Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I've been trying to get one of these older style shower units for a while.

It uses bare live heating elements submerged in the water you are showering with, and while that might sound quite dangerous, it's not.

This unit took me a couple of evenings to reverse engineer, as it uses unexpectedly complicated circuitry that didn't initially make sense until I realised that the custom cam-switch is doing more than just clicking between a few positions. It actually has switch actuation overlapping to allow a latching circuit to operate as the knob is rotated between the cool and low positions.

https://youtu.be/M8f28WsTYDU

Files

Inside a vintage electric shower with bare 240V elements in the water

Although we have hot water tanks and on-demand oil and gas water heating systems in the UK, we commonly use electric showers due to the convenience of instantly having hot water on demand with no delay as it flows through long pipe runs. These units are 100% efficient at converting electrical power to hot water. Modern units use dedicated heating chambers with fully cased heating elements, but this older style unit has the bare live heating element submerged directly in the water. This has the advantage of a near zero heat-up delay and also the best direct water cooling of the element possible. The other unique feature of this shower is its serviceability. You can easily open the heater block by sliding off two metal clamps that hold the sections tightly together with sealing rings, and you can install new heating elements that come with the brass end terminals pre-fitted. The electrical safety of this shower is based on the long thin water paths and the electrical grounding at the inlet and outlet. Combined with the usual equipotential bonding of exposed pipework in bathrooms and kitchens, this means that no significant electrical potential can be present across the person who is using the shower. (Noting that the drain pipe is usually plastic and could theoretically create a conductive path to external ground with soapy water.) It took me an unusually long time to reverse engineer this seemingly simple unit. Mainly because I initially thought the water flow and temperature safety switch was normally closed in operation (it's not), and also because I didn't realise that the cam switch wasn't a decisive click between on and off states of the switches, but also has overlapping switch operation to allow a latching circuit to operate before the initiating circuits are opened. This unit has some premium engineering in it. From the pressure responsive water flow regulator to the heater block, the custom cam switch assembly and even the intriguing ABB contactor. For those who feel a bit squirmy about having a 240V device screwed to the wall next to their bath or in a shower cubicle, you should be aware that when properly installed, these units are completely safe and have a long track record of safety. The main accidents with them are when they have been badly installed with no proper earth connection or poor pipework bonding, and even then the usual result is tingling sensations when using the shower due to normal electrical leakage. Also note that almost every UK home has 30mA RCD/GFCI protection at the source. Another accident scenario that could apply to any installation is when a metal shower enclosure has a mounting screw put through a cable, making exposed metalwork live with respect to the grounded plumbing. That is unfortunately an issue with the trend towards fashionista bathroom and kitchen remodels that result in repeated butchering of the plumbing and electrical services. Especially when legacy pipework and wiring is hidden within walls. One of the very few shower related fatalities in the UK was in the squalid rat infested accommodation used by some modern-slave car wash workers in London. Aside from the electric meter being bypassed, the installations grounding had been compromised. For more info here's a link, noting that there seems to be a lot of deviation of data depending on which article you read about this incident:- https://www.stayenergysafe.co.uk/more-on-energy-theft/electricity-meter-electrocution If you enjoy my videos then the easiest way to support the channel is to subscribe for more good video content. But if you would like to contribute a dollar or two for coffee, cookies and gadgets to take apart, you can do so by supporting me on Patreon. I release videos without adverts for critique and feedback on Patreon as soon as they have been made. I also do Patreon live streams, which are much more relaxed and chatty than the busy public ones. https://www.patreon.com/bigclive Alternatively, for a single coffee contribution you can use PayPal:- https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/bigclive #ElectronicsCreators

Comments

NOEL ONEILL

Very repairable, what a joy.

Mark Gray

I had that exact shower, and lucky for you, mine still had the instruction sticker attached, so this should help with the cam positions: https://flic.kr/p/2rSbVZm The weak point in them wasn't the innards, it was the shaft connecting the external control knob to the cam - mine got brittle and sheared. I'm sure I could have replaced it but by that point I'd got a combi boiler that could provide a much higher flow, so it got removed.

Mark Gray

Also, yes, they were indeed expensive, though I had mine as part of a fully fitted bathroom. The only time it failed was when the shaft snapped.

Big Clive

The rotary selector shaft had snapped on this one too. The cam and switch mechanism was very stiff, but a squirt of a suitable lubricant made a huge difference. Mine has the front sticker too, but it would be nice to find the service data for the schematic if it exists.

Mark Gray

I doubt I still have the instructions, but if it surfaces I'll let you know.

Road Tripping Raccoons

Curious, would there be any difference in safety if used on a North American 240V feed where there is no neutral?

Big Clive

I'm not sure how that would affect it. It would probably depend on the resistivity of the water and sensitivity of the GFCI protecting the circuit.

Jack Hodgson

Hi Clive. I've been wondering about this for a while. It's probably none of our business, but I have to ask. What is it that you do to repeatedly injure the knuckle of your left index finger. It is very often showing a scar, if not bandaged. ???

Big Clive

I'm just prone to the skin cracking on my knuckles.

Tomáš Kováčik

Clive, I did have same problem. I realize it is air temperature related, rapid changes in it. So i stopped using hot/warm water to wash my hands when I came from cold environment (like outside), it helped a lot.

Frank

In a 400 Vac three phase system the phase to earth voltage is 230 V. In a split phase 240 Vac system each phase to ground would be 120 V. This will half the current through the long plastic pipe. And also because both phases have a 180 degrees offset it would 'kind of' result in a zero-sum for the residual-current detection circuit.

Frank

It was made to be repairable. Sadly this is less of a thing these days.