Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello and welcome to the Not A Cast … podcast: the one true chapter-by-chapter podcast going through A Song of Ice and Fire one chapter a week. I’m one of your hosts Jeff better known as BryndenBFish. 

And I’m your other host Emmett, better known as PoorQuentyn. 

Welcome to our twenty-ninth episode of the Not A Cast entitled: “Better Than The Songs: An Analysis of AGOT, Sansa II,” in which Sansa Stark is swept up in the glory and romance of the Hand’s Tourney before being brought face to face with some harsh realities. This episode is brought to you all by our Lords Commander Mark N, Timothy W, Hayden J, WolfmanZack, and Joe L. Thank you, gentlemen!

Emmett intros Chloe

Chloe introduces herself

Spoiler warning: All published books - 5 novels, 3 Dunk and Egg novellas, histories, interviews, TWOW sample chapters, as well as Game of Thrones the TV show. Anything and everything!

Question

Old Sadie, one of our Sworn Swords asks:

Hello boys!
If this question is foolish please ignore it.
I was thinking about the proposed spin-off TV show being set during the first Long Night, and I was wondering if the Stark words are maybe prophetic. We all know that the season of winter is coming, and does so a bit irregularly, but do you think they might also mean that true winter will come again i.e. the second Long Night? Or maybe Bran the Builder was confident enough when he built the Wall that it would keep out any potential threats to Westeros. 
Thanks again for the podcast, I really enjoy it.
(Old) Sadie

Reminder that the Robert Baratheon patreon-only episode is out now!

Synopsis

Two weeks after Catelyn arrests Tyrion at the Inn at the Crossroads, Westeros is blissfully unaware of the coming disaster, but all of that is about to change in a few days. And who better to symbolize this bliss and looming cataclysm than Sansa Stark: the eldest daughter of Lord Eddard Stark. 

Sansa Stark rides in a litter along with Jeyne Poole and Septa Mordane, and the world is magical and full of joy. You see, Sansa and company are on their way to the Hand’s Tourney after Sansa convinced her father to allow her to watch the tourney back in Arya’s second AGOT chapter. And it’s a beauty and wonder to behold -- at least for Sansa.

Outside the city walls, the knights and lords have set splendid pavilions alongside of beautiful horses, wondrous sigils and glorious suits of arms. But Sansa is enamored most of all by the knights.

It’s better than the songs, Sansa whispers to herself.

And so it was … for the moment. Sansa checks out all the great men at the tournament, the knights and lords who the singers had sung about. There’s Jaime Lannister, armored in gold, there, the enormous Gregor Clegane, over here Bronze Yohn Royce with his bronze armored with magical runes running through it, and here, Lord Jason Mallister who had killed three of Rhaegar’s bannermen on the Trident with his silver armor and then there’s the curiosity of Thoros of Myr with his red priest robes and shaven head. But he’s not necessarily a figure of mockery as Septa Mordane points out. Thoros had scaled the walls of Pyke with a flaming sword in hand during the Greyjoy Rebellion.

But there were others too. More knights from the Vale, Stormlands, Reach and Riverlands are here. Sandor Clegane is participating as Jory Cassel - though Sansa is unimpressed with his regular-looking armor. Additionally, two of Ned’s household guards Alyn and Harwin are #InIt2WinIt. And there’s other curiosities: Jalabhar Xho and his cape of green and scarlet feathers scares Jeyne Poole. But Lord Beric Dondarrion with his red gold hair and his black shield slashed by lightning, and Jeyne Poole is in love. Poor Jeyne. Poor Beric.

Anyways, we’re off to the races … jousts … whatever. Jory does well despite his unadorned armor, unhorsing Horas Redwyne and one of the Frey knights. But in his third match, Lothor Brune and Jory tilt thrice and though neither man is knocked from his horse, Lothor is declared the winner for having a steadier lance. Meanwhile, the other Stark bannermen aren’t doing so hot. Harwin is unhorsed by Meryn Trant and Alyn fell to Ser Balon Swann.

But no worries for that matter, the jousting goes on and on and on. Jeyne and Sansa watch horses and riders plunging into each other with lances (Phrasing) over and over again until the ground is a torn wreck. Jeyne looked away when the riders collide, but Sansa watches and keeps composed to the approval of Septa Mordane. But as the day wore on, there were several clear front runners to win the Hand’s Tourney.

Ser Jaime Lannister and Barristan Selmy of the Kingsguard rode exceptionally well. And the Clegane brothers fought with a ferocity that belied belief. Gregor Clegane was so ferocious that he “accidentally” killed a completely, totally random Vale Knight who he just “happened” to be riding against. And who was this Vale knight? Oh, we’re going to talk about him quite a bit.

The death of this man from the Vale sent Jeyne Poole into hysterics, but Sansa’s skin is in the process of turning to ivory (we’re not at the steel stage yet), and she watches on unemotionally. She might have felt differently if the man who fell was her father or Jory or Ser Rodrik, but this dude was just some stranger who name she couldn’t even remember. That said, she does feel sad but not exactly that the man had died. Rather, she feels sad that there will be no songs sung for him. Ehhh, not a great look, Sansa. 

Anyways, after a boy shovels mud over the spot where the Valeman died, the tilting resumes. It’s back to the beauty and majesty of the tilt. Balon Swann, who had defeated Alyn, fell to Gregor Clegane, Lord Renly Baratheon to Sandor Clegane. When Renly was knocked from his horse (very satisfactorily, I might add), he had hit the ground hard with a crack. Unsatisfactorily, he hadn’t broken his neck and had only cracked a tine from his antlered helm.

As a token of his empty and Robert-esque careless generosity, he’d offered the golden tine to Sandor who immediately tossed the golden branch into the commons. This resulted in a mini-brawl as smallfolk fought over a little bit of gold until Renly walked into the crowd and restored the peace.

More tournament feats follow. A hedge knight was declared forfeit after killing Beric Dondarrion’s horse. Beric himself fell to Thoros of Myr. Others tilted and fell or rose triumphant, but by the end of the day when the tourney was called to a temporary halt, only four remained: Sandor Clegane, Jaime Lannister, Loras Tyrell and Gregor Clegane.

But before that, Loras Tyrell tilts one last time against Ser Robar Royce, second son of Bronze Yohn Royce. And what had Loras done before the match? Why, Loras had given a beautiful, red flower to Sansa Stark herself, saying: Sweet lady, no victory is half so beautiful as you. Sansa had fallen in love with that moment, but it’s all despoiled when someone else comes up to Sansa.

Yes, it’s that goddamn sonofabitch Littlefinger who gets into Lord Creepyfinger mode. He smells of mint and comments that Sansa has the Tully look like her mother. He brushes a strand of hair from her face. You have her hair, Creepyfinger says before walking away, like the goddamn grooming asshole that he is. I digress, but not really. Littlefinger being a creepy asshole with Sansa will be a recurring theme in ASOIAF.

But with the final four competitors emerging victorious from the day, it’s feast time in King’s Landing, baby! Oh, we are going to be getting so much food porn! The smallfolk head off to get drunk or some shit, but the highborn are off to eat on the riverside. There’s roast aurochs basted with butter and herbs, sweetgrass and strawberries adorning the tables and hot, freshly-baked bread. Yum-yum.

Sansa and Septa Mordane are given a seat at the high table -- a high honor. And who other than the beautiful Prince Joffrey comes to sit by Sansa. Sansa thinks back to the last time Joffrey spoke to her. It was at Castle Darry. The Prince hadn’t breathed a word to her since then, but now he’s here, and oh! He had nothing to do with the death of Lady. That was Queen Cersei and her sister Arya, and she couldn’t hate Joffrey. Not tonight at least.

And then Joffrey actually speaks to her! He compliments Loras on selecting Sansa for her beauty. When Sansa breathlessly asks if Loras will win tomorrow, Joff scoffs that Sandor or Jaime will defeat Sandor. And in one blink of a moment, Joffrey is not wrong about something.

Anyways, Joffrey the Creep begins doing that really awesome thing again by trying to get Sansa drunk by filling and refilling her cup with wine. But Sansa doesn’t get drunk on the wine. She gets drunk on the experience. The magic of feast, the singers, the fools, but most of all, Sansa is drunk on Joffrey and how he showered her with compliments, court gossip, even explaining Moon Boy’s jokes to Sansa.

But wait. More food porn! Joff slices a queen’s portion of roast aurochs for Sansa. Then Sansa recites the chapter titles from A Feast of Ice and Fire and talks about more food: sweetbreads, pigeon pie, lemon cakes. But as Sansa is about to eat her third lemon cake, a mighty roar rises above the majesty of the moment.

It’s King Robert Baratheon yelling at Cersei Lannister at the top of his lungs

No! You do not tell me what to do, woman. I am king here, do you understand? I rule here, and if I say that I will fight tomorrow, I will fight!

Oh boy. Everyone is staring at Robert, but Sansa notices Renly and Barristan near Robert too. And who is Robert yelling at? Ah, yes. It’s Cersei who is described in overt Snow White Evil Queen terms as having a face like a mask, so bloodless that it might have been sculpted from snow. 

The queen gathers her skirts around her and walks away from Robert with servants in trail. But Robert remains. Ser Jaime puts a hand on the king’s shoulder, but Robert shoves him away, telling the kingslayer that he can still knock him into the dirt before slapping his chest with his wine cup.

Give me my hammer and not a man in the realm can stand before me! Robert roars.

Jaime stiffly agrees, and Renly comes “helpfully” forward offering to bring a fresh goblet of wine for Robert. Sigh. More on that in our patreon-only episode about Robert. 

When Sansa finally turns back to Joffrey, she finds him with a queer look on his face as if he wasn’t seeing her at all. Joff asks if she needs an escort home. Sansa begins to say no, but then she turns and sees that Septa Mordane has passed out like the negligent mother figure she is. Sansa quickly changes her mind and asks for an escort thinking that Joff will take her home.

But it’s not Joffrey who will escort Sansa back. Oh no. Joffrey calls for Sandor Clegane to escort Sansa home and then stalks off. Sandor immediately begins laughing at Sansa’s not-exactly-unfounded naivete in thinking Joff would be the one to escort her home, and then pulls Sansa to her feet to take her home.

Sansa is terrified now and tries to wake Mordane to no avail. And now even Robert is stumbling off and now the benches were clearing.

The feast was over, and the beautiful dream had ended with it, Sansa thinks.

She’s not wrong. Sandor Clegane leads her through King’s Landing, and Sansa follows all the while keeping her eyes to the ground, ensuring she watches where she’s going. And it’s quiet. Silent even. But she won’t look up. She can’t bear the sight of Sandor’s burned face, but she was raised as a true courteous woman. She looks up and tells Sandor, You rode gallantly today, Ser Sandor.

You can just feel the air going out when Sansa says that, especially as re-readers, because Sandor snarls back to spare him of her empty little compliments. He’s no ser. He’s no knight. Knights are shit, and Gregor is one of them. And did Sansa see Gregor ride? She did. He was … she loses her words.

“Gallant,” Sandor finishes for Sansa. No one could withstand him, Sansa says, remembering her courtesies. Yeesh. Sandor mocks her as a pretty bird repeating all the pretty words the septas taught her to say. Sansa, to her credit, stands up for herself, calling Sandor unkind and that he’s frightening her. There, I said it. I am absolved of all future accusations of hating Sansa.

Ahem. Anyways, Sandor proceeds to talk about that random, of no importance boy who died at the tourney today and tells Sansa that Gregor intentionally placed his lance to kill the kid. And when Sansa turns away, Sandor yells at Sansa to look at me! Sandor grabs Sansa’s face and forces her to look at his face, telling her to take a good, hard look.

Sansa does. She looks up at him and sees that the right side of his face was relatively okay,  not handsome, but the left. It’s a bloody horror with most of the skin turned to scar, slick black fresh and hard as leather that gleamed red and wet when Sandor moved. And by his jaw, the hint of bone was there in his face.

Sandor mocks Sansa more, asking if she’s got no compliments that her Septa taught her to say to that, and then he tells the story of his burned face, and I’ll read it at length, because it’s amazing.

"Most of them, they think it was some battle. A siege, a burning tower, an enemy with a torch. One fool asked if it was dragonsbreath." His laugh was softer this time, but just as bitter. "I'll tell you what it was, girl," he said, a voice from the night, a shadow leaning so close now that she could smell the sour stench of wine on his breath. "I was younger than you, six, maybe seven. A woodcarver set up shop in the village under my father's keep, and to buy favor he sent us gifts. The old man made marvelous toys. I don't remember what I got, but it was Gregor's gift I wanted. A wooden knight, all painted up, every joint pegged separate and fixed with strings, so you could make him fight. Gregor is five years older than me, the toy was nothing to him, he was already a squire, near six foot tall and muscled like an ox. So I took his knight, but there was no joy to it, I tell you. I was scared all the while, and true enough, he found me. There was a brazier in the room. Gregor never said a word, just picked me up under his arm and shoved the side of my face down in the burning coals and held me there while I screamed and screamed. You saw how strong he is. Even then, it took three grown men to drag him off me. The septons preach about the seven hells. What do they know? Only a man who's been burned knows what hell is truly like.  

Wow. That’s fucking intense. And what was Gregor Clegane’s fate? Was he punished for nearly burning his brother to death? No. He was anointed with oils and knighted by Princed Rhaegar Targaryen himself.

When Sandor is done telling his story to Sansa, a silence falls between them, but Sansa’s fear is gone too. Instead, she feels sad for him. Finally, she tells Sandor that Gregor was no true knight. This causes Sandor to roar in laughter and then growl that No. No, little bird. He was no true knight.

They walk the rest of the way back to the Red Keep in silence. Only when they arrive in the castle and climb stairs to the Tower of the Hand, does Sansa break the silence by thanking Sandor for escorting her back. Sandor grabs her arm, and I’m just going read the last few lines of the chapter, because again, bravo George. This is fucking great dialogue.

"The things I told you tonight," he said, his voice sounding even rougher than usual. "If you ever tell Joffrey … your sister, your father … any of them …"
"I won't," Sansa whispered. "I promise."
It was not enough. If you ever tell anyone, I’ll kill you.

And that is AGOT, Sansa II: simply amazing chapter that happens to have Sansa Stark in it. First thoughts: Chloe!

This is such a loaded chapter. Not only is this Sansa’s first real foray into her Song, after the disaster first attempt at the Trident with her so-gallant prince, but it’s loaded with exposition on the King’s Landing/Noble cast and also loaded with characterizing Sansa.  While it’s pushed to internal in this chapter, the continued establishment of Sansa knowing banners of houses and their loyalties comes as a direct mirror to Catelyn V, chapter 28, which is the chapter right before this. 

We also get a huge hint of where a lot of Sansa’s more “snobby” attitudes come into play, up close and personal:  Septa Mordane.  Septa Mordane is Sansa’s main maternal influence in teaching her to be a lady and what ladies say, do, think, and act while in King’s Landing, and Cersei becomes who she thinks she should be like as a Queen - with very infrequent guidance and mentoring from Ned, Sansa comes off as a spoiled brat in a lot of Game of Thrones because that’s how she’s being taught.   Septa Mordane’s snobby attitude about Jory’s armor making him look like a beggar among the other men transcends straight to Sansa, and Sansa remaining composed during Ser Hugh’s death is her seeking approval from her maternal figure - which she receives.

Jory establishes himself well in the tourney, though, which Sansa notes, but it is a nod to her girlish, naive tendencies that she later thinks in Sansa III how much handsomer Alyn is compared to Jory in his shining silver armor, and how he is going to be a knight (which, to be fair, he helps execute some of the truest knightly things in letting the BWB form and leave off on the field later on).

And of course, in this very chapter, Sansa begins to discern the difference between true knighthood and “fake” knighthood  -  in fact, she learns that from her main paternal role model in KL, Sandor Clegane.  

Where Margaery Tyrell would attend court with her Grandmother and likely be quizzed afterward, the second Ned kills Sansa’s wolf, he lets her go, resigned to her fate of being the wolf that the Lannisters take from the Starks.  In the next Ned chapter you all do, part two of the tourney, we realize that Ned skipped day one of the tourney and sent Septa Mordane instead, which is something pretty problematic.  Sansa’s attitudes and the perpetual pre-teen girl attitude is firstly, teenage wealthy girl attitude, but secondly, a direct environmental response.  No, Ned’s daughter isn’t going to understand how this beautiful world runs on blood, because he’s never taught her.  Ned should’ve been at her side, murmuring to her which knight was good and bad, what team they fought for, this is like, your first football game watching with your very opinionated dad, guys.  Sansa doesn’t get that education.  

Sansa meeting LF - distrusting his face immediately, noting that his eyes don’t connect with his smile

Depth

As I said last week, this is my favorite chapter in AGOT. It captures the whole series for me, the glorious day and the long night, from the Tourney at Harrenhal to the “knights of summer.” The imagery, the range of emotions, the rich pageantry of it all, the roll call of characters, and above all the arc of disillusionment and enlightenment that Sansa goes through...it’s everything I could want. There are so many moving parts in play here, but before we get into them, I just wanna gush about how Sansa II starts, because like a lot of great chapters, it teaches you how to read it right up front: 

Sansa rode to the Hand's tourney with Septa Mordane and Jeyne Poole, in a litter with curtains of yellow silk so fine she could see right through them. They turned the whole world gold.

That’s what this chapter is about: the golden filter, that filigree of Sansa’s POV, rooted in songs and stories (and therefore in fantasy), and what happens when she gets a glimpse underneath it. 

  • This is the best damn day of Sansa Stark’s life
    • The splendor of it all took Sansa’s breath away; the shining armor, the great chargers caparisoned in silver and gold, the shouts of the crowd, the banners snapping in the wind...and the knights themselves, the knights most of all.
    • This is what she’s been missing, locked away at Winterfell where the singers never come, her father afraid to let her go and even more afraid to tell her the true stories
    • Like any good fangirl, she’s rattling off names and details, glorying in how much better the real deal is, hence “better than the songs” 
    • That phrase really cements Sansa, early on in the chapter, as the Young Fantasy Audience Insert
  • But it’s also a moment she’s been training for
    • Sansa is not merely an excited spectator, she is a participant in court politics as a noble girl nearing womanhood and specifically as the daughter of the Hand for whom the tourney is named
    • There are expectations, she is under observation, and she knows it: 
      • Jeyne covered her eyes whenever a man fell, like a frightened little girl, but Sansa was made of sterner stuff. A great lady knew how to behave at tournaments. Even Septa Mordane noted her composure and nodded in approval.
    • This is training, every bit as much as anything Syrio teaches Arya (and indeed, Sansa too must “look with her eyes” at chapter’s end, and face down the fear that cuts deeper than swords)
    • Even more telling:
      • Sansa was dressed beautifully that day, in a green gown that brought out the auburn of her hair, and she knew they were looking at her and smiling.
    • So it’s not just her mentor watching--it’s the court, it’s beautiful ladies and noble lords, it’s the society she wants to be a part of, more than anything. Sansa can feel herself unlocking it, the world made of gold like her beloved prince’s hair…
    • ...but to borrow from Chloe’s favorite movie, Thor: Ragnarok, where do you think all that gold comes from?
  • The death of Ser Hugh
    • And then the gold curtain slips, and Sansa sees what it was hiding:
      • The most terrifying moment of the day came during Ser Gregor’s second joust, when his lance rode up and struck a young knight from the Vale under the gorget with such force that it drove through his throat, killing him instantly. The youth fell not ten feet from where Sansa was seated. The point of Ser Gregor’s lance had snapped off in his neck, and his

life’s blood flowed out in slow pulses, each weaker than the one before.

  • This the moment that the game crosses into war, a moment GRRM dwells on a lot, especially in this first book
  • As such, it’s a moment of intense disillusionment for Sansa, the Young Fantasy Reader caught up in the splendor of it all and not connecting war games to war
  • Although interestingly, she’s not really broken up about violence in itself, as she notes she’s already experienced that with Bran and Lady
  • It’s the meaning of it--or rather, the lack of meaning: 
    • The young knight in the blue cloak was nothing to her, some stranger from the Vale of Arryn whose name she had forgotten as soon as she heard it. And now the world would forget his name too, Sansa realized; there would be no songs sung for him. That was sad.

      After they carried off the body, a boy with a spade ran onto the field and shoveled dirt over the spot where he had fallen, to cover up the blood. Then the jousts resumed.

  • This is Sansa’s first critique of her songs=society=good worldview. She’s found a blind spot in the songs, something they cannot explain, and this disturbs her. The world ought not literally cover up Ser Hugh’s death
    • It’s a neat character moment how Sansa’s POV shifts though from this moment where she’s sad that Hugh won’t get a song to being genuinely sad about Sandor as a person and his upbringing. Character growth!
    • Sansa’s plot rhythmically provides us these moments again and again.  Sansa starts to think about how Lady’s death could be Joff’s fault, but then immediately places blame at Arya and Cersei’s feet in order to avoid taking off the rose lenses, and she does the same here.  Ser Hugh’s death threatens to open that world up to her again, to end the song, and Loras’s entrance provides that safe escape back to chivalry and fair ladies and flowers and magic.
    • I’d also like to add that this is the first death Sansa has seen like this up close.  The boys have seen several beheadings, but the first beheading Sansa and Arya get to see is Ned Stark’s.
  • The Knight of Flowers
    • What’s interesting about this chapter structurally is that it’s not a straight line to hell--Sansa gets competing stimuli throughout the chapter, sometimes reinforcing her worldview, sometimes contradicting it
    • So if the death of Ser Hugh rattled her certainty about chivalry, here comes the Finest Knight Of His Generation to restore it: 
      • Ser Loras was the youngest son of Mace Tyrell, the Lord of Highgarden and Warden of the South. At sixteen, he was the youngest rider on the field, yet he had unhorsed three knights of the Kingsguard that morning in his first three jousts. Sansa had never seen anyone so beautiful. His plate was intricately fashioned and enameled as a bouquet of a thousand different flowers, and his snow-white stallion was draped in a blanket of red and white roses. After each victory, Ser Loras would remove his helm and ride slowly round the fence, and finally pluck a single white rose from the blanket and toss it to some fair maiden in the crowd.

        His last match of the day was against the younger Royce. Ser Robar's ancestral runes proved small protection as Ser Loras split his shield and drove him from his saddle to crash with an awful clangor in the dirt. Robar lay moaning as the victor made his circuit of the field. Finally they called for a litter and carried him off to his tent, dazed and unmoving. Sansa never saw it. Her eyes were only for Ser Loras. When the white horse stopped in front of her, she thought her heart would burst.

        To the other maidens he had given white roses, but the one he plucked for her was red. "Sweet lady," he said, "no victory is half so beautiful as you." Sansa took the flower timidly, struck dumb by his gallantry. His hair was a mass of lazy brown curls, his eyes like liquid gold. She inhaled the sweet fragrance of the rose and sat clutching it long after Ser Loras had ridden off.
    • I mean, this is the chivalric image, right? I can imagine it as a book cover, a weathered painting, a stained-glass window…
    • ...so of course, it’s undercut in all sorts of ways later on:
      • Loras is gay
      • He doesn’t remember it at all when they meet again
      • He tricks his way to victory against Gregor in the next chapter
      • Ned denies his Oh So Heroic offer to go after Gregor, in view of Sansa
      • The Tyrells pretend to be Sansa’s friends in ASOS, and then abandon and frame her (moment of male silence for Chloe to loudly boo the roses)
        • Your male silence is appreciated, Chloe is indeed booing
        • (also this quote about the Tyrells from Littlefinger is interesting because I totally forgot about the harp part "I also planted the notion of Ser Loras taking the white. Not that I suggested it, that would have been too crude. But men in my party supplied grisly tales about how the mob had killed Ser Preston Greenfield and raped the Lady Lollys, and slipped a few silvers to Lord Tyrell's army of singers to sing of Ryam Redwyne, Serwyn of the Mirror Shield, and Prince Aemon the Dragonknight. A harp can be as dangerous as a sword, in the right hands.”    A HARP CAN BE AS DANGEROUS AS A SWORD and of course Bran II we read far before this chapter so it’s a nice little punch nod okay thanks just wanted other people to read this with me)
    • Of course, that’s all still to come. Within the chapter, it’s undercut by...
  • Littlefinger
    • This is where I go from finding him obnoxious to actively hating him
    • He’s just there like a goddamn slasher villain:
      • When Sansa finally looked up, a man was standing over her, staring.
    • “Staring” is but the first of THIS MAN IS A GROSS CREEP signifiers GRRM packs in to this brief meeting
      • Next up is “almost as old as her father”
      • And then: “He had grey-green eyes that did not smile when his mouth did.”
      • So naturally she’s “ill at ease,” despite him being a high lord
      • And then he touches her hair, euwwwgh
    • The point being that the author isn’t interested in distancing us from Littlefinger’s behavior via “Westerosi standards are different from those of modern readers”
    • He’s interested in showing Sansa’s perspective on Littlefinger, and her perspective is that he creeps her right the fuck out
    • Of course, the point is also that Littlefinger’s creepy obsessive drive is rooted in the exact same romanticism that fuels Sansa in this chapter
    • And he’s a romantic reckless fool still, because this brief encounter leads him to rework his entire master plan so it revolves around her
      • It’s possible but extremely unlikely that Sansa already figured into Littlefinger’s plans before this
      • He acts stunned and dreamlike, so it doesn’t seem like something he’s put forethought into
      • Before this, maybe his endgame was Catelyn in his bed, or purely destructive vengeance
      • But from here to his outlining of the Vale succession and how Sansa fits into it in Alayne II AFFC, she is more and more central to his scheming
      • Which will make it all the more satisfying when she takes him down
    • Not only does Sansa comment on his eyes not reaching his smile, and her immediate distrust and ill ease, LF provides her some lies and truths in what he says.  He tells Sansa that her mother was his queen of love and beauty once, which is a very gross “grooming” he’s trying to start - especially when we know he was defeated by Brandon in their duel, rather embarrassingly, thus Catelyn would definitely not be named QOLAB by him.  Further, it was a personal duel proposed by a 15-year old boy, not a tourney.  He was challenging Brandon for Cat’s hand, and foolishly, at that.  Life is not a song, Petyr.  
  • Joffrey and Robert
    • Joffrey is in full-on perfect prince mode; this is arguably the last time we see him this way. Did Cersei get him to behave himself (so as to not distract from her leading Robert to the noose)?
    • Specifically, he’s ignoring the wound he received from Nymeria, symbolic of both him and Sansa choosing to look away from what happened that day
    • Then he witnesses his father at his worst, and look how he reacts
      • He had a queer look on his face, as if he were not seeing her at all.
      • Is this Joffrey’s most humanizing moment? 
      • (Of course, he’s still immediately a dick by bait-and-switching Sansa with the walk home, so you can only sympathize so far)
      • (Truthfully it’s the nicest thing he ever did for Sansa, in giving her a pet)
    • Speaking of Robert, this is the first time we’ve seen him since Darry, and while he’s in the exact opposite mode--screaming at Cersei instead of letting her do whatever she wants--it’s just as unsympathetic
    • “I am king here,” of course, brings to mind Tywin’s line about those who have to say that they are the king. Is Robert so different from Aerys…?
    • Robert’s clearly sensitive about that, because who does he target but Jaime, calling him “Kingslayer”
    • Look at how he’s conducting himself: drinking, yelling, staggering around. This is who’s in charge? This is the system Sansa wants to belong to? Should she?
    • This is actually such an important passage: this is what Sansa sees.  Sansa sees a drunken, brutish king, attacking the woman he is sworn to love, his queen.  
      • The queen's face was a mask, so bloodless that it might have been sculpted from snow. She rose from the table, gathered her skirts around her, and stormed off in silence, servants trailing behind.
    • This shapes Sansa’s viewpoint later on, and makes Cersei the good one in her mind, and someone she can trust - she sees Cersei as the wronged party.
    • As always with Robert, it all comes back to his youth, and everything that went with it:
      • “The great knight. I can still knock you in the dirt. Remember that, Kingslayer.” He slapped his chest with the jeweled goblet, splashing wine all over his satin tunic. “Give me my hammer and not a man in the realm can stand before me!”
    • “Still.” I can “still” knock you in the dirt. Can he, though? In the very next chapter, he’ll be too fat for his armor.
    • As for “not a man in the realm can stand before me,” hmm, how is it that Sansa describes Gregor?
      • “No man could withstand him.” 
      • So maybe that’s not a good thing, buddy!
    • Speaking of which...
  • Sandor
    • “The feast was over, and the beautiful dream with it.”
    • Everything else about this chapter is fantastic, but it all comes to a head with this conversation, which is what puts it over the top for me as AGOT’s crown jewel
    • This is Sansa the True Believer v. Sandor the Cynic Who Once Believed, and it really does feel like an epic confrontation between ideals, an expansion on her brief encounter with Littlefinger
    • Sansa’s skills as a noble lady in court are explicitly being pushed to the limit, yet she is determined to do her duty: 
      • Sansa could not bear the sight of him, he frightened her so, yet she had been raised in all the ways of courtesy. A true lady would not notice his face, she told herself.
    • Sansa’s upbringing has instructed her that Sandor is owed respect and kindness regardless of how he looks. Which is interesting, because it suggests that Westeros can be saved by people actually living up to their stated values
    • But Sandor argues that Sansa’s courtesy is actually an artifact of a hypocritical society obsessed with covering up its regular atrocities with superficial niceties 
      • Sandor Clegane snarled at her. “Spare me your empty little compliments, girl . . . and your ser’s. I am no knight. I spit on them and their vows. My brother is a knight. Did you see him ride today?”
    • (This same dynamic will be recreated at the Hollow Hill, with Sansa swapped out for the heroic undead paladin Beric Dondarrion on the believer side)
    • Moreover, he specifically mocks her song-oriented worldview…
      • “Yes,” Sansa whispered, trembling. “He was . . .

        “Gallant?” the Hound finished.
    • ...despite having once loved knights himself
      • "I was younger than you, six, maybe seven. A woodcarver set up shop in the village under my father's keep, and to buy favor he sent us gifts. The old man made marvelous toys. I don't remember what I got, but it was Gregor's gift I wanted. A wooden knight, all painted up, every joint pegged separate and fixed with strings, so you could make him fight.”
    • So what we’re seeing in this scene is Sandor telling Sansa is that his love for stories and songs left him vulnerable to the real-world horrors of his big brother
    • Even more significant, though, and what really snaps everything in this chapter into place, is how Sandor’s story ends: 
      • “My father told everyone my bedding had caught fire, and our maester gave me ointments. Ointments! Gregor got his ointments too. Four years later, they anointed him with the seven oils and he recited his knightly vows and Rhaegar Targaryen tapped him on the shoulder and said, 'Arise, Ser Gregor.'"
    • Not only did his brother burn off half his face, but his father lied to cover it up, and Rhaegar Targaryen, the beloved and respected Prince of Dragonstone, validated Gregor and gave him a significant place within the power structure
    • This is the moment that broke Sandor: the knighting of one of the worst people in the series, a lie about his most horrible and intimate moment made public reality
    • We have shifted from personal injustice to systemic. It is not merely that Westeros contains men like Gregor. It is that Westerosi high society has elevated men like Gregor, and will continue to unabashedly.
    • This same society will break every promise it has made to Sansa Stark. Her father has brought her into hell, Septa Mordane failed to look after her at the feast, Joff and Cersei will betray her again and again, the Tyrells will abandon her, Dontos sells her out, Littlefinger manipulates and preys on her…
    • The only one who says he’ll keep her safe and seems to mean it is Sandor, the not-knight (though he’s still very dangerous and I’m glad she didn’t go with him)
    • As such, this is where GRRM’s social/political critique really hit home for me
    • What good is such a system? What use the glory and excitement of the Hand’s Tourney? Why sing songs if songs are lies? Let it all die. Kill it if you have to.
    • Sansa doesn’t reject this out of hand, but nor is she completely taken in by it
    • Like Belle in Disney’s BOTB, she pushes back when Sandor’s a sneering jerk...
      • Sandor Clegane stopped suddenly in the middle of a dark and empty field. She had no choice but to stop beside him. "Some septa trained you well. You're like one of those birds from the Summer Isles, aren't you? A pretty little talking bird, repeating all the pretty little words they taught you to recite."

"That's unkind." Sansa could feel her heart fluttering in her chest. "You're frightening me. I want to go now."

  • ...only reaching out when he proves worthy and in desperate need:
    • The rasping voice trailed off. He squatted silently before her, a hulking black shape shrouded in the night, hidden from her eyes. Sansa could hear his ragged breathing. She was sad for him, she realized. Somehow, the fear had gone away.

      The silence went on and on, so long that she began to grow afraid once more, but she was afraid for him now, not for herself.
  • And boy, do I love her response to all this:
    • She found his massive shoulder with her hand. "He was no true knight," she whispered to him.
  • It’s practically a thesis statement for the series and these two specifically
  • You could see it as pure naivete, and that’s certainly how Sandor reacts 
  • But taken in context with, say, “if I am ever queen, I’ll make them love me,” I think there’s something more resonant at work
  • What Sansa is saying is that what she loves, what Sandor used to love, about knights doesn’t belong to the official institutions nor the Ser in front of your name
  • Instead, it’s about being a true knight, about being a good person and sticking up for the powerless, and any individual can do that even if the world sucks
  • Especially if the world sucks, in fact! No chance, and no choice...
  • That’s ASOIAF: the glorious image taken apart and then put back together, better

Likes/Dislikes

Like: The imagery of Ser Hugh’s death. It’s the same vivid cosmic language GRRM uses in the magic-heavy chapters…

His armor was shiny new; a bright streak of fire ran down his outstretched arm, as the steel caught the light. Then the sun went behind a cloud, and it was gone. His cloak was blue, the color of the sky on a clear summer's day, trimmed with a border of crescent moons, but as his blood seeped into it, the cloth darkened and the moons turned red, one by one. 

...and so this is the passage that really sold me on LML’s theories about Azor Ahai, because the aforementioned “no man can withstand him” line also applies to AA’s patron god R’hllor: 

"R'hllor chooses such instruments as he requires." The ruby at Melisandre's throat shone redly. "His ways are mysterious, but no man may withstand his fiery will."
"No man may withstand him!" the queen cried. (ASOS, Davos V)
"The Lord of Light made the sun and moon and stars to light our way, and gave us fire to keep the night at bay," Melisandre told the wildlings. "None can withstand his flames."
"None can withstand his flames," the queen's men echoed. (ADWD, Jon III)

Dislike: I would’ve liked to actually hear Cersei’s attempt to manipulate Robert into fighting in the melee. The queen has oddly few dialogue scenes in this first book, despite being arguably its central antagonist (arguably only because of Littlefinger). 

Like:

Dislike: A bit of a minor dislike, but I didn’t enjoy the anachronism in this chapter between when Loras gave the rose to Sansa Stark and the final four champions. It took out any tension between the confrontation between Loras and Robar Royce. Again, not a story-killer, but I don’t know what the non-linear storytelling of moving the end-result ahead of the Sansa/Loras and Sansa/Creepyfinger conversations accomplishes. It deflates any dramatic tension of the Robar-Loras tilt.

Likes: what’s not to like about this chapter? There’s knights, there’s fair maidens, and it all ends with a deconstruction of that concept.  The chapter ends with Sansa beginning to understand how the world she has been thrust into works, and that understanding travels on through the following chapters and books.

Dislikes: the goddamn impossible logistics, yes, I get it’s a fantasy story, of Loras Tyrell’s god damn impossible horse blanket weaved together of roses??? That he sits on??? And it doesn't rip in half? Okay, sure, kinda pushing my suspension of disbelief here. In all seriousness, it’s something fun to pick at.  After finishing the chapters we were doing in the east at GGC, some of the “it’s fantasy” costume details gets a bit far fetched and can come off kitschy - like the Herons on their Stilts in the Slaver Cities.

Foreshadowing/Groundwork

Because I enjoy some of the more trivia aspects of ASOIAF, this chapter serves as a who’s-who of minor characters in ASOIAF that keep on keeping on throughout the story. No, I’m not talking about your Jaimes or Barristans or even your secondary characters like your Sandors or Joffreys or Thoros. Not secondary characters, minor ones. So, if you all will indulge me, I figure I’d do a quick casting call of these minor characters and talk about their fates by the start of TWOW. Ready? Here we go!

  • Bronze Yohn Royce: Still leading the anti-Littlefinger coalition in the Vale by TWOW, Alayne I with his son Andar Royce
  • Robar Royce: Joins Renly’s Rainbow Guard, heroically holds off Renly’s men after Renly is killed by the Shadow Baby, is murdered by Loras Tyrell. 
  • Jason/Patrek Mallister: Patrek was captured at the Red Wedding. Black Walder Frey took him to Seaguard and threatened to hang him unless his father Jason surrendered the castle. Jason surrendered the castle
  • Aron Santagar: killed during the Riot in King’s Landing in ACOK
  • Balon Swann: Appointed to the Kingsguard, charged with Cersei in AFFC to participate in the murder of Trystane Martell, on down to Starfall for the Darkstar Hunt
  • Bryce Caron: Joins with Renly, turns to Stannis, is killed at the Blackwater
  • The Redwyne Twins Horas and Hobber: Taken hostage to their fathers’ non-participation in the War of the Five Kings by Cersei, later released after Paxter joins with his liege lord when the Tyrell-Lannister alliance is made, taken prisoner again by Cersei in her conspiracy against Margaery, released by Kevan Lannister in ADWD
  • The Freys
    • Jared: baked into a Manderly pie
    • Hosteen: Leads the Frey cavalry force against Stannis at the Crofters’ Village
    • Danwell: Securing Darry on behalf of the Lannisters
    • Emmon: Lord of Riverrun by the end of AFFC, gonna get Red Wedding’d by Stoneheart in TWOW
      • He said, gleefully
    • Perwyn: becomes one of Robb Stark’s guards, is not present at the Red Wedding (likely due to his Stark sympathies), at the Frey-Lannister Siege of Riverrun
    • Martyn Rivers: leads Robb Stark’s outriders in their invasion of the Westerlands, abandons Robb back at Riverrun after his marriage to Jeyne Westerling
  • Jalabhar Xho: continues mooching his way through King’s Landing, is imprisoned as Margaery Tyrell’s lover 
  • Vale foreshadowing: seeing Bronze Yohn Royce, Ser Hugh’s death - Ser Hugh as Harrold Hardyng
    • . The young knight in the blue cloak was nothing to her, some stranger from the Vale of Arryn whose name she had forgotten as soon as she heard it. And now the world would forget his name too, Sansa realized; there would be no songs sung for him. That was sad.
  • If you’ve had a chance to catch up with the TWOW Sample Chapters, I am guessing by now you hopefully have as the Boys tend to reference them, the Alayne chapter is huge.  It’s, like, ground-breaking huge.  It’s the literal overarching meta of Sansa taking the things she’s learned and attempting to put them into play as she hosts her very own tourney, but of course, she still isn’t a pro, she isn’t ready, and there are other machinations at work around her in her bastard status in the Vale.  
    • Ser Hugh as Harry the Heir in Sansa’s plot 
      • Harry the heir is talked about as upjumped through the books, and that he paid for his position in name and station, and isn’t actually skilled at arms - very all that glitters is not gold
      • Hugh suffered in trying to advance his station, and truthfully, if the only person left that knows Ser Hugh may have been the one to poison Jon Arryn just happens to control the ins and outs of money, and people, and also known to bet in tourneys…..  Littlefinger as his killer does indeed make sense. 
      • So in connecting those pieces, it’s more than likely Sansa will see another death of a boy she didn’t really actually know that Littlefinger has a reason to kill.  Marrying Sansa off to Harry doesn’t actually help him - if Sweetrobin dies, Harry takes ownership of the Vale, and then Harry has Sansa, and Sansa will take the North for herself.  Where does that leave him? Wait for her to birth an heir, then kill Harry and take regency? No, Harry, who will stride out into the lists in sparkling, glittering blue armor, probably isn’t going to survive - and there’s a certain Lady, who’s rather Forlorn, that I think will be involved.
    • There’s also this idea that Sansa needs to get her claim attached to someone else’s to attain power, and, well, she really doesn’t.  To inspire loyalty into the people, we have a theme that comes up with significance in ADWD, which is Valiant Ned’s Precious Little Girl.  Where Dad dies for everyone’s sins, he left a legacy as a good man who stood for what was right - when he wasn’t, you know, broken legged and weary from trauma and … Jaime - and a good man, and he was also a Good Boy.  And where did he grow up? Why, the Vale.
      • Ned running through the halls of the Vale with Robert, the good-tempered, quiet wolf, who did as he was told and stood for his people when he could.  And Sansa’s plot is all about her learning the best of both of her parent’s worlds, from political intrigues and navigating court life to standing up for the people who can not stand for themselves, and ruling through love instead of fear.  
      • Her worry about Bronze Yohn Royce recognizing her comes up several times throughout the story in the Vale, and highlighting him here in the tourney is super important and great storytelling, weaving lines to connect Sansa throughout her chapters.

Thoros of Myr scaling the walls of Pyke

  • Mordane talks about it as a brave courageous act, but in Game of Thrones, Season 7 Thoros has a different memory of it when he talks with Jorah Mormont about it:

    Jorah: How drunk were you when charged through the breach on Pyke?

    Thoros: To be honest, I don't remember charging through the breach. Some of the lads told me about it the next morning. Some good scrap.

    Jorah: Aye. It was a proper scrap. The Ironborn thought you were some kind of god, the way you waving that flaming sword. I thought you were the bravest man I ever saw.

    Thoros: Just the drunkest. 
    • Not entirely sure this will be book canon as Thoros doesn’t mention this in either ASOS or AFFC, but it, at least, reads congruent with Thoros’ characterization in the books as a drunk until he saw the Lord of Light in action when Beric rose.

Theory Discussion

San-San: Is it canon?

Jeff POV: I see the parallels between the Beauty and the Beast story and Sansa and Sandor, but I also see where GRRM has said things like:

I was surprised by the number of women who reacted positively to characters like Theon and the Hound as dashing, romantic figures. The San-San kind of thing took me by surprise, I must admit. - GRRM, Archipelacon 2015
And I do know all these people out there who are they as they call themselves the San-San fans. They want see Sandor and Sansa get together at the end. So, that’s interesting. I’ve played with it in the books. There’s something there. It’s still interesting to see how many people have responded too. - GRRM interview 2012

From all the evidence I’ve seen of GRRM, the way he teases mysteries, I’ve never seen him say something like, “Ah yes, I’ve seen the theories that Rhaegar and Lyanna are Jon’s parents.” He’s typically much more vague, saying things like, “You’ll find out about Jon’s parentage” or “keep reading” or things like that. That George is referencing this theory by name, is speaking to it, the skeptical tone of voice he uses in addressing this theory (if you become one of our patrons, you’ll get access to our show notes where we provide links to the videos of George talking about SanSan) and is “taken by surprise” about it makes me wonder about whether it will ultimately prove true.

I think the breadth and fervency of the reaction to their dynamic surprised him, but as he says, it’s definitely in there, and he had to know that while writing it, especially given that it’s a favorite trope and he gender-flipped it with Jaime and Sandor’s cousin Brienne. Even after they part, look at how Sandor talks about Sansa to Arya in ASOS, or the implication that he spoke of her to the Elder Brother. My guess is that SanSan was endgame back when the five-year-gap was on. Now, though...? I hope not, unless it’s a Bran-vision hand-waving “they got together years later when they were both adults with something resembling emotional literacy” sort of thing.

What do you think, Chloe? Fight me!

Also, a top of the wall of text aside: in the Blackwater commentary, Lena Headey and Peter Dinklage sing the beauty and the beast theme, and when Sansa says why are you here Lena responds with, “because he loves you, stupid girl”.  It’s canon, Lena Headey said so.

AH, A CHANCE TO FIGHT JEFF.  Buckle up gentlemen, we’re about to dig in.

Let me preface all of this with a I do not ship Sansan in the present, thank you very much, but it is very canon, and has been this entire time.  I do think that coupled together after they both have healed and Sansa has matured, definitely an idea - but I also don’t think we’ll ever truly get a Sansan moment, which we will get to after this 9000000 word essay I’m about to write you. 

RE: The 2012 comments from George

And I do know all these people out there who are they as they call themselves the San-San fans. They want see Sandor and Sansa get together at the end. So, that’s interesting. I’ve played with it in the books. There’s something there. It’s still interesting to see how many people have responded too. - GRRM interview 2012

You’re also leaving off a pretty interesting precursor: he discusses all of the fanmail he gets for women who love people like Jaime and Sandor initially, and he calls them both villains.

Now, as most people would love to contest, Jaime Lannister isn’t exactly looked at as a villain anymore - while smarter people, like Emmett Booth and I would contest, yes, he’s still not a good guy.  Some people would even go as far as to say that Jaime is on a redemption arc, because they’re wrong and bad.  But Sandor Clegane is on a redemption arc, and furthermore, his plot is directly tied to the Stark Sisters.

 If we’re going to cherry pick SSMs together, why not throw a couple others in, and some quotes from the books? 

[Will Sandor and Sansa meet?]
Why, the Hound is dead, and Sansa may be dead as well. There's only Alayne Stone. - GRRM, 2008

3. Will we see Sandor again, especially in replacing Sansa's lost wolf?

Yes, we will see Sandor (in the next book I think he said) and Gregor. After that, he said he can't comment on the rest… -GRRM, 2005 

So, I would very much so argue several things with what Jeff said.

  1. These ssm’s are worded just as vaguely as Jon’s parentage is referred to
  2. These ssm’s don’t NEED to be as vague as Jon’s parentage, because we see Sansa think of Sandor over four books, and their relationship is displayed on the page.  This isn’t a song of birds and dogs, though it sure as @$#@$ should be, I’d read the hell out of that.
  3. In fact, Sandor is mentioned 96 times in the book series in Sansa’s Chapters, and she even talks about him, after not seeing him since a clash of kings, in TWOW Alayne II and her Feast chapters, as well.  She thinks of him ‘kissing’ her, which we all know as the infamous unkiss and her misremembering (which george has inferred will come into play in an SSM where he talks about Sansa misremembering Joffrey’s sword [lion’s paw/tooth, but he actually was himself wrong - it’s ARYA that misremembers Joffrey’s sword. Talk about an unreliable narrator, George ;) ])

    . . . this is an inconsistency with ASoS more than an outright error. In ASoS, Sansa thinks that the Hound kissed her before leaving her room and King's Landing. In ACoK, no kiss is mentioned in the scene, though Sansa did think that he was about to do so.

    Well, not every inconsistency is a mistake, actually. Some are quite intentional. File this one under "unreliable narrator" and feel free to ponder its meaning. . . -GRRM 2002
  4. Sandor, Sansa and Arya’s arcs all revolve around Mercy - Sansa sang to Sandor and gave him the original gift of Mercy, which he then teaches “mercy” to Arya, and begs for it himself while he’s pretty much confessing he wanted Arya’s pretty sister. That all begins in Sansa II.  Since we learn about Sandor’s past in this chapter, something that loses all its luster in the show counterpart of Littlefinger explaining it to Sansa (I’m bitter, I’ll always be bitter, let’s move on), let’s go into a bit of that.
  5. House Clegane
    - sister dies in an “accident” that most believe was Gregor, though it’s hush hush
    - mom dies, unsaid how, doesn’t seem related to Gregor for once
    - dad is killed by Gregor, he inherits the keep
    - Sandor has nowhere to run, becomes a Lannister lackey - works his way up the ranks, was at the sack of KL.  (And the man breaks… this is why the Broken Man speech is so important, showing what happens to the men that become dogs for their masters with nowhere to turn, fighting and drinking and fighting and drinking until they can forget it all or die, bloody in a ditch)
    - so, when he meets Sansa and eventually Arya, and Sansa is the first person to show him kindness (a … mother’s kindness) it brings a few things to mind
    - Sandor’s “look”: dark hair, long face, grey eyes
    -  So, we can assume that the younger sister that they lost, who would have been somewhere between 6-9 years old, would’ve been a spritely thing with grey eyes and dark hair, and if she had the same sort of spark in her that the Clegane brothers had (hopefully nothing like Gregor’s), she may just resemble another little girl.  That’s right, folks, you can not only project Lyanna Stark onto Arya, you can now project the unnamed Clegane sister.  You’re welcome.

    “Please,” Sandor Clegane rasped, cradling his arm. “I’m burned. Help me. Someone. Help me.” He was crying. “Please.” Arya looked at him in astonishment. He’s crying like a little baby, she thought. - ARYA VI, ASOS

    - not only can we assume that Arya looks like his family, but there is a lot of subtext in Sansa singing of the mother’s mercy to Sandor when his knife is at her throat in ACOK. She’s the first person, in his 13 years in the capital, to show him kindness.  To tell him you didn’t deserve this, it wasn’t your fault.  In her chambers at the battle of the blackwater, he’s reduced to a blubbering mess, realizing what monstrosities he’s committed - when he breaks finally - and he leaves, but not after trying to save the little girl in front of him, like he wishes he could have saved his little sister.
     
  6. They literally have the same prefixes on their names.  Sandor. Sansa.  
  7. Sandor straight up talks about how she’s blossoming into a young woman, in a, er, little … more aggressive of a tone, and of course when speaking to Arya, talks about how he got a “song” from her.  Which is a euphemism.  For sex.  And then of course, Sansa dreams of him in her wedding bed, in AFFC.

And she dreamed of her wedding night too, of Tyrion's eyes devouring her as she undressed. Only then he was bigger than Tyrion had any right to be, and when he climbed into the bed his face was scarred only on one side. "I'll have a song from you," he rasped, and Sansa woke and found the old blind dog beside her once again. "I wish that you were Lady," she said.
(let’s not forget her petting the old blind dog and saying you sad old hound either. I see you, George.)

  1. The sexual language around the battle of the blackwater? Eyesofmist on Tumblr has written about it, but the ripping, shoving, twisting imagery that is written about in this chapter is really violent and slightly erotic.  The wetness, the raw, harshness, all of it.  It’s not written like an innocent playtime story. And woah, let’s not even get into the cloak symbolism - especially come affc … why she kept it, she could not say. Girl, we know why.   
  2. Let’s not forget Sandor’s taunting of Arya - “I saved your sister, she sang me a sweet little song” on the road  (aka make that chick scream like the gods ain’t lookin’), and then when he’s begging Arya for the gift of mercy, he reveals that of course he didn’t ‘get a song’, that he didn’t save her, that he stood there in his white cloak and let them beat her, he never touched her, he should’ve, he should’ve when he had the chance…
    (which of course we see similar with Jaime against Aerys/Rhaella - so many vows, but Sandor refused to swear)(yet he still tried more than Jaime did, for certain)
  3. With regards to Emmett’s point, I think SanSan was definitely written out with the 5YG - there’s just no way to justify it, and Sandor’s definitely got some things to deal with beyond recovering in the Quiet Isles.  However, I have a strong belief that George will close that loop at some point - if Sandor does come into play again, as we all believe will happen after the Gravedigger scene, I think their reunion is going to be an extremely bittersweet and tragic one.  I expect Sandor to go out saving one of the Stark girls in the end (and let’s be real, if anyone will need saving, Sansa is a candidate in a battle or a fight against the Others), if not because we are owed one last “little bird…” speech from the man that taught Sansa how to lie, the man that protected her in King’s Landing.  Sandor was the only Kingsguard who didn’t beat Sansa in ACOK (just a small reminder that the one beating scene in the TV show doesn’t account for the canon that Joffrey commanded all the kingsguard beat Sansa during the story, and it didn’t just happen occasionally), and he wanted to try and save her from KL.  Is Sansan end game? No, definitely not. But their characters directly affect the other, and Sandor’s arc couldn’t exist without Sansa as a POV. 

Not only does Sandor serve as a psuedo protective paternal figure for Sansa in King’s Landing, he serves overall as the only man in court who has ever respected her wishes.  He asks her to go north, and when she says no, he leaves.  He covered her tracks in helping her lie at Joffrey’s nameday, and even in the corridors with Tyrion.  As Immanuel Kant says, “Happiness is an ideal of the imagination rather than reason” - no, Sansa and Sandor don’t have a sequence where they reveal their emotions together, but Sansa begins to base her ideas after this true knight, and she enhances her imagination to what may or may not have happened with Sandor throughout the books. 

Sansa’s POV directly adds depth and dimensionality to the gruff, scarred man who has been to hell and back, and provides the foundation for Arya’s adventures with him post Blackwater.  Sansa prayed for Sandor at the Blackwater to find his peace, and his finding the Quiet Isles is the answer to that prayer. 

Not only does Sandor help Sansa mature in court through lying and learning to protect herself and even fend for herself in looking for a route home (and respecting her choices in such), as she begins to mature sexually she thinks of him in every man she meets, and thinks of what he, the first “good” man she truly met (ugh, that says a lot, do better, ASOIAF men), would do or say or act like.

The writer who wrote on the TV show Beauty and the Beast in 1987 ‘accidentally’ made the main, princessy character fall for a beast, an animal, sure Jeff

He is no true knight but he saved me all the same, she told the Mother. Save him if you can, and gentle the rage inside him.

There are many sorts of outlaws, just as there are many sorts of birds. A sandpiper and a sea eagle both have wings, but they are not the same. 

Conclusion

  • Thanks for listening!
  • Rate and review us on itunes, google play, etc
  • Patreon/advertise/where we can find our work/social media
  • Follow us on social media (Make sure to mention @NotACastASOIAF and our e mail: NotACastASOIAF@gmail.com)
  • Join us next time for the conclusion of the Hand’s Tourney in a chapter Chloe did a terrific job with over at GGC: Eddard VII!