Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Ahoohoo, Yonders! It's all hands on (tarot) deck for chattin bout ep9, Da King a Da Cups! The Fox, the "feels", and wheels within wheels. How to play, what to say, when the vibe is "dismay." Can you be true to your heart while your squad falls apart? All this and more on the chat-back show some are calling "out today!"

Files

Comments

Ric Freeman

Crackle crackle mudda farkers!

Sven the Scribe

Pics of Brennan in the assless fox costume when?

Sven the Scribe

I mean the philosophy is great too - but get those pics!

Diamondarrel

The Fox is indeed the best Brennan NPC ever.

Becky Dodd

There's such brutal honesty in that choice of Lou's of having Eursulon decline that chance to be move towards a heroic act again...killed me. <3

Alyssa Haughwout

Oh man my goldfish brain needs to relisten right before the Fireside comes out. Y’all are referencing scenes I k i n d a remember but…? Sounds like a great time

Daniel Wong

I wonder if it is a cultural thing, coz the turn away to protect what little we have feels very real to me and kinda something I hear uttered often, and by the people around me. It doesn't feel inhuman or uncommon at all to me 🤔

bluebluebutton

"If you smack your players on the hand every time they do something risky, they will stop taking risks. And then you'll be sitting there, stunned that your story's not moving forward." - Brennan being the sage every gm needs in their ear.

Michelle Spurgeon

I appreciate that you guys talked so much about the episode. 👏🏻👏🏻

Hemlock

Roll tide!

Arillusine

Oof the breakdown of the episode is really digging into some feels and I love that they’re really deconstructing everything in such detail 🥰

Mack Whaley

Honestly regardless if it’s an ep or fireside, it’s such a joy to spend an hour straight with goosebumps. Couldn’t not be more pleased w this crew

Khayroh

Ahoohoo to you! God, what an incredible episode AND talkback. such an incredible font of joy. i have to mention something i havent seen anyone else say: ame’s decisions to one, disguise her shock and horror as disgust for Naram, and to also bullseye what Morrow wanted to hear, saying “and a Wizard from the Citadel has witnessed that it was you that led this…endeavor,” were both so subtle and incredible to me. the voice acting of holding back nausea while perfectly disengaging with deception through only two lines of dialogue really blew me away. all hail erika ishii!

Donnie K

More Taylor on the Fireside! The sound design of this pod is so damned critical to the tone, that he's a welcome addition to the conversation.

Megan Gass

These podcasts and fireside are absolutely amazing!! I am simultaneously can’t wait for the next episode and know that I can’t sustain that level of intensity if binged. My only true complaint was the R*ll T!@e. That’s strictly because I am in the SEC and have my own personal grudges. But seriously, this whole package of experiences is just a masterpiece.

Matthew

When/where can I get an "Ahoohoo!" shirt?

Kai Calvert

Genuinely as someone who’s had this conversation with my therapist multiple times, I wholly understand Brennan’s point about principles, because while it’s from a base point inherently illogical to say “Two contradictory statements can be true.” It’s entirely valid to say “From a point of perspective these two statements are both true, and by the very nature of the universe in all of its chaos and things being on a spectrum that is not black & white, can both be correct without diminishing each other.” That’s what is at the core of the theory of relativity, everything is relative to your point of reference.

Mia Mac-Pry

I love how Erika fully commits to the guest name bit every time.

Grace Bee

Love to hear Brennan quoting Del the Funky Homosapien

Ben Powell

I love that Taylor was here for this one. He's a blast with the group!

James Walker

This ep was the first I've listened to twice in the same week, just simply amazing. This is my favourite actual play content right now, bar none

FootnoteLovenote

We love dropping every bad Kantian categorical imperative logical fallacy for why moral perfectionism is simply a logical name for excusing complicity. Being imperfect and flawed and inconsistent is not a cudgel to beat oneself or others; it's an inevitability given a world which is too big for any one person to tackle every wrong and still allow nuance, difference, and reflection. Freire has a whole thing about the introjection of the mind of the oppressor and how that is one of the most important things to unlearn in order for a more just world to be made.

OdoDaVodo

We need a pet post from the whole crew

Crystal Johnson-Stanislowski

Re-listening to the Suvi and Steel scene with the knowledge that Steel is 15-friggin'-feet tall during it makes it so much more scary in the whole, little-kid-about-to-get-in-BIG-trouble-from-mom way.

Graham

To defend Marcie, listening on two different apps might be a challenge for some

mguin

Going to ha e to relisten for specific Fox quotes, they're begging for a proper embroidery'ing

The Overthinker

We should all be a little more like the fox.

Trey Lord

I am loving the philosophical explanations, they help me understand what what characters are thinking and feeling. Thanks so much!

Gigi

I wonder if there is ever a possibility of getting like video of the with Taylor firesides? I LITERALLY cannot tell Taylor and Brennan's voices apart. The sensory processing is so broken for me 🤣😭

#KittyLearnsToCook

I think it resonates a lot with marginalized communities. Sometimes you're just too tired to fight for the greater good.

#KittyLearnsToCook

Also I just love getting to know Taylor more as a person, what excites him, his politics etc

Bench Appearo

Know what you mean, my brain has to take a couple extra seconds to process whos talking between the two of them.

Morgana Evenstar

Fantastic to hear from the Magnificent Mr Moore on this one, the music and sound production give so much to the world and the story. Rich textures, scintillating contours, so much of the luxurious lushness of life pulses through every moment of WWWW. In particular, I adore how y'all utilize silence.

Josh Hull

I find it really disorienting how similar Taylor and Brennan sound. Just me? Lol.

Lojaan

I think the point is that it is all too human, we're just not supposed to say it.

Daniel Wong

Yeah, I agree with the first part of what you're saying. What I'm referring to is the latter. That we're not supposed to say it. That's something I wonder if it's a cultural thing coz people around me say it all the time.

Jordan Sims

This is so amazing I’ve never been so invested into a podcast before.. can we please get them another level anytime there’s a potential combat encounter I’m sweating I need them to make it to the end of the story lol

DC

Nah. Rules for thee and not for me; inconsistency is the handmaiden of injustice.

DC

I also must make it known that when Taylor is present, the group's initials spell out T.A.B.L.E. Thank you for your time.

Mara Johansen

I mean, I agree, but the crazy in Bloodkeep that wanted to keep his bones stays in my head most days.

Mara Johansen

And if you never make a different decision, does that not show your inability to learn and grow and evolve?

Erik Parsons

I'm so glad that the whole crew was around the fire for this chat because yeah this episode was so damned good and just so so so big

Lucas Curio

Honestly given enough time in her head to justify it, I can see Suvi selling Ame and Ursulon for a dollar

Erik Parsons

Oh and can I just say that as a doctoral candidate learning to Taylor and Brennan talk philosophical shop is my Jam! I mean babe dropping Rawls? Heck yeah. Looking forward to when they bring up Senn and Nussbaum or even drop in some Fricker or Young into the mix.

Erik Parsons

And is there any way I can get Brennan to go on record in dialogue for my dissertation on Improvisation as essential training for teachers? Because... Legit I'm down to do an entire chapter on TTRPG as an analog for the teacher student relationship within a constrained discipline.

Alex Les

So glad you got into the name and it’s tarot roots :) I was drawing that card a lot the day before the episode released which made for a lovey synchronicity experience last week.

Camille Lanata

Unfortunately Lou cannot make it to the fireside today, so it’s TAB_E, and constantly changing, thank you for reading, have a wonderful evening 😅

505Dude

I neeeeeed a The Wizard, The Witch and The Wild One Album. The music is so incredible and I just want to blast it over my speakers as I melt into a pillow

Sven the Scribe

I jokingly refer to Taylor as 'sassy Brennan' but it really does help me differentiate the two when listening.

Gigi

That doesn't help when I cannot tell who is who except in specific words. And Brennan IS SO SASSY! 🤣

DC

I hear you. Thank you (sincerely) for taking the time to elaborate. People are allowed to be better than they were yesterday. So I won't suggest that an individual should not do their imperfect moral best. My view on inconsistency is so grim because humans are biased even when they don't mean to be (though they often mean to be). The favored groups will be showered in grace, mercy, and good deeds. The disfavored groups...well, they're going to be bearing the brunt of everyone else's "bad days" and moral failings. Similar injustice is reflected in court rulings all the time. When the cake ain't cut even, I know who's ending up with the smaller piece. We all hunger for a better world. I often feel that the disfavored must demand that everyone at the table is served before anyone eats, else nobody will care that the plates of the disfavored are empty and they will starve to death. To be clear, I am not placing this at your feet or Brennan's feet. I place it at the feet of society and our natural/historical biases.

Mercy

Does any one else sometimes have a hard gime telling Taylor's and Brennan apart? May be is just that i listen to this when I'm tired?

Adam Cox

I absolutely agree with Brennan's sentiment of don't punish your players but I think I struggle with the opposite issue. I find one my biggest limiting factors is my hesitance to present too great a challenge to the players. What were seeing in the campaign right now is a monumental task laid before level 1 players, my question to Brennan would be how do you feel confident knowing your players will manage this without player death. Most level 1 adventures are like clearing rats from a basement not freeing Godzilla

Sven the Scribe

Rest might help but they definitely do have very similar voices and manners of speech.

Mercy

I did forget to day I'm partially deaf in one ear. But the resemblance is uncanny

Tgraves19

I really want to see a cut of Taylor reading the credits and introducing Urselon as each one of Lou's characters from the Firesides

Mae Worthington

A truly THICK sode lolol Chef's kiss to absolutely every aspect of this episode...I was so wildly uncomfy but I couldn't stop listening

Matthew

Fox Philosophy: I always try to do whatever I want to do. If they can't catch me then what they think about me doesn't matter. If they catch me then I'm in trouble. If I stop trying to do what I want to do then they've already caught me.

Demelza Walkden

Best wishes to Lev, I hope he can manage to graduate this year!

Katie Butler

Merch brainwave: a crackling fireside silhouette with a dialogue bubble reading "Ahoohoo to you"

Terra Riley

For the record: I didn’t know that Aabria had a dog named Suvi before Erika said that. Fully thought Aabria just talked to a figment of Suvi in her imagination.

Nathalie Schoenauer

Love when Taylor is a part of the chats! Also, it's such a delight to listen to the T.A.B.L.E (credit to DC above for the acronym) collectively lose their mind over one another's creative choices and all the hidden meanings within. Additionally, the Fox now lives permanently in my heart and I will straight up die if/when he gets hurt. Scratch that, already dead at the thought. RIP me.

Carrie Mook Bridgman

I found it curious that the discussion of Steel was about *institutions* and how they give freedom within moveable but definite limits, and how they like grids and order and control. My read on Steel was a mom who's been scared out of her wits and is *therefore* furious, with the sense that she has very specific reasons for being afraid for Suvi that she has not told Suvi about. I understand the "yes, of course you have freedom and agency to do anything that serves the institution, but cross that line and you will get squashed." That's there, but so was Galani's comment: "She was relieved that her surrogate daughter is alive. Judging by the tears running down her face, I think she may well be mad when she gets here."

Carrie Mook Bridgman

"How do you feel confident knowing your players will manage this without player death?" He doesn't. Ame went down on the first round of their first battle. Mostly he trusts his very good, very experienced players to pull things out of the hat, and he can tweak things, but the dice are the dice, and Brennan doesn't pull punches.

Vel

Evilest Teapot

Exactly! That has always been how I’ve read her, especially given how close she was with Stone, and how her promises to both Stone and Suvi must affect her personal actions in this circumstance along with the empire.

Mack Whaley

I never thought I’d be into d&d and have a weird internal narrative about not being creative or a writer HOWEVER listening to these five creators has been so inspiring it’s seriously beyond me. I’m now daydreaming about world building and really enjoying exploring my own mind. I feel such pure joy to absorb this content oof

A. N. Snow

Brennan continues to win my heart with the nod to NADDPOD ("Thick 'sode") and using Gorillaz lyrics to explain the player-GM relationship around perceptive world building.

Za'chary Westbrook

It's bound to be a bit of both, yeah? Like Steel would have different expectations of Suvi if their relationship was divorced from the Citadel.

Za'chary Westbrook

She belongs to an organization where members sacrifice themselves for the greater good all the time. There is definitely a situation where she could do that.

Eric Lobdell

"You don't see with your eyes. You perceive with your mind." Brennan spreading the gospel of the great Del the Funky Homosapien. (Guest rapper on Clint Eastwood by Gorillaz) 🙌

Katharine Smith

Okay, 1 - this has to be one of the best firesides yet. SUCH a good deep dive! 2 - I really need to know where Taylor is from, because trying to pin down the accent is driving me NUTS

Matt Kilsby

I love this pod very much but could I make a humble request for Taylor regarding the edit: When you guys are discussing specific things from the episode (certain lines, certain sound effects or score elements), it would be sooo cool if we could have a little 5-second clip of that thing just to jog our memory before or after we hear you guys discuss it. Because personally 80% I can’t remember what exactly you’re talking about, like the “drunken stumbling soundtrack”, and yes I could go back to the episode and try to find it but I might be scrubbing around for ages just looking for it. If this is a really inconvenient and disproportionate amount of work to do, please ignore me, just an idea that came into my head, hopefully others agree! Love you all, you’re all supremely talented and cool and kind x

Mel Kepler

Matt, as another goldfish brain person (5 second memory) that would help me too - or even a time marker so I can open the ep and cut right to it?

Kelly McGillis

Anyone else think Taylor and Brennan’s voices sound sooooo similar?

RNietzsche

Brennan does such a good job of explaining why hypocrisy is often necessary and good

Alicia

I love these chats so much! Defiantly going to be talking to unsuspecting people all week about the debate cadence problem of consistency > making the world better.

petraG

Howdy! Is there a patreon member's podcast I can subscribe to, in the way that NADDPOD have their public and patreon content on separate podcasts? I am not loving the patreon-native episode interface.

RNietzsche

You can just add the rss feed to your app. There is a link under the membership tab in patreon

Worlds Beyond Number

Yep there sure is! Just sign into patreon and go to your membership page and you’ll find an RSS feed you can add to your podcasting app of choice. Check out the Instruction Guide pinned as the top post on the patreon for more help. Bon chance! -t

Charisma Teeth

Ehrmahgerd. I — a woman with the power of search engines — needed to immediately know what was the time frame for the public domain music. "In most cases, songs enter the public domain when its’ copyright expires. Today, this is the case for any song made before 1926. For songs released after that, the copyright typically expires 70 years after the original artist of the song passes away."

Joseph O'Toole

yknow Erika, I really appreciated the suvi dog clarification because it seemed like they had to be a dog but this is the first fireside chat that I've been able to get to! so happy to be here! :D

petraG

Thanks, Steven & Taylor!

M T

Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the Law

Taliyah IDK

The way Lou talks about not being worried in the scene with Will when I literally squealed in relief when he finally got the sword is crazy

Mitch (Sigg43)

I'm finding the Wizard incredibly jarring given the form (Teamwork makes the dreamwork!). I get it's a child prodigy indoctrinated into a dangerous and cut throat group - I just feel the light is on them 24/7 and they use it to belittle the others. It makes me uncomfortable as a listener - I'll be unsubscribing from the patron to come back when there's more likable PCs as I love the production value and the content creators.

Lev Vaesinis

That moment when you didn't know you were on a podcast...

Kevin Engelkamp

I did not know Suvi is the name of Aabrias dog, appreciate the clarification. I don’t think that had made it into the audio before, and I kinda avoid social media at the moment

Dominique Dixon

I honestly flipped out when Aabria mentioned the Precious Moments bible because I ALSO HAVE ONE!! I didn't know other people had them omg

lunarsummer

Yeah absolutely, the first time Taylor and Brennan both spoke this episode I was perplexed and had to rely on context clues lol

lunarsummer

We should all beg Taylor to put little chime cues in before he speaks so we can tell its the sound master about to speak 😂

lunarsummer

WBN liked it, that means it's gotta happen right??? Right? 🙏

lunarsummer

"Will Gallows can't fuck every business associate the moment he meets them and still be a crime boss" I see you're taking a slow burn approach, and I respect that, and I want you to know that the cursed PWP fanfic I'm writing totally disregards that. But like, respectfully and with love!

Liv

KING OF CUPS WAS ONE OF THE BEST EPISODES SO FAR! Every person involved did a phenomenal job with their characters, and for the intricacy of the story.

Jonesey

Super appreciate the love for a good library montage! Thank you so much for this conversation - adding layers every time!!

Ashley Teatum

"A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds."

jerry stokvis

This episode was absolutely incredible. My favourite moment was when Eursulon, who I expected to agree with Ame, had the outburst of just fear of the empire and not wanting to interfere. It just really illustrated to me how scarred he is from the years that have passed.

Just_another_queer

I am so glad Taylor is back chatting on fireside like damn can't even express the talent you have plus fits right in with the banter hoping for more

Cory

25:50 Hey, Taylor? All respect, one musician and sound designer to another, but this is such a weird and confidently wrong tangent. Civilizations don't rely on the types of institutions you're talking about here; that's some bizarre myth for authoritarian sycophants. Any member of society with so much as a shred of empathy doesn't need to "surrender their personal principles" to conform to a group for the greater good; empathy literally exists to conform individual and group social and survival instincts. That's how *healthy* societies and communities are formed. What you're talking about is a bunch of sociopaths getting trapped on an island and being reluctant to treat themselves equally to the group. Or, like, if we tolerated a law enforcement class that beats and murders vulnerable people because they were perceived as threatening rich people's property, and one day we might be rich people. That would be *insane*.

kallyn

23:02 - 26:40 Check out the anime Sword Art Online (season 3) to see a cool example of a society with principles (rules you must always follow) and their bizarre immoral edge cases. There are no rules you can ALWAYS follow, life is too complex.

MamaMayhem - Sal Soeh, Sal Nu

Catching up on episodes - just wanted to say thanks (?) for the shout-out to Iowa! Love listening to this from Des Moines!

Christopher Underhill

was taylor reading wikipedia or did he just have all that tarot knowedge on deck??? that blew my freakingg mind!!!

ZeeDodger

I'm currently on a Marcy listen through right now (only listening to the Firesides all in a row) I hope she did find the main feed. I feel like it might be just a little easier if the main stories are also available on the main feed. Makes it a little less confusing, especially since Patreon has a decent filtering system.

Hilary Willett

So love the intelligence of everyone involved in this pod. And the intelligence in these comments tbh. Hadn't thought about "principles" as problematic in this way before. Forced me to check some of my own tendencies towards "whataboutism." A part of me does wonder if principles serve a function for some people? Maybe I'm not understanding it right, but I had a friend who got a lot of comfort from external principles, like they helped them to believe in the good of the world maybe? Anyway, this pod got me thinking. Fascinating! Beautiful.

The Pompous Peasant

Too late for the crit roll train but listened to this, was thinking it would be meh, NOPE. Addicted from first ep. Then I thought I'll never listen to the fireside, still so much to listen to, just finished first arc, NOPE. I'm now listening to everyone of the fs before second arc and crying, laughing and just enjoying it all. I would pay $$$ just to be in the campaign for a moment in time. Going to up my donation to them regardless.

Louie

How DARE you let Aabria say “What the fox says” and NOBODY jumps in to make the dumb joke!

Julia Thompson

Goddamnit Aabria calling out why I relate to Suvi so much of the thing where “she’s so smart she can justify what she needs to to make sense of the world around her.” Dagger to my fucking heart and my therapist will be hearing about it on Tuesday lol

Psycoticsmile

As someone who has a late Dec birthday I can relate to Brennans not love of birthdays

Albertina Sparrhult

Tip! Try Brennan’s miniseries for Critical Roll called Calamity and Downfall. It had the best of both worlds and I think it’s 3 episodes each. Abria and Lou are also in the first one. 💚

Albertina Sparrhult

Why does Taylor an Brennan sound so alike. 😅 Or is it just me?

Albertina Sparrhult

Glad you found it! I’ve watched all of CR but recognize it can feel a bit overwhelming to get into. But then it’s good you can pick the tastiest cherries out of the cake. 💚🍒

The Pompous Peasant

So agree. I still feel this show is very unique and special, adore it.

Megan

It's not just you!

Dylan Selinger

Taylor's wonderful tarot descriptions here have me imagining a The Wizard, The Witch, and The Wild One tarot deck. Oh, what a treat that would be! Particularly fantastic episode and fireside chat, everyone! Thank you for your beautiful work! I always love to hear about the sound design aspect of this story, as well. ❤️

Eric

Fantastic Brennan philosophical debate bone cone

Nym

Would be willing to explain “bone cone” to me? I have no idea what it means but I keep seeing it. Help? 😭

Nym

Yep not just you. They have similar manic intellectual/philosophical energy 😊

Nym

A therapist once told me I was very sophisticated at justifying ways to be mean to myself 😬

Eric

Bonus content (bone cone)

Nym

Hi! Obviously VERY late to the convo, but I’m just now listening to Firesides. I do think Taylor was joking here, and possibly you are too? But either way, FWIW, I think both his statement and yours are a little oversimplified. I don’t think institutions by *nature* require people to sacrifice their principles, but it’s very common for institutions to require SOME sacrifice of individual wants for the collective good/mission/reason for being. The social contract of government and people (see Locke/Hobbes/Rousseau) is a perfect example: the government (theoretically) protects you from violence and lawbreaking, and in return you sacrifice your personal freedom or desire to, say, punch out a Nazi. I sacrifice my desire to not work 40 hours a week because the organization that pays me money to pay for my life requires it. I agree civilizations may not necessarily require institutions, but the larger and more diverse they become, relying on empathy alone to keep people from harming one another is tenuous. There are people born who literally cannot feel empathy, and some folks are more in touch with it than others. You can have empathy with multiple people whose desires are opposed to one another. And, most commonly, we often have to overcome our own feelings to empathize with someone else. We’re teaching kids that all the time. There’s also Taylor’s point about preserving civilizations across generations. Whoever sets the “original” institutional value system (historically, religion) may require things that don’t suit later generations, so institutions like government have to contend with societal change.

Mic Naranjo

Waaaaaaaay late to the party here, but Meinklang as in the wine? Nobody caught that? Or have my other obsessions betrayed me?

EWEN (they/them)

So here for Brennan and Taylor going down the philosophy rabbit hole - it is so fascinating to ask those big-picture questions through the lens of narrative.

Morgan Aspery

I did not know that Aabria’s dog was named Suvi

Lila

i think it elongates to “bonus content"

Joe Howard

Naddpod shout out with that “thick sode” reference

Joe Howard

It’s one of my favorite things that Brennans on the record for being a huge fan and keeping up to date with Naddpod

Joe Howard

I do have to agree, I love the talkback and will continue to listen, but do feel that compared to Naddpod or adventuring parties, I don’t understand their references unless I just listened to the episode as they just alude to the moments and don’t always specify Not a huge deal, but it’s nice to hear someone else have the same issue with something I’m slightly frustrated with

JustAlilBonsi

Did not know Abria's dog was named Suvi. Now I do!