Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

(It is Openly Known that the "making-of" comics which post two hours later in tiers 2 & 3 have become a comic form and language of their own, including writing and art created just for them — upgrade for a month to come read them all!)

This Is Spinal Tap may technically be a musical, but at least it makes sense that a band, of all protagonists, would burst into song. Particularly during the concert segments. When slickstered gangs of harmonizing Chets do the hop-n-click before jitterbugging blade-first into their urban rivals, that is no time to sing. It's the stuff of television restaurant advertising.

This and countless other transgressions are why I forsook musicals at a young age. To this day — despite numerous entreaties and assurances by the otherwise sane and fully-betoothed — I will not abide them. Action, propelled by realistic dialogue: that's the stuff for me. Call me an old ball cap, but I never saw anybody erupt into stanza about anything, let alone the news that some phantom had wandered into an opera.

Try and persuade me otherwise. You'll see where it stands. I'm a man of enough years to retire the polite "maybe someday" and just tell it the way it's gonna be with me: I don't like fish, I've never spoken with god, and I can't stand musicals.

Files

Comments

Jordan D Cowman

The fish god musical gonna push all of onstad's buttons

b.zap

OH SHIIIIIIIIIIT

DKB

The bluebird of happiness killed me.

Tom P

While I love musical theater, it is Okay for others to not share this taste. They may come around at some key moment, and musicals, much like all other creative production types, follow Sturgeon's Law. That being said, if you do some uppers and take a couple hits of your preferred cannabis delivery system, you may "get" the Andrew Lloyd Webber production, "Starlight Express," as it was intended to be experienced.

Shepton

That sucker has a sharp beak and he is AGGRESSIVE

Josh Egbert

There's some real Avenue Q potential with this show

Aaron J. Rushton, Writer of Words

YES. Say the truth for the masses! Musicals are just kinda fucked up! That's a weird way to behave! It isn't sense!

Lisa Taylor

I felt this in my soul: Man (sings) uuuuuuuugh

Daniel Turcotte

Same here! Never spoken with fish, can't stand God and I don't like musicals.

ladiesbane

I thought I loved musicals until I saw one; I grew up listening to the soundtracks. Same with opera. Sorry Mom, sorry college.

Marc Harkness

I really felt this with Les Miserables. The play I created in my head listening to the soundtrack vastly outperformed the production when I finally saw it on Broadway. See also: Seeing U2 live.

Achewood

I am currently upgrading my phone and will be back in two hours to add my usual “value” to your lovely comments. Thank you everyone!

Douglas Wykstra

I can't follow you into cynicism on this one, Chris, but I have learned Ray's maxim in panel 4 and will not attempt to appeal to the technical skill and aesthetic effect that are maybe easier to appreciate through the prism of kung-fu movies (which have roughly the same relationship to real-life combat as musicals have to real-life emotional expression). I will allow that the genre has a little more dignity when it's rough around the edges, like the itinerant hoofers making the vaudeville/roadhouse circuits in pre-Depression America, or Bob Fosse and Stephen Sondheim recognizing that sex didn't have to be entirely sublimated into dance numbers. All that being said, I would watch Peru: The Musical this evening if it existed, so it's quite possible that I'm just beyond help.

Eric Behrens

I love you Achewood, but earlier this week I cried through Maybe Happy Ending and so you will get no support against musicals from me.

Ste & Danni JM

Just two bros, chilling on the couch with beers after a hard day's work, shooting the shit about a headline in an showbiz trade weekly.

jordan b.

I've never related more to Roast Beef than panel six.

Tom Morris

Oh lord this is a good idea. I love musicals and now I want to see Depression the Musical . Write it Onstad!

Song Club with John Krane

I told a friend (who loves musicals) that I do not care for musicals. So now, he sends me the name of musicals occasionally, and I pretend that I watched them. I tell him that they're "pretty good." I am concerned that he may ask me specific questions about the musicals, but it has not happened yet, and it has been several years.

A. Hamster

I only attempt to add musical theater into my life where it would be completely inappropriate. Reality: my friend’s mom calls early on a Sunday morning because her son left his wallet in my car Me, singing: Gabe’s mom is a filthy slut / Gabe’s mom called to wake me up / (crescendo) at seven thirty in the mooooooooooooorning

Douglas Wykstra

Yeah, I'm guessing he doesn't like The Shape of Water (2018) very much.

Matt Mitchell

Hahaha. I’m a musician fortunate enough to not have depression and I loathe musicals. So many comedy shows use a “musical episode” as a way to spread their wings and it is always such a drag. That said, if Beef’s musical somehow sounded like the Swans or Elliott Smith I’d listen to it once, maybe

Morgan

Looking forward to the showstopper "Fuck! This Guy" where part of the choreo is 13 ugly children rolling gutterballs to audio cues

blair

Featuring the show-stopper "Oh No It's Today"

GruntyGinMan

RB cribbed heavily from the music video he did of the abandoned Chinese Food place. It'll end with Ray putting a single rose on Helen Kellers gravestone.

Jay Y

Ray in all likelihood called my ass out in panel seven I am not a man of musicals either for similar premises plus Mamma Mia would be like gulag level torture for me, but I have to admit that when I saw a promo for Death Becomes Her as a musical, I could see it and experienced a once-in-a-lifetime intrigue

Miles McMahon

Musicals are *boring* except for some damn reason I really enjoy Singin' in the Rain. It might have something to do with a Volkswagen Jetta commercial from the early aughts.

Bruce Wright

Musicals? I only like movies with giant insects in them. Which I guess leaves "Mothra" as the only tolerable musical.

Sedric and Charlie

Fish on the plate (or in a soup or stew, or in some kind of sandwich etc.) or just fish generally? I won't attempt to ply you on musicals or willing artifice in narrative; I have my tastes and they are mine

ChaosSpaceGiraffe

Musicals have always made me feel a kind of baffled, uncomfortable melancholy I can't really explain. A kind of emotion never otherwise felt except outside uncomfortable dreams that border on but never fully become nightmares. Perhaps the Germans have a word for this, for the English language does not.

Jenn

Literally the only musical I would watch willingly. I hate musicals

Jenn

I fully agree with you

Spyguitar

I saw Into The Woods starring Bernadette Peters at an impressionable age, I've been pro-musicals ever since

Andrew

I guess because they've got catchy songs that are fun to listen to, I don't care about realism.

Douglas Wykstra

Basically Aretha's number in The Blues Brothers, but set in a bowling alley full of ugly kids.

Achewood

I'm starting to watch Community, and I pray they do not do this. The claymation episode was hard enough.

Bungus Bronbo

How about listening to a musical soundtrack as one would listen to an album?

Achewood

Suggest one? I am willing to at least try.

Achewood

The score would mostly be gamma waves and migraines, right?

John Ryan

This made me realize that both of the shows I've seen were musicals, and I liked em each. It made sense that those unctuous Jersey Boys sang when they did and knew Joe Pesci... Book of Mormon is how mormon missions actually go as far as I know, so the singing could have been realistic. Diegetic, even.

Julie (HiDeeHoGal)

Some musicals are fun and all right and others are hot garbage. If I go into more detail I will write a whole ass phillipic about the cringe of the genre. How to reconcile that with a huge crush on a member of the Broadway elite? Gah, life is so complicated. But who would Beef cast in his mini show of despair and ugh?

Paul Kim

Roast Beef is SO mad in panel 5. I love it.

Matt Mitchell

Generally I don’t have any major problems w the whole of Community

Lionstooth

There is a musical episode (another holiday one, incidentally) but it is extremely a pisstake

Achewood

This is what it is, to be cursed by a talent you can't stand. It's constant. Unrelenting. A thorn in the sock on a hike. Dear lord, why do you include Musicals in your plan for us

Achewood

I'm with you on the garbage part. I wonder if we put a one-year moratorium on musicals, if they would die out, like some kind of jungle mold.

Matt Mitchell

You’re right! I actually didn’t mind that one at all. Definitely in the meta-deconstructionist vein as opposed to a “we love musicals” vein

Achewood

was book of Mormon that South Park one? I do feel like a Mockumusical has potential.

Achewood

Perhaps one issue is that I listen to music for the instruments, and not the lyrics, so a medium where lyrics are the forefront and the music is canned just smells like circus peanuts to me

Achewood

She was great in The Jerk, especially that one scene where it almost becomes a musical.

Achewood

I think this guy has to be a bass, or whatever the next one up from bass is. A window-shaker.

Achewood

We're rattling the Folger's can around soon, to see if we can get up the scratch to film a trailer.

Achewood

I like this take (except for the part where you have to feel bad). I believe it underscores Beef's statement that musicals reveal the mental torment and derangement that exists in silence all around us...until Musicals start.

Achewood

Any fish that has trimethylamine really ooks my grooks. (I think that's basically all of them.) A tuna salad can be mild enough, and scallops or fresh crab, but for the most part fish is always a chore. For my 50th birthday party I'm putting my foot down on the whole fish thing. No more shame.

Achewood

It will drag itself, on its chest, to the broadway stage. Beef is no quitter.

Achewood

Did they ever do a musical of The Metamorphosis?

Achewood

Yes, boring. They keep dancing around instead of getting back to the interesting parts of the plot. I think this thread is starting to get at why some people respond positively to musicals, and the truth might not be pretty.

Achewood

Buena Vista Social Club is technically a musical, but if you watch it on a modest dose of mushrooms, surrounded by young Italian cineastes, it can be quite fun.

Achewood

I mean, that's how I came up with that line. I grew up assured that if I danced or sang, I was due public disdain and emasculation in proportional measure.

Achewood

Actually, he got writer's block after the first line. *Just like when he wrote the Depressed man in the bed.*

Achewood

oh man that's right, big parts of this musical were written years ago

Achewood

Wait, your friend's mom calls you when he leaves his wallet in your car?

Achewood

this made me very sad for some reason

Achewood

actually, you could just listen to asmr of rain while reading the archive. Voila, Depression The Musical!

Achewood

It's fair, right? Really cheery people can be unbearably grating if you're really laying into your own frozen misery.

Achewood

I think it's the same newspaper where Ray discovered that somebody finally shot that Morrissey character

Achewood

Bravo to any art that can move the viewer so. I am not made of stone.

Achewood

You raise a good point, in that a lack of technology used to mean performers had to sing and jump around in order to keep people from throwing rotten cabbage at them. Now that we have special effects and James Cameron, musicals are kind of like polio.

Achewood

I got a big fancy phone! I succumbed to Device Excitement.

Achewood

In college was the first time I met kids who listened to actual CDs of musicals, instead of bands, and it blew my mind. I considered them the undescended testicles of the intellectual landscape.

Achewood

I think it's a D#, but in a pretty low octave, so it's not clear it's singing at first.

Achewood

I posit this art form is on the decline, as we have superior technology to a hundred years ago, and no longer need to fill the stage with cheap verse and C-grade gymnastics.

Achewood

I looked that up, briefly, and it seems it's a musical! You tricked me.

Achewood

I looked up Sturgeon's Law, and I think Mr. Sturgeon was being generous.

Achewood

did not, does not, will not! It's essentially an identity at this point.

Achewood

he has the same eyes as roast beef when roast beef sings

Achewood

indeed, is this all a setup for some Laszlo's Open Mic?

Achewood

Well, I wouldn't have seen this "shape of water," now would I? (I was busy rewatching all of House and Monk that year.)

Josh Egbert

I am quite untrustworthy

Achewood

musicals bring out the worst in people

Josh Egbert

Should sing a song about it

b.zap

he goes by da-VEE-day

John Ryan

That's the one. I was prepared for it to be filthy but still surprised by the raunch. There were a few folks there you could tell didn't know what they were in for and couldn't abide it. They may have been Mormon themselves.

Aaron J. Rushton, Writer of Words

I agree. We have evolved beyond minstrel shows and the laugh track, let us retire unnecessary song to the memories of the ages.

Clench and Cheese

I just sat through a local production of Next to Normal which was about a severely mentally ill mom whose closest relationship is with an imagined teenage son who in reality died at eight months old. A doctor sings about different psych meds and just before intermission she tries to slit her wrists. Had I left just then I would have liked it more.

ladiesbane

My first college roommate in a nutshell. We compromised on movie musical soundtracks (Rocky Horror, Monty Python's The Meaning of Life), but if I came home to a sock on the doorknob, I knew she was in there with Andrew Lloyd Webber and to stay the hell away.

Jay Y

My dad sang, but it was mostly Jim Croce songs and that is sufficiently masculine in that Jim Croce will teach you essential lessons about who you are or are not allowed to fight.

Darren MacLennan

Hamilton is a pretty good place to start, I think.

Uncle Elephant

Thank you for this validation about my hatred of musicals. I have never felt so seen. I've grudgingly made my peace with them, as I have many of my judgments in middle age amid a family of people with other judgments. But still. I'm there with you. Also, this was a long set-up, but that last panel got me big. Thank you for today.

A. Hamster

This was back in college, and he was not a self-starter. 25 years later, I am fairly certain he wipes his own ass, but with his mother on speed dial.

John Robinson

The previously-mentioned Book of Mormon is pretty fantastic, and listening to the album, you don't have to look at dancing.

John Robinson

May I be the third in this assemblage? I'll bake cookies for the meetings.

Strange Matter (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-20 10:00 musicals can be good, the main issue is that they get docked points on their failings as music and as a theater production, while demanding the viewer's perception of both of those disjoint aspects simultaneously so the art execution almost always seems low quality because many minds just count the things that are negative about something instead of looking for all the things that are right about it, and its twice the effort to experience as well. Its a rare form of optimism when someone genuinely enjoys musicals. but if you watch all of buffy the vampire slayer, you'd be hard pressed to find a better episode than once more with feeling, even if it was a little difficult to watch, due to being a musical.
2025-04-12 06:34

Tom Morris

You are just describing my misspent youth.

Sedric and Charlie

Noted, no fish curry, or musicals about fish curry (there's probably one), for Chris

Nicholas Williams

I told my sister-in-law that I didn't "get" Hamilton (which was a kinder way to say that I hated it) and she was mad at me for most of the family ski vacation.

Sam J

Wait wait wait. You don't like to eat fish, or you detest %80 of the attractions at aquariums? Possibly both?

Ben Wilinofsky

Musicals and threesomes are bad because it's not enjoyable to watch someone half-ass two things at once when you could just have the whole ass

A. Hamster

I usually say something like “didn’t they just get this from Epic Rap Battles of History” and that gets a pretty good reaction

Stavro

Hamilton in particular is rap for people who don't know rap, and musical theater for people who don't know musical theater. Worst of all possible worlds.

Stavro

go for a classic. The King and I. South Pacific. The Sound of Music. etc etc

Stavro

Realizing 10 seconds two late that two or maybe all three of these are super racist in an old-timey way, so be forewarned on that

Miles

You’re at the height of your powers, Chris

FactWino

Basso Profundo

FactWino

So sushi must be out of the question.

FactWino

Maybe Puddle's Pity Party

Achewood

okay, so I'm not exactly George R R Martin or Heisenberg, but I check a certain box. [bows]

Achewood

I aways thought threesomes were a bad idea because that's a lot of feet and legs to manage. Legs are really awkward long things and a regular bed doesn't have space for them. Maybe this is why threesomes are always happening in hot tubs, which are basically three-dimensional beds with gravity benefits.

Achewood

The irony is that I quite enjoy aquariums. I was at an aquarium last month! The smell was kind of strong, but that was mostly the projectile-sharting penguins (this was the Boston one)

Achewood

I'm annoyed just by that little manic Miranda guy. The best part he ever played was perfect for him: the insane guy in the asylum in a House two-parter.

Achewood

I saw a little bit of Witchitaw, the show being made within the Netflix series Love, so I consider myself briefed on Buffy.

Achewood

Dude, why do people even write plays like this. If you were all about making people listen to stories like this in a social setting, people wouldn't endure you, and you'd be diagnosed with some kind of narcissism or BPD or something

Achewood

the South Park one has top slot so far.

Achewood

Thank you for the fact, FactWino!

Achewood

@FactWino (does the @ symbol do anything on this platform?) things like California Rolls just taste sweet and rich, and "spicy tuna" doesn't really taste like anything beyond chilis, but yeah, I'm not a big sushi genius. I am basically the guy you take to sushi and he orders tempura. I am your friend from Arizona State.

Achewood

Ovid's was "Metamorphoses," and quite complex, requiring over twenty hours to tell properly. (I understand some Musicals people would love this.) The Kafka one would just take twenty minutes, with most of that being while the giant cockroach looks at Facebook for fifteen minutes then figures out how to get out of bedsheets.

Bruce Wright

Oh, I know, but surely a shift of one letter is allowed for a half witticism. I went to a Dominican college, man. Stole communion wine and everything.

Bruce Wright

You are, in my opinion, one of the greatest American cartoonists since Walt Kelly.

Achewood

Thank you, Bruce. That's way up there. May they "call [my] failures art," as Elliott Smith sang.

Achewood

I may need to have you on the Achewood Podcast (if it ever exists)

Clench and Cheese

Not only did they write it they won a Pulitzer prize for it. It was so disturbing at and when they sang some kind of song about the sun coming up and the ghost teenager is right there with them for everybody.

Achewood

Awards from other humans for art have come to represent very little value to me. I may be at the point where I much more greatly appreciate the award of seeing a butterfly land on a pollen. If someone has to put on a tortured version of a tuxedo to receive the blandishments of our species, I'll be on the rug, pressing a chilled volume of Patrick O'Brian to my temple.

cody

You and Martin are both good storytellers, but only one is a good writer and you know which of the two is gettin my Patreon coin.

Clench and Cheese

POB has been my ASMR lullaby for decades. The man is forever seared in my soul

Achewood

You’re a dear man, and thank you. Scripts are such a different animal than standalone prose. But to be honest, I haven’t read any of his paper.

Achewood

People say Bowie and Prince were aliens, but POB was truly a next level creature.

zaratustra

I liked Lion King, though I suspect it was all the lion-themed contraptions on display.

Datura

Fine I will, you're an old ball cap! I'm not a fan of musicals either though, but you did ask

Nicholas Williams

It makes me weep that people consider him good at things.

2scrogz

The way it's gonna be with me: I don't like fish, I've never spoken with god, and I can't stand musicals. <-this could become my personal mantra, to be honest.

Minty

I suggest ignoring Bungus Bronbo on this matter.

Alexander Rediger

I'm reading through Cormac McCarthy's plays right now, and this is perfect. "...he has blown everything above his eyebrows off."