worth?” So it sparked this imagination, like oh, my god. It was like, there is gold on the blockchain. All I’ve got to do is dig it up and find it.
Q: I think somewhere I heard that at one point in 2021, Travis said all of a sudden, his DMs started blowing up.
A: I don’t know if you know the full story. I located Travis the day of the rediscovery, after the Mooncats happened and after the CryptoCats happened. I was getting really excited. When Curio Cards happened, that day, I did research just looking for anything I could find about the project, and I basically DM’d every artist I could find and the founders — and one was Travis.
And Travis, the day before, if you look through his Twitter thread. He had posted a tweet: “Friday was the last day of my job. Excited for what’s next.” And the next day, Curio Cards was discovered. So there is a little bit of: “Did Travis tell DieAping about this?”
Basically DieAping and HarryBTC, who is a friend of mine on Twitter. They were in a telegram group and they were finding these old projects and rediscovering them and just putting them out there. Back then at least, people were finding them and they would go and get 10 NFTs and just tell the world about it. So it was this very, friendly, open rediscovery culture, which is awesome and influenced me greatly in the way I rediscovered projects.
Q: So Curio Cards gets rediscovered but now they are not compatible with OpenSea. So who did the wrapper?
I don’t know. It was not Rhett. But they spun up a wrapper quickly. Because people learned over the last week that you have to get a wrapper up as soon as possible so that it can get on OpenSea and you guys can sell all the ones you just claimed. You gotta get it out there and you gotta make it tradeable.
For a while, people were just doing OTC trades through the Curio Discord and that is just kind of trusting people.
Q: So we don’t know who did the wrapper?
We can find that out but I’m not it’s going to matter to you because it’s going to be someone like Frank1234 on Discord. I’m sure it’s an anonymous person.
Q: But then there was a mistake in the wrapper and the cards were lost. What happened?
So there was the initial wrapper. I think there are three wrappers now for Curio. So the initial one was built very, very quickly. A bunch of people put their cards in there. Basically, that wrapper wasn’t tested properly. So those cards are considered lost.
Q: How many were lost?
[Not sure. We are trying to find out.]
The significant one was card #26, which was the rarest one, to begin with. There were only 111 of them and five got lost, so there are only 105 of the #26 cards left.
Q: When they did the cards, the supply for each was 111 to 2,000?
It was actually a lot more because they tried to do this FOMO ramp. When I learned about Curio Cards, I went to go claim the number 10 card. And when I looked, I saw it actually had 100,000 units. And you could claim them and they were only $5. And my math was like, they are only $5 but there are 100,000. How is there ever going to be any value to this? And so I didn’t buy any.
I probably lost $200,000 because what ended up happening was, the original amount was 100,000 and those had to be claimed at a certain time. The moment 2,000 were claimed, all of the rest were burned.
In the later cards, they allowed the artist to select the total number of cards and for Daniel Friedman’s cards, I think it is 24, 25, and 26, he set it as 111, 222, and 333, because he liked the way the numbers looked, so he set those himself.
Q: I heard Cryptograffiti was a contributor?
Yes, which is awesome and you see his cards are all about bitcoin. Graffiti is a bitcoin maxi.
The interesting side story is that XCOPY, who is now the most famous NFT artist, applied to be a part of Curio Cards. You could put in your Google form to be part of Curio Cards and he got it in too late and was delayed. This was amazing because if XCOPY was part of the Curio Cards, it would have been a whole different story.
Q: Somebody develops a wrapper in 2021. Why did they use ERC-1155?
ERC-1155 works better if you have multiples of the same card. What happens with ERC-721, each card would be a different one on OpenSea, and the user experience would be terrible. Instead, with 1155, a card is a card. A #26 card shows up once and you can see all of the owners of that card.
Q: So a whole set, including 17b, sold at Christie’s in October 2021. Who was the seller?
I know who it was, but I think he may have been anonymous. I’m not sure if he wants me to share it. I will get back to you.
Q: Who was the buyer?
One of the founders of Ethereum. [It was Taylor Gerring, who was not considered an Ethereum founder by the other Ethereum co-founders.]
Crypto natives are going to highly value these.
Q: When the cards are rediscovered, did they still link the art?
They were one of the first, if not the first to use IPFS. They [the images] were still there.
Q: With IPFS, you can still seed the image?
As long as one node still has it, it can still populate. Obviously, it will never go down now.
Q: What are Curio Cards selling for now?
They’ve been crushed like everything else. Attention is really hard in today’s world. NFTs are the microcosm of hype cycles. It’s like, a shiny object for two seconds, and it's gone. But for people like myself who collect historical NFTs, we know that that shiny object will come back. NFTs are the first step into a Web3 universe.
Q: What are the vending machines?
Those are the buy-sell mechanisms I was talking about. Back then, there was no OpenSea, so every NFT project had to build its own marketplace for buying and selling. Their marketplace was their website, which would allow you to trade. But their website was simply a reflection of a smart contract. Even though the website wasn’t really working. You could still claim the cards through the vending machine, which was built into the smart contract.
Q: Did Thomas Hunt or Rhett or Travis keep any for themselves?
They say no, but I know they did. [Laughs]. They were looking to treat this as a startup. Thomas brought in Travis as a partner to drum up money through VCs.
Q: What VCs did he talk to?
I have no idea. I don’t think he was successful. This was five years too early. Back in 2017, this was not an idea that was getting any traction, so I don’t think they raised any money. But if you think about it, what do you do to stimulate interest in your project? I’m sure they bought a whole bunch of cards, just to try and do something. Try and just reward the artists a little bit, keep them happy. So I’m sure they bought a bunch.
Of course, Robek is the Curio Card whale. I’m sure you’ve heard of Robek? He is the artist behind three cards: 21, 22, and 23. And 23 is the first GIF of the Curio Cards, possibly the first GIF on Ethereum, so he was very early. [Card #23, “The Barbarian,” is supposed to be Rhett Creighton, and he’s winking.]
Robek is an artist and a tech guy. He saw this all happening and was like, “I’ve got to be a part of this.” So when Curio Cards were first selling, he purchased a lot of cards. He is the OG Curio Card whale.
If you look at cards #21, 22, and 23, each of those cards is one of the founders — Thomas, Rhett, and Travis. There is the barbarian and those sorts of guys. He did that, and they accepted him as an artist. If you dig into Robek a little bit, he is now an uber collector, one of the real leaders of supporting new artists in the NFT space. He has been rewarded with his huge Curio Card collection. He sold out a lot of those. Basically turned that money back into buying new artists and collectors. So he works with [NFT platform] Foundation. If you go to his foundation profile, you will see he is a super collector.
Q: Adam, this has been fantastic. I hope to talk to you more soon about other projects!
# # #