Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Your Thoughts on the Latest Video?

I’d love to hear your feedback. It seems reasonably well received, but the Click-Through Rate (CTR) - which measures how many people click the video when it appears in their feed - is lower than usual. I’d like to find out if it's because the thumbnail / title combination isn’t really working, or if airships, as a topic, don't have the same appeal as the others on the channel?

Merch Idea – USS Akron/Macon Cutaway Print

I’ve been thinking about creating a cutaway drawing of the USS Akron/Macon, similar to the one I made for the Nautilus (especially since most of the work was already done for the video). This would feature illustrations of the airship’s interior spaces, showing how it functioned as a flying aircraft carrier, along with technical annotations (callout boxes with text). If you're interested, let me know which style you think works best:

What’s Next?

Production on Operation Bolo, is well underway. The USS Akron/Macon video ended up taking much longer than expected, partly because we moved to Unreal Engine for most of the visuals. That was a learning curve on its own, but the real challenge was the sheer amount of graphics we wanted to include for a 20 minute video.

Looking ahead, the next video for YouTube will shift focus to a maritime disaster and mystery. It’s one of those stories that has been largely overlooked but is absolutely worth telling.

As always, thank you for your continued support. Let me know your thoughts on the video and the merch idea in the comments!

Gabe

Files

Comments

Carlos Hernandez Sanchez

Probably an outlier here but I usually “save them” to watch later - I wonder if the algorithm penalises this behaviour

Michael Wagner

With frequency of posting down, you may have lost some casual viewers, but that will likely change. It’s also a niche topic that most interested in aviation or military history may not have rushed in to watch. I’m really excited to see you back but the topic really didn’t scratch that Mustard itch for me, exactly.

Bob Johnson

I started to watch the latest (which is fantastic!) on Patreon but family showed up, so I ended up finishing it on YouTube when I saw it posted there. As for merch I think that's a great idea and my vote would be for option C as the Akron navigates the stormy skies!

Blocky's World

I would be very interested in a behind-the-scenes overview of the transition to UnReal. Probably not of general interest, maybe better suited for a tutorial. I’ve fantasized about transitioning to UnReal but have been discouraged by the sheer learning curve. Seeing how you made the jump could be very encouraging.

Delft Trains

For the newest video, maybe the thumbnail is a bit cluttered? If I compare it to the other thumbnails, there the subject stands out more. For the merch I vote for A, I think that one is also the most easy to adapt to different usages (shirt/poster etc.)

Grant H Borman

I'm in a similar boat to Miachael Wagner on this one. I enjoyed it alot but most of the time I have a "Mustard high" and this time i didn't. I will reach watch and report back with some more helpful observations. Love what you are doing. Keep it up!

Martin Holmström

I usually watch on Nebula but am subscribed on youtube to know when a new episode is uploaded but I dont click the youtube video.Doubt there are enough like me to affect the statistics though

North525

I loved the latest video and am a big fan of airship history in general, so I'm sorry to hear the video isn't generating interest the way others have and hope it's not because people don't find them interesting. For what it's worth I thought the thumbnail was good. Maybe people didn't understand the "aircraft carrier" part immediately? I would also be interested in the airship print (your renders are reminiscent of Max Pinucci's very cool "airships" book). Option C has a kind of cool-factor to it with the interior lights throwing contrast into it, but option B would probably be the best-looking on a wall.

Kevin Berne

The new video is as great and exciting as all the others. I loved watching it so I couldn't really tell you why other people wouldn't. Keep up the great work!

Gengis

I really liked the video and story you told, I believe I personally watched it a couple of hours after the upload. No complaints here, and I must say the clouds and overall scene seem to be a lot better in this video! Personally, I like the look of poster version A the most but I am a sucker for that sort of clean aesthetic. So might just be me.

Paul DeWys

I am not a huge air ship fan, but I always watch every video you post because I know you will make any topic interesting, and this one did not disappoint! If the History Channel or Discovery had a clue, they would be knocking down the door of creators like you to produce content for them, but instead we get more big foot and ancient aliens. I cut my cable subscription years ago and put all of it into supporting people like you. Keep up the great work, can’t wait to see what you put out next!

Sam Wise

One minor criticism I had was about the start, as it transitioned through all the archival clips, you put a blur effect on the changes which I found quite uncomfortable. Personally I found it absolutely fascinating and felt it pretty on-brand for Mustard though, but maybe airships just don't hit like planes do. I agree with others that perhaps the thumbnail is a bit busy, especially the circle round the plane which came across a bit, like, content-creatory.

Kiskaloo

I found it to be very entertaining and well worth the watch. I did watch it on Nebula, not YouTube.

Will K

Love that you are still using your voice for the narration. I did not like the guest star a few episodes back or rather maybe that you leaned on him a little too much. Your cadence and delivery was one of the main reasons I was drawn to the channel to begin with, along with absolutely being able to nail the spirit and tone of the era of your subject matter. You really feel like you're in the decade and it has a powerful impact on engagement. I liked the episode but with regard to your comment about lower views I think it's simple; airships are old, slow, lumbering, and not terribly exciting subject matter outside of a few hardcore fans and folks who enjoy aviation in general. I would have suggested adding some more detail and time to the fighter escorts. Anyway I've been waiting for someone to put out a full length comprehensive documentary chronicling the history of US military aviation (including SAC, TAC, hardware, weapons) akin to the old discovery Wings series and you would be just the guy to pull off such an ambitious project. I would pay GOOD money. Love your channel - seriously my favorite Youtube channel and its not really close. I look forward to your new releases like they're the next Batman movie. Only better. Thank you for sharing your passion, dedication and talent. It is very much appreciated.

Dave Gilbert

I prefer "C" for the merch idea poster. My only suggestion is to fully render the biplanes instead of silhouetting them in red. I would also LOVE to see more videos on airships! I think they are fascinating!

Dave Gilbert

I'm not sure if this would make financial sense for you to offer as merch, but what about leveraging your model & texturing work to create a VR experience that you could market on Steam? Even something as simple as a quick walkaround of the models you have created would just be stunning in VR. Unreal Engine deploys beautifully to VR. My immediate reaction to your video on the CL-1201 was "OMG! I need to see this monster in VR to get a feel for the actual size!!!". I wouldn't put the time into trying to make it into a game of any type, just a life-sized rendering that you could walk around (and maybe inside too) as an extra feature to follow up the videos.

Mark Davis

I did thoroughly enjoy the video. This was a brand-new subject for me and I really liked that you provided a healthy mix of historical context and action-oriented storytelling. I can't speak to why the click-rate was lower, but you do AMAZING work. NO ONE has the beautiful imagery, textures, and engaging stories like you. I signed up for Curiosity Stream specifically due to your craftsmanship. Keep up the great work and don't get yourself down!

Mark Davis

I would also buy merchandise with your beautifully rendered art. I love the idea of VR, but won't put that kind of work on you!