Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

A big special batch of outtakes and unused material from the production of this strip posts two hours after the strip itself, in tiers 2 & 3! Bump up for a month, and treat yourself to the Director's Cut experience today!

PORTLAND, OREGON — I was happy to see such robust discussion of the Musicals format, following the release of last week's strip. Even though it appeared that the anti-Musicals crowd broke through with some revolutionary arguments, the Musicals crowd did what they tend to do, which is continue to claim that they like musicals. I think we really do have the new "cilantro flavor / asparagus pee" debate of the year going on, here.

If you have the energy, and the intervening week has seen the development of new insight in your fevered brains, I welcome further discourse. But gloves on and use the buckets, please. We all play nice in here, even when such contentious topics must be dealt with. Especially then. It's what makes us a website, people.

Files

Comments

Bob the Fish Productions

All I know is that every single theoretical musical in this two-strip (so far) sequence has a better premise than Dear Evan Hansen.

Charles Richter

The bulges made by Ray's knees and toes in the large cargo pocket are the mark of a true artist who knows and cares about his craft.

b.zap

Jesus Ray don't sit on them cakes!

DocHaus

Dang this reminds me I gotta hit the gym more often...wait a minute...what if there's a musical about fighting demons keeping me from going to the gym more often?

Martin Brady

I don't know what's wrong with Cargo Shorts: The Musical. After all, the main character clearly decided to have Optimism.

Douglas Wykstra

ALAN (self-insert's name changed for plausible deniability): I woke at least an hour before my usual alarm, Now I'll proceed into the gym and strengthen skinny arms. DEMON: But wouldn't you rather Doomscroll on the toilet For the entire hoooooooouuuuuuur?

Bruce Wright

We need a musical about my horrible struggle not to eat entire sleeves of saltines late at night.

Bungus Bronbo

the fucking pocket on ray's thong

Joe Locastro

That little ditty Ray sings for the pocket song has strong Joe Longthorne "Morning Of My Life" vibes.

Josh Egbert

How does Calories: The Musical not start with the invention of sour cream?

Jay Y

It was either this or Diabetes: The Musical. Which, in retrospect, might just be a Jardiance ad. Man, if musicals are such high art, why they usin them to hawk pills on me?

Douglas Wykstra

Beef hates musicals because his parents scorned him for expressiveness. Ray struggles with his weight because his mother conditioned her approval upon his willingness to overeat. In this vision of the world, musicals bear the psychic burdens we assume from the imperfect parenting we experience. I can therefore only assume, based on this and the way he depicts them, that Onstad hates musicals because, in his preverbal stage, his mother was watching the 1968 movie of Oliver! and failed to respond to his cries with sufficient promptness.

GruntyGinMan

Sondra's friend is going to trip and fall ass backwards onto the cakes I can feel it

blair

Ray's gotta get some nuance in there, like laundering his phone because it was in the wrong pocket. Or conflict: maybe a rumble between the Cargo Pants Posse and the EDC Belt Pouch Crew.

blair

..but they settle their differences to make common cause against the encroaching Man-Purse Mob.

A. Hamster

Or really just any accidental exposure to The Wiz at any point in the 80s. It was everywhere back then.

A. Hamster

I think that would have to be the climax of Act I, just prior to intermission!

A. Hamster

DEMON: and now that he’s forlorn I’ll tempt him with some porn Instead of weights in fist He’ll just work out his wrist

Oppido

Sour cream invented itself, which is very hard to dramatize for the stage.

Douglas Wykstra

Never saw The Wiz, but I struggle to imagine it having as many Cockney accents and straw boaters as are on display in Beef/Onstad's projections, which scream "60s overpolished excess that inadvertently created the New Hollywood" to me.

Ian Stewart

Let's face it, if Ray's Caribbean resorts did come through, there would totally be the awkward Utilikilt contingent, causing controversy and discord among the rest of the dudes. (I myself have no opinion on the garment, but have been in company of dudes who judged Utilikilted bypassers quite harshly.)

Oppido

"What demons do I even fight with" -- I guess Ray's suppressed his daddy issues and the Colonel Ephraim stuff pretty deep.

Douglas Wykstra

Says you. "It's True I Am a Self-Invented Cream" is the patter-song W.S. Gilbert looks at from the afterlife and rends his angelic garments at not having written himself.

Julie (HiDeeHoGal)

I hate Ray's musical ideas. It seems like the kind of thing David Hasselhoff would be in (he ruined Jekyll and Hyde) but who am I to judge?

A. Hamster

I can see Calories the Musical having a singing THC-infused brownie. You like eating carbs You like getting high You can do both at once If you give me a tryyyyyyyyyy

A. Hamster

True, The Wiz was more funk basslines and Michael Jackson as the Scarecrow. Onstad’s vision seems borne of an endless barrage of “I’d quit me job an’ run away, but who would shine these boots all day?”

NuclearNerves

Alright I’m gonna give a go at it. I have nothing but respect for the musical hater crowd. You guys come into the theater already half cocked knowing you’re gonna be annoyed off your rocker, but you give it an earnest shot anyway. Us musical enjoyers see that and appreciate it huge-style. If I were to say anything about musicals, it’s the suspension of disbelief that carries the whole thing. Sometimes, topics that we need to wrestle with that are incredibly hard for one person to do alone (death and loss, gentrification, heart break, etc) can be felt freely and processed easier in the package of the ridiculousness of a tights wearing alto on stage. You can laugh through the tears. Once you get past the silliness… you can see a true and earnest expression that you didn’t know was there, and you feel grateful for the connection. Plus, sometimes you get a fun diddy stuck in your head on the way home! Disney movies growing up helped a lot with that lol. I DO wanna say theres a musical out there for everyone. It’s a tough medium to get into. But I hope everyone gets to witness a form of art that changes them for the better :)

Julie (HiDeeHoGal)

Or at least a song for everyone. "On My Own" From Les Mis is probably one of the most relatable songs ever. Then again I am a Les Mis girlie from long ago. (In the 80s when I was in high school theater, you were a Cats, Phantom, or Les Mis girlie and the factions were at war constantly).

DocHaus

I keep having Gilbert and Sullivan tunes run through my head every so often thanks to my parents showing me VHS tapes though I was too young to understand them or fell asleep through them.

C C

The cats parse their own defining trauma into the most abhorrent of artforms.

C C

Salt Teens! The high school musical about the awkward kids in the AP Baking class who rebel against the establishment and form the "Saltine Club" during a Saturday detention.

2scrogz

Huh, yeah, we never really learned the origin story of Ray's "ladies sitting on cakes" kink, did we... interesting theory for where this is heading.

2scrogz

The thing about musicals is that I may not enjoy them, but without their dramatic songwriting structures, we would never have had the dramatic pop stylings of such as Queen, Elton John, and dare I say it, Billy Joel? A lot of that music calls to mind a rollicking, piano-driven Broadway number. So like I won't choose to attend musicals or listen to their OST's, but I'll concede the influence they've had on parts of mainstream culture I quite enjoy.

Matthew Miller

My problem with Calories: The Musical is that I want to watch it but I keep fucking starring in it.

Matthew Miller

Workin’ my way back down to understudy tho

Matthew Miller

Of course I just all the high notes in “It’s Better the Next Day (We Ordered Too Much Chinese)”

Uncle Elephant

That is the real star of this strip. Sorry to say I didn't notice it until the second reading, but boy, did it make me glad I came back. The only way the next panel could have been better would have been if Philippe jumped out of that pocket (in cargo shorts, of course) singing the high note.

Sedric and Charlie

RAY [singing, dancing] Daddy why weren't you there for me? At parents' evenings and birthday parties? Did I do something wrong in my mother's belly? Was I just not the child you wanted to see? RAMSES [dead flat spoken, stood stock still]: Boy I had some asses to beat RAY: I can't deny that's pretty neat!

cody

Surely the Cats folks knew they didn’t have a lot of troops on the ground in those wars.

cody

If it’s cargos vs utilikilts, and the cargos are being honest with themselves, they’ve gotta admit they lost the war already since they’re matched on practicality but are inherently a peg down on self-confidence.

Tyrone Slothrust

this is also likely the moment where the cake sitting seed is planted; in trying and failing to impress his mother and be deserving of the gifts, he creates a core memory of shame whose pathos lead both to overating (to demonstrate virility) and the cake-sitting itself, where he recontexualizes the fetish object from shameful to erotic by substituting a woman of flexible social mores and deep entrepreneurial spirit for the nurturing mother figure.

Tyrone Slothrust

this is my magnum fuckin' opus and i used it on a patreon reply, goddammit

Taylor

When I saw Ray focus on the bottle I was afraid his musical would be about Alcoholism, this is much less bleak

Mackenzie Guillory

I like how Ray thinks that a pitch for a musical not passing the sniff test would be in the paper.

Achewood

Yeah, Ray can't imagine anything he does not winding up in the Smithsonian. It's a sneak peek into how much he loves his life. (Except for his musicals failing, but even that is seen as a new challenge, about which he might write a musical.)

Achewood

Ray, missing the obvious, an endless wheel, etc

Achewood

I know what you mean. I starred way too hard in Calories: The Musical today at lunch, when I made a super trashy bratwurst omelette with American cheese inside

Achewood

It's hard not to see a comparison between the bouncy, big-assed drama of queen/Joel/etc and Musicals. What I like to think is that Musicals made a deal with the devil and could see into the future, and ripped off those singularly-brilliant 70s/80s songwriters, stealing the good musical ideas back into whenever Musicals started (the 1910s, a time of spats?). That, coupled with whatever nonsense quantum math people are always coming up with, could explain it.

Achewood

Yes, also this. It's almost like you got a preview of the next installment.

Achewood

You are too kind to the Haters, and that perhaps indicates the generosity of heart required to be a true Musicals person. Perhaps all Anti-Musicals have a withering bitterness inside of them which prevents seeing the joy in a wailing tights person with huge eyelashes try to tell you that Jesus couldn't afford his rent, or however that goes. Maybe we have never seen a good one live: like NASCAR, it's just no good on the TV. I like Spinal Tap. That is kind of a musical. But it hasn't been a gateway musical, as the old wags warn us about.

Achewood

I bet that dude plus Action Bronson could Musical the hell out of some cargo shorts

Achewood

Okay, you're trying to sneak Musicals into the comments, we are keeping an eye on you

Achewood

You don't like the idea of men helping each other enjoy cargo shorts? What's gotten into you?

Achewood

Tyrone you really nailed something important there, and if you want us to release the intellectual property back to you, I have the appropriate forms

Achewood

The Utilikilts seem like the logical foes of the Cargo Shorts guys, indeed. Personally, I would have to write it where the Utilikilt guys lose, though, because I represent 99.999999999999999999% of earth's people

Achewood

a common enemy to the cargo shorts camp is emerging in this forum: utili-kilted, man purse, man bun...yogis?

Achewood

yes we are seeing some genesis-grade elements here

Achewood

You take that back about my mother. The only film she ever watched or will watch was Footloose. That woman is a saint

Achewood

Yeah mostly I'm thinking of Dick Van Dyke in Mary Poppins

Achewood

Man, if my name was Empagliflozin I'd go by Jardiance too

Achewood

okay I died (nearly) laughing at all of that. Thank you also for writing in the artist as -=RAY=-

Achewood

I cannot add anything more clever to this thread than already exists, it is a balm for the soul

Ian Stewart

You think when Ramathustra Ron comes back, we're gonna find out he's a Utilikilt guy? Or maybe one of his nephews or something (dude doesn't seem like the type to have any children that he acknowledges)

Achewood

How did you find this strange man?! I looked the song up and yeah, it's about this level of canned dinner theatre stuff

Achewood

To be fair, I think someone in last week's comments mentioned a pocket on Ray's thong, so they deserve the inspo credit

Achewood

That musical is stuck behind all that intestinal inflammation! Don't eat so many saltines so late Bruce!

Achewood

Right? He decided what he wanted. What's the issue?

Achewood

Man, I go out of town for a hospice visit and the comments threads are way better than when I participate

Achewood

[chorus] There's a time and a place Why can't you just sit on a face Like a goooo-ooooood-oooood booooooooyyyyyyy

Achewood

Like a Swiss watchmaker, I knew very few would appreciate the detail, but had to do it for my own sake once I realized it would be nice to see.

Achewood

Okay, I looked up Dear Evan Hansen, and it's another one of those "why did somebody write this instead of a good time type of thing" ones for me

Achewood

I think he's too much of a coward to wear a utilikilt. If he had stones that big, his cult would have been way better than one that has Pat as a main feature.

Joe Locastro

The Algorithm sings for me, apparently. I'm glad it matched my headcanon!

Julie (HiDeeHoGal)

Taste is what's gotten into me. Where's the conflict? what room for character development? Songs that are earworms at best. Yes, cargo shorts are pretty good sometimes. Okay!