Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

 . . . Last 'basic' malt review of the year.   Glad I have other bottles to provide more of a malt-moment. 

Files

Previews only

maxresdefault.jpg

If you like my content you can buy me a 'wee dram' at https://www.patreon.com/ralfy, thanks ! My Books 'Search For A Whisky Bothy' and 'Stories From A Whisky Bar' are both on sale at Amazon and all good book shops. www.oswa.co.uk - An online democratic award programme identifying the best spirits worth buying for each year. For more whisky info & stuff, SUBSCRIBE to 'ralfydotcom' Subscribe to my other YouTube Channel 'Fitter Philosophy' This video represents a personal opinion and perspective only. To comply with Google Adsense policy this video is an independent non-profit review and is not knowingly selling or linking to a site that sells the product being reviewed. 'Ralfydotcom' is brought to you by The Irish Sea Trading Co: Ltd: A British TV licence is NOT required to view my videos or almost every other video on YouTube. ALL items reviewed have been bought from a retailer at market prices within the U.K. unless specified by the presenter. No 'samples', 'free stuff', or gifts are accepted, so please do not try to send them, thank you.

Comments

Anonymous

Two of the most disappointing single malts that I have had have been from Louis Vuitton Moet Hennessy. Tale of Winter by Glenmorangie and just recently a bottling of Ardbeg's Uigeadail. I know that you have been talking about Ardbeg's slide, but I have now been a victim. I bought the Uigeadail as a spare probably about a year ago. My original bottle of Uigeadail was my favorite Ardbeg bottling even though a little pricey. However, when I tasted this bottling about a month ago, I was very disappointed. I put it away for a month and just tried it again. It is painfully artificially sweet and very little peat. I wish Louis Vuitton would stick to hand bags, but I will not be purchasing anything else from this company. It would appear that they are spending all their money on advertising/promotions and not on their casks. They obviously think very lowly of their costumers that they would put such substandard products into the market and think that we would not notice. There are still many great bottlings from others out there for me to spend my money.

Anonymous

I bought three bottles of Glenlivet 12 the other day from a relative that didn’t want them. Not a bad scoop for £35.

Anonymous

Just belatedly bought my Christmas stash. 3 bottles for £115 which is a bit of a splurge for me. Picked up deans tin 12 which I’ve had before and loved , glendronach 12( i know I know but under £40 and never tried it before) and a glenallachie 8 because I liked the 12 and wanted to try a different offering

Anonymous

The only thing I got from the last bottle of this I had was rather a heavy wood presence which was not particularly pleasant. A generous mark.

Chris Molloy

I guess those decisions were being made a decade ago when they filled today's casks, aye? So what do you suppose the issue is, besides the dopey marketing targeted to suckers? You'd think LVMH with over €125-billion would have the resources to source some decent casks; so did they suddenly stop knowing how to make good whisky? I wonder if this is similarly effecting the quality of the leather & zippers on their overpriced handbags & luggage?

Anonymous

A friend gave me a sample a while back. I had pretty low expectations but I thought it wasn’t bad for what it was. Certainly better than Glenmorangie 10.

Anonymous

Yo Steve, ordered on house of malt and says can’t guarantee Christmas delivery but I’m hoping they’ll be here to bring in the new year :-)

ralfy

. . . LVMH are just 'looking after business' in their own style.

Anonymous

Makes me want to go and buy an uigeadail now to see how bad it has got. But it's about £80 where I am so won't be doing that!

Anonymous

I'd rate this a 3 out of 10. It's certainly well below average. The majority of malts marks are in the 80-90 range which indicates they are good malts and this certainly isn't good. You'd probably struggle to find something much worse than this from a credible whisky producer? Their own Founders reserve is worse. I can tell you that!

Anonymous

The branding and display features of bottles may soon be affected with the plans being considered by the Scottish Govt in their battle against alcohol consumption and the effect as a result of excess drinking.

Anonymous

I am guessing it is a few things. It is NAS so either they are now using younger spirit so that they can use older casks for their very over priced over hyped new launches or they used inactive casks. My guess is they then finished it in cheap Sherry casks and left significant sweet Sherry or “cask invigorators” in the cask in an attempt to mask everything. Those are just my guesses as I am just a Ralfy Journeyman. I do know that it tastes drastically different and not in a good way. The only cure was have a dram of Laphroaig 10 Cask Strength to remove the after taste which was a wonderful cure

Chris Molloy

Respectfully Mark, I don't think the Core Range offerings from LVMH have fallen off in quality very much or at all in most cases. The zeitgeist surrounding their whisky brands seems to predictably stem from the overall pretentiousness surrounding LVMH itself and what some would call poor marketing choices. But I've repeatedly stated is that I'm not buying Committee Releases and NFTs, I stick to the bottles they've kept affordable and which I still think are very good and very good values; Ardbeg 5 and Glenmorangie 14 are two good examples of that ✌️

Anonymous

When I was a young lad (many years ago, now!) and starting to get into the old man's liquor cabinet I first discovered scotch whisky. My father liked the stuff, but I recall his idea of a luxury brand was Chivas Regal. The stuff that was usually around was the sort that came in a 1.75 L plastic jug! Not much malt in that juice, I suspect. Eventually I fell victim to some sort of marketing from Glenlivet and discovered what "single malt" was. It was truly an eye-opener. Soon moved on to more serious stuff like Laphroaig, but I've always had fond memories of my first malt. Tried Glenlivet 12 again not too long ago and found it rather simple and forgettable. I guess that's what almost 40 years of chasing down new malts will do. Glad I came across it all those years ago, but today perhaps something best left to nostalgia!

Anonymous

I very recently purchased a 750 ml Glen Grant, 15 yr, 50% ABV on sale at $60 CD with moderate expectation that it would present a bargain against expected retail of $90, given the good age statement and high ABV; and it is not chill-filtered. Disappointingly, it was no bargain, the liquid merited the sale price but on the upside it has been incredibly instructive how it highlighted just how a poorly made whisky can fail. It reminded me of a low quality wine - no structure, unbalanced, yes, a few very present fruit flavors that do not draw one in with their flavor, rather it tasted artificial and boring. What was most enlightening of those features was the poor structure/balance and how terribly the flavors were integrated into the whisky. This whisky shone a very bright light on how a low quality whisky in spite of 15 year age statement and 50% ABV can fail!

Chris Molloy

Yeah, that wasn't very good. I'm not afraid of rough whisky, but that bottle was a bit disjointed.

Anonymous

I have a few whisky novice friends and am looking forward to trying the GG on them!

Anonymous

I've seen the price of Ardbeg 5 creep up to where Ardbeg 10 used to be just a year ago. Think I saw Ardbeg 10 for $70US the other day.

Chris Molloy

Lee, $70 is not an uncommon price around NYC for Ardbeg 10. I can still find the 5 for ~$42, and the 10 for ~$56 😷

Erick Ritchie

When I was given a gift of the new Glenlivet 18 last year and was so disappointed with it I bought the earlier 43% 18 yr at auction and wow, what a difference. Drinking the two side by side is a real eye opener. Since then I've purchased the 12 yr Illicit Still (solid dram) as well as two IBs from Signatory. The first was a 13 yr at 46% which was decent, but the second was a 15 yr aged in a sherry butt at 63.9% and it's a cracker. The latter was only $115 while that new 18 yr I mentioned goes for $130-150 in my area. I feel bad for anyone who wastes their money on it. IBs of Glenlivet don't appear to be too common but the ones from Signatory seem to be good value for the money.

Anonymous

Agreed. Talisker 10 is leagues ahead of this. I think a 1-10 scale would be better for reviews and make use of the full scale. At the moment, everything is 8 or 9 out of 10 which equates to very good or excellent and that's just not the case with some of these malts.

Chris Molloy

Whisky-scores can be very subjective & temperamental, and despite a distillery's best efforts, these bottles vary; so these marks and reviews should be viewed with that understanding. The more you watch, listen, or read a particular reviewer, the more you get to know their like and dislikes and style, and either it resonate with you or it doesn't.

Anonymous

If you want a sweet and sour, apply taste, you would do a lot better with a bottle of Calvados than Glenlivet (or -fiddich) 12.