The One Misstep with Smash Bros's Soundtrack (Patreon)
Content
Ah, Super Smash Bros, where would we be without you? The series set the standard for game crossovers in how it respects the original properties to a level of detail only Masahiro Sakurai could handle. And that also applies to its incredible soundtrack, which features over a thousand songs across dozens of different gaming series.
It should come as no surprise that I’m a fan of Smash’s music, as it has yet to get old even while I’m being juggled zero-to-death by an enterprising Bayonetta. The selection often pulls from the biggest hits (here’s the Mario theme everyone knows, your Jungle Hijinx, your Zelda theme) as well as some beloved cult classics (Yoshi’s Island Athletic, Molgera, Ice Cream Island from Kirby). It goes without saying that the Smash Bros team deserves a heaping helping of thumbs-ups for the breadth and scope that its music selection provides. It can’t have been easy to assemble and arrange the hundreds and hundreds of tracks here and the vast majority of them sound great.
Now! I’m taking off my “giving deserved props” hat and putting on my “grumpy sourpuss” hat to point out the one major flaw that plagues Smash Bros’s music!
The 2-minute song limit in Smash 3DS/Wii U.
If you look closely, you’ll notice that the songs added in the 3DS and Wii U version of the game adhere to a strict 2 minute limit before looping. I think this is because the games were really leaning hard into 2-minute-long matches and wanted the songs to loop/end around the natural endpoint of these throwdowns. The problem is that imposing such an arbitrary limitation really stifles creativity and messes with existing songs' structures.

This is Fire Emblem: Awakening's Id (Purpose), a beautiful piece of music and one of my favorite songs in the 3DS game. It's intense and majestic, perfect for a battle in Smash Bros! Pay special attention to these sections: 0:58-1:28 and 2:00-2:32. Then listen to the vocal part and how it builds over five separate choruses, each adding in a new instrument and/or part. Amazing!
Here's the Smash Bros. 3DS/Wii U version. At first, it sounds like the same song...but it's actually half as long as the original! At 1 minute, it completely skips the B section and the second refrain and goes right into the C part (with the chanting). Then the C part doesn't have the same type of build-up as it does in the original, using three total sets instead of the original's grander crescendo through five.
Similar cuts can also be heard--or NOT heard, rather--in two of my favorite Nintendo songs of the 2010s, Reset Bomb Forest [Kid Icarus Uprising] and Gaur Plains [Xenoblade Chronicles], where both tunes have had several sections cut out or excluded to accommodate the limit. And even existing songs had gotten shortened to fit the limit, such as the DK Rap which drops Lanky and Chunky’s verses.
The problem with the 2-minute limit is that it's just awkward to be forced to write a song within a certain time-frame. You don't have the same sense of freedom--like, if you finish your verse and refrain by the 1:40 mark, there's not really a whole lot you can do then except make up some "filler" to vamp for time until the loop point, whereas with no limit, you might've been inspired to do a C section and loop the song at around 2:30 or something, making for a much more varied listening experience. You can hear this effect in a lot of songs, such as the Good Egg Galaxy remix, where it randomly goes off into the 1-2 theme and then the Starman theme, presumably since they’re quick ways to fill up space to reach two minutes without committing to a new verse.
So I had to get that off my chest. It sounds nitpicky, but these songs were originally written with purpose and to have them cut and re-finagled to fit an arbitrary limit is a disservice to the original composers and their work. But to be fair, this rule has at least relaxed a bit with Super Smash Bros Ultimate, with several songs running shorter or longer again! The cut ones from Smash 4 are sadly still truncated (such as the DK Rap and Reset Bomb Forest)…but I can at least take solace that Fire Emblem’s Id DID get a full remix that finally does the original song justice! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbyl2-Jesfo
I don’t know how dense these articles are for you to read, but I find video game music endlessly fascinating, so I’d like to regularly make new ones on this Patreon featuring my thoughts on the subject. I do enjoy talking about music, ranking songs, making top tens and the like, so I’m curious what sorts of things YOU’D like to see on that subject. Let me know, and take care!
Thanks,
-Matthew
Files
Previews only