Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I saw these bulbs on the shelf at ASDA last time I was across and thought I'd get one for us to explore.

I do get the feeling that they are slightly over hyped.

Something notable was the near carbon copy of the circuitry in the Philips eco lamp.

https://youtu.be/92MUPNq9OLI

Files

Inside an expensive TCP high efficiency light bulb from ASDA

The main reason I bought this bulb was because of its vastly inflated cost compared to the others on the same shelf at ASDA. I wanted to see if the circuitry inside was special. To help sell the image of being better, the bulb is supplied in a huge box compared to normal lamps. There are very strong similarities in the design compared to Philips equivalent high efficiency lamp. That includes the strikingly similar circuitry. Spoilers - the secret sauce seems to be running high efficiency LEDs at lower current with a very efficient low loss buck converter. Will it last the 50,000 hours they claim? Do any of the other high lifespan LED bulbs last as long as they claim? I'll just be a bit skeptical about that as usual. If you enjoy my videos, supporting the channel on Patreon helps keep it independent of YouTube's quirks, avoids intrusive mid-video adverts, gives early access, bonus footage and regular quiet Patreon live streams. https://www.patreon.com/bigclive Alternatively, for a single coffee contribution you can use PayPal:- https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/bigclive #ElectronicsCreators

Comments

Alex Taylor

4 watt savings is 96wh a day for a bulb that is left on all the time. That is 35kwh a year. At $0.15 a kwh that is $5.25 in savings a year. At 5 hours a day it’s a little over $1 a year. So it’s worth it over time.

Brian Deschene

I wonder if Chinese manufacturer approached the retailer (or vice versa) with a Dubai Philips bulb in-hand and sort of reproduced it without exceeding a target price and/or running afoul of Philips’ IP?

Big Clive

I wonder who actually makes Philips bulbs for them. They're just a brand these days.

IamFubar

After forcing us to use these things when has my electricity bill continued to climb higher & higher? /s

Craig Childs

Many years ago I was working on a fairly prestigious new build project c.2007/8. All the GU10 downlight lamps were spec'd as TCP, they were expensive but they had the best colour and intensity output of anything available at the time. I don't recall any failures and I used dozens of them, they were a very high quality product even back then.

Big Clive

It's because they still want to make as much money for less electricity use.

alanmon

As a commissioning engineer I wire-wrapped (aluminium wire) Strowger and TXE4 racks in the 1970s - I still have my set of wrappers and unwrappers. Wonder if they have any value these days....

Big Clive

Probably only to telecoms collectors if they have a heritage.

alanmon

Well, they are stamped STC. and I have a good pension from my time at STC. Parcelled together with my copy of Atkinsons. and my large blue/yellow de-solder sucker. Unused sine 1976.

Jon Knight

Probably a good choice of bulb for awkward locations where you want to have to change the bulb as infrequently as possible.

Big Clive

If it does last a long time then that would be a good option. Like the original electrodeless lamps.

Circuitmike

I have one of those LED testers, which I bought after watching your video about them. The intrusive thoughts won and I touched the probes to my hand to see how spicy they were. Moderately spicy at best!

Big Clive

The DC shock is very different from an AC one. AC is much worse.

Alice Chapman

I’ve some wire wrapping kit in the loft, not used it since the 80s. I did use my solder sucker last week. It’s just a green Radio Spares one.

Jack Hodgson

"... a bright side, and a dark side. It's like the Force." Nice!