MADNESS (Patreon)
Content
I spent the week thinking about what to say about Israel and Gaza. By the time it came to do the show, I had decided that I would not put too much focus on it... I didn't want to put Mike in an uncomfortable place and I really felt like we were better off just adding a little levity to the week for a few hours. None of this was really discussed amongst us, but I think that may explain some of the extra silliness and giggly behavior. It was so nice to just joke around a bit.
I'll be brutally honest with you here. When I first saw the news Saturday morning, on our way to Disneyland, I clocked it as a big story, but just another chapter in the saga of Middle East back-and-forth violence I've been reading about or seeing on the TV since I can remember. I'm 47 years old and some of my first TV memories are of my grandfather watching the evening news and seeing angry men picking up blocks of concrete and rock and throwing them toward riot police - dusty, hollowed-out, cement buildings behind them. But as the news continued to filter in it seemed obvious that what was happening was something different.
The next day, I think my feelings were mixed.... Fear and grief for the scores of people killed, captured, terrorized by the attack... but also a little of "well, what did you expect to happen?" It's a terrible but honest reaction - I'm sorry, but this was GOING to happen someday. Now, in no way do I feel like it deserved to happen or SHOULD happen, just that the conditions created the high probability that it WOULD happen.
The absurd madness of the open-air prison that is the Gaza Strip makes it impossible to think about the Hamas Rampage in a contextless vacuum. What for? Why pretend like Hamas came down from outer space and just started slaughtering people?
I have several friends who seemed to get very angry online when people tried to contextualize the violence and it reminded me of when conservative gun supporters would scold the left for bringing up gun control after a mass shooting. "now is not the time" and the left would say "well, when is the time??"
Listen, i don't think there's a serious voice out there suggesting that the current blockade/occupation of Gaza is tenable. I can look at a map and pretty much deduce that the whole thing is nutso. The more I learn, the less I understand... because when you drill down into the core of this issue, you find we're talking about "HOLY Land..." And it's very hard for me to take any of that talk seriously. Of course, I always try my very best to be empathetic to religious people, but to a point. Like, when your religion starts increasing the probability of my holidays being interrupted by Thermonuclear War.
I love the Jewish people and recognize their special and terribly tragic place in history and do believe that Israel has a right to exist as a State - but if its existence demands the subjugation and imprisonment of the religious Palestinians... well, that's not working for anyone, is it?
I also view Hamas as a sick death cult that stands with many in the region who want to see Israel wiped off the map and It's impossible for me to view their attack or general strategy as any kind of heroic, resistance movement that should be celebrated in the streets.
I'll say this about news coverage - it's a mess. There's a whole lot of misinformation out there, a whole lot of heavy Israeli bias on the major networks - I get it, Israel is basically the 51st State - Their spokespeople speak English, look like us, and have mastered the PR game. But there are helpful voices out there who I think are doing a good job of balancing the hard job of being somewhere in the middle - I really felt like this clip of Emma Vigland on the Majority Report did a fine job of trying to find some amount of honesty in all of this.
And there's lots more good reading you can do... I'm reading this piece that Amy Schumer posted which talks about Hamas' broader strategy - lots of Global chess pieces in play.
Anyway, this has been my Brain Dump of the situation. Please understand my feelings on all of this change day by day. I think anyone acting like you can have a pure and simple black-and-white position on any of this is disingenuous or naive and so comments sections on social media seem to be just about the very worst places on the internet lately. And so while I welcome your feedback, insights, or links to more reading or watching, please keep it respectful and know that I hope we all just want peace and justice for everyone.
PS, saw our Jurist Matt last night, and we laughed about Tar... He was like "It was a little rich, with your Pizza take giving me shit for not liking a movie!" oh how we laughed.
P&L, T