Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Third or second person?

  • Third person 48
  • Second person 156
  • No opinion 24
  • 2023-01-13
  • 228 votes
{'title': 'Third or second person?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Third person', 'votes': 48}, {'text': 'Second person', 'votes': 156}, {'text': 'No opinion ', 'votes': 24}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 1, 13, 11, 23, 54, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 228}

Content

In A New Dawn everything is written in third person perspective (He/She). I started writing some scenes for the sci-fi game and wrote them in second person perspective (You). Famous games use second person, Baldurs gate and divinity original sin. 

Would you rather play in second or third person in the upcoming sci-fi game?

Comments

william wofford

you is more immersive ,since you are the main character

Craig Robinson

Second person only works if the scenes are unisex. E.g., you isn't gonna work if MC is a girl and the player is a boy (unless the player has trans tendencies).

WhiteRaven

I don't agree. I understand people might prefer different perspective. But playing as a female in a game with second or third person perspective doesn't change your sexual orientation.

Craig Robinson

Why ask for the opinions of others if all you are going to do is disagree with them? Just seems as though you have already made up your mind and are looking for validation instead.

william wofford

most guys that play female characters do have those tendencies otherwise they would play male protagonist games

WhiteRaven

I asked for opinions on perspectives in the game. Not about opinions on what gives people certain tendencies or not.

WhiteRaven

On a side note, why can't I disagree? Disagreeing with your opinion on what gives a person certain tendencies doesn't affect the main topic of the poll.

Bohauo

well i just wanna throw in 1:st person, I (e.g I wanna have a biscuit; I am going to have a biscuit...) But out of those two option "you" i the one i prefer!

WhiteRaven

I have never played a game with first person perspective. Can you give me an example so I can look at it? :)

william wofford

a true first person perspective is hard to do in anything other than a kinetic novel type of set up If you are narrating it.. it works because you can say i got up and went to the kitchen to get a snack ...but if you want true immersion into the story ..... you get up feeling hungry and go to the kitchen to get a snack .

Martiandawn

I have been playing games that involve immersive roleplaying for decades, online as well as in the real world, and I assure you that the vast majority of players find enjoyment playing characters of the opposite sex without having transgender "tendencies." I have enjoyed playing games as characters of either sex, and whether or not the format is second or third person has not made any difference for me. That said, second person can feel more immersive for people who want to feel as if they are living in the character's shoes, so to speak. I do not personally need that level of immersion, but I do not begrudge the personal tastes of people who want that.

WhiteRaven

Yea I understand what first person is. I just never experienced a game with it.

OhioOkie

Second person with one cavaet. That is it can be with different people so we can what the thinknof the PC.

WhiteRaven

"That is it can be with different people so we can what the thinknof the PC." Could you rephrase that? I don't understand what you mean.

Notalie Portman

I think Ohio’s intent is for the narration to shift focus to various people to get their opinions of the main character. If I’m correct, I’m not sure precisely how that would be done with second person, but I’m sure it could be.

Notalie Portman

I think second person can be a little tricky so I voted for third person, but I do agree that second person can be fun when it works. I think the tricky bits are cases where the main character has thoughts and inclinations that are very different from the player. I think accommodating that difference in writing can be tricky. However, if the second person mostly describes actions and sensations without talking about thoughts and motivations, then the dissonance is less. So, I think second person can be done, I just think it’s more difficult and you have to ask yourself whether you want to take on that extra challenge.

WhiteRaven

"You feel something way too thick inside your ass." then shift to "You thrust your massive cock inside the presented ass." I don't think shifting perspective is a good idea. It will confuse the player. The protagonist will only be the one referred to in second person all others will be in third. "You can see a creature crawling spider-like. It looks very vicious." Or another example. "You see a fat man. He's standing at the counter counting money, his fat belly even rests on the counter."

WhiteRaven

I understand what you mean. On the other hand third person give weaker connection to the protagonists. I want to believe that the player gets more empathy if it's in second person. So even if the player doesn't agree with a thought or a motivation they'll might understand it better having more empathy and maybe it could solve some of the issues.

OhioOkie

I was not thing about back and forth exchange. More like a cut scene before or after the PC action. Like when Val enters the bar, the owner thinks to herself "it would be good to have Blake date Val" Then Val sees owner leans over talking to Blake. Then when Val leaves we see the owners thought of how the night went with Val. So it is a switch of pages and or chapters but now paragraphes.

WhiteRaven

Okey I think understand what you mean now. All conversations will be in first person like in A New Dawn while the narrator will refer to the protagonist in second person instead of third person. This is a simple example of how I'm writing the scenes right now: (Narrator no face) "A wide smile forms on Mary's face as she watches you enter the bar." (Textbox with Mary's face) "(I think it would be great if Victoria dates Blake.)" (Narrator no face) "As you arrive to the bar Mary winks to you and point with her head towards Blake's direction." (Textbox with Mary's face) "Victoria, go and say hello to Blake." (Textbox with Victoria's face) "Okey I will do that Mary." So it will be a mix like I A New Dawn with the difference instead of using the protagonist first name in scenes I will write "you". Maybe I made it clearer now.

OhioOkie

Yes that is what i meant. I might write like A wisw skild forms on Mary's face as she sees you enter bar. She pipes up, you hear her shout as she points her head toward Blake's diection. "Victoria, go and shske that marvelous ass of yours and say hello to Blake with those lovely lips."

WhiteRaven

Yes this is how the scenes looks right now in the new sci-fi game.