Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

As you probably know, some time ago, I put out a little challenge. There were still three slots in the guild to be filled with members, intentionally left "empty" for the express purpose of creating this interaction/challenge. I originally gave y'all a week, but uhhhh... the deadline got extended a bit due to time issues. Anyway, I've read through all the submissions, carefully evaluated all the characters in terms of how they fit into the story, the guild, and how well they mesh with Gary. Here are the three characters I'll eventually write into the story, in order of submission:

Created by Phlosioneer: Rodney, the T6 fanged verminoid.

Created by Joe: Samuel, the T7 Auric Stone Troll.

Created by Matthias: Crystal, the T6 Veilfang Feline.

All three characters have interesting personalities, little to no overlap with other guild members, and fill a role in the guild that isn't already filled. Congratulations to you three, I really like these. As for the others, no submissions were inherently bad, but rather either didn't vibe with me, or felt too plain. If anybody would like feedback on why exactly I didn't pick their character, feel free to ask.

I can't really link to specific comments, so here's a link to the whole post so you can read up on the winners.

Thank you all for participating, and I'll see you in the next creative writing challenge... if I can come up with one... hmmm... maybe voidling nobles or something...

Comments

Salt Salesman

Congratulations to the winners! I was curious what you thought about my submission though.

Matthias

Nice, I was pretty confident you'd pick Rodney, and am very happy that Crystal got picked as well. Can't wait to see what you end up doing with all of these if you said in the challenge that these would be less important than the already established members

Orthoros

I did like your submission, Serra, but it overall felt like the character was more suited to being something above tier 10, maybe even above tier 15. Picking her would've needed some serious tuning to get her down to where she was supposed to be (T3 - T9), and while I did reserve the right to change things around a bit, I didn't want to do too much. Also, for the three I picked, I could foresee how and where they fit into the guild, while with Serra, I had a little more trouble placing her. She was pretty high up on the list, but unfortunately barely lost out due to these reasons.

Orthoros

For now, they're in a similar boat to the Nineteen. They (including the members I made myself) exist in a list, and I pick and choose who to use when and where until I can establish more solid relationships. I don't exactly know which of the guild members will become most important yet, but I'll just have to see where the story takes me. The three new ones, technically also have a chance to become more important, we'll see. Crystal is especially interesting to me, since she'll probably slot in nicely as a "replacement"/mirror for Redax.

Joe

Awesome! Ive always loved berserker tanks in games and in stories! I Sort of based Samuel's personality/character defects off of Smaug (who i got the name from) and the playstyle which usually losses my runs in DCSS, in which i see a shiny amulet behind a wall of mobs thinking my berserk and boosted regen would carry me to the loot, miss a bunch of rng checks, fall into post berserk debuffs, grab the gear and find its usless for my build and promptly am mauled to death by the remaining mobs if i don't have an item to cover my escape or deploy that item too late, an undeniably powerful build brought down by hubris and greed, figured that'd be interesting to write and read! Cant wait to see what you do with em!

Phlosioneer

I'm excited to see what you do with poor, traumatized Rodney. You have permission to change or tweak anything about him or his background, of course. <3

Joe

Btw i forgot to mention to crowned stat! He crowned Constitution!

Phlosioneer

So they're going into the disorganized junk drawer of "future writing materials" XD

Salt Salesman

Dang I guess I really overestimated the average traveler. Was expecting the wolf guy to be the norm… regardless it was fun to make! Thanks for feedback.