Episode 146: A CLASH OF KINGS, SANSA VIII: "The Gilded Age" SHOW NOTES! (Patreon)
Content
Hello and welcome to the Not A Cast … podcast: the one true chapter-by-chapter podcast going through A Song of Ice and Fire one chapter a week. I’m one of your hosts Jeff better known as BryndenBFish.
And I’m your other host Emmett, better known as PoorQuentyn.
Welcome to the one hundred and forty-sixth episode of the Not A Cast, titled: “The Gilded Age: An Analysis of ACOK, Sansa VIII,” in which Tywin and the Tyrells congratulate each other on doing...barely anything at all, actually, and Sansa finally gets out of her betrothal.
This episode is brought to you by our NotASmallCouncil:
- Hand of the King WolfmanZack
- Grandmaester Timbob, troubleshooter of systems and designer of circuit boards
- Lord Commander of the Kingsguard Mark N.
- Ser Keith J, Master of Whisperers
- Lord Philip the Merciful, Master of Laws
- Archmaester June, Healer of the Lesser Poxes
- Ragged Michael, Warden of the North
- Nelson the Hammer, Prince of Dragonstone
- Scarlett the Other Red Woman and Mistress of Whisperers
- Lord Micah, the Quilled Lion, Warden of the West, Herald of the Golden Tooth, Master of the Banefort and the Kraken’s Bane
- Lord James: the Jim that was Promised
- Lord Jake, Assistant (to the) Hand of the King
- Lady Xena Valyrian
- Ser Jack, Lord of Ser Arthur Dayne and Prince Rhaegar Targaryen's Sad Prophecy Boys Club
- His Grace’s High Inquisitor Frank
- Laurence, Prince of Dorne
- Kelly, Warden of the East and Mistress of (Old) Bay of Crabs
- Steven the Steadfast, Master of Hounds
- The Blue Winter Rose Knight of Highgarden
- Lady Stephanie
- Lord Carlos
- Lord Andrew the Restless, a Priest of the Drowned God
- Ser Sourcedelica
- Sugar Tits Dent the Troglodyte Warrior, formerly known as Low Energy Dent, True Master of the Banefort and True Master of Coin
- Lord Penchant for Nostalgia
- Queer Alex, Beyonce's Favorite Stan and Bastard of Chromatica, Rainbow Commander of the Theydes and Gentlethems
- Haldivar, The Waiter for TWOW
- A-a-ron Damphair Prophet of the Forsaken and High Priest of Euron Crows Eye
- Lieutenant Glenn Lord of H town
- Vanerys of the House Colgaryen, the First of Her Name, Princess of Dragonstone, Mistress of Art, The Overworked, Queen of the Pencils, the Eraser and the First Draft, Queen of Monochrome, Devotee of the Great GOT, Portraitist of the Realm, Lady Realist of the Seven Kingdoms, Blender of Paints, Maker of Drawings and the Michaelangelo of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
- Lord Adam T
- Lady Alexandra of Tarth
- Ser Kristoph Logas, Bloody Scorpion of the Red Field, Defender of the Letter of Kin, and the Wolverine of house Qorgyle
- Lady Elizabeth, Mistress of Horse (Faced Lesbians)
- Ser Josh Snow Bastard Bounty Hunter of the North
- Ser Veyor, Chief of Parties in the Frozen Wastes
- Lord Peter
- The Dead Sheppard Reborn, Preacher of the Poor Fellows
- Marshall Harrison—Absent, shipwrecked in the Jade Sea
- Grave-Robb Stark, the Cadaver King and Horror of Harrenhal
- Olaf, proponent of establishing a feudal, pseudodemocratic system of Great Councils, wherein every count votes
- Ser Tim: The Knight Who Was Guided By Voices
- Lord Nick
- Thucydides, Lord of Plagues
- Ser Jack, Lord of Ser Arthur Dayne and Prince Rhaegar Targaryen’s Sad Prophecy Boys Club
- Lady Anna, The Lovely Castellan
- Pat Yronwood, the bloodroyal and guardian of the Boneway
- Lord Charles Tyrell of Highgarden, Lord Paramount of the Mander, Defender of the Marches, High Marshal of the Reach, Warden of the South, and The Heir of House Tyrell
- Luke, Lord of Lone Leaf & The Pillar of Autumn
- Master of Zorse
- Joe Snow “King of the Metro North and protector of the Tri-State”
- Squire Matt S, future Ser Matt S, the one who will bring balance to the Kingdoms
- BWord, Queen Beyond the Wall
- Lord Kyle
- Lord Samuel Seaworth
- Ser Max, Lord Commander of the Constitutional Guard
- Blackberry the Bold, Champion of Feel Good Times
- Lady Ivory Dayne, aspiring noble author in the seven kingdoms, lady of Starfall, wardeness of the south, and patron of freewheeling bisexuals
- Lady Jemisa, She Who Suggests That Coconuts Migrate
- Lord Kristoff of Arendelle, official ice master and deliverer, the valiant pungent reindeer king, keeper of feisty pants, and prince consort to his ginger sweet love Queen Anna (Pronounced Ah-nuh)
- And our newest member of the Small Council: Lord Russel H.
Spoiler warning: All published books, 5 novels, 3 Dunk and Egg novellas, histories, interviews, TWOW sample chapters, as well as Game of Thrones the TV show. Anything and everything!
Question
Ser Frank B, the King’s Justice on our small council, asks:
In Sansa VIII we get the anonymous badass who goes down swinging for Stannis, thundering to the entire false court of Lannisters and Tyrells that they're foul, sinful slugs that will be purged in flame. Obviously he's the winner for this question but who's your second favorite completely anonymous character in the series?
So, thank you Frank for the question. If you’d like to ask us questions we’ll answer here on the NotACast pod-cast, you are welcome to become a Sworn Sword or higher level patron over at patreon.com/NotACastASOIAF where you can get show notes for every episode,bonus Fevre Dream episodes, free merch, and for our two highest tiers: access to the NotASlack, shout-outs every week, weekly minisodes and bonus episodes like our upcoming full analysis of Zack Snyder’s 2013 Man of Steel!
Absolutely. And as a reminder, we’ll be doing a sauced review of Justice League as a livecast on March 22nd. But enough about patreon and Zack Snyder (peace be upon him). When we last checked in with Sansa, she had nearly died several times before Dontos brought news that all was well. Tywin Lannister was here. Damn. Let’s find out how things are going for King’s landing and Sansa in the aftermath of battle in this synopsis of ACOK, Sansa VIII!
Synopsis
The throne room was a sea of jewels, furs, and bright fabrics. Lords and ladies filled the back of the hall and stood beneath the high windows, jostling like fishwives on a dock.
The denizens of Joffrey's court had striven to outdo each other today. Jalabhar Xho was all in feathers, a plumage so fantastic and extravagant that he seemed like to take flight. The High Septon's crystal crown fired rainbows through the air every time he moved his head. At the council table, Queen Cersei shimmered in a cloth-of-gold gown slashed in burgundy velvet, while beside her Varys fussed and simpered in a lilac brocade. Moon Boy and Ser Dontos wore new suits of motley, clean as a spring morning. Even Lady Tanda and her daughters looked pretty in matching gowns of turquoise silk and vair, and Lord Gyles was coughing into a square of scarlet silk trimmed with golden lace. King Joffrey sat above them all, amongst the blades and barbs of the Iron Throne. He was in crimson samite, his black mantle studded with rubies, on his head his heavy golden crown.
Tanned, rested and ready. Joffrey is ready to run this kingdom.
Sansa pushes her way through the front of the nobles as trumpets blast announcing Lord Tywin Lannister. The shitlord comes riding down the hallway and dismounts in front of the Iron Throne all bedecked in shiny armor just like his horse. He seems so very impressive. Everyone says so!
The Lord of Casterly Rock made such an impressive figure that it was a shock when his destrier dropped a load of dung right at the base of the throne. Joffrey had to step gingerly around it as he descended to embrace his grandfather and proclaim him Savior of the City. Sansa covered her mouth to hide a nervous smile.
No symbolism. Moving on.
Joffrey asks Tywin to take up the protectorate until the king comes of age, and Tywin accepts solemnly. Squires take off his armor, and Tywin sits at the small council table next to Cersei as his horse is led off to probably be shot. The ceremony resumes with more trumpets as the “heroes” of the Blackwater stride into the hall. The best seats are given to Lord Mace Tyrell, Ser Loras Tyrell and Ser Garlan Tyrell who are all dressed in green velvet. Joffrey walks down the Iron Throne and greets them by giving them gold chains or roses in soft yellow gold with the lion of Lannister framed in red rubies. Joffrey, a redditor, tells everyone the meaning of the subtle symbolism behind the chain and ruby.
"The roses support the lion, as the might of Highgarden supports the realm," proclaimed Joffrey.
Anyways, do the Tyrells want anything else of Joffrey? They do. Loras wants to serve in the Kingsguard to defend Joffrey. Joff brings Loras to his feet and plants a sloppy one on his cheek, telling him sure. Mace Tyrell pipes up and says he wants to join the small council due to his, um, loyalty. Joff plants another sloppy one, this time on Mace, granting him his request. But then it’s Garlan Tyrell, him of the thick chest, broad shoulders and handsome (though not as beautiful as Loras’) face.
"Your Grace," Garlan said when the king approached him, "I have a maiden sister, Margaery, the delight of our House. She was wed to Renly Baratheon, as you know, but Lord Renly went to war before the marriage could be consummated, so she remains innocent. Margaery has heard tales of your wisdom, courage, and chivalry, and has come to love you from afar. I beseech you to send for her, to take her hand in marriage, and to wed your House to mine for all time."
Joffrey does his best Hollywood’ing here, saying that he’s promised to another, and he’s supposed to keep his word. Cersei then does her own bit of B-acting, saying that the small council says Joff doesn’t have to wed the daughter of a traitor. Margaery is a much better candidate, and her father is very, very not a traitor.
Everyone starts clamoring for Margaery and against the traitor queen, but Joffrey says that he took a holy vow. The High Septon then steps forward and says, Actually, Ned Starks is a dirty fucking traitor, and you don’t have to marry his traitor daughter. God says it’s okay to do this thing which I am saying as a very honest broker of the Lord’s will.
A tumult of cheering filled the throne room, and cries of "Margaery, Margaery" erupted all around her. Sansa leaned forward, her hands tight around the gallery's wooden rail. She knew what came next, but she was still frightened of what Joffrey might say, afraid that he would refuse to release her even now, when his whole kingdom depended upon it. She felt as if she were back again on the marble steps outside the Great Sept of Baelor, waiting for her prince to grant her father mercy, and instead hearing him command Ilyn Payne to strike off his head. Please, she prayed fervently, make him say it, make him say it.
Tywin stares at Joffrey, and Joffrey looks back sullenly. And then he helps Garlan to his feet and says he’ll marry Margaery of the non-traitor Tyrell family.
Sansa felt curiously light-headed. I am free. She could feel eyes upon her. I must not smile, she reminded herself. The queen had warned her; no matter what she felt inside, the face she showed the world must look distraught. "I will not have my son humiliated," Cersei said. "Do you hear me?"
"Yes. But if I'm not to be queen, what will become of me?"
"That will need to be determined. For the moment, you shall remain here at court, as our ward."
"I want to go home."
The queen was irritated by that. "You should have learned by now, none of us get the things we want."
I have, though, Sansa thought. I am free of Joffrey. I will not have to kiss him, nor give him my maidenhood, nor bear him children. Let Margaery Tyrell have all that, poor girl.
But then everything starts returning to normal as the small council gets down to business while Sansa tries to look very, very sad.
Next bit of business is rewards for the Reach and Westerlands Lords. Then comes the knights and soldiers who had distinguished themselves in battle. So weird how the people who did the fighting were honored after the lords. Anyways, these guys get promoted to lordship or knighthood or get cool new gear or have the pleasure of having their sons becoming squires and pages at Casterly Rock. Then the captains of six Lannister ships that survived were thanked by Joffrey for the feat of surviving the wildfire. Then we find out that Lancel Lannister is awarded the lordship of Darry, but he’s not able to physically accept the title due to how bad his injury is. Tyrion, too, wasn’t there and may be dying.
When the herald called, "Lord Petyr Baelish," he came forth dressed all in shades of rose and plum, his cloak patterned with mockingbirds. She could see him smiling as he knelt before the Iron Throne. He looks so pleased. Sansa had not heard of Littlefinger doing anything especially heroic during the battle, but it seemed he was to be rewarded all the same.
Kevan Lannister rises to his feet and announces that Littlefinger is taking ownership of Harrenhal and will become Lord Paramount of the Trident. And that honor and titles will go this sons and grandsons. Baelish japes that he’ll have to go about finding a wife and sons/grandsons, and everyone laughs. Sansa wonders why Littlefinger was so happy as the title and honor was vacant. Harrenhal wasn’t held by the Lannisters, and the riverlords were sworn to Robb. Hm. Yeah. That is strange, Sansa. Good eye. Sansa thinks Robb will beat LIttlefinger if he has to, just like he beat the Lannisters every time.
Six hundred new knights are created at this ceremony, and the three surviving/present knights of the Kingsguard dub each and every one of them after they walk barefoot through King’s Landing after their vigil at Baelor’s Sept. Sure enough, some of them had bloody feet, but they appear proud to Sansa. This part of the ceremony takes a very long time, and everyone grows restless, especially Joffrey. But the work isn’t done.
Next, the captives are brought in. High Lords and noble knights come into the chamber: three of whom are named for the first time and will feature prominently in AFFC: Ronnet Connington, Aurane Waters and Bonifer Hasty. But there are hundreds of captives in total. If they had switched sides during the battle, they only had to swear for Joffrey, but the ones who had fought to the bitter end for Stannis had to say something in front of the Iron Throne. If they begged for forgiveness and to be loyal, Joff would welcome them back and restore them to their lands and titles. If they didn’t though ...
A handful remained defiant, however. "Do not imagine this is done, boy," warned one, the bastard son of some Florent or other. "The Lord of Light protects King Stannis, now and always. All your swords and all your scheming shall not save you when his hour comes."
"Your hour is come right now." Joffrey beckoned to Ser Ilyn Payne to take the man out and strike his head off. But no sooner had that one been dragged away than a knight of solemn mien with a fiery heart on his surcoat shouted out, "Stannis is the true king! A monster sits the Iron Throne, an abomination born of incest!"
Ser Kevan warns this knight to shut up, but this knight ain’t about that.
The knight raised his voice instead. "Joffrey is the black worm eating the heart of the realm! Darkness was his father, and death his mother! Destroy him before he corrupts you all! Destroy them all, queen whore and king worm, vile dwarf and whispering spider, the false flowers. Save yourselves!" One of the gold cloaks knocked the man off his feet, but he continued to shout. "The scouring fire will come! King Stannis will return!"
Joffrey jumps to his feet, screaming that for this man to die, but then he cuts himself when he makes a chopping motion with his hand. He starts crying for his mom, and then the knight wrestles a spear from a gold cloak and gets back to his feet.
"The throne denies him!" he cried. "He is no king!"
Cersei runs to Joffrey, but Tywin doesn’t move. Instead, he raises a finger, and Ser Meryn Trant comes forward and drives a sword through the man as he screams “No King” one last time.
Joffrey falls into Cersei’s arms as the maesters come forward and the man’s body is dragged off. Sansa wonders if the ceremony will be over, but Tywin orders things to proceed. Those who want to ask for pardons can do so. Tywin then moves to the Iron Throne and seats himself on one of the steps.
It takes the rest of the day for the ceremony to conclude, and Sansa is exhausted by the time she gets back to her room. Despite the exhaustion, she’s joyous at the thought of being free from Joffrey.
Oh, gods be good, he did it, he put me aside in front of everyone. When a serving girl brought her supper, she almost kissed her. There was hot bread and fresh-churned butter, a thick beef soup, capon and carrots, and peaches in honey. Even the food tastes sweeter, she thought.
When it’s dark, Sansa gets into a heavy cloak and walks to the godswood. Osmund Kettleblack was guarding the pathway to the godswood, and Sansa tries very hard to seem sad as she passes by. He leers at her anyways, and she feels she wasn’t convincing. Shudder. At the godswood, Dontos waits him, and she sees that he looks miserable. Why does he look miserable? Joffrey had put Sansa aside!
He took her hand. "Oh, Jonquil, my poor Jonquil, you do not understand. Done with you? They've scarcely begun."
Her heart sank. "What do you mean?"
"The queen will never let you go, never. You are too valuable a hostage. And Joffrey . . . sweetling, he is still king. If he wants you in his bed, he will have you, only now it will be bastards he plants in your womb instead of trueborn sons."
"No," Sansa said, shocked. "He let me go, he . . . "
Dontos very normally then kisses Sansa’s ear and tells her to be brave, but there’s good news. The plan is in motion. They have the day when they’re getting out of dodge. When? At Joffrey’s wedding feast. Amidst all the people and all the festivities, Sansa will be forgotten, and that’s when they’re leaving. But that’s quite a ways away, Sansa says. Yes. But Sansa needs to be a little more patient. And dontos has a gift for her.
Ser Dontos fumbled in his pouch and drew out a silvery spiderweb, dangling it between his thick fingers. It was a hair net of fine-spun silver, the strands so thin and delicate the net seemed to weigh no more than a breath of air when Sansa took it in her fingers. Small gems were set wherever two strands crossed, so dark they drank the moonlight. "What stones are these?"
"Black amethysts from Asshai. The rarest kind, a deep true purple by daylight."
"It's very lovely," Sansa said, thinking, It is a ship I need, not a net for my hair.
"Lovelier than you know, sweet child. It's magic, you see. It's justice you hold. It's vengeance for your father." Dontos leaned close and kissed her again. "It's home."
And that is the synopsis of ACOK, Sansa VIII! These Sansa chapters have been among my favorites from the book, and I’m actually genuinely sad to be leaving her for the next book. What did you think, ser?
Depth
Sansa’s story in ACOK started with Joffrey’s birthday party, and hardly anybody came. Why would they? The fledgling Lannister regime seemed to be hanging by a thread. Sansa’s story in ACOK ends on the opposite note. Now the Lannisters are on top; now everyone shows up to Joffrey’s party. Sansa VIII is a riot of fancy clothes and grand proclamations, every detail designed to establish that this is the face of righteous authority, the Chain of Being in place once more. But Sansa knows, and George shows us, how all of this is a performance, a farce. Even victory is a shadow on a wall.
Something that strikes me about this chapter is how it stands in contrast to our Blackwater chapters. Of course, it’s tonally different than all of those battle chapters as the battle is over and concluded with a Lannister/Tyrell victory (boo), but on another level, the Battle of the Blackwater revealed the true face of the nobility. From the arrogant overconfidence of Imry Florent in Davos III to cruel, childish brutality of Joffrey in Tyrion XIII to Cersei losing hope and making sure that if she goes down, everyone goes down in Sansa VI to the betrayal of Mandon Moore in Tyrion XIV to the casual cruelty of Cersei, the drunken stories of Dontos and the twin faces of Sandor Clegane.
In a way, what we saw at the Blackwater was Sandor’s burned and scarred face. The exposed brutality and cruelty. But here in Sansa VIII, the beautiful face is back. The clothes, the pageantry, the ceremony, shining knights, high lords, beautiful ladies. The nobility has put back on its outward face after the Blackwater exposed it raw. This is the way that the aristocracy sees itself, or at least wants everyone else to see itself. However, the Blackwater, the greater War of the Five Kings has shown permanent cracks in the facade, and even here amidst the beauty, the mask slips, and the cruelty comes out.
- The day’s fashions
- ACOK has been a story told in bright bursts of color, and this chapter is no exception. Every visual detail in the throne room is eye-popping
- George doesn’t write it this way just to grab the reader’s attention. It fits what’s happening in the scene. Everyone is showing off for each other
- The royal court is united in a common goal: acting like this was always obviously the rightful royal court, and anyone who said otherwise was always obviously a traitor. This is how the Lannisters reaffirm their power
- We might like to think that there is some platonic core of righteous leadership out there, and then the surface accoutrements reflect that
- In truth, it works the other way around. All we can access is the surface, and then we project the substance into it. Everyone is dressed in their Sunday best because that’s what being in charge looks like. If enough people agree on that, you’re in charge. Image and reality are intertwined
- So what if Jalabhar Xho is still in exile and will remain so forever? Today, he looks like a bird in flight. Who cares if the High Septon was bought and paid for by Tyrion, that Cersei will have him smothered in his sleep? Today, his crystal crown transforms sunlight into the rainbow of the Seven
- Even Gyles Rosby’s coughing has a gilded edge to it today: he’s spitting up phlegm into a square of scarlet silk to honor Lannister colors...and probably also to hide the blood
- All the world is a stage, and as Tywin himself says, no one is truly free. We are imprisoned by performance, by the eye of the beholder
- Maturation isn’t about accessing pure truth--we still haven’t figured out how to do that. Rather, it’s about understanding the nature of the deceit. How are you being lied to, and why? Qui bono? Who benefits from the lie?
- Something I noticed on reread is that Sansa keeps comparing the royal court to less fancy folks. The lords and ladies are “jostling like fishwives on a dock.” They “cheered as lustily as cutthroats at a cockfight”
- Sansa is beginning to realize that all people are just people; by and large, they behave in similar ways. There’s no inherent property of the lords and ladies that makes them different than the fishwives or the cutthroats
- All that changes is the context, because context is all there actually is to power. The dock becomes the throne room. The cockfight becomes the struggle over royal betrothals. But human nature itself stays constant
- That consistency makes us predictable, and that predictability makes us easy to manipulate. As you read this chapter, you gradually realize that (almost) everything that happens in it has been worked out beforehand
- Sansa knows enough now to understand that when the lords and ladies cheer for Margaery to be their new queen, they are “like a pack of trained dogs.” None of them actually care about Margaery as an individual
- This is merely the public performance of power. The decisions have already been made, yet in a sense, they don’t exist until the court publicly affirms them, even though the court had no part in the decisions!!
- That’s the head-spinning nature of political power. It’s an ouroboros. Who is truly in charge of this room? It’s impossible to say
- I love your observation about the comparisons Sansa makes about the nobility being like “fishwives” and “cutthroats”.
- That speaks to something we’ve been tracking throughout Sansa’s journey in ASOIAF.
- She’s starting to see through the optics of things and is now seeing to the substance.
- And the substance is not great, bob!
- One can think of Sansa’s first chapter where she was enamored with the chivalrous Barristan Selmy and the beautiful Renly Baratheon in his forest-green doublet.
- Or we can look back at the Hand’s Tourney and the glorious banners, coats of arms, armor and great names that Sansa saw when she visited the lists with Jeyne Poole and Septa Mordane.
- Sansa’s journey has been one where she’s moving beyond the surface-level beauty and seeing what lies underneath of that.
- And on the same token, Sansa is getting a front-row seat to the optics game and how it’s played.
- And boy, is it being played well here.
- Yes, it is all bullshit, but it’s baffling the audience with bullshit and projecting strength.
- The Lannisters and Tyrells have won the largest and most complex battle in the War of the Five Kings, and they are going to milk that victory for every political advantage possible and that starts with the ceremony itself and continues through the introduction of Lord Tywin Lannister.
- Announcing Tywin
- As Sansa rushes in, the heralds trumpet the arrival of Lord Tywin Lannister, who manages to literally outshine everyone in the room
- His wealth and military might are on display, linked together into a single show of power. His burnished steel, his ruby-eyed lion; even his horse is wearing ornamentation. Even his horse is better than you
- Tywin developed this style to counter what he saw as his father’s weakness. “The lion has awoken,” as Harys Swyft said of Tywin v. Tytos
- As Sansa says, he makes for an impressive figure. The Lion Lord looks like he has everything under control, so let’s give him control of everything
- And then, of course, Tywin’s horse breaks the mood by taking a Joffrey-sized shit right in front of the Iron Throne. I love this!
- It’s a perfect punchline, undercutting everything Tywin and the Tyrells are trying to get across. It stands in contrast to all the gold and flowers
- It’s a metaphor for everything the victors of the Battle of Blackwater are covering up in their first draft of history. The lie of Joffrey’s parentage, the cruelty of Tywin’s warmaking, the fact that it was the Tyrells who starved out the city in the first place...all of that has to be ignored in order to maintain the image, and that image is being exposed as literal horseshit. As George puts it, this is the horse’s “homage” to Lannister power
- Even putting aside the metaphor, this demonstrates that Tywin and the Tyrells cannot control everything. There are limits to stage managing, even for the best politicians; we’ll see that again later on in the chapter
- Joffrey “made a show” of asking Tywin to become his Hand and take over the government; that was decided beforehand. But he didn’t plan on having to step around a pile of shit. Sansa smiles to see him so powerless. Even kings have to deal with the unexpected
- This is my favorite moment of this chapter, because it’s both the perfect punchline as well as a big, big wink from George in what is otherwise an utterly outrageous chapter.
- I don’t say that as someone who thinks that, on the whole, it probably would have been better for Westeros if Stannis had won on the Blackwater.
- And don’t get me wrong: it’s brilliant optics to have Joff ask Tywin to take on the role and for Tywin And for Tywin to accept and take his position at the table. But. Come. The. Fuck. On.
- But just look at the gall of it all. Tywin, the greatest living monster in Westeros who is responsible for the most civilian casualties and the utter devastation of the Riverlands, is now named Lord Protector of Joffrey and Defender of the Realm.
- And unlike Robb and Roose last week, when we talked about how Robb had no idea Roose was doing war crimes, Tywin had ordered it.
- "Unleash Ser Gregor and send him before us with his reavers. Send forth Vargo Hoat and his freeriders as well, and Ser Amory Lorch. Each is to have three hundred horse. Tell them I want to see the riverlands afire from the Gods Eye to the Red Fork."
- We readers then have the advantage of experiencing what the official policy of Tywin Lannister was like Riverlands via Arya and Catelyn’s chapters in ACOK.
- And his punishment? None here. He’s Hand of the King, Lord Protector of Joffrey and the realm. Gross.
- George wrote this part of the chapter to personally inflame my (or reader) sensibilities, and it works.
- Yet, he lampshades the whole thing with the horse shitting everywhere. As you say, it’s absolute horseshit what’s occurring in the throne room.
- It’s kinda hilarious that the sweet part of the bittersweet equation is the horse shitting, but it’s effective storytelling and shows us that George recognizes the cynicism of his own writing and wants us to know that he knows.
- And speaking of more political bullshit, Tywin didn’t win at the Blackwater because of his own actions or even the actions of his own troops in the battle.
- Announcing the Tyrells
- Next into the throne room after Tywin are his new best friends--the Tyrells of Highgarden. We’re being shown the pyramid of power from the top down. The regime is trying to reboot the zeitgeist, start this epoch all over
- I love that George doesn’t tell us what the heralds actually say about these “heroes” of the Blackwater as they are escorted into the throne room
- Instead, he just tells us that the heralds are listing off everyone’s noble deeds. That clues the reader into how artificial it all is
- The deeds themselves don’t matter, and are probably being inflated or even invented. What matters is the declaration itself as a political act
- Joffrey spouts this metaphor about the roses supporting the lion, and everyone knows he didn’t come up with that. It was written for him
- Sansa is no longer excited by this grandiose rhetoric in itself. She is beginning to see the purpose behind the words
- This is our introduction to Lord Mace and his second son Garlan, but we don’t learn about them as individuals yet. Instead, we see them function as a unit, their practiced political performance in full flower (so to speak)
- Sansa can’t help but compare Mace and Garlan to Loras, the first Tyrell she (and we) met, and more beautiful than his past-his-prime father and his burlier older brother. But Sansa also sees what they have in common:
- The three dressed alike, in green velvet trimmed with sable.
- “And now it comes,” Sansa thinks as the Tyrells launch into their requests from the king. It lets us know that this is all staged: the Tyrells already have cemented their gains, and are now putting them on display
- One by one, they show off their high-placed positions near the king. Loras will guard him; Mace will advise him; Margaery will rule by his side as his queen. They will own Joffrey, balls to brain to bone, and everyone knows it
- Everything they would’ve gotten from Renly, everything they seemed to lose in an instant when Stannis’ shadow slit his throat: they got it all back!
- The Tyrells are now functionally the royal family of Westeros, which was their goal all along. The king himself is an entry point, a means to an end
- They used Renly’s armor to defeat Stannis, even though Renly was dead, and now they prepare to use Joffrey’s crown to take power, even though they know he’s a twincest bastard and they rebelled against him
- In order to pull this off, the Tyrells have to pretend they never crowned Renly and rose up against the Lannisters. But they can’t ignore Renly entirely, because they are here to propose that Joffrey wed Margaery, and everyone in the room knows that Margaery was wed to Renly first. How do you handle the issue of her virginity? What if her first child is Renly’s?
- So Garlan refers to Lord Renly, not King Renly oh no never that, and says that Renly rode off to war before the marriage could be consummated
- It’s so funny to watch Garlan cut himself off with “Lord Renly rode to war.” Rode to war against who, exactly? Was it the people in this room? The family you are now marrying into? How inconvenient! So instead it’s framed as though Renly was rebelling against Stannis the whole time
- Garlan also leaves out the little detail that Margaery went with Renly as far as Bitterbridge. There was plenty of time to consummate the match
- But it really doesn’t matter whether Margaery is actually a virgin, just like it didn’t matter that Renly was actually gay. What matters is what we believe
- The Tyrells: my favorite political players in the game of thrones. I love these conniving assholes so, so much.
- (I love them so much that we even have a whole patreon episode “Every Rose Has Its Thorns” about this fucking family. )
- They’re all high-sounding words and concepts and talking their way around inconveniences. I laughed heartily at the “we went to war against, um, well let’s not get into the who-was-planning-to-kill-who thing right now” moment from the chapter.
- And similar to the Lannisters milking the optics of their victory to maximum effect, the Tyrells start milking their turncloaking to maximum effect here in this chapter.
- Like you were saying: the Tyrells own the Lannisters so hard in this chapter, infiltrating every aspect of the regime.
- And this is where I start my long differing with the general fandom belief that Mace Tyrell is a dunce.
- Sure, he plays a good dunce role every time we see him on-page, but what I see is him is a clever political operator playacting as a dumbass and aided in this by his mom Olenna.
- Let’s fast-forward a bit as Littlefinger provides us the information on what happened during the political negotiations with the Tyrells:
- When I came to Highgarden to dicker for Margaery's hand, she let her lord son bluster while she asked pointed questions about Joffrey's nature.
- Most folks look at this as Olenna having the real power here and “asking the pointed questions”.
- What I see is Mace and Olenna doing a “double act” comedy routine with Olenna playing the “straight man” role and Mace doing the “banana role” (that is: playing the funny man, less educated, dunce role) in a comedy routine.
- Now to be fair, when we meet up with Olenna in Sansa’s first ASOS chapter, Olenna calls her son an oaf, a puff-fish, etc.
- And yet that “buffoonery” leads to Mace getting what he wants:
- The thought that one day he may see his grandson with his arse on the Iron Throne makes Mace puff up
- But then to fast-forward even father, when Mace is in small council, he’s still extracting shit from the Lannisters: placing his men into the gold cloaks and displacing Lannister toadies.
- Kevan Lannister thinks of Mace thusly in the epilogue:
- The more I give him, the more he wants. Kevan Lannister was beginning to understand why Cersei had grown so resentful of the Tyrells.
- But what makes Mace and the rest of the Tyrell clan exemplars of feudal society is their ability to leverage their children into the highest offices in the land.
- Again, like I was saying in that patreon episode, the Tyrells are House Frey with better PR and better people doing their PR.
- They use the same sort of dynamic to claw their way to a higher station in life: Robb has to take Olyvar Frey as his squire, Arya has to marry Elmar Frey and Robb is betrothed to a Frey woman.
- The Tyrells play this game much better getting Loras onto the Kingsguard, Mace into the small council and Margaery betrothed to Joffrey.
- Betrothals old and new
- Tywin is staging this scene as though he forged the alliance with the Tyrells; he was the one who did the military work on the ground
- But never forget it was Tyrion who proposed the marriage pact between Joffrey and Margaery, and sent Littlefinger to the Tyrells on that basis
- He saw that opportunity and seized it right after Renly’s death, striking while the iron was hot. He saved his cause, and never gets the credit
- Tywin despises his son, and anyway, his incentives and worldview lead him to inflate his own role; same reason he wears that armor
- The Tyrells don’t exactly stand to gain from emphasizing Tyrion’s role, because he’s not present and in power to be a useful ally
- And Littlefinger certainly isn’t about to share credit with Tyrion! So in this chapter, everyone else gets to soak in the applause for his good idea
- It’s especially galling to watch Cersei declare that of course Joffrey shouldn’t marry Sansa, given that she argued otherwise when Tyrion proposed the match. It’s equally obvious that the High Septon is talking out of his ass when he says that the gods are on Team Margaery
- The reader is in the privileged position of seeing how the sausage gets made; we know the private faces as well as the public, so we see the gap
- Sansa tells us that Joffrey is only making a show of looking surprised by the proposal. She knows that because, as we gradually learn, Cersei told her everything that was going to happen beforehand
- Why did Cersei do that? It’s not as though Sansa gets a say in what happens to her next; Cersei makes that very clear to her
- Cersei told Sansa what was coming because Cersei knows that Sansa’s automatic reaction to her betrothal being broken would be joy
- Of course it would be! Joffrey executed Sansa’s father and had her beaten by his bodyguards! But Cersei cannot permit Sansa to react that way
- Instead, Sansa has to perform sadness. That way, it looks like marrying the king is desirable, something every girl in the kingdom should want
- In other words, Sansa has to perform her younger more naive self, the Sansa that would be devastated to have her royal betrothal set aside
- That’s the Sansa that fits the pageantry on display. Her true emotions, if they showed on her face, would give away Joffrey’s monstrosity
- Everyone in the room knows that Joffrey is the worst. But their power depends on pretending otherwise, so Sansa must pretend too
- Despite knowing that this was all arranged, Sansa is afraid for a moment that Joffrey will break character. She remembers the day Ilyn Payne beheaded her father. Joffrey didn’t keep to the script that day
- Joffrey clearly doesn’t want to give up Sansa, as Dontos will say later in the chapter. He has been told he must wed Margaery; he is resisting
- Ultimately, though, he gives in. He tells the Tyrells that he is free to heed his heart, even though he has visibly done the opposite of that
- This is the king, right? The font of power? The triumphant occupant of the Iron Throne, his major rival removed, his foundation more secure than ever? And yet, even he is responding to pressure. Even he is not free
- As usual, Cersei puts it bluntly to Sansa: none of us get what we want. It is Tywin who makes Joffrey back down, but even Tywin is not truly happy
- It says something that Sansa is happier than she’s been all book precisely because she is being removed from the inner circle. Her old dream is being denied; she has learned it was not all it was cracked up to be
- That moment when Joffrey gives a sullen glance at Tywin before cracking is so clutch here.
- It reminds me of Tyrion’s memory of Tywin from ADWD
- "No man is free. Only children and fools think elsewise.
- Joffrey’s desire not to wed Margaery is one of this little shit’s most relateable moments in the series here.
- He’s getting bullied by a mass murderer to do “the right thing” and has to very much not follow his heart.
- Now, my interpretation is that Joffrey doesn’t want to wed Margaery because there would be real strings restraining his psychopathic behavior with Margaery -- strings which don’t exist with Sansa Stark.
- But it’s relatable, because Joffrey, the king, is a mere pawn of Tywin Lannister.
- It’s interesting thinking about Tywin in this role as well. This is what he always wanted as Hand of the King: to be able to rule the realm without constraints.
- Given the context we learn about Tywin and Aerys’ relationship, this became a large part of what led to the dissolution of their relationship.
- Aerys wanted to be the king in name and practice, and he kept countermanding Tywin’s decrees and orders.
- But here, Tywin has what he probably thinks is the perfect alternative to Aerys: a kid who owes his very life to Tywin and will probably be compliant.
- As we’ll find out in ASOS, Joffrey is much more like Aerys than Tywin knows, and if either had lived longer, I imagine a similar dynamic would have replayed.
- Rewarding the winners
- Moving on down the pyramid of power, we reach the other nobles hoisting Tywin and the Tyrells up on their shoulders
- The lords of Reach and Westerlands have to be smoothly integrated: Kevan Lannister and Addam Marbrand alongside Randyll Tarly and Mathis Rowan. Their interests overlap...for now. It’ll take work to keep it that way
- They united around a common enemy, Stannis, but now he’s been defeated. The marriage pact gives them an organizing principle, the promise of an heir from both lines, but they will all want a piece of the pie
- And they’re not alone! Those of lesser birth know just as well that chaos is a ladder, and that civil war opens up a window for redistribution
- Four in particular are highlighted here. Unlike the great lords, we do get to hear about their specific deeds: acts of great valor on the battlefield
- I think George writes it this way to emphasize that these are the guys who did the real grunt work of the battle. Of course, they wouldn’t even have been there without Tywin and the Tyrells making a deal, but that’s the point--despite Tywin’s fancy armor, his arena is the game of thrones
- The actual battling of the Battle of Blackwater was done by the likes of Lothor Brune, Josmyn Peckledon, Philip Foote, and Willit
- Here, we see them rewarded for their efforts. For me, it’s an ambiguous moment. On one hand, their lives are changing for the better
- As with Davos, the dream of social mobility is realized. You prove your worth with courage, and that courage translates into material success
- On the other hand, unlike Davos with his merciful gift of onions, this dream is only being realized through the violent deaths of others
- Moreover, while some of the rewards take the form of elevated status, the heroes are also given more weapons. The message is clear, and it’s a bleak one: thanks for risking your neck, now get out there and do it again!
- The irony is especially painful in Willit’s case. He’s the most humbly born of the four. He’s being rewarded for defending his master Harys Swyft, one of the most useless members of the nobility
- He took such grievous wounds that he has to be carried in on a litter. Yet what do they give him? A spear, a hauberk, a helm, things he may never be able to use again. They would’ve served him better during the battle
- Westerosi power runs on a martial culture. This is the most realistic way for Willit to get ahead. Is that why Willit defended Harys Swyft so vociferously? Did he see the chance to change his life and seize it, whatever the cost? He is sacrificed to the power structure, but he also sacrificed himself for his family’s sake, so his sons could be knights
- Terrific point! His kids get to be brought up at Casterly Rock as a squire and page
- If the system can’t chew up Willit and spit him out, there’s always his sons.
- In that context, it feels like a horror story with the Grim Reaper hooking a finger at Willit We may not have gotten you, but we’ll take your children instead.
- And where are his kids going to? Oh yeah. Casterly Rock.
- Sure, it’s a rich castle, controlled by the richest family in Westeros, but it’s also a castle run by unhappy people who like to do war crimes.
- Those dungeons where people are tossed into and never seen again.
- And this is also the castle run by those war criminals who like to do war crimes -- especially to lesser knights, squires and pages.
- "The boys who guard the foodstuffs always eat the best," Ser Lorimer liked to say, until he was discovered with a salted ham he'd stolen from Lord Tywin's personal stores. Tywin Lannister chose to hang him as a lesson to other looters. Podrick had shared the ham and might have shared the rope as well, but his name had saved him.
- So, if the war doesn’t get Willit or his sons, there’s always the danger that the castle itself will swallow his boys.
- Everything Tywin touches dies.
- The songs Sansa used to love tell us that virtue is its own reward. You act heroically because you are a hero. But again, the truth is inverted. You act heroically to become a hero, because heroes get paid
- Or at least, they do sometimes. Running under the surface of this scene, unspoken but present, is the heroism of Podrick Payne
- He saved his master like Willit. He went up against older, stronger opponents like Josmyn Peckledon. Yet he is not honored here, because no one bore witness to it. No one, that is, but us
- Moreover, Podrick’s heroism doesn’t fit the narrative on display here. He killed a Kingsguard knight, one that had just betrayed the Hand
- That would ruin the shadow on the wall, the mandatory air of conviviality papering over the ruin and folly of the Lannister regime
- So Podrick is erased, just like Tyrion is erased. He is mentioned a grand total of once in this chapter, and not even by name, but as “the Imp”
- Doesn’t that perfectly sum up this whole gilded age? Tyrion is the true architect of this victory. Not only did he make the marriage pact, as I said earlier, but he used the chain and wildfire to slow Stannis down. Without him, Tywin and the Tyrells would have shown up too late to save the day
- Yet if you were to read this scene cold, without knowing what had happened, you would never guess that he made all of this possible
- The protagonist of this book has been disappeared before our eyes, his actions overwritten by those who burst in at the last second to take credit. Such is the power of narrative, weaponized for political control
- Lancel, too, has vanished, even as he receives a lordship and a castle. The richest reward cannot heal body and soul, as we’ll see in AFFC
- In their place, the next “hero” to receive his rewards is Petyr Baelish. We haven’t seen Littlefinger for a while; kudos to George for reminding us what a smug asshole he is. You wanna reach into the book and punch him
- Even in this gaudy environment, Littlefinger stands out like a peacock in mating season with his rose-and-plum couture
- He looks so pleased with himself, as Sansa notes, despite him not having done anything heroic in the battle. He climbed the ladder a different way
- Littlefinger squeezed his mission to the Reach dry for every drop of influence, as we’ll continue to see play out in ASOS
- He was able to position himself as an invaluable information broker linking all sides together, while putting none of his own power at risk
- In the process, Littlefinger secured the greatest reward of the Battle of Blackwater: Harrenhal, and the title of Lord Paramount of the Riverlands
- He has gone from heir to stones and sheep shit to the lord of the biggest castle in the realm, with one of the Seven Kingdoms doing him homage
- His children and grandchildren could be among the most powerful people in Westeros. It’s a dizzying ascent...yet as Sansa notes, it’s purely nominal
- The Lannisters don’t even hold Harrenhal, and the riverlords serve House Tully. They’ll never follow an upjumped outsider like Petyr Baelish
- Sansa then worries that her family will be thrown down and forced to serve Littlefinger. This moment captures the complexity of George’s storytelling
- Sansa is right that the post-Blackwater consensus spells doom for her family. She’s just wrong about the source of the danger
- Like Arya, she hopes that Robb will win his next battle like he’s won all the others. What she doesn’t know is that Robb’s defeat won’t be in the field
- The Lannisters offering the Riverlands to Littlefinger is a sign that they have dark plans for Team Stark...but Littlefinger himself isn’t involved
- From what we can tell, he never intended to fight for Harrenhal. He intended on using the title to springboard himself into a match with Lysa
- From there, he has been able to seize power in the Vale, and will try and use the Sansa-Harry the Heir match to seize power in the North
- When Sansa thought that Harrenhal was an empty title, she inadvertently stumbled onto Littlefinger’s plan. That’s all he ever needed it for, because his power doesn’t come from castles and armies. It comes from debts
- Littlefinger is therefore able to escape the trap that claimed Janos Slynt, who thought the title alone would protect him. Littlefinger sees the title as a stepping stone to the next title and the next. If you stop, you die
- Multiple master plans are brushing past each other. Instead of ships passing in the night, it’s icebergs passing, with so much hidden beneath the surface. All Sansa can do is try and read the signs; same goes for us
- There’s such a dramatic contrast between the cynical wheels-within-wheels scheming of Littlefinger and the humility of the hundreds of new knights crossing the city barefoot in simple garb
- They’ve come to offer themselves up, body and soul, a shining ritual of purification...that takes all damn day because there are only three Kingsguard left in town! War and politics have claimed the rest. The projection and the reality are interwoven, and can’t be pulled apart
- Of course, George can’t help but point out that the knights who have crossed the city have done so barefoot with some arriving in the city with bloody feet.
- They have come humble, but it was a bloody affair to get them to their knighthood.
- And as demonstrated by the rewards doled out to those who were already knights, only more blood will carry them forward.
- We were talking about the soldiers who did valorous deeds on the battlefield earlier, and there's one Lothar Brune who allegedly killed 50+ Fossoways and captured Ser Jon Fossoways.
- That seems quite the embellishment on what probably happened at the battle itself
- But why embellish the battle record? I think this is Littlefinger starting to burnish his reputation. He already knows he’s getting Harrenhal, but he needs to surround himself with pieces to play the game.
- When we first met Lothor Brune, he was a mere freerider in service of Littlefinger as introduced in the tourney of gnats from Sansa I.
- But now he’s a knight with a spectacular, probably embellished record. He’s a storybook hero doing storybook deeds on the battlefield by killing all those Fossoways no-names and then chivalrously taking Ser Jon Fossoway prisoner.
- I hate Littlefinger, but game recognizes game here. Even in this embellished telling, the Fossoway men-at-arms are just cleaved apart without anyone giving a shit, but Ser Lothor Brune spared the life of Ser Jon Fossoway.
- We know that Ser Jon is indeed alive and was taken prisoner. Did Lothor do so out of chivalry? Probably not! The idea for taking prisoners on the battlefield was to kill the commons and take the nobles prisoner for ransom purposes.
- Littlefinger is crafting a narrative around his entourage and by extension, himself: one that appeals to his fellow nobles.
- He’s got a storied champion of the battlefield in his service, a knight whose actions rival Ser Barristan Selmy and he’s about to be granted the biggest castle in Westeros and a title that’s even bigger.
- Before Littlefinger gets named to those things, we start to see his ascent: with him acquiring valuable assets and pieces for his future game of thrones.
- First a storied war hero, then a castle and lordship, then a paramountcy, then Sansa and a key to the North, then Lysa and the Vale, then ...
- Punishing the losers
- As George puts it: now the coin is turned over, and the losers of the Battle of Blackwater are ushered in to bend the knee
- I love that phrase: the coin is turned over. It captures what a close thing the battle was. It was a coinflip! If it had come down on the other side, Stannis’ Stormlords would be the ones parading around like heroes, while the Lannister loyalists would be the ones forced to surrender or die
- The winners of the battle have an incentive to act like their triumph was inevitable, but the line between victory and defeat can be a thin one
- For the winners, George emphasized the splendor of their garb. For the losers, he does the opposite: drawing our attention to their wounds
- Those who surrendered during the battle need only vow to serve Joffrey. Those who actively fought for Stannis are compelled to beg and plead. You can imagine both Joffrey and Tywin enjoying the ritual humiliation
- This is an essential part of the shadow on the wall, every bit as much as Tywin’s fancy armor. The Lannisters want everyone to see that those who defied their rule have been reduced to scraping and bowing before them
- Here’s the thing too about this whole charade: if Stannis was the victor, he’d be doing the exact same thing here.
- And we already know how he’d frame this:
- My lords bannermen are inconstant even in their treasons. I need them, but you should know how it sickens me to pardon such as these when I have punished better men for lesser crimes.
- Tywin might not be smiling here as all these Baratheons have to bend the knee and lie that they did treason (again, the gall!)
- But to Tywin and Stannis, this is the dream: everyone parading in front of them, telling them how Tywin and Stannis were right all along, and they are so sorry to have wronged them and please forgive them.
- I think this is such an interesting beat though with Tywin doing the thing that Stannis always gets credit for: forgiving former enemies so long as they’re bending the knee to the correct king.
- I will note here that the terms offered at Storm’s End were a bit more generous than Tywin’s here: you can go home with your weapons, but you’ll have to leave the pack horses.
- But in the event that Stannis had to take the whole castle by force of arms, this was Stannis’ threat to the garrison:
- The king pointed a finger at him. "I give you fair warning. If you force me to take my castle by storm, you may expect no mercy. I will hang you for traitors, every one of you."
- Now, Stannis was saved from having to execute the Storm’s End garrison thanks to Ser Cortnay very mysteriously, who-did-it, it-was-an-accident fell from a tower, but there’s little doubt in mind that Stannis would have hanged every member of the garrison if he had to take the castle.
- And yet here in a circumstance where Tywin has all of these Baratheon prisoners who had fought to the bitter end in his presence, they have to make a profession that they were wrong and dirty, dirty traitors and please forgive me, good king Joffrey.
- And Tywin does. He forgives all of these guys … and then immediately rolls most of them up into a new army that Randyll Tarly takes command of in ASOS.
- And then Tywin sends Randyll Tarly and his army of Reachmen and Stormlanders off to fight Robett Glover and Helman Tallhart coming for Duskendale.
- This is the fate of many of these guys who ask for the king’s forgiveness:
- Lord Randyll Tarly had commanded Joffrey's army, made up of westermen and stormlanders and knights from the Reach. Those men of his who had died here had been carried back inside the walls, to rest in heroes' tombs beneath the septs of Duskendale.
- This was the thing that hit me the hardest on this re-read. All these boys and knights and lords who bent the knee and tried to save their lives ended up getting fucked over by Tywin anyways -- whether at Duskendale or against Aegon or against Dany and her dragons.
- … just like all of the boys and knights and lords who bent the knee to Stannis, thinking that they were trying to save their lives from Stannis’ noose ended up getting fucked over by Stannis anyways at the Blackwater or the Wall or the march on Winterfell or wherever Stannis annihilates himself.
- Everywhere you turn, you’re getting fucked over by your liege. King’s Landing, the game of thrones is a mousetrap, and you’re going to die now or later within it.
- But just as Tywin’s horse broke the mood by taking a dump, not all of the Baratheon captives are willing to play along
- Some declare that the Lannister court is corrupt, that Joffrey is a usurper born of incest, and that Stannis remains the rightful authority in the realm
- Only now is it confirmed for the reader that Stannis himself survived the battle. His rise to power hung over ACOK; now the possibility of his return is broached. He is once more like a shadow, the threat of future revenge
- As during the battle, Stannis is framed as the embodiment of punishment, your sins coming around to lay claim to you. “A scouring fire will come!”
- As always with Stannis, this is an ambiguous moment. On one hand, you could feel hopeful that someone is still out there defying the Lannisters
- It takes immense courage to speak up against the regime at cost of your life; I can’t help but admire these Baratheon diehards
- On the other hand, “a scouring fire” is not exactly hopeful imagery! It’s more likely to fill any observing third party with dread
- So the catharsis of imagining these preening liars brought low is interwoven with the recognition of the bloodshed that would be involved
- The ultimate takeaway from this part of the chapter, though, isn’t about Stannis. It’s about Joffrey, and how he reacts to the Stannis diehards
- He declares that he is the king. He has a monopoly on violence, and he makes a furious chopping gesture to symbolize that power…
- ...and cuts his hand on the Iron Throne. The symbolism has turned against him. As one of the Stannis diehards cries out, the throne has rejected him
- This is a significant sign in Westerosi politics; just look back at Maegor and Rhaenyra. It’s widely accepted that the Iron Throne can signal acceptance or rejection of its occupants
- Now: is this literally true? Almost certainly not. Joffrey just got overenthusiastic. But it doesn’t matter if the Iron Throne is actually sentient any more than it matters whether Renly slept with Margaery
- What matters is what people believe. In the eye of the beholder, Joffrey just offered evidence for the Baratheon case that he is unworthy
- This is the last we see of the victorious king in A Clash of Kings: being ushered out of the room bleeding as he cries for his mother
- The whole point of this event was to cement Lannister power, and now it looks shaky. Tywin steps forward to cut off the gossip before it spreads
- He takes over the room, reasserting Lannister authority and declaring there will be no more follies. He sits on a step of the Throne to do so
- But that’s a Band-Aid at best. Tywin hasn’t solved the problem of Joffrey, which threatens to unravel all his hard work
- This is a much more minor point than the excellent ones you were making here, ser, but I do love that worldbuilding grows through the narrative rather than vice versa.
- What I mean is that George and his co-authors were probably scouring the pages of his novels to try to find the references to things that should be expanded upon and ran across this scene with Joffrey cutting himself on the Iron Throne and Sansa thinking of a common saying without identifying who this applied to.
- And then later, they decided that Maegor and Rhaenyra would cut themselves on the Iron Throne, signifying that they .
- Yeah, it’s somewhere between a retcon and a hand-wave, and that’s okay. It’s only you nerds (not me, #NotANerd) who will pick up on this.
- But it does show how George creates ambiguous worldbuilding that he can later fashion into something else as ideas come to him or as his backstory develops organically alongside the novels.
- Dontos’ gift
- Sansa leaves the throne room happier than she’s been since before her father’s downfall. Even the food tastes better to her now
- The whole world has been born anew for her, matching the ecstatic imagery Dontos used to describe their deliverance in the battle
- She can’t even perform misery properly anymore. She has escaped Joffrey, the villain of her life, the monster she dreaded she’d have to marry
- But then she arrives at the godswood to meet Dontos, and this time, he’s come to dash her hopes. He tells her that they’re not done with her at all
- Cersei isn’t going to let the King in the North’s sister go, and Joffrey can still wield sexual power over Sansa--as a forced mistress instead of a wife
- It’s a grim reminder of how little control Sansa has over her fate, and by contrast, how little restraint Joffrey faces in terms of getting what he wants
- There’s another moment: when Osmund Kettleblack leers at Sansa when she passes.
- Sansa interprets Osmund’s leer as her not being successful at playing at being sad, but I think it’s a bit more disturbing than that.
- Freedom from Joffrey seems like salvation from Joffrey, but it’s not, and it opens up all new venues by which Sansa can be endangered.
- When Sansa was Joffrey’s betrothed, she was only able to be harmed by fellow nobles at the express command of the king’s command: something we saw specifically and most horrifically in ACOK, Sansa III.
- But now that she’s not betrothed to Joffrey, any protection she had from her status as Joffrey’s betrothed is removed.
- Now Sansa is fair game to the Kettleblacks, those brothers who “got along best with the serving wenches” as the gossip went.
- Osmund is probably thinking that Sansa is single and ready to mingle, and In a way, Sansa resembles Pia and the other former Lannister servants at Harrenhal.
- Her status as Joffrey’s betrothed offered a form of ‘protection’. But now that Sansa has been openly declared the daughter of a traitor again: it’s not just one big monster who can hurt her.
- Joffrey, the big monster, can still hurt her, but the little monsters (like Osmund) can now hurt her as well.
- These are the stakes by which the game is played, and those stakes have not changed simply because the musical chairs of power switched around
- Throughout ACOK, Sansa’s not-a-knights Dontos and Sandor have represented the two dramatic poles of her story: the possibility of redemption contrasted with the promise of destruction
- Sandor was on the brink of destruction when Sansa unearthed a kernel of redemption in him with her song; now he has exited her story
- So now Dontos has to wear both masks. He has to disabuse her notions of freedom from Joffrey, but also keep her overall hope of escape alive
- Dontos says her promised escape will take place during Joffrey’s wedding, and as a sign of his good faith, gives her a hairnet with beautiful stones
- As rereaders, we know this is the murder weapon for the Purple Wedding, material proof of the conspiracy linking Littlefinger to the Tyrells
- Dontos calls the hairnet magic, justice, vengeance, home. He wants Sansa to project that wish fulfillment into it like a story, and stop thinking
- Sansa doesn’t get to escape, unlike Arya in Harrenhal or Dany in Qarth. But like Dany with her ships renamed for the heads of the dragon, her desire for her home is being weaponized, and turned against her
- Dontos is under contract like anyone else, despite his claims of knightly redemption. He has woven Sansa into the web; she is metaphorically caught in the net he gives her. As we will see in her ASOS chapters, beauty conceals death, a rose with thorns lurking underneath
- It’s interesting as we close Sansa’s story in ACOK how George is doing these arc conclusions.
- Daenerys departs Qarth, having not learned much in her journey, but she’s making forward plot progression in changing location.
- Arya departs Harrenhal, wishing to resume being a wolf. She makes a forward plot progression, but she’s learned things along the way and stepped through a thematic and literal doorway into her future.
- Sansa is interesting, because in this entire book, she hasn’t gone farther than a few hundred feet in any direction. She’s been at the Red Keep this entire book.
- And yet she’s made huge strides in looking beyond the glittering surfaces. She sees the songs as striving for an ideal but not representing the reality that she’s experienced at court.
- Sansa has matured physically as a woman, getting her first period and yet still having elements of her girlhood quickly fade away.
- But even by the end, when she finally thinks she’s free from Dontos, she doesn’t realize that she’s a pawn again.
- Sansa was a hostage to Robb’s good behavior from AGOT, Sansa III onwards, and her “good treatment” was sourced, in part, to her being Joffrey’s betrothed.
- She was a pawn for the Lannisters, and now Dontos Hollard is setting her up to be a pawn again.
Foreshadowing/Groundwork
Like his horse, Tywin will take a dump at the end of ASOS--and he will not shit gold.
ACOK, Sansa VIII closes Sansa’s arc similarly to AFFC, The Princess in the Tower which closes Arianne’s arc. Dontos and Doran respectively place an object into their hands: a necklace here and an onyx dragon cyvasse piece there. Then they close by stating that the object symbolizes abstract concepts Vengeance and Justice for both and then “home and magic” for Sansa and “Fire and Blood” for Arianne.
Theory/Discussion
So, Littlefinger. Obviously him getting the lordship of Harrenhal and being named Lord Paramount of the Trident will have a lot of plot dovetailing in ASOS with Lysa and the Vale, but what’s the longer arc here?
Conclusion
- Thanks for listening!
- Rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Google Play, Soundcloud, Podbean etc.
- Check out our Patreon at patreon.com/notacastasoiaf
- Follow us on Twitter @NotACastASOIAF, email us at NotACastASOIAF@gmail.com
- Emmett’s social media, Jeff’s social media
- Thank you to our High Lords and Ladies on patreon!
- Red Rahloo Himself who has renounced his allegiance to the Squishers
- Lady of a Thousand Words
- Septon Merrybald, the Shoeless Sage
- Sister Winter - Lady of the Wolfswood
- Nessie the Elusive, warden of the Neck, Defender of the North and Keeper of Secrets
- Ser Thomas the Raven Knight, Lord of Blackwood
- Ser Way of Course
- Matt, Warden of the Sanguine Shore
- Lord Sam K
- Wisdom Benjicot, Alchemist of Sets and Quanta, Mage of the Arts of Boole and DeMorgan
- Tibs the Great of House Catnapping
- Lord J Manderly, Baker of the Frey Pies
- Septon Merifullheadofhair
- Lady Silverwing
- Joe Snow “King of the Metro North and protector of the Tri-State”
- Kaboth the Unfrozen, Lord of the Bricks and Castle Crimson Light
- Ser Keith of House Corbray, wielder of Lady Forlorn
- Lord Andrew - Warden of the Dubai Sands
- Lord Young of the Ghost Woods
- Lady Meera Reed, Wielder of Dark Sister, slayer of tinfoil
- Ser Will of the Anarcho-Syndicalist Commune
- Lord Clay
- Ser Small Paul, Guardian of the Stone Haven, Defender of Dunnottar Castle
- Septon T-Bone
- Refined Wrangler of Icy Arachnids
- Lady Veronica, who has abandoned the the orphans at the Inn at the Crossroads to become the Queen of Memes
- Lady Danielle of House Lannister
- Titanium Pirate
- Lady Joan, Lady-Ranger of the Frost Fangs
- Lady Aemy Blackfyre, Analyzer of Chinese Literature and Dismantler of the Patriarchy
- Cydnii of House Qo, Princess of the Friendly Black Hotties in the Summer Isles
- Random: Fierce Protector of Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things
- Sir Lady Jordan Defender of the God's Eye!
- And our newest high lord: Lord Peter (not Petyr), Drinker of Strongwine and Lord Commander of the Flat Planetos Society
- Join us next week for ACOK Theon VI as Theon is besieged by Rodrik Cassel but is … saved by … his man … Reek.