which shading style?! (Patreon)

HI this is a bit unusual but i was working on one of my sticker designs for this month's sticker club (tiers 4 and 6) and after rendering frankie i wondered if it went too far and would just look better with cell shading?!

which one do you guys prefer?

disclaimer i may just end up reworking it entirely after i sleep lol but id love to know what style you guys are more drawn to!!