Interview: NFT archeologist Adam McBride on CryptoPunks (Patreon)
Content
Revisiting the history of V1 Punks with NFT archeologist Adam McBride
Amy Castor and I have a post going up shortly about CryptoPunks.
(I also have one about Finblox, the latest casualty of the crypto collapse. I'm having a busy evening.)
What follows is an interview with NFT archeologist Adam McBride, which we're making available as a benefit to our patrons.
McBride is obsessed with the finer details of early NFT projects. In this interview with Amy, he takes use us through the early history of Punks and the captivating story of the V1 Punks.
CryptoPunks got off to a rough start in June 2017. Early mistakes long-buried came back to haunt them five years later. Edited for clarity. Additional notes and comments are in brackets.
AC: Nice to see you again, Adam. Let’s talk about CryptoPunks!
AM: CryptoPunks are the most important NFT project ever. Simply for that reason, they have made a global impact. Most people don’t know the V1 Punks story. When the two original developers released the Punks, they were free to claim. Gas back then was pennies, 50 cents, maybe a dollar.
AC: Eleven cents is what I noted. Basically, it was pennies.
AM: It was pennies, yes. But it was different from buying NFTs today. You had to know about Ethereum. You were early if you were into Ethereum in 2017. You had to get a wallet. A lot of people were using different wallets and all these weird interfaces. Nothing was easy. Getting money into the wallet wasn’t easy. Now you can get money in from Coinbase, right? You could back then, too, but it was a challenge.
AC: That’s something I hadn’t thought of. Ethereum launched in July 2015. It was just making its way into the world. The ICO boom was getting going. [Tweet; LarvaLabs website archive, June 10, 2017; github]
AM: ICOs were definitely starting then. That was when I purchased my first crypto. Because I tried to do a business to help companies launch ICOs. I saw ICOs for what they were, which is this incredible ability to raise funds from a global community. Of course, 99% of it was just money-grabbing scams.
It feels like a lot of the NFT market is the same. You get this, OMG, I’ll just get this global capital that is willing to pay me for nothing. And that is a lot of what the NFT market is now. So obviously there are going to be huge corrections to the NFT market as well. But yeah, ICOs were popping and all of this money was flooding in. Amidst that, CryptoPunks launched successfully to a very, very small group of people. It was a successful launch, but literally, there were people who grabbed [hundred of] CryptoPunks — super early adopters.
AC: Because everybody was distracted by ICOs, right?
AM: There were people thinking about NFTs, but nobody really understood that they were going to be big, that they were going to have this massive explosion in 2021. Nobody on earth could have predicted that. But in 2017, CryptoPunks didn’t make any money for the founders. It didn’t have a global impact. It was a very small group of people who even knew about it.
AC: Can you talk about how people bought Punks? MetaMask had been around since 2016, right?
AM: I can’t even honestly remember. I didn’t buy any Punks at the launch. I made some coins and learned how to code and stuff, and I can’t even remember what wallet I used. The whole idea of storing seed phrases. I have no idea what I did with my stuff back then. It is completely lost to the wind. And that’s what happened to a lot of people who were playing around with stuff back then.
AC: Stuff got lost.
AM: Yeah, stuff got lost. Because the reality was it had little to no value. It was virtually worthless. So are you really going to guard your seed phrase when this stuff is worth zero? It doesn’t even matter, right? It is dust in the wind. You don’t even care about it until X number of years later and these things are worth $200,000 each. And then you care, but it’s too late. So that is for sure what has happened with a lot of people. Everyone who was launching NFT projects back then was launching their own marketplace. The Punks had their own marketplace.
AC: Should we call them “NFT-like” projects, because the word NFT didn’t even exist back then.
AM: No, it was crypto-collectibles, crypto art. NFT wasn’t even a word back then. I don’t know if it was “digital collectibles”; I can’t even remember. I first heard about Punks on a podcast. It made sense to me because I’ve always liked collectibles and the idea of baseball cards on a blockchain. But I had no idea that it was going to be what it has become. Nobody got the crazy valuations, and that is why when V1 Punks, the first release of the CryptoPunks contract, had a bug in it, nobody really cared.
How the bug worked: If you listed your Punk for sale, the buyer put the money in to buy the Punk, they would then receive the Punk and then they could claim the ETH back as well.
AC: Before we get into V1, I want to make sure we talk about the founders of Punks — Matt Hall and John Watkinson. They were two Canadian programmers living in Brooklyn. They had a company called Larva Labs that had been around for a while. And their idea was to create a collection of 10,000 algorithmic avatars, which are like game sprites, right?
AM: There is a lot of resentment in the historical NFT community toward the founders of Punks for the way they literally branded CryptoPunks as the first NFT. They branded themselves as creating an entire space. And they clearly didn’t. They were inspired by Rare Pepes. They talked about Rare Pepes. There were blog posts that mention Rare Pepes. They are Reddit posts. They were speakers at events where they are literally talking about Rare Pepes. [Tweet]
AC: So they were influenced by these earlier projects but they weren’t really giving credit to them?
AM: They did not give credit. They basically said, “We’ve created this entire thing called NFTs.” And it’s like, wow, no you didn’t. They backtracked a little, but the reality is that these two guys were so ahead of the curve and rightly so, should be hailed as geniuses and innovators in the space without question, but they didn’t invent NFTs.
AC: Can we just talk about what they were trying to do? They were playing with this idea of scarcity and demand.
AM: You just nailed it. They were playing around.
AC: Before that, there were trading cards on the blockchain. Everything was like a trading card, right?
AM: No, there are lots of examples of one-of-one NFTs back then. There are examples of what we would now call PFP projects, where a lot of people were referring to CryptoPunks as a PFP or avatar. But they were calling them crypto art, digital collectibles.
AC: But why avatars? They were like these 1980s archaic-looking things. What was that about?
AM: Why they created those, in particular, I can’t say.
AC: Later on we had BAYC which were these cool-looking ape cartoons and you could do things with them in terms of the brand. But Punks, they were these pixelated avatars.
AM: I don’t believe in any way, they were forward-thinking enough to say, oh, people are going to use these as their avatars, PFPs and that’s going to be our marketing strategy.
AC: Why 10,000? It seems like all of the collectibles that came after Punks were 10,000 this, 10,000 that. They were the first.
AM: The NFT collectibles that came after were just mimicking Punks. The names escape me now, but there was an artist 20 years ago who did a collection, and I think he was the inspiration for Punks. [It wasn’t 10,000, but there is an artist who did 1,000 paintings]
AC: Larva Labs were not able to put the actual avatars on the blockchain. They had a hash to this composite image of all 10,000 Punks. They were not separated out. Why?
AM: They were experimenting. This is common across all old NFT projects. People were experimenting. Larva Labs did not know the best way to protect their copyright. Why would they even be concerned about their copyright? These things were basically worthless back then.
AC: Did they use IPFS?
AM: I can’t recall. But regardless now, they did change their contract structure so that now they are completely on-chain now. [No they did not use IPFS, tweet.]
AC: How do you change the contract structure if the smart contract is already on the blockchain? [Larva Labs blog post]
AM: You change how it points. It is a complicated process and a bunch of old projects have done that because current market sentiment rewards the idea of it being on-chain.
AC: So they just wrapped Punks in another smart contract? I can’t think of how else they would do this.
AM: I have no idea the technicalities of it, but there is magical coding. Mooncats, which is also a 2017 project, spent 10 ETH upgrading to new contracts, which basically recreate the Mooncats, putting all 26,000 Mooncats on chain. Literally, even if all was lost but the blockchain, you could recreate every Mooncat.
AC: So Larva Labs released Punks in June 2017 and all you needed was some ETH to pay for the transaction fee. They keep 1,000 for themselves, just in case they happen to go up in value.
AM: It’s actually a great strategy. We’ve seen people in the last few months revisit that strategy in the bear market where they are literally launching the project for free, so people will grab them. It’s a great way to build community quickly because your biggest fans get in cheap, and everybody is automatically made whole right from the very beginning.
AC: And that was really what held the Punks together all these years, community. They had a very strong community on Discord. Not the nicest group of people, though.
AM: Interesting. I haven’t had a negative experience there. But yeah, anonymous culture can bring out your true self. So if you are a good person, it brings out a good person. If you are not a good person, you’re not a good person if you are anonymous.
AC: Back to this V1, which I think is one of the most fascinating things about the CryptoPunks project. So they make a boo-boo and they release all of the Punks with an error in the smart contract on June 9. [June 17, 2017, Larva Labs tweets a warning]
AM: Exactly. And that error allowed as I said before, the buyer to buy your Punk. They would receive the Punk and then basically, refund the ETH to themselves. [According to Foobar, only the buyer could withdraw the ETH, The seller could not withdraw. tweet; tweet]
I talked to one of [the people who took the V1 Punks], and my brain is, wow, where is your ethical foundation? Don’t you consider that stealing? He was more of a “code is law” type of guy. He was also, which is a somewhat legitimate reason, like: “You have to understand, these were worthless at that point. They were literally free. So, yes, I was taking their Punks from them, but the Punks didn’t have any value.” This was two days after the Punks were launched. On top of that, people were made whole when Larva Labs air dropped the brand new V2 Punks into those wallets. [They airdopped V2 on June 23.]
AC: People were stealing Punks, or they were stealing ETH?
AM: I’ll put it like this. You have a CryptoPunk. You put it up for sale on the Larva Labs website. Say, you put it for sale for 1 ETH. I give you the 1 ETH, I get your Punk, and then I take the money back. So that was the method of withdrawal.
If you didn’t have your Punk for sale, there was no way for me to get it. But most people got their Punks for free and they immediately listed them for a price. And so there were literally hundreds and hundreds for sale, some at crazy 200 ETH, 300 ETH prices. But this one person got so emboldened, that they bought the ones that were for sale. Even the ones at 200 ETH, 300 ETH, which was a lot even then.
AC: So it was just a few people stealing the V1s?
AM: Just a few people. Because they figured it out. Their moral compass didn’t kick in and they just took them.
AC: Did Punks have a Discord community early on?
AM: I don’t know when their Discord community came along. [It was announced on June 28, 2017, by Larva Labs. Tweet]
A lot of this was Telegram back then. I haven’t gone back to the beginning of their Discord, but that and the Kitties’ Discord are the two oldest Discords. And they’ve died down. When the markets tank, these always fall to almost zero. And we’ve seen that in the last few months. Whenever people lose money, interest completely evaporates. It’s not just NFTs. I’ve been in stocks and options and that kind of stuff. It is the same thing across the board.
AC: So V2 comes out. They airdrop those on the original V1 holders and say, “Hey, use these instead.” And everyone forgets about V1.
AM: Everyone basically trades V2. In 2020, the Punks really started moving again. That’s what actually got me re-interested in NFTs.
AC: What is interesting to me is how the community just sauntered along. It still existed. A lot of early NFT projects disappeared. But this one kept itself alive after 2017.
AM: Just as with Rare Pepes, you get a small group of holders who believe in the project right from the beginning. Early on, there were people selling Punks for 100s of dollars in ETH. And people were like, whoa! I just got $200 for something that was free. People were incredibly excited about this. And then it fades and dies away. Then it comes back again. This is the third cycle of Pepes.
But what’s different with NFTs compared to coins is that they don’t go away. They are still there and you get this new influx of interest from collectors and when that influx comes — and this is like, the Punk's second cycle — and you had a huge increase in interest. And Punks have reached a global audience, which is amazing. That is the differentiator. NFTs stay around. They don’t go away. When interest cycles into them again, you can have these tremendous runups.
AC: So in 2021, the community develops a wrapper for V1 Punks. In the past, the only place to trade Punks was on the Larva Labs website. Third-party marketplaces like OpenSea didn’t exist yet. So OpenSea comes along, the NFT boom comes along, and someone decides, “Hey, let's bring V1 back to life.”
AM: Basically, on [March 25, 2021], a guy named Foobar on Twitter built a wrapper. In the historical NFT community, people were aware of these V1s. And so he built the wrapper and V1 Punks were selling on OpenSea for a brief period. And then LarvaLabs put a DCMA order against it, and V1 got taken off OpenSea.
AC: And the wrapper fixes the bug?
AM: It fixes the bug and makes those tokens viewable by modern marketplaces. They are all using the ERC721 standard, allowing them to be visible on OpenSea. So when Foobar did that, V1 was available for a brief period on OpenSea. When Larva Labs got it taken down from OpenSea, there wasn’t a LooksRare back then. There wasn’t really any other place to put the wrapper so it just died away.
AC: When did one of the Larva Labs founders dump their own V1 stash?
AM: The next step was, that the guys who had large V1 Punk holdings decided to get back in the game and do their own wrapper. Because they have a huge monetary reason.
AC: Why didn’t they just use Foobar’s wrapper?
AM: I believe Foobar may have charged a percentage of sales on his wrapper. [Foobar denies this. He claims Hemba cloned his wrapper and created a wrapper with a new exploit. Hemba denies Foobar’s claims as well, so there you have it.]
They wanted to make their wrapper free. They wanted to have a wrapper and a website so that even if the wrapper was removed from OpenSea they would still have a marketplace for buying and selling. They had a much larger strategy than Foobar had. They were thinking, yeah, let’s get it on OpenSea, but also if it gets removed from OpenSea, we’re still going to have a platform to trade it on. So for that reason, they built their own wrapper.
They built a wrapper, got community interest, got V1 onto OpenSea, and then Larva Labs fumbled the ball completely, and actually did them a huge favor. Larva Labs tweeted about it in a really incredibly poor way. And this generated so much buzz that it actually launched V1 Punks. It was critical to their success that Larva Labs actually FUDed it and brought a whole bunch of attention to the V1 Punks.
AC: So, when did Larva Labs founder dump their V1s?
AM: They didn’t sell all of them. They sold some. I think it turned out to be $400,000 worth? I can’t remember. [They sold 39 V1 Punks for 260 ETH, worth $460,000, according to NFT Ethics.]
Larva Labs’ tweet was basically: “We sold these. These are worthless, and there you go. [Tweet]
It was the worst PR strategy. Imagine you sold something to somebody and then the moment you sold it, you are like, “That’s a piece of garbage.” It’s just the worst of humanity, like what kind of person are you? I think it highlighted what LarvaLabs is, which is, that they are good creatives, but they are terrible at community management, the worst. I believe they recognized that weakness, and that was a key reason why they actually sold [the IP to Yuga Labs in March 2022.]
AC: It looked like they were just after the money?
AM: It looked like they were trying to get the money. They then backtracked and donated the money to the rainforest. [Laughs.]
AC: They also said they were going to use the money to buy V2 Punks [and Meebits.]
AM: It was just the worst, so bad from a PR strategy. If you literally thought these were garbage, and you were going to do everything to crush those, what kind of person would sell something like that? What kind of ethics is that? It is not only a money grab. It is immoral. You are going to sell it and then you are going to tell everybody on earth that what you sold is a piece of garbage. It is unconscionable. It couldn’t have been better PR for V1.
AC: Here is what they wrote on their Discord: “Let there be no confusion about the legitimacy of this V1 project. It has no right to use the art or the name.”
AM: That turned out to be not right either. I talked to some amazing IP lawyers and it’s very, very fuzzy that Larva Labs has any copyrightable stuff at all here.
AC: Do you mean with the V1? It was their own project!
AM: It was their own project, but very, very difficult to IP a 24x24 pixel piece of art. Extremely difficult to do that. When they copyrighted the Punks. They copyrighted the full 10,000 images. That entire image. They didn’t do each individual one. It was very murky whether or not they had any copyright claims at all. And V1 Punks, because those guys have literally hundreds of millions of dollars, they were willing to fight it. They actually had lawyers set up. They actually fought on OpenSea. Their wrapper got taken down. They fought it, and they won. It got put back up.
When Larva Labs put out that Tweet, they got so much blowback, not only from V1 holders, but also from their own community from the poor handling. It was a big moment for them when they realized, “Maybe we are not best equipped to handle this going forward.” And I think it was a big move for them to sell to YugaLabs [in March 2022.]. Because it highlighted for them that maybe we are really not community managers.
AC: And they had already made their money. They sold [9 rare Punks at Christie's for $16.9 million on May 11, 2021.]
AM: They have made tons of money. In their Meebit sale, they made over $80 million.
AC: What were the Autoglyphs?
AM: This is why I hold them in the highest esteem as far as NFTs go. Autoglyphs was the second successful project from them. It was launched in 2019. It was onchain generative art.
The mechanism for generating the art is all on the blockchain. Those images are made by taking a time-stamp hash of when it was minted and generating art based on that time-stamp hash. So the mechanism for generating that is all on the blockchain. That’s why, if you’ve seen them, they are very simple images. It pushed a ball forward in that it was really responsible for the giant art blocks generative art explosion in 2021.
AC: How many Autoglyphs were there?
AM: It’s a much smaller project than Punks, only 512 Autoglyphs.
AC: Did those ever go for big money?
AM: Omg. They are some of the most sought-after NFTs. The floor price is $180,000.
AC: Then we get to Meebits in 2021. The Meebits got more attention.
AM: This is what we mean about attention. Not as many people knew about Autoglyphs because there were only 512 people that could possibly claim them. So creating a community with a set this small is hard. And that is why 10,000 has worked so well. Because you can get this broad group of people. And Meebits was actually 20,000.
In 2021, if you had a Punk, you had the ability to claim a Meebit for free. And then they sold the rest of the Meebits into the marketplace. [LL sold Autoglyphs to raise money for a charity, according to their website. They did not keep any for themselves.]
AC: This is very similar to what Yuga Labs did with their Mutant Apes later on. You could claim 10,000 and then they sold the other 10,000 at auction.
AM: Larva Labs made $75 million that afternoon when they sold the Meebits. And because they are catering to this high-end crowd, which are Punk holders, basically gifting them $7,000 at that time, it is great for the holdings. I don’t know how great it is for the people who are aping in, but right now, I’m looking at the floor price for Meebits, and it’s $8,000. So it is probably the same as when they dropped because the price of ETH has done some crazy stuff but, yeah, these guys… I can’t give them enough credit for how forward-thinking and innovative they were.
AC: In August 2021, Larva Labs signed with United Talent Agency. Whatever happened to that? Anything?
AM: There is this alternative thought process that these guys are so smart that the FUD they were doing on V1 Punks, the signing with the talent agency, the DCMAing people who tried to put alternative Punk versions on OpenSea. All of this FUDing and poor community management and people were like, “What are they doing, they are idiots, why would they do that?” People are like, “Are we talking about them? Are we talking about them?” And I’m like, omg, maybe these guys are geniuses who figured they would create all of this chatter around their projects.
AC: There is a lot to be said about being first though. They were first and then they were copied by Yuga Labs who ended up making a lot of money. Who got a huge investment from a16z. Punks didn’t have any VCs backing them.
AM: Yes, but obviously, they weren’t trying. And as they put it on their exit tweet: Mea Culpa, we suck at community management and we suck at building community. We are good innovators and project developers but we are not good at the second step that we all see is required. [Amy: I can’t find this exit tweet.]
AC: So, on March 11, 2022, Larva Labs sell the IP for CryptoPunks and Meebits to Yuga. And they gave them the developer Punks and Meebits as part of the deal. I mean, they are not really selling the entire project, are they? [Tweet]
AM: No, I would consider that the project has been sold. The thing is, what did Yuga Labs buy? They also got the V1 Punks, which was not disclosed.
AC: And that makes sense because if someone tries to resurrect the V1 Punks, they can police that.
AM: I think for the V1 Punkholders, it was viewed as a huge positive, having Yuga now in charge. Yuga has a much more inclusive vision of what Web3 is.
AC: They have a lot of funding behind them, too.
AM: Tons of funding, but more importantly for V1 holders is this idea that they want to encourage the V1 holders to build. So they want to encourage the idea that you own your Punk's IP rights. So you can build on top of that.
AC: What good is that though? You are creating derivative products.
AM: Not necessarily. You know @Punk6529, right? Very famous Twitter influencer. He has created a brand that is tied to that Punk. He can never sell that Punk. If Larva Labs owned that brand, they could prevent him from doing things with that brand. The reality is that he actually owns that 6529 brand and nobody can take it away from him. And that is really important.
We are only just beginning. People think it is going to be an image on a coffee mug or something like that. No, it is much different and it’s bigger than that. We are only beginning to scratch the surface of it, and 6529 is something that is easy to understand. Some people still don’t get it, like “Why would you want to create a brand around a Punk?”
You will start to see more things developed around these projects. We are at the baby steps. We are at the first stages, so we can’t see the full picture of how it will progress. I do know that it is very important that the IP is held by the individual NFT holders. Very, very important in Web3.
AC: One other thing I want to ask about. Visa bought a Punk in August 2021. What was that about? They tweeted: “Visa Welcomes CryptoPunks 7610 to our collection.”
AM: These companies are smart, and they have smart marketing departments. They realize that a $200,000 purchase, which they could then sell again and get their $200,000 back, is the cheapest ad buy ever. You just got put in the WSJ and CNBC Finance. I think they look at it as a cheap ad buy.
AC: Adam, it was great talking to you, as always. Thank you!
# # #