Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I tend to use phones to record my videos because of their convenience and large touch screen interface. For a while I've been using a Pixel 6A, but Google recently sent out rogue "updates" that have caused lots of problems with many of the Pixel series phones.

In the case of the Pixel 6A it resulted in random upside down videos and equally random additions of a red tone to the video, making the bench look pink and my hands look sunburnt! The corruption also seems to be affecting some video editing software.

A full factory reset hasn't resolved the problems.

So now I have to make a decision.

  1. Keep going and try to fix the mess afterwards.

  2. Try to install an older version of the phone's firmware.

  3. Install Graphene OS.

  4. Go through the annoying experience of buying a new recording phone and hoping it deals with the close focus I require and that the camera firmware doesn't have audio/focus/depth of field "quirks".

    Which would you choose?

Comments

Todd Sharp

What's the process to install the older firmware? That'd be the way I'd lean if it's not too much hassle.

Jeff Thieleke

Options 2 & 3 will wipe your phone (OEM unlock forces a factory reset), so it is toss up on which to do. Upgrading to Graphene will get you ongoing security and system updates, but it may or may not work as well as a camera. If this is just a WiFi-only camera device, I would probably start by flashing an older Pixel 6a factory image (https://developers.google.com/android/images#bluejay) and see if that helps, and if not, try Graphene.

Big Clive

It's not too bad. It can be done via Google's own Chrome interface. Likewise Graphene can be installed the same way and allows you to revert back to original Pixel firmware later.

horrovac

You missed the option 5: Do nothing. If this is a problem that affects others, odds are that either Google will fix their fix, or that someone will figure out how to fix it yourself. In the meantime, you do have a heap of phones that are at least bearable as a recording device.

William Taylor

I think I'd try installing the older firmware, and make sure any updates are disabled. Probably good to have the camera phone as not your normal use phone, for security reasons, but once it's working well, if it aint broke, don't fix it!

Andrew Ellis

Made my choice. As an old person, health and safety features are key to me. Nothing with Android comes close to Apple. As for Pixel, the loss of multi-carrier selection was the last straw. Switching from my Moto 5G to iPhone 18-pro plus series 12 watch cost me nearly $2,000. It was worth every penny. Since I don’t carry my phone into the shower, a fall there would leave me with no way to summon help. iPhone+watch would do it for me, after asking first if I was OK. Not trying to start an argument. You asked, and this is my response.

Dennis

Horrovac is correct in so much as to say, persevere for 3 or 4 weeks, edit in post. He correctly says if others are affected then the fix will be prioritised, but updates and fixes are applied on a cycle so you may have to wait a few weeks for the fix and the next update cycle. Yes, Horrovac has said something sensible 😆 (love you Horrovac😆)

TopEndSpoonie

Older firmware, block updates. Use what you know, when it is the money maker, and also not the personal carry device.

Dave Frederick AKA @amorphuc

Maybe time to retire the phone. Wow. I don't know Big Clive. I think I've seen creators like Project Farm and others using GoPros and others. I used to be a commercial producer but the cameras we used (way back then) were in the $70,000 + range not even including the various lenses. Then again, the editing software and hardware was in similar ranges. (a Beta deck like the BVW-75 was also in the $70K+ range - we used three of them in edit as well as a Sony 1" deck) LOL Okay, that was professional TV way back then some 25 years ago and top of the line stuff. Don't even get me started on lighting but then you are keenly aware of the lighting pros. These days, There is Adobe Premier, Final Cut Pro used very commonly in professional and beginner applications. There are other brands of software as well like Avid Media Composer, I used a version of Pinnacle Purple software (not available now but it was good) - All of them with layering of audio and video that's pretty intuitive with great degrees of control over audio and more, even graphics and such if you want. Many of them won't break the bank! I'm not sure what you use for editing or whether it's sort of "in camera" or YouTube based or what have you but these software offerings give you a LOT of control. I'm sort of thinking the phone camera sort of thing might be your compromise and seemingly a hassle in your case. As opposed to something of a more dedicated and useful tool at your disposal. Not sure. Think of just running a camera continuously and then just easily clipping out portions you don't want at a couple of clicks in edit, or adding different views easily say picture in picture or what ever. Click Click - render. Painless control of content in video, audio and even graphics if you want or what have you. I think I might talk to other creators. From my experience going from inline deck to deck "Paltex" editing (there's a blast from the past) to software editing and shooting, it wasn't too hard and very rewarding from a production perspective with more control and professional output. I can elaborate on any of it to some extent but I think some of the more modern creators might have the most up to date stuff to lend a hand. I know your post was about the Pixel and updates or reboots but in a way, would you be better served and free from hassle to sort of go with the tools of the trade? Fluke for your content except in the video realm.

Dave Frederick AKA @amorphuc

Oh, I have also had no complaints - what so ever - with your videos. I'm dedicated to seeing every one and love them so what ever you decide to do - I'll still be a completely dedicated fan. I meant absolutely no criticism at all.

Ciarán Fahy

I use a pixel 6A with GrapheneOS, the camera experience is not the same as stock - autofocus is less reliable and you don't have the same level of customisation. I would be a proponent of rolling back the OS version

Carlos Capriotti

Oh boy, do I have a few thoughts on the topic... Grab a coffee or some tea. (fixed some typos) Firstly, it's just fair to say that I am actively trying to distance myself from Apple and Google. With a passion. On the technical matter: Yep, Google will likely fix the bug if it affects more people, but life and production go on. Falling back to one of the older phones will not kill us or the channel, IMO. If money is not an issue, I would buy an used Pixel and install GrapheneOS, but keep in mind this will be a somewhat steep learning curve. You would have to install third party app stores (Aurora + Obtanium + AppVerify, I think). Also, out of the box, several YouTubers have mentioned that GrapheneOS' camera app does not have the same image quality. You'd have to fiddle with several 3rd party apps to find one that suits you. Alternatively you CAN install Google's Play Store and install even the Android Camera App, but there is no way to say if it will carry the bug with it. Having said that, there is a very good chance that App Stores Like Aurora will have older versions of Google's camera app, prior to the bug. If this sounds like a lot of work, it's because it is. I am not saying this to discourage anyone, but to set expectations. I honestly find the GrapheneOS solution brilliant, but its value, and the freedom is brings to you, comes with a cost: Your time. One needs to learn the Graphene way. Honestly, after you've learned it, the phone "just works", but until you get there, the phone looks like a nice slab of dark rock in your hands. Should you have the time to fiddle with it, I'd highly recommend breaking free from Google (or Apple for that matter) and going the Graphene way. Support to Motorola phones is said to be coming, for new models. While LineageOS is a great option too, in terms of security it still keeps you bonded to Big Brother, leeching on your data. Trust me, it is scary what data they steal from you and what ends in the hands of data brokers and the dark web, even if you are a savvy person. In the past year I've bought four (yes... 4) Pixel 9a phones and converted them all, moving my family away from Google. I can share my technical experience if anyone needs a hand. I admit not caring about the image/camera quality, but at least I can show people the ropes, installing and configuring the phone.

Craig Groves

Another option , check the version of your camera ( see attached , install another possibly an older version GCam from here https://www.celsoazevedo.com/files/android/google-camera/ ( force stop and disable the original pixel camera and if it's no good in install the GCam and re enable the original ) or an another option get an older pixel camera from here https://www.apkmirror.com/ , not sure the pixel cam will work but the GCam should. Hope this helps . Craig

Mark Garth

I would sit tight for a week or so and see if a further update fixes the issue. If enough people complain, they will work on it, provided it's not too old.

Keri Szafir

I'd say back up your data and install GrapheneOS. Scorched earth!

horrovac

I reject this unfair accusation in the strongest of terms!!!

Liz Edwards

I’d go for the annoying experience of buying a (couple of) second hand phone and see if it deals with your requirements, try different options.

Mike Page

Until you know the cause (ie the pathology) you can't know the solution. Pursue a rational path.

John McFerren

Clive, I'm probably going against the collective here as I have a pro-Apple Bias, but a lot of professional phone camera users typically use Apple phones. The iPhone 18 Pro Max has a Macro Mode so that should really help with the close-up shots. Another option to consider.

Ymir the Frost Giant

Of your own 4 options, where 1 is the same as horrovac's 5, the logical answer is no.4, if Graphene is known to be good. Trying older firmware might result in installation issues or worse, which might be much more painful than a new app's learning curve. However, getting another phone just as an emergency backup is never a bad idea. Go for a different brand for 'backup resilience' - these days many bog standard phones do 1080p video. That would allow you to take option 1/5 as well. Update; I just read Carlos's reply, so now option 3 is not as attractive as option 1/5 with different brand backup phone. Reliable content and content creation is more important than high quality ditto.

Gareth P

Just to add my agreement to this point - even with Google Camera installed from the (sandboxed) Play Store I don't think it is quite the same as "stock" (I have a 9 Pro with Graphene)

SOTNAM

Are you using stock camera app or something else? I won't pretend I know anything about the Pixel range, but do use Android as a second device.

Macguru

Going to say a hard no on the GrapheneOS, while it's secure and gets updates, there can be issues with the camera, audio and NFC, I would suggest that you roll back the OS, disable updates (and just use it off-line if possible). and then only use it for recording.

Steve Rickaby

Echoing that. One may resent the Apple ecosystem, possibly with good cause, but once committed to it everything usually just works, with seamless data synchronisation between multiple devices. Like Andrew, I am an old person, and a fall that resulted in a broken humerus made me realise the virtue of a smart watch. I know that this is not really germane to your pixel issue, and that probably suggesting an iPhone of some sort would not be welcome. I would only add that I've been very pleased with the service that I have had from BackMarket.

Don'z Lockz

Install Graphene! 👌🍻🤠

John Key

I would be inclined to use a camera, no software updates and choices on lenses etc. But not convenient for travel.

L3P3

Strongly favoring 3! I use over 10 years old phones with LineageOS and I am very satisfied. And I feel like I have control over my device.

Bert Driehuis

You could have a look at OpenCamera. I've got a Fairphone 6, which also has had its share of issues. Having an alternate app in case the Android one craps out is always a good idea.

RonNona

Obviously someone hacked horrovac's account.

Randy Hearn

Honestly I would buy a shutterless camera, cheap and the quality can be up to 4K. When I was streaming I used web cams instead of phones. But you have been doing this a while, time to get a camera that does not need updates - simple, and just takes video. Just be careful. Dont want one that limits video recording time. You need constant recording.

horrovac

Just you wait till I catch the fucker!

Henry Becker

Option 6 - consider getting a camera?

David K

I have a pixel 6 and i'm not seeing these issues, but the pixel 6 is out of support by the end of the year so it's probably worth upgrading regardless.

GmtKid

Keep going. I have a Pixel6 and Pixel8, both on GrapheneOS. The P8 has a better camera, but I think the Graphene camera app won't suit your needs, and the Pixel Camera app on Graphene is quirky.

Nick Poulakos

I second this. Give OpenCamera a shot. If that doesnt help, then Graphene is a good option

Chris Horry

Honestly find an older Pro model iPhone. I know Apple have their controversies, but so do Google. Anything over an iPhone 13 Pro should be fine for the type of recording you do, and I bet it won't cost a great deal. They tend to Just Work rather than acquire weird issues over time like Android does. Just my opinion!

Chris Horry

Yep, hard agree. I used to love playing around with all the different Android customization and trying out different images, but after a while I said "this is too much effort, I just need my phone to work". So, went Apple, swallowed the bile, and have been happy ever since.

George Dorn

Installing a prior version of the firmware can be extremely painful, if not outright impossible on many devices. I'd give it a week, maybe use an older device to record in the meantime, and if Google still doesn't fix it, switch to Graphene.

George Dorn

I would not be even a little surprised if switching to Graphene + microG didn't provide every necessary thing but free up so much CPU from the removal of the Google Play Services bloatware than recording became a much, much better experience. Back when a prior device of mine was getting long in the tooth, I couldn't find a replacement (nobody makes sliders anymore) so I stuck Lineage + microG on it and it was so much smoother and faster that I held out another three years before replacing it.

Ymir the Frost Giant

Re-reading your post, Clive, "large touch screen interface" can also be achieved with some digital cameras. My Olympus OM-D-EM1 mk II has that for example. You plug a separate screen into a port. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhgQ9hkv5xE as an example. The pro monitors are designed to be bright enough not to get washed out in sunlight when used in the open; I believe bog std tablets might also work indoors.

Bob Carter

I would down level the Pixel 6A wrap it in cotton wool and only take it out to record videos. Block any updates. Meantime go and buy another phone that you can keep up to date for banking/mail etc...

Anthony M

I came here also to recommend GrapheneOS, largely for the principle of distancing oneself from Big Tech, but Carlos's message here covers most of my thoughts already, and he lays them out more clearly than I would have :) I use GrapheneOS myself, and Carlos is correct that it is a bit more work, largely because you're treading away from the "happy path" that Google tries to funnel everyone towards (where they conveniently also collect all your data). It's possible to install the Google Play Store and the Google Pixel Camera app if you want to go that route, but you could also install the F-Droid app store and install OpenCamera from there (which I believe you've referenced before on your channel in the past). I occasionally use OpenCamera when I want to do something that the basic GrapheneOS camera app can't do, such as manually focusing or selecting a specific lens, and I can confirm that OpenCamera works very well with my Pixel 9 Pro running GrapheneOS, including the exposure lock and focus lock features.

DC Allan

Oh heck, I cant help but good luck sorting it.

richard ockman

i Would try an older software version first.

This ADHD Life

Personally, I’d go for Graphene. If that doesn’t work, then try installing an older version of the OS.

Circuitmike

I think Clive may already be using OpenCamera since I'm pretty sure he's who I learned about it from.

NightshadeLenar

Clice is using OpenCamera already, thats how he is able to do ehat he does with ease.

Mark Gray

Given GrapheneOS known lesser camera drivers (if that’s the right word), downgrade and keep the thing away from future updates. Ideally consider that your ‘business’ phone and use it for nothing else so it’s walled off from any other nonsense (even streaming, arguably).

Gary Ritter Jr

If you have a phone dedicated to only filming, it might be worthwhile to just disable all updates and never let it go online. Then nothing will ever break if you know it gets the job done for you. I'd say learning Graphene just for this situation may be its own kind of annoying. Maybe Google will get a fix published. If it's affecting multiple camera apps, then it's surely a firmware issue processing the camera signal rather than a bug in their camera app itself.

Benjamin Hall

As to the question - agree with earlier poster hoorvac - option 5, do nothing. To me, video content is KING - if you've got good content, technical issues aren't important. I'm behind on videos lately due to work / family stuff, but your content is so good you could film it with a potato and I'd still watch it! I've got a love / hate relationship with Google and Apple. I've always had work-issued iPhones, wife and son have iPhones, so I've got an iPhone to simply the household phone/tablet logistics. -b

Benjamin Hall

100% spot on horrovac! Do nothing.

Carlos Capriotti

Hey folks. Please, patch your devices. I know this is no longer about a phone and operating systems. Apologies. Just a quick comment about the "downgrade and freeze in time" approach. Don't take this personally. I get where you all are coming from, but in today's life this is not a good option. With zero day bugs, apps and operating systems with gazilions of vulnerabilities, supply chain attacks, the best option is to keep a device updated, the device seeing the 'outside world' or not. Big companies will "tolerate" devices with medium to low securtity advisories to go unpatched for something like 6 months, because this USED to be how long it took for hackers to find bugs and exploit them. Nowadays with AI this is no longer true... Patch your devices, I urge you. If no patches exist anymore, ditch the device. In Clive's case - I don't mean to speak for you, Clive - we have a channel with nearly 1.2M subscribers at stake. Too much to risk because of an unpatched device. Just my 3 cents.

Mina

I have graphine on my main device and I love it. If you want to rip your phone out of Google's grasp and dont mind alternative app stores/side loading I highly recommend it.

Mina

While I love graphine its worth noting, there are other less security focused ROMs like liniage os that will probably also fix your camera and can be installed without google services. For a filming device that might be better?

Big Clive

The Pixel is only used for recording videos. I have a Samsung for general use.

Big Clive

I use Open Camera for better control and a standard interface between different phones.

Chris Wiley

I'd go for the Grapheno OS. If it doesn't work, you can always revert back to Android.

Eric

Sorry, a little late to the post. I would try and install the older version first. If that doesn't work I would try Graphene OS. If that doesn't work you can try finding a used/refurbished phone on eBay or something, (same model or not, up to how much you want to mess about).