Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

I’m certain there are millions of people who know me for one thing and one thing only. Not Turnabout Musical, Brawl in the Family, Tadpole Treble, Gamemaster Classified or BitMusical. Nope—it’s as the guy who does those covers of songs using a Waluigi voice. These began during the days of the comic and I made a few more solely to promote my Waluigi book spinoff, but it blindsided me with how ubiquitous they’d become. Or were, anyway.

My most popular video ever—by far—is “Wa-Elegy,” with 11 million views. By comparison, my latest Waluigi Sings video has 27 thousand views, which is around 0.2% of Wa-Elegy’s count. While there are many factors that affect views (such as timing, luck, and that inscrutable algorithm), I can’t help but feel that much of these dwindling numbers is due to a more crowded marketplace nowadays.

AI seems to be one of those subjects that everyone has an opinion on, doesn’t it? And why shouldn’t it? With a few prompts, you can have original images, songs, and even videos created essentially out of thin air. Whether or not these works qualify as art is already a heated debate (and not one I’m really interested on weighing into today) but there’s no doubt people like me are already feeling the repurcussions.

To that end, it’s easy nowadays to find an AI version of WAluIgi singing a pop song or standard, just as one can find Sinatra crooning Gangsta’s Paradise or Johnny Cash belting out Barbie Girl. If you’d asked me five years ago if I thought my niche of Nintendo drawings and Waa covers would be the next jobs affected by automation, I would’ve laughed in your face (Waluigi style). And yet here we are, in a world where Arnold Schwarzenegger longs to be Somewhere Over the Rainbow!

Don’t be alarmed though—Waluigi’s sticking around and more videos will be coming from us per my 2024 schedule. But I do hope people get something more out of them than they could from an AI one. It’s part of the reason I add in harmonies and other extra parts, ad-libbing, some line changes, etc. Gotta adapt with what’s out there, after all!

I’m curious what your own thoughts on this topic are, not just for my specific niche but also for visual design (which is a field I also happen to be involved in). Does the existence of AI content affect where you look for entertainment and art? And for those of you out there who are also YouTubers, I’ve heard that views were dropping rapidly for a number of creators; have you felt these effects firsthand? Personally, I’m going to continue to make everything by hand (and throat), because I think the end results are worth it.

Your carbon-based singer,

-Matthew

Files

Previews only

Comments

PigDan

Good points. It's crazy how much it's been dominating as a major universal discussion.. and how much it's ending up being used for stupid memes, music and art (reactions ranging from awe to concern). I deliberately try to find legitimate creations made by humans -- I'm frustrated by the search engine image results being flooded with this AI art garbage whenever you're trying to find useful results, and this is pretty recently! A lot of it people associated with it immediately get roped into being looked through a negative lens and under greater scrutiny, thankfully. Usage already seems to be largely synonymous with cutting corners when used with professional projects (like for example when game devs are caught using it, perhaps due to lack of budget or effort, and I'm sure it really leaves a sour impression about their creativity level and questionable character). I appreciate the real human effort put on screen, the hours upon hours of hard work that one goes through to create something from thin-air, trained by experience and natural inspirations rather than dubiously obtained code, and not what trained software can attempt to replicate (it's undoubtedly impressive but for most people it feels immediately wrong, with one major talking point being the training models AI uses without consent). The implications of AI being used for unethical purposes are a serious and enormous concern I'm sure. I'm seeing it being mentioned everywhere

PigDan

That Waluigi video you made seems very naturally fitting to be an algorithm hit. It's a very famous song, simple to understand.. silliness and absurdity can very much be prone to viral-ness, especially when it comes to the younger generations where short-form, crazy memes are insanely popular (humor definitely gets people clicking on videos, and Waluigi has been a prevalent meme to a certain extent for years). The algorithm has frustrated creators for years, sometimes not even pushing videos to people at all. I think with the right mixture of circumstances, the rest of your videos could get more views with time.

Jonathan Stein

I've been trying to keep a distance from AI-generated art and videos on YouTube and elsewhere. I've also found myself just... not browsing YouTube like I used to. There were days in the past where I'd just be on for hours, catching up on every video from whatever channels I subscribed to and watching whatever comes up. But these days I mostly... don't. I'll usually go on to look up something specific, and have graduated to other platforms (like Patreon) to let me know when I should dive back into Youtube to find what new content I want to see. I still find the genuine human talent (singing, art, writing) to be the more impressive, and I strongly hope that it won't start being used to squeeze out whatever artistic niches it can find. I know the EU has recently put out some restrictions on AI content, including requirements that it be labeled as AI-generated, and while I imagine that kind of stuff is hard to detect and that there will always be people trying to take advantage of systems, I still feel ultimately hopeful that this, too, shall pass. And in the meantime, I look forward to more videos, Waluigi and otherwise!