Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

I posted part 2 of HALL 9000: A Ball Balancing Robot, yesterday for Patrons.

Well, the new ball has arrived and things look a lot better!

Files

Previews only

Comments

Anonymous

Love it! Disco Hal. Hope you're going to teach the robot to get down and funky :D

Anonymous

Haha, I’m going to pretend that the mirrors will be kept on!

Anonymous

Ok my mind is blown!

Pete Mertz

YES. Can you add some LEDs under the balancing bit so that you get a light show as well!?

Anonymous

Dr. Nefario, I need tiny robots disguised as cookies... COOKIE ROBOTS!! Coo.. Oh forget it..

Scott Cress

That's fabulous. Ingenious idea. I hope the mirrors don't effect the LIDAR, or whichever solution you have for object detection and navigation.

Scott Cress

This quote is perfect :D Also his tiny cookie robots look a little like the Hal 9000 bot James is making, only with spider legs.

XRobots

I think there will be a V2 before we can do navigation, but I have a separate video coming up about that soon hopefully.

Anonymous

I hope those mirrors won't start coming off!

Duane Degn

I've been watching some of your older BB-8 videos and I understand your reluctance to 3D print another ball. I've been working on a way to 3D print balls and in my extremely biased opinion, I think I have a good way to 3D print large spheres. I plan to make a public video once I've printed a large sphere (hoping for 500mm diameter) but in the meantime, I wanted to show the technique I'm using. https://youtu.be/ieFDEl05r7s I'm happy to share CAD files and make changes if you think it would be useful. That said, I doubt you're in the mood to print another large sphere. Thanks for all the fun content.

XRobots

Looks great. I think it would be find for a ball balancing robot - how thin do you think you could make the wall?

Duane Degn

I think the 3D printed screws probably need about 5mm of thread for a secure fit. The inner wall has the threaded holes. The outer wall could probably be 3mm thick for a total wall thickness of 8mm. The soccer ball sized sphere in the video is held together entirely with 3D printed screws secured in 3D printed threaded holes. If you used metal fasteners, rather than PLA, the inner wall could likely be reduced to 3mm. This would give a total thickness of 6mm. The shape of the soccer ball sized sphere became rounder as each piece was added. As the pieces are joined, they pull themselves into alignment. (I'll add some additional detail in separate reply.)

XRobots

Sounds good. I guess the only remaining issue is adding a clear access hatch for BB-8 droids with internal drives.

Duane Degn

I don't think there's much of a weight penalty for making the walls thicker. The inner and outer perimeters make up most of the weight. With a very low infill value, it's possible for a thicker walled shell to weigh less than a thin walled shell. With a thick shell, the area of the inner wall becomes smaller. If the infill percent is low enough, the reduction in weight from the smaller inner wall can be greater than the weight increase caused by the piece edges and infill. (Continued.)

Duane Degn

Inner wall area related to radius squared. The area of the edges have a linear relationship the radius. The infill has a cubed relationship. As mentioned previously, if the infill is low enough, a thicker shell can actually weight less than a thin shell. (Assuming outer diameter stays the same.)

XRobots

The issue with BB-8 is the walls being thin enough for the magnets to grip - I think BB-9E had 8mm total wall width.

Duane Degn

I'm not sure how useful this would be for BB-8 style droids. A pentagon may be removed to provide an opening but this opening is smaller than the ones you used with your droids. This opening also requires 10 screws to be removed (based on the current design). When I finish printing the entire soccer ball, I'll make another video showing the opening size. I'll also provide more detail about how the panels are fastened together.

Duane Degn

The magnets will likely be a problem with this design. It might be possible to decrease the wall thickness by not using 3D printed screws and threads. Glueing/welding could likely be used to reduce the thickness.